Hydrotropism: The current state of our knowledge

The response of roots to a moisture gradient has been reexamined, and positive hydrotropism has been demonstrated in recent years. Agravitropic roots of a pea mutant have contributed to the studies on hydrotropism. The kinetics of hydrotropic curvature, interactions between hydrotropism and gravitropism, moisture gradients required for the induction of hydrotropism, the sensing site for moisture gradients, characteristics of hydrotropic signal and differential growth, and calcium involvement in signal transduction have been subjects of these studies. This review summarizes the current state of our knowledge on hydrotropism in roots.     

A molecular mechanism unique to hydrotropism in roots

Plants are sessile in nature and must respond to various environmental cues to regulate their growth orientation. Root hydrotropism, a response to moisture gradients, has been considered to play an important role in drought avoidance. Nonetheless, the processes underlying hydrotropism in roots have remained obscure until recently because of the interfering effect of gravitropism. To shed light on root hydrotropism, we isolated and analyzed two Arabidopsis mutants, mizu-kussei (miz) 1 and 2, that have abnormal hydrotropic responses but normal responses to gravity. MIZ1 encodes a protein of unknown function with a conserved domain at its C-terminus. MIZ2 encodes a guanine-nucleotide exchange factor for ADP-ribosylation factor-type G proteins, which has been identified as GNOM. These findings suggest that roots possess molecular mechanisms essential for hydrotropism but independent of gravitropism. One of such mechanisms involves vesicle transport unique to hydrotropism in roots. Here we summarize recent progress on the molecular mechanism of root hydrotropism and the roles of MIZ1 and MIZ2.     

Hydrotropism in abscisic acid,wavy, and gravitropic mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana

We have developed experimental systems to study hydrotropism in seedling roots of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. Arabidopsis roots showed a strong curvature in response to a moisture gradient, established by applying 1% agar and a saturated solution of KCl or K(2)CO(3) in a closed chamber. In this system, the hydrotropic response overcame the gravitropic response. Hydrotropic curvature commenced within 30 min and reached 80-100 degrees within 24 h of hydrostimulation. When 1% agar and agar containing 1 MPa sorbitol were placed side-by-side in humid air, a water potential gradient formed at the border between the two media. Although the gradient changed with time, it still elicited a hydrotropic response in Arabidopsis roots. The roots curved away from 0.5-1.5 MPa of sorbitol agar. Various Arabidopsis mutants were tested for their hydrotropic response. Roots of aba1-1 and abi2-1 mutants were less sensitive to hydrotropic stimulation. Addition of abscisic acid restored the normal hydrotropic response in aba1-1 roots. In comparison, mutants that exhibit a reduced response to gravity and auxin, axr1-3 and axr2-1, showed a hydrotropic response greater than that of the wild type. Wavy mutants, wav2-1 and wav3-1, showed increased sensitivity to the induction of hydrotropism by the moisture gradient. These results suggest that auxin plays divergent roles in hydrotropism and gravitropism, and that abscisic acid plays a positive role in hydrotropism. Furthermore, hydrotropism and the wavy response may share part of a common molecular pathway controlling the directional growth of roots.     

A test for hydrotropic behavior by roots of two coastal dune shrubs

Root hydrotropism could be a means by which plants forage for limited and patchy distributions of soil water. While root hydrotropism has been induced in distinctly artificial conditions, it is unclear if it operates in natural settings. Here, we tested for this possibility in seedlings of two species of dune shrubs. Growth of individual roots in sand-filled observation chambers was monitored in response to moisture-rich patches and resultant soil water gradients. Chambers were designed so that roots could intercept the moisture gradients but not the moisture-rich patches simply through gravitropism. While up to 12% of the Eriogonum parvifolium roots grew into the moisture-rich patches, comparable root growth was observed in the control. None of the Artemisia californica roots grew into the patches. Thus, in a reasonable simulation of field conditions, we found no compelling evidence for hydrotropic root behavior in seedlings of these two dune shrubs. Our results leave the ecological significance of root hydrotropism in question.     

