Immunosuppressive activity of T cell clones generated from human T cells stimulated with autologous TPHA cells

T cell clones were generated from human T cells stimulated with autologous phytohemagglutinin (PHA)-activated T (TPHA) cells. Characterization of three T cell clones originated from donor SF and one from donor JM showed that they proliferated when stimulated with autologous TPHA cells, non-T cells, and peripheral blood mononuclear cells, but did not proliferate when stimulated with allogeneic TPHA cells, non-T cells, and mononuclear cells, with autologous and allogeneic resting T cells, and with PHA. These results in conjunction with the blocking of the proliferation by anti-histocompatibility leukocyte antigen class II monoclonal antibodies indicate that these class II antigens are involved in the proliferation of T cell clones stimulated with autologous lymphoid cells. The four T cell clones are cytotoxic neither to autologous lymphoid cells nor to a panel of cultured human cell lines. The four T cell clones display immunosuppressive activity, since they inhibit the proliferation of autologous and allogeneic cells stimulated with antigens and mitogens and the secretion of immunoglobulin by B cells stimulated with pokeweed mitogen in presence of T cells. Furthermore, the four T cell clones display differential inhibitory activity on the proliferation of cultured human cell lines. The immunosuppressive activity is species-specific, since the T cell clones do not inhibit the proliferation of murine cells. The suppression is mediated by a factor(s) with an apparent m.w. of 13,000 to 16,000. The suppressor activity is labile at alkaline pH and is lost following incubation with pronase (100 U/ml) for 30 min at 37 degrees C.     

Microtubules and microtubule-associated proteins in resting and mitogenically activated normal human peripheral blood T cells.

The binding of an appropriate ligand to its specific receptor on the membrane of T cells triggers a cascade of events involved in T cell activation. An important yet unanswered question is how the mitogenic signals are transmitted through the cytoplasm and into the nucleus. The present study was carried out to determine changes in the microtubule (MT) system, following T cell activation. Fluorescence microscopy was employed to examine the organization of the microtubule network in human peripheral blood T cells in response to four different mitogens (phytohemagglutinin, concanavalin A, anti-CD3, and phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate). The microtubules increase in length, number, and complexity of distribution 20 h after mitogenic stimulation. Using an in situ direct analysis protocol consisting of selective extraction of cells with detergent and Ca2+, 11 protein species, which fulfill the operational definition of microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs), were identified in resting human T cells. Alterations in the expression of these protein species were studied following mitogenic stimulation. These alterations in MAPs expression were also found in purified blast cell fractions indicating that they were specific changes occurring in activated T cell populations. These observations suggest a role for MT and MAPs in the cascade of human T cell activation.     

Calcium transport and calcium-ATPase activity in human lymphocyte plasma membrane vesicles

We have studied Ca transport and the Ca-activated Mg-ATPase in plasma membrane vesicles prepared from normal human lymphocytes. Membrane vesicles that were exposed to oxalate as a Ca-trapping agent accumulated Ca in the presence of Mg2+ and ATP. ADP, AMP, GTP, UTP, ITP, TTP, or CTP did not substitute for ATP in energizing uptake. The Vmax for Ca uptake was 2.4 pmol of Ca/micrograms of protein/min, and the Km values for Ca and ATP were 1.0 and 80 microM, respectively. One microM A23187, added initially, completely inhibited net Ca uptake and, if added later, caused the release of Ca accumulated previously. Cyanide, oligomycin, ouabain, or varying Na+ or K+ concentrations had no effect on Ca uptake. A Ca-activated ATPase was present in the same membrane vesicles, which had a Vmax of 25 pmol of Pi/micrograms of protein/min at a free Ca concentration of 4-5 microM. This Ca-ATPase had Km values for Ca and ATP of 0.6 and 90 microM, respectively. These kinetic parameters were similar to those observed for uptake of Ca by the vesicles. The Ca-ATPase activity was insensitive to azide, oligomycin, ouabain, or varying Na+ or K+ concentrations. No Ca-activated hydrolysis of GTP or UTP was observed. Both Ca transport and the Ca-ATPase activity of ethylene glycol bis(beta-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid-treated lymphocyte plasma membranes were stimulated 2-fold by a cytoplasmic component (calmodulin) that was purified 500-fold from lymphocyte cytoplasm. Thus, human lymphocyte plasma membranes have both a Ca transport activity and a Ca-stimulated ATPase activity with similar substrate affinities and specificities and similar sensitivities to calmodulin.     

