Interplay of ion binding and attraction in DNA condensed by multivalent cations

We have measured forces generated by multivalent cation-induced DNA condensation using single-molecule magnetic tweezers. In the presence of cobalt hexammine, spermidine, or spermine, stretched DNA exhibits an abrupt configurational change from extended to condensed. This occurs at a well-defined condensation force that is nearly equal to the condensation free energy per unit length. The multivalent cation concentration dependence for this condensation force gives the apparent number of multivalent cations that bind DNA upon condensation. The measurements show that the lower critical concentration for cobalt hexammine as compared to spermidine is due to a difference in ion binding, not a difference in the electrostatic energy of the condensed state as previously thought. We also show that the resolubilization of condensed DNA can be described using a traditional Manning–Oosawa cation adsorption model, provided that cation–anion pairing at high electrolyte concentrations is taken into account. Neither overcharging nor significant alterations in the condensed state are required to describe the resolubilization of condensed DNA. The same model also describes the spermidine³⁺/Na⁺ phase diagram measured previously.     

Structural and electrostatic effects on binding of trivalent cations to double-stranded and single-stranded poly[d (AT)

We have measured the thermal melting profile for poly[d(AT)].poly[d(TA)] as a function of concentration of three trivalent cations: spermidine, me8spermidine, and hexammine cobalt(III). Using McGhee's (1976) theory of DNA melting in the presence of ligands, we have estimated association constants Kh, Kc and binding site sizes nh, nc for binding to double-helical (h) and single-stranded (c) polynucleotide. The results are as follows: (table; see text) The binding parameters for spermidine and hexammine cobalt(III) to double helical molecules agree fairly well with direct equilibrium dialysis measurements, and are in reasonable accord with predictions of counterion condensation theory. However, despite their identical charges, the three ligands bind to single-stranded DNA with quite different affinities. Estimates of the charge spacing of single-stranded DNA suggest that poly[d(AT)] is less elongated in the presence of spermidine and hexammine cobalt(III) than it is when complexed with me8spermidine.     

Trivalent counterion condensation on DNA measured by pulse gel electrophoresis

Pulse gel electrophoresis was used to measure the reduction of mobilities of λ-DNA-Hind III fragments ranging from 23.130 to 2.027 kilobase pairs in Tris borate buffer solutions mixed with either hexammine cobalt(III), or spermidine³⁺ trivalent counterions that competed with Tris⁺ and Na⁺ for binding onto polyion DNA. The normalized titration curves of mobility were well fit by the two-variable counterion condensation theory. The agreement between measured charge fraction neutralized and counterion condensation prediction was good over a relatively wide range of trivalent cation concentrations at several solution conditions (pH, ionic strength). The effect of ionic strength, trivalent cation concentration, counterion structure, and DNA length on the binding were discussed based on the experimental measurements and the counterion condensation theory. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Evidence that both kinetic and thermodynamic factors govern DNA toroid dimensions: effects of magnesium(II) on DNA condensation by hexammine cobalt(III)

Millimolar concentrations of divalent cations are shown to affect the size of toroids formed when DNA is condensed by multivalent cations. The origins of this effect were explored by varying the order in which MgCl(2) was added to a series of DNA condensation reactions with hexammine cobalt chloride. The interplay between Mg(II), temperature, and absolute cation concentration on DNA condensation was also investigated. These studies reveal that DNA condensation is extremely sensitive to whether Mg(II) is associated with DNA prior to condensation or Mg(II) is added concurrently with hexammine cobalt(III) at the time of condensation. It was also found that, in the presence of Mg(II), temperature and dilution can have opposite effects on the degree of DNA condensation. A systematic comparison of DNA condensates observed in this study clearly illustrates that, under our low-salt conditions, toroid size is determined by the kinetics of toroid nucleation and growth. However, when Mg(II) is present during condensation, toroid size can also be limited by a thermodynamic parameter (e.g., undercharging). The path dependence of DNA condensation presented here illustrates that regardless of which particular factors limit toroid growth, toroids formed under the various conditions of this study are largely nonequilibrium structures.     

