Mutagenic potential of toluidine blue evaluated in the Ames test.

Toluidine blue is a vital, metachromatic thiazine dye which is used as an adjunct in clinical examination for the early detection of asymptomatic recurrent or secondary primary carcinoma in individuals who are at high risk for developing oral cancer. Because available data on the mutagenicity of toluidine blue was limited and contradictory, this study was conducted to evaluate the mutagenic potential of toluidine blue in the in vitro Ames Salmonella test. Tester strains TA97a, TA98, TA100 and TA102 were used. Toluidine blue was tested at concentrations of 0.1, 1.0, 10, 50, 100, 250 and 500 micrograms/plate, with and without S9 microsomal activation, and positive and negative controls were included. Results from tests without S9 showed a significant increase (p less than 0.05) in number of revertants in TA102 and in TA97a with 50 and 100 micrograms toluidine blue/plate, respectively. In tests with S9 activation, doses of toluidine blue ranging from 10 to 250 micrograms/plate induced dose-related increases in the number of revertants in all 4 strains. The results of this study indicate that toluidine blue has a mutagenic effect in the Ames test.     

Nitrogen-substitution effects on the mutagenicity and cytochrome P450 isoform-selectivity of chrysene analogs

Nitrogen-containing analogs of chrysene, 1,10-diazachrysene (1,10-DAC) and 4,10-DAC, were tested for mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium TA100 in the presence of rat liver S9 and human liver microsomes to investigate the effect of nitrogen-substitution. Although these DACs could not be converted to the bay-region diol epoxide because of their nitrogen atoms in the bay-region epoxide or diol moiety, DACs were mutagenic in the Ames test with rat liver S9. Both DACs also showed mutagenicity in the Ames test using pooled human liver microsomes, although chrysene itself was not mutagenic in the presence of pooled human liver microsomes. The mutagenicity of DACs (50nmol/plate) in Ames tests using human liver microsome preparations from 10 individuals was compared with cytochrome P450 (CYP) activity in each microsome preparation to investigate the CYP isoform involved in the activation of DACs to the genotoxic forms. The numbers of induced revertants obtained by 1,10-DAC varied 6.2-folds (109-680) and those by 4,10-DAC 4.8-folds (155-751) among the 10 individuals. The number of induced revertants obtained by 1,10-DAC significantly correlated with the CYP1A2-selective catalytic activity (r=0.84, P<0.01) in each microsome preparation. On the other hand, the number of induced revertants obtained by 4,10-DAC significantly correlated with the combined activity of CYP2A6 and 1A2 (CYP2A6+0.51xCYP1A2; r=0.75, P<0.01). However, in Ames tests using microsomes from insect cells expressing various human CYP isoforms, the mutagenicity of 1,10-DAC was induced only by recombinant human CYP1A2, whereas both recombinant human CYP2A6 and 1A2 contributed to the mutagenicity of 4,10-DAC. These results suggest that 1,10-DAC shows the mutagenicity through involvement of CYP1A2 in human liver, and 4,10-DAC does so through both CYP2A6 and 1A2. In conclusion, our results suggested that the difference in the nitrogen-substituted position in the chrysene molecule might affect the mutagenic activity through influencing the ratio of participation of the metabolic activation enzyme isoforms of CYP.     

Direct comparison of the Ames microplate format (MPF) test in liquid medium with the standard Ames pre-incubation assay on agar plates by use of equivocal to weakly positive test compounds

The Ames microplate format (MPF?) test, which uses liquid media and in 384-well microplates with a readout based on a colour-change, has been used for over 10 years at several major pharmaceutical companies for screening the genotoxic potential of early drug candidates when compound supply is minimal. Meanwhile, Xenometrix has adapted this screen from the two-strain Ames II test for use with five tester strains, in compliance with OECD Guideline 471. A set of 15 equivocal to weakly positive chemicals selected from the National Toxicology Program (NTP) database was tested simultaneously in the Ames microplate format (MPF) and the standard Ames pre-incubation method on agar plates. Such a direct comparison of the two test methods with the same overnight culture(s), chemicals and S9-mix preparation should exclude external variability factors. Thirteen of the 15 chemicals showed concordant results in both tests despite the choice of chemicals that showed varying inter- and even intra-laboratory results in the NTP studies. These results indicate that the Ames MPF? assay is a reliable predictive tool that can be used like the regular Ames test to evaluate compounds for mutagenicity.     

