Evaluation of fluorescent compound interference in 4 fluorescence polarization assays: 2 kinases, 1 protease,and 1 phosphatase

With the increasing use of fluorescence-based assays in high-throughput screening (HTS), the possibility of interference by fluorescent compounds needs to be considered. To investigate compound interference, a well-defined sample set of biologically active compounds, LOPAC, was evaluated using 4 fluorescein-based fluorescence polarization (FP) assays. Two kinase assays, a protease assay, and a phosphatase assay were studied. Fluorescent compound interference and light scattering were observed in both mixture- and single-compound testing under certain circumstances. In the kinase assays, which used low levels (1-3 nM) of fluorophore, an increase in total fluorescence, an abnormal decrease in mP readings, and negative inhibition values were attributed to compound fluorescence. Light scattering was observed by an increase in total fluorescence and minimal reduction in mP, leading to false positives. The protease and phosphatase assays, which used a higher concentration of fluorophore (20-1200 nM) than the kinase assays, showed minimal interference from fluorescent compounds, demonstrating that an increase in the concentration of the fluorophore minimized potential fluorescent compound interference. The data also suggests that mixtures containing fluorescent compounds can result in either false negatives that can mask a potential "hit" or false positives, depending on the assay format. Cy dyes (e.g., Cy3B and Cy5 ) excite and emit further into the red region than fluorescein and, when used in place of fluorescein in kinase 1, eliminate fluorescence interference and light scattering by LOPAC compounds. This work demonstrates that fluorescent compound and light scattering interferences can be overcome by increasing the fluorophore concentration in an assay or by using longer wavelength dyes.     

A homogeneous assay of kinase activity that detects phosphopeptide using fluorescence polarization and zinc

Homogeneous antibody-free assays of protein kinase activity have great utility in high-throughput screening in support of drug discovery. In an effort to develop such an assay, we have used a pair of fluorescein-labeled peptides of identical amino acid sequence with and without phosphorylation on serine to mimic the substrate and product, respectively, of a kinase. Using fluorescence polarization (FP), we have demonstrated that a mixture of zinc sulfate, phosphate-buffered saline, and bovine serum albumin added to the peptides dramatically and differentially increased the fluorescence polarization of the phosphorylated peptide over its nonphosphorylated derivative. A similar FP differential was observed using different peptide pairs, though the magnitude varied. The FP values obtained using this method were directly proportional to the fraction of phosphopeptide present. Therefore, an FP assay was developed using a proprietary kinase. Using this FP method, linear reaction kinetics were obtained in enzyme titration and reaction time course experiments. The IC(50) values for a panel of inhibitors of kinase activity were determined using this FP method and a scintillation proximity assay. The IC(50) values were comparable between the two methods, suggesting that the zinc FP assay may be useful as an inexpensive high-throughput assay for identifying inhibitors of kinase activity.     

A high-throughput fluorescent polarization assay for nuclear receptor binding utilizing crude receptor extract.

A homogenous high-throughput assay has been developed to measure the binding between nuclear receptors and test compounds. This assay applies a fluorescence polarization (FP) detection method using human glucocorticoid receptor (GR) as a model system. Crude receptor extract, which requires no additional purification, is used in the assay. The binding conditions (i.e., DMSO tolerance, temperature, stability, and variability) have been investigated and validated. At the optimized conditions, a signal-to-background ratio of 2:1 and a Z'-factor of 0.7 was achieved in a 384-well format. Several known strong and weak GR ligands have been evaluated in this system. Possible interference of fluorescent compounds and methods to identify false positives are also discussed. This FP-based assay system can potentially be used for many soluble nuclear receptors in high-throughput binding assays.     

