Restimulation of cytolytic T-lymphocytes in long-term mixed leukocyte cultures. 1. Physical and proliferative characteristics of cytolytic T-lymphocytes restimulated at low cell density.

Some physical and proliferative characteristics of cytolytic thymus-derived lymphocytes (CTL) have been investigated in long-term mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). Velocity sedimentation analysis of MLC cells restimulated by homologous alloantigens at low responding cell density indicated that a shift from large cycling CTL to much smaller (probably non-cycling) CTL occurred between the third and sixth day in secondary cultures. This change in physical characteristics as a function of growth phase was accompanied by a parallel change in the responsiveness of secondary MLC cells to a further alloantigenic stimulus; restimulated Day 3 secondary cells gave rise to a transient CTL response (peaking after 2–3 days) whereas the response of restimulated Day 6 secondary cells increased for 4 days and reached much higher peak levels. Repeated stimulation of MLC cells under the latter conditions led to dramatic increases in both CTL activity and viable cell number. In particular, four sequential restimulations at 7-day intervals resulted in a calculated absolute increase of approximately 500,000-fold in both parameters. Cells derived from such extensive proliferation retained their original lytic specificity and were uniquely T cells as determined by surface markers. These results raise interesting questions regarding the extent and regulation of CTL proliferation in MLC.     

Increased cytolytic T lymphocyte activity induced by 2-mercaptoethanol in mixed leukocyte cultures: kinetics and possible mechanisms of action.

The 20- to 50-fold increase in cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity caused by the addition of 50 muM 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) at the onset of a one-way murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) between C57BL/6 and DBA/2 splenic lymphocytes appears to be unrelated to early events in the culture: if 2-ME was present for the first 24 hr of culture only, there was no increase on day 4, but if addition of 2-ME was delayed until the last 24 hr of culture, the CTL activity was almost as high as that of cultures that were exposed to 2-ME for the entire 4-day culture period. The increase of CTL activity caused by delayed addition of 2-ME ("2-ME rescue") was used to investigate the mechanism by which the thiol induces differentiation of CTL from precursor cells. 2-ME rescue was mimicked by two other thiols, dithiothreitol and cysteamine phosphate, but at higher concentrations. Because the latter compound has no free sulhydryl group until it diffuses into cells and is enzymatically dephosphorylated, we conclude that thiols may increase the differentiation of CTL from precursor cells by an intracellular process involving free sulphydryl groups rather than by interaction with membrane sulfhydryls or destruction of inhibitor cells or their products. Cell separation experiments indicated that 2-ME rescue was independent of the presence of B lymphocytes and of adherent cells (macrophages) and was restricted to a subpopulation of T lymphocytes that developed into large lymphoid precursor cells during the first 3 days in culture even without 2-ME. The development of this subpopulation required DNA synthesis between 24 nad 72 hr after the onset of MLC. When 2-ME was added to day-3 MLC, CTL activity increased slightly as early as 4 hr later, but the major increase occurred during the second half of the 24 hr "rescue"period. Because this increase was inhibited by cytosine arabinoside (ARA-C), it seems likely that DNA synthesis is associated with and may be required for the differentiation of large precursor lymphoid cells into CTL after the addition of 2-ME.     

Cyclosporine-induced tolerance in experimental organ transplantation. Evidence of diminished donor-specific cytotoxicity relative to donor-specific proliferative response

