Quinoline antimalarials decrease the rate of beta-hematin formation

The strength of inhibition of beta-hematin (synthetic hemozoin or malaria pigment) formation by the quinoline antimalarial drugs chloroquine, amodiaquine, quinidine and quinine has been investigated as a function of incubation time. In the assay used, beta-hematin formation was brought about using 4.5M acetate, pH 4.5 at 60 degrees C. Unreacted hematin was detected by formation of a spectroscopically distinct low spin pyridine complex. Although, these drugs inhibit beta-hematin formation when relatively short incubation times are used, it was found that beta-hematin eventually forms with longer incubation periods (<8h for chloroquine and >8h for quinine). This conclusion was supported by both infrared and X-ray powder diffraction observations. It was further found that the IC(50) for inhibition of beta-hematin formation increases markedly with increasing incubation times in the case of the 4-aminoquinolines chloroquine and amodiaquine. By contrast, in the presence of the quinoline methanols quinine and quinidine the IC(50) values increase much more slowly. This results in a partial reversal of the order of inhibition strengths at longer incubation times. Scanning electron microscopy indicates that beta-hematin crystals formed in the presence of chloroquine are more uniform in both size and shape than those formed in the absence of the drug, with the external morphology of these crystallites being markedly altered. The findings suggest that these drugs act by decreasing the rate of hemozoin formation, rather than irreversibly blocking its formation. This model can also explain the observation of a sigmoidal dependence of beta-hematin inhibition on drug concentration.     

A colorimetric high-throughput beta-hematin inhibition screening assay for use in the search for antimalarial compounds

Antimalarial drugs such as chloroquine are believed to act by inhibiting hemozoin formation in the food vacuole of the malaria parasite. We have developed a new assay for measuring and detecting inhibition of synthetic hemozoin (beta-hematin) formation. Aqueous pyridine (5% v/v, pH 7.5) forms a low-spin complex with hematin but not with beta-hematin. Its absorbance obeys Beer's law, making it useful for quantitating hematin concentration in hematin/beta-hematin mixtures, allowing compounds to be investigated for inhibition of beta-hematin formation. The assay is rapid (60 min incubation) and requires no centrifugation. The beta-hematin inhibition data show good agreement with alternative assay methods reported by four laboratories. The assay was adapted for high-throughput colorimetric screening, allowing visual identification of beta-hematin inhibitors. In this mode, the assay successfully detected all 18 beta-hematin inhibitors in a set of 47 compounds tested, with no false positive results. The quantitative in vitro antimalarial activities of a set of 13 aminoquinolines and quinoline methanols were found to correlate significantly with beta-hematin inhibition values determined using the assay.     

Standardization of the physicochemical parameters to assess in vitro the beta-hematin inhibitory activity of antimalarial drugs

Intraerythrocytic plasmodia form hemozoin as a detoxification product of hemoglobin-derived heme. An identical substance, beta-hematin (BH), can be obtained in vitro from hematin at acidic pH. Quinoline-antimalarials inhibit BH formation. Standardization of test conditions is essential for studying the interaction of compounds with this process and screening potential inhibitors. A spectrophotometric microassay of heme polymerization inhibitory activity (HPIA) (Basilico et al., Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy 42, 55-60, 1998) previously reported was used to investigate the effect of pH and salt concentration on BH formation. The yield of BH formation decreased with pH. Moreover, under conditions used in the above HPIA assay (18 h, 37 degrees C, pH = 2.7), several salts including chloride and phosphate inhibited the process. Aminoquinoline drugs formulated as salts (chloroquine-phosphate, primaquine-diphosphate), but not chloroquine-base, also inhibited the reaction. Interference by salts was highest at low pH and decreased at higher pH (pH 4). Here, we describe different assay conditions that eliminate these problems (BHIA, beta-hematin inhibitory activity). By replacing hematin with hemin as the porphyrin and NaOH solution with DMSO as solvent, the formation of BH was independent of pH up to pH 5.1. No interference by salts was observed over the pH range 2.7-5.1. Dose-dependent inhibition of BH formation was obtained with chloroquine-base, chloroquine-phosphate, and chloroquine-sulfate at pH 5.1. Primaquine was not inhibitory. The final product, characterized by solubility in DMSO, consists of pure BH by FT-IR spectroscopy. The BHIA assay (hemin in DMSO, acetate buffer pH 5 +/- 0.1, 18 h at 37 degrees C) is designed to screen for those molecules forming pi-pi interactions with hematin and thus inhibiting beta-hematin formation.     