Structural analysis of DNA interactions with biogenic polyamines and cobalt(III)hexamine studied by Fourier transform infrared and capillary electrophoresis

Biogenic polyamines, such as putrescine, spermidine, and spermine are small organic polycations involved in numerous diverse biological processes. These compounds play an important role in nucleic acid function due to their binding to DNA and RNA. It has been shown that biogenic polyamines cause DNA condensation and aggregation similar to that of inorganic cobalt(III)hexamine cation, which has the ability to induce DNA conformational changes. However, the nature of the polyamine.DNA binding at the molecular level is not clearly established and is the subject of much controversy. In the present study the effects of spermine, spermidine, putrescine, and cobalt(III)hexamine on the solution structure of calf-thymus DNA were investigated using affinity capillary electrophoresis, Fourier transform infrared, and circular dichroism spectroscopic methods. At low polycation concentrations, putrescine binds preferentially through the minor and major grooves of double strand DNA, whereas spermine, spermidine, and cobalt(III)hexamine bind to the major groove. At high polycation concentrations, putrescine interaction with the bases is weak, whereas strong base binding occurred for spermidine in the major and minor grooves of DNA duplex. However, major groove binding is preferred by spermine and cobalt(III)hexamine cations. Electrostatic attractions between polycation and the backbone phosphate group were also observed. No major alterations of B-DNA were observed for biogenic polyamines, whereas cobalt(III)hexamine induced a partial B --> A transition. DNA condensation was also observed for cobalt(III)hexamine cation, whereas organic polyamines induced duplex stabilization. The binding constants calculated for biogenic polyamines are K(Spm) = 2.3 x 10(5) M(-1), K(Spd) = 1.4 x 10(5) M(-1), and K(Put) = 1.02 x 10(5) M(-1). Two binding constants have been found for cobalt(III)hexamine with K(1) = 1.8 x 10(5) M(-1) and K(2) = 9.2 x 10(4) M(-1). The Hill coefficients indicate a positive cooperativity binding for biogenic polyamines and a negative cooperativity for cobalt(III)hexamine.     

Condensation of DNA by trivalent cations. 2. Effects of cation structure

Electron microscopy is employed to examine DNA aggregates produced by three tripositively charged condensing agents. Spermidine, hexammine cobalt (III), and me8spermidine (in which the amine groups of spermidine are exhaustively methylated) all produce condensates. The predominant form of condensate observed is toroidal; however, me8spermidine produces a large fraction of rodlike condensates. Distributions of toroidal radii and estimated volumes suggest that the size of condensates depends on the condensing agent employed, its concentration, and the time elapsed after addition of condensing agent. While ligand charge seems to be the major factor in predicting condensing power, ligand structure influences the morphology and dimensions of the particles produced. The ability to form hydrogen bonds is not required to promote condensation, since me8spermidine has no NHs. There may be a kinetic barrier to condensation at low me8spermidine concentrations. The relative proportions of toroids and rods may depend on the energetic compensation between bending and binding in cyclic structures, or on rate-limiting formation of sharply bent or kinked regions in rods.     

Why double-stranded RNA resists condensation

The addition of small amounts of multivalent cations to solutions containing double-stranded DNA leads to inter-DNA attraction and eventual condensation. Surprisingly, the condensation is suppressed in double-stranded RNA, which carries the same negative charge as DNA, but assumes a different double helical form. Here, we combine experiment and atomistic simulations to propose a mechanism that explains the variations in condensation of short (25 base-pairs) nucleic acid (NA) duplexes, from B-like form of homopolymeric DNA, to mixed sequence DNA, to DNA:RNA hybrid, to A-like RNA. Circular dichroism measurements suggest that duplex helical geometry is not the fundamental property that ultimately determines the observed differences in condensation. Instead, these differences are governed by the spatial variation of cobalt hexammine (CoHex) binding to NA. There are two major NA-CoHex binding modes—internal and external—distinguished by the proximity of bound CoHex to the helical axis. We find a significant difference, up to 5-fold, in the fraction of ions bound to the external surfaces of the different NA constructs studied. NA condensation propensity is determined by the fraction of CoHex ions in the external binding mode.     

Packaging of DNA in bacteriophage heads: some considerations on energetics

We have made quantitative estimates of some of the energetic factors to be considered in packaging of double-stranded DNA in virus particles. Numerical calculations were made using parameters appropriate for T4 bacteriophage. The unfavorable factors, and the Gibbs free energies per mole virus at 20°C associated with them, are bending, 1.5 × 10³ kcal/mol; conformational restriction upon condensation, 5.1 × 10² kcal/mol; polyelectrolyte repulsion, 2.1 × 10⁵kcal/mol; and melting or kinking, 6.9 × 10³ kcal/mol. These must be counterbalanced in the assembled phage by noncovalent bonding interactions between protein subunits in the phage-head shell; by interactions between the DNA and polyvalent cations, especially putrescine and spermidine; nad perhaps by repulsive excluded volume and electrostatic interaction between the DNA and acidic polypeptides. Indeed, a rough estimate of the standard free energey of interaction between T4 DNA and the putrescine and spermidine contained in the head is --2.1 × 10⁵ kcal/mol. In the absence of the other two sources of stabilization, each head protein subunit must contribute about 210 kcal/mol of binding energy.     

