Accuracy of the EcoRI restriction endonuclease: binding and cleavage studies with oligodeoxynucleotide substrates containing degenerate recognition sequences

We have synthesized a series of 18 nonpalindromic oligodeoxynucleotides that carry all possible base changes within the recognition sequence of EcoRI. These single strands can be combined with their complementary single strands to obtain all possible EcoRI sequences (left), or they can be combined with a single strand containing the canonical sequence to obtain double strands with all possible mismatches within the recognition sequence (right): (sequence; see text) The rate of phosphodiester bond cleavage of these oligodeoxynucleotides by EcoRI was determined in single-turnover experiments under normal buffer conditions in order to find out to what extent the canonical recognition site can be distorted and yet serve as a substrate for EcoRI. Our results show that oligodeoxynucleotides containing mismatch base pairs are in general more readily attacked by EcoRI than oligodeoxynucleotides containing EcoRI sites and that the rates of cleavage of the two complementary strands of degenerate oligodeoxynucleotides are quite different. We have also determined the affinities of these oligodeoxynucleotides to EcoRI. They are higher for oligodeoxynucleotides carrying a mismatch within the EcoRI recognition site than for oligodeoxynucleotides containing an EcoRI site but otherwise do not correlate with the rate with which these oligodeoxynucleotides are cleaved by EcoRI. Our results allow details to be given for the probability of EcoRI making mistakes in cleaving DNA not only in its recognition sequence but also in sequences closely related to it. Due to the fact that the rates of cleavage in the two strands of a degenerate sequence generally are widely different, these mistakes are most likely not occurring in vivo, since nicked intermediates can be repaired by DNA ligase.     

Facilitated diffusion during catalysis by EcoRI endonuclease. Nonspecific interactions in EcoRI catalysis

The potential for processive EcoRI endonuclease hydrolysis has been examined on several DNA substrates containing two EcoRI sites which were embedded in identical sequence environments. With a 388-base pair circular DNA, in which the two recognition sites are separated by 51 base pairs (shorter distance) or 337 base pairs (longer distance), 77 and 34% of all events involved processive hydrolysis at ionic strengths of 0.059 and 0.13, respectively. However, the frequency of processive action on linear substrates, in which the two sites were separated by 51 base pairs, was only 42 and 17% at these ionic strengths, values half those observed with the circular DNA. Processive action was not detectable on circular or linear substrates at an ionic strength of 0.23. These findings indicate that DNA search by the endonuclease occurs by facilitated diffusion, a mechanism in which the protein locates and leaves its recognition sequence by interacting with nonspecific DNA sites. We suggest that processivity on linear substrates is limited to values half that for small circles due to partitioning of the enzyme between the two products generated by cleavage of a linear molecule. Given such topological effects, measured processivity values imply that the endonuclease can diffuse within a DNA domain to locate and recognize an EcoRI site 50 to 300 base pairs distant from an initial binding site, with minimum search efficiencies being 80 and 30% at ionic strengths of 0.059 and 0.13, respectively. The high efficiency of processive action indicates that a positionally correlated mode of search plays a major role in facilitated diffusion in this system under such conditions. Also consistent with this view was the identification of a striking position effect when two closely spaced EcoRI sites were asymmetrically positioned near the end of a linear DNA. The endonuclease displays a substantial preference for the more centrally located recognition sequence. This preference does not reflect differential sensitivity of the two sites to cleavage per se, but can be simply explained by preferential entry of the enzyme via the larger nonspecific target available to the more centrally positioned recognition sequence. These conclusions differ from those of a previous qualitative analysis of endonuclease processivity over short distances (Langowski, J., Alves, J., Pingoud, A., and Maass, G. (1983) Nucleic Acids Res. 11, 501-513).     