Spectrophotometric determination of de novo hemozoin/beta-hematin formation in an in vitro assay

Formation of hemozoin in the malaria parasite, due to its unique nature, is an attractive molecular target. Several laboratories have been trying to unravel the molecular mechanism of hemozoin biosynthesis within the parasite digestive vacuoles. Use of different assay protocols for in vitro beta-hematin (synthetic identical to hemozoin) formation by these laboratories has led to inconsistent and often contradictory findings. Much of the difficulty may be attributed to oligomeric heme aggregates, which may be indistinguishable in some detection approaches if adequate separation of beta-hemtin is not achieved. Therefore, there is an urgent need for a widely accepted protocol for in vitro beta-hematin formation. We describe here a spectrophotometric assay for in vitro beta-hematin formation. The assay has been validated with the Plasmodium falciparum lysate, the parasite lipid extracts, and some commercially available fatty acids, which are known to initiate/catalyze beta-hematin formation in vitro. The necessity for multiple wash steps for accurate quantification of de novo hemozoin/beta-hematin formation was verified experimentally. It was necessary to wash the pellet, which contains beta-hematin and heme aggregates, sequentially with Tris/SDS buffer and alkaline bicarbonate solution for complete removal of monomeric heme and heme aggregates and accurate quantification of beta-hematin formed during the assay. The pellets and side products in the supernatant were characterized by infrared spectroscopy. No beta-hematin formation occurred in the absence of a catalytic/initiating factor. Based on these findings, a filtration-based assay that uses 96-well microplates, and which has important application in in vitro screening and identification of novel inhibitors of hemozoin formation as potential blood schizontocidal antimalarials, has been developed.     

Metalloporphyrins inhibit beta-hematin (hemozoin) formation

Metal-substituted protoporphyrin IXs (Cr(III)PPIX (1), Co(III)PPIX (2), Mn(III)PPIX (3), Cu(II)PPIX (4), Mg(II)PPIX (5), Zn(II)PPIX (6), and Sn(IV)PPIX (7)) act as inhibitors to beta-hematin (hemozoin) formation, a critical detoxification biopolymer of malarial parasites. The central metal ion plays a significant role in the efficacy of the metalloprotoporphyrins to inhibit beta-hematin formation. The efficacy of these compounds correlates well with the water exchange rate for the octahedral aqua complexes of the porphyrin's central metal ion. Under these in vitro reaction conditions, metalloporphyrins 5, 6 and 7 are as much as six times more efficacious than the free ligand protoporphyrin IX in preventing beta-hematin formation and four times as efficacious as chloroquine, while metalloporphyrins 3 and 4 are three to four times more effective at preventing beta-hematin formation than the free protoporphyrin IX base. In contrast, the relatively exchange inert metalloporphyrins 1 and 2 are only as efficacious as the free ligand and only two-thirds as effective as chloroquine. Aggregation studies of the heme:MPPIX using UV-Vis and fluorescence spectroscopies are indicative of the formation of pi-pi hetero-metalloporphyrin assemblies. Thus, hemozoin inhibition is likely prevented by the formation of heme:MPPIX complexes through pi-stacking interactions. The ramifications of such hetero-metalloporphyrin assemblies, in the context of the emerging structural picture of hemozoin, are discussed.     

In vitro beta-hematin formation assays with plasma of mice infected with Plasmodium yoelii and other parasite preparations: comparative inhibition with quinoline and endoperoxide antimalarials.

Formation of beta-hematin in vitro could be catalyzed in the presence of various preparations related to the malaria parasite viz., the cell free homogenate of Plasmodium yoelii, lipid extract of the parasite homogenate, purified malarial hemozoin and synthetic beta-hematin. Plasma from mice infected with P. yoelii also catalyzed in vitro beta-hematin formation with highly significant efficiency. The plasma based beta-hematin formation assay was highly sensitive, as the background absorbance was almost negligible due to absence of any preformed hemozoin. The plasma beta-hematin synthesizing activity was recovered in the lipid extract. The quinoline and endoperoxide antimalarials act by inhibiting hemozoin biosynthesis in the malaria parasite. Therefore, the in vitro beta-hematin formation assay is useful for the screening and identification of blood schizontocidal antimalarials acting through interruption of heme detoxification in the parasite. Quinoline and endoperoxide antimalarials showed about three fold greater inhibition of beta-hematin synthesizing activity in the plasma-based assays as compared to that of P. yoelii homogenate-based assays. The specificity of the inhibition was similar in both preparations. The plasma-based assay therefore provides a better alternative than the parasite homogenate-based assay for in vitro screening and identification of novel inhibitors of hemozoin biosynthesis as potential blood schizontocidal antimalarials.     

