Enhanced recA protein binding to Z DNA represents a kinetic perturbation of a general duplex DNA binding pathway

recA protein binding to duplex DNA is enhanced when a B form DNA substrate is replaced with a left-handed Z form helix. This represents a kinetic rather than an equilibrium effect. Binding to Z DNA is much faster than binding to B DNA. In other respects, binding to the two DNA forms is quite similar. recA protein binds to B or Z DNA with a stoichiometry of 1 monomer/4 base pairs. The final protein filament exhibits a right-handed helical structure when either B or Z form DNAs are bound. There are only two evident differences: the kcat for ATP hydrolysis is reduced 3-4-fold when Z DNA is bound, and recA binding at equilibrium is less stable on Z DNA than on B DNA. At steady state, the binding favors B DNA in competition experiments. The results indicate that Z DNA binding by recA protein follows the same pathway as for recA binding to B DNA, but that the nucleation step is faster on the Z form helix.     

recA protein-promoted ATP hydrolysis occurs throughout recA nucleoprotein filaments

When recA protein binds cooperatively to single-stranded DNA to form filamentous nucleoprotein complexes, it becomes competent to hydrolyze ATP. No correlation exists between the ends of such complexes and the rate of ATP hydrolysis. ATP hydrolysis is not, therefore, restricted to the terminal subunits on cooperatively bound recA oligomers, but occurs throughout the complex. Similarly, during recA protein-promoted branch migration (during DNA strand exchange), ATP hydrolysis is not restricted to recA protein monomers at the branch point. DNA cofactors of lengths varying from 16 bases to over 12,000 bases support ATP hydrolysis. The maximum value of kcat at infinite DNA concentration is about 29/min independent of the length of the DNA cofactor. The apparent dissociation constant, however, is a strong function of DNA length, providing evidence for a minimum site size of 30-50 bases for efficient binding of recA protein.     

Biochemical basis of the constitutive repressor cleavage activity of recA730 protein. A comparison to recA441 and recA803 proteins.

The recA730 mutation results in constitutive SOS and prophage induction. We examined biochemical properties of recA730 protein in an effort to explain the constitutive activity observed in recA730 strains. We find that recA730 protein is more proficient than the wild-type recA protein in the competition with single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB protein) for single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding sites. Because an increased aptitude in the competition with SSB protein has been previously reported for recA441 protein and recA803 protein, we directly compared their in vitro activities with those of recA730 protein. At low magnesium ion concentration, both ATP hydrolysis and lexA protein cleavage experiments demonstrate that these recA proteins displace SSB protein from ssDNA in a manner consistent with their in vivo repressor cleavage activity, i.e. recA730 protein > recA441 protein > recA803 protein > recAwt protein. Additionally, a correlation exists between the proficiency of the recA proteins in SSB protein displacement and their rate of association with ssDNA. We propose that an increased rate of association with ssDNA allows recA730 protein to displace SSB protein from the ssDNA that occurs naturally in Escherichia coli and thereby to become activated for the repressor cleavage that leads to SOS induction. RecA441 protein is similarly activated for repressor cleavage; however, in this case, significant SSB protein displacement occurs only at elevated temperature. At physiological magnesium ion concentration, we argue that recA803 protein and wild-type recA protein do not displace sufficient SSB protein from ssDNA to constitutively induce the SOS response.     

Increase of the DNA strand assimilation activity of recA protein by removal of the C terminus and structure-function studies of the resulting protein fragment

A proteolytic fragment of recA protein, missing about 15% of the protein at the C terminus, was found to promote assimilation of homologous single-stranded DNA into duplex DNA more efficiently than intact recA protein. This difference was not found if Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein was present. The ATPase activity of both intact recA protein and the fragment was identical. The difference in strand assimilation activity cannot be due to differences in single-stranded DNA affinity, since both the fragment and intact proteins bind to single-stranded DNA with nearly identical affinities. However, the fragment was found to bind double-stranded DNA more tightly and to aggregate more extensively than recA protein; both of these properties may be important in strand assimilation. Aggregation of the fragment was extensive in the presence of duplex DNA under the same condition where recA protein did not aggregate. The double-stranded DNA binding of both recA protein and the fragment responds to nucleotide cofactors in the same manner as single-stranded DNA binding, i.e. ADP weakens and ATP gamma S strengthens the association. The missing C-terminal region of recA protein includes a very acidic region that is homologous to other single-stranded DNA binding proteins and which has been implicated in DNA binding modulation. This C-terminal region may serve a similar function in recA protein, possibly inhibiting double-stranded DNA invasion. The possible role of the enhanced double-stranded DNA affinity of the fragment protein in the mechanism of strand assimilation is discussed.     

