Dos, a heme-binding PAS protein from Escherichia coli, is a direct oxygen sensor

A direct sensor of O(2), the Dos protein, has been found in Escherichia coli. Previously, the only biological sensors known to respond to O(2) by direct and reversible binding were the FixL proteins of Rhizobia. A heme-binding region in Dos is 60% homologous to the O(2)-sensing PAS domain of the FixL protein, but the remainder of Dos does not resemble FixL. Specifically, the C-terminal domain of Dos, presumed to be a regulatory partner that couples to its heme-binding domain, is not a histidine kinase but more closely resembles a phosphodiesterase. The absorption spectra of Dos indicate that both axial positions of the heme iron are coordinated to side chains of the protein. Nevertheless, O(2) and CO bind to Dos with K(d) values of 13 and 10 microM, respectively, indicating a strong discrimination against CO binding. Association rate constants for binding of O(2) (3 mM(-)(1) s(-)(1)), CO (1 mM(-)(1) s(-)(1)) and even NO (2 mM(-)(1) s(-)(1)) are extraordinarily low and very similar. Displacement of an endogenous ligand, probably Met 95, from the heme iron in Dos triggers a conformational change that alters the activity of the enzymatic domain. This sensing mechanism differs from that of FixL but resembles that of the CO sensor CooA of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Overall the results provide evidence for a heme-binding subgroup of PAS-domain proteins whose working range, signaling mechanisms, and regulatory partners can vary considerably.     

Signal transduction by heme-containing PAS-domain proteins.

The most common physiological strategy for detecting the gases oxygen, carbon monoxide, and nitric oxide is signal transduction by heme-based sensors, a broad class of modular proteins in which a heme-binding domain governs the activity of a neighboring transmitter domain. Different structures are possible for the heme-binding domains in these sensors, but, so far, the Per-ARNT-Sim motif, or PAS domain, is the one most commonly encountered. Heme-binding PAS (heme-PAS) domains can accomplish ligand-dependent switching of a variety of partner domains, including histidine kinase, phosphodiesterase, and basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) DNA-binding modules. Proteins with heme-PAS domains occur in all kingdoms of life and are quite diverse in their physiological roles. Examples include the neuronal bHLH-PAS carbon monoxide sensor NPAS2 that is implicated in the mammalian circadian clock, the acetobacterial oxygen sensor AxPDEA1 that directs cellulose production, and the rhizobial oxygen sensor FixL, which governs nitrogen fixation. What factors determine the range of detection of these sensors? How do they transduce their signal? This review examines the recent advances in answering these questions.     

A proximal arginine R206 participates in switching of the Bradyrhizobium japonicum FixL oxygen sensor

In oxygen-sensing PAS domains, a conserved polar residue on the proximal side of the heme cofactor, usually arginine or histidine, interacts alternately with the protein in the "on-state" or the heme edge in the "off-state" but does not contact the bound ligand directly. We assessed the contributions of this residue in Bradyrhizobium japonicum FixL by determining the effects of an R206A substitution on the heme-PAS structure, ligand affinity, and regulatory capacity. The crystal structures of the unliganded forms of the R206A and wild-type BjFixL heme-PAS domains were similar, except for a more ruffled porphyrin ring in R206A BjFixL and a relaxation of the H214 residue and heme propionate 7 due to their lost interactions. The oxygen affinity of R206A BjFixL (Kd approximately 350 microM) was 2.5 times lower than that of BjFixL, and this was due to a higher off-rate constant for the R206A variant. The enzymatic activities of the unliganded "on-state" forms, either deoxy or met-R206A BjFixL, were comparable to each other and slightly lower (twofold less) than those of the corresponding BjFixL species. The most striking difference between the two proteins was in the enzymatic activities of the liganded "off-state" forms. In particular, saturation with a regulatory ligand (the Fe(III) form with cyanide) caused a >2000-fold inhibition of the BjFixL phosphorylation of BjFixJ, but a 140-fold inhibition of this catalytic activity in R206A BjFixL. Thus, in oxygen-sensing PAS domains, the interactions of polar residues with the heme edge couple the heme-binding domain to a transmitter during signal transduction.     

