Alternative reproductive tactics and the propensity of hybridization

One explanation for hybridization between species is the fitness benefits it occasionally confers to the hybridizing individuals. This explanation is possible in species that have evolved alternative male reproductive tactics: individuals with inferior tactics might be more prone to hybridization provided it increases their reproductive success and fitness. Here we experimentally tested whether the propensity of hybridization in the wild depends on male reproductive tactic in Calopteryx splendens damselflies. Counter to our expectation, it was males adopting the superior reproductive tactic (territoriality) that had greatest propensity to hybridize than males adopting the inferior tactics (sneakers and floaters). Moreover, among the territorial males, the most ornamented males had greatest propensity to hybridize whereas the pattern was reversed in the sneaker males. Our results suggest that there is fluctuating selection on male mate discrimination against heterospecific females depending on both ornament size and the male’s reproductive tactic.     

Dimorphic male midshipman fish: reduced sexual selection or sexual selection for reduced characters?

In most taxa with male dimorphisms, some males are large inbody size with exaggerated secondary sexual characters (exaggeratedmorph), whereas other males in the same population are smalland have reduced secondary sexual characters (reduced morph).What selective pressures cause male dimorphisms? Reduced morphologiesmay result when a) some males develop a morphology that, inthe absence of sexual selection pressures for an exaggeratedmorphology, reduces energetic and developmental costs and/orb) some males opt for an alternative morphology that does wellat an alternative behavioral tactic such as cuckoldry. The 2mechanisms could act together, but each alone is theoreticallysufficient to drive dimorphisms. Here, we tested hypothesis\"b\" (sexual selection for reduced characters) in the plainfinmidshipman fish, Porichthys notatus. Behavioral plasticity betweenterritoriality and cuckoldry in an exaggerated male morph (typeI) allows for a direct comparison of cuckoldry by exaggeratedmorph males to cuckoldry by reduced morph (type II) males. Comparedwith type I cuckolders, type II cuckolders were able to remainnear the nest for longer periods before being chased by theterritorial type I male, suggesting that the reduced type IImorphology allows type II males to prolong the time before attackby territorial males. Combined with other studies showing arole of sexual selection in maintaining the exaggerated morph,the data support the \"sexual selection for reduced characters\"hypothesis and elucidate how sexual selection can act in differentways on different males to maintain 2 male morphologies withina single species.     

Experience does not alter alternative mating tactics in the burying beetle Nicrophorus vespilloides

Alternative male mating tactics are widespread, but the cuesthat determine which tactic is adopted remain unclear. Sizeis commonly associated with alternative mating tactics, butit is not known how individuals gauge their size effectively,especially given that size is relative and frequency dependent.One possibility is that interactions with conspecifics are usedto assess size, relative to potential competitors, and thusfine-tune tactics. Success in mating might also influence matingtactics given that this should indicate the potential availabilityof mates in the population. We tested these ideas in the buryingbeetle Nicrophorus vespilloides, examining whether individualsuse the outcome of larval or adult interactions as cues to adjustthe tactics used to acquire mates. Male N. vespilloides employ2 tactics; search for a carcass, a resource required for reproduction,or release a pheromone (call) to attract a mate. Males are plasticin the amount of time they invest in each tactic, and in a relatedspecies (Nicrophorus orbicollis), male size influences the tacticadopted. We examine the potential effects of parental care,sibling competition, relative size within a brood, and adultexperience of agonistic interactions and mating on tactic adoption.Absolute size was consistently the best predictor of callingrate, with smaller males calling more often than larger males.We suggest that the lack of a response to adult cues may reflectunpredictability in the occurrence of social interactions orstable size distributions in this population.     

Effects of social structure on reproductive activity in male fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas)

The selection of alternative reproductive phenotypes is oftenthought to be the result of physiological state, with smallindividuals forced energetically to postpone the allocationof resources to reproduction. However, for male fathead minnows(Pimephales promelas), we show that seasonal reproductive activityis modulated by social status. In enclosure and pond experiments,small males advanced their reproductive condition, held nesting territories, and spawned earlier in the reproductive seasononly when large males were absent or removed from the population.Since differences in the timing of reproduction among smallmales were not size- or condition-dependent, the common explanationfor the selection of alternative reproductive phenotypes, basedon state-dependence, is insufficient. In the absence of large,socially dominant individuals, small males produced comparablenumbers of offspring as the treatment with large males, although the offspring of these uninhibited small males were smallerat the end of the growing season than the young of large males.Thus, interactions among conspecifics may account for muchof the phenotypic diversity observed within and among naturalfathead minnow populations, through their direct and indirecteffects on growth, recruitment and survival.     