Alloreactivity of intragraft and peripheral blood lymphocytes from tolerant canine lung allograft recipients was examined. Tolerance was induced by variable periods of treatment with cyclosporine. Analysis of effector cells from lung allografts (obtained by bronchoalveolar lavage) revealed the absence of specific cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity and the presence of a low level of cytolytic activity detected in a lectin-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay. In contrast, high levels of specific CTL activity and lectin-dependent activity were detected in cell preparations from lung allografts undergoing rejection. Tolerant recipients retained normal ability to generate specific CTL activity to third party alloantigens in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) but had diminished ability to generate CTL to donor alloantigens in recipient X donor MLC. Addition of exogenous interleukin 2 to these MLC was unable to restore donor-specific CTL activity. Lymphocytes from tolerant recipients were, however, capable of generating proliferative responses and lectin-dependent cytotoxicity on exposure to donor alloantigens in MLC. Evidence presented in this report suggests that the lectin-dependent cytolytic activity generated in these MLC is mediated by lymphokine-activated killer cells. Such cells are likely to be activated by interleukin 2 released in the proliferative response. The results support the proposal that the cyclosporine-induced tolerant state is characterized by the relative inability to respond against major histocompatibility complex class I antigens in contrast to class II antigens and/or minor histocompatibility antigens since MLC-induced CTL are directed, for the most part, against class I molecules.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VI. Effect of cell density on response in mixed leukocyte cultures.

Reexposure of day 14 murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations to the original irradiated allogeneic stimulating spleen cells has previously been found to result in the ratpid generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) associated with a net increase in cultured cell number. Under the experimental conditions used, day 5 MLC cells appeared unable to respond to the allogeneic stimulus. In order to characterize further the development of the potential for anamnestic reactivity during the course of MLC, C57BL/6 spleen cells were incubated with irradiated (1000 rads) DBA/2 spleen cells (primary MLC) for up to 3 weeks. At various time intervals after the onset of the primary MLC, the surviving cells were collected and reexposed, at varying cell concentrations, to irradiated DBA/2 spleen cells (secondary MLC). At daily intervals thereafter, CTL activity was assessed using a quantitative 51Cr-release assay system. A paradoxic effect of responding cell concentration on generation of CTL activity was observed; relatively greater increase in CTL activity was observed as the concentration of responding cells was decreased over a 100-fold range. This effect was more pronounced with responding cells reexposed to antigen after primary MLC for 20 days, but was observed even with normal cells. The apparent unresponsiveness of day 5 MLC cells to alloantigen restimulation could be overcome by simple dilution of responding cells. Cytotoxic activity at the time of restimulation with antigen seems to be a major factor determining the magnitude of the secondary response. Since intact cells bearing alloantigens are required for the generation of CTL in MLC, residual cytotoxic cells reduce the effective antigenic stimulus by destroying stimulating cells. This effect of concentration of responding cells on generation of CTL in MLC complicates interpretation of experiments investigating the role of "inhibitor" and "helper" cell in cell-mediated immune responses occurring in vitro. Under optimal conditions, the highest CTL activity and the largest increase in total cell number was observed 4 days after restimulation of day 10 MLC cells. On a per cell basis, the lytic activity was up to 4 times greater than that observed at the peak of a primary response, and the number of viable cells recovered was nearly 20 times higher than that at the onset. Such secondary MLC are thus a convenient source of lymphoid cells selected primarily on the basis of proliferation induced by alloantigens.     

Regulation of human cytotoxic T lymphocyte development by IL-7

The effects of IL-7 on the generation of human CTL in alloantigen-, virus-, and lectin-stimulated systems were examined. Addition of IL-7 at the onset of cultures resulted in marked (up to 80-fold) augmentation of cytotoxicity accompanied by smaller (1.5- to 4-fold) increases in total lymphocyte number. Studies of CTL development in purified lectin-stimulated CD8+ T cell populations demonstrated that IL-7 could act directly on the CD8+ lymphocyte subset to augment cytotoxicity. In MLC, the IL-7-induced enhancement of cytotoxicity was found to be mediated primarily by the CD8+ subpopulation of lymphocytes. Late addition of IL-7 (day 5 of 7) resulted in an increase in cytolytic activity that was associated with little or no increase in total or activated CD8+ lymphocyte number indicating that IL-7 may act as a differentiation factor for human CTL. A role for endogenous IL-7 in CTL development was suggested by the observation that addition of neutralizing antiserum to IL-7 to MLC at initiation (or 5 days thereafter) resulted in decreased levels of cytotoxicity. These results indicate that IL-7 can exert major up-regulatory effects on human CTL development and suggest that these effects are both proliferative and differentiative.     