Fluorescent retinoid X receptor ligands for fluorescence polarization assay

Retinoid X receptor (RXR) agonists are candidate agents for the treatment of metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes via activation of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR)/RXR or liver X receptor (LXR)/RXR-heterodimers, which control lipid and glucose metabolism. Reporter gene assays or binding assays with radiolabeled compounds are available for RXR ligand screening, but are unsuitable for high-throughput screening. Therefore, as a first step towards stabilizing a fluorescence polarization (FP) assay system for high-throughput RXR ligand screening, we synthesized fluorescent RXR ligands by modification of the lipophilic domain of RXR ligands with a carbostyril fluorophore, and selected the fluorescent RXR agonist 6-[ethyl(1-isobutyl-2-oxo-4-trifluoromethyl-1,2-dihydroquinolin-7-yl)amino]nicotinic acid 8d for further characterization. Compound 8d showed FP in the presence of RXR and the FP was decreased in the presence of the RXR agonist LGD1069 (2). This compound should be a lead compound for use in high-throughput assay systems for screening RXR ligands.     

Data concordance from a comparison between filter binding and fluorescence polarization assay formats for identification of ROCK-II inhibitors

The Rho-associated coiled-coil-containing protein serine/threonine kinases ROCK-I and ROCK-II are thought to play a major role in cytoskeletal dynamics by serving as downstream effectors of the Rho/Rac family of cytokine- and growth factor-activated small GTPases. As such, the ROCK family members are attractive intervention targets for a variety of pathologies, including cancer and cardiovascular disease. The authors developed a high-throughput screen to identify ROCK-II inhibitors and report results from a direct comparison of 2 screening campaigns for ROCK-II inhibitors using fluorescence polarization (FP) and filter binding (FB). Screening protocols to identify inhibitors of ROCK-II were developed in FB and FP formats under similar assay and kinetic conditions. A 30,000-member compound library was screened using FB ((33)P) and FP detection systems, and compounds that were active in either assay were retested in 5-point curve confirmation assays. Analysis of these data showed an approximate 95% agreement of compounds identified as active in both assay formats. Also, compound potency determinations from FB and FP had a high degree of correlation and were considered equivalent. These data suggest that the assay methodology has little impact on the quality and productivity of the screen, provided that the assays are developed to standardize kinetic conditions.     

Fluorescence polarization competition immunoassay for tyrosine kinases

To increase the sensitivity and throughput of protein tyrosine kinase (PTK), simple, homogeneous, nonradioactive, direct and indirect fluorescence polarization (FP) protein tyrosine kinase immunoassays have been developed that are compatible with high-throughput and ultrahigh-throughput screening for developing drugs. In the direct method, a fluorescinylated peptide substrate is incubated with the kinase, ATP, and antiphosphotyrosine antibody. The phosphorylated peptide product is immunocomplexed with the antiphosphotyrosine antibody, resulting in an increase in the polarization signal. Since the direct method can be used only with a peptide substrate and requires large amounts of antiphosphotyrosine antibody, a modified indirect method, wherein a phosphorylated peptide or protein produced by kinase reaction will compete with a fluorescent phosphopeptide used as a tracer for immunocomplex formation with phosphotyrosine antibody, was developed. In this format kinase activity will result in loss of the polarization signal. Both the direct and indirect FP-PTK immunoassays have been compared with a more commonly used (32)PO(4) transfer assay and validated using lymphoid T-cell protein tyrosine kinase (Lck). In both assays, Lck activity showed a similar dependence on ATP, Lck enzyme, and peptide substrate concentration, comparable to the (32)PO(4) transfer assay. Inhibition by staurosporine and the Lck inhibitor 4-amino-5-(methylphenyl)-7-(tert-butyl)pyrazolo[3, 4-d]pyrimidine in these two FP assays was similar to that obtained in the (32)PO(4) transfer assay. The advantages of these FP-PTK assays over the other kinase assays, besides high sensitivity, are use of inexpensive nonisotropic substrate; environmental safety; homogeneous nature of FP kinase assays that are done in the same tube (or in a well of 96- or 384-well microtiter plates), without separation, precipitation, or washing; and increase of throughput.     