On the mechanism of hemozoin production in malaria parasites: activated erythrocyte membranes promote beta-hematin synthesis

The ferriprotoporphyrin IX (FP) molecules released by intraerythrocytic malaria parasites during hemoglobin digestion are converted to beta-hematin and are stored in the parasites' food vacuoles. It has been demonstrated in cell-free medium that the incorporation of FP into beta-hematin under physiological conditions requires a catalyst from parasite lysates or pre-formed beta-hematin. In the present studies, lysates of Plasmodium falciparum-infected erythrocytes were suspended in 1 M NaOH and were washed with phosphate buffer, pH 7.6. When the cell extracts were incubated with hematin in 0.5 M sodium acetate buffer, pH 5, for 20 hr at 37 degrees C, a large quantity of beta-hematin was formed. To determine whether parasite components were necessary for the beta-hematin formation, normal erythrocyte ghosts were similarly treated with 1 M NaOH and then incubated with hematin. In repeated experiments it was found that, on the average, 70% of the hematin was converted to beta-hematin. Membranes treated with HCl or CH(3)COOH also promoted the formation of beta-hematin, while untreated membranes were ineffective. The possibility that metabolic activities in the food vacuoles of malaria parasites may activate membrane fragments, from hemoglobin vesicles, to promote beta-hematin formation is discussed in this paper.     

Physico-chemical aspects of hemozoin (malaria pigment) structure and formation

Recent literature dealing with the chemical composition, structure and mechanism of formation of hemozoin and its synthetic counterpart, beta-hematin, is reviewed.     

Antimalarial drugs inhibiting hemozoin (beta-hematin) formation: a mechanistic update

Digestion of hemoglobin in the food vacuole of the malaria parasite produces very high quantities of redox active toxic free heme. Hemozoin (beta-hematin) formation is a unique process adopted by Plasmodium sp. to detoxify free heme. Hemozoin formation is a validated target for most of the well-known existing antimalarial drugs and considered to be a suitable target to develop new antimalarials. Here we discuss the possible mechanisms of free heme detoxification in the malaria parasite and the mechanistic details of compounds, which offer antimalarial activity by inhibiting hemozoin formation. The chemical nature of new antimalarial compounds showing antimalarial activity through the inhibition of hemozoin formation has also been incorporated, which may help to design future antimalarials with therapeutic potential against multi-drug resistant malaria.     

A physiochemical mechanism of hemozoin (beta-hematin) synthesis by malaria parasite.

Malaria parasite homogenate, the lipid extracts, and an unsaturated fatty acid, linoleic acid, which have been shown to promote beta-hematin formation in vitro, were used to investigate the mechanism of hemozoin biosynthesis, a distinct metabolic function of the malaria parasite. In vitro beta-hematin formation promoted by Plasmodium yoelii homogenate, the lipid extracts, and linoleic acid were blocked by ascorbic acid, reduced glutathione, sodium dithionite, beta-mercaptoethanol, dithiothreitol, and superoxide dismutase. Oxidized glutathione did not show any effect. Preoxidized preparations of the lipids extracts or the P. yoelii homogenate failed to catalyze beta-hematin formation. Depletion of oxygen in the reaction mixtures also inhibited the lipid-catalyzed beta-hematin formation. Under the reaction conditions similar to those used for the in vitro beta-hematin formation assay, the antioxidants and reducing agents mentioned above, except the DTT and beta-mercaptoethanol, did not cause degradation of heme. beta-Hematin formation was also inhibited by p-aminophenol, a free radical chain reaction breaker. Hemozoin biosynthesis within the digestive vacuoles of the malaria parasite may be a lipid-catalyzed physiochemical reaction. An oxidative mechanism may be proposed for lipid-mediated beta-hematin formation, which may be mediated by generation of some free radical intermediates of heme.     

Docking studies on the binding of quinoline derivatives and hematin to Plasmodium falciparum lactate dehydrogenase

The literature has reported that ferriprotoporphyrin IX (hematin) intoxicates the malarial parasite through competition with NADH for the active site of the enzyme lactate dehydrogenase (LDH). In order to avoid this, the parasite polymerizes hematin to hemozoin. The quinoline derivatives are believed to form complexes with dimeric hematin, avoiding the formation of hemozoin and still inhibiting LDH. In order to investigate this hypothesis we calculated the docking energies of NADH and some quinoline derivatives (in the free forms and in complex with dimeric hematin) in the active site of the Plasmodium falciparum LDH (PfLDH). Ours results showed better docking score values to the complexes when compared to the free compounds, pointing them as more efficient inhibitors of Pf_LDH. Further we performed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations studies on the best docking conformation of the complex chloroquine-dimeric hematin with PfLDH. Our in silico results corroborate experimental data suggesting a possible action route for the quinoline derivatives in the inhibition of PfLDH.     

