Leaf ultrastructure of C4 species possessing different Kranz anatomical types in the cyperaceae

The leaf ultrastructure of NADP-malic enzyme type C₄ species possessing different anatomical features in the Cyperaceae was examined: types were the Rhynchosporoid type, a normal Kranz type in which mesophyll cells are adjacent to Kranz cells, and Fimbristyloid and Chlorocyperoid types, unusual Kranz types in which nonchlorophyllous mestome sheath intervenes between the two types of green cells. They show structural characteristics basically similar to the NADP-malic enzyme group of C₄ grasses, that is, centrifugally located chloroplasts with reduced grana and no increase of mitochondrial frequency in the Kranz cells. However, the Kranz cell chloroplasts of the Fimbristyloid and Chlorocyperoid types exhibit convoluted thylakoid systems and a trend of extensive development of peripheral reticulum, although those of the Rhynchosporoid type do not possess such particular membrane systems. The suberized lamella, probably a barrier for CO₂ diffusion, is present in the Kranz cell walls of the Rhynchosporoid type and in the mestome sheath cell walls of the other two types, and tightly surrounds the Kranz cells (sheaths) that are the sites of the decarboxylation of C₄ acids. These ultrastructural features are discussed in relation to C₄ photosynthetic function.     

VARIATIONS IN ANATOMY,ASSOCIATIONS, AND ORIGINS OF KRANZ TISSUE

Although the unique tissue required for C₄ photosynthesis in nonsucculent plants is often described as being modified leaf parenchyma sheath, which is positioned meaningfully between the mesophyll externally and the vascular tissues internally, the actual range of locations and known associations make that concept untenable. In origin the Kranz tissue develops from procambium as well as ground parenchyma. It is found in stems as well as leaves. In position Kranz tissue can lie in the parenchyma sheath, in the mestome sheath, isolated in the mesophyll, peripherally in some thick leaves, or within the veins. It can be associated with mesophyll only, mesophyll and colorless parenchyma, mesophyll and sclerenchyma, other Kranz tissue and vascular tissues, mesophyll and mestome sheath, mesophyll and phloem, mesophyll and xylem, epidermis, and, finally, mestome sheath and xylem and phloem. The use of the term Kranz is expounded.     

Structure and immunocytochemical localization of photosynthetic enzymes in the lamina joint and sheath pulvinus of the C4 grass Arundinella hirta

The C₄ grass Arundinella hirta exhibits a unique C₄ anatomy, with isolated Kranz cells (distinctive cells) and C₄-type expression of photosynthetic enzymes in the leaf sheath and stem as well as in the leaf blade. The border zones between these organs are pale green. Those between the leaf blade and sheath and between the sheath and stem are called the lamina joint and sheath pulvinus, respectively, and are involved in gravity sensing. We investigated the structure and localization of C₃ and C₄ photosynthetic enzymes in these tissues. In both zones the epidermis lacked stomata. The inner tissue was composed of parenchyma cells and vascular bundles. The parenchyma cells were densely packed with small intercellular spaces and contained granal chloroplasts with large starch grains. No C₄-type cellular differentiation was recognized. Western blot analysis showed that the lamina joint and pulvinus accumulated substantial amounts of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC), pyruvate,Pi dikinase (PPDK), and ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rubisco). Immunogold electron microscopy revealed PEPC in the cytosol and both PPDK and rubisco in the chloroplasts of parenchyma cells, suggesting the occurrence of C₃ and C₄ enzymes within a single type of chlorenchyma cell. These data indicate that the lamina joint and pulvinus have unique expression patterns of C₃ and C₄ enzymes, unlike those in C₄-type anatomy.     

Diversity in forms of C4 in the genus Cleome (Cleomaceae)

Background and Aims

Cleomaceae is one of 19 angiosperm families in which C₄ photosynthesis has been reported. The aim of the study was to determine the type, and diversity, of structural and functional forms of C₄ in genus Cleome.

Methods

Plants of Cleome species were grown from seeds, and leaves were subjected to carbon isotope analysis, light and scanning electron microscopy, western blot analysis of proteins, and in situ immunolocalization for ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase (Rubisco) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC).

