In vivo competition between iron and manganese for occupancy of the active site region of the manganese-superoxide dismutase of Escherichia coli

Three forms of the dimeric manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) were isolated from aerobically grown Escherichia coli which contained 2 Mn, 1 Mn and 1 Fe, or 2 Fe, respectively. These are designated Mn2-MnSOD, Mn,Fe-MnSOD, and Fe2-MnSOD. Substitution of iron in place of manganese, eliminated catalytic activity, decreased the isoelectric point, and increased the native electrophoretic anodic mobility, although circular dichroism, high performance liquid chromatography gel exclusion chromatography, and sedimentation equilibrium revealed no gross changes in conformation. Moreover, replacement of iron by manganese restored enzymatic activity. Fe2-MnSOD and the iron-superoxide (FeSOD) of E. coli exhibit distinct optical absorption spectra. These data indicate that the active site environments of E. coli MnSOD and FeSOD must differ. They also indicate that competition between iron and manganese for nascent MnSOD polypeptide chains occurs in vivo, and copurification of these variably substituted MnSODs can explain the substoichiometric manganese contents and the variable specific activities which have been reported for this enzyme.     

In Vivo Metal Substitution in Bacteroides Fragilis Superoxide Dismutase

Bacteroides fragilis. an obligate anaerobe, synthesizes an azide-inhibitable iron-containing superoxide dismutase when grown in complex medium. Cells grown anaerobically in complex media containing dcsferrioxamine (Desferal^TM, Ciba-Geigy) and graded concentrations of Mn synthesize the azide-resistant manganese-containing SOD. The fraction of MnSOD activity in dialyzed cell extracts increased prograsively as the Mn concentration in the medium increased. The fraction of MnSOD activity also increased in extracts of cells grown in the medium with I mM Mn but with graded concentrations of desferrioxamine (0–10 micromolar). The SOD activity in the cells grown under the various conditions varied but not in a causal relationship with either Mn or desferrioxamine concentration. Electrophoresis reveaicd that the SOD activity in cells grown in the absence or presence of I mM Mn migrated with the same relative mobility and exhibited identical activity patterns when examined separately or as a mixture. These data are consistent with substitution of Mn for Fe in the B. fragilis apoprotein under anaerobic conditions and support the model of a single protein binding either Fe or Mn.     

Novel insights into the basis for Escherichia coli superoxide dismutase's metal ion specificity from Mn-substituted FeSOD and its very high E(m).

Fe and Mn are both entrained to the same chemical reaction in apparently superimposable superoxide dismutase (SOD) proteins. However, neither Fe-substituted MnSOD nor Mn-substituted FeSOD is active. We have proposed that the two SOD proteins must apply very different redox tuning to their respective metal ions and that tuning appropriate for one metal ion results in a reduction potential (E(m)) for the other metal ion that is either too low (Fe) or too high (Mn) [Vance and Miller (1998) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 461-467]. We have demonstrated that this is true for Fe-substituted MnSOD from Escherichia coli and that this metal ion-protein combination retains the ability to reduce but not oxidize superoxide. We now demonstrate that the corollary is also true: Mn-substituted FeSOD [Mn(Fe)SOD] has a very high E(m). Specifically, we have measured the E(m) of E. coli MnSOD to be 290 mV vs NHE. We have generated Mn(Fe)SOD and find that Mn is bound in an environment similar to that of the native (Mn)SOD protein. However, the E(m) is greater than 960 mV vs NHE and much higher than MnSOD's E(m) of 290 mV. We propose that the different tuning stems from different hydrogen bonding between the proteins and a molecule of solvent that is coordinated to the metal ion in both cases. Because a proton is taken up by SOD upon reduction, the protein can exert very strong control over the E(m), by modulating the degree to which coordinated solvent is protonated, in both oxidation states. Thus, coordinated solvent molecules may have widespread significance as "adapters" by which proteins can control the reactivity of bound metal ions.     