Phosphodiesterase A1, a regulator of cellulose synthesis in Acetobacter xylinum, is a heme-based sensor

The phosphodiesterase A1 protein of Acetobacter xylinum, AxPDEA1, is a key regulator of bacterial cellulose synthesis. This phosphodiesterase linearizes cyclic bis(3'-->5')diguanylic acid, an allosteric activator of the bacterial cellulose synthase, to the ineffectual pGpG. Here we show that AxPDEA1 contains heme and is regulated by reversible binding of O(2) to the heme. Apo-AxPDEA1 has less than 2% of the phosphodiesterase activity of holo-AxPDEA1, and reconstitution with hemin restores full activity. O(2) regulation is due to deoxyheme being a better activator than oxyheme. AxPDEA1 is homologous to the Escherichia coli direct oxygen sensor protein, EcDos, over its entire length and is homologous to the FixL histidine kinases over only a heme-binding PAS domain. The properties of the heme-binding domain of AxPDEA1 are significantly different from those of other O(2)-responsive heme-based sensors. The rate of AxPDEA1 autoxidation (half-life > 12 h) is the slowest observed so far for this type of heme protein fold. The O(2) affinity of AxPDEA1 (K(d) approximately 10 microM) is comparable to that of EcDos, but the rate constants for O(2) association (k(on) = 6.6 microM(-)(1) s(-)(1)) and dissociation (k(off) = 77 s(-)(1)) are 2000 times higher. Our results illustrate the versatility of signal transduction mechanisms for the heme-PAS class of O(2) sensors and provide the first example of O(2) regulation of a second messenger.     

Mammalian PASKIN, a PAS-serine/threonine kinase related to bacterial oxygen sensors.

The PAS domain is a versatile protein fold found in many archaeal, bacterial, and plant proteins capable of sensing environmental changes in light intensity, oxygen concentration, and redox potentials. The oxygen sensor FixL from Rhizobium species contains a heme-bearing PAS domain and a histidine kinase domain that couples sensing to signaling. We identified a novel mammalian PAS protein (PASKIN) containing a domain architecture resembling FixL. PASKIN is encoded by an evolutionarily conserved single-copy gene which is ubiquitously expressed. The human PASKIN and mouse Paskin genes show a conserved intron-exon structure and share their promoter regions with another ubiquitously expressed gene that encodes a regulator of protein phosphatase-1. The 144-kDa PASKIN protein contains a PAS region homologous to the FixL PAS domain and a serine/threonine kinase domain which might be involved in signaling. Thus, PASKIN is likely to function as a mammalian PAS sensor protein.     

Crystal structures of deoxy and CO-bound bjFixLH reveal details of ligand recognition and signaling

Rhizobia directly regulate the expression of genes required for symbiotic nitrogen fixation in response to oxygen concentration via the sensor protein FixL. The N-terminal PAS domain of FixL contains a histidine-coordinated heme and regulates the activity of its effector domain, a C-terminal histidine kinase, in response to binding of oxygen and other ligands at the heme. To further investigate ligand-induced inhibition of FixL, we have determined the crystal structures of the heme domain in both the deoxy state and bound to carbon monoxide, a weak inhibitor of FixL kinase activity. Structures collected at room temperature are presented in each state from two crystallographic space groups at 1.8 and 2 A resolution. These structures reveal displacement of the residues of the H(beta) and I(beta) strands by Leu236 upon CO binding, and this structural change propagates more than 15 A to a region of the structure implicated in signal transduction in PAS proteins. Displacement of residues Ile215, Ile216, and Gly217 in the FG loop is also evident, accompanied by the movement of heme propionate 6 upon change in iron ligation. CO binding increases the temperature factors in the FG loop of the protein and disorders the side chain of Arg206, a conserved residue involved in the FG loop switch mechanism. We relate these results to structural changes in other PAS sensor domains and their involvement in catalytic control.     

