Reappearance of Cucumber mosaic virus Isolates Belonging to Subgroup IB in Tomato Plants in North-eastern Spain

A disease characterized by symptomless leaves and fruit decolouration, loss of consistency and mild deformation on ripening was detected in tomato fields in north‐eastern Spain during 2003 and 2004. DAS‐ELISA analysis revealed the presence of the Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) in all diseased plants. CMV isolates were characterized by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) analysis of double‐stranded RNAs (dsRNAs) and nucleotide sequence analysis, and compared with some CMV isolates belonging to different subgroups used as controls. A total of 12 isolates obtained from the infected tomato plants selected for this study gave the same electrophoresis pattern for the three genomic dsRNAs, which was different to the patterns showed by the CMV isolates collected in the same region a few years ago. The identity of the complete nucleotide sequence of one of these CMV isolates and the partial sequence of other five isolates compared to the Tfn strain from Italy and the BAR92/1 isolate from tomato collected in Barcelona in 1992 was higher than 99%, both belonging to subgroup IB of CMV. The CMV isolates of this subgroup found in eastern Spain in previous studies were not detected after 1996. The nucleotide sequences of two isolates that were chosen as representatives of the CMV isolates more frequently detected in previous years revealed that they belonged to the CMV subgroups IA. The origin and the possible causes of reappearance of CMV IB isolates in north‐eastern Spain are discussed.     

Natural resistance to cucumber mosaic virus in lupin species

Ten species of lupins (Lupinus spp.) were tested for resistance to cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV) in field experiments where inoculation was by naturally-occurring aphid vectors, and in the glasshouse by sap or graft-inoculation. L. albus and six species of ‘rough-seeded’ lupins did not become infected with CMV either under intense inoculum pressure in the field or when graft-inoculated. Two L. hispanicus, 17 L. luteus and four L. mutabilis genotypes became infected with CMV in the field, but no infection was detected in L. hispanicus P26858 or seven L. luteus genotypes. CMV was detected at seed transmission rates of 0.2–16% in seedlings of infected L. luteus, differences in levels of seed transmission between genotypes being significant and relatively stable from year to year. Graft-inoculation of CMV to plants of six genotypes of L. luteus in which no infection was found in the field induced a systemic necrotic reaction suggesting that the resistance they carry is due to hypersensitivity. In L. hispanicus accessions P26849, P26853 and P26858, CMV sub-group II isolate SN caused necrotic spots in inoculated leaves without systemic movement, while sub-group I isolate SL infected them systemically without necrosis. Another sub-group I and two other sub-group II isolates behaved like SL in P26849 and P26853 but infected only inoculated leaves of P26858. This suggests that two strain specific hypersensitive resistance specificities are operating against CMV in L. hispanicus. When plants of L. luteus genotypes that gave hypersensitive reactions on graft-inoculation were inoculated with infective sap containing two sub-group I and seven sub-group II isolates, they all responded like L. hispanicus P26858. A strain group concept is proposed for CMV in lupins based on the two hypersensitive specificities found: strain group 1 represented by isolate SN which induces hypersensitivity with both specificities, strain group 2 represented by the three isolates which induced hypersensitivity only with the specificity present in L. luteus and L. hispanicus P26858, strain group 3 by as yet hypothetical isolates that induce hypersensitivity only in presence of the specificity in L. hispanicus P26849 and P26853 that responded just to isolate SN, and strain group 4 by isolate SL which overcomes both specificities. When F₂ progeny plants from crosses between hypersensitive and susceptible L. luteus parents were inoculated with isolate SN, the resistance segregated with a 3:1 ratio (hypersensitive:susceptible), suggesting that a single dominant hypersensitivity gene, Ncm-1, is responsible. As gene Ncm-1 had broad specificity and was not overcome by any of the five CMV isolates from lupins tested, it is valuable for use in breeding CMV resistant L. luteus cultivars.     

