Comparison of variation in adaptive traits between wild-type and transgenic silver birch (Betula pendula) in a field trial

The use of genetic modification (GM) in tree breeding would require that GM trees are superior to currently used seed orchard seedlings in the target trait and equal in other traits. We compare the variation of silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) lines carrying a sugar beet chitinase IV gene (chiIV) with the objective to improve fungal disease resistance to the variation of wild-type genotypes in disease resistance and other adaptive traits. The genetic variation in disease resistance was at the same level in transgenic (CV_g 0.9?C19.0%) and wild-type trees (CV_g 0?C19.7%), but the resistance characteristics of the most resistant wild-type genotype were usually equal or better than those of the best transgenic line. The broad-sense heritabilities varied from very low to moderate in disease resistance in both types. Broad-sense heritabilities in growth and leaf phenology-related traits were moderate and generally higher among the transgenic than the wild-type trees. The introduction of the sugar beet chiIV gene is likely to have fitness consequences in the form of lowered growth and quality characteristics of the transgenic lines without significant improvement in disease resistance compared with the natural variation of the same traits.     

Effects of sugar beet chitinase IV on root-associated fungal community of transgenic silver birch in a field trial

Heterogenous chitinases have been introduced in many plant species with the aim to increase the resistance of plants to fungal diseases. We studied the effects of the heterologous expression of sugar beet chitinase IV on the intensity of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) colonization and the structure of fungal communities in the field trial of 15 transgenic and 8 wild-type silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) genotypes. Fungal sequences were separated in denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and identified by sequencing the ITS1 region to reveal the operational taxonomic units. ECM colonization was less intense in 7 out of 15 transgenic lines than in the corresponding non-transgenic control plants, but the slight decrease in overall ECM colonization in transgenic lines could not be related to sugar beet chitinase IV expression or total endochitinase activity. One transgenic line showing fairly weak sugar beet chitinase IV expression without significantly increased total endochitinase activity differed significantly from the non-transgenic controls in the structure of fungal community. Five sequences belonging to three different fungal genera (Hebeloma, Inocybe, Laccaria) were indicative of wild-type genotypes, and one sequence (Lactarius) indicated one transgenic line. In cluster analysis, the non-transgenic control grouped together with the transgenic lines indicating that genotype was a more important factor determining the structure of fungal communities than the transgenic status of the plants. With the tested birch lines, no clear evidence for the effect of the heterologous expression of sugar beet chitinase IV on ECM colonization or the structure of fungal community was found.     

Field performance of chitinase transgenic silver birches (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Betula pendula</Emphasis>): resistance to fungal diseases

A field trial of 15 transgenic birch lines expressing a sugar beet chitinase IV gene and the corresponding controls was established in southern Finland to study the effects of the level of sugar beet chitinase IV expression on birch resistance to fungal diseases. The symptoms caused by natural infections of two fungal pathogens, Pyrenopeziza betulicola (leaf spot disease) and Melampsoridium betulinum (birch rust), were analysed in the field during a period of 3 years. The lines that had shown a high level of sugar beet chitinase IV mRNA accumulation in the greenhouse also showed high sugar beet chitinase IV expression after 3 years in the field. The level of sugar beet chitinase IV expression did not significantly improve the resistance of transgenic birches to leaf spot disease. Instead, some transgenic lines were significantly more susceptible to leaf spot than the controls. The level of sugar beet chitinase IV expression did have an improving effect on most parameters of birch rust; the groups of lines showing high or intermediate transgene expression were more resistant to birch rust than those showing low expression. This result indicates that the tested transformation may provide a tool for increasing the resistance of silver birch to birch rust.     

Analysis of gene inheritance and expression in hybrids between transgenic sugar beet and wild beets

Reciprocal gene exchange between cultivated sugar beet and wild beets in seed production areas is probably the reason for the occurence of weed beets in sugar beet production fields. Therefore, when releasing transgenic sugar beet plants into the environment, gene transfer to wild beets ( Beta vulgaris ssp. maritima ) has to be considered. In this study the transfer of BNYVV- (beet necrotic yellow vein virus) resistance and herbicide-tolerance genes from two transgenic sugar beet lines that were released in field experiments in 1993 and 1994 in Germany to different wild beet accessions was investigated. In order to evaluate the consequences of outcrossing, manual pollinations of emasculated wild beet plants with homozygous transgenic sugar beet plants were performed. In the resulting hybrids the transgenes were stably inherited according to Mendelian law. Gene expression in leaves and roots of the hybrids was in the same range as in the original transgenic sugar beet plants. Moreover, it was found that in one of the wild beet accessions, transfer and expression of the BNYVV resistance gene did considerably increase the level of virus resistance.     

