The affinity/avidity and length of exposure to the deleting ligand determine dependence on CD28 for the efficient deletion of self-specific CD4+CD8+ thymocytes

Whether the CD28/B7 signaling pathway is essential for the negative selection of immature CD4+CD8+ (DP) thymocytes expressing self-specific alphabeta TCRs is a controversial issue. In this study we examined the role of CD28 in the deletion of thymocytes that express either the H-Y or the 2C transgenic TCR. In H-2(b) male mice that expressed the H-Y TCR, negative selection of DP H-Y TCR+ thymocytes occurred very efficiently and this deletion was unaffected by the CD28(-/-) mutation. In H-2(b) 2C mice, where the deletion of DP 2C TCR+ thymocytes occurred less efficiently, the CD28(-/-) mutation led to a higher recovery of DP thymocytes. Using an in vitro deletion assay, a requirement for the CD28 signaling pathway in the deletion of DP H-Y TCR+ thymocytes was evident at low, but not high, densities of the antigenic ligand. Similar results were also observed in an in vivo assay for the deletion of these thymocytes. Intraperitoneal administration of an anti-CD3epsilon mAb led to the intrathymic deletion of DP H-Y TCR+ thymocytes in a CD28-dependent manner at the 24-h time point. However, the CD28 dependence was less evident at the 40-h time point. These results indicate that the dependence on CD28 for the efficient deletion of self-specific thymocytes is determined by the concentration, affinity/avidity, and length of exposure to the deleting ligand.     

CD30 overexpression enhances negative selection in the thymus and mediates programmed cell death via a Bcl-2-sensitive pathway.

The biological function of CD30 in the thymus has been only partially elucidated, although recent data indicate that it may be involved in negative selection. Because CD30 is expressed only by a small subpopulation of medullary thymocytes, we generated transgenic (Tg) mice overexpressing CD30 in T lymphocytes to further address its role in T cell development. CD30 Tg mice have normal thymic size with a normal number and subset distribution of thymocytes. In vitro, in the absence of CD30 ligation, thymocytes of CD30 Tg mice have normal survival and responses to apoptotic stimuli such as radiation, dexamethasone, and Fas. However, in contrast to controls, CD30 Tg thymocytes are induced to undergo programmed cell death (PCD) upon cross-linking of CD30, and the simultaneous engagement of TCR and CD30 results in a synergistic increase in thymic PCD. CD30-mediated PCD requires caspase 1 and caspase 3, is not associated with the activation of NF-kappaB or c-Jun, but is totally prevented by Bcl-2. Furthermore, CD30 overexpression enhances the deletion of CD4+/CD8+ thymocytes induced by staphylococcal enterotoxin B superantigen and specific peptide. These findings suggest that CD30 may act as a costimulatory molecule in thymic negative selection.     

A requirement for IL-2/IL-2 receptor signaling in intrathymic negative selection

The nature of the signals that influence thymocyte selection and determine the fate of CD4(+)8(+) (double positive) thymocytes remains unclear. Cytokines produced locally in the thymus may modulate signals delivered by TCR-MHC/peptide interactions and thereby influence the fate of double-positive thymocytes. Because the IL-2/IL-2R signaling pathway has been implicated in thymocyte and peripheral T cell survival, we investigated the possibility that IL-2/IL-2R interactions contribute to the deletion of self-reactive, Ag-specific thymocytes. By using nontransgenic and transgenic IL-2-sufficient and -deficient animal model systems, we have shown that during TCR-mediated thymocyte apoptosis, IL-2 protein is expressed in situ in the thymus, and apoptotic thymocytes up-regulate expression of IL-2RS: IL-2R(+) double-positive and CD4 single-positive thymocytes undergoing activation-induced cell death bind and internalize IL-2. IL-2-deficient thymocytes are resistant to TCR/CD3-mediated apoptotic death, which is overcome by providing exogenous IL-2 to IL-2(-/-) mice. Furthermore, disruption or blockade of IL-2/IL-2R interactions in vivo during Ag-mediated selection rescues some MHC class II-restricted thymocytes from apoptosis. Collectively, these findings provide evidence for the direct involvement of the IL-2/IL-2R signaling pathway in the deletion of Ag-specific thymocyte populations and suggest that CD4 T cell hyperplasia and autoimmunity in IL-2(-/-) mice is a consequence of ineffective deletion of self-reactive T cells.     