Limiting dilution analysis of alloantigen-reactive T lymphocytes. III. Effect of priming on precursor frequencies.

The effect of specific priming with alloantigens on the frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) has been investigated. Alloimmune lymphoid cells were obtained from the spleen of C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice primed with DBA/2 (H-2d) tumor cells or from 14-day unidirectional mixed leukocyte cultures (C57BL/6 anti-DBA/2). CTL-P frequencies directed against H-2d alloantigens were estimated by limiting dilution analysis in a sensitive micro MLC system. Under these conditions, an apparent increase of 3 to 4-fold in CTL-P frequency was observed in alloimmune (as compared with normal) C57BL/6 spleen cells. Evidence was obtained suggesting that this increase was specific for the priming alloantigens. A much greater increase in CTL-P frequency (25 to 100-fold) was observed after alloimmunization of C57BL/6 spleen cells in unidirectional MLC. Under the latter conditions, 5 to 20% of the surviving splenic MLC cells could be identified operationally as CTL-P. A similar enrichment in CTL-P frequency was obtained when lymph node, peripheral blood, or thymus cells were cultured for 14 days in MLC. These studies provide direct evidence that the pool of specific CTL-P can be expanded after alloimmunization. Furthermore, the very high frequencies observed after in vitro priming indicate that this system should be particularly useful for future studies of the progeny of individual CTL-P.     

Reversal of phorbol ester-mediated reduction of cloned T lymphocyte cytolysis by interleukin 2

During previous studies on the regulation of cloned T lymphocyte function, we observed that murine cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones progressively lose the ability to lyse appropriate target cells during prolonged (24 to 48 hr) incubation with the tumor promoter phorbol myristic acetate (PMA). We further observed that the cytolytic function of PMA-treated CTL clones can be restored by incubation with secondary MLC supernatant (2 degrees MLC SN), a potent source of cytokines. We now report our observations on the nature of the cytokine(s) responsible for recovery of CTL activity. Like 2 degrees MLC SN, the lectin-induced SN from a cloned helper T cell and the lectin-induced SN from a T cell hybridoma can restore cytolytic activity to cloned CTL treated with PMA. In contrast, supernatants from L929 cells, WEHI-3 cells, and P388D1 cells fail to restore cytolytic activity to similarly treated cloned CTL. These data suggest that IL 2 and/or gamma-IFN, but not CSF-1, CSF-GM, IL 3, or IL 1, can influence expression of cytolysis by cloned CTL. Furthermore, highly purified IL 2 can restore cytolytic activity, even when cytosine arabinoside is present to inhibit clonal expansion. Our studies indicate that cytolysis is a reversible function of cloned CTL, and that cytolysis may not necessarily represent an end-stage feature of CTL maturation. Our studies further show that IL 2 is both necessary and sufficient for resumption of cytolytic function by "deactivated" CTL. As such, these observations suggest that IL 2 can regulate not only T cell proliferation but also the expression of cytolysis by some cytolytic T cell populations.     

Human T cell subpopulations defined by a monoclonal antibody. II. Evidence for cell cooperation in the response to alloantigens and generation of cytolytic cells

It has been shown previously that the 5/9 monoclonal antibody defines a small T cell subpopulation in human peripheral blood that includes all the cells responsible for proliferation to tetanus toxoid and to alloantigens as well as the helper cells for B cell differentiation. In the present study, human peripheral blood T cells were fractionated according to their reactivity with the 5/9 monoclonal antibody and stimulated in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). In spite of a strong proliferative response in MLC, 5/9+ cells generated no cytolytic activity against PHA-activated lymphocytes bearing the stimulating alloantigens (CTL activity) or against the K562 human cell line (NK activity). The precursors of these cytolytic effector cells were present in the 5/9- fraction. However, 5/9+ cells or soluble factors derived from 5/9+ cells were needed to induce 5/9- cells to respond in MLC and develop cytolytic activity. Both 5/9+ and 5/9- cell populations, upon MLC stimulation, were able to lyse L1210 mouse lymphoma cells in the presence of specific antibodies (ADCC).     