Transposition of the maize transposable element dSpm in transgenic sugar beets

Transgenic plants and cell lines of sugar beet carrying Spm/dSpm system of maize transposable elements have been obtained by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. A heterologous system of mobile elements Spm/dSpm remains active in the genome of sugar beet that permit of transposon-based gene tagging and obtaining of marker-free transgenic sugar beet.     

Identification of the predominant nonrestoring allele for Owen-type cytoplasmic male sterility in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.): development of molecular markers for the maintainer genotype

Hybrid seed production in sugar beet relies on cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS). As time-consuming and laborious test crosses with a CMS tester are necessary to identify maintainer lines, development of a marker-assisted selection method for the rf gene (the nonrestoring allele of restorer-of-fertility locus) is highly desirable for sugar-beet breeding. To develop such a method, we investigated genetic variation at the Rf1 locus, one of two Rf loci known in sugar beet. After HindIII-digestion, genomic DNAs from beet plants known to have a restoring Rf1 allele yielded a range of hybridization patterns on agarose gels, indicating that Rf1 is a multi-allelic locus. However, the hybridization patterns of 22 of 23 maintainer lines were indistinguishable. The nucleotide sequences of the rf1 coding regions of these 22 maintainer lines were found to be identical, confirming that the lines had the same rf1 allele. Two PCR markers were developed that targeted a downstream intergenic sequence and an intron of Rf1. The electrophoretic patterns of both markers indicated multiple Rf1 alleles, one of which, named the dd(L) type, was associated with the maintainer genotype. To test the validity of marker-assisted selection, 147 sugar beet plants were genotyped using these markers. Additionally, the 147 sugar beet plants were crossed with CMS plants to determine whether they possessed the maintainer genotype. Analysis of 5038 F1 offspring showed that 53 % of the dd(L) plants, but none of the plants with other alleles, had the maintainer genotype. Thus, selection for the dd(L) type considerably enriched the proportion of plants with the maintainer genotype.     

Enhanced drought resistance in fructan-producing sugar beet

Fructans are soluble polymers of fructose that are produced by approximately 15 % of the flowering plant species. Production of bacterial fructans in tobacco has been shown previously to lead to improved biomass production under polyethylene glycol-mediated drought stress. Here, we used the same SacB gene from Bacillus subtilis to produce bacterial fructans in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.). The transgenic sugar beets accumulated fructans to low levels (max. 0.5 % of dry weight) in both roots and shoots. Two independent transgenic lines of fructan-producing sugar beets showed significantly better growth under drought stress than untransformed beets. Drought stressed fructan-producing plants attained higher total dry weights (+25–35 %) than wildtype sugar beet, due to higher biomass production of leaves (+30–33 %), storage roots (+16–33 %) and fibrous roots (+37–60 %). Under well-watered conditions, no significant differences were observed between the transgenic and wildtype beets. In conclusion, the introduction of fructan biosynthesis in transgenic plants is a promising approach to improve crop productivity under drought stress.     

Genetic approaches to sustainable pest management in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris)

Sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) is an important arable crop, traditionally used for sugar extraction, but more recently, for biofuel production. A wide range of pests, including beet cyst nematode (Heterodera schachtii), root‐knot nematodes (Meloidogyne spp.), green peach aphids (Myzus persicae) and beet root maggot (Tetanops myopaeformis), infest the roots or leaves of sugar beet, which leads to yield loss directly or through transmission of beet pathogens such as viruses. Conventional pest control approaches based on chemical application have led to high economic costs. Development of pest‐resistant sugar beet varieties could play an important role towards sustainable crop production while minimising environmental impact. Intensive Beta germplasm screening has been fruitful, and genetic lines resistant to nematodes, aphids and root maggot have been identified and integrated into sugar beet breeding programmes. A small number of genes responding to pest attack have been cloned from sugar beet and wild Beta species. This trend will continue towards a detailed understanding of the molecular mechanism of insect–host plant interactions and host resistance. Molecular biotechnological techniques have shown promise in developing transgenic pest resistance varieties at an accelerated speed with high accuracy. The use of transgenic technology is discussed with regard to biodiversity and food safety.     