The Rhizobium etli FixL protein differs in structure from other known FixL proteins

The central heme-binding domain in the FixL proteins of Sinorhizobium meliloti, Bradyrhizobium japonicum, Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viciae and Azorhizobium caulinodans, is highly conserved. The similarity with the corresponding domain in the Rhizobium etli FixL protein is considerably less. This observation prompted us to analyze the heme-binding capacities of the R. etli FixL protein. The R. etlifixL gene was overexpressed in Escherichia coli. In the presence of S. meliloti FixJ, the overexpressed R. etli FixL protein was able to enhance FixJ-mediated activation of an S. meliloti pnifA-lacZ fusion, indicating that the R.?etli FixL protein possesses an active conformation in E. coli. Subsequently, using a non-denaturing gel assay for heme, we analyzed the heme-binding capacity of the R.?etli FixL protein expressed in E. coli, taking the S.?meliloti FixL protein as a positive control. The R. etli FixL protein expressed in E. coli does not contain a heme group, in contrast to the S. meliloti FixL protein. Therefore we conclude that the R. etli FixL is a non-heme protein in the nif regulatory cascade.     

Cache Domains That are Homologous to,but Different from PAS Domains Comprise the Largest Superfamily of Extracellular Sensors in Prokaryotes

Cellular receptors usually contain a designated sensory domain that recognizes the signal. Per/Arnt/Sim (PAS) domains are ubiquitous sensors in thousands of species ranging from bacteria to humans. Although PAS domains were described as intracellular sensors, recent structural studies revealed PAS-like domains in extracytoplasmic regions in several transmembrane receptors. However, these structurally defined extracellular PAS-like domains do not match sequence-derived PAS domain models, and thus their distribution across the genomic landscape remains largely unknown. Here we show that structurally defined extracellular PAS-like domains belong to the Cache superfamily, which is homologous to, but distinct from the PAS superfamily. Our newly built computational models enabled identification of Cache domains in tens of thousands of signal transduction proteins including those from important pathogens and model organisms. Furthermore, we show that Cache domains comprise the dominant mode of extracellular sensing in prokaryotes.     

Heme-based sensors in biological systems

The past several years have been witness to a staggering rate of advancement in the understanding of how organisms respond to changes in the availability of diatomic molecules that are toxic and/or crucial to survival. Heme-based sensors presently constitute the majority of the proteins known to sense NO, O2 and CO and to initiate the chemistry required to adapt to changes in their availabilities. Knowledge of the three characterized members of this class, soluble guanylate cyclase, FixL and CooA, has grown substantially during the past year. The major advances have resulted from a broad range of approaches to elucidation of both function and mechanism. They include growth in the understanding of the interplay between the heme and protein in soluble guanylate cyclase, as well as alternate means for its stimulation. Insight into the O2-induced structural changes in FixL has been supplied by the single crystal structure of the heme domain of Bradyrhizobium japonicum. Finally, the ligation environment and ligand interchange that facilitates CO sensing by CooA has been established by spectroscopic and mutagenesis techniques.     

PAS domain residues involved in signal transduction by the Aer redox sensor of Escherichia coli

PAS domains sense oxygen, redox potential and light, and are implicated in behaviour, circadian rhythmicity, development and metabolic regulation. Although PAS domains are widespread in archaea, bacteria and eukaryota, the mechanism of signal transduction has been elucidated only for the bacterial photo sensor PYP and oxygen sensor FixL. We investigated the signalling mechanism in the PAS domain of Aer, the redox potential sensor and aerotaxis transducer in Escherichia coli. Forty-two residues in Aer were substituted using cysteine-replacement mutagenesis. Eight mutations resulted in a null phenotype for aerotaxis, the behavioural response to oxygen. Four of them also led to the loss of the non-covalently bound FAD cofactor. Three mutant Aer proteins, N34C, F66C and N85C, transmitted a constant signal-on bias. One mutation, Y111C, inverted signalling by the transducer so that positive stimuli produced negative signals and vice versa. Residues critical for signalling were mapped onto a three-dimensional model of the Aer PAS domain, and an FAD-binding site and 'active site' for signal transduction are proposed.     

