Recollections of the electron crystallographic heavy atom derivative search of purple membrane: the quest for EM structure determination.

The use of multiple isomorphous replacement in protein electron crystallography for phase determination has been systematically studied only for purple membrane, even though the use of heavy atoms or heavy atom clusters has been used on many occasions in electron microscopy for locating domains or subunits in protein assemblies. The background behind the structure determination of bacteriorhodopsin, the protein component of purple membranes, is summarized and an evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of using isomorphous replacement in electron crystallography is discussed.     

Structure of ferricytochrome c' from Rhodospirillum rubrum at 6 A resolution

The structure of a ferricytochrome c' extracted from Rhodospirillum rubrum has been determined at 6 A resolution by the X-ray crystallographic method. The crystals, obtained by dialyzing the protein solution against polyethylene glycol 4000, belong to the hexagonal space group P6(1). Two heavy atom derivatives were obtained by soaking the native crystals in K2PtCl6 and CH3HgCl solution. The phases calculated by the multiple isomorphous replacement method gave an overall figure of merit of 0.90 at 6 A resolution. The resulting electron density map showed the molecular boundary clearly, and gave molecular dimensions of 50 X 25 X 30 A for a monomer molecule. From visual examination of this map, the cytochrome c' from Rhodospirillum rubrum has a similar chain-folding pattern to the cytochrome c' from Rhodospirillum molischianum, the structure determination of which has already been carried out.     

Beta-lactamase TEM1 of E. coli. Crystal structure determination at 2.5 A resolution.

The crystal structure of beta-lactamase TEM1 from E. coli has been solved to 2.5 A resolution by X-ray diffraction methods and refined to a crystallographic R-factor of 22.7%. The structure was determined by multiple isomorphous replacement using four heavy atom derivatives. The solution from molecular replacement, using a polyalanine model constructed from the C alpha coordinates of S. Aureus PCl enzyme, provided a set of phases used for heavy atom derivatives analysis. The E. coli beta-lactamase TEM1 is made up of two domains whose topology is similar to that of the PCl enzyme. However, global superposition of the two proteins shows significant differences.     

Phasing statistics for alpha helical membrane protein structures

In this report we highlight the latest trends in phasing methods used to solve alpha helical membrane protein structures and analyze the use of heavy atom metals for the purpose of experimental phasing. Our results reveal that molecular replacement is emerging as the most successful method for phasing alpha helical membrane proteins, with the notable exception of the transporter family, where experimentally derived phase information still remains the most effective method. To facilitate selection of heavy atoms salts for experimental phasing an analysis of these was undertaken and indicates that organic mercury salts are still the most successful heavy atoms reagents. Interestingly the use of seleno‐l ‐methionine incorporated protein has increased since earlier studies into membrane protein phasing, so too the use of SAD and MAD as techniques for phase determination. Taken together this study provides a brief snapshot of phasing methods for alpha helical membrane proteins and suggests possible routes for heavy atom selection and phasing methods based on currently available data.     

Rare earths as isomorphous calcium replacements for protein crystallography

Replacement of calcium in thermolysin by lanthanide ions has been found to provide a useful isomorphous derivative for the X-ray analysis of the protein. The substitution can be achieved simply by diffusion of the heavy metal ions into the native protein crystals and, as measured by crystallographic residuals, causes little disruption of the native conformation. This disruption is noticeably less when the radius of the lanthanide ion is less than that of calcium. The results suggest that lanthanide substitution may be a generally applicable method of obtaining isomorphous heavy atom derivatives of calcium binding proteins.     

Crystallographic structure analysis of lamprey hemoglobin from anomalous dispersion of synchrotron radiation

The molecular structure of lamprey hemoglobin was previously determined and refined by conventional crystallographic analysis. In this study, the structural analysis has been repeated in the course of developing the method of multiwavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD) for phase determination. New experimental and analytical procedures that were devised to perform this determination should have general applicability. These include an experimental design to optimize signal strength and reduce systematic errors, experimental evaluation of anomalous scattering factors, and a least-squares procedure for analyzing the MAD data. MAD phases for the structure at 3 A resolution are as accurate overall as the multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) phases determined previously.     

Crystallization and preliminary characterization of three crystal forms of human recombinant transforming growth factor-alpha.

Three crystal forms of human recombinant TGF-alpha have been grown from solutions containing 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol. One of the forms belongs to the orthorhombic space group C222(1) and the other two belong to the monoclinic space group C2. Two of the crystal forms diffract to approximately 2.3 A Bragg spacings. X-ray diffraction data has been collected for all three forms. These data appear to be suitable for crystal structure determination, using either heavy atom isomorphous replacement methods or molecular replacement, for phase determination.     

