Reduction of gene repair by selenomethionine with the use of single-stranded oligonucleotides

Background  

The repair of single base mutations in mammalian genes can be directed by single-stranded oligonucleotides in a process known as targeted gene repair. The mechanism of this reaction is currently being elucidated but likely involves a pairing step in which the oligonucleotide align in homologous register with its target sequence and a correction step in which the mutant base is replaced by endogenous repair pathways. This process is regulated by the activity of various factors and proteins that either elevate or depress the frequency at which gene repair takes place.     

Stimulation of D-loop formation by polypurine/polypyrimidine sequences

Most of the approaches used to correct gene mutations in mammalian cells involve the targeting of short nucleotide molecules to homologous chromosomal sequences and the replacement of resident sequences via homologous recombination and mismatch repair. The limited efficiency and inconsistent reproducibility of these techniques are major constraints to their use in gene therapy. One of the main problems is that it is impossible to obtain reproducible results when the targeted gene loci differ. We investigated the effects of flanking sequences on homologous recombination by means of an in vitro assay of the efficiency of oligonucleotide targeting to its homologous sequence on a large duplex molecule in a reaction catalysed by the Escherichia coli RecA protein. We demonstrated that polypurine·polypyrimidine tracts (PPTs) in duplex DNA strongly stimulate the formation of D-loops with short oligodeoxynucleotides. This result was reproduced with various PPT sequences and oligonucleotides. The stimulatory effect was observed at loci as far as 4000 bp from the PPT. The formation of complexes between the oligonucleotide and the duplex molecule depended on the extent of sequence similarity between the two DNAs and the presence of the RecA protein. The stimulatory effect was inhibited by excess RecA and restored by adding heterologous DNA. We suggest that PPT sequences induce conformational changes in duplex DNA, leading to the aggregation of molecules, facilitating homology searches. We com pared, in vivo, the efficiency of the oligonucleotide-mediated correction of a URA3 chromosomal mutation for sequences with and without a PPT sequence in the vicinity. Consistent with our in vitro results, the efficiency of correction was eight times higher in the presence of the PPT sequence.     

Targeted nucleotide repair of cyc1 mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae directed by modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides

Modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides have been used to direct base changes in the CYC1 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In this process, the oligonucleotide is believed to hybridize to the target site through the action of a DNA recombinase and, once bound, DNA repair enzymes act to excise the nucleotide, replace it, and revert the gene to wild-type status. Nucleotide exchange exhibits a strand bias as, in most cases, a higher level of base reversal appears in cells in which the oligonucleotide is designed to hybridize to the nontemplate strand. But, in one case, a higher level was observed when an oligonucleotide complementary to the transcribed strand was used. Mutant haploid and diploid strains are reverted to wild type at this locus with approximately the same frequency and all strains take up the oligonucleotide with approximately equal efficiency. Some repair preference for certain base mismatches was observed; for example, T/T and C/C mispairs exhibited the highest degree of reactivity. Finally, we demonstrate that proteins involved in DNA pairing can enhance the repair activity up to 22-fold, while others affect the reaction minimally. Taken together, these results confirm the importance and versatility of yeast as a model system to elucidate the factors regulating the frequency of nucleotide exchange directed by oligonucleotides.     

Optimizing the design of oligonucleotides for homology directed gene targeting

Background

Gene targeting depends on the ability of cells to use homologous recombination to integrate exogenous DNA into their own genome. A robust mechanistic model of homologous recombination is necessary to fully exploit gene targeting for therapeutic benefit.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In this work, our recently developed numerical simulation model for homology search is employed to develop rules for the design of oligonucleotides used in gene targeting. A Metropolis Monte-Carlo algorithm is used to predict the pairing dynamics of an oligonucleotide with the target double-stranded DNA. The model calculates the base-alignment between a long, target double-stranded DNA and a probe nucleoprotein filament comprised of homologous recombination proteins (Rad51 or RecA) polymerized on a single strand DNA. In this study, we considered different sizes of oligonucleotides containing 1 or 3 base heterologies with the target; different positions on the probe were tested to investigate the effect of the mismatch position on the pairing dynamics and stability. We show that the optimal design is a compromise between the mean time to reach a perfect alignment between the two molecules and the stability of the complex.

Conclusion and Significance

A single heterology can be placed anywhere without significantly affecting the stability of the triplex. In the case of three consecutive heterologies, our modeling recommends using long oligonucleotides (at least 35 bases) in which the heterologous sequences are positioned at an intermediate position. Oligonucleotides should not contain more than 10% consecutive heterologies to guarantee a stable pairing with the target dsDNA. Theoretical modeling cannot replace experiments, but we believe that our model can considerably accelerate optimization of oligonucleotides for gene therapy by predicting their pairing dynamics with the target dsDNA.     