Elevated Mcl-1 inhibits thymocyte apoptosis and alters thymic selection

T cells developing in the thymus undergo rigorous positive and negative selection to ensure that those exported to peripheral lymphoid organs bear T-cell receptors (TCRs) capable of reacting with foreign antigens but tolerant of self. At each checkpoint, whether a thymocyte survives or dies is determined by antiapoptotic and proapoptotic Bcl-2 family members. We used Mcl-1 transgenic (tg) mice to investigate the impact of elevated expression of antiapoptotic Mcl-1 on thymocyte apoptosis and selection, making a side-by-side comparison with thymocytes from BCL-2tg mice. Mcl-1 was as effective as Bcl-2 at protecting thymocytes against spontaneous cell death, diverse cytotoxic insults and TCR–CD3 stimulation-driven apoptosis. In three different TCR tg models, Mcl-1 markedly enhanced positive selection of thymocytes, as did Bcl-2. In H-Y TCR tg mice, elevated Mcl-1 and Bcl-2 were equally effective at inhibiting deletion of autoreactive thymocytes. However, in the OT-1tg model where deletion is mediated by a peripheral antigen whose expression is regulated by Aire, Mcl-1 was less effective than Bcl-2. Thus, the capacity of Mcl-1 overexpression to inhibit apoptosis triggered by TCR stimulation apparently depends on the thymocyte subset subject to deletion, presumably due to differences in the profiles of proapoptotic Bcl-2 family members mediating the deletion.     

The TNF receptor family member CD30 is not essential for negative selection

CD30 is a member of the TNF receptor superfamily that has been implicated in negative selection and some forms of peripheral tolerance. A previous study of CD30(-/-) mice in a class I-restricted H-Y TCR-transgenic mouse model showed that CD30 is essential for removal of autoreactive thymocytes. During the course of the studies of CD30 in the class II-restricted TCR-transgenic mice, we found that the absence of CD30 has no effect on negative selection. Surprisingly, we also found that the CD30 mutation does not perturb apoptosis of the autoreactive thymocytes in the class I-restricted H-Y TCR-transgenic model. The minimal role of CD30 in negative selection and other recent data are discussed.     

Ligation of retinoic acid receptor alpha regulates negative selection of thymocytes by inhibiting both DNA binding of nur77 and synthesis of bim

Negative selection refers to the selective deletion of autoreactive thymocytes. Its molecular mechanisms have not been well defined. Previous studies in our laboratory have demonstrated that retinoic acids, physiological ligands for the nuclear retinoid receptors, selectively inhibit TCR-mediated death under in vitro conditions, and the inhibition is mediated via the retinoic acid receptor (RAR) alpha. The present studies were undertaken to investigate whether ligation of RARalpha leads to inhibition of TCR-mediated death in vivo and to identify the molecular mechanisms involved. Three models of TCR-mediated death were studied: anti-CD3-mediated death of thymocytes in wild-type mice, and Ag- and bacterial superantigen-driven thymocyte death in TCR-transgenic mice expressing a receptor specific for a fragment of pigeon cytochrome c in the context of the E(k) (class II MHC) molecule. Our data demonstrate that the molecular program of both anti-CD3- and Ag-driven, but not that of superantigen-mediated apoptosis involves up-regulation of nur77, an orphan nuclear receptor, and bim, a BH3-only member of the proapoptotic bcl-2 protein family, proteins previously implicated to participate in the negative selection. Ligation of RARalpha by the synthetic agonist CD336 inhibited apoptosis, DNA binding of nur77, and synthesis of bim induced by anti-CD3 or the specific Ag, but had no effect on the superantigen-driven cell death. Our data imply that retinoids are able to inhibit negative selection in vivo as well, and they interfere with multiple steps of the T cell selection signal pathway.     