Natural resistance to cucumber mosaic virus in lupin species

Ten species of lupins (Lupinus spp.) were tested for resistance to cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV) in field experiments where inoculation was by naturally-occurring aphid vectors, and in the glasshouse by sap or graft-inoculation. L. albus and six species of ‘rough-seeded’ lupins did not become infected with CMV either under intense inoculum pressure in the field or when graft-inoculated. Two L. hispanicus, 17 L. luteus and four L. mutabilis genotypes became infected with CMV in the field, but no infection was detected in L. hispanicus P26858 or seven L. luteus genotypes. CMV was detected at seed transmission rates of 0.2–16% in seedlings of infected L. luteus, differences in levels of seed transmission between genotypes being significant and relatively stable from year to year. Graft-inoculation of CMV to plants of six genotypes of L. luteus in which no infection was found in the field induced a systemic necrotic reaction suggesting that the resistance they carry is due to hypersensitivity. In L. hispanicus accessions P26849, P26853 and P26858, CMV sub-group II isolate SN caused necrotic spots in inoculated leaves without systemic movement, while sub-group I isolate SL infected them systemically without necrosis. Another sub-group I and two other sub-group II isolates behaved like SL in P26849 and P26853 but infected only inoculated leaves of P26858. This suggests that two strain specific hypersensitive resistance specificities are operating against CMV in L. hispanicus. When plants of L. luteus genotypes that gave hypersensitive reactions on graft-inoculation were inoculated with infective sap containing two sub-group I and seven sub-group II isolates, they all responded like L. hispanicus P26858. A strain group concept is proposed for CMV in lupins based on the two hypersensitive specificities found: strain group 1 represented by isolate SN which induces hypersensitivity with both specificities, strain group 2 represented by the three isolates which induced hypersensitivity only with the specificity present in L. luteus and L. hispanicus P26858, strain group 3 by as yet hypothetical isolates that induce hypersensitivity only in presence of the specificity in L. hispanicus P26849 and P26853 that responded just to isolate SN, and strain group 4 by isolate SL which overcomes both specificities. When F₂ progeny plants from crosses between hypersensitive and susceptible L. luteus parents were inoculated with isolate SN, the resistance segregated with a 3:1 ratio (hypersensitive:susceptible), suggesting that a single dominant hypersensitivity gene, Ncm-1, is responsible. As gene Ncm-1 had broad specificity and was not overcome by any of the five CMV isolates from lupins tested, it is valuable for use in breeding CMV resistant L. luteus cultivars.     

Interaction of Cucumber mosaic virus and Bean yellow mosaic virus in co-infected plants of bean and broad bean

After evaluation of the responses of bean and broad bean common cultivars against an isolate of Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV-K) and Bean yellow mosaic virus (BYMV-K), interaction of isolates was statistically studied on co-infected plants of bean cv. Bountiful and broad bean cv. Lahijan at two trials. Based on viral relative concentration determined by quantitative enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, BYMV interacts synergistically with CMV in bean at 14 days post inoculation, while in co-infection with BYMV, CMV interacts antagonistically in both host plants at least in one of the two trials. This suggests that CMV/BYMV interaction is dependent on host species and developmental stage of plant. Co-infection like single infection with CMV in bean plants led to significantly decrease in plants’ height and fresh weight than BYMV singly infected and healthy plants, while viral infection of broad bean plants did not significantly affect growth parameters. Decline effect of viral infection (especially co-infection) on chlorophyll and carotenoids value of bean plants was greater than those of broad bean. Viral infection (singly or doubly) caused irregular changes in nutrient elements values of both hosts compared with healthy ones.     

Transmission Comparisons of Cucumber Mosaic Virus Subgroup I and II Isolates by Different Aphid Species

To investigate the transmission differences between Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) subgroup isolates, we carried out a comparative study with five aphid species Myzus persicae, Aphis gossypii, Lipaphis erysimi, Aphis craccivora and Megoura viciae in laboratory and field experiments to evaluate spread of CMV Subgroup I NX and subgroup II AG isolates in tobacco. Both NX and AG varied in transmission efficiency by the five aphids, and our transmission results revealed important differences in transmission efficiency of two isolates by Myzus persicae and Aphis gossypii. In contrast, significant transmission differences were not detected with Lipaphis erysimi, Aphis craccivora or Megoura viciae. Interestingly, the overall transmission efficiencies of the two different subgroup strains were almost equal when field transmissions were tested with mixed populations of the five aphid species. Our results together with our previously reported experiments on competition of CMV subgroup isolates in tobacco suggest that variations in aphid vector populations contribute substantially to the epidemic potential of CMV subgroup isolates.     