Metabolic activation of 10-aza-substituted benzo[a]pyrene by cytochrome P450 1A2 in human liver microsomes

We previously reported that 10-azabenzo[a]pyrene (10-azaBaP), a 10-aza-analog of BaP and an environmental carcinogen, showed greater mutagenicity than BaP in the Ames test using pooled human liver S9. To investigate the cytochrome P450 (CYP) isoform involved in the activation of 10-azaBaP to the genotoxic form, the mutagenicity of 10-azaBaP using nine individual donors' and pooled human liver microsome preparations was compared with each CYP activity. Induced revertants by 2.5 nmol per plate 10-azaBaP with 0.5 mg per plate human liver microsomal protein showed a large inter-individual variation (42-fold) among the nine donors. The number of induced revertants highly correlated with the CYP1A2-selective catalytic activity from each microsome preparation, and no correlation was observed with other CYP isoform-selective catalytic activities. Moreover, recombinant human CYP1A2 contributed to the mutagenicity of 10-azaBaP more markedly than recombinant human CYP1A1. These results suggest that CYP1A2 may be the principal enzyme responsible for the metabolic activation of 10-azaBaP in human liver microsomes. With regard to the proposal that BaP may be activated by human CYP1A1, our results suggest that the nitrogen-substitution at position-10 of BaP may cause the CYP enzyme-specificity in metabolic activation to change from CYP1A1 to CYP1A2.     

Absence of mutagenic and antimutagenic activities of fluoride in Ames salmonella assays

The mutagenicity of fluoride (as sodium fluoride, NaF) was investigated with Ames Salmonella/microsome assays in strains of TA97a, TA98, TA100, TA102 and TA1535. The concentrations of NaF tested ranged from 0.44 to 4421 micrograms/plate (0.1 to 1000 ppm F), both with and without microsome activation. In addition, the suggested antimutagenic effect of fluoride was evaluated with known mutagens at various concentrations of NaF (0.44-442.2 micrograms/plate, 0.1-100 ppm F). The data showed that NaF, in amounts from 0.44 to 442.2 micrograms/plate (0.1-100 ppm F), failed to significantly increase the number of the revertants over the number observed in the solvent (distilled deionized water) controls. Increases of NaF to, and beyond, 1100 micrograms/plate (250 ppm F) resulted in a toxic effect and a reduction of the revertants to various degrees among the strains. NaF in the presence of known mutagens did not significantly decrease the number of the revertants. The results of this study indicate that NaF does not have mutagenic or antimutagenic effects in the strains tested with Ames Salmonella assays.     

A procedure for the statistical evaluation of Ames Salmonella assay results. Comparison of results among 4 laboratories

Ames Salmonella test data collected in our laboratory and 3 National Cancer Institute contract laboratories were analyzed to study the distribution of experimental errors associated with the test. It is shown that the Poisson distribution is not appropriate, and that the power transformation model Y = (revertants/plate)lambda, with lambda = 0.2 as estimated by the methods of Box and Cox, produced a measurement scale on which the experimental errors could be adequately described by a normal (Gaussian) distribution with a constant variance. The modeling procedure enables one to properly use analysis of variance, regression analysis, and Student's t test to analyze Ames Salmonella test results, and well-known statistical quality control procedures to monitor laboratory performance. The method detects weak mutagenic activity and measures the amount and uncertainty of the increase in revertants/plate. The development of the power transformation model is discussed and examples of its use in the interpretation of Ames Salmonella assay results are included.     

