Utilization of an in vitro assay to evaluate chromatin degradation by candidate apoptotic nucleases

Apoptosis is commonly associated with the catabolism of the genome in the dying cell. The chromatin degradation occurs in essentially two forms: (1) internucleosomal DNA cleavage to generate oligonucleosomal-length fragments (180-200 bp and multiples thereof), and (2) cleavage of higher order chromatin structures to generate approximately 30-50 Kb fragments. To investigate this component of apoptosis and identify the nuclease(s) responsible, we have developed and utilized an in vitro assay that recapitulates the genomic destruction seen during apoptosis in vivo and allows the simultaneous analysis of both forms of DNA degradation from the same sample. Using this assay we evaluated the digestion patterns of several candidate apoptotic nucleases: DNase I, DNase II, and cyclophilin (NUC18) as well as the bacterial enzyme micrococcal nuclease (not thought to be involved in apoptosis). Chromatin degraded by DNase I formed a smear of DNA on conventional static-field agarose gels and approximately amp;30 - 50 Kb DNA fragments on pulsed field gels. In contrast, DNase II, at a physiologically relevant pH, had no effect on the integrity of HeLa chromatin in either analysis. Similar to DNase I, cyclophilin C produced only approximately 30-50 Kb DNA fragments but did not generate internucleosomal fragments. In contrast, micrococcal nuclease generated both oligonucleosomal and approximately 30-50 Kb DNA fragments. Nuclear extracts from glucocorticoid-treated apoptotic thymocytes generated oligonucleosomal DNA fragments and the larger approximately 30-50 Kb DNA fragments, fully recapitulating both types of apoptotic DNA degradation. Previously, differential sensitivity of nucleases to inhibition by Zn2+ was used to argue that two distinct enzymes mediate approximately 30-50 Kb DNA cleavage and internucleosomal DNA degradation. While, the nuclease activity present in thymocyte nuclear extracts was differentially sensitive to inhibition by Zn2+ during short term incubations it was not during prolonged digestions, suggesting that differences in DNA detection are likely to account for previous results. Together our studies show that none of the nucleases commonly associated with apoptosis could fully recapitulate the DNA degradation seen in vivo.     

Apoptotic DNA fragmentation is not related to the phosphorylation state of histone H1

Changes in chromatin structure, histone phosphorylation and cleavage of DNA into nucleosome-size fragments are characteristic features of apoptosis. Since H1 histones bind to the site of DNA cleavage between nucleosomal cores, the question arises as to whether the state of H1 phosphorylation influences the rate of internucleosomal cleavage. Here, we tested the relation between DNA fragmentation and H1 phosphorylation both in cultured cells and in vitro. In Jurkat cells, hyperosmotic mannitol concentration resulted in apoptosis, including nucleosomal fragmentation, whereas apoptosis induction by increased NaCl concentration was not accompanied by DNA fragmentation. However, both treatments induced dephosphorylation of H1 histones. In contrast, treatment of Raji cells with alkylphosphocholine led to induction of apoptosis with internucleosomal fragmentation, albeit without notable histone H1 dephosphorylation. These results demonstrate that dephosphorylation of H1 histones is neither a prerequisite for nor a consequence of internucleosomal cleavage. Moreover, we observed with an in vitro assay that the known enhancing effect of H1 histones on the activity of the apoptosis-induced endonuclease DFF40 is independent of the subtype or the phosphorylation state of the linker histone.     

The DFF40/CAD endonuclease and its role in apoptosis

The sequential generation of large-scale DNA fragments followed by internucleosomal chromatin fragmentation is a biochemical hallmark of apoptosis. One of the nucleases primarily responsible for genomic DNA fragmentation during apoptosis is called DNA Fragmentation Factor 40 (DFF40) or Caspase-activated DNase (CAD). DFF40/CAD is a magnesium-dependent endonuclease specific for double stranded DNA that generates double strand breaks with 3'-hydroxyl ends. DFF40/CAD is activated by caspase-3 that cuts the nuclease's inhibitor DFF45/ICAD. The nuclease preferentially attacks chromatin in the internucleosomal linker DNA. However, the nuclease hypersensitive sites can be detected and DFF40/CAD is potentially involved in large-scale DNA fragmentation as well. DFF40/CAD-mediated DNA fragmentation triggers chromatin condensation that is another hallmark of apoptosis.     