T lymphocyte cloning from rejected human kidney allograft. Recognition repertoire of alloreactive T cell clones

We analyzed the recognition repertoire of 16 human alloreactive T cell clones (ATLC) derived from cells invading an irreversibly rejected kidney allograft. These clones, which specifically proliferated against the kidney donor B lymphoblastoid cell line, fell into two classes: CD4+ killers and CD8+ killers. Cytotoxic and proliferative activities of the ATLC were studied by using a panel of allogeneic cells sharing HLA specificities with kidney donor cells. Moreover, mAb recognizing monomorphic parts of HLA class I and class II molecules were used in blocking experiments of ATLC cytotoxicity. The results obtained from proliferative and cytotoxic assays were concordant. All ATLC investigated were directed against HLA molecules, and some clones were found to recognize HLA-B, -C, -DP, -DQ, or -DR products. All anti-HLA class I ATLC were CD8+, whereas both CD4+ and CD8+ ATLC were committed against HLA class II specificities. Nine of 16 ATLC were shown to react against serologically defined donor HLA determinants. These data indicate the recognition of HLA determinants in the course of an in vivo alloimmune response and particularly emphasize the role of HLA-C and DP loci products so far ignored in clinical transplantation.     

Antigen-specific and MHC-restricted Plasmodium falciparum-induced human T lymphocyte clones

We established and analyzed human T lymphocyte clones induced by crude Plasmodium falciparum antigens of schizont-enriched asexual blood stages. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were stimulated for 6 days with antigen, and the T cell blasts were separated and were transferred to limiting dilution cultures with antigen, irradiated PBMC, and recombinant interleukin 2. The following observations were made. Malaria antigen (M.Ag) induced similar proportions of T blasts in PBMC from infected individuals and noninfected controls, and the M.Ag-dependent clone frequencies (1/79 to 1/216) obtained with the blasts were similar. The majority of established clones derived from infected and noninfected subjects specifically recognized M.Ag and would not proliferate in response to red blood cells or autologous PBMC alone. They also required HLA class II determinant-compatible antigen-presenting (E-) cells. With three clones from one malaria patient, DR 1 or DR 5 specificities correlated with antigen presentation. Although T4+ and T8+ blasts were induced by M.Ag in PBMC, only T4 (Leu-3+) clones were obtained in our culture system. These clones secreted IL 2 in response to M.Ag. 4) Differential patterns of reactivity to native M.Ag, heat-stable antigens, and heat-precipitated antigens were exhibited by T cell clones, and the tested clones did not recognize Plasmodium berghei antigen. In conclusion, it is important with regard to previous observations on apparently nonspecific, mitogen-like effects of M.Ag in bulk T cell cultures that our results demonstrate specific recognition of P. falciparum by human T cells. The T cell clones obtained will be an important tool in the quest for a better understanding of the mechanisms involved in resistance to malaria infection.     

Establishment of human T cell clones exhibiting natural killer-like activity

We have succeeded in establishing a method to reproducibly immortalize human T cells by oncogene(s) transfection (Alam, 1997). This study was based on our previous discoveries that these immortalized T cell lines contained T cells which showed cytotoxicity against K562 cells in MHC-nonrestricted manner. Then we attempted to obtain human T cell clones exhibiting natural killer-like activity. Here, we tried to establish clones from these immortalized T cell lines by limiting dilution after stimulation with K562 cells, and then obtained 16 T cell clones. Two clones among them maintained their stability and showed vigorous growth phenotype. Thus we selected these two clones for further analysis. One is derived from the T cell line transfected with oncogenes ras and fos, the other is from the T cell line transfected with myc and fos. Both clones were demonstrated to be CD4⁺ T cells, indicating that CD4⁺ T cells were preferably expanded from T cell lines immortalized by oncogene transfection. These two clones showed cytotoxicity against K562 cells, indicating that these two T cell clones still retain a natural killer-like activity of killing target cells of K562 cells in a MHC-nonrestricted manner. The natural killer-like activity of the T cell clones was shown to be stable for more than 2 yr when cultured in the presence of IL-2, indicating that introduction of two oncogenes such as ras/fos or myc/fos resulted in the acquisition of infinite replicative life-span but not in transformational alteration of cellular function. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Antigen receptor-mediated anergy in resting T lymphocytes and T cell clones. Correlation with lymphokine secretion patterns.