The Ability of Aphis craccivora, A. gossypii and A. citricola to Transmit Single and Mixed Viruses to Cowpeas

The ability of populations of adult apterous Aphis craccivora, A. gossypii and A. citricola to transmit the cowpea aphid-borne virus (CAMV) and cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) to cowpea was investigated. CMV was more readily transmitted than CAMV by all three aphid species, but was most readily transmitted by A. craccivora and A. citricola, with transmissions ranging from 64–71 %. With CAMV, the infection level with A. gossypii was higher than with A. craccivora and both were more efficient than A. citricola, although the differences were not significant. With mixed infections of CAMV and CMV, there was a higher level of CAMV transmission using A. craccivora from sequential feeding when CMV-infected plants were fed on first followed by CAMV-infected plants, suggesting that cowpea plants were more prone to infection by CAMV when already infected by CMV.     

Grafting to manage infections of top stunting and necrogenic strains of cucumber mosaic virus in tomato

Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) lists among the most important etiological agents of tomato diseases. Some isolates of CMV function as helper virus for replication, encapsidation and transmission of satellite RNAs (satRNA), which may exacerbate symptoms induced by CMV in certain hosts. Outbreaks of CMV strains supporting hypervirulent variants of satRNAs are recurrent in tomato with devastating effects on crop production and efficient control measures are still unavailable. In this study, we examined the dynamics of infection of the CMV strains tomato top stunting (TTS) and 77 supporting replication of satRNA variants that codetermine top stunting (TTS‐satRNA) and necrotic (77‐satRNA) phenotypes in two tomato cultivars denoted Solanum lycopersicum Manduria (Sl‐Ma) and S. lycopersicum UC82 (Sl‐UC). Sl‐Ma but not Sl‐UC recovered from disease symptoms induced by CMV‐TTS while both the cultivars succumbed to the infection of CMV‐77 and its necrogenic satRNA. Ability to recover of the Sl‐Ma plants was transmitted by grafting to the susceptible genotype Sl‐UC. More interestingly, recovery was observed also against the challenge inoculation of CMV plus 77‐satRNA in plants grafted on Sl‐Ma and in self‐grafted plants of both the Sl‐Ma and Sl‐UC cultivars. Analysis of small RNAs and genes of the defence plant response based on RNA interference (RNAi) suggested that RNAi is involved in the recovery of Sl‐Ma against CMV with hypervirulent satRNAs and in scions grafted on this rootstock. The response of Sl‐Ma to the inoculation of CMV‐77 plus 77‐satRNA was compared with that of the transgenic tomato line S. lycopersicum transgenic line UCTC5.9.2 that expresses constitutively the benign variant of the satRNA denoted Tfn‐satRNA. Comparative analysis suggested that the response may operate via similar mechanisms, which involve RNAi, the graft and the presence of the satRNA.     

Responses of potato cultivars (Solanum tuberosum) to infection with Cucumber mosaic virus isolated from different host species

Eight isolates of Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) isolated from seven different host species were tested for their virulence on potato cv. Desirée. Three isolates caused a systemic infection, of which one isolate from Asiatic lily (CMV-P26) and one from cucumber (CMV-J) appeared to be highly virulent, in contrast to the third isolate (CMV-M) that originated from cucumber and caused mild symptoms only. These three isolates were transmitted to 26 additional potato cultivars by mechanical inoculation in a greenhouse. All cultivars were infected with at least one CMV isolate and developed local chlorotic symptoms, but only 17 cultivars (including Desiree) developed primary systemic symptoms including necrosis, mosaic and/or malformation of leaves. Furthermore, in only five cultivars (including Desiree) CMV was transmitted to tubers and was subsequently detected in plants of the first and second vegetative progeny, the secondary symptoms of these plants being severe. The observed phenotypic responses of potatoes to CMV were not associated with the maturity type (early or late) or resistance to other viruses. Results of this study indicate a high level of biological variability among CMV isolates and that infection in potato depends on CMV isolate and potato cultivar.     