Induction of superoxide dismutases in Escherichia coli by manganese and iron.

Growth of Escherichia coli B in simple media enriched with Mn(II) resulted in the elevation of the manganese-containing superoxide dismutase, whereas growth in such medium enriched with iron caused increased content of the iron-containing superoxide dismutase. Enrichment of the medium with Co(II), Cu(II), Mo(VI), Zn(II), or Ni(II) had no effect. The inductions of superoxide dismutase by Mn(II) or by Fe(II) were dioxygen dependent, but these metals did not affect the CN- -resistant respiration of E. coli B and did not influence the increase in the CN- -resistant respiration caused by paraquat. Mn(II) and paraquat acted synergistically in elevating the superoxide dismutase content, and Mn(II) reduced the growth inhibition imposed by paraquat, E. coli grown in the complex 3% Trypticase soy broth (BBL Microbiology Systems)-0.5% yeast extract-0.2% glucose medium contained more superoxide dismutase than did cells grown in the simple media and were less responsive to enrichment of the medium with Mn(II) or Fe(II). Nevertheless, in the presence of paraquat, inductions of superoxide dismutase by these metals could be seen even in the Trypticase-yeast extract-glucose medium. On the basis of these observations we propose that the apo-superoxide dismutases may act as autogenous repressors and that Mn(II) and Fe(II) increase the cell content of the corresponding enzymes by speeding the conversion of the apo- to the holoenzymes.     

Functional differences between manganese and iron superoxide dismutases in Escherichia coli K-12.

Superoxide dismutases are enzymes that defend against oxidative stress through decomposition of superoxide radical. Escherichia coli contains two highly homologous superoxide dismutases, one containing manganese (MnSOD) and the other iron (FeSOD). Although E. coli Mn and FeSOD catalyze the dismutation of superoxide with comparable rate constants, it is not known if they are physiologically equivalent in their protection of cellular targets from oxyradical damage. To address this issue, isogenic strains of E. coli containing either Mn or FeSOD encoded on a plasmid and under the control of tac promoter were constructed. SOD specific activity in the Mn and FeSOD strains could be controlled by the concentration of isopropyl beta-thiogalactoside in the medium. The tolerance of these strains to oxidative stress was compared at equal Mn and FeSOD specific activities. Our results indicate that E. coli Mn and FeSOD are not functionally equivalent. The MnSOD is more effective than FeSOD in preventing damage to DNA, while the FeSOD appears to be more effective in protecting a cytoplasmic superoxide-sensitive enzyme. These data are the first demonstration that Mn and FeSOD are adapted to different antioxidant roles in E. coli.     

Inductions of superoxide dismutases in Escherichia coli under anaerobic conditions. Accumulation of an inactive form of the manganese enzyme

Escherichia coli growing anaerobically respond to NO3- with a 3-fold induction of the iron-containing superoxide dismutase. Mutants lacking nitrate reductase do not show this response. Anaerobically grown cells also contain an inactive form of the manganese-containing superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) which can be activated by addition of Mn(II) salts in the presence of acidic guanidinium chloride, followed by dialysis against neutral buffer. Direct addition of Mn(II) to a neutral solution of the inactive MnSOD does not impart activity. This inactive MnSOD thus behaves as would the apoenzyme or the enzyme bearing a metal other than Mn(II) at its active sites. Terminal electron acceptors, such as NO3- or trimethylamine N-oxide, increase the amount of inactive MnSOD produced by anaerobic E. coli. Paraquat, which is itself ineffective in this regard, markedly augments the effect of these terminal electron acceptors. It appears that flow of electrons to sinks such as NO3- or trimethylamine N-oxide, facilitated by paraquat, is sufficient to elicit biosynthesis of the MnSOD protein and that O2- is not needed for this process. Yet, oxygenation and concomitant O2- production do appear important for the insertion of manganese into the growing MnSOD polypeptide, possibly because O-2 oxidizes Mn(II) to Mn(III), and the latter is the valence state most effective in combining with the apoenzyme.     