Limiting dilution analysis of alloantigen-reactive T lymphocytes. IV. High frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursor cells in MLC blasts separated by velocity sedimentation

A sensitive limiting dilution microculture system was used to obtain minimal estimates of the frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursor cells (CTL-P) directed against DBA/2 alloantigens, after priming of spleen cells in unidirectional mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC, C57BL/6 anti-DBA/2). The mean CTL-P frequency in day 4 to 5 MLC populations was found to be approximately 50- to 100-fold greater than the frequency in normal spleen, and up to 25% of the cells present in such MLC could be identified operationally as CTL-P. Even higher frequencies (up to 50%) of CTL-P were obtained in a population of large-sized cells separated from day 4 MLC by velocity sedimentation. Furthermore, since a strikingly quantitative correlation was observed between CTL activity and CTL-P frequency in such separated MLC populations, it is likely that mature CTL in MLC are not end cells, but can further proliferate and thus behave operationally as CTL-P.     

Cytolytic T lymphocyte responses to metabolically inactivated stimulator cells. II. Effect of a soluble "costimulator" factor(s) in primary and secondary mixed leukocyte culture

The ability of a concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cell supernatant (“costimulator”) to overcome the effects of impaired CD and LD antigen presentation by metabolically inactivated stimulator spleen cells was examined in the primary and secondary cytolytic T lymphocyte (T_c) response. (i) Cells inactivated by ultraviolet irradiation or mild glutaraldehyde treatment, which were unable to stimulate primary cytolytic activity on their own, generated near maximal responses in the presence of costimulator. The 30-fold lower efficiency of splenic membrane fragments as antigen in primary MLC with the supernatant indicated that the damage to immunogenicity caused by membrane isolation was not equivalent to that caused by uv light and glutaraldehyde, as has previously been assumed. (ii) Comparison of the relative effects of antigen and costimulator demonstrated that costimulator played the dominant regulatory role in primary MLC, increasing sensitivity to suboptimal antigen doses 10- to 30-fold; neither antigen nor the supernatant appeared preferentially to control the strength of the secondary response. (iii) Metabolically inactivated adult and untreated neonatal spleen cells failed to release costimulator activity in response to concanavalin A. However, the ability of the neonatal cells to induce a primary cytolytic response suggested that costimulator production by the stimulator cells themselves is not essential for primary T_c activation, and supports the hypothesis that the lack of primary immunogenicity of inactivated spleen cells reflects their failure to induce costimulator production by the responder population.     

Allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reactions in humans: pretreatment of either the stimulator or the responder cell population with monoclonal anti-Ia antibodies leads to an inhibition of cell proliferation

We analyzed the effect of 2 hybridoma monoclonal antibodies (Mab), D1-12 and D4-22, with specificity for common determinants of human Ia molecules, on the mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) response. The results show that addition of either of the 2 Mab as late as day 3 after the onset of the culture completely inhibits the proliferative response generated in MLC. Because the antigenic determinants recognized by the 2 Mab that were used in this study have been shown to belong to distinct Ia molecules, it appears the inhibitory effect observed in MLC containing such Mabs cannot be explained simply by the masking of Ia molecules on the stimulator cell population. In agreement with previous studies by other investigators, treatment of a leukocyte population with the cytolytic D1-12 Mab plus complement strongly reduced its ability to stimulate in MLC. More importantly such a treatment also decreased the ability of a leukocyte population to respond in MLC. In the latter case, the inhibitory effect appears to be directed against T cells since highly purified E-rosetting cells treated with D1-12 plus complement were unable to respond in MLC. The possible implications of these results are discussed.     

