Nucleotide sequence structure and consistency of a developmentally regulated DNA deletion in Tetrahymena thermophila.

DNA deletion by site-specific chromosome breakage and rejoining occurs extensively during macronuclear development in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. We have sequenced both the micronuclear (germ line) and rearranged macronuclear (somatic) forms of one region from which 1.1 kilobases of micronuclear DNA are reproducibly deleted during macronuclear development. The deletion junctions lie within a pair of 6-base-pair direct repeats. The termini of the deleted sequence are not inverted repeats. The precision of deletion at the nucleotide level was also characterized by hybridization with a synthetic oligonucleotide matching the determined macronuclear (rejoined) junction sequence. This deletion occurs in a remarkably sequence-specific manner. However, a very minor degree of variability in the macronuclear junction sequences was detected and was shown to be inherent in the mechanism of deletion itself. These results suggest that DNA deletion during macronuclear development in T. thermophila may constitute a novel type of DNA recombination and that it can create sequence heterogeneity on the order of a few base pairs at rejoining junctions.     

A family of DNA sequences is reproducibly rearranged in the somatic nucleus of Tetrahymena.

A small family of DNA sequences is rearranged during the development of the somatic nucleus in Tetrahymena. The family is defined by 266 bp of highly conserved sequence which restriction mapping, hybridization and sequence analysis have shown is shared by a cloned micronuclear fragment and three sequences which constitute the macronuclear family. Genomic Southern hybridization experiments indicate there are five members of the family in micronuclear DNA. All of the family members are present in whole genome homozygotes and are therefore nonallelic. The three macronuclear sequences are all present in clonal cell lines and are reproducibly generated in every developing macronucleus. The rearrangement event begins 14 hours after conjugation is initiated and is nearly completed by 16 hours.     

A micronucleus-limited sequence family in Tetrahymena thermophila: organization and sequence conservation.

During macronuclear development in the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila, sequence reorganization including sequence loss occurs. Addressing questions about the organization and nucleotide sequence of micronucleus limited regions can lead to insights about mechanisms of DNA rearrangements during macronuclear development as well as mechanisms for the maintenance of the stability of micronucleus-limited sequence families. We have previously identified a moderately repetitive micronucleus-limited sequence family called X-H (family members hybridize to an approximately 450 bp Xbal-HindIII restriction fragment), completely absent from macronuclear DNA. The first member of this family which we isolated is associated with terminal sequences characteristic of a Tel-1 element, a putative micronuclear transposable element. Two additional family members have been isolated which are not closely associated with Tel-1 terminal sequences. We have nucleotide sequence data for three cloned members of the X-H family. This analysis has demonstrated that the longest cloned members of the X-H family share a region of homology of approximately 2,400 bp and are highly conserved, differing only by small insertions or deletions of 100 bp or less. The sequences from one of the sequenced family members flanking the region of homology are themselves mostly micronucleus-limited.     

Sequence microheterogeneity is generated at junctions of programmed DNA deletions in Tetrahymena thermophila.

Regulated DNA deletions are known to occur to thousands of specific DNA segments in Tetrahymena during macronuclear development. In this study we determined the precision of this event by examining the junction sequences produced by three different deletions in many independent caryonidal lines. 0.9 kb deletions in region M produce at least 3 types of junction sequences, of which two have been determined and found to be different by 4 bp. The alternative 0.6 kb deletions in this region are much less variable. 1.1 kb deletions in region R, known from a previous study to be slightly variable, produce two types of junction sequences which are different from each other by 3 bp. Thus, developmentally regulated deletions in Tetrahymena can produce sequence microheterogeneity at their junctions. This process contributes significantly to the diversification of Tetrahymena's somatic genome.     

Lia1p, a novel protein required during nuclear differentiation for genome-wide DNA rearrangements in Tetrahymena thermophila

Extensive genome-wide rearrangements occur during somatic macronuclear development in Tetrahymena thermophila. These events are guided by RNA interference-directed chromatin modification including histone H3 lysine 9 methylation, which marks specific germ line-limited internal eliminated sequences (IESs) for excision. Several genes putatively involved in these developmental genome rearrangements were identified based on their proteins' localization to differentiating somatic nuclei, and here we demonstrate that one, LIA1, encodes a novel protein that is an essential component of the genome rearrangement machinery. A green fluorescent protein-Lia1 fusion protein exhibited dynamic nuclear localization during development that has striking similarity to that of the dual chromodomain-containing DNA rearrangement protein, Pdd1p. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments showed that Lia1p associates with Pdd1p and IES chromatin during macronuclear development. Cell lines in which we disrupted both the germ line and somatic copies of LIA1 (DeltaLIA1) grew normally but were unable to generate viable progeny, arresting late in development just prior to returning to vegetative growth. These mutant lines failed to properly form Pdd1p-containing nuclear structures and eliminate IESs despite showing normal levels of H3K9 methylation. These data indicate that Lia1p is required late in conjugation for the reorganization of the Tetrahymena genome.     