Condensation of chromatin: role of multivalent cations

We have used electric dichroism to investigate the influence of multivalent cations upon the compaction of chicken erythrocyte chromatin from the unfolded, 10-nm fiber to the 30-nm solenoid and subsequent aggregation. The pattern of condensation, which consists of compaction plus aggregation, is found to be strikingly similar for a variety of cations of differing charge, including the physiologically important polyamines spermine and spermidine. With a few exceptions such as Cu2+ and Gd3+, an optimally compacted fiber with reproducible hydrodynamic properties is produced prior to the onset of aggregation. We report the concentrations of di-, tri-, and tetravalent cations required for optimal condensation; in addition, for tri- and tetravalent cations, we were able to estimate the extent of charge neutralization produced by their binding to the optimally compacted fiber. The results show that the multivalent ion concentration required for optimal compaction decreases as cationic charge increases. In addition, the effect of a mixture of dilute mono- and multivalent cations on chromatin condensation is synergistic, rather than competitive as has been found for the multivalent cation induced condensation of DNA or the B----Z conformational transition. A simple calculation indicates that the entropy of ion uptake in chromatin condensation is surprisingly constant for a range of ionic conditions; this factor may be a dominant one in determining the folding equilibrium.     

Contribution of hydrophobicity to thermodynamics of ligand-DNA binding and DNA collapse

The importance of understanding the dynamics of DNA condensation is inherent in the biological significance of DNA packaging in cell nuclei, as well as for gene therapy applications. Specifically, the role of ligand hydrophobicity in DNA condensation has received little attention. Considering that only multivalent cations can induce true DNA condensation, previous studies exploring monovalent lipids have been unable to address this question. In this study we have elucidated the contribution of the hydrophobic effect to multivalent cation- and cationic lipid-DNA binding and DNA collapse by studying the thermodynamics of cobalt hexammine-, spermine-, and lipospermine-plasmid DNA binding at different temperatures. Comparable molar heat capacity changes (DeltaC(p)) associated with cobalt hexammine- and spermine-DNA binding (-23.39 cal/mol K and -17.98 cal/mol K, respectively) suggest that upon binding to DNA, there are insignificant changes in the hydration state of the methylene groups in spermine. In contrast, the acyl chain contribution to the DeltaC(p) of lipospermine-DNA binding (DeltaC(p ) = DeltaC(p lipospermine) - DeltaC(p spermine)) is significant (-220.94 cal/mol K). Although lipopermine induces DNA ordering into "tubular" suprastructures, such structures do not assume toroidal dimensions as observed for spermine-DNA complexes. We postulate that a steric barrier posed by the acyl chains in lipospermine precludes packaging of DNA into dimensions comparable to those found in nature.     

Condensation and precipitation of chromatin by multivalent cations

The condensation and the precipitation of rat liver chromatin upon addition of spermine4+, spermidine3+, hexamminecobalt(III)3+ and Mg2+ cations have been studied using solubility, fluorescence, circular dichroism, melting curves, electric dichroism and spermidine binding measurements, made on both soluble and precipitated complexes. The soluble complexes obtained with tetra- and trivalent cations were depleted from all histones and enriched in other proteins, particularly high mobility group proteins 1 and 2, which brings about an important enhancement of tryptophan fluorescence without modification of its two lifetimes 5.1 and 1.2 ns. In the precipitates the non-histone proteins are eliminated. Under precipitation by Mg2+ ions, the distribution of proteins remains practically unchanged. The electric dichroism and the melting curves indicate that the soluble complexes between polyamines and chromatin undergo important condensation and, at high ratios of cation over phosphate, are constituted by heterogeneous assemblies of non-histone proteins and DNA. On the contrary, the insoluble complexes seem to retain the main features of original chromatin. Precipitation by Mg2+ ions reveal much less drastic changes than those produced by polyamines. Precipitation by spermidine occurs when one cation is bound per eight nucleotides, which in addition to the histone positive charges brings about a complete neutralization of chromatin phosphates.     