An experimental approach to altering mating tactics in male horseshoe crabs (Limulus polyphemus)

Alternative reproductive tactics are often correlated with phenotype, density, environment, or social context. Male horseshoe crabs(Limulus polyphemus) have two mating tactics that are associatedwith phenotype. Males in good condition arrive at the nestingbeach and spawn while attached to females, whereas those inpoorer condition come ashore unattached and crowd around thenesting couples as satellites, fertilizing eggs through sperm competition. The correlation between mating tactic and phenotypemay be due to males choosing tactics based on condition, orit may be that males that have not found a female choose tocome ashore as satellites. To distinguish between these twopossibilities, I conducted an experiment on male horseshoe crabsin the field at Seahorse Key on the northern Gulf coast ofFlorida. I prevented males from attaching to females by placingsmall plastic bags over the claws they use to attach. The resultsshowed that males in poor condition came ashore as satellites,whereas males in good condition remained at sea. This meansthat mating tactics are cued by information about the male'scondition and not about whether he found a female. The evolutionof phenotype-correlated mating tactics can be represented bya model in which the fitness of each tactic changes with conditionand fitness curves cross. I hypothesize that male horseshoecrabs in good condition have higher fitness when attached and that males in poorer condition to better when unattached.     

Polyandry and alternative mating tactics

Many species in the animal kingdom are characterized by alternative mating tactics (AMTs) within a sex. In males, such tactics include mate guarding versus sneaking behaviours, or territorial versus female mimicry. Although AMTs can occur in either sex, they have been most commonly described in males. This sex bias may, in part, reflect the increased opportunity for sexual selection that typically exists in males, which can result in a higher probability that AMTs evolve in that sex. Consequently, females and polyandry can play a pivotal role in governing the reproductive success associated with male AMTs and in the evolutionary dynamics of the tactics. In this review, we discuss polyandry and the evolution of AMTs. First, we define AMTs and review game theoretical and quantitative genetic approaches used to model their evolution. Second, we review several examples of AMTs, highlighting the roles that genes and environment play in phenotype expression and development of the tactics, as well as empirical approaches to differentiating among the mechanisms. Third, ecological and genetic constraints to the evolution of AMTs are discussed. Fourth, we speculate on why female AMTs are less reported on in the literature than male tactics. Fifth, we examine the effects of AMTs on breeding outcomes and female fitness, and as a source, and possibly also a consequence, of sexual conflict. We conclude by suggesting a new model for the evolution of AMTs that incorporates both environmental and genetic effects, and discuss some future avenues of research.     

Alternative reproductive tactics in male eastern gray squirrels: "making the best of a bad job"

Male eastern gray squirrels (Sciurus carolinensis) congregatearound and pursue a female on her single day of estrus. Thetactics of uniquely marked adult males were monitored duringwinter mating bouts from 1986 to 1990 to examine variation inmale copulatory success. Two tactics were chosen by males: activepursuit or satellite. Active-pursuit males were dominant anddefended proximity to females. Satellite males were subordinateand remained dispersed in the female's home range. Active pursuitwas used only by males 2.75 years old. The switch point betweenthe tactics is about 3 years. Copulations were not distributedevenly among males, with about 30% of all adult males failingto copulate during a breeding season. Active pursuit was themost successful strategy, with male success attributed to theability to defend access to the female. However, satellite malessuccessfully copulated due to the escape of females from dominantmales. Females appear to avoid the overt aggression characteristicof the competition among active-pursuit males by running fromthe group of males. Male success after a female's breakawaywas evenly distributed between the two tactics and accountedfor all copulations by satellite males. The activepursuit andsatellite tactics appear to be a conditional evolutionarilystable strategy where young, subordinate males are "making thebest of a bad job".     