The goal of these studies was to define the stimuli and factors that control the induction of anergy in unimmunized resting T lymphocytes. Initial experiments, aimed at establishing the system, showed that exposure of Th1 but not Th2 clones to immobilized anti-CD3 leads to a block in autocrine growth factor production and proliferation upon subsequent restimulation with Ag+APC. Anergy is not prevented by accessory cells, suggesting that this model of T cell tolerance may be due to receptor-mediated inhibitory signals, independent of costimulatory molecules. Culture of small (resting) unimmunized T lymphocytes with anti-CD3 +/- IL-2 induces unresponsiveness to restimulation with anti-CD3, but culture with anti-CD3+IL-4, which stimulates the differentiation of resting cells into IL-4 producers, does not induce anergy. Thus, IL-4-producing clones and bulk populations of IL-4-producing T cells are resistant to Ag receptor-mediated inhibitory stimuli. These results provide experimental models for studying the mechanisms of anergy in normal, unselected, mature T cells, and demonstrate fundamental similarities between cloned cell lines and unimmunized T lymphocytes in the induction of anergy.     

Induction of cystine transport activity in human fibroblasts by oxygen

The transport activity for cystine in cultured human fibroblasts decreased after incubation of the cells under a low oxygen concentration. After the incubation for 48 h under 3% oxygen, the Vmax of the transport was decreased to less than one-third of that of the control cells, with little change in Km. The similar transport activity was observed in the cells cultured under 3% oxygen for 10-40 days with several times of passages. When these low oxygen-cultured cells were incubated under room air, the activity was enhanced with a lag of about 4 h and was almost completely restored within 24 h. This restoration required protein synthesis. The cystine transport activity increased by 50% after exposure of the cells to hyperoxia (40% oxygen). From these results it is concluded that the transport activity for cystine is induced by oxygen. In contrast, little change in the transport activities for alanine and leucine occurred in the cells exposed to the corresponding hypoxia or hyperoxia. Since the cystine transported into the cells is reduced to cysteine and the cysteine readily exits to the culture medium where it autoxidizes to cystine, a cystine-cysteine cycle across the plasma membrane has been postulated. Since the autoxidation of cysteine in the culture medium was markedly slowed down under the low oxygen concentration, the change in the cystine transport activity in response to the oxygen concentration was regarded as pertinent. Induction of the cystine transport activity may constitute a protective mechanism against the oxidative stress, to which the culture cells are exposed, by providing the cells with cysteine which is mainly incorporated into glutathione.     

Oxidative stresses induced the cystine transport activity in human erythrocytes

Cystine was transported into human erythrocytes in the presence of tertiary-butyl hydroperoxide (t-BH) or 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB). The transport rate of cystine was dependent on the extracellular concentration of t-BH or CDNB, and on the incubation time. According to Dowex-1 column chromatography, the transported cystine was incorporated into fractions of glutathione disulfide (GSSG) and glutathione-S (GSH-S) conjugate. The transport of cystine was competitively inhibited by DL-homocystine and alanine. The inhibition rates by DL-homocystine and alanine were 75% and 68%, with similar Ki values of 0.7 mM and 0.6 mM, respectively. It is suggested that cystine transport is induced for glutathione synthesis when human erythrocytes are exposed to oxidative stresses. This transport system of cystine may serve as an emergency function in human erythrocytes.     