Isolation of superoxide dismutase mutants in Escherichia coli: is superoxide dismutase necessary for aerobic life?

Mu transposons carrying the chloramphenicol resistance marker have been inserted into the cloned Escherichia coli genes sodA and sodB coding for manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) and iron superoxide dismutase (FeSOD) respectively, creating mutations and gene fusions. The mutated sodA or sodB genes were introduced into the bacterial chromosome by allelic exchange. The resulting mutants were shown to lack the corresponding SOD by activity measurements and immunoblot analysis. Aerobically, in rich medium, the absence of FeSOD or MnSOD had no major effect on growth or sensitivity to the superoxide generator, paraquat. In minimal medium aerobic growth was not affected, but the sensitivity to paraquat was increased, especially in the sodA mutant. A sodA sodB double mutant completely devoid of SOD was also obtained. It was able to grow aerobically in rich medium, its catalase level was unaffected and it was highly sensitive to paraquat and hydrogen peroxide; the double mutant was unable to grow aerobically on minimal glucose medium. Growth could be restored by removing oxygen, by providing an SOD-overproducing plasmid or by supplementing the medium with the 20 amino acids. It is concluded that the total absence of SOD in E. coli creates a conditional sensitivity to oxygen.     

Superoxide dismutases: ancient enzymes and new insights

Superoxide dismutases (SODs) catalyze the de toxification of superoxide. SODs therefore acquired great importance as O(2) became prevalent following the evolution of oxygenic photosynthesis. Thus the three forms of SOD provide intriguing insights into the evolution of the organisms and organelles that carry them today. Although ancient organisms employed Fe-dependent SODs, oxidation of the environment made Fe less bio-available, and more dangerous. Indeed, modern lineages make greater use of homologous Mn-dependent SODs. Our studies on the Fe-substituted MnSOD of Escherichia coli, as well as redox tuning in the FeSOD of E. coli shed light on how evolution accommodated differences between Fe and Mn that would affect SOD performance, in SOD proteins whose activity is specific to one or other metal ion.     

Increased Tolerance to Mn Deficiency in Transgenic Tobacco Overproducing Superoxide Dismutase

The effect of Mn deficiency on plant growth and activities ofsuperoxide dismutase (SOD) was studied in hydroponically-grownseedlings of transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) engineeredto overexpress FeSOD in chloroplasts or MnSOD in chloroplastsor mitochondria. In comparison to the non-transgenic parentalline, the activity of MnSOD in the lines overproducing MnSODwas 1.6-fold greater, and the activity of FeSOD in the FeSOD-overproducinglines was 3.2-fold greater, regardless of the Mn treatment (deficientor sufficient). The MnSOD activities decreased due to Mn deficiency,while activities of FeSOD and Cu/ZnSOD remained unaffected 25d after transplanting (DAT). With an increased duration of theMn deficiency stress (45 DAT), FeSOD activity decreased, andthat of MnSOD continued to decrease, while Cu/ZnSOD activitysimultaneously increased. Under Mn sufficiency, non-transgenicparental plants had greater shoot biomass than the transgenics;however, when subjected to Mn deficiency stress, non-transgenicparents suffered a proportionally greater growth reduction thantransgenic lines. Thus, overproduction of MnSOD in chloroplastsmay provide protection from oxidative stress caused by Mn deficiency.Copyright 1999 Annals of Botany Company Manganese deficiency, Nicotiana tabacum, superoxide dismutase (SOD), transgenic tobacco.     