The effects of resource availability on alternative mating tactics in guppies (Poecilia reticulata)

Food availability can influence the optimal allocation of timeand energy among alternative behaviors such as foraging, courting,and competing for mates. If populations differ consistentlyin food availability, selection may cause geographic divergencein allocation strategies. At the opposite extreme, a norm ofreaction may evolve such that food intake influences the allocationstrategy of individuals in the same way in all populations.Between these two extremes, food intake reaction norms may divergegenetically among populations. For example, at sites where foodis scarce, selection may strengthen the effect of food intakeon behavior, whereas at sites with abundant food, selectionmay be weak or even oppose plasticity. We tested these ideasby raising male guppies from streams differing in food availabilityin a common laboratory environment on either low or high foodlevels, and then observing them in the presence of male competitors(from the same population and diet group) and receptive females.Males from low-food-availability streams spent more time foragingthan males from high-food-availability streams, independentof food intake. Compared with males raised on the high foodlevel, males raised on the low food level spent more time foragingand were less aggressive towards other males. Courtship displayrate increased with food intake but only in males from low-foodstreams. In contrast, males from high-food streams showed greaterplasticity with respect to male-male aggression. These resultsgenerally support the resource availability/behavioral tradeoffhypothesis while also revealing a surprising degree of ontogeneticcomplexity in a relatively simple system.     

Male tactics and reproductive success in the harem polygynous bat Saccopteryx bilineata

Alternative tactics in reproductive behavior enable individualsto maximize their fitness in relation to competitors in thesame population. In many taxa, territoriality is a common tacticof males to increase their reproductive success. In the batSaccopteryx bilineata, territorial males defend roosting areasfor females against other males and court females throughout the year. Peripheral males in the same colonies do not defendterritories but compete with territorial males for reproductionwith females. In this study, we monitored the behavior of themales in a natural colony over three reproductive seasons.We compared morphological and age data and measured the reproductiveoutput of males adopting the territorial or peripheral tactic.No differences in body size or weight were detected betweenmale types, but the probability of adopting a tactic seemedto be age dependent. Peripherals were often young males andreplaced territorials in several cases, whereas the oppositecase was not observed. Peripherals were not excluded from reproduction,but territorials were more likely to reproduce. Variation in reproductive success was high within both male tactics, andthe reproductive success of some peripherals was comparableto territorials, but, on average, the reproductive successof territorials was more than twice as high. Therefore, behavioraltactics do not seem to be equally profitable in general butmay represent different phases in the reproductive life of manyS. bilineata males.     

The success of alternative reproductive tactics in monogyne populations of the ant Solenopsis invicta: significance for transitions in social organization

Newly produced queens from monogyne (single-queen) coloniesof the ant Solenopsis invicta usually initiate reproductionindependently, that is, without worker assistance. However,some recently mated queens attempt to bypass this risky phaseof new colony foundation by entering established nests to reproduce,although it is unclear how often these queens are successfulin natural populations. We surveyed a mature monogyne populationof S. invicta in both 1995 and 1996 for colonies headed by queensincapable of independent colony founding (diploid-male-producingqueens) in order to estimate the frequency of colonies thatare headed by queens that initiated reproduction within establishednests (adopted queens). Using the frequency of diploid-male-producingqueens among the recently mated queens in this population, weestimated that the overall rate of queen replacement by adoptedqueens is about 0.7% per colony per year. Although theory suggeststhat a change to a novel queen reproductive tactic could beassociated with a fundamental change in social organization(queen number), this does not appear to be the case in monogyneS. invicta. However, the evolution of nest-infiltrating reproductivetactics by queens in a monogyne population and the evolutionof multiple-queen societies may result from similar ecologicalpressures facing newly mated queens. We therefore incorporatethis strategy into an existing theoretical framework that wasdeveloped to explain the evolution of alternative social organizationsin ants, providing testable predictions regarding the distributionand frequency of queen adoption in other single-queen ant societies.     