Characterization of apoptotic pathway associated with caspase-independent excision of DNA loop domains

Excision of chromatin loop domains and internucleosomal DNA fragmentation are widely considered as consecutive stages of chromatin disassembly during apoptosis. We report here on apoptosis induced by staurosporine in NB-2a neuroblastoma cells, which was accompanied by excision of chromatin loop domains, but proceeded without internucleosomal DNA cleavage. In contrast to apoptosis associated with internucleosomal DNA fragmentation, the apoptotic pathway associated with excision of chromatin loop domains was largely caspase independent. We identify here MAPK family member, p38/JNK, mitochondria, and topoisomerase II as the components of this caspase-independent apoptotic pathway. While caspase-independent excision of chromatin loop domains was a predominant mechanism of DNA disintegration in staurosporine-treated neuroblastoma, both caspase-dependent internucleosomal DNA fragmentation and caspase-independent excision of chromatin loop domains accompanied staurosporine-induced apoptosis of promyelocytic leukemia cells. Our results suggest that caspase-independent excision of chromatin loop domains represents a separate cell death pathway, which operates either in parallel or independently from caspase-dependent internucleosomal DNA fragmentation.     

Early-stage apoptosis is associated with DNA-damage-independent ATM phosphorylation and chromatin decondensation in NIH3T3 fibroblasts

Chromatin condensation and degradation of DNA into internucleosomal DNA fragments are key hallmarks of apoptosis. The phosphorylation of protein kinase ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) and histone H2A.X was recently shown to occur concurrently with apoptotic DNA fragmentation. We have used immunofluorescence microscopy, Western blot analysis and alkali comet assays to show that phosphorylation of ATM in NIH3T3 fibroblasts occurs prior to apoptotic DNA fragmentation, nuclease degradation and phosphorylation of histone H2A.X in cells treated with low levels of either staurosporine (STS) or tumor necrosis factor-alpha mixed with cycloheximide (TNF-alpha/CHX). In extension to previous findings, ATM phosphorylation was associated with chromatin decondensation, i.e., by loss of dense foci of constitutive heterochromatin. These results suggest that chromatin is decondensed and that ATM is activated independently of DNA damage signaling pathways during the very early stages of apoptosis.     

Lack of internucleosomal DNA fragmentation is related to Cl(-) efflux impairment in hematopoietic cell apoptosis.

The heterodimeric DNA fragmentation factor (DFF) is responsible for DNA degradation into nucleosomal units during apoptosis. This process needs the caspase-dependent release of ICAD/DFF-45, the inhibitory subunit of DFF. Here we report that triggering apoptosis via a hyperosmotic shock in hematopoietic cells causes the appearance of mitochondrial and cytosolic alterations, activation of caspases, chromatin condensation, nuclear disruption, and DNA fragmentation. However, oligonucleosomal but not high molecular weight (50-150 kb) DNA cleavage is abolished if Cl(-) efflux is prevented by using NaCl to raise extracellular osmolarity or by Cl(-) channel blockers, even when apoptosis is initiated by other agents (staurosporine, anti-Fas antibody). In these conditions, all the apoptosis hallmarks investigated remain detectable, including the cleavage of ICAD/DFF-45. In vitro assays with lysates of cells in which Cl(-) efflux is blocked confirm the lack of internucleosomal DNA degradation. These findings establish that neither caspase activation nor ICAD/DFF-45 processing per se is sufficient to induce oligonucleosomal DNA fragmentation and that high molecular weight DNA degradation and chromatin condensation appear independently of it. Finally, they suggest that Cl(-) efflux is a necessary cofactor that intervenes specifically in the activation of the DFF endonuclease.     

The telomeric region is excluded from nucleosomal fragmentation during apoptosis, but the bulk nuclear chromatin is randomly degraded

Characteristic steps during cellular apoptosis are the induction of chromatin condensation and subsequent DNA fragmentation, finally leading to the formation of oligomers of nucleosomes. We have examined the kinetics and local distribution of this nucleosomal fragmentation within different genomic regions. For the induction of apoptosis, HL60 cells were treated with the water-soluble camptothecin derivative topotecan (a topoisomerase I inhibitor). The genomic origin of the fragments was analysed by Southern blot hybridisation of the cleaved DNA. In these experiments we observed similar hybridisation patterns of the fragmented DNA, indicating a random and synchronous cleavage of the nuclear chromatin. However, hybridisation with a telomeric probe revealed that, in contrast to the other analysed genomic regions, the telomeric chromatin was not cleaved into nucleosomal fragments despite our observation that the telomeric DNA in HL60 cells is organised in nucleosomes. We determined just a minor shortening of the telomeric repeats early during apoptosis. These observations suggest that telomeric chromatin is excluded from internucleosomal cleavage during apoptosis.     