The structure of tumor necrosis factor-alpha at 2.6 A resolution. Implications for receptor binding

The three-dimensional structure of tumor necrosis factor (TNF-alpha), a protein hormone secreted by macrophages, has been determined at 2.6 A resolution by x-ray crystallography. Phases were determined by multiple isomorphous replacement using data collected from five heavy atom derivatives. The multiple isomorphous replacement phases were further improved by real space symmetry averaging, exploiting the noncrystallographic 3-fold symmetry of the TNF-alpha trimer. An atomic model corresponding to the known amino acid sequence of TNF-alpha was readily built into the electron density map calculated with these improved phases. The 17,350-dalton monomer forms an elongated, antiparallel beta-pleated sheet sandwich with a "jelly-roll" topology. Three monomers associate intimately about a 3-fold axis of symmetry to form a compact bell-shaped trimer. Examination of the model and comparison to known protein structures reveals striking structural homology to several viral coat proteins, particularly satellite tobacco necrosis virus. Locations of residues conserved between TNF-alpha and lymphotoxin (TNF-beta, a related cytokine known to bind to the same receptors as TNF-alpha) suggest that lymphotoxin, like TNF-alpha, binds to the receptor as a trimer and that the general site of interaction with the receptor is at the "base" of the trimer.     

Molecular Shape and Packing in Crystals of Soybean β-Amylase

The structure of soybean β-amylase in trigonal (P3₂21) crystals was determined at 4.5 Å resolution by X-ray crystallographic techniques using the isomorphous replacement method. X-Ray diffraction data were collected by the screened precession method for the native enzyme and two heavy atom derivatives. The shape of the enzyme molecule and the locations of mercurial binding are presented. The molecule appeared to be composed of two domains: the larger domain contains one mercurial site on its surface and the smaller domain has another mercurial site, which seemed to be the so-called essential sulfhydryl group. A distinct cleft formed between the domains near the latter sulfhydryl group may be a substrate binding region.     

Crystal structure of haloalkane dehalogenase: an enzyme to detoxify halogenated alkanes.

Haloalkane dehalogenase from Xanthobacter autotrophicus GJ10 converts 1-haloalkanes to the corresponding alcohols and halide ions with water as the sole cosubstrate and without any need for oxygen or cofactors. The three-dimensional structure has been determined by multiple isomorphous replacement techniques using three heavy atom derivatives. The structure has been refined at 2.4 A resolution to an R-factor of 17.9%. The monomeric enzyme is a spherical molecule and is composed to two domains: domain I has an alpha/beta type structure with a central eight-stranded mainly parallel beta-sheet. Domain II lies like a cap on top of domain I and consists of alpha-helices connected by loops. Except for the cap domain the structure resembles that of the dienelactone hydrolase in spite of any significant sequence homology. The putative active site is completely buried in an internal hydrophobic cavity which is located between the two domains. From the analysis of the structure it is suggested that Asp124 is the nucleophilic residue essential for the catalysis. It interacts with His289 which is hydrogen-bonded to Asp260.     

Structural insights into the beta-mannosidase from T. reesei obtained by synchrotron small-angle X-ray solution scattering enhanced by X-ray crystallography

A molecular envelope of the beta-mannosidase from Trichoderma reesei has been obtained by combined use of solution small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and protein crystallography. Crystallographic data at 4 A resolution have been used to enhance informational content of the SAXS data and to obtain an independent, more detailed protein shape. The phased molecular replacement technique using a low resolution SAXS model, building, and refinement of a free atom model has been employed successfully. The SAXS and crystallographic free atom models exhibit a similar globular form and were used to assess available crystallographic models of glycosyl hydrolases. The structure of the beta-galactosidase, a member of a family 2, clan GHA glycosyl hydrolases, shows an excellent fit to the experimental molecular envelope and distance distribution function of the beta-mannosidase, indicating gross similarities in their three-dimensional structures. The secondary structure of beta-mannosidase quantified by circular dichroism measurements is in a good agreement with that of beta-galactosidase. We show that a comparison of distance distribution functions in combination with 1D and 2D sequence alignment techniques was able to restrict the number of possible structurally homologous proteins. The method could be applied as a general method in structural genomics and related fields once protein solution scattering data are available.     