An altered hydrotropic response (ahr1) mutant of Arabidopsis recovers root hydrotropism with cytokinin

Roots are highly plastic and can acclimate to heterogeneous and stressful conditions. However, there is little knowledge of the effect of moisture gradients on the mechanisms controlling root growth orientation and branching, and how this mechanism may help plants to avoid drought responses. The aim of this study was to isolate mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana with altered hydrotropic responses. Here, altered hydrotropic response 1 (ahr1), a semi-dominant allele segregating as a single gene mutation, was characterized. ahr1 directed the growth of its primary root towards the source of higher water availability and developed an extensive root system over time. This phenotype was intensified in the presence of abscisic acid and was not observed if ahr1 seedlings were grown in a water stress medium without a water potential gradient. In normal growth conditions, primary root growth and root branching of ahr1 were indistinguishable from those of the wild type (wt). The altered hydrotropic growth of ahr1 roots was confirmed when the water-rich source was placed at an angle of 45° from the gravity vector. In this system, roots of ahr1 seedlings grew downward and did not display hydrotropism; however, in the presence of cytokinins, they exhibited hydrotropism like those of the wt, indicating that cytokinins play a critical role in root hydrotropism. The ahr1 mutant represents a valuable genetic resource for the study of the effects of cytokinins in the differential growth of hydrotropism and control of lateral root formation during the hydrotropic response.     

Novel hydrotropism mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana and their altered waving response and phototropism.

Roots display positive hydrotropism in response to a moisture gradient, which is important for plants to escape from water stress and regulate the directional growth by interacting with other growth movements such as gravitropism, phototropism and waving response. On Earth, hydrotropism is interfered by gravitropism in particular, so that microgravity conditions or agravitropic mutants have been used for the study of hydrotropism. However, we have recently established an experimental system for the study of hydrotropism in Arabidopsis roots that easily develop hydrotropism in response to moisture gradient by overcoming gravitropism. Using the Arabidopsis system, we isolated hydrotropism mutants named root hydrotropism (rhy). In the present study, we examined the hydrotropism, gravitropism, phototropism, waving response and elongation growth of rhy4 and rhy5 roots that were defective in positive hydrotropism. Interestingly, rhy4 roots curved away from the water source and showed a reduced waving response. Both rhy4 and rhy5 showed normal gravitropism and a slight reduction in phototropism. These results suggest that there is a mutual molecular mechanism underlying hydrotropism, waving response and/or phototropism. Thus, we have obtained novel hydrotropic mutants that will be used for revealing molecular mechanism of root hydrotropism and its interaction with waving response and/or phototropism.     

Characterization of hydrotropism: the timing of perception and signal movement from the root cap in the agravitropic pea mutant ageotropum.

In recent years, experiments have demonstrated that the gravity response of roots can be separated from the hydrotropic response by using the agravitropic pea mutant ageotropum. Though this mutant has been a useful tool for demonstrating the existence of the hydrotropic response of roots, little is known about how perception, transduction, transmission, and the growth response is accomplished. In this study, we have used the ageotropum mutant to investigate both the threshold time for perception of an osmotic stimulation and the minimum time required for signal transduction and transmission in roots following an osmotic stimulation at the root cap. In addition, we have compared the threshold times and signal transmission times of hydrotropism in the ageotropum roots to the gravity response of Alaska pea roots.     

Interactions between Hydrotropism and Gravitropism in the Primary Seminal Roots of Triticum eastivum L.