The Rhizobium etli FixL protein differs in structure from other known FixL proteins

The central heme-binding domain in the FixL proteins of Sinorhizobium meliloti, Bradyrhizobium japonicum, Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viciae and Azorhizobium caulinodans, is highly conserved. The similarity with the corresponding domain in the Rhizobium etli FixL protein is considerably less. This observation prompted us to analyze the heme-binding capacities of the R. etli FixL protein. The R. etlifixL gene was overexpressed in Escherichia coli. In the presence of S. meliloti FixJ, the overexpressed R. etli FixL protein was able to enhance FixJ-mediated activation of an S. meliloti pnifA-lacZ fusion, indicating that the R.␣etli FixL protein possesses an active conformation in E. coli. Subsequently, using a non-denaturing gel assay for heme, we analyzed the heme-binding capacity of the R.␣etli FixL protein expressed in E. coli, taking the S.␣meliloti FixL protein as a positive control. The R. etli FixL protein expressed in E. coli does not contain a heme group, in contrast to the S. meliloti FixL protein. Therefore we conclude that the R. etli FixL is a non-heme protein in the nif regulatory cascade. Received: 22 August 1997 / Accepted: 20 October 1997     

Expression and characterization of the catalytic domains of soluble guanylate cyclase: interaction with the heme domain

The catalytic domains (alpha(cat) and beta(cat)) of alpha1beta1 soluble guanylate cyclase (sGC) were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. alpha(cat), beta(cat), and the alpha(cat)beta(cat) heterodimeric complex were characterized by analytical gel filtration and circular dichroism spectroscopy, and activity was assessed in the absence and presence of two different N-terminal regulatory heme-binding domain constructs. Alpha(cat) and beta(cat) were inactive separately, but together the domains exhibited guanylate cyclase activity. Analysis by gel filtration chromatography demonstrated that each of the approximately 25-kDa domains form homodimers. Heterodimers were formed when alpha(cat) and beta(cat) were combined. Results from circular dichroism spectroscopy indicated that no major structural changes occur upon heterodimer formation. Like the full-length enzyme, the alpha(cat)beta(cat) complex was more active in the presence of Mn(2+) as compared to the physiological cofactor Mg(2+), although the magnitude of the difference was much larger for the catalytic domains than for the full-length enzyme. The K(M) for Mn(2+)-GTP was measured to be 85 +/- 18 microM, and in the presence of Mn(2+)-GTP, the K(D) for the alpha(cat)beta(cat) complex was 450 +/- 70 nM. The N-terminal heme-bound regulatory domain of the beta1 subunit of sGC inhibited the activity of the alpha(cat)beta(cat) complex in trans, suggesting a domain-scale mechanism of regulation by NO. A model in which binding of NO to sGC causes relief of an autoinhibitory interaction between the regulatory heme-binding domain and the catalytic domains of sGC is proposed.     

CO metabolism, sensing, and signaling

CO is a colorless and odorless gas produced by the incomplete combustion of hydrocarbons, both of natural and anthropogenic origin. Several microorganisms, including aerobic and anaerobic bacteria and anaerobic archaea, use exogenous CO as a source of carbon and energy for growth. On the other hand, eukaryotic organisms use endogenous CO, produced during heme degradation, as a neurotransmitter and as a signal molecule. CO sensors act as signal transducers by coupling a "regulatory" heme-binding domain to a "functional" signal transmitter. Although high CO concentrations inhibit generally heme-protein actions, low CO levels can influence several signaling pathways, including those regulated by soluble guanylate cyclase and/or mitogen-activated protein kinases. This review summarizes recent insights into CO metabolism, sensing, and signaling.     

Quaternary structure changes in a second Per-Arnt-Sim domain mediate intramolecular redox signal relay in the NifL regulatory protein