Development of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cucumber mosaic virus</Emphasis> as a vector modifiable for different host species to produce therapeutic proteins

We have developed Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) as a plant virus vector especially for production of pharmaceutical proteins. The CMV vector is a vector modifiable for different host plants and does not require further engineering steps. CMV contains three genomic RNA molecules (RNAs 1–3) necessary for infectivity. With this system, instead of creating different vector constructs for each plant we use, we take advantage of the formation of pseudrecombinants between two CMV isolates by simply reassembling a vector construct (RNA 2 base) and an RNA molecule containing the host determinant (mostly RNA 3). In this study, the gene for acidic fibroblast growth factor (aFGF), one of the human cytokines, was cloned under the control of the subgenomic promoter for RNA 4A of the CMV-based vector, C2-H1. Infected Nicotiana benthamiana plants produced aFGF at levels up to 5–8% of the total soluble protein. The tobacco-produced aFGF was purified, and its biological activity was confirmed. Using this system, which provides a versatile and viable strategy for the production of therapeutic proteins in plants, we also demonstrated a high level of aFGF in Glycine max (soybean) and Arabidopsis thaliana.     

Virus symptom expressions on Musa landraces in 1999, 2000 and 2004 in southern Nigeria: Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) disease incidence and subgroup differentiation

Musa landraces (469) from 73 villages in 10 states in 1999, 2000 and 2004 in southern Nigeria were visually assessed to determine virus symptoms associated with CMV disease. CMV indexing was done using dot-blot immunoassay and ELISA. Monoclonal antibodies were used to group CMV isolates in 2004. Symptoms of interveinal chlorosis and chlorotic streaks were observed in 22.4 and 17.9% of the Musa samples with CMV disease incidences of 17.1% and 14.7%, respectively. Other virus symptoms accounted for between 1.5 and 12.2% of the total leaf samples while 13.9% were asymptomatic. CMV incidence in asymptomatic leaf samples was as high as 10.4% while the virus incidence in the other symptom types were between 0.9 and 7.9%. The incidences of CMV in both the symptomatic and asymptomatic plants in 1999, 2000 and 2004 were between 1.3 and 18.7%, 1.9 and 26.9% and 4.9 and 26.4%, respectively.     

Resistance to cucumber mosaic virus in potato

Reactions to two subgroup I isolates (Fny-CMV and Pf-CMV) and two subgroup II isolates (A9-CMV and LS-CMV) of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) were studied in three non tuber-bearing wild potato species (Solanum spp.) of the series Etuberosa, and in two tuber-bearing interspecific potato hybrids and four potato cultivars using graft-inoculation. Three classes of phenotypic reactions (susceptible, hypersensitive, extreme resistance) were observed in the tuber-bearing genotypes. Susceptible genotypes developed mosaic or severe mosaic with leaf malformation and had high CMV titres. Hypersensitive genotypes developed either top necrosis or vein necrosis and/or necrotic spots on apical leaves, and had low CMV titres. Extremely resistant genotypes had no symptoms and no CMV was detected. The hybrid 87HW13.7 (S. tuberosum×S. multidissectum) developed top necrosis specific to infection with Fny-CMV. The hybrid ‘A6’ (S. demissum×S. tuberosum cv. Aquila) was hypersensitive to all CMV isolates tested. Extreme resistance was not functional against all CMV isolates. Neither hypersensitivity nor extreme resistance were related to the CMV subgroup.     

Resistance to Cucumber mosaic virus in Gladiolus plants transformed with either a defective replicase or coat protein subgroup II gene from Cucumber mosaic virus

Transgenic Gladiolus plants that contain either Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) subgroup I coat protein, CMV subgroup II coat protein, CMV replicase, a combination of the CMV subgroups I and II coat proteins, or a combination of the CMV subgroup II coat protein and replicase genes were developed. These plants were multiplied in vitro and challenged with purified CMV isolated from Gladiolus using a hand-held gene gun. Three out of 19 independently transformed plants expressing the replicase gene under control of the duplicated CaMV 35S promoter were found to be resistant to CMV subgroup I. Three out of 21 independently transformed plants with the CMV subgroup II coat protein gene under control of the Arabidopsis UBQ3 promoter were resistant to CMV subgroup II. Eighteen independently transformed plants with either the CMV subgroup I coat protein or a combination of CMV subgroups I and II coat proteins were challenged and found to be susceptible to both CMV subgroups I or II. Virus resistant plants with the CMV replicase transgene expressed much lower RNA levels than resistant plants expressing the CMV subgroup II coat protein. This work will facilitate the evaluation of virus resistance in transgenic Gladiolus plants to yield improved floral quality and productivity.     