Characterization of the O2-induced manganese-containing superoxide dismutase from Bacteroides fragilis

A manganese-containing superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) has been isolated from extracts of O2-induced Bacteroides fragilis. The enzyme, Mr 43,000, was a dimer composed of noncovalently associated subunits of equal size. A preparation whose specific activity was 1760 U/mg had 1.1 g-atoms Mn, 0.3 g-atoms Fe, and 0.2 g-atoms Zn per mol dimer. Exposing the enzyme to 5 M guanidinium chloride, 20 mM 8-hydroxyquinoline abolished enzymatic activity. Dialysis of the denatured apoprotein in buffer containing either Fe (NH4)2(SO4)2 or MnCl2 restored O2-. scavenging activity. The iron-reconstituted enzyme was inhibited 89% by 2 mM NaN3, similar to other Fe-containing superoxide dismutases. The Mn-reconstituted and native MnSOD were inhibited approximately 50% by 20 mM NaN3. Addition of ZnSO4 to dialysis buffer containing either the iron or manganese salt inhibited restoration of enzymatic activity to the denatured apoprotein. MnSOD migrated as a single protein band coincident with a single superoxide dismutase activity band in 7.5 or 10% acrylamide gels. Isoelectric focusing resulted in a major isozymic form with pI 5.3 and a minor form at pI 5.0. Mixtures of the MnSOD and the iron-containing superoxide (FeSOD), isolated from anaerobically maintained B. fragilis [E. M. Gregory and C. H. Dapper (1983) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 220, 293-300], migrated as a single band on acrylamide gels and isoelectrically focused to a major protein band (pI 5.3) and a minor band at pI 5.0. The amino acid composition of MnSOD was virtually identical to that of the FeSOD. The data are consistent with synthesis of a single superoxide dismutase apoprotein capable of accepting either Mn or Fe to form the holoenzyme.     

Isolation of paraquat-resistant mutants of Escherichia coli: lack of correlation between resistance and the activity of superoxide dismutase

Abstract Paraquat-resistant Escherichia coli mutants were isolated. The mutants were 10- to 50-fold more resistant to paraquat than the wild type. The wild type was more responsive to the presence of paraquat by inducing higher levels of the manganese-containing superoxide dismutase (MnSOD). Thus, in minimal medium, 0.1 mM paraquat caused a 5-fold increase in MnSOD in the wild type while it had no effect on the level of MnSOD in the mutants. Yet, 50 mM paraquat exerted a dramatic induction of SOD in the mutant strains when grown in trypticase soy yeast extract (TSY) medium. In TSY medium, catalase was not significantly affected by paraquat in all the strains tested. Resistance to paraquat in these mutant strains is, therefore, unrelated to their capacity to detoxify superoxide or hydrogen peroxide.     

Thermostability of manganese- and iron-superoxide dismutases from Escherichia coli is determined by the characteristic position of a glutamine residue.

The structurally homologous mononuclear iron and manganese superoxide dismutases (FeSOD and MnSOD, respectively) contain a highly conserved glutamine residue in the active site which projects toward the active-site metal centre and participates in an extensive hydrogen bonding network. The position of this residue is different for each SOD isoenzyme (Q69 in FeSOD and Q146 in MnSOD of Escherichia coli). Although site-directed mutant enzymes lacking this glutamine residue (FeSOD[Q69G] and MnSOD[Q146A]) demonstrated a higher degree of selectivity for their respective metal, they showed little or no activity compared with wild types. FeSOD double mutants (FeSOD[Q69G/A141Q]), which mimic the glutamine position in MnSOD, elicited 25% the activity of wild-type FeSOD while the activity of the corresponding MnSOD double mutant (MnSOD[G77Q/Q146A]) increased to 150% (relative to wild-type MnSOD). Both double mutants showed reduced selectivity toward their metal. Differences exhibited in the thermostability of SOD activity was most obvious in the mutants that contained two glutamine residues (FeSOD[A141Q] and MnSOD[G77Q]), where the MnSOD mutant was thermostable and the FeSOD mutant was thermolabile. Significantly, the MnSOD double mutant exhibited a thermal-inactivation profile similar to that of wild-type FeSOD while that of the FeSOD double mutant was similar to wild-type MnSOD. We conclude therefore that the position of this glutamine residue contributes to metal selectivity and is responsible for some of the different physicochemical properties of these SODs, and in particular their characteristic thermostability.     