Hemozoin formation in malaria: a two-step process involving histidine-rich proteins and lipids

Major blood stage antimalarial drugs like chloroquine and artemisinin target the heme detoxification process of the malaria parasite. Hemozoin formation reactions in vitro using the Plasmodium falciparum histidine-rich protein-2 (Pfhrp-2), lipids, and auto-catalysis are slow and could not explain the speed of detoxification needed for parasite survival. Here, we show that malarial hemozoin formation is a coordinated two component process involving both lipids and histidine-rich proteins. Hemozoin formation efficiency in vitro is 1-2% with Pfhrp-2 and 0.25-0.5% with lipids. We added lipids after 9h in a 12h Pfhrp-2 mediated reaction that resulted in sixfold increase in hemozoin formation. However, a lipid mediated reaction in which Pfhrp-2 was added after 9h produced only twofold increase in hemozoin production compared to the reaction with Pfhrp-2 alone. Synthetic peptides corresponding to the Pfhrp-2 heme binding sequences, based on repeats of AHHAAD, neither alone nor in combination with lipids were able to generate hemozoin in vitro. These results indicate that hemozoin formation in malaria parasite involves both the lipids and the scaffolding proteins. Histidine-rich proteins might facilitate hemozoin formation by binding with a large number of heme molecules, and facilitating the dimer formation involving iron-carboxylate bond between two heme molecules, and lipids may then subsequently assist the mechanism of long chain formation, held together by hydrogen bonds or through extensive networking of hydrogen bonds.     

Hemozoin formation in Echinostoma trivolvis rediae

Rediae of the trematode Echinostoma trivolvis, from naturally infected Helisoma trivolvis snails, form a black pigment while inside the snail host. Here we examine the black pigment to show that the insolubility characteristics in detergent and weak base solution are identical to Plasmodium falciparum hemozoin. Laser desorption mass spectrometry of the purified pigment demonstrates the presence of heme. Examination of purified pigment under polarized light microscopy illuminates ordered birefringent crystals. Field emission in lens scanning electron microscopy reveals irregular ovoid crystals of 200-300 nm in diameter. The purified pigment crystals seeded extension of monomeric heme onto the crystal which by Fourier Transform Infrared analysis is beta-hematin. Rediae of a second echinostome parasite, Echinostoma caproni, from experimentally infected Biomphalaria glabrata, do not produce measurable or recoverable heme crystals. These observations are consistent with heme crystal formation by a hematophagous parasite within a non-vertebrate intermediate host.     

Raman imaging of hemozoin within the food vacuole of Plasmodium falciparum trophozoites

Micro-Raman spectra of hemozoin encapsulated within the food vacuole of a Plasmodium falciparum-infected erythrocyte are presented. The spectrum of hemozoin is identical to the spectrum of beta-hematin at all applied excitation wavelengths. The unexpected observation of dramatic band enhancement of A(1g) modes including nu(4) (1374 cm(-1)) observed when applying 780 nm excitation enabled Raman imaging of hemozoin in the food vacuole. This unusual enhancement, resulting from excitonic coupling between linked porphyrin moieties in the extended porphyrin array, enables the investigation of hemozoin within its natural environment for the first time.     

Evidences for the formation of bisbenzamidine-heme complexes in cell-free systems

Infrared and colorimetry data suggest that bisbenzamidines connected by various rigid or flexible linkers are able to interact with heme in cell-free systems. At pH 5.0 the inhibition of formation of beta-hematin could be ascertained by infrared spectroscopy whereas at pH 7.0 the interaction yielded insoluble complexes for which a sandwich-type structure of stoichiometry 2:1, heme-drug, is tentatively proposed.     

Design and synthesis of new antimalarial agents from 4-aminoquinoline

This study describes the synthesis of new 4-aminoquinoline derivatives and evaluation of their activity against a chloroquine sensitive strain of P. falciparum in vitro and chloroquine resistant N-67 strain of P. yoelii in vivo. All the analogues were found to form strong complex with hematin and inhibit the beta-hematin formation in vitro. These results suggest that these compounds act on heme polymerization target.     