Crystallographic studies of the chicken gizzard G-actin X DNase I complex at 5A resolution

The structure of the chicken gizzard G-actin X DNase I complex has been determined at 5 A resolution by an X-ray diffraction method. Protein phases were computed by the multiple isomorphous replacement method using four heavy atom derivatives. The mean figure of merit was 0.65. Dimensions of the three molecular species, the complex, G-actin and DNase I, were determined based on the "cypress wood" models derived from the electron density map. The natures of the heavy atom binding sites are discussed in relation to the distinction between the two component molecules. The pattern of successive contacts between actin molecules observed in the present crystal seems unrelated to that found in F-actin.     

The structure of cytochrome c3 from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Miyazaki at 2.5 A resolution

The structure of tetraheme cytochrome c3 isolated from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Miyazaki has been determined at 2.5 A resolution by an X-ray diffraction method. Protein phases were computed by the multiple isomorphous replacement method using the native and four heavy atom derivatives, anomalous scattering measurements of the latter being considered. The mean figure of merit was 0.77. Four heme groups are exposed on the surface of the molecule. There are some short helical segments in the polypeptide chain, and hair-pin turns are often observed at glycine and alanine residues.     

Structure of the crystalline complex between ribonuclease A and D(pA)4.

Crystals of a complex formed between ribonuclease A and d(pA)4 were grown and their structure determined by a combination of multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) and molecular replacement techniques. The known structure of ribonuclease A in the correct orientation in the unit cell yielded a conventional crystallographic R factor of 0.32 at 2.8 A resolution when refined as a rigid body. Difference Fourier syntheses permitted determination of the disposition of the DNA in the unit cell. Refinement of both protein and DNA by constrained-restrained least squares procedures resulted in an R factor of 0.22 at 2.5 A resolution. The structure of the crystalline complex is comprised of four ordered oligomers of d(pA)4 associated with each molecule of RNAse. If the sites of interaction between protein and d(pA)4 fragments are mapped on the surface of the protein, they describe an essentially continuous path into and through the active site, across the surface of the enzyme and finally into the basic amino acid cluster on the opposite side of the protein.     

Crystal structure of Clostridium acidi-urici ferredoxin at 5-A resolution based on measurements of anomalous X-ray scattering at multiple wavelengths

The crystal structure of Clostridium acidi-urici ferredoxin has been determined using multiple wavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD) techniques at 5.0-A resolution. The electron density map shows striking similarity to a map of Peptococcus aerogenes ferredoxin computed at the same resolution from the atomic coordinates reported by Adman et al. (Adman, E. T., Sieker, L. C., and Jensen, L. H. (1973) J. Biol. Chem. 248, 3987-3996). Such similarity is expected from the high degree of identity between amino acid sequences of the two proteins. The use of MAD methods has in the relatively recent past become a practical possibility due to instrumental advances enabling the collection of accurate data at several wavelengths at synchrotrons and due to theoretical and computational advances that facilitate the analysis of these data for the determination of phases. These methods hold great promise as an alternative to the multiple isomorphous replacement method in macromolecular structure determination. The present report represents one of the first applications of the MAD techniques to the determination of the structure of a protein which was previously unknown in detail.     

The molecular structure of insecticyanin from the tobacco hornworm Manduca sexta L. at 2.6 A resolution.

Insecticyanin, a blue biliprotein isolated from the tobacco hornworm Manduca sexta L., is involved in insect camouflage. Its three-dimensional structure has now been solved to 2.6 A resolution using the techniques of multiple isomorphous replacement, non-crystallographic symmetry averaging about a local 2-fold rotation axis and solvent flattening. All 189 amino acids have been fitted to the electron density map. The map clearly shows that insecticyanin is a tetramer with one of its molecular 2-fold axes coincident to a crystallographic dyad. The individual subunits have overall dimensions of 44 A X 37 A X 40 A and consist primarily of an eight-stranded anti-parallel beta-barrel flanked on one side by a 4.5-turn alpha-helix. Interestingly the overall three-dimensional fold of the insecticyanin subunit shows remarkable similarity to the structural motifs of bovine beta-lactoglobulin and the human serum retinol-binding protein. The electron density attributable to the chromophore is unambiguous and shows that it is indeed the gamma-isomer of biliverdin. The biliverdin lies towards the open end of the beta-barrel with its two propionate side chains pointing towards the solvent and it adopts a rather folded conformation, much like a heme.     