Evolutionary Conservation of Sequences Directing Chromosome Breakage and Rdna Palindrome Formation in Tetrahymenine Ciliates

Extensive, programmed chromosome breakage occurs during formation of the somatic macronucleus of ciliated protozoa. The cis-acting signal directing breakage has been most rigorously defined in Tetrahymena thermophila, where it consists of a 15-bp DNA sequence known as Cbs, for chromosome breakage sequence. We have identified sequences identical or nearly identical to the T. thermophila Cbs at sites of breakage flanking the germline micronuclear rDNA locus of six additional species of Tetrahymena as well as members of two related genera. Other general features of the breakage site are also conserved, but surprisingly, the orientation and number of copies of Cbs are not always conserved, suggesting the occurrence of germline rearrangement events over evolutionary time. At one end of the T. thermophila micronuclear rDNA locus, a pair of short inverted repeats adjacent to Cbs directs the formation of a giant palindromic molecule. We have examined the corresponding sequences from two other Tetrahymena species. We find the sequence to be partially conserved, as previously implied from analysis of macronuclear rDNA, but of variable length and organization.     

DNA elimination in Tetrahymena: a developmental process involving extensive breakage and rejoining of DNA at defined sites

Elimination of specific DNA sequences occurs during macronuclear development in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. Recombinant DNA clones containing a segment of micronuclear (germinal) DNA involved in elimination and the corresponding segment of macronuclear (somatic) DNA produced after elimination were isolated. Detailed comparisons of the cloned DNAs, as well as the genomic DNAs, by hybridization indicated that DNA elimination is accompanied by specific DNA rearrangements. In this 9.5 kb region three defined DNA segments are deleted and the remaining sequences are linked together as one contiguous piece in the macronucleus. Specific DNA rearrangement of this kind occurs widely in the genome. Analysis of 20 randomly selected DNA clones suggests that there are more than 5000 such rearrangement sites in the genome. Thus specific breakage and rejoining of DNA occurs extensively during development, and might play an essential role in nuclear differentiation.     

Sequence-specific epigenetic effects of the maternal somatic genome on developmental rearrangements of the zygotic genome in Paramecium primaurelia.

In ciliates, the germ line genome is extensively rearranged during the development of the somatic macronucleus from a mitotic product of the zygotic nucleus. Germ line chromosomes are fragmented in specific regions, and a large number of internal sequence elements are eliminated. It was previously shown that transformation of the vegetative macronucleus of Paramecium primaurelia with a plasmid containing a subtelomeric surface antigen gene can affect the processing of the homologous germ line genomic region during development of a new macronucleus in sexual progeny of transformed clones. The gene and telomere-proximal flanking sequences are deleted from the new macronuclear genome, although the germ line genome remains wild type. Here we show that plasmids containing nonoverlapping segments of the same genomic region are able to induce similar terminal deletions; the locations of deletion end points depend on the particular sequence used. Transformation of the maternal macronucleus with a sequence internal to a macronuclear chromosome also causes the occurrence of internal deletions between short direct repeats composed of alternating thymines and adenines. The epigenetic influence of maternal macronuclear sequences on developmental rearrangements of the zygotic genome thus appears to be both sequence specific and general, suggesting that this trans-nucleus effect is mediated by pairing of homologous sequences.     

A micronucleus-limited sequence family in Tetrahymena thermophila: Organization and sequence conservation

During mocronuclear development in the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila, sequence reorganization including sequence loss occurs. Addressing questions about the organization and nucleotide sequence of micronucleus limited regions can lead to insights about mechanisms of DNA rearrangements during macronuclear development as well as mechanisms for the maintenance of the stability of micronucleus-limited sequence families. We have previously identified a moderately repetitive micronu-cleus-limited sequence family called X-H (family members hybridize to an approximately 450 bp Xbal-HindIII restriction fragment), completely absent from macronuclear DNA. The first member of this family which we isolated is associated with terminal sequences characteristic of a Tel-1 element, a putative micronuclear transposable element. Two additional family members have been isolated which are not closely associated with Tel-1 terminal sequences. We have nucleotide sequence data for three cloned members of the X-H family. This analysis has demonstrated that the longest cloned members of the X-H family share a region of homology of approximately 2,400 bp and are highly conserved, differing only by small insertions or deletions of 100 bp or less. The sequences from one of the sequenced family members flanking the region of homology are themselves mostly micronucleus-limited. © 1992 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Genomic Organization and Developmental Fate of Adjacent Repeated Sequences in a Foldback DNA Clone of Tetrahymena thermophila