Genetic localization of four genes for nematode (Heterodera schachtii Schm.) resistance in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.)

Sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) is highly susceptible to the beet cyst nematode (Heterodera schachtii Schm.). Three resistance genes originating from the wild beets B. procumbens (Hs1 ^pro-1) and B. webbiana (Hs1 ^web-1, Hs2 ^web-7) have been transferred to sugar beet via species hybridization. We describe the genetic localization of the nematode resistance genes in four different sugar beet lines using segregating F₂ populations and RFLP markers from our current sugar beet linkage map. The mapping studies yielded a surprising result. Although the four parental lines carrying the wild beet translocations were not related to each other, the four genes mapped to the same locus in sugar beet independent of the original translocation event. Close linkage (0–4.6 cM) was found with marker loci at one end of linkage group IV. In two populations, RFLP loci showed segregation distortion due to gametic selection. For the first time, the non-randomness of the translocation process promoting gene transfer from the wild beet to the sugar beet is demonstrated. The data suggest that the resistance genes were incorporated into the sugar beet chromosomes by non-allelic homologous recombination. The finding that the different resistance genes are allelic will have major implications on future attempts to breed sugar beet combining the different resistance genes.     

Transgenic silver birch (Betula pendula) expressing sugarbeet chitinase 4 shows enhanced resistance to Pyrenopeziza betulicola

A sugar beet chitinase gene driven by the (42) CaMV 35S promoter was introduced into silver birch (Betula pendula) through Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Transgenic shoots were regenerated and grown on WPM medium supplemented with 150 mg/ml kanamycin. From a total of 220 explants, 52 transgenics were obtained and 13 transgenic lines were randomly taken for molecular analysis to confirm the presence of the introduced sugar beet chitinase 4 cDNA by polymerase chain reaction and Southern hybridisation. All 13 transgenic lines were confirmed to contain the gene and further characterised. Northern blot analysis of total RNA indicated that the transgenic lines differed with respect to the steady-state levels of chitinase mRNA. Transgenic lines with high levels of mRNA of chitinase 4 cDNA consistently showed higher levels of resistance to Pyrenopeziza betulicola than transgenics with intermediate or low mRNA levels or a non-transgenic control plant. This report demonstrates that the constitutive expression of this gene in transgenic birch lines increased the resistance of birch against the leaf spot fungus P. betulicola.     

Enhanced Heavy Metal Tolerance and Accumulation by Transgenic Sugar Beets Expressing Streptococcus thermophilus StGCS-GS in the Presence of Cd,Zn and Cu Alone or in Combination

Phytoremediation is a promising means of ameliorating heavy metal pollution through the use of transgenic plants as artificial hyperaccumulators. A novel Streptococcus thermophilus γ-glutamylcysteine synthetase-glutathione synthetase (StGCS-GS) that synthesizes glutathione (GSH) with limited feedback inhibition was overexpressed in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.), yielding three transgenic lines (s2, s4 and s5) with enhanced tolerance to different concentrations of cadmium, zinc and copper, as indicated by their increased biomass, root length and relative growth compared with wild-type plants. Transgenic sugar beets accumulated more Cd, Zn and Cu ions in shoots than wild-type, as well as higher GSH and phytochelatin (PC) levels under different heavy metal stresses. This enhanced heavy metal tolerance and increased accumulation were likely due to the increased expression of StGCS-GS and consequent overproduction of both GSH and PC. Furthermore, when multiple heavy metal ions were present at the same time, transgenic sugar beets overexpressing StGCS-GS resisted two or three of the metal combinations (50 μM Cd-Zn, Cd-Cu, Zn-Cu and Cd-Zn-Cu), with greater absorption in shoots. Additionally, there was no obvious competition between metals. Overall, the results demonstrate the explicit role of StGCS-GS in enhancing Cd, Zn and Cu tolerance and accumulation in transgenic sugar beet, which may represent a highly promising new tool for phytoremediation.     

Genetic diversity and linkage disequilibrium analysis in elite sugar beet breeding lines and wild beet accessions

Key message

Linkage disequilibrium decay in sugar beet is strongly affected by the breeding history, and varies extensively between and along chromosomes, allowing identification of known and unknown signatures of selection.