Fluorescence stopped-flow kinetics of the cleavage of synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides by the EcoRI restriction endonuclease

We have investigated in fluorescence stopped-flow and temperature-jump experiments the EcoRI-catalyzed cleavage of synthetic palindromic tridecadeoxynucleotides which contain the EcoRI site but differ in the flanking sequences. The overall reaction can be resolved in several reactions which were analyzed by a nonlinear least-squares fitting procedure on the experimental data. The result of this analysis is a minimal scheme that describes the overall reaction in terms of the rate constants of the individual reactions. According to this scheme EcoRI and the tridecadeoxynucleotide substrates associate in the presence of Mg2+ in a nearly diffusion-controlled process. This is followed by a reaction which is or includes the cleavage of the first phosphodiester bond. There is no indication for a time-resolved conformational transition prior to catalysis. After cleavage of the first strand, dissociation of the nicked double strand can occur, which then rearranges to the original palindromic double-stranded substrate and is bound again by the enzyme. Alternatively, the nicked double strand can be cleaved in the second strand. This reaction is followed by product release from the enzyme. The magnitude of the individual rate constants depends on the substrate used; the differences explain the preference of EcoRI for substrates that contain AT as compared to GC base pairs next to the recognition site.     

The activity of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease is influenced by flanking DNA sequences both inside and outside the DNA-protein complex.

The EcoRV restriction endonuclease cleaves DNA not only at its recognition sequence but also at most other sequences that differ from the recognition site by one base pair. Compared to the reaction at the recognition site, the reactions at noncognate sites are slow but 1 out of the 12 noncognate sites on the plasmid pAT153 is cleaved more than 50 times faster than any other. The increase in the reaction rate at the preferred noncognate site, relative to other sites, was caused by the DNA sequences in the 4 base pairs from either side of the site. For enhanced activity by EcoRV, particular bases were needed immediately adjacent to the site, inside the DNA-protein complex. At these loci, the protein interacts with the phosphate groups in the DNA and the flanking sequence may control the activity of the enzyme by determining the conformation of the DNA, thus aligning the phosphate contacts. But the preferential cleavage also depended on sequences further away from the site, at loci outside the complex. At external positions, beyond the reach of the protein, the EcoRV enzyme required flanking sequences that give rise to flexibility in DNA conformation. These may facilitate the distortion of the DNA required for catalysis by EcoRV.     

Interaction of EcoRII restriction and modification enzymes with synthetic DNA fragments. V. Study of single-strand cleavages.

Concatemer DNA duplexes which contain at the EcoRII restriction endonuclease cleavage sites (formula; see text) phosphodiester, phosphoamide or pyrophosphate internucleotide bonds have been synthesized. It has been shown that this enzyme did not cleave the substrate at phosphoamide bond. EcoRII endonuclease catalyzes single-strand cleavages both in dA- and dT-containing strands of the recognition site if the cleavage of the other strand has been blocked by modification of scissile bond or if the other strand has been cleaved. This enzyme interacts with both strands of the DNA recognition site, each of them being cleaved independently on the cleavage of another one. Nucleotide sequences flanking the EcoRII site on both sides are necessary for effective cleavage of the substrate.     

The highly homologous isoschizomers RsrI endonuclease and EcoRI endonuclease do not recognize their target sequence identically

Using a series of decadeoxyribonucleotides containing base analogues as substrates we measured the steady-state kinetic parameters for the reaction catalyzed by RsrI endonuclease and compared the results to those with its isoschizomer EcoRI. The kinetics of RsrI cleavage are affected by each substitution, with the effects being generally more deleterious than with EcoRI, as shown by the greater reduction in the specificity constant kcat/KM. The magnitudes of the effects of several substitutions are consistent with the formation of direct enzyme-nucleobase contacts at the indicated positions. With substrates containing 2-amino-purine or 2,6-diaminopurine at the central adenine or uracil at the outermost thymine in the recognition sequence, cleavage by RsrI was very slow, less than one-tenth the rate of the corresponding EcoRI-catalyzed reaction. The lower tolerance of RsrI endonuclease for functional group changes in its recognition site may reflect differences in the mechanisms of DNA recognition by the two enzymes. Although RsrI and EcoRI endonucleases bind with similar affinities to specific and nonspecific DNA sequences and appear to introduce similar structural distortions in DNA upon binding, the use of substrate analogues reveals significant differences at the level of catalysis in the mechanisms by which these two endonucleases recognize the duplex sequence GAATTC.     