Alternative tactics and individual reproductive success in natural associations of the burying beetle, Nicrophorus vespilloides

Alternative reproductive tactics can be maintained through differentevolutionary avenues. They can be genetically or stochasticallydetermined, in which case they must yield equal fitness, ortheir use can be conditional, in which case the fitness payoffof alternatives may differ. We attempted to assess the reproductivesuccess of alternative reproductive tactics employed by wildmale and female burying beetles in natural associations on carcassesplaced in the field. A beetle's reproductive tactic was definedby its potential involvement in care of larvae, and parentagewas assessed using oligolocus DNA fingerprinting of offspringand potential parents. Both in males and in females, alternativetactics yielded significantly different reproductive benefits:subordinate females (brood parasites) and males (satellite males)had considerably lower reproductive success than dominant oruncontested individuals. Joint breeding was too infrequent forstatistical inferences, generating intermediate offspring numbers.About 15% of offspring were sired by males not present on thecarcass, suggesting that mating away from reproductive resourcescan produce reproductive benefits to males. Our results, inconcert with the observation that beetles using one tactic canbe manipulated into employing the alternative, support the notionthat Nicrophorus vespilloides uses alternatives conditionally,opportunistically employing lower-benefit tactics when moreprofitable tactics are not available, or as additional "on-the-side"tactics to bolster reproductive success.     

Natural selection of Varroa jacobsoni explains the different reproductive strategies in colonies of Apis cerana and Apis mellifera

In colonies of European Apis mellifera, Varroa jacobsoni reproduces both in drone and in worker cells. In colonies of its original Asian host, Apis cerana, the mites invade both drone and worker brood cells, but reproduce only in drone cells. Absence of reproduction in worker cells is probably crucial for the tolerance of A. cerana towards V. jacobsoni because it implies that the mite population can only grow during periods in which drones are reared. To test if non-reproduction of V. jacobsoni in worker brood cells of A. cerana is due to a trait of the mites or of the honey-bee species, mites from bees in A. mellifera colonies were artificially introduced into A. cerana worker brood cells and vice versa. Approximately 80% of the mites from A. mellifera colonies reproduced in naturally infested worker cells as well as when introduced into worker cells of A. mellifera and A. cerana. Conversely, only 10% of the mites from A. cerana colonies reproduced, both in naturally infested worker cells of A. cerana and when introduced into worker cells of A. mellifera. Hence, absence of reproduction in worker cells is due to a trait of the mites. Additional experiments showed that A. cerana bees removed 84% of the worker brood that was artificially infested with mites from A. mellifera colonies. Brood removal started 2 days after artificial infestation, which suggests that the bees responded to behaviour of the mites. Since removal behaviour of the bees will have a large impact on fitness of the mites, it probably plays an important role in selection for differential reproductive strategies. Our findings have large implications for selection programmes to breed less-susceptible bee strains. If differences in non-reproduction are mite specific, we should not only look for non-reproduction as such, but for colonies in which non-reproduction in worker cells is selected. Hence, in selection programmes fitness of mites that reproduce in both drone and worker cells should be compared to fitness of mites that reproduce only in drone cells. © Rapid Science Ltd. 1998     

Predators, reproductive parasites, and the persistence of poor males on leks

Lekking males are thought to face strong directional selectionon secondary sexual traits. How variation in male traits canpersist under these conditions remains problematic (the lekparadox). Here, we present several game-theoretic models thatshow that avoidance of costly and mobile predators, sneakers,or brood parasites (enemies) leads to variation in female choice.This can result in maintenance of variation in male quality."Enemies" will congregate around higher quality males. Femalesmust then trade-off the benefits of mating with high-qualitymales against the increased risk of enemies. At equilibrium,the models predict a positive correlation between the qualityof a male and the proportions of both enemies and females visitinghim. In the first model, we use this framework to predict thelowest quality male on the lek that will receive any matings.In the second model, we examine the influence of this female-enemygame on the maintenance of variation in male quality. Low-qualitymales are likely to persist when enemies are costly to femalesor occur at high density, and when there is some spatial structureon the lek, so that neighboring males are typically of similarquality. If enemies are more costly to males than to females,high-quality males may benefit from receiving fewer female visits.In the third model, we consider the special case when enemiesare male reproductive parasites. These models illustrate theimportance of considering the simultaneous decisions of multipleplayers in mate choice games.     