Abstract

Genetic diversity and linkage disequilibrium (LD) patterns were investigated in 233 elite sugar beet breeding lines and 91 wild beet accessions, using 454 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and 418 SNPs, respectively. Principal coordinate analysis suggested the existence of three groups of germplasm, corresponding to the wild beets, the seed parent and the pollen parent breeding pool. LD was investigated in each of these groups, with and without correction for genetic relatedness. Without correction for genetic relatedness, in the pollen as well as the seed parent pool, LD persisted beyond 50 centiMorgan (cM) on four (2, 3, 4 and 5) and three chromosomes (2, 4 and 6), respectively; after correction for genetic relatedness, LD decayed after <6 cM on all chromosomes in both pools. In the wild beet accessions, there was a strong LD decay: on average LD disappeared after 1 cM when LD was calculated with a correction for genetic relatedness. Persistence of LD was not only observed between distant SNPs on the same chromosome, but also between SNPs on different chromosomes. Regions on chromosomes 3 and 4 that harbor disease resistance and monogermy loci showed strong genetic differentiation between the pollen and seed parent pools. Other regions, on chromosomes 8 and 9, for which no a priori information was available with respect to their contribution to the phenotype, still contributed to clustering of lines in the elite breeding material.     

High Level Resistance against Rhizomania Disease by Simultaneously Integrating Two Distinct Defense Mechanisms

With the aim of achieving durable resistance against rhizomania disease of sugar beet, the employment of different sources of resistance to Beet necrotic yellow vein virus was pursued. To this purpose, Nicotiana benthamiana transgenic plants that simultaneously produce dsRNA originating from a conserved region of the BNYVV replicase gene and the HrpZ_Psph protein in a secreted form (SP/HrpZ_Psph) were produced. The integration and expression of both transgenes as well as proper production of the harpin protein were verified in all primary transformants and selfed progeny (T1, T2). Transgenic resistance was assessed by BNYVV-challenge inoculation on T2 progeny by scoring disease symptoms and DAS-ELISA at 20 and 30 dpi. Transgenic lines possessing single transformation events for both transgenes as well as wild type plants were included in inoculation experiments. Transgenic plants were highly resistant to virus infection, whereas in some cases immunity was achieved. In all cases, the resistant phenotype of transgenic plants carrying both transgenes was superior in comparison with the ones carrying a single transgene. Collectively, our findings demonstrate, for a first time, that the combination of two entirely different resistance mechanisms provide high level resistance or even immunity against the virus. Such a novel approach is anticipated to prevent a rapid virus adaptation that could potentially lead to the emergence of isolates with resistance breaking properties.     

Epigenetic variation of the choriflowered-symflowered character in the symflowered sugar beet line SOAN-14

The effect of 5-azacytidine on the variation of the choriflowered (CF)-symflowered (SF) character in sugar beet was studied in several generations obtained via seed reproduction. The epimutagen (5-azacytidine) significantly reduced the number of flowers in glomerate inflorescences in the year of seed treatment and in the next generation (Az₁), leading to the appearance of plants with single flowers in bract axils of a flower stalk. The CF character resulting from epimutagene treatment of sugar beet seeds (plants with genotype M ^Z M ^Z ) was inherited as a monohybrid character in both zygotic and apozygotic seed progenies. The proportion of the CF and SF phenotypes in the progenies was affected by the chromatid number in the chromosomes (mixoploidy of the cell populations). Alleles of the Mm locus were found to affect the variation in phytomere organization of flower stalks.     

Physical mapping and cloning of a translocation in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L) carrying a gene for nematode (Heterodera schachtii) resistance from B. procumbens

Two diploid (2n=18) sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) lines which carry monogenic traits for nematode (Heterodera schachtii Schm.) resistance located on translocations from the wild beet species Beta procumbens were investigated. Short interspersed repetitive DNA elements exclusively hybridizing with wild beet DNA were found to be dispersed around the translocations. The banding pattern as revealed by genomic Southern hybridization was highly conserved among translocation lines of different origins indicating that the translocations are not affected by recombination events with sugar beet chromosomes. Physical mapping revealed that the entire translocation is represented by a single Sal I fragment 300 kb in size. A representative YAC (yeast artifical chromosome) library consisting of approximately 13,000 recombinant clones (2.2 genome equivalents) with insert sizes ranging between 50 and 450 kb and an average of 130kb has been constructed from the resistant line A906001. Three recombinant YACs were isolated from this library using the wild beet-specific repetitive elements as probes for screening. Colinearity between YAC inserts and donor DNA was confirmed by DNA fingerprinting utilizing these repetitive probes. The YACs were arranged into two contigs with a total size of 215 kb; these represent a minimum of 72% of the translocation.     