Nuclear extracts promote gene correction and strand pairing of oligonucleotides to the homologous plasmid

We compared strand pairing and gene correction activities between different constructs of oligonucleotides, using homologous supercoiled DNA and eukaryotic nuclear extracts. The RNA-DNA chimeric oligonucleotide was more efficient in strand pairing and gene correction than its DNA-DNA homolog. Single-stranded deoxyoligonucleotides showed similar strand pairing and correction activity to the modified RNA-DNA chimeric oligonucleotides, whereas single-stranded ribooligonucleotides did not show either activity. However, the correlations were not always linear, suggesting that only a fraction of the joint molecules may be processed to cause the final gene correction. Several mammalian extracts with markedly different in vitro activity showed the similar amounts of the joint molecules. These results led us to conclude that strand pairing is a necessary event in gene correction but may not be the rate-limiting step. Furthermore, depletion of HsRad51 protein caused large decreases in both strand-pairing and functional activities, whereas supplementation of HsRad51 produced only a slight increase in the repair activity, indicating that HsRad51 participates in the strand pairing, but subsequent steps define the frequency of gene correction. In addition, we found that the structure and stability of intermediates formed by single-stranded deoxyoligonucleotides and RNA-DNA chimeric oligonucleotides were different, suggesting that they differ in their mechanisms of gene repair.     

The effect of heterologous insertions on gene conversion in mitotically dividing cells in Drosophila melanogaster

We examined the influence that heterologous sequences of different sizes have on the frequency of double-strand-break repair by gene conversion in Drosophila melanogaster. We induced a double-strand break on one X chromosome in female flies by P-element excision. These flies contained heterologous insertions of various sizes located 238 bp from the break site in cis or in trans to the break, or both. We observed a significant decrease in double-strand-break repair with large heterologous insertions located either in cis or in trans to the break. Reestablishing the homology by including the same heterologous sequence in cis and in trans to the double-strand break restored the frequency of gene conversion to wild-type levels. In one instance, an allelic nonhomologous insertion completely abolished repair by homologous recombination. The results show that the repair of a double-strand break by gene conversion requires chromosome pairing in the local region of the double-strand break.     

Gene Correction by RNA‐DNA Oligonucleotides

An oligonucleotide composed of a contiguous stretch of RNA and DNA residues has been developed to facilitate the correction of single‐base mutations of episomal and chromosomal targets in mammalian cells. The design of the oligonucleotide exploited the highly recombinogenic RNA‐DNA hybrids and featured hairpin capped ends avoiding destruction by cellular helicases or exonucleases. The RNA‐DNA oligonucleotide (RDO) was designed to correct a point mutation in the tyrosinase gene and caused a permanent gene correction in mouse albino melanocytes, determined by clonal analysis at the level of genomic sequence, protein and phenotypic change. Recently, we demonstrated correction of the tyrosinase gene using the same RDO in vivo, as detected by dark pigmentation of several hairs and DOPA staining of hair follicles in the treated skin of albino mice. Such RDOs might hold a promise as a therapeutic method for the treatment of skin diseases. However, the frequency of gene correction varies among different cells, indicating that cellular activities, such as recombination and repair, may be important for gene conversion by RDOs. As this technology becomes more widely utilized in the scientific community, it will be important to understand the mechanism and to optimize the design of RDOs to improve their efficiency and general applicability.     

By searching processively RecA protein pairs DNA molecules that share a limited stretch of homology

RecA protein promotes homologous pairing by a reaction in which the protein first binds stoichiometrically to single-stranded DNA in a slow presyn-aptic step, and then conjoins single-stranded and duplex DNA, thereby forming a ternary complex. RecA protein did not pair molecules that shared only 30 bp homology, but, with full efficiency, it paired circular single-stranded and linear duplex molecules in which homology was limited to 151 bp at one end of the duplex DNA. The initial rate of the pairing reaction was directly related to the length of the heterologous part of the duplex DNA, which we varied from 0 to 3060 base pairs. Since interactions involving the heterologous part of a molecule speed the location of a small homologous region, we conclude that RecA protein promotes homologous alignment by a processive mechanism involving relative motion of conjoined molecules within the ternary complex.     

