Clonal diversity, somatic mutation, and immune memory to phosphocholine-keyhole limpet hemocyanin

Group II antibodies to phosphocholine (PC)-keyhole limpet hemocyanin in BALB/c mice are genetically diverse and of a defined binding phenotype which recognizes the hapten, phenyl-PC, and PC coupled to protein but not free PC. We sequenced the V regions of 14 kappa and lambda-bearing group II antibodies. Both types show extensive somatic mutations. The pattern of the mutations differs between kappa and lambda antibodies. The nature of the somatic mutation in lambda chains suggests strong Ag selection on the L chain but not the H chain of the lambda-bearing antibodies. The reverse pattern of selection was observed among kappa-containing antibodies wherein the accumulation of replacement mutations in the CDR of the H chain appears to result from selection while changes in the L chain appear unselected. From these findings it appears that somatic mutation plays a major role in anti-PC-keyhole limpet hemocyanin memory development because all 14 antibodies displayed changes from germ-line sequences.     

Somatic evolution of diversity among anti-phosphocholine antibodies induced with Proteus morganii

The variable region sequences of light and heavy chains (VL and VH) were determined for 11 hybridoma antibodies produced in response to the PC moiety on Proteus morganii. These hybridomas were derived from two separate fusions, one obtained from mice early in a secondary response and the other from late in a secondary response. All of these antibodies possessed a cross-reactive idiotype found on anti-PC antibodies in the M603 family, and exhibited preferential specificity for PC in the context of P. morganii. We found that all of the antibodies were derived from a single VH/VL pair. VH was encoded by V1, DFL16.1 and JH1, and VL was encoded by a consensus VK8 gene and JK5. Antibodies differed from each other by somatic point mutations that occurred at a high rate. The mutations in VL were approximately one-third as abundant as those in VH and were randomly distributed throughout the molecule. Mutations in VH were concentrated in CDR 2 and 3 and had a replacement to silent ratio that was three to six times greater than predicted from random accumulation. Based on the sequence data, a single genealogic tree with multiple branches could accommodate all the hybrids from a fusion. We concluded that in both examples the anti-PC response arose by somatic mutation and stepwise selection from a single precursor. Antigen binding studies with these 11 hybridomas and a 12th that had no mutations revealed that the acquisition of preferential specificity for antigen was dependent on somatic mutation of germline genes. Additional binding studies demonstrated that continued selection during clonal expansion was probably antigen driven. An unexpected finding was five independently selected antibodies from one fusion that had identically mutated VH and VL sequences. We suggest that the hypermutation mechanism is not a continuously active process during clonal expansion and that it is regulated, probably during the mid to late phase of the primary response.     

Mouse antibody response to group A streptococcal carbohydrate

In an attempt to more fully understand the generation of antibody diversity to carbohydrate (CHO) Ag, we produced and characterized a panel of hybridoma cell lines specific for group A streptococcal CHO from mice injected with the intact bacteria (minus the hyaluronic acid capsule and cell wall protein Ag). We have analyzed the use of H and L chain V region genes in the early (day 7) and late response (hyperimmune) and have sequenced the dominant VH gene used in several of our hybridomas. Our data allowed us to assess the extent to which the recombination of various V, D, and J gene segments and somatic mutation contribute to antibody diversification in this system. In this report we confirm that a minimum of two VH and four VK gene segments are used to encode this response. We extend this analysis to show that multiple D and J gene segments are used and that a significant amount of junctional variability is tolerated in CDR 3. Our results indicate that the level of somatic mutation in the hyperimmune response is generally low in comparison with the response to haptens and protein Ag. These data also suggest that there is a positive selection for mutation in CDR 1 during the hyperimmune response to group A streptococcal CHO.     