Quantitative trait locus responsible for resistance to Aphanomyces root rot (black root) caused by Aphanomyces cochlioides Drechs. in sugar beet

Aphanomyces root rot, caused by Aphanomyces cochlioides Drechs., is one of the most serious diseases of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.). Identification and characterization of resistance genes is a major task in sugar beet breeding. To ensure the effectiveness of marker-assisted screening for Aphanomyces root rot resistance, genetic analysis of mature plants’ phenotypic and molecular markers’ segregation was carried out. At a highly infested field site, some 187 F₂ and 66 F₃ individuals, derived from a cross between lines ‘NK-310mm-O’ (highly resistant) and ‘NK-184mm-O’ (susceptible), were tested, over two seasons, for their level of resistance to Aphanomyces root rot. This resistance was classified into six categories according to the extent and intensity of whole plant symptoms. Simultaneously, two selected RAPD and 159 ‘NK-310mm-O’-coupled AFLP were used in the construction of a linkage map of 695.7 cM. Each of nine resultant linkage groups was successfully anchored to one of nine sugar beet chromosomes by incorporating 16 STS markers. Combining data for phenotype and molecular marker segregation, a single QTL was identified on chromosome III. This QTL explained 20% of the variance in F₂ population (in the year 2002) and 65% in F₃ lines (2003), indicating that this QTL plays a major role in the Aphanomyces root rot resistance. This is the first report of the genetic mapping of resistance to Aphanomyces-caused diseases in sugar beet.     

Monosomic addition lines of Beta corolliflora Zoss in sugar beet: cytological and molecular-marker analysis

Beta corolliflora is a wild relative of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) with 2n=4x=36 chromosomes. Monosomic addition lines (2n=19) of B. corolliflora in B. vulgaris were identified from backcross progenies between triploid hybrids (genome constitution VVC) and sugar beet. They were characterized by DNA-fingerprinting using nine different B. corolliflora-specific repetitive sequences as probes and by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) using two B. corollifora specific sequences and two rDNA probes. Unique banding patterns obtained after genomic Southern hybridization enabled the classification of monosomic addition lines into 11 clusters, three of which proved to have a wild beet chromosome fragment in addition to the sugar beet chromosomes as revealed by FISH. Repetitive sequences pBC216 and pBC1416 were found to be present only on wild beet chromosomes IV and V. Chromosomes I and IV were found to carry genes for 18S and 5S rRNA, respectively. An idiogram of B. corolliflora was established in the triploid VVC hybrid on the basis of chromosome size and FISH. Eight B. corolliflora addition lines could be unequivocally identified by Southern hybridization and FISH, one addition line carrying the missing wild beet chromosome is probably not viable under greenhouse conditions. The monosomic addition lines will serve as a bridge for transferring genes from wild species to sugar beet and will help to uncover genetic relationships between species of the genus Beta.     

dsRNA-mediated resistance to Beet Necrotic Yellow Vein Virus infections in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L. ssp. vulgaris)

Rhizomania, one of the most devastating diseases in sugar beet, is caused by Beet Necrotic Yellow Vein Virus (BNYVV) belonging to the genus Benyvirus. Use of sugar beet varieties with resistance to BNYVV is generally considered as the only way to maintain a profitable yield on rhizomania-infested fields. As an alternative to natural resistance, we explored the transgenic expression of viral dsRNA for engineering resistance to rhizomania. Transgenic plants expressing an inverted repeat of a 0.4 kb fragment derived from the BNYVV replicase gene displayed high levels of resistance against different genetic strains of BNYVV when inoculated using the natural vector, Polymyxa betae. The resistance was maintained under high infection pressures and over prolonged growing periods in the greenhouse as well as in the field. Resistant plants accumulated extremely low amounts of transgene mRNA and high amounts of the corresponding siRNA in the roots, illustrative of RNA silencing as the underlying mechanism. The transgenic resistance compared very favourably to natural sources of resistance to rhizomania and thus offers an attractive alternative for breeding resistant sugar beet varieties.