Antigen-independent activation of memory cytotoxic T cells by interleukin 2

Culture supernatants from mitogen- or antigen-activated murine spleen cells are capable of causing reexpression of specific cytolytic activity from inactive memory cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in the absence of the original priming antigen. We have demonstrated that memory CTL from cytolytically inactive day 14 MLC cells are induced to reexpress high levels of specific cytotoxic activity after incubation with IL 2. Highly purified IL 2 was shown to induce levels of lytic activity comparable with that induced by supernatants from secondary mixed lymphocyte cultures (secondary MLC SN), suggesting that only IL 2 is necessary for the reactivation process. Moreover, only Lyt-2+ cells are necessary for reactivation inasmuch as inactive MLC cells depleted of Lyt-1+ cells by treatment with antibody and complement, followed by FACS selection of Lyt-2+ cells, were efficiently reactivated by IL 2. Because IL 2 is considered a proliferative signal, we examined whether proliferation was requisite for reactivation of memory CTL by IL 2. In the presence of cytosine arabinoside, which effectively inhibited proliferation, IL 2 was capable of reactivating memory CTL as efficiently as antigen, thus implying a differentiative role for IL 2 in secondary CTL activation. Reactivation of CTL by IL 2 and antigen appear to be functionally distinct events, because antigen but not IL 2 could trigger immune interferon release, although either IL 2 or antigen induced high levels of cytotoxicity. We propose that resting, memory CTL retain a heightened level of expression of IL 2 receptors as compared with naive CTL precursors, and thus are able to respond directly to exogenous IL 2. The consequences of this are proliferation and reexpression of specific killing activity, but this signal is not sufficient to induce immune interferon secretion. Rather, it appears that a signal via the antigen receptor is necessary for release of this lymphokine.     

Generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes in vitro. VIII. failure of anti-RS antisera to inhibit the generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes or cytolytic T lymphocyte activity.

Antibody reactive with "recognition structures" (RS) of mouse lymphoid cells for alloantigens (anti-RS) was prepared by immunization of F1 hybrid mice with parentalstrain lymphoid cells or with antibody produced in one parental strain against alloantigens of the other parental strain. Such antisera prevented generation of the "product of antigenic recognition" (PAR) that is produced within a few hours in cultures prepared with a mixture of lymphoid cells from genetically disparate mice. However, treatment of responding lymphoid cells with anti-RS sera and complement did not inhibit generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Treatment of cells obtained from MLC with anti-RS sera and complement failed to inhibit cytolytic activity of such cells for specific alloantigens.     

Interferon production by human and murine lymphocytes in response to alloantigens

The production of interferon (IF) by human and mouse lymphocytes sensitized to alloantigens in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) was analyzed. During primary MLC, IF appeared in the culture fluid on day 2 and was maximal on day 5. Based on several biologic criteria, the IF produced is of the "immune" type. When lymphocytes sensitized to alloantigens were reestimulated in vitro, IF was produced within a few hours of culture. In all stimulated cultures, cell proliferation was observed in spite of the high concentrations of IF. The IF-producing cells in human MLC were identified as T lymphocytes lacking the receptor for the Fc fragment of IgG molecules (Fc gamma R(-)). Human MLC supernatants containing immune type IF mediate the enhancement of natural killer (NK) cell activity and protect NK target cells from lysis.     

Prenatal diazepam induced persisting depression of cellular immune responses

Treatment of pregnant Long Evans rats with a low dose of diazepam (1.25 mg/kg per day s.c.) from gestational day (GD) 14 to 20 resulted in severe and long lasting depression of cellular immune responses in male and female offspring. T lymphocyte proliferation, induced by allogeneic stimulation in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) or geneic stimulation in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) or mitogenic stimulation (concanavalin A), decreased by 50 % or more over a postnatal period of about 2 months. Treatment of the pregnant dam during the early fetal period, from GD 12 to GD 16, did not significantly affect these immune parameters, whereas treatment during later gestation, from GD 16 to 20, significantly affected T lymphocyte function. Clonazepam, a benzodiazepine with high affinity for the central type benzodiazepine site, also affected cellular immune response in offspring. Our data indicate that benzodiazepine treatment during the fetal period may result in persistent postnatal deficiency of cellular immune responses. The relative role of central and peripheral type benzodiazepine receptor and possible interactions with maternal and fetal pituitary - adrenocortical systems are discussed.     

