Mechanics of the inner ear of the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana): the contact membranes and the periotic canal

The frog inner ear consists of a complex of fluid-filled membranous sacs and canals containing eight distinct clusters of sensory hair cells. In this study we attempt to delineate the potential pathways for acoustic energy flow toward two of these clusters located within the amphibian papilla and the basilar papilla. Detailed morphological measurements of the periotic canal based on internal casts of the inner ear in the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) revealed that it is divided into a wide, tapered section and a narrower section comprised of two branches – one short and blind projecting into the endolymphatic space and another longer, terminating in the round window. Additionally, we used laser Doppler velocimetry to record the velocity responses of the contact membranes of the amphibian papilla and basilar papilla. We found that the acoustic energy flow through these two structures is frequency dependent such that the amphibian papilla contact membrane displays a peak velocity amplitude at frequencies less than 500 Hz, whereas the basilar papilla contact membrane velocity response exhibits a maximum above 1100 Hz. Our data advocate a mechanical substrate underlying the frequency segregation in the auditory nerve fibers innervating the amphibian papilla and the basilar papilla. Accepted: 9 March 2000     

The inner ear of gymnophione amphibians and its nerve supply: A comparative study of regressive events in a complex sensory system (Amphibia,Gymnophiona)

Summary The inner ears of representatives of all six gymnophionan families, as well as an ontogenetic series of one species, were studied in order to understand the origin and changes of the amphibian and basilar papillae. The amphibian papilla is in close proximity to the papilla neglecta in some adult gymnophionans. During ontogeny, both epithelia are adherent before they are separated by the formation of the utriculosaccular foramen. The nerve fibers to both epithelia run together, and both epithelia show a comparable variation in size and position among amphibians (amphibian papilla) and among vertebrates (papilla neglecta). Based on these arguments we propose that the amphibian papilla is a translocation of a part of the papilla neglecta specific to amphibians. Present in all primitive gymnophionans, the basilar papilla is lost in all derived gymnophionans. In contrast to anurans, but similar to some urodeles, amniotes, and Latimeria, the basilar papilla rests partly on a basilar membrane. Because of similarities in structure, topology, and innervation, the basilar papilla is suggested to be homologous in Latimeria and tetrapods. The structural differences of most amphibian basilar papillae, compared to those of amniotes and Latimeria, may be due to the different course of the periotic system and the formation of a basilar papillar recess rather than to a separate evolution of this epithelium. In addition to loss of the basilar papilla, some derived gymnophionans have lost the lagena, presumably independently, and the amphibian papilla is extremely reduced in the only genus without a stapes (Scolecomorphus). The papilla neglecta is, for unknown functional reasons, relatively large in aquatic gymnophionans, whereas it is almost lost in some thoroughly terrestrial gymnophionans. The regressive changes in the inner ear are not reflected in obvious changes in the pattern of eighth nerve projection. However, there is a rearrangement of cell masses in the rhombencephalic alar plate of derived gymnophionans, which may be related to the partial or complete loss of lateral line afferents. We propose that the presence of a basilar papilla is a synapomorphy of tetrapods and Latimeria, that the translocation of the papilla neglecta is related to the unique course of the amphibian periotic canal, and that regressive changes in the inner ear are related to the primitive absence of a tympanic ear.     

Seismic and auditory tuning curves from bullfrog saccular and amphibian papular axons

We present seismic and auditory frequency tuning curves of individual bullfrog, Rana catesbeiana, saccular and amphibian papilla axons that responded to both seismic and auditory stimuli. In this study we found: 1) most saccular axons respond well to auditory stimuli with moderate signal strength (50-70 dB SPL) as well as to seismic stimuli; 2) most amphibian papilla axons respond well to seismic stimuli as well as to auditory stimuli, and their seismic sensitivities are comparable to those of saccular axons (responding to sinusoidal stimuli with peak accelerations in the range 0.001 to 0.1 cm/S2); 3) the responses to both seismic and auditory stimuli from both saccule and amphibian papilla are tuned, i.e. the strength of the response varies with the frequency of the stimulus; and this tuning is clearly not the result of second order resonance; 4) in individual axons the tuning properties for seismic stimuli often are not the same as those for auditory stimuli, a fact that may provide clues about how the stimulus signal energy is transferred to the hair cells in each case.     

