Reconstitution and analysis of soluble inhibin and activin receptor complexes in a cell-free system

Activins and inhibins compose a heterogeneous subfamily within the transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) superfamily of growth and differentiation factors with critical biological activities in embryos and adults. They signal through a heteromeric complex of type II, type I, and for inhibin, type III receptors. To characterize the affinity, specificity, and activity of these receptors (alone and in combination) for the inhibin/activin subfamily, we developed a cell-free assay system using soluble receptor-Fc fusion proteins. The soluble activin type II receptor (sActRII)-Fc fusion protein had a 7-fold higher affinity for activin A compared with sActRIIB-Fc, whereas both receptors had a marked preference for activin A over activin B. Although inhibin A and B binding was 20-fold lower compared with activin binding to either type II receptor alone, the mixture of either type II receptor with soluble TGF-beta type III receptor (TbetaRIII; betaglycan)-Fc reconstituted a soluble high affinity inhibin receptor. In contrast, mixing either soluble activin type II receptor with soluble activin type I receptors did not substantially enhance activin binding. Our results support a cooperative model of binding for the inhibin receptor (ActRII.sTbetaRIII complex) but not for activin receptors (type II + type I) and demonstrate that a complex composed of activin type II receptors and TbetaRIII is both necessary and sufficient for high affinity inhibin binding. This study also illustrates the utility of this cell-free system for investigating hypotheses of receptor complex mechanisms resulting from crystal structure analyses.     

Structural basis for a functional antagonist in the transforming growth factor beta superfamily

Within the transforming growth factor beta superfamily, the agonist-antagonist relationship between activin and inhibin is unique and critical to integrated reproductive function. Activin acts in the pituitary to stimulate follicle-stimulating hormone, and is antagonized by endocrine acting, gonadally derived inhibin. We have undertaken a mutational analysis of the activin betaA subunit to determine the precise structural aspects that contribute to inhibin antagonism of activin. By substituting specific amino acid residues in the activin betaA subunit with similarly aligned amino acids from the alpha subunit, we have pinpointed the residues required for activin receptor binding and activity, as well as for inhibin antagonism of activin through its receptors. Additionally, we have identified an activin mutant with a higher affinity for the activin type I receptor that provides structural evidence for the evolution of ligand-receptor interactions within the transforming growth factor beta superfamily.     

Novel activin receptors: distinct genes and alternative mRNA splicing generate a repertoire of serine/threonine kinase receptors.

We have cloned ActR-IIB, which encodes four new activin receptor isoforms belonging to the protein serine/threonine kinase receptor family. Two of the ActR-IIB isoforms have higher affinity for activin A than the previously cloned activin receptor and differ from each other by the inclusion of an alternatively spliced segment in the cytoplasmic juxtamembrane region. A second alternative splicing event generates two additional receptor isoforms that lack a proline cluster in the external juxtamembrane region and have lower affinity for activin A. All isoforms bind inhibin A with low affinity. Thus, the repertoire of activin receptors includes species that differ in ligand binding affinity, cytoplasmic domain structure, or both. This receptor heterogeneity might underlie the sharply different responses that activin can elicit in a dose- or cell-specific manner.     

Assignment of transforming growth factor beta1 and beta3 and a third new ligand to the type I receptor ALK-1

Germ line mutations in one of two distinct genes, endoglin or ALK-1, cause hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT), an autosomal dominant disorder of localized angiodysplasia. Both genes encode endothelial cell receptors for the transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) ligand superfamily. Endoglin has homology to the type III receptor, betaglycan, although its exact role in TGF-beta signaling is unclear. Activin receptor-like kinase 1 (ALK-1) has homology to the type I receptor family, but its ligand and corresponding type II receptor are unknown. In order to identify the ligand and type II receptor for ALK-1 and to investigate the role of endoglin in ALK-1 signaling, we devised a chimeric receptor signaling assay by exchanging the kinase domain of ALK-1 with either the TGF-beta type I receptor or the activin type IB receptor, both of which can activate an inducible PAI-1 promoter. We show that TGF-beta1 and TGF-beta3, as well as a third unknown ligand present in serum, can activate chimeric ALK-1. HHT-associated missense mutations in the ALK-1 extracellular domain abrogate signaling. The ALK-1/ligand interaction is mediated by the type II TGF-beta receptor for TGF-beta and most likely through the activin type II or type IIB receptors for the serum ligand. Endoglin is a bifunctional receptor partner since it can bind to ALK-1 as well as to type I TGF-beta receptor. These data suggest that HHT pathogenesis involves disruption of a complex network of positive and negative angiogenic factors, involving TGF-beta, a new unknown ligand, and their corresponding receptors.     