Key Results

Three species with C₄-type carbon isotope values occurring in separate lineages in the genus (Cleome angustifolia, C. gynandra and C. oxalidea) were shown to have features of C₄ photosynthesis in leaves and cotyledons. Immunolocalization studies show that PEPC is localized in mesophyll (M) cells and Rubisco is selectively localized in bundle sheath (BS) cells in leaves and cotyledons, characteristic of species with Kranz anatomy. Analyses of leaves for key photosynthetic enzymes show they have high expression of markers for the C₄ cycle (compared with the C₃–C₄ intermediate C. paradoxa and the C₃ species C. africana). All three are biochemically NAD-malic enzyme sub-type, with higher granal development in BS than in M chloroplasts, characteristic of this biochemical sub-type. Cleome gynandra and C. oxalidea have atriplicoid-type Kranz anatomy with multiple simple Kranz units around individual veins. However, C. angustifolia anatomy is represented by a double layer of concentric chlorenchyma forming a single compound Kranz unit by surrounding all the vascular bundles and water storage cells.

Conclusions

NAD-malic enzyme-type C₄ photosynthesis evolved multiple times in the family Cleomaceae, twice with atriplicoid-type anatomy in compound leaves having flat, broad leaflets in the pantropical species C. gynandra and the Australian species C. oxalidea, and once by forming a single Kranz unit in compound leaves with semi-terete leaflets in the African species C. angustifolia. The leaf morphology of C. angustifolia, which is similar to that of the sister, C₃–C₄ intermediate African species C. paradoxa, suggests adaptation of this lineage to arid environments, which is supported by biogeographical information.     

Structural features of NAD-malic enzyme type C4 Eleocharis: An additional report of C4 acid decarboxylation types of the cyperaceae

The genusEleocharis, a blade-less sedge group, has been very recently recorded to include NAD-malic enzyme type C₄ species. The ultrastructural features of culms of two C₄ representatives in the genus were examined in relation to the C₄ acid decarboxylation type. They possessed non-chlorophyllous mestome sheath cells between mesophyll cells and Kranz cells, and were confirmed biochemically to be NAD-malic enzyme type. The oval or lenticular chloroplasts with well-developed grana are scattered in the Kranz cells with abundant large mitochondria, and do not show such centripetal position as is known in the “classical NAD-malic enzyme type”. The suberized lamellae occur in the mestome sheath cells internally surrounding the Kranz sheath and may contribute to maintaining high CO₂ concentration in the Kranz cells. These new structural features of the NAD-malic enzyme type found inEleocharis are added to the structural and functional relationships of the C₄ types in the Cyperaceae reported previously     

Distribution and evolution of C4 syndrome inRhynchospora (Rhynchosporeae-Cyperaceae)

In order to elucidate the evolution of C₄ syndrome, the taxonomic relationships, leaf anatomy, and ecological and global distribution of C₃ and C₄ species in the genusRhynchospora were investigated. The anatomical observation for 181 species revealed that 26 C₄ species occurred within theCapitatae group of the subgenusHaplostyleae, a natural group showing highly advanced morphological characteristics, together with several C₃ species. In spite of there being rather few C₄ species, they possessed two kinds of Kranz anatomical structure differing from each other in the location of Kranz cells. Some C₃ species ofCapitatae showed radial arrangement in mesophyll cells surrounding vascular bundles, which is distinguished from typical non-Kranz anatomy. The C₄ species extended their ecological ranges from wet habitats to dry savanna grasslands, while the C₃ species showed the best development in wet habitats. The C₃ species were widespread from tropical to temperate regions with partial range extension into subarctic regions of both hemispheres, showing conspicuously high concentration of species in the New World, but being absent from arid climatic regions. The C₄ species were distributed mostly in tropics and subtropics, showing two separate distributional centers in South and Central America and in Tropical Asia and Australia. The range of C₄ species was nearly completely included in the C₃ range. In conclusion, it seems that inRhynchospora the C₄ syndrome evolved relatively recently, and arose in at least two separate phylogenetic trends in the tropics and the subtropics, more probably in the Neotropics.     