Neonatal and adult primary B cells use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes in their (T,G)-A-L-specific repertoire

Although there is a nonrandom usage of VH gene families by primary B cells early in ontogeny, at issue is whether the preferential rearrangement of 3' germ-line VH genes, e.g., VH7183 and VHQ52 family genes, influences the neonatal B cell repertoire that can be expressed in response to Ag. In order to address this issue, and to determine whether neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes as adult B cells in their primary response, we have analyzed at the molecular level the neonatal antibody response to (T,G)-A-L and compared it with the adult primary response. Among the TGB5 Id+, GT+ antibodies, which dominate the neonatal response to (T,G)-A-L, two VH gene families were used: J558 (high frequency) and 36-60 (low frequency). The majority of Id+ neonatal hybridomas used the same germ-line VH gene (H10, from the VHJ558 family), but with enormous diversity in the D region, and one of two germ-line V kappa 1 genes (V kappa 1A, V kappa 1C). These are the same germ-line V-genes used by most primary adult Id+ hybridomas, and the frequency of expression of this germ-line V-gene combination appears equivalent in the neonatal and adult primary repertoires. Therefore, it is clear from this study that as early as day 5, neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line V-genes as adult primary B cells in their Ag-specific repertoire.     

Nucleotide and translated amino acid sequences of cDNA coding for the variable regions of the light and heavy chains of mouse hybridoma antibodies to blood group A and B substances

This is the first report of nucleotide and translated amino acid sequences of the variable region light (VL) and heavy (VH) chains of mouse monoclonal hybridoma anti-blood group A and B substances, the combining sites of which have been mapped. Monoclonal hybridoma anti-A and anti-B produced in BALB/c mice by immunization with A or B blood group substances, with A1 erythrocytes, and water-soluble blood group A substance or with synthetic B determinants coupled to bovine serum albumin or to O erythrocytes have been characterized immunochemically. To relate the immunochemical properties of the monoclonals to their primary structures, we have cloned and sequenced cDNAs of variable regions of light and heavy chains of two anti-A and two anti-B. The anti-A hybridomas have very similar combining site specificities and have almost identical VH sequences belonging to the J558 germ-line family, but their VL are from different germ-line VK gene families. The two anti-B hybridomas have different combining site specificities and use the same VL which differs completely from the anti-A VL; their VH are derived from different VH germ-line genes belonging to the J606 family. The results suggest that the heavy chains play a major role in determining the specificities of the antibody combining sites, with only minor contribution of VL. Additional sequence data on monoclonal antibodies of defined specificity for blood group substances are needed for further insights into the genetic and structural basis for their specificities.     

Complete amino acid sequence of the heavy-chain variable region from an A/J mouse antigen-nonbinding monoclonal antibody bearing the predominant arsonate idiotype

The 1F6 hybridoma protein, exhibiting the predominant cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) associated with the immune response to p-azophenylarsonate in A/J mice but failing to bind the hapten arsonate, was elicited following immunization with rat anti-CRI [Wysocki, L.J., & Sato, V. (1981) Eur. J. Immunol. 11, 832-839]. The dissociation of idiotype and antigen binding in this hybridoma provides an opportunity to determine structural features involved in antigen binding and idiotypic sites. The complete heavy-chain variable region (VH) amino acid sequence was obtained by automated Edman degradation of the intact chain and fragments due to CNBr cleavage, trypsin digestion, mild acid hydrolysis, and carboxypeptidase A digestion of a CNBr fragment. Comparison of the CRI+ arsonate-nonbinding 1F6 sequence with the CRI+ germ-line VH gene sequence reveals that the 1F6 heavy chain differs from the germ-line-encoded amino acid sequence at seven positions within VH [Siekevitz, M., Gefter, M. L., Brodeur, P., Riblet, R., & Marshak-Rothstein, A. (1982) Eur. J. Immunol. 12, 1023-1032]. The 1F6 VH appears to arise from the CRI+ germ-line VH by somatic mutation at at least seven amino acid residues, each of which could be due to a single nucleotide base change. The diversity (D) gene-encoded segment of 1F6 is similar to that of the CRI+ antigen-binding hybridoma 36-65 except for two amino acid substitutions. Further, the idiotype (CRI) is preserved despite use of a JH4 gene segment in 1F6 as compared to JH2 in all CRI+ arsonate-binding hybridomas examined to date.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Germline antibody V regions as determinants of clonal persistence and malignant growth in the B cell compartment.