Translocation of Escherichia coli recA protein from a single-stranded tail to contiguous duplex DNA

Duplex DNA with a contiguous single-stranded tail was nearly as effective as single-stranded DNA in acting as a cofactor for the ATPase activity of recA protein at neutral pH and concentrations of MgCl2 that support homologous pairing. The ATP hydrolysis reached a steady state rate that was proportional to the length of the duplex DNA attached to a short 5' single-stranded tail after a lag. Separation of the single-stranded tail from most of the duplex portion of the molecule by restriction enzyme cleavage led to a gradual decline in ATP hydrolysis. Measurement of the rate of hydrolysis as a function of DNA concentration for both tailed duplex DNA and single-stranded DNA cofactors indicated that the binding site size of recA protein on a duplex DNA lattice, about 4 base pairs, is similar to that on a single-stranded DNA lattice, about four nucleotides. The length of the lag phase preceding steady state hydrolysis depended on the DNA concentration, length of the duplex region, and the polarity of the single-stranded tail, but was comparatively independent of tail length for tails over 70 nucleotides in length. The lag was 5-10 times longer for 3' than for 5' single-stranded tailed duplex DNA molecules, whereas the steady state rates of hydrolysis were lower. These observations show that, after nucleation of a recA protein complex on the single-stranded tail, the protein samples the entire duplex region via an interaction that is labile and not strongly polarized.     

Interaction of the recA protein of Escherichia coli with single-stranded DNA

The interaction of recA protein with single-stranded (ss) phi X174 DNA has been examined by means of a nuclease protection assay. The stoichiometry of protection was found to be 1 recA monomer/approximately 4 nucleotides of ssDNA both in the absence of a nucleotide cofactor and in the presence of ATP. In contrast, in the presence of adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) (ATP gamma S) the stoichiometry was 1 recA monomer/approximately 8 nucleotides. No protection was seen with ADP. In the absence of a nucleotide cofactor, the binding of recA protein to ssDNA was quite stable as judged by equilibration with a challenge DNA (t1/2 approximately 30 min). Addition of ATP stimulated this transfer (t1/2 approximately 3 min) as did ADP (t1/2 approximately 0.2 min). ATP gamma S greatly reduced the rate of equilibration (t1/2 greater than 12 h). Direct visualization of recA X ssDNA complexes at subsaturating recA protein concentrations using electron microscopy revealed individual ssDNA molecules partially covered with recA protein which were converted to highly condensed networks upon addition of ATP gamma S. These results have led to a general model for the interaction of recA protein with ssDNA.     

Stable binding of recA protein to duplex DNA. Unraveling a paradox

recA protein binding to duplex DNA is a complicated, multistep process. The final product of this process is a stably bound complex of recA protein and extensively unwound double-stranded DNA. recA monomers within the complex hydrolyze ATP with an apparent kcat of approximately 19-22 min-1. Once the final binding state is achieved, binding and ATP hydrolysis by this complex becomes pH independent. The weak binding of recA protein to duplex DNA reported in previous studies does not, therefore, reflect an intrinsically unfavorable binding equilibrium. Instead, this apparent weak binding reflects a slow step in the association pathway. The rate-limiting step in this process involves the initiation rather than the propagation of DNA binding and unwinding. This step exhibits no dependence on recA protein concentration at pH 7.5. Extension or propagation of the recA filament is fast relative to the overall process. Initiation of binding is pH dependent and represents a prominent kinetic barrier at pH 7.5. ATP hydrolysis occurs only after the duplex DNA is unwound. The binding density of recA protein on double-stranded DNA is approximately one monomer/4 base pairs. A model for this process is presented. These results provide an explanation for several paradoxical observations about recA protein-promoted DNA strand exchange. In particular, they demonstrate that there is no thermodynamic requirement for dissociation of recA protein from the heteroduplex DNA product of strand exchange.     