It has been proposed that hydrotropism interacts with gravitropismin seedling roots; that is, roots which are highly gravitropicshow less hydrotropism (Takahashi and Suge, 1991 PhysiologiaPlantarum 82: 24-31; Takahashi and Scott, 1993 Plant, Cell andEnvironment 16: 99-103). Here, we examine varietal differencesin the hydrotropic response and its interaction with gravitropismin wheat roots. Primary seminal roots of wheat (Triticum aestivumL.) were hydrotropically stimulated by different moisture gradientsestablished by placing wet cheesecloth and saturated solutionsof different salts in closed chambers. From equations obtainedby relative humidity (RH) at different distances from the wetcheesecloth, moisture gradients at the root-tip level were estimatedto be 0·03 to 1·84% RH mm^-1, depending upon thesalt introduced into the chamber. The roots showed positivehydrotropism in response to 0·67% RH mm^-1, and the responseapparently increased as the gradient was strengthened. Whenthe primary seminal roots of 12 cultivars were exposed to amoisture gradient of 1·84% RH mm-1, hydrotropic responsesignificantly differed depending upon the cultivar tested. Amongthe cultivars, the roots of Norin 11, Norin 15, Norin 117, andNorin 125 responded hydrotropically more strongly than the others.These roots, with the exception of Norin 11, showed a less vigorousresponse to gravity compared to the remaining cultivars. However,the roots of Norin 20, Norin 38, and Norin 107 were relativelyunresponsive to both a moisture gradient and to gravity. Thus,the primary seminal roots of wheat respond hydrotropically,and the responsiveness differs among cultivars. However, thevarietal difference in hydrotropic response cannot be explainedsolely by converse differences in responsiveness to gravity.Copyright1995, 1999 Academic Press Cultivar, gravitropism, hydrotropism, primary seminal roots, Triticum aestivum L., wheat     

Involvement of Arabidopsis thaliana phospholipase Dζ2 in root hydrotropism through the suppression of root gravitropism

Root hydrotropism is the phenomenon of directional root growth toward moisture under water-deficient conditions. Although physiological and genetic studies have revealed the involvement of the root cap in the sensing of moisture gradients, and those of auxin and abscisic acid (ABA) in the signal transduction for asymmetric root elongation, the overall mechanism of root hydrotropism is still unclear. We found that the promoter activity of the Arabidopsis phospholipase Dζ2 gene (PLDζ2) was localized to epidermal cells in the distal root elongation zone and lateral root cap cells adjacent to them, and that exogenous ABA enhanced the activity and extended its area to the entire root cap. Although pldζ2 mutant root caps did not exhibit a morphological phenotype in either the absence or presence of exogenous ABA, the inhibitory effect of ABA on gravitropism, which was significant in wild-type roots, was not observed in pldζ2 mutant roots. In root hydrotropism experiments, pldζ2 mutations significantly retarded or disturbed root hydrotropic responses. A drought condition similar to that used in a hydrotropism experiment enhanced the PLDζ2 promoter activity in the root cap, as did exogenous ABA. These results suggest that PLDζ2 responds to drought through ABA signaling in the root cap and accelerates root hydrotropism through the suppression of root gravitropism.     

Hydrotropism interacts with gravitropism by degrading amyloplasts in seedling roots of Arabidopsis and radish

In response to a moisture gradient, roots exhibit hydrotropism to control the orientation of their growth. To exhibit hydrotropism, however, they must overcome the gravitropism that is dominant on Earth. We found that moisture gradient or water stress caused immediate degradation of the starch anchors, amyloplasts, in root columella cells of Arabidopsis and radish (Raphanus sativus). Namely, development of hydrotropic response was accompanied by a simultaneous reduction in starch content in columella cells. Rapid degradation of amyloplasts in columella cells also occurred in the water-stressed roots with sorbitol or mannitol. Both hydrotropically stimulated and water-stressed roots showed a reduced responsiveness to gravity. Roots of a starchless mutant, pgm1-1, showed an enhanced hydrotropism compared with that of the wild type. These results suggest that the reduced responsiveness to gravity is, at least in part, attributable to the degradation of amyloplasts in columella cells. Thus, the reduction in gravitropism allows the roots to exhibit hydrotropism.     