RNA isolation and fractionation with compaction agents

A new approach to the isolation of RNA from bacterial lysates employs selective precipitation by compaction agents, such as hexammine cobalt and spermidine. Using 3.5 mM hexammine cobalt, total RNA can be selectively precipitated from a cell lysate. At a concentration of 2 mM hexammine cobalt, rRNA can be fractionated from low molecular weight RNA. The resulting RNA mixture is readily resolved to pure 5S and mixed 16S/23S rRNA by nondenaturing anion-exchange chromatography. Using a second stage of precipitation at 8 mM hexammine cobalt, the low molecular weight RNA fraction can be isolated by precipitation. Compaction precipitation was also applied to the purification of an artificial stable RNA derived from Escherichia coli 5S rRNA and to the isolation of an Escherichia coli-expressed ribozyme.     

Aggregation of nucleosomes by divalent cations.

Conditions of precipitation of nucleosome core particles (NCP) by divalent cations (Ca(2+) and Mg(2+)) have been explored over a large range of nucleosome and cation concentrations. Precipitation of NCP occurs for a threshold of divalent cation concentration, and redissolution is observed for further addition of salt. The phase diagram looks similar to those obtained with DNA and synthetic polyelectrolytes in the presence of multivalent cations, which supports the idea that NCP/NCP interactions are driven by cation condensation. In the phase separation domain the effective charge of the aggregates was determined by measurements of their electrophoretic mobility. Aggregates formed in the presence of divalent cations (Mg(2+)) remain negatively charged over the whole concentration range. They turn positively charged when aggregation is induced by trivalent (spermidine) or tetravalent (spermine) cations. The higher the valency of the counterions, the more significant is the reversal of the effective charge of the aggregates. The sign of the effective charge has no influence on the aspect of the phase diagram. We discuss the possible reasons for this charge reversal in the light of actual theoretical approaches.     

DNA intercalation by quinacrine and methylene blue: a comparative binding and thermodynamic characterization study

There is compelling evidence that cellular DNA is the target of many anticancer agents. Consequently, elucidation of the molecular nature governing the interaction of small molecules to DNA is paramount to the progression of rational drug design strategies. In this study, we have compared the binding and thermodynamic aspects of two known DNA-binding agents, quinacrine (QNA) and methylene blue (MB), with calf thymus (CT) DNA. The study revealed noncooperative binding phenomena for both the drugs to DNA with an affinity one order higher for QNA compared to MB as observed from diverse techniques, but both bindings obeyed neighbor exclusion principle. The data of the salt dependence of QNA and MB from the plot of log K versus log [Na+] revealed a slope of 1.06 and 0.93 consistent with the values predicted by theories for the binding of monovalent cations, and have been analyzed for contributions from polyelectrolytic and nonpolyelectrolytic forces. The binding of both drugs was further characterized by strong stabilization of DNA against thermal strand separation in both optical melting and differential scanning calorimetry studies. The binding data analyzed from the thermal denaturation and from isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) were in close proximity to those obtained from spectral titration data. ITC results revealed the binding to be exothermic and favored by both negative enthalpy and positive entropy changes. The heat capacity changes obtained from temperature dependence of enthalpy indicated -146 and -78 cal/(mol.K), respectively, for the binding of QNA and MB to CT DNA. Circular dichroism study further characterized the structural changes on DNA upon intercalation of these molecules. Molecular aspects of interaction of these molecules to DNA are discussed.     

Effect of Mg++ and polyamines on proflavine binding to T2 DNA

Proflavine binding may be used as a probe of the environment and interactions of DNA. In this paper we report the effects of the divalent cations Mg⁺⁺ and putrescine and the trivalent cation spermidine on the proflavine–Na DNA binding equilibrium. Difference spectroscopy at 430 nm was used to determine apparent proflavine–DNA binding constants K at several concentrations of each cation for temperatures between 15 and 43°C, and at a constant total ionic strength of 0.1M. Mg⁺⁺, putrescine, and spermidine all have greater effects on K than expected on the basis of ionic strength alone in the order spermidine > Mg⁺⁺ ? putrescine. van't Hoff analysis of K(T) enabled calculation of ΔH° and ΔS°, which are affected differently by each cation. These differences are discussed qualitatively in terms of such concepts as release of condensed counterions, localized or unlocalized condensation, hydration, and restriction of molecular and internal rotation.     

Ion concentration and temperature dependence of DNA binding: comparison of PurR and LacI repressor proteins.