Peripheral auditory processing in the bobtail lizard Tiliqua rugosa

Summary We have labelled single physiologically-characterized primary auditory neurones in the bobtail lizard and traced them to their innervation sites within the basilar papilla. The distribution of stained fibre terminals shows that low frequencies (up to a characteristic frequency, CF, of about 0.8 kHz) are processed in the smaller apical segment of the papilla and medium to high frequencies in the much longer basal segment. It is possible that the frequency ranges of these segments partly overlap in individual animals.The tonotopic organization of the basal segment is well described by an exponential relationship; the CF increases towards the basal end. Systematic, peripheral recordings from the auditory nerve very close to the papilla confirm this tonotopicity for the basal segment.The apical segment of the papilla shows an unusual tonotopic organization in that the CF appears to increase across the epithelium, from abneural to neural. A tonotopicity in this direction has not previously been demonstrated in vertebrates.All stained neurones branched within the basilar papilla to innervate, typically, between 4 and 14 hair cells. The branching patterns of fibres innervating in the apical and basal papillar segment, respectively, show characteristic differences. Apical fibres tend to innervate hair cells with the same morphological polarity and often branch extensively along the segment. Basal fibres, in contrast, typically innervate about equal numbers of hair cells of opposing polarity and are more restricted in their longitudinal branching.Abbreviation CF characteristic frequency     

Comparative features of the surface morphology of the basilar papilla in five families of salamanders (Amphibia; Caudata)

The surface morphology of the basilar recess and papilla was examined in 14 species of newts and salamanders selected from the five families of urodeles (Ambystomatidae, Salamandridae, Hynobiidae, Cryptobranchidae, and Amphiumidae) known to have this end-organ. In this sampling, the general organization of basilar structures is essentially similar across species investigated. The recess forms a tubular diverticulum of the proximal part of the lagena. One wall of the recess is associated with a diverticulum of the intracapsular periotic sac, and an adjacent wall is occupied by the basilar papilla. The papilla contained from as few as five hair cells in specimens of Taricha torosa to over 200 hair cells in Cryptobranchus allegheniensis. In most species, the papilla showed a morphological continuum between tall centrally or distally placed ciliary bundles and short ciliary bundles near the papillar margins. In certain species examined, tall bundles had kinocilia with swellings near their tips. Most forms showed a tendency to have groups of ciliary bundles morphologically polarized either toward or away from the saccule. In Cryptobranchus and Dicamptodon, many bundles had a random orientation. The gross and fine structural features of the basilar complex are compared in urodeles and anurans, and "generalized" features for the amphibian basilar complex are suggested. The basilar complex of Cryptobranchus is interpreted as being most generalized, representing a structural form from which most features of the basilar complex in other urodeles and anurans can be derived.     

The tonotopic organization of the bullfrog amphibian papilla,an auditory organ lacking a basilar membrane

Summary Intracellular dye-injection studies have revealed tonotopic organization of the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) amphibian papilla, an auditory organ lacking a basilar membrane or its equivalent. The best excitatory frequency (BEF) for auditory stimuli was identified in each of twenty-nine VIIIth-nerve afferent axons that subsequently were traced to their peripheral terminations at the sensory surface. Among those axons, the five with BEFs greater than 550 Hz all terminated in the caudalmost region of the papilla, the ten with the BEFs greater than 300 Hz and less than or equal to 550 Hz all terminated in the central region of the papilla, and the fourteen with BEFs equal to or less than 300 Hz all terminated in the rostralmost region of the papilla (Fig. 4). The tectorium is very much larger and presumably more massive under the low-frequency region of the papilla than it is under the high-frequency region (Fig. 1). Higher-frequency axons tended to innervate few (one to four) receptor cells, and low-frequency axons tended to innervate many (six or more). Higher-frequency axons often terminated in large claw-like structures that engulfed the basal portions of individual hair cells and in this way were morphologically similar to type I terminals in the inner ears of higher vertebrates.Abbreviations BEF best excitatory frequency - HRP horseradish peroxidase     

Directionality of phase locking in auditory nerve fibers of the leopard frog Rana pipiens pipiens