Analysis of high-resolution electron diffraction patterns from purple membrane labelled with heavy-atoms

Progress in the structure determination of bacteriorhodopsin, the protein component of purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium has been limited by the lack of three-dimensional phase information between 6 and 3 A resolution. By analogy with X-ray methods, it is possible that heavy-atom labelling of the membrane crystal may provide heavy-atom derivatives that can be used for phasing by the multiple isomorphous replacement method. This paper describes the screening of heavy-atom compounds as potential derivatives, and the evaluation of the data collected from these heavy-atom-labelled membranes. Improvements in the methods for collecting electron diffraction data and analysing and merging the data are presented. Diffraction patterns of purple membrane samples were taken at -120 degrees C to minimize radiation damage. About 30 heavy-atom compounds were tested for use as potential derivatives. The diffraction patterns from labelled membranes were analysed by examining 6.5 A difference Fourier maps. Two heavy-atom compounds were selected for three-dimensional data collection at 3 A resolution. In addition, a full set of native data at -120 degrees C was collected to 2.7 A resolution. The intensity merging, heavy-atom derivative evaluation, heavy-atom refinement and the calculation of phases are presented. Phases are compared to those determined by electron microscope imaging, and limitations of the method are discussed. It is concluded that, with the present accuracy of data collection and the present magnitude of delta F/F available for the derivatives, the phasing power is too small. The phases that are obtained are not sufficiently accurate to provide a reliably interpretable map. It may be possible, however, to use the heavy-atom derivative data in difference Fourier calculations in which the presence of a peak would confirm the phases calculated from a model or obtained by electron microscope imaging.     

Crystal and molecular structure of the sulfhydryl protease calotropin DI at 3·2 Å resolution

The three-dimensional structure of the sulfhydryl protease calotropin DI from the madar plant, Calotropis gigantea, has been determined at 3·2 Å resolution using the multiple isomorphous replacement method with five heavy atom derivatives. A Fourier synthesis based on protein phases with a mean figure of merit of 0·857 was used for model building. The polypeptide backbone of calotropin DI is folded to form two distinct lobes, one of which is comprised mainly of α-helices, while the other is characterized by a system of all antiparallel pleated sheets. The overall molecular architecture closely resembles those found in the sulfhydryl proteases papain and actinidin.Despite the unknown amino acid sequence of calotropin DI a number of residues around its active center could be identified. These amino acid side-chains were found in a similar arrangement as the corresponding ones in papain and actinidin. The polypeptide chain between residues 1 and 18 of calotropin DI folds in a unique manner, providing a possible explanation for the unusual inability of calotropin DI to hydrolyze those synthetic substrates that papain and actinidin act upon.     

Solution of the phase problem in the X-ray diffraction method for proteins with the nuclear magnetic resonance solution structure as initial model. Patterson search and refinement for the alpha-amylase inhibitor tendamistat

Patterson search calculations using the three-dimensional structure of the alpha-amylase inhibitor from Streptomyces tendae obtained from experimental nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) data were performed to study the possibility of solving the phase problem in the X-ray diffraction method with protein structures determined by n.m.r. Using all heavy atoms (C, N, O, S) of the residues 5 to 73 in the best n.m.r. structure of the alpha-amylase inhibitor (520 out of the 558 heavy atoms in the complete polypeptide chain), the maximum of the rotation function corresponded to the correct solution obtained by the previous independent determination of the crystal structure. However, additional local maxima, which are not significantly lower than the global maximum, also showed up. Performing the Patterson search with a model containing the backbone atoms and the heavy atoms of only the interior side-chains (399 atoms), which are much better defined by the n.m.r. data, the correct maximum was significantly higher than all other maxima. A translation search for the best orientation of the latter model yielded the correct solution. The energy-restrained crystallographic refinement was performed with this model to an R-factor of 26%. This corresponds approximately to the R-factor calculated for the X-ray crystal structure previously determined using the isomorphous replacement technique, if the residues 1 to 4 and 74 and all localized solvent molecules were removed from this structure. During the refinement the root-mean-square deviation between the two structures decreased from 1.03 A to 0.26 A for the polypeptide backbone and from 1.64 A to 0.73 A for all heavy atoms. There are no major local conformational differences between the two structures, with the single exception of the side-chain of Gln52.     

The low-resolution structure of human muscle aldolase

The three-dimensional structure of human muscle aldolase has been solved at 5 A resolution with the use of two isomorphous heavy atom derivatives. The enzyme's four subunits are arranged about three mutually perpendicular intersecting twofold axes to form a compact spherical molecule. The subunit boundaries are clearly defined but a possible domain structure is not apparent in this preliminary electron density map.