Caspase enzyme activity is not essential for apoptosis during thymocyte development

Caspases, a family of cysteine proteases, are critical mediators of apoptosis. To address the importance of caspases in thymocyte development, we have generated transgenic mice that express the baculovirus protein p35, a viral caspase inhibitor, specifically in the thymus. p35 expression inhibited Fas (CD95)-, CD3-, or peptide-induced caspase activity in vitro and conferred resistance to Fas-induced apoptosis. However, p35 did not block specific peptide-induced negative selection in OT1 and HY TCR transgenic mouse models. Even the potent pharmacological caspase inhibitor zVAD-FMK (benzyloxycarbonyl-Val-Ala-Asp-fluoromethyl-ketone) could not prevent peptide-induced deletion of OT1 thymocytes, although it improved basal thymocyte survival in vitro. Moreover, the developmental block observed in rag1-/- thymocytes, which lack pre-TCR signaling, was also not rescued by p35 expression. These results indicate that caspase-independent signal transduction pathways can mediate thymocyte death during normal T cell development.     

Ionomycin-induced apoptosis of thymocytes is independent of Nur77 NBRE or NurRE binding, but is accompanied by Nur77 mitochondrial targeting

The induction of thymocyte apoptosis through the Nur77-mediated intrinsic pathway can be of physiological importance in the clonal deletion of autoreactive thymocytes during negative selection in the thymus and/or in thymocytes undergoing oncogenic transformation. Ionomycin treatment induces endogenous Nur77 expression as well as apoptosis and cytochrome c release in thymocytes. Here it is shown for the first time that in normal thymocytes undergoing apoptosis, ionomycin induces translocation of endogenous Nur77 not only to the nucleus, but also to mitochondria. Immunosuppressant FK506 inhibits Nur77 NBRE and NurRE binding activity but has no effect on thymocytes apoptosis, the subcellular localization of Nur77, or cytochrome c release. This indicates that thymocytes can undergo apoptosis through the intrinsic Nur77-mediated mitochondrial pathway and that the transactivation activity of Nur77 monomers or dimers is not necessary for thymocyte apoptosis.     

CD40 ligand functions non-cell autonomously to promote deletion of self-reactive thymocytes

CD40 ligand (CD40L)-deficient mice have been shown to have a defect in negative selection of self-reactive T cells during thymic development. However, the mechanism by which CD40L promotes deletion of autoreactive thymocytes has not yet been elucidated. We have studied negative selection in response to endogenous superantigens in CD40L-deficient mice and, consistent with previous reports, have found a defect in negative selection in these mice. To test the requirement for expression of CD40L on T cells undergoing negative selection, we have generated chimeric mice in which CD40L wild-type and CD40L-deficient thymocytes coexist. We find that both CD40L wild-type and CD40L-deficient thymocytes undergo equivalent and efficient negative selection when these populations coexist in chimeric mice. These results indicate that CD40L can function in a non-cell-autonomous manner during negative selection. Deletion of superantigen-reactive thymocytes was normal in B7-1/B7-2 double-knockout mice, indicating that CD40-CD40L-dependent negative selection is not solely mediated by B7 up-regulation and facilitation of B7-dependent T cell signaling. Finally, although the absence of CD40-CD40L interactions impairs negative selection of autoreactive CD4(+) and CD8(+) cells during thymic development, we find that self-reactive T cells are deleted in the mature CD4(+) population through a CD40L-independent pathway.     