Antibody V gene expression was studied in a subpopulation of murine B cells (Ly1 B) which was enriched by cell transfer and had earlier been shown to persist in the immune system over long periods of time. Among 17 hybridomas derived from Ly1 B cells of two different mice, eight were progeny of only three different B cell precursors which apparently had expanded to clones of large size, in the absence of detectable somatic mutation of their antibody V regions. Furthermore, several clonally independent cells expressed identical, unmutated V genes. These data define a novel pathway of B cell development in which cells expressing a selected set of germline antibodies are continuously propagated in the organism. A Ly1 B cell leukemia derived from a similar transfer experiment expressed a VH gene that had been isolated in three independent Ly1 B cell hybridomas, suggesting that the leukemic cells had been equally selected in this pathway.     

Many variable region genes are utilized in the antibody response of BALB/c mice to the influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin

We have examined how many different H chain variable (VH) and kappa-chain variable (Vk) germ-line genes are used in the antibody response to the influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin (PR8 HA), and have assessed how the expression of individual VH and/or Vk genes contributes to the generation of specificity for the HA. A panel of 51 hybridoma antibodies that recognize two antigenic regions on the HA were compared for the sequence of their Ig H and L chain V regions. The hybridomas were obtained from 28 individual BALB/c mice that had been immunized with PR8 under a variety of primary and secondary response immunization protocols. The degree and pattern of sequence similarity suggests that 29 different VH genes drawn from seven different VH gene families, and 25 different Vk genes drawn from 12 different Vk gene families were used in this panel. Based on current estimates of the total numbers of VH and Vk genes in the mouse, this suggests that between 2.5 and 10% of the entire VH and Vk germ-line repertoires were used by these hybridomas. Despite this extensive diversity, some V genes were repetitively identified among these hybridomas, and were most often expressed in the context of specific VH/Vk combinations. Because antibodies that used identical VH/Vk combinations also usually displayed similar reactivity patterns with a panel of mutant viruses, this indicates that VH/Vk pairing can be important in establishing the specificity of antibodies for the HA.     

Sequences of the VH and VL regions of murine monoclonal antibodies against 3-fucosyllactosamine

Many mAb that bind the carbohydrate antigenic determinant 3-fucosyl-lactosamine (3-FL), Gal beta 1-4[Fuc alpha-3]GlcNAc-R have been raised in BALB/c mice, and we are studying the structure and regulation of these antibodies. In this report, we present the first information about their amino acid sequences and the Ig gene segments used to encode them. V regions of the H and L chains of three anti-3-FL antibodies, PMN6, PMN29, and PM81, were sequenced by a combination of mRNA and amino acid sequencing. The L chain sequences of PMN6 and PM81 antibodies indicate that their VK and JK regions are encoded by VK24B and JK1 germ-line genes, respectively. The nucleotide and amino acid sequences of the H chains suggest that the three anti-3-FL antibodies are encoded by the VH441 gene segment of the X24 VH family, and this conclusion was supported by Southern filter hybridization with VH441 and JH3-JH4 probes. PMN29 has at least 11 amino acid substitutions, which is an unusually large amount of somatic mutation for an IgM antibody. Previous analyses of BALB/c genomic libraries with VHX24 and VH441 probes make it unlikely that this VH family contains additional germ-line genes, but this possibility cannot be excluded. All three antibodies use the DQ52 and JH4 gene segments. The single VH and VL gene segments used to encode the anti-3-FL antibodies is in contrast to the multiple VH and VL segments used by antibodies against other carbohydrate Ag such as alpha 1-6 dextran and group A streptococcal carbohydrate. VH441 also encodes the VH regions of antibodies against galactan and levan (beta 2-6 fructosan). The similarities among VH segments of antibodies against 3-FL, levan, and galactan, and the striking differences in their CDR3 sequences, suggest that CDR3 plays an important role in the formation of the Ag binding site. The use of a single VH segment from the smallest VH gene family by antibodies against at least three different carbohydrate determinants is noteworthy. It raises the possibility that the amino acid sequence encoded by VH441 has some general structural features that make it particularly well adapted for binding to carbohydrate sequences.     