DNA sequence elimination and rearrangement occurs during the development of somatic cell lineages of eukaryotes and was first discovered over a century ago. However, the significance and mechanism of chromatin elimination are not understood. DNA elimination also occurs during the development of the somatic macronucleus from the germinal micronucleus in unicellular ciliated protozoa such as Tetrahymena thermophila. In this study foldback DNA from the micronucleus was used as a probe to isolate ten clones. All of those tested (4/4) contained sequences that were repetitive in the micronucleus and rearranged in the macronucleus. The presence of inverted repeated sequences was clearly demonstrated in one of them by electron microscopy. DNA sequence analysis showed that the left portion of this clone contains three tandem, directly repeated copies of a 340-bp sequence, a 120-bp portion of which appears in inverted orientation at a 1.6-kb distance. This clone, pTtFB1, was subjected to a detailed analysis of its developmental fate. Subregions were subcloned and used as probes against Southern blots of micronuclear and macronuclear DNA. We found that all subregions defined repeated sequence families in the micronuclear genome. A minimum of four different families was defined, two of which are retained in the macronucleus and two of which are completely eliminated. The inverted repeat family is retained with little rearrangement. Two of the families, defined by subregions that do not contain parts of the inverted repeat, one in the "loop" and one in the "right flanking region," are totally eliminated during macronuclear development--and contain open reading frames. A fourth family occurs in the "loop" region and is rearranged extensively during development. The two gene families that are eliminated are stable in the micronuclear genome but are not clustered together as evidenced by experiments in which DNAs from nullisomic strains are used to map family members to specific micronuclear chromosomes. The inverted repeat family is also stable in the micronuclear genome and is dispersed among several chromosomes. The significance of retained inverted repeats to the process of elimination is discussed.     

A small family of elements with long inverted repeats is located near sites of developmentally regulated DNA rearrangement in Tetrahymena thermophila.

Extensive DNA rearrangement occurs during the development of the somatic macronucleus from the germ line micronucleus in ciliated protozoans. The micronuclear junctions and the macronuclear product of a developmentally regulated DNA rearrangement in Tetrahymena thermophila, Tlr1, have been cloned. The intrachromosomal rearrangement joins sequences that are separated by more than 13 kb in the micronucleus with the elimination of moderately repeated micronucleus-specific DNA sequences. There is a long, 825-bp, inverted repeat near the micronuclear junctions. The inverted repeat contains two different 19-bp tandem repeats. The 19-bp repeats are associated with each other and with DNA rearrangements at seven locations in the micronuclear genome. Southern blot analysis is consistent with the occurrence of the 19-bp repeats within pairs of larger repeated sequences. Another family member was isolated. The 19-mers in that clone are also in close proximity to a rearrangement junction. We propose that the 19-mers define a small family of developmentally regulated DNA rearrangements having elements with long inverted repeats near the junction sites. We discuss the possibility that transposable elements evolve by capture of molecular machinery required for essential cellular functions.     

The transition from conjugal development to the first vegetative cell division is dependent on RAD51 expression in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila

Rad51p, the eukaryotic homolog of the prokaryotic recA protein, catalyzes strand exchange between single- and double-stranded DNA and is involved in both genetic recombination and double-strand break repair in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. We have previously shown that disruption of the Tetrahymena RAD51 somatic macronuclear locus leads to defective germline micronuclear division and that conjugation of two somatic rad51 null strains results in an early meiotic arrest. We have constructed Tetrahymena strains that are capable of RAD51 expression from their parental macronuclei and are homozygous, rad51 nulls in their germline micronuclei. These rad51 null heterokaryons complete all of the early and middle stages of conjugation, including meiosis, haploid nuclear exchange, zygotic fusion, and the programmed chromosome fragmentations, sequence eliminations, and rDNA amplification that occur during macronuclear development. However, the rad51 null progeny fail to initiate the first vegetative cell division following conjugal development. Coincident with the developmental arrest is a disproportionate amplification of rDNA, despite the maintenance of normal total DNA content in the developing macronuclei. Fusion of arrested rad51 null exconjugants to wild-type cells is sufficient to overcome the arrest. Cells rescued by cytoplasmic fusion continue to divide, eventually recapitulating the micronuclear mitotic defects described previously for rad51 somatic nulls.     