Improved procedure for detection of superoxide dismutase isoforms in potato,Solanum tuberosum L.

Superoxide dismutase (SOD) in-gel activity assay with selective inhibitors (KCN and H₂O₂) is one of the most commonly used methods for identification of SOD isoform types, i.e., FeSOD, MnSOD or Cu/ZnSOD, and evaluation of oxidative stress response in plants. However, there are potential pitfalls that surround this assay, such as problem to detect isoforms with low activity, comigration of SOD isoforms or application of inappropriate inhibitor concentration. We propose an improved method based on the combination of in-gel analysis of SOD activity and native-PAGE immunoblotting for identification of isoforms and determination of SOD isoenzyme activity pattern in potato. Depending on cultivar and growing conditions, one MnSOD, 3 FeSOD and 5–6 Cu/ZnSOD isoforms were identified in potato leaves. The most important qualitative difference between ex vitro- and in vitro-grown plants was the presence of additional FeSOD and Cu/ZnSOD isoforms in plantlets grown in vitro. Compared with results of in-gel activity assay with selective inhibitors, new method allowed accurate identification of comigrating FeSOD and Cu/ZnSOD isoforms and two protein bands of ambiguous identities. Potato SODs were also characterized by SDS-PAGE immunoblotting and single MnSOD (23.6 kDa), three Cu/ZnSOD polypeptides (17.9, 17 and 16.3 kDa) and single FeSOD (25.1 kDa) polypeptide were detected in leaves of four examined cultivars. The difference in the number of FeSOD and Cu/ZnSOD isoforms/polypeptides between native-PAGE and SDS-PAGE immunoblots suggests that SOD proteins may have undergone post-translational modifications affecting protein mobility or existence of isoforms that differ from each other in total protein charge, but not in molecular weight.     

Superoxide dismutase activity in Pseudomonas putida affects utilization of sugars and growth on root surfaces

To investigate the role of superoxide dismutases (SOD) in root colonization and oxidative stress, mutants of Pseudomonas putida lacking manganese-superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) (sodA), iron-superoxide dismutase (FeSOD) (sodB), or both were generated. The sodA sodB mutant did not grow on components washed from bean root surfaces or glucose in minimal medium. The sodB and sodA sodB mutants were more sensitive than wild type to oxidative stress generated within the cell by paraquat treatment. In single inoculation of SOD mutants on bean, only the sodA sodB double mutant was impaired in growth on root surfaces. In mixed inoculations with wild type, populations of the sodA mutant were equal to those of the wild type, but levels of the sodB mutant and, to a great extent, the sodA sodB mutant, were reduced. Confocal microscopy of young bean roots inoculated with green fluorescent protein-tagged cells showed that wild type and SOD single mutants colonized well predominantly at the root tip but that the sodA sodB double mutant grew poorly at the tip. Our results indicate that FeSOD in P. putida is more important than MnSOD in aerobic metabolism and oxidative stress. Inhibition of key metabolic enzymes by increased levels of superoxide anion may cause the impaired growth of SOD mutants in vitro and in planta.     

Characterization of the iron superoxide dismutase gene of Azotobacter vinelandii: sodB may be essential for viability

Azotobacter vinelandii contains two superoxide dismutases (SODs), a cytoplasmic iron-containing enzyme (FeSOD), and a periplasmic copper/zinc-containing enzyme (CuZnSOD). In this study, the FeSOD was found to be constitutive, while the activity of CuZnSOD increased as the culture entered the stationary phase. Total SOD (units/mg protein) in stationary phase cells grown under nitrogen-fixing conditions was not significantly different from those grown under non-nitrogen-fixing conditions. The gene encoding FeSOD (sodB) was isolated from an A. vinelandii cosmid library. A 1-kb fragment containing the coding region and 400 base pairs of upstream sequence was cloned and sequenced. The nucleotide sequence and the deduced amino acid sequence had a high degree of homology with other bacterial FeSODs, particularly with P. aeruginosa. Attempts to construct a sodB mutant by recombination of a sodB::kan insertion mutation into the multicopy chromosome of A. vinelandii were unsuccessful even in the presence of SOD mimics or nutritional supplements. These results suggest that FeSOD may be essential for the growth and survival of A. vinelandii, and that the periplasmic CuZnSOD cannot replace the function of FeSOD.     