Genotoxic activity and potency of 135 compounds in the Ames reversion test and in a bacterial DNA-repair test

Compounds of various chemical classes were comparatively assayed in the Ames reversion test with his- S. typhimurium strains TA1535, TA157 , TA1538, TA98, TA100, and, in part, TA97 , and in a DNA-repair test with trp- E. coli strains WP2 (repair-proficient), WP67 (uvrA- polA-) and CM871 (uvrA- recA- lexA-). A liquid micromethod procedure for the assessment of the minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) of test compounds, using the same reagents as the Ames test, was set up and calibrated in its technical details. Other techniques (spot test and treat-and-plate method) were applied to a number of compounds in order to obtain more complete information on their DNA-damaging activity in E. coli. From a qualitative standpoint, the results obtained in the reversion test and in the DNA-repair test (liquid micromethod) were overlapping for 96 (59 positive and 37 negative) out of 135 compounds (71.1%). There was disagreement for 39 compounds (28.9%), 9 of which were positive only in the reversion test (8 requiring metabolic activation and 5 genotoxic in the treat-and-plate method). 30 compounds were positive only in the lethality test, showing a direct DNA-damaging activity, which in half of the cases was completely eliminated by S9 mix. Although the experimental protocol intentionally included several compounds already reported as nonmutagenic carcinogens or as noncarcinogenic mutagens, the overall accuracy was 64.5% for the reversion test and 72.4% for the DNA-repair test, as evaluated for 75 compounds classified according to their carcinogenic activity. Quantitation of results was obtained in the Ames test by relating the net number of revertants to nmoles of compound and in the DNA-repair test by means of a formula relating the difference and ratio of MICs in repair-proficient and -deficient bacteria to nmoles of compound. Following these criteria, the genotoxic potency varied over a 4.5 X 10(7)-fold range among compounds positive in the reversion test and over a 6 X 10(9)-fold range among compounds damaging E. coli DNA. The genotoxic potencies in the two bacterial systems were correlated within the majority of the chemical classes under scrutiny.     

A European collaborative study of the Ames assay: I. Results and general interpretation

Results are presented of a collaborative study between 19 European laboratories on the variability of the Ames test. Examples are shown of various methods that are generally used to evaluate an Ames test without reference to a specific statistical model: the number of revertants per plate, mutation factors (increase over the spontaneous value) and determination of the doubling concentration.Considerable variations between test results occurred, between laboratories as well as within laboratories. Partly this was due to different interpretations of the guidelines given, as these allowed some flexibility. The results were also influenced by other factors, some of which are perhaps not yet generally recognized. Apart from the level and quality of the S9 preparations, the most important factor might be the number and physiological condition of the cells plated.When the results from all experiments were considered together, 60–80% of the test results were found within the half- to two-fold range of the overall median. This might be considered satisfactory for a study not using rigidly standardized test conditions.From the experience with the present study, several recommendations are given for the design and performance of future collaborative studies.     

A quantitative comparison of a percentile rule with a 2-fold rule for assessing mutagenicity in the Ames assay

Using a model based on the bivariate normal density function, this paper compares the effectiveness of two commonly employed decision rules for assessing mutagenicity in the standard Ames Salmonella assay. The 2-fold method, which considers a compound significantly mutagenic if its mean number of revertants per plate at any dose is equal to or greater than twice the mean number of revertants per plate in the concurrent control, may be a poor indicator of significant mutagenesis. In the percentile method, the frequency of induced mutations for the test compound is tested against the 95th percentile of the accumulated historical data for the spontaneous mutation frequency. As judged by the higher probability of declaring a compound mutagenic that elevates the reversion rate above background, the percentile rule is more reliable than the 2-fold method.     

Simultaneous measurement of toxicity and mutagenic activity

The assay of mutagenic activity of toxic drugs is difficult to perform and analyze, because one needs to know the kinetics of both effects in order to draw reliable conclusions. This is the case with niflumic acid (NA), which reduced the viability of S. typhimurium TA1535 100 times in the Ames test, but the background microcolonies show no difference from controls and the number of revertants was not altered by the drug. A test which measures the kinetics of growth of viable bacteria and mutants in liquid medium has been developed and applied to NA. No mutagenic activity was detected and elimination of the toxicity from the medium is suggested.     