LIGHT (a cellular ligand for herpes virus entry mediator and lymphotoxin receptor)-mediated thymocyte deletion is dependent on the interaction between TCR and MHC/self-peptide

Negative selection serves as a major mechanism to maintain self-tolerance. We previously reported that LIGHT (a cellular ligand for herpes virus entry mediator and lymphotoxin receptor), a TNF family member, plays an important role in thymocyte development via promoting apoptosis of double-positive thymocytes. Here, we demonstrated that LIGHT-mediated deletion of thymocyte requires the strong interaction of TCR with MHC/self-peptide. Transgenic mice overexpressing LIGHT in thymocytes were bred with a transgenic mouse line expressing a TCR recognizing the H-Y male Ag in the context of H-2b class I MHC molecules. In male H-Y/LIGHT double-transgenic mice, more efficient negative selection of H-Y T cells occurred, and total thymocyte number was further reduced compared with H-Y/negative littermates. In contrast, the presence of LIGHT transgene had no evident impact on the thymocyte development of female H-Y/LIGHT double-transgenic mice. Taken together, LIGHT plays a role in negative selection of thymocytes via inducing the apoptosis of thymocytes bearing high affinity TCR during negative selection.     

T-cell receptor ligation by peptide/MHC induces activation of a caspase in immature thymocytes: the molecular basis of negative selection.

T-cell receptors (TCRs) are created by a stochastic gene rearrangement process during thymocyte development, generating thymocytes bearing useful, as well as unwanted, specificities. Within the latter group, autoreactive thymocytes arise which are subsequently eliminated via a thymocyte-specific apoptotic mechanism, termed negative selection. The molecular basis of this deletion is unknown. Here, we show that TCR triggering by peptide/MHC ligands activates a caspase in double-positive (DP) CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes, resulting in their death. Inhibition of this enzymatic activity prevents antigen-induced death of DP thymocytes in fetal thymic organ culture (FTOC) from TCR transgenic mice as well as apoptosis induced by anti-CD3epsilon monoclonal antibody and corticosteroids in FTOC of normal C57BL/6 mice. Hence, a common caspase mediates immature thymocyte susceptibility to cell death.     

Caspases in T-cell receptor-induced thymocyte apoptosis.

Apoptosis eliminates inappropriate or autoreactive T lymphocytes during thymic development. Intracellular mediators involved in T-cell receptor (TCR)-mediated apoptosis in developing thymocytes during negative selection are therefore of great interest. Caspases, cysteine proteases that mediate mature T-cell apoptosis, have been implicated in thymocyte cell death, but their regulation is not understood. We examined caspase activities in distinct thymocyte subpopulations that represent different stages of T-cell development. We found caspase activity in CD4+CD8+ double positive (DP) thymocytes, where selection involving apoptosis occurs. Earlier and later thymocyte stages exhibited no caspase activity. Only certain caspases, such as caspase-3 and caspase-8-like proteases, but not caspase-1, are active in DP thymocytes in vivo and can be activated when DP thymocytes are induced to undergo apoptosis in vitro by TCR-crosslinking. Thus, specific caspases appear to be developmentally regulated in thymocytes.     

A role for E2F1 in the induction of apoptosis during thymic negative selection.

Thymic negative selection is the process in which maturing thymocytes that express T-cell receptors recognizing self are eliminated by apoptotic cell death. The molecular mechanism by which this occurs is poorly understood. Notably, genes involved in cell death, even thymocyte death, such as Fas, Fas-ligand, p53, caspase-1, caspase-3, and caspase-9, and Bcl-2 have been found to not be required for normal thymic negative selection. We have demonstrated previously that E2F1-deficient mice have a defect in thymocyte apoptosis. Here we show that E2F1 is required for normal thymic negative selection. Furthermore, we observed an E2F1-dependent increase of p53 protein levels during the process of thymic clonal deletion, which suggests that E2F1 regulates activation-induced apoptosis of self-reactive thymocytes by a p53-dependent mechanism. In contrast, other apoptotic pathways operating on developing thymocytes, such as glucocorticoid-induced cell death, are not mediated by E2F1. The T lymphocytes that escape thymic negative selection migrate to the peripheral immune system but do not appear to be autoreactive, indicating that there may exist E2F1-independent mechanisms of peripheral tolerance, which protect mice from developing an autoimmune response. We expect that E2F1-deficient mice will provide a useful tool for understanding the molecular mechanism of and the immunological importance of thymic negative selection.     