DIFFERING ONTOGENETIC ORIGINS OF PCR (“KRANZ”) SHEATHS IN LEAF BLADES OF C4 GRASSES (POACEAE)

The origin and early development of procambium and associated ground meristem of major and minor veins have been examined in the leaf blades of seven C₄ grass species, representing different taxonomic groups and the three recognized biochemical C₄ types (NAD-ME, PCK, and NADP-ME). Comparisons were made with the C₃ species, Festuca arundinacea. In “double sheath” (XyMS+) species (Panicum effusum, Eleusine coracana, and Sporoboìus elongatus), the procambium of major veins gives rise to xylem, phloem, and a mestome sheath; associated ground meristem differentiates into PCA (“C₄ mesophyll”) tissue and the PCR (“Kranz”) sheath. Development in the C₃ species parallels this pattern, except that associated ground meristem differentiates into mesophyll and a parenchymatous bundle sheath. In contrast, major vein procambium of “single sheath” (XyMS–) species (Panicum bulbosum, Digitaria brownii, and Cymbopogon procerus) differentiates into xylem, phloem and a PCR sheath; associated ground meristem gives rise to PCA tissue. These observations of major vein development support W. V. Brown's hypothesis that the PCR sheaths of “double sheath” (XyMS+) C₄ grasses are homologous with the parenchymatous bundle sheaths of C₃ grasses, while in “single sheath” (XyMS–) C₄ species they are homologous with the mestome sheath. Although there are some similarities in the development of the major and minor vascular bundle procambium in the C₄ species examined, the ontogeny of the smaller minor veins is characterized by a precocious delineation of the PCR sheath layer that may even precede the appearance of the distinctive cytological features of ground meristem and procambium. This contracted development in minor veins appears to be related to their close spacing in mature leaves and to their comparatively late appearance during leaf ontogeny.     

Structure and enzyme expression in photosynthetic organs of the atypical C4 grass Arundinella hirta

In its leaf blade, Arundinella hirta has unusual Kranz cells that lie distant from the veins (distinctive cells; DCs), in addition to the usual Kranz units composed of concentric layers of mesophyll cells (MCs) and bundle sheath cells (BSCs; usual Kranz cells) surrounding the veins. We examined whether chlorophyllous organs other than leaf blades—namely, the leaf sheath, stem, scale leaf, and constituents of the spike—also have this unique anatomy and the C₄ pattern of expression of photosynthetic enzymes. All the organs developed DCs to varying degrees, as well as BSCs. The stem, rachilla, and pedicel had C₄-type anatomy with frequent occurrence of DCs, as in the leaf blade. The leaf sheath, glume, and scale leaf had a modified C₄ anatomy with MCs more than two cells distant from the Kranz cells; DCs were relatively rare. An immunocytochemical study of C₃ and C₄ enzymes revealed that all the organs exhibited essentially the same C₄ pattern of expression as in the leaf blade. In the scale leaf, however, intense expression of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) occurred in the MCs as well as in the BSCs and DCs. In the leaf sheath, the distant MCs also expressed Rubisco. In Arundinella hirta, it seems that the ratio of MC to Kranz cell volumes, and the distance from the Kranz cells, but not from the veins, affects the cellular expression of photosynthetic enzymes. We suggest that the main role of DCs is to keep a constant quantitative balance between the MCs and Kranz cells, which is a prerequisite for effective C₄ pathway operation.     

Immunocytochemical localization of enzymes involved in the C3 and C4 pathways in the photosynthetic cells of an amphibious sedge, Eleocharis vivipara