A flow-through fluorescence polarization detection system for measuring GPCR-mediated modulation of cAMP production

A flow-through fluorescence polarization (FP) detection system that makes use of a novel high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) fluorescence detector modified with polarization filters was developed. This flow-through FP detection system was evaluated by using a novel and very cost-effective bioassay for cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP). The bioassay was first evaluated and optimized in an FP plate reader format and subsequently in a flow-through bioassay setup. The principle of the bioassay is based on the competition of cAMP and a fluorescent cAMP derivative for the cAMP binding domain of protein kinase A. cAMP could accurately be determined over a range of 0.8 to 30 pmol/well in the plate reader FP assay and over a range of 0.3 to 50 pmol/well in the flow-through FP assay setup. High Z' factors (i.e., 0.89 for the plate reader and 0.93 for the flow-through FP cAMP assay, respectively) indicated robust assays. Finally, functional cAMP signaling of the human histamine H(3) G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) in cell cultures was measured with both assay formats with good sensitivities and assay windows. The pEC(50) values obtained in both assay formats were in accordance with those obtained with standard methods. The flow-through FP detection system could thus be used as a cost-effective alternative to FP plate reader assays. Moreover, the novel flow-through FP detection system for cAMP constitutes a good analytical tool to be used in the GPCR research field as an alternative to the use of FP plate readers or radioactive laboratories nowadays used for cAMP measurements.     

High throughput fluorescence polarization: a homogeneous alternative to radioligand binding for cell surface receptors

High throughput fluorescence polarization (FP) assays are described that offer a nonradioactive, homogeneous, and low-cost alternative to radioligand binding assays for cell surface receptors (G protein-coupled receptors and ligand-gated ion channels). FP assays were shown to work across a range of both peptide (vasopressin V1a and delta-opioid) and nonpeptide (beta1-adrenoceptor, 5-hydroxytryptamine3) receptors. Structure-activity relationships were investigated at beta1-receptors and were found to be consistent with radioligand binding assays. FP was shown to tolerate up to 5% DMSO with no loss in sensitivity or signal window. From a random set of 1,280 compounds, 1.9% were found to significantly interfere with FP measurement. If fluorescent or quenching compounds were eliminated (3% of all compounds), less than 0.4% of compounds were found to interfere with FP measurement. Assays could be run in 384-well plates with little loss of signal window or sensitivity compared to 96-well plate assays. New advances in FP measurement have therefore enabled FP to offer a high throughput alternative to radioligand binding for cell surface receptors.     

Fluorescence polarization assay for inhibitors of the kinase domain of receptor interacting protein 1

Necrotic cell death is prevalent in many different pathological disease states and in traumatic injury. Necroptosis is a form of necrosis that stems from specific signaling pathways, with the key regulator being receptor interacting protein 1 (RIP1), a serine/threonine kinase. Specific inhibitors of RIP1, termed necrostatins, are potent inhibitors of necroptosis. Necrostatins are structurally distinct from one another yet still possess the ability to inhibit RIP1 kinase activity. To further understand the differences in the binding of the various necrostatins to RIP1 and to develop a robust high-throughput screening (HTS) assay, which can be used to identify new classes of RIP1 inhibitors, we synthesized fluorescein derivatives of Necrostatin-1 (Nec-1) and Nec-3. These compounds were used to establish a fluorescence polarization (FP) assay to directly measure the binding of necrostatins to RIP1 kinase. The fluorescein-labeled compounds are well suited for HTS because the assays have a dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) tolerance up to 5% and Z' scores of 0.62 (fluorescein-Nec-1) and 0.57 (fluorescein-Nec-3). In addition, results obtained from the FP assays and ligand docking studies provide insights into the putative binding sites of Nec-1, Nec-3, and Nec-4.     

Development and validation of a competitive AKT serine/threonine kinase fluorescence polarization assay using a product-specific anti-phospho-serine antibody.

A competitive fluorescence polarization (FP) assay has been developed for the serine/threonine kinase, AKT. The FP assay has been formatted in a 384-well microtiter plate and automated using a pipeting workstation with performance suitable for high-throughput screening. The assay design utilizes a fluorescent phosphorylated peptide complexed to a product-specific anti-phospho-serine antibody. When unlabeled substrate is phosphorylated, by the kinase, the product competes with the fluorescent phosphorylated peptide for the antibody. The fluorescent phosphorylated peptide is then released from the antibody into solution resulting in a loss in polarization signal. Seven fluorescent phosphorylated peptides and 19 antibodies were evaluated for this assay. RARTSpSFAEPGK-Fl peptide and anti-phospho-GSK-3alpha Ser21 antibody gave the best affinity and change in polarization signal. The apparent kinetic constants were calculated for the FP assay and were consistent with reported values. The FP assay was validated with known inhibitors and the results compared to a radioactive Flashplate transfer assay, utilizing [(33)P]ATP and a biotinylated substrate, also developed in our laboratory. The IC(50) values generated were comparable between the two methods suggesting the competitive FP assay and Flashplate assay have similar sensitivities and abilities to identify inhibitors during screening.     