Induction of SOS functions by nitrogen dioxide in Escherichia coli with different DNA-repair capacities

The effect of gaseous nitrogen dioxide (NO2) on cytotoxicity, induction of synthesis of UmuC and RecA proteins, and mutagenesis was studied in Escherichia coli strains with different capacities of DNA repair. Gaseous NO2 (90, 180 microliter/l) killed Escherichia coli. The recA mutant was most sensitive, the lexA mutant moderately sensitive, and the uvrA mutant and the wild-type the least sensitive. When 90 microliter/l NO2 gas was bubbled into bacterial suspensions for 30 min at a flow rate of 100 ml/min, the induction of umuC gene expression increased in the wild-type strain. NO2 also induced the recA gene expression in the wild-type strain. The synthesis of neither RecA nor UmuC proteins was induced in the recA and lexA mutants. We further investigated the NO2 mutagenesis in the cells treated with bubbling of NO2 gas. NO2 caused mutation to Trp+ of WP2.     

Isolation of altered recA polypeptides and interaction with ATP and DNA

In this paper we describe the partial proteolytic digestion of recA proteins from Escherichia coli and Proteus mirabilis and the production and isolation of truncated recA polypeptides. A proteolytic fragment of the P. mirabilis recA protein bound single-strand DNA and ATP normally but has altered duplex DNA binding properties. This protein was shown to initiate but not complete DNA strand transfer from a DNA duplex to a complementary single strand. The product of the E. coli recA1 allele bound but could not hydrolyze ATP and the protein bound single-strand but not double-strand DNA. This protein did not appear to initiate the transfer of a strand from a linear duplex to a single-strand circle and inhibited the wild-type recA protein from performing strand transfer. We report that recA protein binds linear duplex DNA in a manner that enhances the rate of ligation by T4 DNA ligase. When heterologous single-strand DNA was added in addition to the duplex DNA large stable aggregates of protein and DNA were formed that could easily be sedimented from solution.     

Purification of an SOS repressor from Bacillus subtilis.

We have identified in Bacillus subtilis a DNA-binding protein that is functionally analogous to the Escherichia coli LexA protein. We show that the 23-kDa B. subtilis protein binds specifically to the consensus sequence 5'-GAACN4GTTC-3' located within the putative promoter regions of four distinct B. subtilis DNA damage-inducible genes: dinA, dinB, dinC, and recA. In RecA+ strains, the protein's specific DNA binding activity was abolished following treatment with mitomycin C; the decrease in DNA binding activity after DNA damage had a half-life of about 5 min and was followed by an increase in SOS gene expression. There was no detectable decrease in DNA binding activity in B. subtilis strains deficient in RecA (recA1, recA4) or otherwise deficient in SOS induction (recM13) following mitomycin C treatment. The addition of purified B. subtilis RecA protein, activated by single-stranded DNA and dATP, abolished the specific DNA binding activity in crude extracts of RecA+ strains and strains deficient in SOS induction. We purified the B. subtilis DNA-binding protein more than 4,000-fold, using an affinity resin in which a 199-bp DNA fragment containing the dinC promoter region was coupled to cellulose. We show that B. subtilis RecA inactivates the DNA binding activity of the purified B. subtilis protein in a reaction that requires single-stranded DNA and nucleoside triphosphate. By analogy with E. coli, our results indicate that the DNA-binding protein is the repressor of the B. subtilis SOS DNA repair system.     