Eleocharis vivipara link, an amphibious leafless sedge, develops traits of C₄ photosynthesis and Kranz anatomy in the terrestrial form but develops C₃-like traits with non-Kranz anatomy when submerged. The cellular localization of C₃ and C₄ enzymes in the photosynthetic cells of the two forms was investigated by immunogold labeling and electron microscopy. The terrestrial form has mesophyll cells and three kinds of bundle sheath cell, namely, parenchyma sheath cells, non-chlorophyllous mestome sheath cells, and Kranz cells. Phosphoenol-pyruvate carboxylase (PEPCase) was present in the cytosol of both the mesophyll cells and the parenchyma sheath cells, with higher-density labeling in the latter, but not in the Kranz cells. Pyruvate, Pi dikinase (PPDK) was found at high levels in the chloroplasts of both the mesophyll cells and the parenchyma sheath cells with some-what stronger labeling in the latter. This enzyme was also absent from the Kranz cells. Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) was found in the chloroplasts of all types of photosynthetic cell, but labeling was significantly less intense in the parenchyma sheath cells than in other types of cell. The submerged form also has three types of photosynthetic cell, as well as non-chlorophyllous mestome sheath cells, but it lacks the traits of Kranz anatomy as a consequence of modification of the cells. Rubisco was densely distributed in the chloroplasts of all the photosynthetic cells. However, PEPCase and PPDK were found in both the mesophyll cells and the parenchyma sheath cells but at lower levels than in the terrestrial form. These data reveal that the terrestrial form has a unique pattern of cellular localization of C₃ and C₄ enzymes, and they suggest that this pattern and the changes in the extent of accumulation of the various enzymes are the main factors responsible for the difference in photosynthetic traits between the two forms.Abbreviations CAM crassulacean acid metabolism - MC meso phyll cell - PSC parenchyma sheath cell - KC Kranz cell - PEP-Case phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase - PPDK pyruvate, Pi dikinase - Rubisco ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase - LS large subunit - RuBP ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate This study was supported by Grants-in-Aid from the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan (Integrated Research Program for the Use of Biotechnological Procedures for Plant Breeding) and from the Science and Technology Agency of Japan (Enhancement of Center-of-Excellence, the Special Coordination Funds for Promoting Science and Technology). The author is grateful to Drs M. Matsuoka and S. Muto for providing the antisera and Dr. M. Samejima for his advice at the early stages of this study.     

Ultrastructure of leaves in C4 Cyperus iria and C3 Carex siderosticta

The ultrastructural aspects ofCyperus iria leaves showing the C₄ syndrome and the typical C₃ species,Carex siderosticta, in the Cyperaceae family were examined.C. iria exhibited the chlorocyperoid type, showing an unusual Kranz structure with vascular bundles completely surrounded by two bundle sheaths. The cellular components of the inner Kranz bundle sheath cells were similar to those found in the NADP-ME C₄ subtype, having centrifugally arranged chloroplasts with greatly reduced grana and numerous starch grains. Their chloroplasts contained convoluted thyla-koids and a weakly-developed peripheral reticulum, although it was extensive mostly in mesophyll cell chloroplasts. The outer mestome bundle sheath layer was sclerenchymatous and generally devoid of organelles, but had unevenly thickened walls. Suberized lamellae were present on its cell walls, and they became polylamellate when traversed by plasmodesmata. Mesophyll cell chloroplasts showed well-stacked grana with small starch grains. InC. siderosticta, vascular bundles were surrounded by the inner mestome sheath and the outer parenchymatous bundle sheath with intercellular spaces. The mestome sheath cells degraded in their early development and remained in a collapsed state, although the suberized lamellae retained polylamellate features. Plastids with a crystalline structure, sometimes membrane-bounded, were found in the epidermal cells. The close interveinal distance was 35–50 μm inC. iria, whereas it was 157–218 μm inC. siderosticta. These ultrastructural characteristics were discussed in relation to their photosynthetic functions.     

C3 and C4 Photosynthetic and Anatomical Forms of Alloteropsis semialata (R.Br.) Hitchcock: 2. A Comparative Investigation of Leaf Ultrastructure and Distribution of Chlorenchyma in the Two Forms

Alloteropsis semialata (R.Br.) Hitchcock is a widely distributedgrass species known to show marked morphological, anatomicaland physiological variation. An unusual feature of this grassis that it shows both C₃, and C₄ photosynthetic pathways withthe respective anatomy related to these pathways in one speciesand within a single environment. This study investigates ultrastructuraldifferences between C₃ and C₄ forms of A. semialata, and showsdistribution of chlorenchyma in the two forms, at light microscopelevel. Quantitative assessment shows marked differences in mesophylland Kranz sheath cells with regard to size and organelle content;also in distribution of starch grains, lipid droplets and organellesin the mesophyll cells of both forms. These differences arediscussed in relation to the C₃/C₄ syndrome. Measurements were made using a Digiplan electronic planimeteron transmission electron micrographs of mature leaves sectionedtransversely at mid-lamina, and on drawings of leaf sectionsshowing the distribution of chlorenchymatous tissue. Alloteropsis semialata(R.Br.) Hitchcock, leaf structure, chlorenchyma, ultrastructure, C₃-photosynthesis, C₄-photosynthesis     