Complementary addressed modification of plasmid DNA

The possibility to accomplish the sequence-specific chemical modification of superhelical DNA with reactive oligonucleotide derivatives was demonstrated. Plasmids containing fragments of the immunoglobulin gene were modified with alkylating derivatives of oligonucleotides complementary to a nucleotide sequence in the immunoglobulin gene. In contrast to the relaxed plasmid DNAs, superhelical DNAs (sigma = -0.1) were found to be attacked by the derivatives at the target nucleotide sequence. The efficiency of the reaction increases with the increase of the plasmids negative superhelicity. It was found also that the denatured derivatives. The sequence-specific modification of plasmid DNAs with the reactive oligonucleotide derivatives can be used for the site-directed mutagenesis and the investigation of the repair processes.     

Transformation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae with nonhomologous DNA: illegitimate integration of transforming DNA into yeast chromosomes and in vivo ligation of transforming DNA to mitochondrial DNA sequences.

When the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae was transformed with DNA that shares no homology to the genome, three classes of transformants were obtained. In the most common class, the DNA was inserted as the result of a reaction that appears to require base pairing between the target sequence and the terminal few base pairs of the transforming DNA fragment. In the second class, no such homology was detected, and the transforming DNA was integrated next to a CTT or GTT in the target; it is likely that these integration events were mediated by topoisomerase I. The final class involved the in vivo ligation of transforming DNA with nucleus-localized linear fragments of mitochondrial DNA.     

Heterology tolerance and recognition of mismatched base pairs by human Rad51 protein

Human Rad51 (hRad51) promoted homology recognition and subsequent strand exchange are the key steps in human homologous recombination mediated repair of DNA double-strand breaks. However, it is still not clear how hRad51 deals with sequence heterology between the two homologous chromosomes in eukaryotic cells, which would lead to mismatched base pairs after strand exchange. Excessive tolerance of sequence heterology may compromise the fidelity of repair of DNA double-strand breaks. In this study, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) was used to monitor the heterology tolerance of human Rad51 mediated strand exchange reactions, in real time, by introducing either G-T or I-C mismatched base pairs between the two homologous DNA strands. The strand exchange reactions were much more sensitive to G-T than to I-C base pairs. These results imply that the recognition of homology and the tolerance of heterology by hRad51 may depend on the local structural motif adopted by the base pairs participating in strand exchange. AnhRad51 mutant protein (hRad51K133R), deficient in ATP hydrolysis, showed greater heterology tolerance to both types of mismatch base pairing, suggesting that ATPase activity may be important for maintenance of high fidelity homologous recombination DNA repair.     

DNA pairing is an important step in the process of targeted nucleotide exchange

Modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides can direct the repair of genetic mutations in yeast, plant and mammalian cells. The mechanism by which these molecules exert their effect is being elucidated, but the first phase is likely to involve the homologous alignment of the single strand with its complementary sequence in the target gene. In this study, we establish the importance of such DNA pairing in facilitating the gene repair event. Oligonucleotide-directed repair occurs at a low frequency in an Escherichia coli strain (DH10B) lacking the RECA DNA pairing function. Repair activity can be rescued by using purified RecA protein to catalyze the assimilation of oligonucleotide vectors into a plasmid containing a mutant kanamycin resistance gene in vitro. Electroporation of the preformed complex into DH10B cells results in high levels of gene repair activity, evidenced by the appearance of kanamycin-resistant colonies. Gene repair is dependent on the formation of a double-displacement loop (double-D-loop), a recombination intermediate containing two single-stranded oligonucleotides hybridized to opposite strands of the plasmid at the site of the point mutation. The heightened level of stability of the double-D-loop enables it to serve as an active template for the DNA repair events. The data establish DNA pairing and the formation of the double-D-loop as important first steps in the process of gene repair.     

Targeted correction of a chromosomal point mutation by modified single-stranded oligonucleotides in a GFP recovery system

Synthetic oligonucleotides had been employed in DNA repair and promised great potentials in gene therapy. To test the ability of single-stranded oligonucleotide (SSO)-mediated gene repair within a chromosomal site in human cells, a HeLa cell line stably integrated with mutant enhanced green fluorescence protein gene (mEGFP) in the genome was established. Transfection with specific SSOs successfully repaired the mEGFP gene and resulted in the expression of functional fluorescence proteins, which could be detected by fluorescence microscopy and FACS assay. Western blot showed that EGFP was only present in the cells transfected with correction SSOs rather than the control SSOs. Furthermore, DNA sequencing confirmed that phenotype change resulted from the designated nucleotide correction at the target site. Using this reporter system, we determined the optimal structure of SSO by investigating the effect of length, modifications, and polarities of SSOs as well as the positions of the mismatch-forming nucleotide on the efficiency of SSO-mediated gene repair. Interestingly, we found that SSOs with mismatch-forming nucleotide positioned at different positions have varying potencies that homology at the 5'-end of SSOs was more crucial for the SSO's activity. These results provided guidance for designing effective SSOs as tools for treating monogenic inherited diseases.     