Increases in microtubule assembly and in tubulin content in mitogenically stimulated mouse splenic T lymphocytes

We have examined the changes in the microtubule and tubulin contents in populations of mouse splenic T lymphocytes stimulated by the mitogen concanavalin A. Indirect immunofluorescence staining with antiserum to tubulin indicated that a more extensive microtubule network was assembled from the centrosome in those cells which had increased in size in response to the mitogen. Direct counts of microtubules from electron micrographs of the centrosome regions of cells showed approximately a 2-fold increase in microtubule number in 48 h stimulated populations and up to a 5-fold increase in the large, fully stimulated, blast cells. Determinations of tubulin and actin contents were made by the measurement of peptides specific to those proteins. As a percentage of total cell protein both of these cytoskeletal proteins increased during the first 24 h of stimulation. Tubulin increased 50% by 24 h and remained high in populations stimulated for 48 h. The tubulin content per cell increased 2.5-fold, from 0.20 to 0.51 μg/10⁶ cells, in the 48 h stimulated population. An increase in tubulin content was also seen following the stimulation of nude mouse B lymphocyte populations and of total splenic lymphocyte populations. Our results show that during lymphocyte stimulation there is a large increase in the numbers of microtubules assembled which is correlated with, and appears dependent on, a similar large increase in the cellular tubulin content.     

Allospecific human T cell lines and clones which mediate HLA-DR restricted helper activity

In order to analyze the immunoregulatory activity of allospecific human T cells, we have combined the techniques of limiting dilution culture and IL-2 dependent T cell growth to generate cloned alloreactive T cell lines (TCL). These TCL have been expanded in continuous culture for greater than 8 mo with retention of stable phenotypic and functional characteristics. For example, phenotypic analysis of alloproliferative TCL, utilizing a panel of monoclonal antibodies, demonstrate that these cultures are comprised of T cells belonging exclusively to the T3+ T4+ T8- "helper" or "inducer" T cell subset. Coculture of cloned alloproliferative TCL cells with a panel of allogeneic stimulators reveals that these clones are specifically reactive against the HLA-DRw1 determinant. Of greater interest, coculture of selected alloproliferative TCL cells with DRw1+ but not DRw1- B cells results in a vigorous polyclonal response as measured by the reverse hemolytic plaque assay. Although major histocompatibility complex restriction of this T-B interaction operates at the inductive level, help is at least partially unrestricted at the effector level as alloantigen-activated TCL cells provide demonstrable, although not maximal, help for DRw1- B cells.     

Lysosomal cystine transport. Effect of intralysosomal pH and membrane potential

The regulation of lysosomal cystine transport was studied using cystine dimethyl ester-loaded lysosomes isolated from human diploid fibroblasts. Net efflux from normal fibroblast lysosomes was compared to that from lysosomes of cystinotic fibroblasts, which contain an inherited mutation decreasing lysosomal cystine transport. This exodus of cystine from normal fibroblast lysosomes was greater than from cystinotic fibroblast lysosomes. When lysosomes were incubated with both 5 mM MgCl2 and 2 mM ATP (Mg/ATP), the amount of lysosomal cystine lost from normal lysosomes doubled, but the amount of cystine lost from cystinotic lysosomes remained small. This effect of Mg/ATP on cystine loss from lysosomes isolated from normal fibroblasts was abolished when either carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone or N-ethylmaleimide was present, suggesting that the effect of Mg/ATP was mediated by the action of a lysosomal proton-translocating ATPase. Addition of KCl, RbCl, or NaCl to normal lysosomes caused smaller increases in cystine exodus. A variety of experimental conditions altered lysosomal pH, membrane potential, and the cystine lost from normal fibroblast lysosomes. These same experimental conditions produced similar alterations in the lysosomal pH and membrane potential of cystinotic fibroblast lysosomes without a comparable alteration in cystine loss. These results have led us to propose a model in which the transport of cystine out of the normal lysosome is regulated by both the lysosomal membrane potential gradient and the transmembrane pH gradient.     

Role of I-region gene products in T cell activation. I. Stimulation of T lymphocyte proliferative responses by subcellular membrane preparations containing Ia alloantigens

A model system has been developed for exploring the requirements for activation of T cells by subcellular forms of Ia alloantigen. Lymph node cells from mice recently primed subcutaneously with viable allogeneic cells show strong proliferative responses in vitro to membrane preparations derived from cells bearing the appropriate I-region-encoded glycoproteins. This stimulation shows kinetics characteristic of a secondary response, with a peak at 24 to 48 hr. Primary responses to alloantigen-bearing membranes are weak or absent under these conditions. The predominant cell type involved in the secondary response is the Lyt-1+ T lymphocyte, and the major antigenic stimulus is the I-A subregion-encoded Ia glycoprotein. Syngeneic Ia+ accessory cells do not appear necessary for activation to occur. Detergent solubilized reconstituted membrane vesicles also will stimulate primed T lymphocytes to respond by proliferation. The applications of this approach to the study of T cell recognition of antigen and the role of nonspecific lymphokines in T cell triggering are discussed.     