Inhibin α-subunit N terminus interacts with activin type IB receptor to disrupt activin signaling

Inhibin is a heterodimeric peptide hormone produced in the ovary that antagonizes activin signaling and FSH synthesis in the pituitary. The inhibin β-subunit interacts with the activin type II receptor (ActRII) to functionally antagonize activin. The inhibin α-subunit mature domain (N terminus) arose relatively early during the evolution of the hormone, and inhibin function is decreased by an antibody directed against the α-subunit N-terminal extension region or by deletion of the N-terminal region. We hypothesized that the α-subunit N-terminal extension region interacts with the activin type I receptor (ALK4) to antagonize activin signaling in the pituitary. Human or chicken free α-subunit inhibited activin signaling in a pituitary gonadotrope-derived cell line (LβT2) in a dose-dependent manner, whereas an N-terminal extension deletion mutant did not. An α-subunit N-terminal peptide, but not a control peptide, was able to inhibit activin A signaling and decrease activin-stimulated FSH synthesis. Biotinylated inhibin A, but not activin A, bound ALK4. Soluble ALK4-ECD bioneutralized human free α-subunit in LβT2 cells, but did not affect activin A function. Competitive binding ELISAs with N-terminal mutants and an N-terminal region peptide confirmed that this region is critical for direct interaction of the α-subunit with ALK4. These data expand our understanding of how endocrine inhibin achieves potent antagonism of local, constitutive activin action in the pituitary, through a combined mechanism of competitive binding of both ActRII and ALK4 by each subunit of the inhibin heterodimer, in conjunction with the co-receptor betaglycan, to block activin receptor-ligand binding, complex assembly, and downstream signaling.     

The BMP7/ActRII extracellular domain complex provides new insights into the cooperative nature of receptor assembly

Activins and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) elicit diverse biological responses by signaling through two pairs of structurally related type I and type II receptors. Here we report the crystal structure of BMP7 in complex with the extracellular domain (ECD) of the activin type II receptor. Our structure produces a compelling four-receptor model, revealing that the types I and II receptor ECDs make no direct contacts. Nevertheless, we find that truncated receptors lacking their cytoplasmic domain retain the ability to cooperatively assemble in the cell membrane. Also, the affinity of BMP7 for its low-affinity type I receptor ECD increases 5-fold in the presence of its type II receptor ECD. Taken together, our results provide a view of the ligand-mediated cooperative assembly of BMP and activin receptors that does not rely on receptor-receptor contacts.     

Identification of a binding site on the type II activin receptor for activin and inhibin

Type II activin receptors (ActRII and ActRIIB) are single-transmembrane domain serine/threonine kinase receptors that bind activin to initiate the signaling and cellular responses triggered by this hormone. Inhibin also binds type II activin receptors and antagonizes many activin effects. Here we describe alanine scanning mutagenesis of the ActRII extracellular domain. We identify a cluster of three hydrophobic residues (Phe(42), Trp(60), and Phe(83)) that, when individually mutated to alanine in the context of the full-length receptor, cause the disruption of activin and inhibin binding to ActRII. Each of the alanine-substituted ActRII mutants retaining activin binding maintains the ability to form cross-linked complexes with activin and supports activin cross-linking to the type I activin receptor ALK4. Unlike wild-type ActRII, the three mutants unable to bind activin do not cause an increase in activin signaling when transiently expressed in a corticotroph cell line. Together, our results implicate these residues in forming a critical binding surface on ActRII required for functional interactions with both activin and inhibin. This first identification of a transforming growth factor-beta family member binding site may provide a general basis for characterizing binding sites for other members of the superfamily.     