A no hydrotropic response root mutant that responds positively to gravitropism in Arabidopsis

For most plants survival depends upon the capacity of root tips to sense and move towards water and other nutrients in the soil. Because land plants cannot escape environmental stress they use developmental solutions to remodel themselves in order to better adapt to the new conditions. The primary site for perception of underground signals is the root cap (RC). Plant roots have positive hydrotropic response and modify their growth direction in search of water. Using a screening system with a water potential gradient, we isolated a no hydrotropic response (nhr) semi-dominant mutant of Arabidopsis that continued to grow downwardly into the medium with the lowest water potential contrary to the positive hydrotropic and negative gravitropic response seen in wild type-roots. The lack of hydrotropic response of nhr1 roots was confirmed in a system with a gradient in air moisture. The root gravitropic response of nhr1 seedlings was significantly faster in comparison with those of wild type. The frequency of the waving pattern in nhr1 roots was increased compared to those of wild type. nhr1 seedlings had abnormal root cap morphogenesis and reduced root growth sensitivity to abscisic acid (ABA) and the polar auxin transport inhibitor N-(1-naphtyl)phtalamic acid (NPA). These results showed that hydrotropism is amenable to genetic analysis and that an ABA signaling pathway participates in sensing water potential gradients through the root cap.     

Intensity of hydrostimulation for the induction of root hydrotropism and its sensing by the root cap

Roots of Pisum sativum L. and Zea mays L. were exposed to different moisture gradients established by placing both wet cheesecloth (hydrostimulant) and saturated aqueous solutions of various salts in a closed chamber. Atmospheric conditions with different relative humidity (RH) in a range between 98 and 86% RH were obtained at root level, 2 to 3mm from the water-saturated hydrostimulant. Roots of Silver Queen corn placed vertically with the tips down curved sideways toward the hydrostimulant in response to approximately 94% RH but did not respond positively to RH higher than approximately 95%. The positive hydrotropic response increased linearly as RH was lowered from 95 to 90%. A maximum response was observed at RH between 90 and 86%. However, RH required for the induction of hydrotropism as well as the responsiveness differed among plant species used; gravitropically sensitive roots appeared to require a somewhat greater moisture gradient for the induction of hydrotropism. Decapped roots of corn failed to curve hydrotropically, suggesting the root cap as a major site of hydrosensing.     

Molecular mechanisms mediating root hydrotropism: what we have observed since the rediscovery of hydrotropism

Roots display directional growth toward moisture in response to a water potential gradient. Root hydrotropism is thought to facilitate plant adaptation to continuously changing water availability. Hydrotropism has not been as extensively studied as gravitropism. However, comparisons of hydrotropic and gravitropic responses identified mechanisms that are unique to hydrotropism. Regulatory mechanisms underlying the hydrotropic response appear to differ among different species. We recently performed molecular and genetic analyses of root hydrotropism in Arabidopsis thaliana. In this review, we summarize the current knowledge of specific mechanisms mediating root hydrotropism in several plant species.

     

Hydrotropism and its interaction with gravitropism in roots

We have studied hydrotropism and its interaction with gravitropism in agravitropic roots of a pea mutant and normal roots of peas (Pisum sativum L.) and maize (Zea mays L.). The interaction between hydrotropism and gravitropism in normal roots of peas or maize were also examined by nullifying the gravitropic response on a clinostat and by changing the stimulus-angle for gravistimulation. Depending on the intensity of both hydrostimulation and gravistimulation, hydrotropism and gravitropism of seedling roots strongly interact with one another. When the gravitropic response was reduced, either genetically or physiologically, the hydrotropic response of roots became more unequivocal. Also, roots more sensitive to gravity appear to require a greater moisture gradient for the induction of hydrotropism. Positive hydrotropism of roots occurred due to a differential growth in the elongation zone; the elongation was much more inhibited on the moistened side than on the dry side of the roots. It was suggested that the site of sensory perception for hydrotropism resides in the root cap, as does the sensory site for gravitropism. Furthermore, an auxin inhibitor, 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA), and a calcium chelator, ethyleneglycol-bis-(-aminoethylether)-N,N,N,N- tetraacetic acid (EGTA), inhibited both hydrotropism and gravitropism in roots. These results suggest that the two tropisms share a common mechanism in the signal transduction step.     