Recent advances in understanding the mechanism of hemozoin (malaria pigment) formation

The recent literature on hemozoin/β-hematin formation is reviewed, with an emphasis on the mechanism of its formation. Recent findings from unrelated organisms that produce hemozoin, namely the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum, the worm Schistosoma mansoni and the kissing bug Rhodnius prolixus all of which consume human hemoglobin show that the formation of this crystalline substance occurs within or at the surface of lipids. Biomimetic experimental models of the lipid–water interface as well as computational studies indicate that these lipid environments are probably extraordinarily efficient at producing hemozoin. A rethink is now needed, with a new emphasis on Fe(III)PPIX in non-aqueous environments that mimic lipids and indeed within the lipid environment itself. These findings are explored and discussed in the context of earlier studies on β-hematin formation.     

Kinetics of complex formation between fluorescein mercuric acetate and DNA

The kinetics of complex formation between fluorescein mercuric acetate and heat-denatured DNA were studied by measuring the fluorescence quenching of this reagent. This quenching process involved no immeasurably rapid phase and it was shown that this reaction follows simple second-order kinetics. The rate constant at 25°C was estimated to be 2.9 × 10⁴M^?1 sec^?1 for calf-thymus DNA (42% G + C) and 1.1 × 10⁴M^?1 sec^?1 for Micrococcus lysodeikticus DNA (72% G + C). Activation parameters for this reaction were calculated from the temperature dependence of the reaction rate, and the activation entropy was found to be highly negative (?27.5 cal/mol deg for calf-thymus DNA and ?25.5 cal/mol deg for M. lysodeikticus DNA). The binding of fluorescein mercuric acetate to native DNA, which requires the opening of the double-helical structure, was also followed by measuring the absorbance change of this reagent. There was a lag phase in this binding process, and the enthalpy change for the opening step corresponded roughly to that for the opening of one base pair. These findings are discussed in relation to the results of a similar study with formaldehyde.     

A novel way to grow hemozoin-like crystals in vitro and its use to screen for hemozoin inhibiting antimalarial compounds

Background

Hemozoin crystals are normally formed in vivo by Plasmodium parasites to detoxify free heme released after hemoglobin digestion during its intraerythrocytic stage. Inhibition of hemozoin formation by various drugs results in free heme concentration toxic for the parasites. As a consequence, in vitro assays have been developed to screen and select candidate antimalarial drugs based on their capacity to inhibit hemozoin formation. In this report we describe new ways to form hemozoin-like crystals that were incidentally discovered during research in the field of prion inactivation.

Methods

We investigated the use of a new assay based on naturally occurring “self-replicating” particles and previously described as presenting resistance to decontamination comparable to prions. The nature of these particles was determined using electron microscopy, Maldi-Tof analysis and X-ray diffraction. They were compared to synthetic hemozoin and to hemozoin obtained from Plasmodium falciparum. We then used the assay to evaluate the capacity of various antimalarial and anti-prion compounds to inhibit “self-replication” (crystallisation) of these particles.

Results

We identified these particles as being similar to ferriprotoporphyrin IX crystal and confirmed the ability of these particles to serve as nuclei for growth of new hemozoin-like crystals (HLC). HLC are morphologically similar to natural and synthetic hemozoin. Growth of HLC in a simple assay format confirmed inhibition by quinolines antimalarials at potencies described in the literature. Interestingly, artemisinins and tetracyclines also seemed to inhibit HLC growth.

Conclusions

The described HLC assay is simple and easy to perform and may have the potential to be used as an additional tool to screen antimalarial drugs for their hemozoin inhibiting activity. As already described by others, drugs that inhibit hemozoin crystal formation have also the potential to inhibit misfolded proteins assemblies formation.     

Resonance Raman spectroscopy in malaria research

In recent years, the field of Raman spectroscopy has witnessed a surge in technological development, with the incorporation of ultrasensitive, charge-coupled devices, improved laser sources and precision Rayleigh-filter systems. This has led to the development of sensitive confocal micro-Raman spectrometers and imaging spectrometers that are capable of obtaining high spatial-resolution spectra and images of subcellular components within single living cells. This review reports on the application of resonance micro-Raman spectroscopy to the study of malaria pigment (hemozoin), a by-product of hemoglobin catabolization by the malaria parasite, which is an important target site for antimalarial drugs. The review aims to briefly describe recent studies on the application of this technology, elucidate molecular and electronic properties of the malaria pigment and its synthetic analog beta-hematin, provide insight into the mechanism of hemozoin formation within the food vacuole of the parasite, and comment on developing strategies for using this technology in drug-screening protocols.