The structure of the follistatin:activin complex reveals antagonism of both type I and type II receptor binding

TGF-beta ligands stimulate diverse cellular differentiation and growth responses by signaling through type I and II receptors. Ligand antagonists, such as follistatin, block signaling and are essential regulators of physiological responses. Here we report the structure of activin A, a TGF-beta ligand, bound to the high-affinity antagonist follistatin. Two follistatin molecules encircle activin, neutralizing the ligand by burying one-third of its residues and its receptor binding sites. Previous studies have suggested that type I receptor binding would not be blocked by follistatin, but the crystal structure reveals that the follistatin N-terminal domain has an unexpected fold that mimics a universal type I receptor motif and occupies this receptor binding site. The formation of follistatin:BMP:type I receptor complexes can be explained by the stoichiometric and geometric arrangement of the activin:follistatin complex. The mode of ligand binding by follistatin has important implications for its ability to neutralize homo- and heterodimeric ligands of this growth factor family.     

Characterization and cloning of a receptor for BMP-2 and BMP-4 from NIH 3T3 cells.

The bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) are a group of transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta)-related factors whose only receptor identified to date is the product of the daf-4 gene from Caenorhabditis elegans. Mouse embryonic NIH 3T3 fibroblasts display high-affinity 125I-BMP-4 binding sites. Binding assays are not possible with the isoform 125I-BMP-2 unless the positively charged N-terminal sequence is removed to create a modified BMP-2, 125I-DR-BMP-2. Cross-competition experiments reveal that BMP-2 and BMP-4 interact with the same binding sites. Affinity cross-linking assays show that both BMPs interact with cell surface proteins corresponding in size to the type I (57- to 62-kDa) and type II (75- to 82-kDa) receptor components for TGF-beta and activin. Using a PCR approach, we have cloned a cDNA from NIH 3T3 cells which encodes a novel member of the transmembrane serine/threonine kinase family most closely resembling the cloned type I receptors for TGF-beta and activin. Transient expression of this receptor in COS-7 cells leads to an increase in specific 125I-BMP-4 binding and the appearance of a major affinity-labeled product of approximately 64 kDa that can be labeled by either tracer. This receptor has been named BRK-1 in recognition of its ability to bind BMP-2 and BMP-4 and its receptor kinase structure. Although BRK-1 does not require cotransfection of a type II receptor in order to bind ligand in COS cells, complex formation between BRK-1 and the BMP type II receptor DAF-4 can be demonstrated when the two receptors are coexpressed, affinity labeled, and immunoprecipitated with antibodies to either receptor subunit. We conclude that BRK-1 is a putative BMP type I receptor capable of interacting with a known type II receptor for BMPs.     

An activin mutant with disrupted ALK4 binding blocks signaling via type II receptors

Activins control many physiologic and pathophysiologic processes in multiple tissues and, like other TGF-beta superfamily members, signal via type II (ActRII/IIB) and type I (ALK4) receptor serine kinases. ActRII/IIB are promiscuous receptors known to bind at least a dozen TGF-beta superfamily ligands including activins, myostatin, several BMPs, and nodal. Here we utilize a new screening procedure to rapidly identify activin-A mutants with loss of signaling activity. Our goal was to identify activin-A mutants able to bind ActRII but unable to bind ALK4 and which would be, therefore, candidate type II activin receptor antagonists. Using the structure of BMP-2 bound to its type I receptor (ALK3) as a guide, we introduced mutations in the context of the inhibin betaA cDNA and assessed the signaling activity of the resulting mutant proteins. We identified several mutants in the finger (M91E, I105E, M108A) and wrist (activin A/activin C chimera, S60P, I63P) regions of activin-A with reduced signaling activity. Of these the M108A mutant displayed the lowest signaling activity while retaining wild-type-like affinity for ActRII. Unlike wild-type activin-A, the M108A mutant was unable to form a cross-linked complex with ALK4 in the presence of ActRII indicating that its ability to bind ALK4 was disrupted. This data suggested that the M108A mutant might be capable of modulating signaling of activin and related ligands. Indeed, the M108A mutant antagonized activin-A and myostatin, but not TGF-beta, signaling in 293T cells, indicating it may be generally capable of blocking ligands that signal via ActRII/IIB.     