Optimization of the Salmonella/mammalian microsome assay for urine mutagenesis by experimental designs

Assessing urine mutagenicity with the Salmonella mutagenicity test is often limited by the volumes of the samples. Optimization of the assay was performed with factorial and Doehlert designs. Two fractional factorial designs 2^3-1 (3 factors, 4 experiments) were used to estimate the main effects of the percent S9 in the mix, the time of liquid incubation, the inoculum size and the growth conditions. A Doehlert design (3 factors, 13 experiments) was used to study the main effects and the interactions of the NADP, G6P and S9 in the mix. The positive markers were benzo[a]pyrene (BaP, 0.3 μg/plate) and a pool of smokers' urine (SU, 1.25 ml equivalent/plate). The response was limited to the induction factor (IF, number of induced revertants/number of spontaneous revertants) with Salmonella typhimurium TA98. The optimal conditions for BaP were: a 60 min period of liquid incubation and a volume of 0.1 ml (approx. 10⁸ cells/plate) of an overnight culture grown in 50 ml of Nutrient Broth No. 2 from a 250 ml flask. The S9 mix (0.1 ml, final volume) included 1.5% of S9, 1.0 mM NADP and 4.4 mM G6P. The maximal IF was 15.79. The optimal conditions for SU were: a 60 min period of liquid incubation and a volume of 0.1 ml (approx. 10⁸ cells/plate) of an overnight culture grown in 7 ml of Nutrient Broth No. 2 from a 20 × 180 mm tube. The S9 mix (0.1 ml, final volume) included: 4% S9, 4.2 mM NADP and 5.2 mM G6P. The maximal I7F was 10.95. These optimal conditions did not modify the spontaneous frequencies of the tester strains: TA97a, TA98, TA100 and TA102. The dose-response curves of mutagenic urine samples were found to be non-linear. This micromethod required 8-fold less urine sample and 12.5-fold less liver homogenate as compared to the standard plate incorporation assay and was from 6.2- to 11.8-fold more sensitive to evaluate urine mutagenicity. The sensitivity of this technique was found to be limited to individuals smoking more than approx. 5 cigarettes/day by the standard extraction-concentration procedure.     

The presence of arginine may be a source of false positive results in the Ames test

An increase in the number of revertant colonies in the Ames test is generally taken as a strong indication of mutagenic activity of a test compound. However, irrelevant positive findings may constitute a major problem in regulatory drug testing. In this study, mixtures containing only amino acids such as glycine, lysine, arginine and isoleucine, routinely used as peptide preservatives in polypeptide pharmaceutical products, were investigated for mutagenesis in the Ames Salmonella typhimurium test. The results demonstrated that in the presence of metabolic activation, all the solutions containing arginine induced an increase in the number of revertant colonies in strains TA98, TA100 and TA1535 compared with the solvent control. More specifically, for strain TA98, all arginine doses tested, i.e. from 0.4 to 8 mg/plate induced a statistically significant increase in the number of revertants. This increase was biologically significant from 1.2 to 8 mg/plate. For strain TA100, the five highest test doses, i.e. from 1.2 to 8 mg/plate, induced statistically and biologically significant increases in the number of revertants. A statistically significant increase in colony number was also observed in strain TA1535, but only at the maximal test dose of 8 mg/plate arginine. These increases were observed with arginine from two different sources, suggesting that the observed effect would not be due to the presence of potential impurities in the type of arginine used. Our findings show that a functional metabolic activation system was required to induce an increase in the number of colonies. The presence of vitamin C inhibited the arginine-induced increase in the number of revertant colonies in S. typhimurium strain TA98, suggesting a potential involvement of oxidative stress.     

The Ames Salmonella/microsome mutagenicity assay

The Ames Salmonella/microsome mutagenicity assay (Salmonella test; Ames test) is a short-term bacterial reverse mutation assay specifically designed to detect a wide range of chemical substances that can produce genetic damage that leads to gene mutations. The test employs several histidine dependent Salmonella strains each carrying different mutations in various genes in the histidine operon. These mutations act as hot spots for mutagens that cause DNA damage via different mechanisms. When the Salmonella tester strains are grown on a minimal media agar plate containing a trace of histidine, only those bacteria that revert to histidine independence (his(+)) are able to form colonies. The number of spontaneously induced revertant colonies per plate is relatively constant. However, when a mutagen is added to the plate, the number of revertant colonies per plate is increased, usually in a dose-related manner. The Ames test is used world-wide as an initial screen to determine the mutagenic potential of new chemicals and drugs. The test is also used for submission of data to regulatory agencies for registration or acceptance of many chemicals, including drugs and biocides. International guidelines have been developed for use by corporations and testing laboratories to ensure uniformity of testing procedures. This review provides historical aspects of how the Ames was developed and detailed procedures for performing the test, including the design and interpretation of results.     