Summary A dorsal approach to the eighth nerve and free-field stimulation were used to investigate the effect of sound direction and intensity on phase locking in auditory nerve fibers of the leopard frog Rana pipiens pipiens.Tuning curves of 75 auditory neurons were analyzed (Fig. 2). Amphibian papillar neurons, but not basilar papillar neurons, exhibit significant phase locking to short tone bursts at the characteristic frequency (CF), the degree of phase locking (vector strength) decreasing with the neuron's CF (Figs. 3, 4 and 10E). Vector strength increases with sound pressure level to saturate about 20 dB above threshold, while the preferred firing phase is only slightly affected (Figs. 5 and 6).In contrast, sound direction hardly affects vector strength (Figs. 7, 8, 9A and 10A and C), but has a strong influence on the preferred firing phase (Figs. 7, 8, 9B and C, 10B and D): With respect to anterior tone presentation there are phase lags for ipsilateral and phase leads for posterior and contralateral presentation. Phase differences between both ears show a sinusoidal or cardioid/ovoidal directional characteristic; maximum differences are found with antero-lateral tone presentation (Fig. 11). The directionality of phase locking decreases with the neuron's CF (Fig. 10F) and only slightly changes with sound pressure level (Fig. 12). Thus, phase locking of amphibian papilla neurons can potentially provide intensity-independent information for sound localization.Abbreviations SPL sound pressure level - FTC frequency threshold curve - CF characteristic frequency - TF test frequency - VS vector strength - AP amphibian papilla - BP basilar papilla     

Morphological and fine structural features of the basilar papilla in ambystomatid salamanders (Amphibia; Caudata)

The morphology and fine structure of the basilar recess and basilar papilla were investigated in four species of salamanders from the family Ambystomatidae. The otic relationships of the recess and papilla to the proximal part of the lagena and saccule are described, and new terminology is suggested for the periotic relationships of the basilar recess to a diverticulum of an intracapsular periotic sac. The basilar papilla consists of supporting cells united laterally by gap junctions, capped by microvilli uniformly arranged around a short, central cilium, and hair cells that typically show several synapses with a single afferent nerve fiber, each marked by a rounded synaptic body surrounded by vesicles. In contrast to anuran basilar papillae, efferent nerve terminals were observed in synapse with hair cells and, rarely, upon afferent fibers. The distal half of the ambystomatid papilla contained hair cells capped by tall ciliary bundles, with kinocilia that show swellings near their tips with delicate attachments to adjacent tall stereocilia. A tectorial body covers only this region of the papilla. Hair cells with shorter stereocilia, situated in the proximal half and at the papillar margins, are related only to filamentous extensions of the tectorial body. The ambystomatid basilar recess and papilla are compared to auditory end-organs in other vertebrates, and it is suggested that a basic distinction can be made between aural neuroepithelia in amniotes versus that in nonamniotic vertebrate ears.     

Ultrastructure of the sensory formations of the internal ear in the common frog

By means of scanning electron microscopy method, sensory formations of the membranous labyrinth has been studied in the frog (Rana temporaria). The form of sensory fields and morphological peculiarities of the hair cells are described. For the saccular macula, amphibian and basilar papillae, the number of the hair cells is calculated, orientation of the hair cell poles is demonstrated.     

Mechanics of the exceptional anuran ear

The anuran ear is frequently used for studying fundamental properties of vertebrate auditory systems. This is due to its unique anatomical features, most prominently the lack of a basilar membrane and the presence of two dedicated acoustic end organs, the basilar papilla and the amphibian papilla. Our current anatomical and functional knowledge implies that three distinct regions can be identified within these two organs. The basilar papilla functions as a single auditory filter. The low-frequency portion of the amphibian papilla is an electrically tuned, tonotopically organized auditory end organ. The high-frequency portion of the amphibian papilla is mechanically tuned and tonotopically organized, and it emits spontaneous otoacoustic emissions. This high-frequency portion of the amphibian papilla shows a remarkable, functional resemblance to the mammalian cochlea.     