High resolution structures of the bone morphogenetic protein type II receptor in two crystal forms: implications for ligand binding

BMPRII is a type II TGF-beta serine threonine kinase receptor which is integral to the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signalling pathway. It is known to bind BMP and growth differentiation factor (GDF) ligands, and has overlapping ligand specificity with the activin type II receptor, ActRII. In contrast to activin and TGF-beta type ligands, BMPs bind to type II receptors with lower affinity than type I receptors. Crystals of the BMPRII ectodomain were grown in two different forms, both of which diffracted to high resolution. The tetragonal form exhibited some disorder, whereas the entire polypeptide was seen in the orthorhombic form. The two structures retain the basic three-finger toxin fold of other TGF-beta receptor ectodomains, and share the main hydrophobic patch used by ActRII to bind various ligands. However, they present different conformations of the A-loop at the periphery of the proposed ligand-binding interface, in conjunction with rearrangement of a disulfide bridge within the loop. This particular disulfide (Cys94-Cys117) is only present in BMPRII and activin receptors, suggesting that it is important for their likely shared mode of binding. Evidence is presented that the two crystal forms represent ligand-bound and free conformations of BMPRII. Comparison with the solved structure of ActRII bound to BMP2 suggests that His87, unique amongst TGF-beta receptors, may play a key role in ligand recognition.     

Expression of the human activin type I and II receptor extracellular domains in Pichia pastoris

Methods for the expression in Pichia pastoris and purification of the human activin receptor type I and II extracellular domains (ARIa/ARIb-ECDs, ARIIA/ARIIB-ECDs) are described. Key experimental aspects are also documented of the vector transformation methodology and the binding characteristics of these ECDs with activin A and inhibin. The cDNA constructs for these ECDs contained a C-terminal His6-tag with either the native signal (N) or the yeast alpha mating factor (alphaMF) sequence and were introduced into the pPICZ expression vector either as a single-copy or as a four-copy expression cassette. Hyper-resistant transformants (zeo(R): 500 microg/mL) generated from the cassette containing a single copy of the expression vector gave the stronger signal intensity with a DNA dot-blot screening assay. These transformants also produced higher quantities of the corresponding recombinant protein compared to transformants using the four-copy cassette vector. All receptor-ECD proteins expressed were found to be heterogeneously glycosylated, whereby the ARIIA-ECD and ARIIB-ECD had undergone two Asn-linked glycosylation events and the ARIb-ECD a single event. By SDS-PAGE, the de-glycosylated proteins migrated larger than the expected core size, indicating that they may have undergone O-linked glycosylation. Biacore-based procedures with the glycosylated and de-glycosylated ARIIA-ECD were employed to determine the kinetic and equilibrium binding parameters for the interaction with activin A and inhibin. The glycosylated ARIIA-ECD bound to activin A with a KD of 11.9 nM and inhibin with a KD of 21.1 nM. Although glycosylation of ARIIA-ECD was not strictly required for high affinity interactions with activin A or inhibin, it markedly improved the overall stability of the ARIIA-ECD.     

Follicle-restricted compartmentalization of transforming growth factor beta superfamily ligands in the feline ovary