Requirement for a complex array of costimulators in the negative selection of autoreactive thymocytes in vivo

Autoreactive thymocytes can be deleted at an immature stage of their development by Ag-induced apoptosis or negative selection. In addition to Ag, negative selection also requires costimulatory signals from APC. We recently used a fetal thymus organ culture system to show that CD5, CD28, and TNF cooperatively regulate deletion of autoreactive thymocytes. Although these experiments provided strong evidence for the action of several costimulators in negative selection, we wished to demonstrate a role for these molecules in a physiologically natural model where thymocytes are deleted in vivo by endogenously expressed AGS: Accordingly, we examined thymocyte deletion in costimulator-null mice in three models of autoantigen-induced negative selection. We compared CD5(-/-) CD28(-/-) mice to CD40L(-/-) mice, which exhibited a profound block in negative selection in all three systems. Surprisingly, only one of the three models revealed a requirement for the CD5 and CD28 costimulators in autoantigen-induced deletion. These results suggest that an extraordinarily complex array of costimulators is involved in negative selection. We predict that different sets of costimulators will be required depending on the timing of negative selection, the Ag, the signal strength, the APC, and whether Ag presentation occurs on class I or class II MHC molecules.     

Apaf1-dependent programmed cell death is required for inner ear morphogenesis and growth

During inner ear development programmed cell death occurs in specific areas of the otic epithelium but the significance of it and the molecules involved have remained unclear. We undertook an analysis of mouse mutants in which genes encoding apoptosis-associated molecules have been inactivated. Disruption of the Apaf1 gene led to a dramatic decrease in apoptosis in the inner ear epithelium, severe morphogenetic defects and a significant size reduction of the membranous labyrinth, demonstrating that an Apaf1-dependent apoptotic pathway is necessary for normal inner ear development. This pathway most probably operates through the apoptosome complex because caspase 9 mutant mice suffered similar defects. Inactivation of the Bcl2-like (Bcl2l) gene led to an overall increase in the number of cells undergoing apoptosis but did not cause any major morphogenetic defects. In contrast, decreased apoptosis was observed in specific locations that suffered from developmental deficits, indicating that proapoptotic isoform(s) produced from Bcl2l might have roles in inner ear development. In Apaf1(-/-)/Bcl2l(-/-) double mutant embryos, no cell death could be detected in the otic epithelium, demonstrating that the cell death regulated by the anti-apoptotic Bcl2l isoform, Bcl-X(L) in the otic epithelium is Apaf1-dependent. Furthermore, the otic vesicle failed to close completely in all double mutant embryos analyzed. These results indicate important roles for both Apaf1 and Bcl2l in inner ear development.     

Human CD4 expression at the late single-positive stage of thymic development supports T cell maturation and peripheral export in CD4-deficient mice

Positive selection of developing thymocytes is initiated at the double-positive (DP) CD4(+)CD8(+) stage of their maturation. Accordingly, expression of a human CD4 (hCD4) transgene beginning at the DP stage has been shown to restore normal T cell development and function in CD4-deficient mice. However, it is unclear whether later onset CD4 expression would still allow such a restoration. To investigate this issue, we used transgenic mice in which a hCD4 transgene is not expressed on DP, but only on single-positive cells. By crossing these animals with CD4-deficient mice, we show that late hCD4 expression supports the maturation of T cell precursors and the peripheral export of mature TCRalphabeta(+) CD8(-) T cells. These results were confirmed in two different MHC class II-restricted TCR transgenic mice. T cells arising by this process were functional in the periphery because they responded to agonist peptide in vivo. Interestingly, thymocytes of these mice appeared refractory to peptide-induced negative selection. Together, these results indicate that the effect of CD4 on positive selection of class II-restricted T cells extends surprisingly late into the maturation process by a previously unrecognized pathway of differentiation, which might contribute to the generation of autoreactive T cells.