Interaction of EcoRII restriction and modification enzymes with synthetic DNA fragments. IX. Cleavage of substrates with point modifications in the recognition site and flanking sequences

Ability of the EcoRII restriction endonuclease to cleave 14-base-pair DNA duplexes with nucleotide substitutions in the recognition site CCA/TGG and in the adjacent base pair has been studied. Modifications leading to a local change in the substrate conformation (rU residue in and outside the recognition site, A.A- or A.C-pairs in the flanking sequence) reduce the rate of hydrolysis, the effect being maximal when the modified base pair is outside the recognition site. No digestion occurs when the internal dC-residue of the recognition site is 5-methylated in one or both strands. Replacement of dT residue in the EcoRII recognition site by dfl5U residue results in a dramatic inhibition of hydrolysis. Km and kcat for the cleavage of 14-base-pair DNA duplex have been determined. The cleavage rate of the dT-containing strand of the recognition site in 1.5 fold higher comparing with the dA-containing strand. The cleavage of both strands of the substrate by EcoRII endonuclease is confirmed to proceed in one enzyme-substrate complex.     

Base mutation analysis of topoisomerase II-idarubicin-DNA ternary complex formation. Evidence for enzyme subunit cooperativity in DNA cleavage.

Antitumor drugs, such as anthracyclines, interfere with mammalian DNA topoisomerase II by forming a ternary complex, DNA-drug-enzyme, in which DNA strands are cleaved and covalently linked to the enzyme. In this work, a synthetic 36-bp DNA oligomer derived from SV40 and mutated variants were used to determine the effects of base mutations on DNA cleavage levels produced by murine topoisomerase II with and without idarubicin. Although site competition could affect cleavage levels, mutation effects were rather similar among several cleavage sites. The major sequence determinants of topoisomerase II DNA cleavage without drugs are up to five base pairs apart from the strand cut, suggesting that DNA protein contacts involving these bases are particularly critical for DNA site recognition. Cleavage sites with adenines at positions -1 were detected without idarubicin only under conditions favouring enzyme binding to DNA, showing that these sites are low affinity sites for topoisomerase II DNA cleavage and/or binding. Moreover, the results indicated that the sequence 5'-(A)TA/(A)-3' (the slash indicates the cleaved bond, parenthesis indicate conditioned preference) from -3 to +1 positions constitutes the complete base sequence preferred by anthracyclines. An important finding was that mutations that improve the fit to the above consensus on one strand can also increase cleavage on the opposite strand, suggesting that a drug molecule may effectively interact with one enzyme subunit only and trap the whole dimeric enzyme. These findings documented that DNA recognition by topoisomerase II may occur at one or the other strand, and not necessarily at both of them, and that the two subunits can act cooperatively to cleave a double helix.     

Importance of phosphate contacts for sequence recognition by EcoRI restriction enzyme

We have studied the importance of charge and hydrogen-bonding potential of the phosphodiester backbone for binding and cleavage by EcoRI restriction endonuclease. We used 12-mer oligodeoxynucleotide substrates with single substitutions of phosphates by chiral methylphosphonates at each position of the recognition sequence -pGpApApTpTpCp-. Binding was moderately reduced between 4- and 400-fold more or less equally for the R(P) and S(P)-analogues mainly caused by missing charge interaction. The range of cleavage effects was much wider. Four substrates were not cleaved at all. At both flanking positions and in the purine half of the sequence up to the central position, cleavage was more impaired than binding and differences between R(P) and S(P) diastereomeres were more pronounced. These effects are easily interpreted by direct phosphate contacts seen in the crystal structure. For the effects of substitutions in the pyrimidine half of the recognition sequence, more indirect effects have to be discussed.     