GNOM-Mediated Vesicular Trafficking Plays an Essential Role in Hydrotropism of Arabidopsis Roots

Roots respond not only to gravity but also to moisture gradient by displaying gravitropism and hydrotropism, respectively, to control their growth orientation, which helps plants obtain water and become established in the terrestrial environment. As gravitropism often interferes with hydrotropism, however, the mechanisms of how roots display hydrotropism and differentiate it from gravitropism are not understood. We previously reported MIZU-KUSSEI1 (MIZ1) as a gene required for hydrotropism but not for gravitropism, although the function of its protein was not known. Here, we found that a mutation of GNOM encoding guanine-nucleotide exchange factor for ADP-ribosylation factor-type G proteins was responsible for the ahydrotropism of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), miz2. Unlike other gnom alleles, miz2 showed no apparent morphological defects or reduced gravitropism. Instead, brefeldin A (BFA) treatment inhibited both hydrotropism and gravitropism in Arabidopsis roots. In addition, a BFA-resistant GNOM variant, GN^M696L, showed normal hydrotropic response in the presence of BFA. Furthermore, a weak gnom allele, gnom^B/E, showed defect in hydrotropic response. These results indicate that GNOM-mediated vesicular trafficking plays an essential role in hydrotropism of seedling roots.Stationary growth is a distinct feature of plants and distinguishes them from other organisms. Plants have evolved a variety of mechanisms for responding to environmental cues, which enables them to survive in the presence of limited resources or environmental stresses. One of the most important growth adaptations plants have acquired is tropism, growth response that involves bending or curving of plant organs toward or away from a stimulus. For example, roots display tropisms in response to environmental cues such as gravity, light, touch, and moisture (Darwin and Darwin, 1880; Takahashi, 1997; Correll and Kiss, 2002; Monshausen et al., 2008). Gravitropism has been the subject of intense study, while other tropic responses of roots have been less well characterized. There is some evidence of hydrotropism in roots, but this response has proven difficult to differentiate from gravitropism, as the latter always interferes with hydrotropism (Jaffe et al., 1985; Takahashi, 1994; Takahashi, 1997). The demonstration of true hydrotropism in roots has facilitated the identification of some of the physiological aspects of hydrotropism and its existence in a wide range of plant species. However, the underlying mechanisms that regulate hydrotropism remain unknown. The limited supply of water and precipitation in many parts of the world greatly affects agriculture and ecosystems. Elucidating the molecular mechanism of hydrotropism in roots is therefore important not only for understanding how terrestrial plants adapt to changes in moisture, but also for improving crop yields and biomass production.The isolation and analysis of hydrotropism-deficient mutants using the model plant species Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) represents a potent tool for dissecting the molecular mechanism of hydrotropism. Previously, we isolated an ahydrotropic mutant of Arabidopsis, mizu-kussei1 (miz1), and showed that MIZ1 encodes a protein of unknown function (Kobayashi et al., 2007). In light of both the physiological features of hydrotropism, as well as what we have learned from genetic studies of other tropisms, it is unlikely that miz1 alone governs the hydrotropic response. In support of this, we have identified a second ahydrotropic mutant, miz2, a unique allele of gnom that confers ahydrotropic but not agravitropic growth, which implies distinct roles of vesicular trafficking between hydrotropism and gravitropism in roots.     