DNA loop organization and DNA fragmentation during radiation-induced apoptosis in human lymphocytes

Apoptotic DNA fragmentation induced by gamma-rays has been compared with the DNA loop sizes in G0-human lymphocytes using pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Genomic DNA was cleaved into the DNA loops at the topoisomerase II mediated attachment points using short treatment of cells with etoposide. The apoptotic fragmentation, with a distinct cut-off around 50 kb for a maximum length of fragments, appeared 5 h after irradiation when the most part of radiation-induced DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) have been repaired. The data indicate that apoptotic fragmentation of DNA in the G0-human lymphocytes begins when repair of radiation-induced DSBs has been completed. Similar apoptotic DNA fragmentation was also observed following the treatment of cells with etoposide. All genomic DNA was fragmented into 50-kb fragments during the final stages of apoptosis. Most of the DNA in resting lymphocytes is organized into Mb-size loops but loops of sizes down to 50 kb were also observed. A sharp border between the size distributions of DNA loops and apoptotic fragments was found. The data suggest that 50 kb apoptotic fragmentation is not based on excision of the DNA loops. No apoptotic fragments with the sizes more than 5.7 Mb were seen during the whole course of apoptosis. This observation indicates that despite intensive apoptotic fragmentation into the 50-kb fragments the chromosomes maintain integrity during radiation-induced apoptosis in human lymphocytes. We propose a model for radiation-induced apoptotic fragmentation in human lymphocytes that involves four stages: induction of DNA breaks and relaxation of DNA loops; DNA repair followed by reorganization of the DNA loops into the 50-kb units of condensed chromatin; co-operative fragmentation of the reorganized DNA loops into the distinct 50-kb fragments and resealing of the chromosome ends at the sites of this fragmentation; cleavage of the 50-kb fragments at the internucleosomal spacers.     

Endonucleases and apoptosis in animals

Endonucleases are the main instruments of obligatory DNA degradation in apoptosis. Many endonucleases have marked processive action; initially they split DNA in chromatin into very large domains, and then they perform in it internucleosomal fragmentation of DNA followed by its hydrolysis to small fragments (oligonucleotides). During apoptosis, DNA of chromatin is attacked by many nucleases that are different in activity, specificity, and order of action. The activity of every endonuclease is regulated in the cell through its own regulatory mechanism (metal ions and other effectors, possibly also S-adenosylmethionine). Apoptosis is impossible without endonucleases as far as it leads to accumulation of unnecessary (defective) DNA, disorders in cell differentiation, embryogenesis, the organism’s development, and is accompanied by various severe diseases. The interpretation of the structure and functions of endonucleases and of the nature and action of their modulating effectors is important not only for elucidation of mechanisms of apoptosis, but also for regulation and control of programmed cell death, cell differentiation, and development of organisms.     

A quantitative assay for fragmented DNA in apoptotic cells.

Cleavage of cellular chromatin at internucleosomal sites is a characteristic change of DNA integrity in cells undergoing apoptosis. We have developed an assay for quantitation of internucleosomal DNA fragmentation in apoptotic cells. This technique involves purification of cellular DNA, dephosphorylation of the DNA ends, labeling of DNA with 32P at the 5'-end, gel electrophoresis through agarose, and quantitation of the radioactivity in DNA bands. This assay, which is about 1000- to 2000-fold more sensitive than visualization of DNA bands by ethidium staining, allows the detection of DNA fragments at picogram levels. A method for quantitatively determining the number of fragmented DNA strands is also described. Application of this new assay to evaluate the time course of internucleosomal DNA fragmentation was demonstrated in apoptotic cells induced by an anticancer nucleoside analogue.     