An asymmetric complex of restriction endonuclease MspI on its palindromic DNA recognition site

Most well-known restriction endonucleases recognize palindromic DNA sequences and are classified as Type IIP. Due to the recognition and cleavage symmetry, Type IIP enzymes are usually found to act as homodimers in forming 2-fold symmetric enzyme-DNA complexes. Here we report an asymmetric complex of the Type IIP restriction enzyme MspI in complex with its cognate recognition sequence. Unlike any other Type IIP enzyme reported to date, an MspI monomer and not a dimer binds to a palindromic DNA sequence. The enzyme makes specific contacts with all 4 base pairs in the recognition sequence, by six direct and five water-mediated hydrogen bonds and numerous van der Waal contacts. This MspI-DNA structure represents the first example of asymmetric recognition of a palindromic DNA sequence by two different structural motifs in one polypeptide. A few possible pathways are discussed for MspI to cut both strands of DNA, either as a monomer or dimer.     

Does the specific recognition of DNA by the restriction endonuclease EcoRI involve a linear diffusion step? Investigation of the processivity of the EcoRI endonuclease.

The time course of the EcoRI endonuclease catalysed cleavage of three substrates, two plasmid DNAs and one oligonucleotide, each with two EcoRI sites, was measured. The two plasmid DNAs with the EcoRI sites 318 and 96 base pairs apart are cut in a distributive fashion, while the oligonucleotide with the EcoRI sites 8 base pairs apart is cut in a partially processive manner. It is concluded that a linear diffusion of the EcoRI endonuclease on its substrate across long stretches of DNA is not likely to be operative during the recognition process. Microscopic dissociation-reassociation processes, however, increase the probability of the enzyme to attack further sites located in the immediate vicinity of a given site.     

Peculiarities of recognition of CCA/TGG sequences in DNA by restriction endonucleases MvaI and EcoRII.

To elucidate the mechanism of action of restriction endonucleases MvaI and EcoRII a study was made of their interaction with a set of synthetic substrates in which the heterocyclic bases or the sugar-phosphate backbone had been modified; individual nucleotide residues had been removed or replaced with hydrocarbon bridges, and mismatched base pairs had been introduced. The groups of atoms in the heterocyclic bases and the phosphates in the recognition site that produce the most significant influence on the functioning of endonucleases MvaI and EcoRII were discerned. Profound differences were found in the functioning of the MvaI and EcoRII neoschizomers. The catalytic activity of EcoRII is significantly affected by any alteration in the recognition site structure and conformation, with a modification in one strand of the substrate causing the same decrease in the hydrolysis rate of both strands. Endonuclease MvaI is tolerant to a number of structural abnormalities; the latter sometimes affect only hydrolysis of one strand of the recognition site. The enzyme can preferentially cleave one of the substrate strands. Mismatched base pairs retard and sometimes block the hydrolysis. The effect depends on the particular enzyme, mismatch and its location.     

Molecular recognition of B-DNA by Hoechst 33258.

The binding sites of Hoechst 33258, netropsin and distamycin on three DNA restriction fragments from plasmid pBR322 were compared by footprinting with methidiumpropyl-EDTA X Fe(II) [MPE X Fe(II)]. Hoechst, netropsin and distamycin share common binding sites that are five +/- one bp in size and rich in A X T DNA base pairs. The five base pair protection patterns for Hoechst may result from a central three base pair recognition site bound by two bisbenzimidazole NHs forming a bridge on the floor of the minor groove between adjacent adenine N3 and thymine O2 atoms on opposite helix strands. Hydrophobic interaction of the flanking phenol and N-methylpiperazine rings would afford a steric blockade of one additional base pair on each side.     

Many type IIs restriction endonucleases interact with two recognition sites before cleaving DNA.