Blockage of stylet tips as the mechanism of resistance to virus transmission by Aphis gossypii in melon lines bearing the Vat gene

Aphis gossypii is the main virus vector in muskmelon crops. The melon gene Vat confers resistance to non‐persistent virus transmission by this aphid. The mechanism of this resistance is not well understood, but no relationship has been detected between resistance and the probing behaviour of aphids on resistant plants. Results presented here suggest that temporary blockage of aphid stylet tips preventing virus particle release may explain the resistance conferred by Vat gene. We performed experiments in which viruliferous aphids were allowed to probe different sequences of resistant (Vat‐bearing) and/or susceptible melon plants. The results demonstrated that A. gossypii inoculates Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) efficiently in susceptible plants having previously probed resistant plants, showing that the resistance mechanism is reversible. Furthermore, the infection rate obtained for susceptible plants was the same (25%) regardless of whether the transmitting aphid had come directly from the CMV source or had subsequently probed on resistant plants. This result suggests that virus is not lost from stylet to plant during probing of resistant plants, supporting the temporary blockage hypothesis. We also found that the ability of Myzus persicae to transmit CMV is noticeably reduced after probing on resistant plants, providing evidence that this aphid species also responds to the presence of the Vat gene. Finally, we also found that in probes immediately after virus acquisition M. persicae inoculates resistant plants with CMV more efficiently than susceptible plants, perhaps because the Vat gene product induces increased salivation by this aphid.     

Detection of cucumber mosaic virus in some ornamental plants and elimination of nonspecific ELISA reactions

During surveys carried out in 2008 in the nurseries of some ornamental and medical plants, about 90 plant samples belonging to six plant species were collected. Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) was detected by routinely double antibody sandwich-enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (DAS-ELISA) in most tested plants. In Vinca rosea, Ocimum basilicum and Pelargonium sp., which reacted positively for CMV, 100% of the samples were infected. High absorbance values were obtained when extracts were prepared from these species and then examined by DAS-ELISA. The results indicated that CMV concentration on O. basilicum is greater than 50 μg ml^?1 when compared with purified CMV standards. High absorbance values occur even under conditions fully unsuitable for the detection of antigens. This result suggested that the strong ELISA absorbance values were nonspecific reactions with materials in plant extracts. So, other detection methods including dot blot, Western blot and bioassay was used for comparing with ELISA test. The nonspecific reactions were substantiated when CMV was not detected by dot blot and Western blot. Also, infectious CMV was not detected in bioassay involving inoculation of extracts onto Chenopodium amaranticolor and Nicotiana tabacum var. White Burley plants as indicator hosts. Addition of bovine serum albumin (BSA) or polyvinylpyrolidene (PVP) to extraction buffer or to wells after IgG coating for DAS-ELISA reduced nonspecific reactions. Finally, CMV was isolated from V. rosea symptomatic plants, which give a positive reaction by DAS-ELISA, dot blot, Western blot and bioassay. CMV vinca-isolate was identified based on transmission, host range, serological tests, purification and electron microscope.     

Arabis mosaic and Prunus necrotic ringspot viruses in hop (Humulus lupulus L.)