Genotoxicity assessment of ethylenediamine dinitrate (EDDN) and diethylenetriamine trinitrate (DETN)

Ethylenediamine dinitrate (EDDN) and diethylenetriamine trinitrate (DETN) are relatively insensitive explosive compounds that are being explored as safe alternatives to other more sensitive compounds. When used in combination with other high explosives they are an improvement and may provide additional safety during storage and use. The genetic toxicity of these compounds was evaluated to predict the potential adverse human health effects from exposure by using a standard genetic toxicity test battery which included: a gene mutation test in bacteria (Ames), an in vitro Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cell chromosome aberration test and an in vivo mouse micronucleus test. The results of the Ames test showed that EDDN increased the mean number of revertants per plate with strain TA100, without activation, at 5000μg/plate compared to the solvent control, which indicated a positive result. No positive results were observed with the other tester strains with or without activation in Salmonella typhimurium strains TA98, TA1535, TA1537, and Escherichia coli strain WP2 uvrA. DETN was negative for all Salmonella tester strains and E. coli up to 5000μg/plate both with and without metabolic activation. The CHO cell chromosome aberration assay was performed using EDDN and DETN at concentrations up to 5000μg/mL. The results indicate that these compounds did not induce structural chromosomal aberrations at all tested concentrations in CHO cells, with or without metabolic activation. EDDN and DETN, when tested in vivo in the CD-1 mouse at doses up to 2000mg/kg, did not induce any significant increase in the number of micronuclei in bone marrow erythrocytes. These studies demonstrate that EDDN is mutagenic in one strain of Salmonella (TA100) but was negative in other strains, for in vitro induction of chromosomal aberrations in CHO cells, and for micronuclei in the in vivo mouse micronucleus assay. DETN was not genotoxic in all in vitro and in vivo tests. These results show the in vitro and in vivo genotoxicity potential of these chemicals.     

A simple modification of the Salmonella liquid-incubation assay. Increased sensitivity for detecting mutagens in human urine

A simple modification of the Salmonella/microsome liquid-incubation procedure improves the sensitivity of the assay for detecting mutagens in human urine. Extracts from cigarette smokers' urine were used as a model complex mutagenic mixture for validation of the assay. The modification consists of adding increased numbers of bacterial cells (approximately 10(9] in a concentrated suspension to liver homogenate mix and urine extract, all in 0.2-ml volume. After 90 min incubation at 37 degrees C, the mixture is processed according to the standard Ames test protocol. This procedure is 20 times more sensitive than the standard plate-incorporation test and 13 times more sensitive than a previously reported liquid-incubation protocol. The number of spontaneous revertants did not increase under these conditions and, compared to the plate-incorporation test, 10-fold less liver homogenate and 5-fold less enzymatic cofactors were needed per plate. The procedure was approximately 14 times more sensitive in detecting the mutagenic activity of benzo[ a ]pyrene. We also used the modification to determine mutagenic activity in urine from a group of nonsmokers. The method may be generally useful for investigations of mutagenic activity in human urine samples.     

A low volume, high-throughput forward mutation assay in Salmonella typhimurium based on fluorouracil resistance

A forward mutation assay based on 5-fluorouracil (FU) resistance has been developed using a strain of Salmonella typhimurium derived from the Ames strain TA100. The sensitivity of the assay benefits from the genetic characteristics present in the standard Ames strain that enhances the response to genotoxic agents. A mutation conferring resistance to 5-fluorouridine was also introduced into the test strain to avoid unwanted toxicity resulting from cross-feeding of 5-fluorouridine between wild-type and FU-resistant (FU(R)) cells during selection with FU. In the mutation assay 1 ml aliquots of exponentially growing bacteria are exposed to the test agent for 2 h in the presence and absence of a rat-liver S-9 metabolizing system. The aliquots are then diluted, allowed to grow for 3 h, and assessed for treatment-related toxicity/inhibition by optical density. The cultures are diluted a second time and grown overnight to permit full recovery from toxicity and to allow expression of the FU(R) phenotype. Samples of the cultures are then plated in 384-well microtiter dishes in the presence of 2 microg/ml FU and the pH-sensitive indicator bromcresol purple. Three days later positive wells containing FU(R) colonies are detected by their yellow color and enumerated. Results were obtained using a variety of 45 compounds to validate the assay. Of the 25 mutagens and 20 non-mutagens tested, the results correlated 100% with those collected using the battery of standard Ames reversion strains, further supporting the use of the FU Assay as an alternative screen to the Ames assay. The use of a single strain exposed in liquid suspension permits assessment of high concentrations of test compound but with a low overall compound requirement (30 mg total). The highly parallel nature of culture handling/dilution and use of standard microtiter plates also offers the possibility of assay automation.     