Germline V genes encode viable motheaten mouse autoantibodies against thymocytes and red blood cells

Autoantibodies against thymocytes and RBC may contribute to the pathophysiology of homozygous viable motheaten (mev) autoimmune disease. Whether the production of these autoantibodies in mev mouse results from polyclonal nonspecific B cell activation or specific Ag-driven stimulation is not known. To understand the mechanisms involved in the induction of antithymocyte autoantibody response in mev mouse, we have studied the fine antigenic specificity, structure, and origin of three antithymocyte autoantibodies derived from mev splenic B cell hybridomas. Western blot analysis showed that these mAb bind to polypeptides of 33 and 105 kDa present in RBC and thymocytes, respectively. Additional specificities for the epitopes present in other polypeptides distinguished these three autoantibodies. Northern hybridization and flow microfluorimetry analysis indicated that these hybridomas are derived from the Ly1+ B cell subset. These autoreactive Ly-1 B cell hybridomas, chosen on the basis of their specificity, expressed L chain V genes from a single VK family (VK9) and VH genes from J606 and S107 families. Hybridomas UN34.11 and UN42.5 expressed the VK9 gene identical to that used by peritoneal Ly1+ B cells from various mouse strains and malignant B lymphoma cells secreting anti-mouse RBC treated with proteolytic enzyme bromelin and anti-SRBC antibodies. The third hybridoma, S2-14.2, used a VK9 gene identical to that expressed by MOPC41. None of the VK genes encoding these autoantibodies showed any somatic mutations. In the case of VH genes, the two hybridomas UN42.5 and S2-14.2 derived from two separate fusions, used identical VH genes from the J606 family. The third hybridoma UN34.11 used unmutated V11 germline VH gene, a member of the S107 family. Southern hybridizations, using oligonucleotide probes specific for CDR1 and CDR2, showed that the VH genes encoding the J606 autoantibodies were derived from a germline gene found in the 6.7-kb fragment of EcoRI-digested germline DNA. This germline VH gene is distinct from VH22.1 germline gene that codes for antigalactan antibodies. Sequence analysis of this gene showed perfect homology with the rearranged VH genes confirming the lack of somatic mutations. Thus, our data demonstrate that antithymocyte antibody response occurring in mev mouse is polyclonal and it involves Ly-1 B cells expressing unmutated germline VH and VK genes. These results indicate that antigen driven stimulation may not play an important role in the induction of anti-thymocyte antibody response in mev mouse.     

Genetics of the phosphocholine-specific antibody response to Streptococcus pneumoniae. Germ-line but not mutated T15 antibodies are dominantly selected

The role that somatic mutations play in the phosphocholine-specific, antibody response to Streptococcus pneumoniae was examined by studying sets of hybridomas from different individual mice. As expected most of the cell lines were from the T15 anti-phosphocholine family and were not encoded by the v1 gene of the T15 VH family and V kappa 22. A minority of antibodies were from the M603 (v1/V kappa 8) and M511 (v1/V kappa 24) families. Three additional antibodies were encoded by the v11 gene of the T15 family; two were paired with a V lambda and the other with a V kappa 1 gene. In vitro binding studies showed that T15- and M603-like antibodies had the highest affinity for S. pneumoniae. Complete sequencing of the VH and VL mRNA from 25 of the hybridomas revealed somatic mutations in 11 of the antibodies. A total of 17 independently derived T15 positive cell lines were studied in detail, six of these were mutated. These mutations were scattered throughout the V regions and the replacement to silent ratio was typical of that for framework regions. Statistical evaluation of the placement of mutations showed that there was a slight but significantly decreased frequency of mutations in complementarity determining regions. Comparisons of mutated and unmutated T15-related antibodies showed that mutations caused a decrease in binding to S. pneumoniae in every case. These results argue that the optimal specificity for this molecular form of phosphocholine is encoded in the germline and that Ag-driven events favor selection of B cells expressing these germ-line encoded antibodies.     