Protein synthesis in resting and stimulated human lymphocytes

Summary The ribosomal profiles in lysates from resting and phytohemagglutinin stimulated human lymphocytes have been analyzed by sucrose gradient centrifugation. The percentage of polyribosomes increased during lymphocyte transformation reaching a maximal value of 60 to 70% of the total ribosomes after 72 hours of mitogen addition. This time period coincides with maximalin vivo protein synthesis. On the other hand, in nonstimulated lymphocytes, about 25% of the ribosomal particles appeared as aggregates, independently of the incubation period.Experiments performed with homologous cell free systems containing ribosomes and supernatant fluids prepared from unstimulated or activated lymphocytes demonstrate that the mixtures containing both components from stimulated lymphocytes are several fold more active in polypeptide synthesis than the systems which contain ribosomal particles and cell sap from resting cells. Assays carried out with mixtures combining the components from both sources indicate that the increased activity depends on ribosomes as well as on the supernatant fractions.Dedicated to Professor LUIS F. LELOIR on the occasion of his 70^th birthday.     

Phenotypic and functional characterization of human T cell clones

The capacity of human peripheral blood-derived T cell clones to carry out a variety of functions was examined. T cell clones were generated by stimulating individual peripheral blood T cells with PHA by a procedure that yielded a growing clone from a mean of greater than 92% of the cultured cells. A total of 65 T cell clones (44 CD4+ and 21 CD8+) generated from two individual donors were examined for their functional capabilities. All T cell clones examined secreted IL-2, IFN-gamma, and lymphotoxin/tumor necrosis factor like activity when stimulated with immobilized mAb to the CD3 complex (64.1). When 54 additional T cell clones from a third donor were analyzed, all were found to produce IL-2. Upon activation with immobilized 64.1, all CD4+ clones and 91% of the CD8+ clones induced the generation of Ig-secreting cells from purified B cells. The CD8+ clones that did not serve as Th cells alone were able to augment the capacity of fresh CD4+ cells to generate Ig-secreting cells. Each of these clones was also found to effect MHC-unrestricted cytotoxicity upon activation with immobilized 64.1. The CD8+ clones were somewhat more effective killers than CD4+ clones, although there was considerable overlap. A total of 18 clones was analyzed for TCR beta-chain gene rearrangement. Of the clones exhibiting rearrangements of the beta-chain gene, 94% were found to have a single rearrangement pattern. Finally, the detailed phenotype of 15 (11 CD4+ and 4 CD8+) of these clones was examined. Variable numbers of cells of each of the clones expressed Ag identified by mAb 4B4 (CD29), Leu 8, Leu 15 (CD11b), and NKH1. Moreover, cells of 6 of 11 CD4+ clones and 4 of 4 CD8+ clones also expressed CD45R in addition to CD29; expression of CD45R and CD29 varied with the activation status of the clone. The current data demonstrate that nearly all of the T cell clones were able to accomplish each of the functions examined regardless of the surface phenotype. Inasmuch as the clones were generated using a technique that expanded more than 92% of the circulating T cells, the data imply that the progeny of the vast majority of T cells may have the inherent capacity to exert a wide array of functional activities.     

Functional activity in vivo of effector T cell populations. II. Anti-tumor activity exhibited by syngeneic anti-MoMULV-specific cytolytic T cell clones