Some effects of bacteria populations on quantitation of ames salmonella-histidine reversion mutagenesis assays

We show from simple theory that the number of mutants observed in the Ames assay should be approximately proportional to αCn_oP where α is the mutation rate per concentration of mutagen, C; n₀ is the initial inoculum; and P is the average number of bacteria per colony in the background lawn. We tested this theory by carrying out Ames assay for the directly acting mutagen 2-nitrofluorene on TA98 as a function of initial inoculum over the range 10⁴–10⁸ bacteria/plate. P was assumed to be proportional to the average volume of the background colonies and was estimated from 100X photomicrographs of the background lawn. The initial inoculum was determined by counting background colonies in the photomicrographs, by dilution-plating, and by electronic particle counting. We found that the number of mutants depended weakly on n₀, but the dependence could be quantitatively accounted for by the simple theory. These data and the theory explain at least some of the reported variations in quantitation of the Ames assay; show that the slopes of dose— response curves depend on n₀; explain the range observed for spontaneous revertants; suggest some limitations to quantifying the Ames assay and, within these limits, suggest a method for normalizing independently obtained Ames assay data.     

Bacterial mutagenicity of aceanthrylene: a novel cyclopenta-fused polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon of low molecular weight

Aceanthrylene, a non-alternant cyclopenta-fused hydrocarbon, was shown to be weakly mutagenic without S9 and strongly mutagenic with S9 in the Ames Salmonella plate incorporation assay. The compound was most active in strain TA100 (35 revertants/nmole in the presence of 0.3 mg of S9 protein), and less active in strains TA98, TA1537 and TA1538 (20, 10 and 3.1 rev/nmole respectively, + S9). Strain TA1535 was unresponsive, suggesting that this compound induces frameshift mutations rather than base-pair substitutions. The mutagenic potency of aceanthrylene is consistent with predictions of its activity based on the relatively large delocalization energy (delta E deloc/beta = 0.931) of the carbonium ion which would result from oxirane ring opening of the 1,2-epoxide, a potential active metabolite.     

Effects of amount and type of agar on the number of spontaneous revertants in the Ames test

It has been shown that the spontaneous revertants in the Ames test can depend on the amount and type of bottom agar on the plates. The most clear-cut effect was found with the his G46 strains, carrying the delta uvrB mutation, and with the new hisG428 strain, TA102. Evidence of mutagenic impurities in agar has been found.     

Effect of phenolic antioxidants on the mutagenicity of aflatoxin B1.

The Ames assay employing Salmonella typhimurium TA100 and TA98 was used to investigate potential interactions between aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) and the phenolic antioxidants butylated hydroxytoluene, butylated hydroxyanisole, and propyl gallate. AFB1 doses were within the linear response range, and the antioxidants were used at levels of 0 to 50 micrograms per plate. All three antioxidants were nonmutagenic in either bacterial tester strain, with or without the hepatic S-9 enzyme preparation; toxic effects were observed at doses higher than 20 micrograms per plate. Butylated hydroxytoluene and butylated hydroxyanisole substantially increased AFB1-induced mutagenesis in the two tester strains with microsomal activation. The addition of 5 to 20 micrograms of butylated hydroxytoluene or hydroxyanisole to 5 to 20 ng of AFB1 per plate caused more than a twofold increase in the number of His+ revertants. Addition of propyl gallate resulted in only a moderate increase in the number of revertants. Whereas several anticarcinogenic and antimutagenic effects by phenolic antioxidants have been reported, particularly in studies with polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, the enhancement of mutagenic potency of AFB1 by these compounds suggests a specificity with respect to the chemical nature of AFB1.