Aptamer-guided gene targeting in yeast and human cells

Gene targeting is a genetic technique to modify an endogenous DNA sequence in its genomic location via homologous recombination (HR) and is useful both for functional analysis and gene therapy applications. HR is inefficient in most organisms and cell types, including mammalian cells, often limiting the effectiveness of gene targeting. Therefore, increasing HR efficiency remains a major challenge to DNA editing. Here, we present a new concept for gene correction based on the development of DNA aptamers capable of binding to a site-specific DNA binding protein to facilitate the exchange of homologous genetic information between a donor molecule and the desired target locus (aptamer-guided gene targeting). We selected DNA aptamers to the I-SceI endonuclease. Bifunctional oligonucleotides containing an I-SceI aptamer sequence were designed as part of a longer single-stranded DNA molecule that contained a region with homology to repair an I-SceI generated double-strand break and correct a disrupted gene. The I-SceI aptamer-containing oligonucleotides stimulated gene targeting up to 32-fold in yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and up to 16-fold in human cells. This work provides a novel concept and research direction to increase gene targeting efficiency and lays the groundwork for future studies using aptamers for gene targeting.     

RecA-mediated strand invasion of DNA by oligonucleotides substituted with 2-aminoadenine and 2-thiothymine

Sequence-specific recognition of DNA is a critical step in gene targeting. Here we describe unique oligonucleotide (ON) hybrids that can stably pair to both strands of a linear DNA target in a RecA-dependent reaction with ATP or ATPγS. One strand of the hybrids is a 30-mer DNA ON that contains a 15-nt-long A/T-rich central core. The core sequence, which is substituted with 2-aminoadenine and 2-thiothymine, is weakly hybridized to complementary locked nucleic acid or 2′-OMe RNA ONs that are also substituted with the same base analogs. Robust targeting reactions took place in the presence of ATPγS and generated metastable double D-loop joints. Since the hybrids had pseudocomplementary character, the component ONs hybridized less strongly to each other than to complementary target DNA sequences composed of regular bases. This difference in pairing strength promoted the formation of joints capable of accommodating a single mismatch. If similar joints can form in vivo, virtually any A/T-rich site in genomic DNA could be selectively targeted. By designing the constructs so that the DNA ON is mismatched to its complementary sequence in DNA, joint formation might allow the ON to function as a template for targeted point mutation and gene correction.     

Reaction parameters of targeted gene repair in mammalian cells

Targeted gene repair uses short DNA oligonucleotides to direct a nucleotide exchange reaction at a designated site in a mammalian chromosome. The widespread use of this technique has been hampered by the inability of workers to achieve robust levels of correction. Here, we present a mammalian cell system in which DLD-1 cells bearing integrated copies of a mutant eGFP gene are repaired by modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides. We demonstrate that two independent clonal isolates, which are transcribed at different levels, are corrected at different frequencies. We confirm the evidence of a strand bias observed previously in other systems, wherein an oligonucleotide designed to be complementary to the nontranscribed strand of the target directs a higher level of repair than one targeting the transcribed strand. Higher concentrations of cell oligonucleotides in the electroporation mixture lead to higher levels of correction. When the target cell population is synchronized into S phase then released before electroporation, the correction efficiency is increased within the entire population. This model system could be useful for pharmacogenomic applications of targeted gene repair including the creation of cell lines containing single-base alterations.     

A plausible mechanism for gene correction by chimeric oligonucleotides

Self-complementary chimeric oligonucleotides that consist of DNA and 2'-O-methyl RNA nucleotides arranged in a double-hairpin configuration can elicit a point mutation when targeted to a gene sequence. We have used a series of structurally diverse chimeric oligonucleotides to correct a mutant neomycin phosphotransferase gene in a human cell-free extract. Analysis of structure-activity relationships demonstrates that the DNA strand of the chimeric oligonucleotide acts as a template for high-fidelity gene correction when one of its bases is mismatched to the targeted gene. By contrast, the chimeric strand of the oligonucleotide does not function as a template for gene repair. Instead, it appears to augment the frequency of gene correction by facilitating complex formation with the target. In the presence of RecA protein, each strand of a chimeric oligonucleotide can hybridize with double-stranded DNA to form a complement-stabilized D-loop. This reaction, which may take place by reciprocal four-strand exchange, is not observed with oligonucleotides that lack 2'-O-methyl RNA segments. Preliminary sequencing data suggest that complement-stabilized D-loops may be weakly mutagenic. If so, a low level of random mutagenesis in the vicinity of the chimera binding site may accompany gene repair.