The functional activity in vivo of murine tumor-specific cytolytic T lymphocyte populations and clones was studied. Tumor cell destruction induced after the i.v. injection of cytolytic effector cells was quantitated by monitoring the elimination of 131IUdR-labeled tumor cells in the peritoneal cavity by using whole-body counting techniques. Mixed leukocyte-tumor cell cultures were established by using spleen cells from C57BL/6 regressor mice that had rejected an intramuscular tumor induced by the injection of MSV-MoMuLV virus. This effector cell population was observed to eliminate syngeneic MoMuLV-induced tumor cells in a dose-dependent manner. Treatment of the effector cell population with monoclonal anti-Lyt-2 antibodies plus complement totally abrogated their ability to induce tumor cell destruction in the peritoneal cavity. MSV-MoMuLV-specific Lyt-2+ cytolytic T cell clones derived by micro-manipulation of T lymphocyte-tumor cell conjugates were also tested for functional activity in vivo. Several clones induced a rapid, specific elimination of 131I-labeled MBL-2 tumor cells from the peritoneal cavity after i.v. injection, whereas others were inactive. Both active and inactive clones were highly cytolytic and secreted MAF/IFN-gamma lymphokines. In contrast to previous results obtained in a tumor allograft model, the MSV-MoMuLV-specific cytolytic T cell clones that were active in vivo did not proliferate in vitro in response to stimulation with irradiated tumor cells plus filler spleen cells in the absence of an added source of interleukin 2.     

Phosphatidylethanolamine N-methyltransferase in human red blood cell membrane preparations. Kinetic mechanism

The successive methylations of phosphatidylethanolamine to form phosphatidylcholine were measured using exogenously added intermediates and membrane preparations from human red blood cells. The addition of phosphatidylethanolamine resulted in no increase in methylation rate over that with endogenous substrate; however, the addition of monomethylphosphatidylethanolamine (PME) and dimethylphosphatidylethanolamine (PDE) markedly increased the reaction rate and allowed studies into the kinetic mechanism for the second and third methylation reactions. The data are consistent with catalysis of the last two methylations being by a single enzyme with a random Bi-Bi sequential mechanism. Analysis of PDE:phosphatidylcholine product ratios indicates that the enzyme can conduct multiple methylations of enzyme-bound phospholipid. The nature of the acyl chain (16:0 versus 18:1) of the phospholipid had only a small effect on the value of the kinetic constants. The maximal velocities obtained with the 18:1 substrate were less than 5% lower than those obtained with the 16:0 substrate. The Km values for the two phospholipids were 20-45 and 10-14 microM for the methylation of PME and PDE, respectively. The Km for S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet) was 5-9 microM with PME and 4 microM with PDE as substrates. Depending on the acyl chain and the phospholipid, the Ki(AdoMet) varied from 8 to 19 microM, the Ki(PME) from 41 to 82 microM, and the Ki(PDE) from 35 to 61 microM. The Ki for S-adenosylhomocysteine (AdoHcy) was between 1.0 and 1.4 microM depending upon the variable substrate. The endogenous concentrations of PME and PDE in red blood cell membranes were estimated to be 0.49 and 0.24 mumol/liter packed cells, respectively. The product from the utilization of AdoMet, S-adenosylhomocysteine (AdoHcy), was shown to be a competitive inhibitor of its precursor, AdoMet, and a noncompetitive inhibitor of the two phospholipid substrates.     

Signals for activation and proliferation of murine T lymphocyte clones

Biochemical signals required for the growth of T cell clones were studied. Antigen-specific helper T cell clones, 6-1 and KO.6, could enter the state similar to the resting state where the cells expressed only small numbers of interleukin 2 (IL2) receptors and could not respond to IL2 without antigenic stimulation. A combination of a phorbol ester, 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA), and a calcium ionophore, A23187, induced the expression of IL2 receptors on resting 6-1 cells and induced DNA synthesis in the presence of IL2. TPA alone did not induce IL2 receptors. A23187 induced the expression of the receptors to some extent but did not induce DNA synthesis even in the presence of IL2. IL2 receptors induced by A23187 alone were mostly low affinity receptors, whereas the combination of TPA and A23187 induced high affinity receptors in addition to low affinity receptors. Resting KO.6 cells produced IL2 in response to a combination of TPA and A23187, whereas either one of the agents did not induce the production of IL2. Dicaprylin, a permeable diacylglycerol and a potent activator of protein kinase C (the Ca2+/phospholipid-dependent enzyme) could replace TPA in both cases when dicaprylin was repeatedly added to the culture. These results suggest that strong and continuous activation of protein kinase C together with calcium mobilization is required for IL2 production and IL2 receptor expression. On the contrary, signals for DNA synthesis generated by binding of IL2 to IL2 receptors are different from those for IL2 production and IL2 receptor expression, as the combination of TPA and A23187 could not induce DNA synthesis without IL2.