Flanking Regulatory Sequences of the Tetrahymena R Deletion Element Determine the Boundaries of DNA Rearrangement

In the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila, thousands of DNA segments of variable size are eliminated from the developing somatic macronucleus by specific DNA rearrangements. It is unclear whether rearrangement of the many different DNA elements occurs via a single mechanism or via multiple rearrangement systems. In this study, we characterized in vivo cis-acting sequences required for the rearrangement of the 1.1-kbp R deletion element. We found that rearrangement requires specific sequences flanking each side of the deletion element. The required sequences on the left side appear to span roughly a 70-bp region that is located at least 30 bp from the rearrangement boundary. When we moved the location of the left cis-acting sequences closer to the eliminated region, we observed a rightward shift of the rearrangement boundary such that the newly formed deletion junction retained its original distance from this flanking region. Likewise, when we moved the flanking region as much as 500 bp away from the deletion element, the rearrangement boundary shifted to remain in relative juxtaposition. Clusters of base substitutions made throughout this critical flanking region did not affect rearrangement efficiency or accuracy, which suggests a complex nature for this regulatory sequence. We also found that the right flanking region effectively replaced the essential sequences identified on the left side, and thus, the two flanking regions contain sequences of analogous function despite the lack of obvious sequence identity. These data taken together indicate that the R-element flanking regions contain sequences that position the rearrangement boundaries from a short distance away. Previously, a 10-bp polypurine tract flanking the M-deletion element was demonstrated to act from a distance to determine its rearrangement boundaries. No apparent sequence similarity exists between the M and R elements. The functional similarity between these different cis-acting sequences of the two elements is firm support for a common mechanism controlling Tetrahymena rearrangement.     

Evolution of Germline-Limited Sequences in Two Populations of the Ciliate Chilodonella uncinata

Ciliates are microbial eukaryotes that separate their nuclear functions into a germline micronucleus and a somatic macronucleus. During development of the macronucleus the genome undergoes a series of reorganization events that includes the precise excision of intervening DNA. Here, we determine the architecture of four loci in the micronuclear and macronuclear genomes of the ciliate Chilodonella uncinata and compare the levels of variation in micronuclear-limited sequences to macronuclear destined sequences at two of these loci. We find that within a population, germline-limited sequences are evolving at the same rate as other putatively neutral sites, but between populations germline-limited sequences are accumulating mutations at a much faster rate than other sites. We also find evidence of macronuclear recombination and incomplete elimination of intervening DNA, which result in increased diversity in the macronuclear genome. Our results support the assertion that the unusual genomic features of ciliates can result in rapid and unpredicted patterns of diversification.     

Analysis of the micronuclear B type surface protein gene in Paramecium tetraurelia.

The micronuclear DNA of Paramecium contains sequences that are precisely excised during the formation of the macronuclear (somatic) genome. In this paper we show that four eliminated sequences ranging in size from 28 to 416 base pairs, are present in or near the micronuclear copy of the B surface protein gene. Each excised sequence is bounded by the dinucleotide 5'-TdA-3'. Comparison of the micronuclear B gene with the previously determined micronuclear sequence of the A surface protein gene shows that although the positions of at least three of the eliminated sequences are conserved in both genes, the sequences are highly divergent. Transformation of vegetative macronuclei with fragments of the micronuclear B gene results in replication and maintenance of the DNA, but the micronuclear specific sequences are not removed. Previous studies have shown that the correct incorporation of the B gene into the new macronucleus requires copies of the macronuclear B gene in the old macronucleus. Using macronuclear transformation, we show that the micronuclear B gene can substitute for the macronuclear B gene with regard to its role in DNA processing. This suggests that the macronuclear DNA is not acting as a guide for the excision of the micronuclear specific sequences.     

Organization of the Euplotes crassus micronuclear genome

Euplotes crassus, like other hypotrichous ciliated protozoa, eliminates most of its micronuclear chromosomal DNA in the process of forming the small linear DNA molecules that comprise the macronuclear genome. By characterizing randomly selected lambda phage clones of E. crassus micronuclear DNA, we have determined the distribution of repetitive and unique sequences and the arrangement of macronuclear genes relative to eliminated DNA. This allows us to compare the E. crassus micronuclear genome organization to that of another distantly related hypotrichous ciliate, Oxytricha nova. The clones from E. crassus segregate into three prevalent classes: those containing primarily eliminated repetitive DNA (Class I); those containing macronuclear genes in addition to repetitive sequences (Class II); and those containing only eliminated unique sequence DNA (Class III). All of the repetitive sequences in these clones belong to the same highly abundant repetitive element family. Our results demonstrate that the sequence organization of the E. crassus and O. nova micronuclear genomes is related in that the macronuclear genes are clustered together in the micronuclear genome and the eliminated unique sequences occur in long stretches that are uninterrupted by repetitive sequences. In both organisms a single repetitive element family comprises the majority of the eliminated interspersed middle repetitive DNA and appears to be preferentially associated with the macronuclear sequence clusters. The similarities in the sequence organization in these two organisms suggest that clustering of macronuclear genes plays a role in the chromosome fragmentation process.