Type IIs restriction endonucleases recognize asymmetric DNA sequences and cleave both DNA strands at fixed positions, typically several base pairs away from the recognition site. These enzymes are generally monomers that transiently associate to form dimers to cleave both strands. Their reactions could involve bridging interactions between two copies of their recognition sequence. To examine this possibility, several type IIs enzymes were tested against substrates with either one or two target sites. Some of the enzymes cleaved the DNA with two target sites at the same rate as that with one site, but most cut their two-site substrate more rapidly than the one-site DNA. In some cases, the two sites were cut sequentially, at rates that were equal to each other but that exceeded the rate on the one-site DNA. In another case, the DNA with two sites was cleaved rapidly at one site, but the residual site was cleaved at a much slower rate. In a further example, the two sites were cleaved concertedly to give directly the final products cut at both sites. Many type IIs enzymes thus interact with two copies of their recognition sequence before cleaving DNA, although via several different mechanisms.     

Structure of PvuII endonuclease with cognate DNA.

We have determined the structure of PvuII endonuclease complexed with cognate DNA by X-ray crystallography. The DNA substrate is bound with a single homodimeric protein, each subunit of which reveals three structural regions. The catalytic region strongly resembles structures of other restriction endonucleases, even though these regions have dissimilar primary sequences. Comparison of the active site with those of EcoRV and EcoRI endonucleases reveals a conserved triplet sequence close to the reactive phosphodiester group and a conserved acidic pair that may represent the ligands for the catalytic cofactor Mg2+. The DNA duplex is not significantly bent and maintains a B-DNA-like conformation. The subunit interface region of the homodimeric protein consists of a pseudo-three-helix bundle. Direct contacts between the protein and the base pairs of the PvuII recognition site occur exclusively in the major groove through two antiparallel beta strands from the sequence recognition region of the protein. Water-mediated contacts are made in the minor grooves to central bases of the site. If restriction enzymes do share a common ancestor, as has been proposed, their catalytic regions have been very strongly conserved, while their subunit interfaces and DNA sequence recognition regions have undergone remarkable structural variation.     

Recognition of the 5' leader of pre-tRNA substrates by the active site of ribonuclease P

The bacterial tRNA processing enzyme ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein composed of a approximately 400 nucleotide RNA and a smaller protein subunit. It has been established that RNase P RNA contacts the mature tRNA portion of pre-tRNA substrates, whereas RNase P protein interacts with the 5' leader sequence. However, specific interactions with substrate nucleotides flanking the cleavage site have not previously been defined. Here we provide evidence for an interaction between a conserved adenosine, A248 in the Escherichia coli ribozyme, and N(-1), the substrate nucleotide immediately 5' of the cleavage site. Specifically, mutations at A248 result in miscleavage of substrates containing a 2' deoxy modification at N(-1). Compensatory mutations at N(-1) restore correct cleavage in both the RNA-alone and holoenzyme reactions, and also rescue defects in binding thermodynamics caused by A248 mutation. Analysis of pre-tRNA leader sequences in Bacteria and Archaea reveals a conserved preference for U at N(-1), suggesting that an interaction between A248 and N(-1) is common among RNase P enzymes. These results provide the first direct evidence for RNase P RNA interactions with the substrate cleavage site, and show that RNA and protein cooperate in leader sequence recognition.     

A novel bipartite mode of binding of M. smegmatis topoisomerase I to its recognition sequence

We have investigated interaction of Mycobacterium smegmatis topoisomerase I at its specific recognition sequence. DNase I footprinting demonstrates a large region of protection on both the scissile and non-scissile strands of DNA. Methylation protection and interference analyses reveal base-specific contacts within the recognition sequence. Missing contact analyses reveal additional interactions with the residues in both single and double-stranded DNA, and hence underline the role for the functional groups associated with those bases. These interactions are supplemented by phosphate contacts in the scissile strand. Conformation specific probes reveal protein-induced structural distortion of the DNA helix at the T-A-T-A sequence 11 bp upstream to the recognition sequence. Based on these footprinting analyses that define parameters of topoisomerase I-DNA interactions, a model of topoisomerase I binding to its substrate is presented. Within the large protected region of 30 bp, the enzyme makes direct contact at two locations in the scissile strand, one around the cleavage site and the other 8-12 bases upstream. Thus the enzyme makes asymmetric recognition of DNA and could carry out DNA relaxation by either of the two proposed mechanisms: enzyme bridged and restricted rotation.     