Properties of the high-affinity single-stranded DNA binding state of the Escherichia coli recA protein

The properties of the high-affinity single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding state of Escherichia coli recA protein have been studied. We find that all of the nucleoside triphosphates that are hydrolyzed by recA protein induce a high-affinity ssDNA binding state. The effect of ATP binding to recA protein was partially separated from the ATP hydrolytic event by substituting calcium chloride for magnesium chloride in the binding buffer. Under these conditions, the rate of ATP hydrolysis is greatly inhibited. ATP increases the affinity of recA protein for ssDNA in a concentration-dependent manner in the presence of both calcium and magnesium chloride with apparent Kd values of 375 and 500 microM ATP, respectively. Under nonhydrolytic conditions, the molar ratio of ATP to ADP has an effect on the recA protein ssDNA binding affinity. Over an ATP/ADP molar ratio of 2-3, the affinity of recA protein for ssDNA shifts cooperatively from a low-to a high-affinity state.     

Real-time observation of RecA filament dynamics with single monomer resolution

RecA and its homologs help maintain genomic integrity through recombination. Using single-molecule fluorescence assays and hidden Markov modeling, we show the most direct evidence that a RecA filament grows and shrinks primarily one monomer at a time and only at the extremities. Both ends grow and shrink, contrary to expectation, but a higher binding rate at one end is responsible for directional filament growth. Quantitative rate determination also provides insights into how RecA might control DNA accessibility in vivo. We find that about five monomers are sufficient for filament nucleation. Although ordinarily single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB) prevents filament nucleation, single RecA monomers can easily be added to an existing filament and displace SSB from DNA at the rate of filament extension. This supports the proposal for a passive role of RecA-loading machineries in SSB removal.     

Genetic separation of Escherichia coli recA functions for SOS mutagenesis and repressor cleavage.

Evidence is presented that recA functions which promote the SOS functions of mutagenesis, LexA protein proteolysis, and lambda cI repressor proteolysis are each genetically separable from the others. This separation was observed in recombination-proficient recA mutants and rec+ (F' recA56) heterodiploids. recA430, recA433, and recA435 mutants and recA+ (F' recA56) heterodiploids were inducible for only one or two of the three functions and defective for mutagenesis. recA80 and recA432 mutants were constitutively activated for two of the three functions in that these mutants did not have to be induced to express the functions. We propose that binding of RecA protein to damaged DNA and subsequent interaction with small inducer molecules gives rise to conformational changes in RecA protein. These changes promote surface-surface interactions with other target proteins, such as cI and LexA proteins. By this model, the recA mutants are likely to have incorrect amino acids substituted as sites in the RecA protein structure which affect surface regions required for protein-protein interactions. The constitutively activated mutants could likewise insert altered amino acids at sites in RecA which are involved in the activation of RecA protein by binding small molecules or polynucleotides which metabolically regulate RecA protein.     

Interaction of recA protein with single-stranded DNA. Quantitative aspects of binding affinity modulation by nucleotide cofactors

We have investigated quantitative molecular aspects of the interaction of recA protein with single-stranded DNA, by using a fluorescent modified-DNA referred to as etheno-M13 DNA. In addition, the effects of the nucleotide cofactors ATP and ADP, and the analogues ATP-gamma-S, AMP-P-C-P, and AMP-P-N-P on this interaction have been studied. It is shown that ATP, AMP-P-N-P and, in particular, ATP-gamma-S significantly increase the affinity of recA protein for single-stranded DNA, whereas ADP and, to a lesser degree, AMP-P-C-P decrease the affinity. Binding to etheno-M13 single-stranded DNA is co-operative, with the value of the co-operativity parameter, omega, being approximately 50 under all conditions measured. The effect that ADP has on recA protein-DNA affinity is to lower the intrinsic binding constant, but it has no effect on the co-operativity of binding. In addition, the stability of the recA protein-DNA complex is very salt dependent (d log K/d log [NaC1] approximately -10) and it is the intrinsic binding affinity rather than the co-operativity of binding that is affected; thus, under all conditions observed, recA protein binds single-stranded DNA co-operatively with a value of omega = 50 +/- 10. The binding affinity is also influenced by the type of anion present, being approximately 10,000-fold higher when acetate ion is present instead of chloride ion. These data have been interpreted to suggest that recA protein forms up to five ionic interactions when it binds to single-stranded DNA and that five to six anions are displaced upon binding. The modulation of recA protein-DNA complex stability by nucleotide cofactors suggests that these cofactors play a role in the cycling of recA protein on and off single-stranded DNA, with ATP being required for DNA binding under physiological conditions and ADP serving as a "release" factor. These results are discussed in terms of a model for the role of ATP hydrolysis in a recA protein-single stranded DNA binding cycle.     