Per-Arnt-Sim (PAS) domains play a critical role in signal transduction in multidomain proteins by sensing diverse environmental signals and regulating the activity of output domains. Multiple PAS domains are often found within a single protein. The NifL regulatory protein from Azotobacter vinelandii contains tandem PAS domains, the most N-terminal of which, PAS1, contains a FAD cofactor and is responsible for redox sensing, whereas the second PAS domain, PAS2, has no apparent cofactor and its function is unknown. Amino acid substitutions in PAS2 were identified that either lock NifL in a form that constitutively inhibits NifA or that fail to respond to the redox status, suggesting that PAS2 plays a pivotal role in transducing the redox signal from PAS1 to the C-terminal output domains. The isolated PAS2 domain is a homodimer in solution and the subunits are in rapid exchange. PAS2 dimerization is maintained in the redox signal transduction mutants, but is inhibited by substitutions in PAS2 that lock NifL in the inhibitory conformer. Our results support a model for signal transduction in NifL, whereby redox-dependent conformational changes in PAS1 are relayed to the C-terminal domains via changes in the quaternary structure of the PAS2 domain.     

Structural and functional analysis of the fixLJ genes of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli CNPAF512

The fixLJ genes of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli CNPAF512 were identified by DNA hybridization of a genomic library with an internal fragment of the Rhizobium meliloti fixJ gene. The nucleotide sequence was determined and the corresponding amino acid sequence was aligned with the amino acid sequences of the FixL proteins of R. meliloti, Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Azorhizobium caulinodans. While the FixJ protein and the carboxy-terminal part of the FixL protein are highly homologous to the other FixL and FixJ proteins, the homology in the central heme-binding, oxygen-sensing domain and in the amino-terminal domain of FixL is very low. The R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli FixL protein does not contain the heme-binding motif defined for the previously described FixL proteins. R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli fixLJ and fixJ mutants were constructed. These mutants can still fix nitrogen, albeit at a reduced level. Expression analysis of nifA-gusA and nifH-gusA fusions in the constructed mutants revealed that the R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli fixLJ genes are involved in microaerobic nifH expression but not in nifA expression.     

Changes in quaternary structure in the signaling mechanisms of PAS domains

FixL from Bradyrhizobium japonicum is a PAS sensor protein in which two PAS domains covalently linked to a histidine kinase domain are responsible for regulating nitrogen fixation in an oxygen-dependent manner. The more C-terminal PAS domain, denoted bjFixLH, contains a heme cofactor that binds diatomic molecules such as carbon monoxide and oxygen and regulates the activity of the FixL histidine kinase as part of a two-component signaling system. We present the structures of ferric, deoxy, and carbon monoxide-bound bjFixLH in a new space group ( P1) and at resolutions (1.5-1.8 A) higher than the resolutions of those previously obtained. Interestingly, bjFixLH can form two different dimers (in P1 and R32 crystal forms) in the same crystallization solution, where the monomers in one dimer are rotated approximately 175 degrees relative to the second. This suggests that PAS monomers are plastic and that two quite distinct quaternary structures are closely similar in free energy. We use screw rotation analysis to carry out a quantitative pairwise comparison of PAS quaternary structures, which identifies five different relative orientations adopted by isolated PAS monomers. We conclude that PAS monomer arrangement is context-dependent and could differ depending on whether the PAS domains are isolated or are part of a full-length protein. Structurally homologous residues comprise a conserved dimer interface. Using network analysis, we find that the architecture of the PAS dimer interface is continuous rather than modular; the network of residues comprising the interface is strongly connected. A continuous dimer interface is consistent with the low dimer-monomer dissociation equilibrium constant. Finally, we quantitate quaternary structural changes induced by carbon monoxide binding to a bjFixLH dimer, in which monomers rotate by up to approximately 2 degrees relative to each other. We relate these changes to those in other dimeric PAS domains and discuss the role of quaternary structural changes in the signaling mechanisms of PAS sensor proteins.     

Globin-coupled sensors, protoglobins, and the last universal common ancestor

The strategy for detecting oxygen, carbon monoxide, nitric oxide, and sulfides is predominantly through heme-based sensors utilizing either a globin domain or a PAS domain. Whereas PAS domains bind various cofactors, globins bind only heme. Globin-coupled sensors (GCSs) were first described as regulators of the aerotactic responses in Bacillus subtilis and Halobacterium salinarum. GCSs were also identified in diverse microorganisms that appear to have roles in regulating gene expression. Functional and evolutionary analyses of the GCSs, their protoglobin ancestor, and their relationship to the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) are discussed in the context of globin-based signal transduction.