Purified virus preparations made from nettlehead-diseased hop plants, or from Chenopodium quinoa, to which the virus was transmitted by inoculation of sap, contained polyhedral virus particles of 30 mμ diameter which were identified serologically as arabis mosaic virus (AMV). There were serological differences between AMV isolates from hop and from strawberry, and also differences in host range and in symptoms caused in C. quinoa and C. amaranticolor. AMV was always associated with nettlehead disease. The nematode Xiphinema diversicaudatum occurred in small numbers in most hop gardens, but was numerous where nettlehead disease was spreading rapidly. Preparations from nettlehead-affected hops also contained a second virus, serologically related to Prunus necrotic ringspot virus (NRSV), in mild and virulent forms which infected the same range of test plants but showed some serological differences. Mild isolates did not protect C. quinoa plants against infection by virulent isolates. Hop seedlings inoculated with virulent isolates of NRSV developed symptoms indistinguishable from those of split leaf blotch disease. Latent infection with NRSV was prevalent in symptomless hop plants. Nettlehead disease is apparently associated with dual infection of AMV and virulent isolates of NRSV. An unnamed virus with rod-shaped particles 650 mμ long was common in hop and was transmitted by inoculation of sap to herbaceous plants. Cucumber mosaic virus was obtained from a single plant of Humulus scandens Merr.     

Studies on the seed transmission of cucumber mosaic virus in chickweed (Stellaria media) in relation to the ecology of the virus

Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) was transmitted in the seed of infected Stellaria media plants. The rate of seed transmission varied both in manually infected plants (3–21%) and in plants grown from infected seed (21–40%). In naturally infected plants the rates of transmission found were 4–29%. Seeds recovered from field soil carried 4–5% infection and in infected seed placed in the soil the virus persisted for at least 5 months. Seed transmission of CMV also occurred in infected Lamium purpureum (4%), Cerastium holosteoides (2%) and Spergula arvensis (2%) but it could not be demonstrated in six other more common weed species in five botanical families. Seed transmission in Stellaria media occurred with a British (W) and an American (Y) strain of CMV. The virus was shown to occur in S. media pollen. The importance of CMV-infected S. media seed in the soil in relation to the epidemiology of the virus is discussed.     

Resistance of tomato infected with cucumber mosaic virus satellite RNA to potato spindle tuber viroid

Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum cvs Rutgers and Lichun) plants were firstly pre-inoculated either with a cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) isolate containing satellite RNA (CMV-S52) or with a CMV isolate without satellite RNA, and then challenged 14 days later with a severe strain of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd). Also, tomato plants transformed with CMV satellite cDNA and non-transgenic control plants were directly inoculated with PSTVd. Protection effects were assessed by the observation of symptoms and by assay of PSTVd accumulation in tomato plants using return polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and silver staining. The results indicated that the satellite-transgenic plants and plants pre-inoculated with CMV-S52 showed much milder symptoms of PSTVd infection than the respective control plants. The concentration of PSTVd RNA in the satellite-transgenic plants and CMV-S52 pre-inoculated plants was reduced to about 0.02–0.03 of the controls. PSTVd infection did not increase the amount of satellite ds-RNA in plants. It is concluded that the plant resistance to PSTVd is induced by the presence of satellite RNA rather than the CMV infection. It is suggested that as there is considerable sequence similarity between satellite RNA and PSTVd, base pairings may be a cause of reduction of both symptoms and the accumulation of PSTVd.     

Resistance of tomato infected with cucumber mosaic virus satellite RNA to potato spindle tuber viroid

Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum cvs Rutgers and Lichun) plants were firstly pre-inoculated either with a cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) isolate containing satellite RNA (CMV-S52) or with a CMV isolate without satellite RNA, and then challenged 14 days later with a severe strain of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd). Also, tomato plants transformed with CMV satellite cDNA and non-transgenic control plants were directly inoculated with PSTVd. Protection effects were assessed by the observation of symptoms and by assay of PSTVd accumulation in tomato plants using return polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and silver staining. The results indicated that the satellite-transgenic plants and plants pre-inoculated with CMV-S52 showed much milder symptoms of PSTVd infection than the respective control plants. The concentration of PSTVd RNA in the satellite-transgenic plants and CMV-S52 pre-inoculated plants was reduced to about 0.02-0.03 of the controls. PSTVd infection did not increase the amount of satellite ds-RNA in plants. It is concluded that the plant resistance to PSTVd is induced by the presence of satellite RNA rather than the CMV infection. It is suggested that as there is considerable sequence similarity between satellite RNA and PSTVd, base pairings may be a cause of reduction of both symptoms and the accumulation of PSTVd.