The immune response toward beta-adrenergic ligands and their receptors. VIII. Extensive diversity of VH and VL genes encoding anti-alprenolol antibodies

The V region genes (VH and VL) used in the immune response of BALB/c mice to alprenolol, a synthetic beta-adrenergic ligand, were examined by Southern blot and nucleotide sequence analyses. Fourteen anti-alprenolol hybridomas utilize 10 different combinations of six Vk, one V lambda, eight VH, three JK, one J lambda, and three JH genes. In addition to the combinatorial association, somatic mutations and junctional variation of assembled genes further contribute to diversity of the anti-alprenolol response. Although differing both in length and structure, the five H-chain third complementarity-determining region analyzed contain several acidic residues. Neither V gene utilization, nor H-chain third complementarity-determining-region structure can be simply correlated with affinity of the antibodies for the ligand. The anti-alprenolol V genes were compared with the corresponding sequences of unrelated antibodies. Antibody 37A4 shares a VH gene with anti-(Glu60Ala30Tyr10)n random terpolymer and anti-nitrophenyl antibodies, and a Vk gene with two anti-oxazolone antibodies. Antibodies 14C3 and 17C1 use the same germ-line VH and Vk genes as do anti-anti-idiotypic antibodies of the (Glu60Ala30Tyr10) system. These data demonstrate the genetic diversity of the antibody response to alprenolol, and illustrate the extensive flexibility of the immune system.     

Differences in antibody repertoires for (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) in splenic vs immature bone marrow precursor cells

To evaluate the contribution of environmental regulatory mechanisms in fashioning the primary B cell repertoire, we have compared the repertoire of (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-specific primary splenic B cells with that of precursor cells present as surface immunoglobulin-negative (sIg-) cells in adult bone marrow of C.B20 (Ighb) mice. Previous analyses using a variety of antigens have led to the conclusion that the antibody repertoire expressed in the spleen is similar to that expressed in newly generated B cell precursors with respect to both repertoire diversity and the representation of various predominant clonotypes. However, in the response to NP of C.B20 precursor cells, two marked disparities have been identified between the repertoire of sIg- bone marrow cells vs splenic precursor cells. The first concerns precursor cells that give rise to lambda-bearing NP-specific antibodies with heteroclitic fine specificity. Such antibodies normally dominate the primary response of Ighb mice; however, the representation of precursor cells giving rise to lambda-bearing antibodies is disproportionately low in the sIg- bone marrow cell population of C.B20 mice. Thus, during the maturation of these cells, post-sIg receptor expression, there is an apparent increase in the proportionate representation of lambda-bearing NP-specific cells. The second disparity concerns precursor cells whose antibody products bear kappa-light chains and exhibit high affinity and homoclitic binding for the NP haptenic determinant. Such precursor cells are poorly represented in the spleen, but represent a sizeable proportion of the sIg- NP-specific precursor cell population. Thus, there seems to be a selective elimination of high affinity, kappa-homoclitic anti-NP antibody-bearing cells as they acquire their sIg receptors. The elimination of this cell population could partially account for the dominance of lambda-heteroclitic antibodies in the serum responses to NP of C.B20 mice.     

Antibody engineering for the analysis of affinity maturation of an anti-hapten response.

The influence of structural variation, previously observed in a panel of V186.2 VH/V lambda 1-expressing anti-NP antibodies from the secondary response, on the affinity of these antibodies was examined by site-specific mutagenesis and recombinant antibody construction. A tryptophan----leucine exchange at position 33 in the VH segment of all but one of the high-affinity antibodies is the most frequently observed somatic mutation and by itself leads to a 10-fold higher affinity; all other somatic exchanges are irrelevant for affinity selection. In the single case of a high-affinity antibody without this common exchange, high affinity is mediated by a combination of mutations (including a one-codon deletion) in VH and the particular D-JH rearrangement carried by this antibody. The data indicate that the pattern of somatic diversification through hypermutation is shaped by affinity selection, but that only a single point mutation is available in the VH and the VL gene of lambda 1 chain-bearing anti-NP antibodies which by itself leads to an increase of hapten-binding affinity. Based on the analysis of two secondary response antibodies from which somatic mutations in VH and VL have been eliminated, it is also concluded that the recruitment of B cell clones into the pathway of hypermutation involves a mechanism which is not based upon affinity differences towards the antigen.     