Anaerobic induction of ProMn-superoxide dismutase in Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli growing anaerobically respond to NO3- plus PQ2+ with a 20-30-fold induction of an inactive form of the manganese-containing superoxide dismutase (MnSOD). Mutants lacking a functional nitrate reductase fail to show this response. This inactive enzyme can be activated by addition of Mn(II) salts to cell extracts in the presence of acidic guanidinium chloride, followed by dialysis against neutral buffer. Direct addition of Mn(II) to cell extracts does not result in activation. However, addition of Mn(II) to purified apo-MnSOD results in partial activation. Inactive, reconstitutable MnSOD is induced 13-fold within 15 min of exposure to NO3- plus PQ2+. Western blot analysis revealed a 15-fold increase in immunoreactive MnSOD under these conditions, suggestive of de novo synthesis of this protein. A strain of E. coli bearing a multicopy plasmid carrying the MnSOD gene (sodA) overproduces inactive MnSOD 19-fold compared to the parent strain under anaerobic conditions. Strains of E. coli with an inactivating insertion in the sodA gene do not induce inactive, reconstitutable MnSOD in response to NO3- plus PQ2+ and lack the immunoreactive MnSOD band. These results, in toto, suggest that the inactive protein synthesized under anaerobic conditions in the presence of NO3- plus PQ2+, acting as an electron sink, is a product of the sodA gene and is devoid of activity due to occupation of the manganese site by another metal.     

Cloned prokaryotic iron superoxide dismutase protects yeast cells against oxidative stress depending on mitochondrial location

Superoxide dismutase (SOD) is considered to be the first line of defense against oxygen toxicity. It exists as a family of three metalloproteins with copper,zinc (Cu,ZnSOD), manganese (MnSOD), and iron (FeSOD) forms. In this work, we have targeted Escherichia coli FeSOD to the mitochondrial intermembrane space (IMS) of yeast cells deficient in mitochondrial MnSOD. Our results show that FeSOD in the IMS increases the growth rate of the cells growing in minimal medium in air but does not protect the MnSOD-deficient yeast cells when exposed to induced oxidative stress. Cloned FeSOD must be targeted to the mitochondrial matrix to protect the cells from both physiological and induced oxidative stress. This confirms that the superoxide radical is mainly generated on the matrix side of the inner mitochondrial membrane of yeast cells, without excluding its potential appearance in the mitochondrial IMS where its elimination by SOD is beneficial to the cells.     

Lucigenin chemiluminescence as a probe for measuring reactive oxygen species production in Escherichia coli

Addition of oxygen to whole cells of Escherichia coli suspended in the presence of the chemiluminescent probe bis-N-methylacridinium nitrate (lucigenin) resulted in a light emission increase of 200% of control. Addition of air to cells showed a chemiluminescent response far less than the response to oxygen. The redox cycling agents paraquat and menadione, which are known to increase intracellular production of O2- and H2O2, were also found to cause a measurable increase in lucigenin chemiluminescence in E. coli cells when added at concentrations of 1 and 0.1 mM, respectively. The oxygen-induced chemiluminescent response was not suppressed by extracellularly added superoxide dismutase or catalase. Further, the lucigenin-dependent chemiluminescent response of aerobically grown E. coli to oxygen was significantly greater than that of cells grown anaerobically. Heat-killed cells showed no increase in chemiluminescence on the addition of either oxygen, paraquat, or menadione. These results show that lucigenin may be used as a chemiluminescent probe to demonstrate continuous intracellular production of reactive oxygen metabolites in E. coli.