Identification of a high-affinity anti-phosphoserine antibody for the development of a homogeneous fluorescence polarization assay of protein kinase C

In the last few years, fluorescence polarization (FP) has been applied to the development of robust, homogeneous, high throughput assays in molecular recognition research, such as ligand-protein interactions. Recently, this technology has been applied to the development of homogeneous tyrosine kinase assays, since there are high-affinity anti-phosphotyrosine antibodies available. Unlike tyrosine kinases, application of FP to assay development for serine/threonine kinases has been impeded because of lack of high-affinity anti-phosphoserine/threonine antibodies. In the present study, we report the discovery of a high-affinity, monoclonal anti-phosphoserine antibody, 2B9, with a Kd of 250 +/- 34 pM for a phosphoserine-containing peptide tracer, fluorescein-RFARKGS(PO(4))LRQKNV. Our data suggest that 2B9 is selective for fluorescein-RFARKGS(PO(4))LRQKNV. The antibody and tracer have been used for the development of a competitive FP assay for protein kinase C (PKC) in 384-well plates. Phosphatidylserine, which enhances the kinase activity of PKC in a Ca(2+)-dependent manner and has a structure similar to that of phosphoserine, did not interfere with binding of the peptide tracer to the antibody in the FP assay. The data indicate that the FP assay is more sensitive and robust than the scintillation proximity assay for PKC. The FP assay developed here can be used for rapid screening of hundreds of thousands of compounds for discovery of therapeutic leads for PKC-related diseases.     

Utilization of fluorescence polarization and time resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay formats for SAR studies: Src kinase as a model system

High-throughput screening (HTS), a major component of lead identification, often utilizes fluorescence-based assay technologies. For example, HTS kinase assays are formatted using a variety of fluorescence-based assay technologies including, but not limited to, dissociation enhanced lanthanide fluoroimmunoassay (DELFIA), time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET), and fluorescence polarization (FP). These assays offer tremendous advantages such as a nonradioactive format, ease of automation, and excellent reproducibility. Fluorescence-based assays frequently used for lead identification can also be useful for structure activity relationship (SAR) studies during lead optimization. An important issue when assessing an assay to be used for SAR is the ability of the assay to discriminate high-affinity small molecule inhibitors (pM-nM) from low-affinity inhibitors (microM-mM). The purpose of this study was to utilize HTS-friendly assay formats for SAR by developing TR-FRET, FP, and DELFIAassays measuring Src kinase activity and to define the theoretical lower limit of small molecule inhibitor detection achievable with these assay formats. The authors show that 2 homogeneous assay formats, TR-FRET and FP, allowed for the development of Src kinase assays with a lower limit of detection of K(i) = 0.01 nM. This study indicates that assay technologies typically used for HTS can be used during lead optimization by providing quantitative measurements of compound activity critical to driving SAR studies.     

Development of a Transcreener kinase assay for protein kinase A and demonstration of concordance of data with a filter-binding assay format

A Transcreener kinase fluorescence polarization (FP) assay has been developed for the serine/threonine kinase protein kinase A (PKA). The PKA Transcreener kinase assay is an homogenous, competitive antibody-based FP assay that uses Far Red Alexa Fluor 633-labeled adenosine 5' disphosphate (ADP) tracer and mouse monoclonal anti-ADP antibody. The Transcreener PKA assay was validated with both known PKA inhibitors and library compounds. The Transcreener PKA assay is resistant to low-wavelength (or common) fluorescent interference from small-molecule library compounds and generates IC50 results comparable with current radioactive filter-binding assay.     