Occurrence and forms of Kranz anatomy in photosynthetic organs and characterization of NAD-ME subtype C4 photosynthesis in Blepharis ciliaris (L.) B. L. Burtt (Acanthaceae)

Blepharis (Acanthaceae) is an Afroasiatic genus comprising 129 species which occur in arid and semi-arid habitats. This is the only genus in the family which is reported to have some C(4) species. Blepharis ciliaris (L.) B. L. Burtt. is a semi-desert species with distribution in Iran, Oman, and Pakistan. Its form of photosynthesis was investigated by studying different organs. C(4)-type carbon isotope composition, the presence of atriplicoid type Kranz anatomy, and compartmentation of starch all indicate performance of C(4) photosynthesis in cotyledons, leaves, and the lamina part of bracts. A continuous layer of distinctive bundle sheath cells (Kranz cells) encircle the vascular bundles in cotyledons and the lateral vascular bundles in leaves. In older leaves, there is extensive development of ground tissue in the midrib and the Kranz tissue becomes interrupted on the abaxial side, and then becomes completely absent in the mature leaf base. Cotyledons have 5-6 layers, and leaves 2-3 layers, of spongy chlorenchyma beneath the veins near the adaxial side of the leaf, indicating bifacial organization of chlorenchyma. As the plant matures, bracts and spines develop and contribute to carbon assimilation through an unusual arrangement of Kranz anatomy which depends on morphology and exposure to light. Stems do not contribute to carbon assimilation, as they lack chlorenchyma tissue and Kranz anatomy. Analysis of C(4) acid decarboxylases by western blot indicates B. ciliaris is an NAD-malic enzyme type C(4) species, which is consistent with the Kranz cells having chloroplasts with well-developed grana and abundant mitochondria.     

An investigation for the occurrence of C4 photosynthesis in the Cyperaceae from Australia

Two hundred and twenty species of 38 genera in the Cyperaceae from Australia were examined for the possible occurrence of the C₄ photosynthesis and the anatomical features of leaves and culms. The Kranz type of anatomy and the carbon isotope ratios typical of C₄ plants were found in 84 species in the following six genera of four tribes belonging to subfamily Cyperoideae:Bulbostylis, Crosslandia, andFimbristylis (Fimbristylideae);Lipocarpha (Lipocarpheae);Cyperus (Cypereae);Rhynchospora (Rhynchosporeae). The anatomical observation revealed that the C₄ species possessed any one of the three Kranz anatomical types found by previous investigators. It was suggested that in the Cyperaceae the C₄ syndrome evolved independently within several taxa of the subfamily. The relative distribution of C₃ and C₄ species of the Cyperaceae in Australia was investigated by use of floristic data. It was recognized that the C₄ species dominated in the northern part of the continent which was characterized by tropical and subtropical savannas and hot dry areas with summer rainfall, and the C₃ species in the southern part, which contained temperate areas and mediterranean climatic areas with winter rainfall.     

Atypical foliar anatomy related to Kranz syndrome in Paspalum inaequivalve and Paspalum microstachyum (Poaceae: Panicoideae: Paniceae)