Purine repressor (PurR) binding to specific DNA is enhanced by complexing with purines, whereas lactose repressor (LacI) binding is diminished by interaction with inducer sugars despite 30% identity in their protein sequences and highly homologous tertiary structures. Nonetheless, in switching from low- to high-affinity DNA binding, these proteins undergo a similar structural change in which the hinge region connecting the DNA and effector binding domains folds into an alpha-helix and contacts the DNA minor groove. The differences in response to effector for these proteins should be manifest in the polyelectrolyte effect which arises from cations displaced from DNA by interaction with positively charged side chains on a protein and is quantitated by measurement of DNA binding affinity as a function of ion concentration. Consistent with structural data for these proteins, high-affinity operator DNA binding by the PurR-purine complex involved approximately 15 ion pairs, a value significantly greater than that for the corresponding state of LacI (approximately 6 ion pairs). For both proteins, however, conversion to the low-affinity state results in a decrease of approximately 2-fold in the number of cations released per dimeric DNA binding site. Heat capacity changes (DeltaC(p)) that accompany DNA binding, derived from buried apolar surface area, coupled folding, and restriction of motional freedom of polar groups in the interface, also reflect the differences between these homologous repressor proteins. DNA binding of the PurR-guanine complex is accompanied by a DeltaC(p) (-2.8 kcal mol(-1) K(-1)) more negative than that observed previously for LacI (-0.9 to -1.5 kcal mol(-1) K(-1)), suggesting that more extensive protein folding and/or enhanced structural rigidity may occur upon DNA binding for PurR compared to DNA binding for LacI. The differences between these proteins illustrate plasticity of function despite high-level sequence and structural homology and undermine efforts to predict protein behavior on the basis of such similarities.     

The iso-competition point for counterion competition binding to DNA: calculated multivalent versus monovalent cation binding equivalence.

In this paper we introduce an important parameter called the iso-competition point (ICP), to characterize the competition binding to DNA in a two-cation-species system. By imposing the condition of charge neutralization fraction equivalence theta1 = ZthetaZ upon the two simultaneous equations in Manning's counterion condensation theory, the ICPs can be calculated. Each ICP, which refers to a particular multivalent concentration where the charge fraction on DNA neutralized from monovalent cations equals that from the multivalent cations, corresponds to a specific ionic strength condition. At fixed ionic strength, the total DNA charge neutralization fractions thetaICP are equal, no matter whether the higher valence cation is divalent, trivalent, or tetravalent. The ionic strength effect on ICP can be expressed by a semiquantitative equation as ICPZa/ICPZb = (Ia/Ib)Z, where Ia, Ib refers to the instance of ionic strengths and Z indicates the valence. The ICP can be used to interpret and characterize the ionic strength, valence, and DNA length effects on the counterion competition binding in a two-species system. Data from our previous investigations involving binding of Mg2+, Ca2+, and Co(NH3)63+ to lambda-DNA-HindIII fragments ranging from 2.0 to 23.1 kbp was used to investigate the applicability of ICP to describe counterion binding. It will be shown that the ICP parameter presents a prospective picture of the counterion competition binding to polyelectrolyte DNA under a specific ion environment condition.     

Divalent cations and polyamines bind to loop 8 of 14-3-3 proteins, modulating their interaction with phosphorylated nitrate reductase

Binding of 14-3-3 proteins to nitrate reductase phosphorylated on Ser543 (phospho-NR) inhibits activity and is responsible for the inactivation of nitrate reduction that occurs in darkened leaves. The 14-3-3-dependent inactivation of phospho-NR is known to require millimolar concentrations of a divalent cation such as Mg2+ at pH 7.5. We now report that micromolar concentrations of the polyamines, spermidine(4+) and spermine(3+), can substitute for divalent cations in modulating 14-3-3 action. Effectiveness of the polyamines decreased with a decrease of polycation charge: spermine(4+) > spermidine(3+) > cadavarine(2+) approximately putrescine(2+) approximately agmatine(2+) approximately N1-acetylspermidine(2+), indicating that two primary and at least one secondary amine group were required. C-terminal truncations of GF14 omega, which encodes the Arabidopsis 14-3-3 isoform omega, indicated that loop 8 (residues 208-219) is the likely cation-binding site. Directed mutagenesis of loop 8, which contains the EF hand-like region identified in earlier studies, was performed to test the role of specific amino acid residues in cation binding. The E208A mutant resulted in a largely divalent cation-independent inhibition of phospho-NR activity, whereas the D219A mutant was fully Mg(2+)-dependent but had decreased affinity for the cation. Mutations and C-terminal truncations that affected the Mg(2+) dependence of phospho-NR inactivation had similar effects on polyamine dependence. The results implicate loop 8 as the site of divalent cation and polyamine binding, and suggest that activation of 14-3-3s occurs, at least in part, by neutralization of negative charges associated with acidic residues in the loop. We propose that binding of polyamines to 14-3-3s could be involved in their regulation of plant growth and development.