Response against single minor histocompatibility antigens. I. Functional and immunogenetic analysis of cloned cytolytic T cells

A clonal approach was used to investigate the cellular basis of a T cell response to single minor histocompatibility antigens (miHA). This analysis was performed by functional and immunogenetic characterization of a large number of clones derived from short-term mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations generated against the miHA, H-1.3. Forty-nine clones isolated from such MLC were specifically cytolytic for H-1.3-bearing, H-2Db-compatible target cells. Thirty-seven of the 49 cytolytic clones were driven to proliferate when stimulated by spleen cells bearing the H-1.3 alloantigen in the absence of added T cell-derived growth factor(s) (GF). The remaining 12 clones proliferated only when GF was added. A strong positive correlation was observed between antigen-induced proliferation and the production of interleukin 2 (IL 2) activity. A similar correlation was observed when comparing the ability of both antigen and concanavalin A to induce IL 2 activity from the clones. These data suggest that i) antigen-driven or helper T cell-independent cytolytic T cells (HITc) are frequent components of an MLC response to a single miHA, and ii) the ability of HITc to undergo antigen-driven proliferation is related to their ability to produce antigen-induced GF.     

Proliferation and cytotoxicity of thymus lymphocytes in vitro]

Proliferative and cytollytical activity of lymphocytes was compared in lymphocyte alloimmunization of the spleen and intact thymus. The count of live cells and DNA-synthesizing cells in the thymocyte monoculture was 10--15-fold, and in mixed thymus cell culture--about 5-fold lower than the corresponding amounts of spleen cells. The index of immune thymocyte stimulation was several times greater than that of the immune cells of the spleen. The cytotoxicity peak was observed on the 4th--5th day of stimulation when the cytolytic activity of the immune thymocytes approached the action of the immune cells of the spleen. Low DNA synthesis and a marked cytotoxic activity of immune thymocytes signified that stimulation of the thymus cells in vitro permitted to obtain cell population with a high content of cytolytic T-lymphocytes.     

Immune response to a syngeneic mammary adenocarcinoma. III. Development of memory and suppressor functions modulating cellular cytotoxicity.

Measurement of the development of cytolytic activity by mammary tumor primed or unprimed syngeneic spleen cells on in vitro monolayers of the 13762 rat mammary tumor operationally defined several subpopulations of lymphoid cells involved in the cytotoxic response. In vitro sensitization of cells from Fischer 344 animals injected 2 to 10 days earlier with 2 x 10(7) viable tumor cells always resulted in a higher and earlier lytic response than cells from non-inoculated animals. Adoptive transfer of the same in vivo primed cells for 5 days in irradiated syngeneic hosts removed any cytotoxic cells originally present but subsequent in vitro sensitization still resulted in a higher and earlier cytolytic response. We defined such cells as "memory" cells for cytotoxicity. Memory cells were radiosensitive and specific for the immunizing target cell. In contrast to cells from animals inoculated for 3 to 10 days, cells obtained 11 and 12 days after immunization had a lower response than unprimed cells on vitro sensitization. The anamnestic response could be restored either by culturing 12-day primed cells in vitro for 2 days without antigen or by adoptive transfer for 5 days into irradiated syngeneic rats. This suggests that another population of cells is present in spleen and suppresses the conversion of memory to cytotoxic cells. A more direct measurement of suppressor cell function was obtained by coincubating tumor-primed and unprimed cells on monolayers during in vitro sensitization. Cells from animals bearing tumors for 5 to 10 days always caused an increase in the response of the mixed lymphocyte groups, whereas 11- to 13-day tumor primed cells always caused a marked decrease in the cytolytic response. These results suggest the following interpretation of the kinetics of cell-mediated cytotoxicity to syngeneic tumor inoculation. Cytotoxic cells appear about 6 days after immunization, reach peak levels 2 days later, and then decrease rapidly. Memory cells are generated at a faster rate, reach peak levels before maximum cytolytic activity, but are then functionally inhibited from converting into differentiated cytotoxic cells by a new population of suppressor cells which reach peak activity about 12 days after immunization.     