Paspalum L. is a large and complex genus, enclosing more than 300 species, whose boundaries and infrageneric classification are still being studied. Recent phylogenetic analyses suggest that Paspalum inaequivalve Raddi and Paspalum microstachyum J. Presl, from the Inaequivalvia informal group, should be excluded from Paspalum. Focused on the unclear taxonomic position of P. inaequivalve and P. microstachyum, their leaf anatomy was studied, and some atypical features related to C₄ photosynthesis were found. This atypical Kranz syndrome is the aim of this research. Transverse leaf blade sections from fresh and herbarium material of P. inaequivalve were studied by light, fluorescence, and transmission microscopy. Additionally, sheaths and culms of P. inaequivalve and leaf blades of P. microstachyum were observed by light microscopy. δ¹³C isotope discrimination was determinated for P. inaequivalve. We compared our results with available anatomical data from related taxa. As well as typical mesophyll cells (PCA) and mestome sheath cells (PCR), a third type of cells, here called ‘globose parenchymatous cells’, was observed in leaf blades of P. inaequivalve and P. microstachyum. These cells are placed externally to the mestome sheaths of the first and second vascular bundles, they have thin walls, with no developed suberine lamella, few chloroplasts with 1–2 starch grains, thylakoids not organized in grana, and a large central vacuole. The globose parenchymatous cells represent a novel trait in P. inaequivalve and P. microstachyum, further supporting the close relation between both species and their exclusion from the genus Paspalum. This atypical Kranz syndrome has not been described in Paspalum before, but the globose parenchymatous cells here described resemble the distinct cells considered as remnants of the outer parenchymatous sheath described for Anthaenantiopsis, some sections of Panicum L., and Chaetium Nees, providing possible taxonomic significance.     

Photosynthetic Characteristics of Portulaca grandiflora, a Succulent C(4) Dicot : CELLULAR COMPARTMENTATION OF ENZYMES AND ACID METABOLISM

The succulent, cylindrical leaves of the C₄ dicot Portulaca grandiflora possess three distinct green cell types: bundle sheath cells (BSC) in radial arrangement around the vascular bundles; mesophyll cells (MC) in an outer layer adjacent to the BSC; and water storage cells (WSC) in the leaf center. Unlike typical Kranz leaf anatomy, the MC do not surround the bundle sheath tissue but occur only in the area between the bundle sheath and the epidermis. Intercellular localization of photosynthetic enzymes was characterized using protoplasts isolated enzymatically from all three green cell types.     

Genome‐wide transcript analysis of early maize leaf development reveals gene cohorts associated with the differentiation of C4 Kranz anatomy

Photosynthesis underpins the viability of most ecosystems, with C₄ plants that exhibit ‘Kranz’ anatomy being the most efficient primary producers. Kranz anatomy is characterized by closely spaced veins that are encircled by two morphologically distinct photosynthetic cell types. Although Kranz anatomy evolved multiple times, the underlying genetic mechanisms remain largely elusive, with only the maize scarecrow gene so far implicated in Kranz patterning. To provide a broader insight into the regulation of Kranz differentiation, we performed a genome‐wide comparative analysis of developmental trajectories in Kranz (foliar leaf blade) and non‐Kranz (husk leaf sheath) leaves of the C₄ plant maize. Using profile classification of gene expression in early leaf primordia, we identified cohorts of genes associated with procambium initiation and vascular patterning. In addition, we used supervised classification criteria inferred from anatomical and developmental analyses of five developmental stages to identify candidate regulators of cell‐type specification. Our analysis supports the suggestion that Kranz anatomy is patterned, at least in part, by a SCARECROW/SHORTROOT regulatory network, and suggests likely components of that network. Furthermore, the data imply a role for additional pathways in the development of Kranz leaves.     

Structural, biochemical, and physiological characterization of C4 photosynthesis in species having two vastly different types of kranz anatomy in genus Suaeda (Chenopodiaceae)

C (4) species of family Chenopodiaceae, subfamily Suaedoideae have two types of Kranz anatomy in genus Suaeda, sections Salsina and Schoberia, both of which have an outer (palisade mesophyll) and an inner (Kranz) layer of chlorenchyma cells in usually semi-terete leaves. Features of Salsina (S. AEGYPTIACA, S. arcuata, S. taxifolia) and Schoberia type (S. acuminata, S. Eltonica, S. cochlearifoliA) were compared to C (3) type S. Heterophylla. In Salsina type, two layers of chlorenchyma at the leaf periphery surround water-storage tissue in which the vascular bundles are embedded. In leaves of the Schoberia type, enlarged water-storage hypodermal cells surround two layers of chlorenchyma tissue, with the latter surrounding the vascular bundles. The chloroplasts in Kranz cells are located in the centripetal position in Salsina type and in the centrifugal position in the Schoberia type. Western blots on C (4) acid decarboxylases show that both Kranz forms are NAD-malic enzyme (NAD-ME) type C (4) species. Transmission electron microscopy shows that mesophyll cells have chloroplasts with reduced grana, while Kranz cells have chloroplasts with well-developed grana and large, specialized mitochondria, characteristic of NAD-ME type C (4) chenopods. In both C (4) types, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase is localized in the palisade mesophyll, and Rubisco and mitochondrial NAD-ME are localized in Kranz cells, where starch is mainly stored. The C (3) species S. heterophylla has Brezia type isolateral leaf structure, with several layers of Rubisco-containing chlorenchyma. Photosynthetic response curves to varying CO (2) and light in the Schoberia Type and Salsina type species were similar, and typical of C (4) plants. The results indicate that two structural forms of Kranz anatomy evolved in parallel in species of subfamily Suaedoideae having NAD-ME type C (4) photosynthesis.     