Alternative reproductive routines in a small fly, Puliciphora borinquenensis (Diptera: Phoridae)

Abstract. 1. Puliciphora borinquenensis (Wheeler), a very small phorid fly in which the female is apterous, breeds in small patches of decomposing organic matter such as dead insects. 2. Females leave the shelter of oviposition sites during the afternoon and ‘parade’ in exposed places making vigorous abdominal pumping movements which probably help to disperse a pheromone. 3. Males exhibit one of four reproductive routines. In the first they perform rapid sequences of stationary copulations with different parading females, achieving rates of 0.66 females min^-1 for periods of 30min (Al). In the second (A2) they wait on oviposition sites and grab non-parading females which have recently arrived. 4. In the third routine a male airlifts a parading female in copula to an oviposition site (Bl); in the final type of routine, females are airlifted and then deposited randomly when oviposition sites cannot be found (B2). 5. Males are able to learn the location of oviposition sites and this enables them to transport large numbers of females (up to thirty-three per male) to sites at a high rate (0.5 females min^-1). 6. Immediately a female is released after a B routine, the male follows her closely for up to 10s. This is thought to represent a phase of non-contact guarding, suggesting the occurrence of sperm competition. 7. Individual males persist with either A or B routines for long periods (c. 30 min), but they are able to switch between routines. 8. Young males (< 27 h after emergence) carry out A routines 18 times more commonly than B routines, whereas older males carry out A routines only 1.6 times more commonly than B routines. The choice between A and B routines in older flies does not depend on male or female density. 9. Males benefit from B routines because the eggs they fertilize are likely to reach oviposition sites, but they pay a considerable energy cost. A routines, on the other hand, are energetically cheaper, but mated females are less likely to reach oviposition sites unless they are subsequently transported by B males. An A male can then benefit provided his sperm are not completely displaced by the second male.     

Territoriality and male reproductive success in arctic ground squirrels

Although territorial defense is a common form of reproductivecompetition among male vertebrates, the exact reproductiveconsequences of this behavior are often poorly understood.To explore relationships between territoriality and reproductivesuccess in a nongroup-living mammal, we quantified patterns of space use, mating success, and fertilization success formales in a free-living population of arctic ground squirrels(Spermophilus parryii plesius). Because litters of this speciesare sired almost exclusively by a female's first mate, we predictedthat territory ownership would be associated with first accessto estrous females. During the 2-week period when mating occurred,each male in the study population attempted to defend a distinctportion of the habitat, although the success of this defensevaried among individuals. Twenty-six of 28 females monitoredmated with the male on whose territory they resided. However,the majority of females observed throughout estrus (65%; n= 20) also mated with at least one other male, indicating thatterritory ownership was not associated with exclusive accessto females. In contrast, territory ownership was significantly associated with first access to estrous females; 20 (71.4%)of 28 females mated first with the male on whose territorythey resided. In this regard, the behavior of S. parryii plesiusparallels that of socially monogamous birds in which territorialdefense by males functions to deter extrapair copulations byfemales. Although territorial defense represents an important component of male reproductive success in arctic ground squirrels,other aspects of male behavior (e.g., the ability to dominateagonistic interactions on the day of a female's estrus) arealso critical. We suggest that future studies of vertebratemating systems will benefit by viewing such defense as onlyone of multiple axes along which conspecific males compete foraccess to females.     

Fitness trade-offs and the maintenance of alternative male morphs in the bulb mite (Rhizoglyphus robini)

Alternative reproductive phenotypes (ARPs) occur across a wide range of taxa. Most ARPs are conditionally expressed in response to a cue, for example body size, that reliably correlates with the status of the environment: individuals below the (body size) threshold then develop into one morph, and individuals above the threshold develop into the alternative morph. The environmental threshold model provides a theoretical framework to understand the evolution and maintenance of such ARPs, yet no study has examined the underlying fitness functions that are necessary to realize this. Here, we empirically examined fitness functions for the two male morphs of the bulb mite (Rhizoglyphus robini). Fitness functions were derived in relation to male size for solitary males and in relation to female size under competition. In both cases, the fitness functions of the two morphs intersected, and the resulting fitness trade-offs may play a role in the maintenance of this male dimorphism. We furthermore found that competition was strongest between males of the same morph, suggesting that fitness trade-off in relation to male size may persist under competition. Our results are a first step towards unravelling fitness functions of ARPs that are environmentally cued threshold traits, which is essential for understanding their maintenance and in explaining the response to selection against alternative morphs.