Chromatin Collapse during Caspase-dependent Apoptotic Cell Death Requires DNA Fragmentation Factor, 40-kDa Subunit-/Caspase-activated Deoxyribonuclease-mediated 3′-OH Single-strand DNA Breaks

Apoptotic nuclear morphology and oligonucleosomal double-strand DNA fragments (also known as DNA ladder) are considered the hallmarks of apoptotic cell death. From a classic point of view, these two processes occur concomitantly. Once activated, DNA fragmentation factor, 40-kDa subunit (DFF40)/caspase-activated DNase (CAD) endonuclease hydrolyzes the DNA into oligonucleosomal-size pieces, facilitating the chromatin package. However, the dogma that the apoptotic nuclear morphology depends on DNA fragmentation has been questioned. Here, we use different cellular models, including MEF CAD^−/− cells, to unravel the mechanism by which DFF40/CAD influences chromatin condensation and nuclear collapse during apoptosis. Upon apoptotic insult, SK-N-AS cells display caspase-dependent apoptotic nuclear alterations in the absence of internucleosomal DNA degradation. The overexpression of a wild-type form of DFF40/CAD endonuclease, but not of different catalytic-null mutants, restores the cellular ability to degrade the chromatin into oligonucleosomal-length fragments. We show that apoptotic nuclear collapse requires a 3′-OH endonucleolytic activity even though the internucleosomal DNA degradation is impaired. Moreover, alkaline unwinding electrophoresis and In Situ End-Labeling (ISEL)/In Situ Nick Translation (ISNT) assays reveal that the apoptotic DNA damage observed in the DNA ladder-deficient SK-N-AS cells is characterized by the presence of single-strand nicks/breaks. Apoptotic single-strand breaks can be impaired by DFF40/CAD knockdown, abrogating nuclear collapse and disassembly. In conclusion, the highest order of chromatin compaction observed in the later steps of caspase-dependent apoptosis relies on DFF40/CAD-mediated DNA damage by generating 3′-OH ends in single-strand rather than double-strand DNA nicks/breaks.     

Spontaneous release of nucleosome cores from embryoblast chromatin

During in vitro incubation of the rabbit blastocyst, chromatin fragments of the nucleosome series are released spontaneously by cells of the pluripotent embryoblast but not by the developmentally restricted trophoblast. The DNA of these fragments is double stranded and linear, and represents total genomic DNA. The fragments are stable for at least 24 hr and are initially found in the cytoplasm of intact cells. The kinetics of radiolabeling of the DNA component of these fragments suggest that they originate from actively replicating cells, possibly only at the time of mitosis. DNase II-like activity, one of the endonucleases known preferentially to attack spacer DNA between nucleosome cores, is readily detectable in the blastocyst, although the evidence for its involvement in the observed chromatin fragmentation remains circumstantial. These nonrandom chromatin breaks, presumably representing an early event in cell death, occur more frequently under suboptimal conditions of incubation but are still detectable in embryos developing normally. There is no evidence for lysosomal activation in these dying cells. These findings, together with previous reports of identical chromatin fragmentation in other cell systems, suggest that this form of cell death in the embryoblast may be only one possible result of an active process, and that the mechanisms responsible for generating double-strand breaks in internucleosomal DNA may be of more biological significance than DNA degradation alone.     

Ubiquitin dependent proteolysis is activated in apoptotic fibroblasts in culture

The ubiquitin mediated pathway constitutes an early response in cultured cells where apoptosis, assessed by internucleosomal specific DNA fragmentation, was induced by serum withdrawal. Data demonstrate that nuclear ubiquitin proteolytic system, but not cytoplasmic, is activated. This activation is paralleled by a substantial chromatin de-condensation. We suggest that chromatin relaxation is causative of the fragmentation since it exposes the DNA to nucleolytic attack. Finally, maintenance of homeostasis and induction of apoptosis seem to undergo a parallel contemporary pathway with a possible mutual feedback.     

Modeling apoptotic chromatin condensation in normal cell nuclei. Requirement for intranuclear mobility and actin involvement

Hallmarks of the terminal stages of apoptosis are genomic DNA fragmentation and chromatin condensation. Here, we have studied the mechanism of condensation both in vitro and in vivo. We found that DNA fragmentation per se of isolated nuclei from non-apoptotic cells induced chromatin condensation that closely resembles the morphology seen in apoptotic cells, independent of ATP utilization, at physiological ionic strengths. Interestingly, chromatin condensation was accompanied by release of nuclear actin, and both condensation and actin release could be blocked by reversibly pretreating nuclei with Ca2+, Cu2+, diamide, or low pH, procedures shown to stabilize internal nuclear components. Moreover, specific inhibition of nuclear F-actin depolymerization or promotion of its formation also reduced chromatin condensation. Chromatin condensation could also be inhibited by exposing nuclei to reagents that bind to the DNA minor groove, disrupting native nucleosomal DNA wrapping. In addition, in cultured cells undergoing apoptosis, drugs that inhibit depolymerization of actin or bind to the minor groove also reduced chromatin condensation, but not DNA fragmentation. Therefore, the ability of chromatin fragments with intact nucleosomes to form large clumps of condensed chromatin during apoptosis requires the apparent disassembly of internal nuclear structures that may normally constrain chromosome subdomains in non-apoptotic cells.     