The ultrastructure and innervation of the ear of the gar, Lepisosteus osseus

The endorgans of the inner ear of the gar were examined using transmission and scanning electron microscopy as well as nerve staining. The ultrastructure of the sensory hair cells and supporting cells of the gar ear are similar to cells in other bony fishes, whereas there are significant differences between the gar and other bony fishes in the orientations patterns of the sensory hair cells on the saccular and lagenar sensory epithelia. The saccular sensory epithelium has two regions, a main region and a secondary region ventral to the main region. The ciliary bundles on the main region are divided into two groups, one oriented dorsally and the other ventrally. Furthermore, as a result of curvature of the saccular sensory epithelium, the dorsal and ventral ciliary bundles on the rostral portion of the epithelium are rotated ninety degrees and are thus oriented on the animal's rostro-caudal axis. Hair cells on the secondary region are generally oriented ventrally. The lagenar epithelium has three groups of sensory hair cells. The groups on the rostral and caudal ends of the macula are oriented dorsally, whereas the middle group is oriented ventrally. Hair cell orientations on the utricular epithelium and macula neglecta are similar to those in other bony fishes. Nerve fiber diameters can be divided into three size classes, 1-8 microns, 9-13 microns, and 14 microns or more, with the smallest size class containing the majority of fibers. The distribution of the various classes of fiber diameters is not the same in nerve branches to each of the end organs. Similarly, the ratio of hair cells to axons differs in each end organ. The highest hair cell to axon ratio is in the utricle (23:1) and the smallest is in the macula neglecta (7:1). The number of sensory hair cells far exceed the number of eighth nerve axons in all sensory epithelia.     

Axonal atrophy: the retraction reaction.

Recent studies indicate that morphological alterations of axon branches that are removed during normal development are similar to those that occur following ablation of postsynaptic cells in adult animals. In both situations, axons retract (rather than degenerate), the calibers of withdrawing axon branches are markedly reduced, and spherical swellings near (or at) the axon terminations appear. The similarity between naturally occurring and target-deprived axon withdrawal suggests that both developing and adult axons withdraw from target cells that no longer provide support.     

Aroclor 1254 impairs the hearing ability of Xenopus laevis

In this study we assessed the effects of chronic, dietary exposure of Aroclor 1254 (A1254) on the hearing of Xenopus frogs. We used the auditory brainstem response (ABR) to assay changes in hearing physiology; ABR thresholds, as well as latency-intensity and amplitude-intensity profiles of the initial positive (P1) and negative (N1) peaks were measured. Two groups of animals that received 50 ppm and 100 ppm of A1254 in their diet from 5 days post-fertilization through metamorphosis were compared to a control group that received untreated chow. The results showed significant threshold elevations in the 3–4 kHz range and significantly delayed peak latencies and reduced amplitudes at these frequencies in A1254 treated animals as compared to control animals. These findings indicate that A1254 selectively damages the high-frequency sensorineural hearing system associated with the basilar papilla of frogs. This preferential damage may be related to inherent differences in the vulnerability of the basilar versus amphibian papilla in the frog. The overall results of this study are also consistent with the reported A1254-induced auditory deficits in mammals indicating that the basilar papilla of the Xenopus frog may serve as an effective model for studying the effects of A1254 on the auditory system.     

A model for energy flow in the inner ear of the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana)

We present a quantitative mathematical model that represents the main features of the bullfrog inner ear. Calculated responses based on this model predict the observed frequency separation between the amphibian papilla and basilar papilla responses. The origin of this separation can be traced to the effect of the contact membranes on the impedance of the respective paths. Additionally, we calculated the input impedance of the periotic canal and showed that at low frequencies it acts as a bypass for most of the energy entering the ear, shunting it away from the amphibian-basilar papilla complex. As this shunting decreases with increasing frequency, we propose that the periotic canal functions as a protection mechanism to prevent overload of the amphibian papilla and basilar papilla during ventilation and for quasi-static pressure equalization. Our model explains the main features of the empirical data obtained from direct measurement of the amphibian papilla and basilar papilla contact membranes reported in an accompanying paper (this issue). Accepted: 9 March 2000     