Universal SNP genotyping assay with fluorescence polarization detection

The degree of fluorescence polarization (FP) of a fluorescent molecule is a reflection of its molecular weight (Mr). FP is therefore a useful detection methodfor homogeneous assays in which the starting reagents and products differ significantly in Mr. We have previously shown that FP is a good detection method for the single-base extension and the 5'-nuclease assays. In this report, we describe a universal, optimized single-base extension assay for genotyping single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). This assay, which we named the template-directed dye-terminator incorporation assay with fluorescence polarization detection (FP-TDI), uses four spectrally distinct dye terminators to achieve universal assay conditions. Even without optimization, approximately 70% of all SNP markers tested yielded robust assays. The addition of an E. coli ssDNA-binding protein just before the FP reading significantly increased FP values of the products and brought the success rate of FP-TDI assays up to 90%. Increasing the amount of dye terminators and reducing the number of thermal cycles in the single-base extension step of the assay increased the separation of the FP values benveen the products corresponding to different genotypes and improved the success rate of the assay to 100%. In this study the genomic DNA samples of 90 individuals were typed for a total of 38 FP-TDI assays (using both the sense and antisense TDI primers for 19 SNP markers). With the previously described modifications, the FP-TDI assay gave unambiguous genotyping data for all the samples tested in the 38 FP-TDI assays. When the genotypes determined by the FP-TDI and 5'-nuclease assays were compared, they were in 100% concordance for all experiments (a total of 3420 genotypes). The four-dye-terminator master mixture described here can be used for assaying any SNP marker and greatly simplifies the SNP genotyping assay design.     

USE OF FLUORESCENCE POLARIZATION DETECTION FOR THE MEASUREMENT OF FLUOPEPTIDE™ BINDING TO G PROTEIN-COUPLED RECEPTORS

ABSTRACT

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) represent the single largest molecular target of therapeutic drugs currently on the market, and are also the most common target in high throughput screening assays designed to identify potential new drug candidates. A large percentage of these assays are now formatted as radioligand binding assays. Fluorescence polarization ligand binding assays can offer a non-rad alternative to radioligand binding assays. In addition, fluorescence polarization assays are a homogenous format that is easy to automate for high throughput screening. We have developed a series of peptide ligands labeled with the fluorescent dye BODIPY® TMR whose binding to GPCRs can be detected using fluorescence polarization methodology. BODIPY® TMR has advantages over the more commonly used fluorescein dye in high throughput screening (HTS) assays due to the fact that its excitation and emission spectra are red-shifted approximately 50 nm relative to fluorescein. Assays based on BODIPY® TMR ligands are therefore less susceptible to interference from tissue auto-fluorescence in the assay matrix, or the effects of colored or fluorescent compounds in the screening libraries. A series of BODIPY® TMR labeled peptides have been prepared that bind to a range of GPCRs including melanin concentrating hormone, bradykinin, and melanocortin receptors. Conditions have been optimized in order to utilize a comparable amount of receptor membrane preparation as is used in a radioligand binding assay. The assays are formatted in 384-well microplates with a standard volume of 40 µL. We have compared the assays across the different fluorescence polarization (FP) readers available to determine the parameters for each instrument necessary to achieve the required precision.     

Use of fluorescence polarization detection for the measurement of fluopeptidetm binding to G protein-coupled receptors

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) represent the single largest molecular target of therapeutic drugs currently on the market, and are also the most common target in high throughput screening assays designed to identify potential new drug candidates. A large percentage of these assays are now formatted as radioligand binding assays. Fluorescence polarization ligand binding assays can offer a non-rad alternative to radioligand binding assays. In addition, fluorescence polarization assays are a homogenous format that is easy to automate for high throughput screening. We have developed a series of peptide ligands labeled with the fluorescent dye BODIPY TMR whose binding to GPCRs can be detected using fluorescence polarization methodology. BODIPY TMR has advantages over the more commonly used fluorescein dye in high throughput screening (HTS) assays due to the fact that its excitation and emission spectra are red-shifted approximately 50 nm relative to fluorescein. Assays based on BODIPY TMR ligands are therefore less susceptible to interference from tissue auto-fluorescence in the assay matrix, or the effects of colored or fluorescent compounds in the screening libraries. A series of BODIPY TMR labeled peptides have been prepared that bind to a range of GPCRs including melanin concentrating hormone, bradykinin, and melanocortin receptors. Conditions have been optimized in order to utilize a comparable amount of receptor membrane preparation as is used in a radioligand binding assay. The assays are formatted in 384-well microplates with a standard volume of 40 microL. We have compared the assays across the different fluorescence polarization (FP) readers available to determine the parameters for each instrument necessary to achieve the required precision.     