Roles of amyloplasts and water deficit in root tropisms

Directed growth of roots in relation to a moisture gradient is called hydrotropism. The no hydrotropic response (nhr1) mutant of Arabidopsis lacks a hydrotropic response, and shows a stronger gravitropic response than that of wild type (wt) in a medium with an osmotic gradient. Local application of abscisic acid (ABA) to seeds or root tips of nhr1 increased root downward growth, indicating the critical role of ABA in tropisms. Wt roots germinated and treated with ABA in this system were strongly gravitropic, even though they had almost no starch amyloplasts in the root-cap columella cells. Hydrotropically stimulated nhr1 roots, with or without ABA, maintained starch in the amyloplasts, as opposed to those of wt. Hence, the near-absence (wt) or abundant presence (nhr1) of starch granules does not influence the extent of downward gravitropism of the roots in an osmotic gradient medium. Starch degradation in the wt might help the root sustain osmotic stress and carry out hydrotropism, instead of reducing gravity responsiveness. nhr1 roots might be hydrotropically inactive because they maintain this starch reserve in the columella cells, sustaining both their turgor and growth, and in effect minimizing the need for hydrotropism and at least partially disabling its mechanism. We conclude that ABA and water stress are critical regulators of root tropic responses.     

How do Arabidopsis Roots Differentiate Hydrotropism from Gravitropism?

Root hydrotropism is a response to moisture gradients, which is considered to be important for drought avoidance. Recent reevaluation of root hydrotropism has emphasised the dominating effect of root gravitropism on it. It has been suggested that amyloplast dynamics inside columella cells and auxin regulation play roles in this interacting mechanism, even though the existence of distinct pathways of two tropisms derived from different stimuli remained unclear. We have recently found two factors that separate the mechanism of hydrotropism from that of gravitropism in Arabidopsis seedling roots. One is the difference in the mode of auxin-mediated growth regulation between two tropisms, and the other is the identification of gene indispensable only for root hydrotropism. Here we summarize the recent progress on root hydrotropism research and discuss the remaining and emerging issues.Key Words: auxin, gravitropism, hydrotropism, root, MIZU-KUSSEI1 (MIZ1)     

Root hydrotropism of an agravitropic pea mutant, ageotropum

We have partially characterized root hydrotropism of an agravitropic pea mutant, ageotropum (from Pisum sativum L. cv. Weibull's Weitor), without interference of gravitropism. Lowering the atmospheric air humidity inhibited root elongation and caused root curvature toward the moisture-saturated substrate in ageotropum pea. Removal of root tips approximately 1.5 mm in length blocked the hydrotropic response. A computer-assisted image analysis showed that the hydrotropic curvature in the roots of ageotropum pea was chiefly due to a greater inhibition of elongation on the humid side than the dry side of the roots. Similarly, gravitropic curvature of Alaska pea roots resulted from inhibition of elongation on the lower side of the horizontally placed roots, while the upper side of the roots maintained a normal growth rate. Gravitropic bending of Alaska pea roots was apparent 30 min after stimulation, whereas differential growth as well as curvature in positive root hydrotropism of ageotropum pea became visible 4–5 h after the continuous hydrostimulation. Application of 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid or ethyleneglycol-bis-( β -aminoethylether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid was inhibitory to both root hydrotropism of ageotropum pea and root gravitropism of Alaska pea. Some mutual response mechanism for both hydrotropism and gravitropism may exist in roots, although the stimulusperception mechanisms differ from one another.     

植物根向水性反应研究进展

根的向水性生长是指植物通过根尖感知土壤中的水分梯度, 向着水势较高区域生长的一种生物学特性, 这一特性对植物从土壤中有效获取水分极为重要。植物向水性研究已成为当前植物学研究的热点领域, 但对于调控这一生理反应的分子机制仍知之甚少。目前的研究表明, MIZ1和GNOM作为植物向水性反应的重要调节因子, 正向调控植物根的向水性生长。此外, 植物激素、光、ROS及钙离子也参与调节植物的向水性反应。该文将从向水性的研究历史、调控基因以及内外因素等方面进行阐述, 便于读者全面了解植物向水性研究进展, 以期为向水性研究提供新思路。