Does Bienertia cycloptera with the single-cell system of C(4) photosynthesis exhibit a seasonal pattern of delta (13)C values in nature similar to co-existing C (4) Chenopodiaceae having the dual-cell (Kranz) system?

Family Chenopodiaceae is an intriguing lineage, having the largest number of C₄ species among dicots, including a number of anatomical variants of Kranz anatomy and three single-cell C₄ functioning species. In some previous studies, during the culture of Bienertia cycloptera Bunge ex Boiss., carbon isotope values (δ¹³C values) of leaves deviated from C₄ to C₃−C₄ intermediate type, raising questions as to its mode of photosynthesis during growth in natural environments. This species usually co-occurs with several Kranz type C₄ annuals. The development of B. cycloptera morphologically and δ¹³C values derived from plant samples (cotyledons, leaves, bracts, shoots) were analyzed over a complete growing season in a salt flat in north central Iran, along with eight Kranz type C₄ species and one C₃ species. For a number of species, plants were greenhouse-grown from seeds collected from the site, in order to examine leaf anatomy and C₄ biochemical subtype. Among the nine C₄ species, the cotyledons of B. cycloptera, and of the Suaeda spp. have the same respective forms of C₄ anatomy occurring in leaves, while cotyledons of members of tribe Caroxyloneae lack Kranz anatomy, which is reflected in the δ¹³C values found in plants grown in the natural habitat. The nine C₄ species had average seasonal δ¹³C values of −13.9‰ (with a range between species from −11.3 to −15.9‰). The measurements of δ¹³C values over a complete growing season show that B. cycloptera performs C₄ photosynthesis during its life cycle in nature, similar to Kranz type species, with a seasonal average δ¹³C value of −15.2‰. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Characterization of C₃--C₄ intermediate species in the genus Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): anatomy, ultrastructure and enzyme activity

Photosynthetic pathway characteristics were studied in nine species of Heliotropium (sensu lato, including Euploca), using assessments of leaf anatomy and ultrastructure, activities of PEP carboxylase and C₄ acid decarboxylases, and immunolocalization of ribulose 1·5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) and the P‐subunit of glycine decarboxylase (GDC). Heliotropium europaeum, Heliotropium calcicola and Heliotropium tenellum are C₃ plants, while Heliotropium texanum and Heliotropium polyphyllum are C₄ species. Heliotropium procumbens and Heliotropium karwinskyi are functionally C₃, but exhibit ‘proto‐Kranz’ anatomy where bundle sheath (BS) cells are enlarged and mitochondria primarily occur along the centripetal (inner) wall of the BS cells; GDC is present throughout the leaf. Heliotropium convolvulaceum and Heliotropium greggii are C₃–C₄ intermediates, with Kranz‐like enlargement of the BS cells, localization of mitochondria along the inner BS wall and a loss of GDC in the mesophyll (M) tissue. These C₃–C₄ species of Heliotropium probably shuttle photorespiratory glycine from the M to the BS tissue for decarboxylation. Heliotropium represents an important new model for studying C₄ evolution. Where existing models such as Flaveria emphasize diversification of C₃–C₄ intermediates, Heliotropium has numerous C₃ species expressing proto‐Kranz traits that could represent a critical initial phase in the evolutionary origin of C₄ photosynthesis.