Initiation of DNA fragmentation during apoptosis induces phosphorylation of H2AX histone at serine 139

Histone H2AX is a ubiquitous member of the H2A histone family that differs from the other H2A histones by the presence of an evolutionarily conserved C-terminal motif, -KKATQASQEY. The serine residue in this motif becomes rapidly phosphorylated in cells and animals when DNA double-stranded breaks are introduced into their chromatin by various physical and chemical means. In the present communication we show that this phosphorylated form of H2AX, referred to as gamma-H2AX, appears during apoptosis concurrently with the initial appearance of high molecular weight DNA fragments. gamma-H2AX forms before the appearance of internucleosomal DNA fragments and the externalization of phosphatidylserine to the outer membrane leaflet. gamma-H2AX formation is inhibited by N-benzyloxycarbonyl-Val-Ala-Asp-fluoromethyl ketone and the inhibitor of caspase-activated DNase, and it is induced when DNase I and restriction enzymes are introduced into cells, suggesting that any apoptotic endonuclease is sufficient to induce gamma-H2AX formation. These results indicate that gamma-H2AX formation is an early chromatin modification following initiation of DNA fragmentation during apoptosis.     

Effect of Protease Inhibitors on Early Events of Apoptosis

Proteolysis is an early event of apoptosis which appears to be associated with activation of the endonuclease which is responsible for internucleosomal DNA cleavage. The present study was designed to reveal the possible role of proteolysis in other early events, such as chromatin condensation, nuclear breakdown, and destabilization ofin situDNA double-stranded structure. Apoptosis of human leukemic HL-60 cells and rat thymocytes was induced by different agents, including DNA topoisomerase inhibitors, an RNA antimetabolite, and the glucocorticosteroid, prednisolone. DNA degradation was evaluated by pulsed field and conventional gel electrophoresis and by the presence ofin situDNA strand breaks. DNA stability was estimated by the measure of its sensitivityin situto denaturation. Chromatin condensation, nuclear breakdown, and other morphological changes were monitored by interference contrast and UV microscopy following cell staining with the DNA-specific fluorochrome 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole. Several irreversible or reversible serine protease inhibitors prevented internucleosomal DNA degradation, nuclear breakdown, and destabilization of DNA double-stranded structure. The effective inhibitors, however, did not prevent the onset of chromatin condensation, nor the loss of the fine structural framework, nor the initial step of DNA cleavage generating DNA fragments of ≥50 kb in size. The data indicate that in both cell systems the activity of proteases sensitive to the inhibitors tested is needed for internucleosomal DNA cleavage to occur. The data also suggest that these proteases may be involved in dissolution of the nuclear envelope. Because nuclear matrix proteins and histones stabilize DNAin situ,and the decrease in DNA stability which occurs during apoptosis is precluded by the inhibitors, it is likely that serine proteases may degrade DNA stabilizing proteins. The activity of these proteases, however, appears needed neither for DNA cleavage to ≥50-kb fragments nor for the onset of chromatin condensation which is associated with dissolution of the structural framework of the nucleus.     

Glutathione depletion induces giant DNA and high-molecular-weight DNA fragmentation associated with apoptosis through lipid peroxidation and protein kinase C activation in C6 glioma cells

Glutathione (GSH) depletion caused by l-buthionine-(S,R)-sulfoximine (BSO) induced apoptosis that was recognized by terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP-biotin nick endo-labeling (TUNEL), nuclear DNA staining with fluorescence dye, and internucleosomal DNA fragmentation in C6 rat glioma cells. The BSO-induced cell death was associated with caspase-3 activation. Lipid peroxidation and protein kinase C (PK-C) activation were observed during the apoptosis of C6 cells, and these events were inhibited by antioxidants and iron chelators without affecting BSO-induced GSH depletion. Furthermore, approximately 2 Mbp giant DNA fragments were observed in the BSO-treated cells. The giant DNA fragmentation were followed by approximately 30-700 kbp and then less than 100 kbp, including internucleosomal DNA fragmentations. Such serial DNA degradation was prevented by the antioxidants, the iron chelators, and the PK-C inhibitors. These results suggest that during apoptosis induced by GSH-depletion caused by BSO, reactive oxygen species endogenously produced cause lipid peroxidation and that the lipid peroxidation induced PK-C activation, processes which are thought to be involved in the giant DNA, high-molecular-weight DNA, and the internucleosomal DNA fragmentations.     