A fluorescence lifetime-based assay for serine and threonine kinases that is suitable for high-throughput screening

We describe the development of a novel method for the assay of serine/threonine protein kinases based on fluorescence lifetime. The assay consists of three generic peptides (which have been used by others in the assay of >140 protein kinases in various assay formats) labeled with a long lifetime fluorescent dye (14 or 17 ns) that act as substrates for protein kinases and an iron(III) chelate that modulates the fluorescence lifetime of the peptide only when it is phosphorylated. The decrease in average fluorescence lifetime as measured in a recently developed fluorescence lifetime plate reader (Edinburgh Instruments) is a measure of the degree of phosphorylation of the peptide. We present data showing that the assay performs as well as, and in some cases better than, the “gold standard” radiometric kinase assays with respect to Z′ values, demonstrating its utility in high-throughput screening applications. We also show that the assay gives nearly identical results in trial screening to those obtained by radiometric assays and that it is less prone to interference than simple fluorescence intensity measurements.     

High-throughput fluorescence polarization assay to identify small molecule inhibitors of BRCT domains of breast cancer gene 1

The C-terminus region of the 1863 residue early onset of breast cancer gene 1 (BRCA1) nuclear protein contains a tandem globular carboxy terminus domain termed BRCT. The BRCT repeats in BRCA1 are phosphoserine- and/or phosphothreonine-specific binding modules. The interaction of the BRCT(BRCA1) domains with phosphorylated BRCA1-associated carboxyl terminal helicase (BACH1) is cell cycle regulated and is essential for DNA damage-induced checkpoint control during the transition from the G(2) phase to the M phase of the cell cycle. Development of a competitive, homogeneous, high-throughput fluorescence polarization (FP) assay to identify small molecule inhibitors of BRCT(BRCA1)-BACH1 interaction is reported here. The FP assay was used for measuring binding affinities and inhibition constants of BACH1 peptides and small molecule inhibitors of BRCT(BRCA1) domains, respectively. A fluorescently labeled wild-type BACH1 decapeptide (BDP1) containing the critical phosphoserine, a phenylalanine at (P+3), and a GST-BRCT fusion protein were used to establish the FP assay. BDP1 has a dissociation constant (K(d)) of 1.58+/-0.01microM and a dynamic range (DeltamP) of 164.9+/-1.9. The assay tolerates 20% dimethyl sulfoxide, which enables screening poorly soluble compounds. Under optimized conditions, a Z' factor of 0.87 was achieved in a 384-well format for high-throughput screening.     

Comparison of assay technologies for a tyrosine kinase assay generates different results in high throughput screening

In today's high-throughput screening (HTS) environment, an increasing number of assay detection technologies are routinely utilized in lead finding programs. Because of the relatively broad applicability of several of these technologies, one is often faced with a choice of which technology to utilize for a specific assay. The aim of this study was to address the question of whether the same compounds would be identified from screening a set of samples in three different versions of an HTS assay. Here, three different versions of a tyrosine kinase assay were established using scintillation proximity assay (SPA), homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (HTR-FRET), and fluorescence polarization (FP) technologies. In this study, 30,000 compounds were evaluated in each version of the kinase assay in primary screening, deconvolution, and dose-response experiments. From this effort, there was only a small degree of overlap of active compounds identified subsequent to the deconvolution experiment. When all active compounds were then profiled in all three assays, 100 and 101 active compounds were identified in the HTR-FRET and FP assays, respectively. In contrast, 40 compounds were identified in the SPA version of the kinase assay, whereas all of these compounds were detected in the HTR-FRET assay only 35 were active in the FP assay. Although there was good correlation between the IC(50) values obtained in the HTR-FRET and FP assays, poor correlations were obtained with the IC(50) values obtained in the SPA assay. These findings suggest that significant differences can be observed from HTS depending on the assay technology that is utilized, particularly in assays with high hit rates.