VH gene analysis of spontaneously activated B cells in adult MRL-lpr/lpr mice. J558 bias is not limited to classic lupus autoantibodies

To determine the genetic origins of lupus auto-antibodies, we analyzed the relationship between VH gene usage and auto-Ag-binding properties of 352 B cell hybridomas derived from MRL-lpr/lpr mice. The hybridomas were derived from neonatal, 1-month-old, 3-month-old, and 6-month-old mice. The experimental strategy provided that the hybridomas were monoclonal at initial evaluation, so the Ag binding and V gene frequencies of the entire population could be determined. Initially, 1032 Ig-producing hybridomas were evaluated for binding to six Ag; VH gene family use was determined in 119 anti-DNA and anti-rabbit thymus extract (RTE) antibodies (autoantibodies) and in 233 age-matched Ig that did not bind to any of the six Ag (nonbinders). Neonatal B cells, including cross-reactive IgM autoantibodies and nonbinder IgM, used relatively 3' VH genes. The majority of B cells in adult mice used VH genes of the J558 family. Although J558 use was significantly higher among the autoantibodies (anti-DNA and anti-RTE) than among the nonbinder Ig, this difference was due to a higher frequency of J558 use by 1-month-old mice. At 3 months, J558 use by the nonbinder Ig increased to the same frequency of J558 use as in the autoantibody population. J558 use in both groups of antibodies exceeded a previously reported estimation of J558 expression in the functional B cell repertoire of young adult MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Several subgroups of antibodies that share properties with pathogenic Ig, including IgG, cross-reactive Ig, and anti-dsDNA autoantibodies, demonstrated a marked preferential expression of the J558 family. These results suggest that there is an age-related bias in the activation of B cells using J558 VH genes in MRL-lpr/lpr mice that is under the influence of a selective force distinct from, or in addition to, an ssDNA or RTE auto-Ag-driven response.     

High frequency expression of S107 VH genes by peritoneal B cells of B10.H-2aH-4bP/WTS mice

Our previous analyses of peritoneal Ly-1 B cells indicate that a high percentage express VH genes of the VH11 and VH12 families, and that this bias is due to clonal selection. The antibodies encoded by these genes bind the same hapten, phosphatidyl choline (PtC). Twenty-one of 73 hybridomas generated from fusions with peritoneal Ly-1 and Ly-1 sister population B cells of B10.H-2aH-4bp/Wts mice produce anti-PtC specific antibodies. We show here that 19 of these express VH11 and VH12 family genes and two express VH36-60 family genes. To assess whether there is a bias in VH gene use among non-PtC-specific hybridomas we analyzed the remaining 52 hybridomas for VH family expression by using VH family-specific probes in an RNA dot blot assay and by Ig mRNA sequencing. We find a seven-fold increase in the expression of the VHS107 family genes, and only slight differences in the expression of VH genes of other families relative to splenic B cells. We attribute the increase in VHS107 gene expression to clonal selection inasmuch as five of the seven VHS107+ hybridomas express the same VH gene (V11) and VL association is nonrandom. The bias in VH gene use among the entire panel of 73 peritoneal hybridomas is to the extent that approximately one-third express one of three genes: the V11 gene of the S107 family, the CH34 gene of the VH11 family, and the VH12 family gene.     

The affinity threshold for antigenic triggering differs for tolerance susceptible immature precursors vs mature primary B cells

The specificity of antibody responses is dependent on the extent to which a given antigen selectively stimulates cells from within a diverse B cell repertoire. Previous studies have shown that the triggering of B cells by T cell-dependent antigens is a highly discriminatory process, and that tolerance induction of immature B cells by antigen is equally discriminatory. This symmetry in the requirements for stimulation and tolerance induction could provide a basis for the capacity of antibody responses to discriminate among foreign antigens and yet minimize self recognition. The extent to which this potential for discriminate recognition is applicable to the mature immune system remains controversial, because B cells reactive to self antigens have been identified and, in addition, several investigators have identified heteroclitic immune responses, such as the response to NP of Ighb mice, wherein antibodies are found with higher affinities for analogues of the immunogen than for the immunogen itself. To further investigate the capacity of B cells to discriminate among closely related antigenic determinants, we analyzed the fine specificity and idiotypic distribution of monoclonal antibodies derived from both splenic B cells and immature sIg- bone marrow B cell precursors stimulated in fragment culture with NP-Hy and its structural analogues NIP-Hy and NNP-Hy. The results indicate that the majority of responsive B cells discriminate among these haptenic determinants; however, lambda-bearing B cells responsive to the NP and NIP determinants represent a highly overlapping set of clonotypes. Comparison of the responses to NP-Hy and NIP-Hy of splenic vs sIg- precursors of this clonotype family suggests that the T cell-dependent stimulation of both mature and immature B cells by antigen is highly affinity dependent. Significantly, the affinity thresholds for both stimulation and tolerance induction of immature B cells appears to be higher than that required for the stimulation of mature splenic B cells. Such a disparity in the requisites for triggering mature vs immature B cells could readily account for the presence of low-affinity self-reactive B cells in the mature B cell pools of normal individuals.     