Inhibition of cytolytic T lymphocyte maturation with ornithine, arginine, and putrescine

L-Ornithine was shown to inhibit the development of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Lymphokines were unable to reverse the suppressive effect, and cytotoxic activity was not revealed by coupling ornithine-inhibited MLC cells to target cells with phytohemagglutinin (PHA). If addition of ornithine to MLC were delayed, sensitivity of CTL to inhibition was reduced after 24 hr and lost by 48 hr. Suppression of CTL development was not due to a toxic effect. MLC washed free of ornithine after 3 days produced detectable cytolytic activity within 24 hr of secondary culture, and to the same degree as the uninhibited MLC control within 48 hr. Cytotoxic cells generated in secondary cultures were Lyt-2+, did not kill the natural killer-sensitive YAC-1 cell line, and were shown to be antigen-specific by virtue of the findings that cytolysis and cold target inhibition were observed only with cells carrying the original, inducing H-2 haplotype. Cytolysis of target cells by normal CTL effector cells was not inhibited by L-ornithine. MLC depleted of accessory cells so that CTL activation was dependent upon addition of lymphokines remained susceptible to inhibition by ornithine. Our findings indicate that in the ornithine-inhibited MLC, CTL precursors undergo clonal expansion, but their maturation is arrested at a precytolytic stage. L-Arginine and putrescine also suppressed generation of CTL in primary MLC, and cells recovered from arginine- and putrescine-inhibited MLC developed control levels of CTL within 48 hr of secondary culture. Inhibition by putrescine was observed in tissue culture medium supplemented with human serum but not with fetal calf serum, presumably due to the presence of diamine oxidase activity in fetal calf serum. Similar to ornithine, the suppressive effects of arginine and putrescine on T lymphocytes were apparently selective for CTL because they did not inhibit mitogen activation with concanavalin A or the production of interleukin 2 and interleukin 3. These findings are consistent with a hypothesis that the inhibitory effects of ornithine, arginine, and putrescine are mediated by polyamines, and exerted on the differentiative stage of CTL development.     

Cloned "anomalous" killer cells derived from allogeneic mixed leukocyte culture

In addition to allospecific cytotoxic lymphocytes, cytolytic effector cells capable of killing a broad range of targets are generated during mixed leukocyte culture (MLC). These cells, which have been previously called anomalous killer cells, are a distinct functional subset separate from natural killer cells or allospecific cytotoxic lymphocytes but display many characteristics of lymphokine-activated killers. In order to isolate anomalous killer cells for detailed analysis, we generated the cytolytic effectors from an allogeneic MLC using heat-inactivated stimulators. This treatment of the stimulator population abrogated the generation of classical allospecific cytotoxic lymphocytes but allowed the generation of anomalous killer cells which were subsequently cloned via limiting dilution. The clones derived by this method displayed the functional properties of anomalous killers seen in bulk MLCs. The clones demonstrated potent cytolytic activity against both NK-sensitive and NK-resistant tumor targets in vitro and also suppressed tumor growth in vivo. Ultrastructural studies revealed features similar to those of cloned antigen-specific cytolytic cells and clones with NK-like function. The cells expressed surface glycoproteins associated with both NK and T lymphocytes including Thy-1, Ly-2, T200, Qa-5, asialo GM1, and the antigens defined by the NK alloantisera NK-2.1 and NK-3.1. These cells may play an important role during early phases of the immune response, since cytolytic cells of broad specificity may protect the host until classical cytotoxic lymphocytes with restricted specificity are generated.