Defective homologous pairing and proficient processive unwinding by the recA430 mutant protein and intermediates of homologous pairing by recA protein

The recA protein promotes the formation and processing of joint molecules of homologous double- and single-stranded DNAs in vitro. Under a set of specified conditions, we found that the substitution of a single amino acid in the recA protein (recA430 mutation) depresses its activity for the homologous pairing to about 1/100 of that by the wild type protein when compared by the rate for the first 2-3 min of the reaction, but that the mutation only slightly, if at all, affects its ability to bind progressively to double-stranded DNA to unwind the double helix ("processive unwinding"). This is in striking contrast to an anti-recA protein monoclonal IgG, ARM193, which severely inhibits the processive unwinding but not the homologous pairing, providing further support for our conclusion that the homologous pairing and processive unwinding are functionally independent of each other. Antibody ARM193 caused the breakdown of spontaneously formed filaments of the recA protein, but the recA430 mutation did not affect the self-polymerization of the protein. The recA430 protein was apparently proficient in the functional binding to a single-stranded DNA and in the hydrolysis of ATP. However, we found that under the above conditions the mutant protein was defective as to homology-independent conjunction of DNA molecules to form a "ternary complex" (of macromolecules). These results suggest that (i) only one DNA-binding site is sufficient for the recA protein to promote the processive unwinding (the ability of the protein to form spontaneous filaments is closely related to this process) and that (ii) two DNA-binding sites on each of the recA polypeptides or those composed of a dimer (or oligomer) of the polypeptide are required for the recA protein to promote both the conjunction of parental DNA molecules and the homologous pairing (the ability to form the spontaneous filaments is not essential to this process). (iii) The simultaneous inactivation of the activity to promote the homologous pairing and that to form the ternary complex by the single substitution of the amino acid provides a physical support for the conclusion that the ternary complex is an indispensable intermediate in the homologous pairing.     

Biochemical properties of the Escherichia coli recA430 protein. Analysis of a mutation that affects the interaction of the ATP-recA protein complex with single-stranded DNA

The biochemical properties of the recA430 protein have been examined and compared to those of wild-type recA protein. We find that, while the recA430 protein possesses ssDNA-dependent rATP activity, this activity is inhibited by the Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB protein) under many conditions that enhance wild-type recA protein rATPase hydrolysis. Stimulation of rATPase activity by SSB protein is observed only at high concentrations of both rATP (greater than 1 mM) and recA430 protein (greater than 5 microM). In contrast, stimulation of ssDNA-dependent dATPase activity by SSB protein is less sensitive to protein and nucleotide concentration. Consistent with the nucleotide hydrolysis data, recA430 protein can carry out DNA strand exchange in the presence of either rATP or dATP. However, in the presence of rATP, both the rate and the extent of DNA strand exchange by recA430 protein are greatly reduced compared to wild-type recA protein and are sensitive to recA430 protein concentration. This reduction is presumably due to the inability of recA430 protein to compete with SSB protein for ssDNA binding sites under these conditions. The cleavage of lexA repressor protein by recA430 protein is also sensitive to the nucleotide cofactor present and is completely inhibited by SSB protein when rATP is the cofactor but not when dATP is used. Finally, the steady-state affinity and the rate of association of the recA430 protein-ssDNA complex are reduced, suggesting that the mutation affects the interaction of the ATP-bound form of recA protein with ssDNA. This alteration is the likely molecular defect responsible for inhibition of recA430 protein rATP-dependent function by SSB protein. The biochemical properties observed in the presence of dATP and SSB protein, i.e. the reduced levels of both DNA strand exchange activity and cleavage of lexA repressor protein, are consistent with the phenotypic behavior of recA430 mutations.     