Interaction of EcoRII restriction and modification enzymes with synthetic DNA fragments. X. Hydrolysis of substrates with structural abnormalities

Interaction of the EcoRII restriction endonuclease with a set of 30-membered substrates having structural anomalies in the recognition site (decreases CCT/AGG) and in adjacent sequences has been studied. A nick in the centre of the EcoRII recognition site between dC and dA residues slows down hydrolysis of the nonmodified strand, whereas the modified one is not cleaved. Removal of the phosphate group from the nick in this substrate does not alter the rate of the cleavage. The absence of one of the phosphate groups in the flanking sequence at a two-base-pair "distance" from the recognition site slows down the enzymatic hydrolysis. Removal of dA or dT out of the EcoRII recognition site blocks the enzymatic reaction. It appears that EcoRII does not interact with the phosphate group between dC and dA residues in the recognition site. Suggestions are made concerning possible contacts of the EcoRII restriction endonuclease with dA- and dT-residues of the recognition site and with the sugar-phosphate backbone of the adjacent nucleotide sequences.     

Oligodeoxynucleotide-directed photo-induced cross-linking of HIV proviral DNA via triple-helix formation.

The HIV proviral genome contains two copies of a 16 bp homopurine.homopyrimidine sequence which overlaps the recognition and cleavage site of the Dra I restriction enzyme. Psoralen was attached to the 16-mer homopyrimidine oligonucleotide, d5'(TTTTCT-TTTCCCCCCT)3', which forms a triple helix with this HIV proviral sequence. Two plasmids, containing part of the HIV proviral DNA, with either one (pLTR) or two (pBT1) copies of the 16-bp homopurine.homopyrimidine sequence and either 4 or 14 Dra I cleavage sites, respectively, were used as substrates for the psoralen-oligonucleotide conjugate. Following UV irradiation the two strands of the DNA targeted sequence were cross-linked at the triplex-duplex junction. The psoralen-oligonucleotide conjugate selectively inhibited Dra I enzymatic cleavage at sites overlapping the two triple helix-forming sequences. A secondary triplex-forming site of 8 contiguous base pairs was observed on the pBT1 plasmid when binding of the 16 base-long oligonucleotide was allowed to take place at high oligonucleotide concentrations. Replacement of a stretch of six cytosines in the 16-mer oligomer by a stretch of six guanines increased binding to the primary sites and abolished binding to the secondary site under physiological conditions. These results demonstrate that oligonucleotides can be designed to selectively recognize and modify specific sequences in HIV proviral DNA.     

Nonidentical DNA-binding sites of endonuclease NaeI recognize different families of sequences flanking the recognition site.

NaeI endonuclease uses a two-site binding mechanism to cleave substrate DNA: reaction-rate studies imply that occupancy of the second DNA site causes an allosteric change in the protein that enables DNA cleavage at the first site [Conrad, M., & Topal, M. D. (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 86, 9707-9711]. Measurements of relative binding affinities for 14-base-pair DNA fragments containing the NaeI recognition sequence GCCGGC and various flanking sequences showed that the two DNA-binding sites are not identical. G.C-rich flanking sequences were preferred by the activator binding site, whereas A.T-rich flanking sequences were preferred by the substrate binding site: GGGTGCCGGCAGGG was preferred 8-fold more by the activator site but 14-fold less by the substrate site than TTTCGCCGGCGTTT. Substitution of pyrimidine or 7-deazapurine for purine immediately 3' to GCCGGC reduced DNA affinity for only the activator site by up to 26-fold, implying that the activator DNA-binding site requires N-7 base contacts immediately flanking GCCGGC. The implications of nonidentical DNA-binding sites, one of which binds a specific DNA site to allosterically activate the other, are discussed.