Ovarian follicular development, follicle selection, and the process of ovulation remain poorly understood in most species. Throughout reproductive life, follicle fate is balanced between growth and apoptosis. These opposing forces are controlled by numerous endocrine, paracrine, and autocrine factors, including the ligands represented by the transforming growth factor beta (TGFbeta) superfamily. TGFbeta, activin, inhibin, bone morphometric protein (BMP), and growth differentiation factor 9 (GDF-9) are present in the ovary of many animals; however, no comprehensive analysis of the localization of each ligand or its receptors and intracellular signaling molecules during folliculogenesis has been done. The domestic cat is an ideal model for studying ovarian follicle dynamics due to an abundance of all follicle populations, including primordial stage, and the amount of readily available tissue following routine animal spaying. Additionally, knowledge of the factors involved in feline follicular development could make an important impact on in vitro maturation/in vitro fertilization (IVM/IVF) success for endangered feline species. Thus, the presence and position of TGFbeta superfamily members within the feline ovary have been evaluated in all stages of follicular development by immunolocalization. The cat inhibin alpha subunit protein is present in all follicle stages but increases in intensity within the mural granulosa cells in large antral follicles. The inhibin betaA and betaB subunit proteins, in addition to the activin type I (ActRIB) and activin type II receptor (ActRIIB), are produced in primordial and primary follicle granulosa cells. Additionally, inhibin betaA subunit is detected in the theca cells from secondary through large antral follicle size classes. GDF-9 is restricted to the oocyte of preantral and antral follicles, whereas the type II BMP receptor (BMP-RII) protein is predominantly localized to primordial- and primary-stage follicles. TGFbeta1, 2, and 3 ligand immunoreactivity is observed in both small and large follicles, whereas the TGFbeta type II receptor (TGFbeta RII) is detected in the oocyte and granulosa cells of antral follicles. The intracellular signaling proteins Smad2 and Smad4 are present in the granulosa cell cytoplasm of all follicle size classes. Smad3 is detected in the granulosa cell nucleus, the oocyte, and the theca cell nucleus of all follicle size classes. These data suggest that the complete activin signal transduction pathway is present in small follicles and that large follicles primarily produce the inhibins. Our data also suggest that TGFbeta ligands and receptors are colocalized to large antral follicles. Taken together, the ligands, receptors, and signaling proteins for the TGFbeta superfamily are present at distinct points throughout feline folliculogenesis, suggesting discrete roles for each of these ligands during follicle maturation.     

Roles of the activin regulatory system in fish reproduction

Activin (betaAbetaA, betaAbetaB, and betaBbetaB) is a dimeric growth factor with diverse biological activities in vertebrate reproduction. Activin exerts its actions by binding to its specific type II and type I receptors. The activity of activin is regulated by follistatin, its binding protein, and the antagonists inhibin and antivin. All major components of the activin-inhibin-follistatin system have been identified in fish except the alpha subunit of inhibin. Using goldfish as a model, we have demonstrated that activin is expressed in the pituitary and the recombinant goldfish activin B has novel inverse effects on the expression of GTH beta subunits. Activin increases the mRNA level of GTH-Ibeta while significantly suppressing the expression of GTH-IIbeta. We have also demonstrated the expression of activin and its receptors in the goldfish and zebrafish ovary. Using an in vitro ovarian follicle incubation as the system, we have investigated the involvement of the activin system in the process of final oocyte maturation. Our evidence clearly indicates that activin has potent effect of promoting final oocyte maturation, and that it may play a role in mediating the stimulatory effect of pituitary gonadotropin in the event of oocyte maturation.     

Differential expression of inhibin subunits and follistatin, but not of activin receptor type II, during early murine embryonic development.

Activins are known to be potentially important regulators of early developmental processes in amphibians, birds, and mammalians. In this study we report the expression of the inhibin subunits, including those that make up activin, the activin-binding protein follistatin, and activin receptor type II in several in vitro systems that model early murine embryonic development, namely embryonic stem (ES) cells, embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells, and their differentiated derivatives. In addition, we examine the expression pattern of these factors in different stages of the mouse embryo itself. Expression of inhibin alpha and beta A subunits is restricted to certain differentiated cell types, while beta B subunits are expressed in both differentiated and undifferentiated cells. Our results further indicate a change in the expression pattern of inhibin subunits during early development from beta B at the blastocyst stage largely to beta A in postgastrulation embryos. This is similar to the expression pattern at equivalent stages of Xenopus and chick development. Expression of the activin-binding protein follistatin is altered by the induction of differentiation of P19 EC and ES cells by several factors, including retinoic acid. In contrast to the inhibin subunits and follistatin, activin receptor levels are not influenced by differentiation in these cell types. The results of this study demonstrate that the inhibin subunits and follistatin, but not the activin receptor type II, are differentially expressed during early murine development and suggest that the different forms of activin/inhibin are involved in the regulation of different developmental processes.