Tympanic and extratympanic sound transmission in the leopard frog

Summary The inner ear of the leopard frog,Rana pipiens, receives sound via two separate pathways: the tympanic-columellar pathway and an extratympanic route. The relative efficiency of the two pathways was investigated. Laser interferometry measurements of tympanic vibration induced by free-field acoustic stimulation reveal a broadly tuned response with maximal vibration at 800 and 1500 Hz. Vibrational amplitude falls off rapidly above and below these frequencies so that above 2 kHz and below 300 Hz tympanic vibration is severely reduced. Electrophysiological measurements of the thresholds of single eighth cranial nerve fibers from both the amphibian and basilar papillae in response to pure tones were made in such a way that the relative efficiency of tympanic and extratympanic transmission could be assessed for each fiber. Thresholds for the two routes are very similar up to 1.0 kHz, above which tympanic transmission eventually becomes more efficient by 15–20 dB. By varying the relative phase of the two modes of stimulation, a reduction of the eighth nerve response can be achieved. When considered together, the measurements of tympanic vibration and the measurements of tympanic and extratympanic transmission thresholds suggest that under normal conditions in this species (1) below 300 Hz extratympanic sound transmission is the main source of inner ear stimulation; (2) for most of the basilar papilla frequency range (i.e., above 1.2 kHz) tympanic transmission is more important; and (3) both routes contribute to the stimulation of amphibian papilla fibers tuned between those points. Thus acoustic excitation of the an uran's inner ear depends on a complex interac tion between tympanic and extratympanic sound transmission.Abbreviations dB SPL decibels sound pressure level re: 20 N/ m² - AP amphibian papilla - BP basilar papilla - BEF best excitatory frequency     

Morphological gradients in the starling basilar papilla

The starling cochlea was studied with TEM at four locations along the basilar papilla to investigate gradients in morphological features over the papilla's length and width. Hair cell shape changes continuously from neural to abneural and from basal to apical. Unlike the situation in mammals, there are no distinct populations of hair cells; the previously described types (tall hair cells and short hair cells) are merely extremes in a continuum. Contacts between THC are a normal feature. Except at the base of the papilla, SHC have very large cuticular plates, suggesting a micromechanical function for these cells. In contrast to the THC, the SHC normally completely lack afferent innervation; this indicates that their function is restricted to within the basilar papilla itself. © 1992 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Structure and Innervation of the Inner Ear Sensory Organs in an Otophysine Fish,the Upside–down Catfish (Synodontis nigriventrisDavid)

All the sensory epithelia of the inner ear in the upside–down catfish (Synodontis nigriventrisDavid) were examined by light microscopy. The morphology of the membranous labyrinth and the orientation of the hair cells is similar to what has been found in other otophysine fishes. The sensory cells are of variable size both inter– and intraepithelially; particularly the macula sacculi is equipped with heterogeneous receptors. Regional differences in the hair cell density are presented for all the otolith organs plus the papilla neglecta. Nerve stainings reveal regional differentiation. The central areas are innervated by stout and stubbly nerve endings intermingled with a few thin nerve fibres while the peripheral parts are reached exclusively by thin axons. In the anterior region of the macula sacculi are found unique cup–shaped axon terminations which surround the basal parts of a single or a few sensory cells. The number and diameter range of the myelinated nerve fibres as well as the hair cell/axon ratio are presented. Electron microscopy demonstrates the presence of unmyelinated axons in all inner ear nerve ramuli.     

Diversity of form in the amphibian papilla of Puerto Rican frogs

Summary In modern frogs, the amphibian papilla exhibits a caudal extension whose shape, relative length, and proportion of hair cells vary markedly from species to species. Tuning in the caudal extension is organized tonotopically and evidently involves the tectorium. In terms of the proportion of amphibian-papillar hair cells in the caudal extension, we report more diversity among 8 species of a single genus (Eleutherodactylus) on a single island (Puerto Rico) than has been found so far among all of the (more than 50) other modern anurans examined for this feature from around the world. These 8 Puerto Rican species have overlapping habitat and conspicuous diversity in the male advertisement call. For 7 of the 8 species, we report that the call has transient spectral components in the frequency range of the amphibian papilla, and that the proportion of caudal extension hair cells and the frequency distribution of those components are correlated. Thus one might conclude that the selective pressures that led to diversity of calls among the 8 species also led to diversity in form of the amphibian papilla.Abbreviations AP amphibian papilla - BEF best excitatory frequency - PR Puerto Rican - SEM scanning electron microscope - SVL snout-vent length - TC tectorial corner - TM tectorial membrane