recA protein filaments bind two molecules of single-stranded DNA with off rates regulated by nucleotide cofactor

To probe the role of nucleotide cofactor in the binding of single-stranded DNA to recA protein, we have developed a sedimentation assay using 5'-labeled 32P-poly(dT).recA.poly(dT) complexes sediment quantitatively when centrifuged at 100,000 x g for 45 min, whereas free poly(dT) remains in the supernatant. In the presence of ATP, between 6 and 7 bases cosediment per recA monomer; but when ADP is present or in the absence of added nucleotide cofactor, only 3-3.5 bases/recA monomer cosediment. In competition experiments in which recA.32P-poly(dT) complexes are incubated with unlabeled poly(dT), we again find 3-3.5 bases of labeled poly(dT) cosedimenting per recA monomer when no nucleotide cofactor is present. However, when the same experiment is performed with ATP, only half of the expected 6-7 bases of labeled poly(dT) remain bound to the DNA, demonstrating that half of the poly(dT) in the complex exchanges rapidly with free poly(dT), whereas the other half equilibrates slowly, like poly(dT) in the absence of nucleotide. The rate of exchange of the second more tightly bound poly(dT) is accelerated when ADP is present. Our observations are rationalized by a model in which each recA protein helical filament binds two strands of poly(dT) with a stoichiometry of 3-3.5 bases/recA monomer/strand.     

The physical and enzymatic properties of Escherichia coli recA protein display anion-specific inhibition.

The enzymatic activities of Escherichia coli recA protein are sensitive to ionic composition. Here we report that sodium glutamate (NaGlu) is much less inhibitory to the DNA strand exchange, DNA-dependent ATPase, and DNA binding activities of the recA protein than is NaCl. Both joint molecule formation and complete exchange of DNA strands occur (albeit at reduced rates) at NaGlu concentrations as high as 0.5 M whereas concentrations of NaCl greater than 0.2 M are sufficient for complete inhibition. The single-stranded DNA (ssDNA)-dependent ATPase activity is even less sensitive to inhibition by NaGlu; ATP hydrolysis stimulated by M13 ssDNA is unaffected by 0.5 M NaGlu and is further stimulated by E. coli ssDNA binding protein approximately 2-fold. Finally, NaGlu has essentially no effect on the stability of recA protein-epsilon M13 DNA complexes, with concentrations of NaGlu as high as 1.5 M failing to dissociate the complexes. Surprisingly, NaGlu also has little effect on the concentration of NaCl required to disrupt the recA protein-epsilon M13 DNA complex, demonstrating that destabilization is dependent on both the concentration and type of anionic rather than cationic species. Quantitative analysis of DNA binding isotherms establishes that the intrinsic binding affinity of recA protein is affected by the anionic species present and that the cooperativity parameter is relatively unaffected. Consequently, the sensitivity of recA protein-ssDNA complexes to disruption by NaCl does not result from the competitive effects associated with cation displacement from the ssDNA upon protein binding but rather results from anion displacement upon complex formation. The magnitude of this anion-specific effect on ssDNA binding is large relative to that of other nucleic acid binding proteins.     

Escherichia coli K-12 mutants in which viability is dependent on recA function.

A gene required for growth and viability in recA mutants of Escherichia coli K-12 was identified. This gene, rdgB (for Rec-dependent growth), mapped near 64 min on the E. coli genetic map. In a strain carrying a temperature-sensitive recA allele, recA200, and an rdgB mutation, DNA synthesis but not protein synthesis ceased after 80 min of incubation at 42 degrees C, and there was extensive DNA degradation. The rdgB mutation alone had no apparent effect on DNA synthesis or growth; however, mutant strains did show enhanced intrachromosomal recombination and induction of the SOS regulon. The rdgB gene was cloned and its-gene product identified through the construction and analysis of deletion and insertion mutations of rdgB-containing plasmids. The ability of a plasmid to complement an rdgB recA mutant was correlated with its ability to produce a 25-kilodalton polypeptide as detected by the maxicell technique.