Modulation of apoptosis by starvation: morphological and biochemical study of rat intestinal mucosa

Morphology at light and electron microscopic levels, expression and activation of transglutaminase and DNA fragmentation at internucleosomal sites were used as markers to study the effect of starvation on the apoptosis of small intestinal epithelial cells. The cells entering apoptotic programme in well-fed animals undergo many morphological changes in apical cytoplasm involving alterations in actin cytoskeleton organisation which may cause a discharge of microvilli. Some free floating cells in the intestinal lumen show characteristics of apoptotic cell death, e.g. shrinkage of cell and peripheral condensation of chromatin, while mitochondria and lysosomes remain unchanged. Apoptotic bodies are also seen in scanning electron micrographs. During progressive starvation, epithelial cells do not enter the apoptotic cell death programme. Biochemical markers for apoptosis such as increased transglutaminase activity and DNA fragmentation are clearly discernible in normally fed animals. The percentage of cells labelled immunohistochemically by antibody against transglutaminase decreased during starvation while DNA fragmentation was absent. The exact mechanism for suppressing apoptosis in intestinal cells under starvation is not known. However, the data presented here support the existence of such a regulatory process.     

Dose-dependent zinc inhibition of DNA ladder in apoptotic HeLa cells regulates the activity of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase and does not protect from death induced by VP-16

Zinc ions exert an inhibitory effect on Ca(2+)Mg(2+)-dependent endonuclease which is supposed to be responsible for the fragmentation of DNA during apoptosis. In the experimental system we used, that is HeLa cells treated with VP-16, the protection from internucleosomal DNA degradation is modulated by Zn concentration and appears to be dependent on the time after treatment. This effect does not prevent cell death or occurrence of apoptotic parameters, suggesting that DNA ladder appearance is not a crucial event in apoptosis. The activation of poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase following the administration of VP-16, is not observed in cells in which DNA fragmentation has been abolished by zinc, supporting the hypothesis that this event is regulated by the appearance of small-sized DNA fragments.     

Cleavage of Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase measured in situ in individual cells: relationship to DNA fragmentation and cell cycle position during apoptosis

Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP), a nuclear enzyme involved in DNA repair, is a target of caspases during apoptosis: its cleavage onto 89- and 24-kDa fragments is considered to be a hallmark of the apoptotic mode of cell death. Another hallmark is the activation of endonuclease which targets internucleosomal DNA. The aim of the present study was to reveal cell cycle phase specificity as well as the temporal and sequence relationships of PARP cleavage vis-à-vis DNA fragmentation in two model systems of apoptosis, one induced by DNA damage via cell treatment with camptothecin (CPT) (mitochondria-induced pathway) and another by the cytotoxic ligand tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) (cell surface death receptor pathway). PARP cleavage was detected immunocytochemically using antibody which recognizes its 89-kDa fragment (PARP p89) while DNA fragmentation was assayed by in situ labeling of DNA strand breaks. The frequency and extent of PARP cleavage as well as DNA fragmentation were measured by mutiparameter flow and laser scanning cytometry. PARP cleavage, selective to S phase cells, was detected 90 min after administration of CPT. PARP cleavage in the cells treated with TNF-alpha was not selective to any cell cycle phase and was seen already after 30 min. DNA fragmentation trailed PARP cleavage by about 30 min and showed a similar pattern of cell cycle specificity. PARP p89 was present in nuclear chromatin but at least in the early phase of apoptosis it did not colocalize with DNA strand breaks. The rate of cleavage of PARP molecules in individual cells whether induced by CPT or TNF-alpha was rapid as reflected by the paucity of cells with a mixture of cleaved and noncleaved PARP molecules. In contrast, DNA fragmentation proceeded stepwise before reaching the maximal number of DNA strand breaks. Although time windows for PARP cleavage vs DNA fragmentation were different at early stages of apoptosis, a good overall correlation between the cytometric assays of apoptotic cells identification based on these events was observed in both CPT- and TNF-alpha-treated cultures.