The frequency and fine specificity of B cells responsive to (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl in aged mice

The B-cell response to NP-Hy of two murine strains has been analyzed in order to evaluate the affects of aging on B-cell repertoire expression. The results indicate that for both BALB/c mice (Igha) and B10.D2 mice (Ighb) the frequency of (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-responsive splenic B cells is approximately twofold lower, on a per B cell basis, in aged mice as compared to young adults. However, as with previous assessments of the response to DNP-Hy in aged mice, the frequency of newly generated surface immunoglobulin negative bone marrow precursor cells specific for NP in aged BALB/c mice is the same as in young mice. The decrease in frequency of responsive splenic B cells is not accompanied by a measurable decrease in repertoire diversity or changes in clonotype distribution as assessed by representation of kappa vs lambda light chain-bearing antibodies, binding of monoclonal antibodies to a panel of analogues of NP, and the proportionate representation of B10.D2 monoclonal antibodies that bear NPb idiotypic determinants. By these criteria it appears that down-regulation of B cells as they mature and emerge from the bone marrow of aged mice is pan-specific and does not disproportionately affect B cells of a predominant clonotype family. Consistent with other investigations which have demonstrated differences in secreted antibodies of immunized aged vs young mice, we have observed that 4 weeks after immunization of B10.D2 mice with NP-BSA, the frequency of newly generated secondary B cells is lower in aged than in young mice and the generation of lambda-bearing secondary precursor cells is particularly low. Thus, clonotype-specific down-regulation may play a role in shaping the B-cell repertoire subsequent to immunization of aged mice.     

Immunologic memory to phosphocholine. IV. Hybridomas representative of Group I (T15-like) and Group II (non-T15-like) antibodies utilize distinct VH genes

The anti-phosphocholine (PC) memory response elicited in BALB/c mice by phosphocholine-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (PC-KLH) contains two groups of antibodies distinguished by their fine specificity for PC and p-nitrophenylphosphocholine (NPPC). Group I antibodies are inhibited by both PC and NPPC, while Group II antibodies are inhibited appreciably only by NPPC; only Group I antibodies are dominated by the T15 idiotype. Anti-PC hybridomas representative of the memory response to PC-KLH were produced to examine the variable region genes expressed by memory B cells. Two IgM hybridomas were of the Group I type, because they were inhibited by both PC and NPPC and they bound to the pneumococcus R36A. However, only one of these antibodies (PCM-2) expressed a T15 idiotope, while the other (PCM-1) did not express any of three T15 idiotopes. Despite its negative T15 idiotype profile, N-terminal amino acid sequencing of PCM-1 purified heavy chain and Southern blots of the hybridoma DNA indicated that it utilizes the T15 VH and JH1 genes. Three hybridomas, IgG1, IgM, and IgE, typical of Group II antibodies, were examined; these were negative for three T15 idiotopes and displayed measurable avidity only for NPPC in a PC-protein binding inhibition assay. These three hybridoma antibodies, like serum Group II IgG1, did not measurably bind to the bacterium R36A. The heavy chain amino termini of all three of these antibodies were inaccessible for Edman degradation. Southern blots of DNA from the IgG1 hybridoma revealed the T15 VH gene to be in the germ line configuration only and unassociated with any JH segment, indicating that this Group II antibody utilizes a VH gene different from the T15 family. These results signify that, whereas some diversity of the (anti-PC) memory response may be generated by somatic diversification of variable regions important in the primary response, a significant contribution to the overall heterogeneity of memory antibodies originates in the expression of additional variable region genes.