Ozone sensitivity in hybrid poplar correlates with insensitivity to both salicylic acid and jasmonic acid. The role of programmed cell death in lesion formation

Our earlier studies demonstrated that the ozone-sensitive hybrid poplar clone NE-388 displays an attenuated level of ozone-, wound-, and phytopathogen-induced defense gene expression. To determine if this reduced gene activation involves signal transduction pathways dependent on salicylic acid (SA) and/or jasmonic acid (JA), we compared the responses of NE-388 and an ozone-tolerant clone, NE-245, to these signal molecules. JA levels increased in both clones in response to ozone, but only minimal increases in SA levels were measured for either clone. Treatment with SA and methyl jasmonate induced defense gene expression only in NE-245, indicating that NE-388 is insensitive to these signal molecules. DNA fragmentation, an indicator of programmed cell death (PCD), was detected in NE-245 treated with either ozone or an avirulent phytopathogen, but was not detected in NE-388. We conclude that these clones undergo two distinct mechanisms of ozone-induced lesion formation. In NE-388, lesions appear to be due to toxic cell death resulting from a limited ability to perceive and subsequently activate SA- and/or JA-mediated antioxidant defense responses. In NE-245, SA-dependent PCD precedes lesion formation via a process related to the PCD pathway activated by phytopathogenic bacteria. These results support the hypothesis that ozone triggers a hypersensitive response.     

Physiological, stomatal and ultrastructural ozone responses in birch (Betula pendula Roth.) are modified by water stress

The physiological, stomatal and ultrastructural responses to ozone and drought of ozone-sensitive and more ozone-tolerant birch ( Betula pendula Roth.) clones were studied singly and in combination, in a high-stress chamber experiment and in a low-stress open-field experiment. In the chamber experiment, well watered (WW), moderately watered (MW) or drought-stressed (DS) saplings were exposed for 36 d to 0 or 130 nmol mol^∠1 ozone. In the open-field experiment, well watered or drought-stressed saplings were grown for one growing season in ambient air or exposed to 1·8 × ambient ozone. Drought stress reduced growth rate, stomatal conductance, stomatal density and the proportion of starch and thylakoids in chloroplasts, but stimulated net photosynthesis, Rubisco and chlorophyll quantity at the end of the growing season, and increased the size and density of plastoglobuli. Ozone fumigations caused more variable, clone- and exposure-dependent responses in growth, decreased stomatal conductance and net photosynthesis, an increased number of stomata, visible and ultrastructural chloroplast injuries, and enhanced autumn yellowing of the leaves. Ozone-induced changes in plastoglobuli, starch and thylakoids resembled drought responses. The two experiments revealed that, depending on the experimental conditions and the variable, the response to drought and ozone stress can be independent, additive or interactive. Drought protected the plants from ozone injuries under high-stress conditions in the chamber experiment. In the low-stress, open-field experiment, however, enhanced ozone damage was observed in birch saplings grown under restricted water supply.     

The effects of ozone on growth and stomatal response in the F<Subscript>2</Subscript> generation of hybrid poplar (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Populus trichocarpa × Populus deltoides</Emphasis>)

Thirty-six F₂ hybrid poplar (Populus trichocarpa × P. deltoides) clones were fumigated with ozone to record its effects on growth, correlate them with stomatal response and screen for ozone sensitivity. Fumigation was applied for 6 to 9 h each day for approximately 3 months at ozone concentrations of 85 to 128 μg g⁻¹ using open-top chambers. Height, diameter, number of leaves, stomatal conductance, transpiration rate, total biomass, biomass components and root/shoot ratios were reduced by ozone stress. Percent of leaf fall in ozone-treated plants was nearly three times higher than in control plants exposed to charcoal-filtered air. Leaf senescence, because of ozone exposure, did not appear to be associated with reduced biomass production. Some clones had a high percentage of leaf-fall with ozone exposure, but were able to maintain total biomass production near that of the control. Their response may be an example of an ability to adjust or compensate for ozone damage. There was no significant or consistent relationship between stomatal conductance and total biomass or the change in stomatal conductance as a result of ozone exposure and the change in total biomass. Taken together, these results suggest that effects of ozone on poplar growth cannot be solely correlated to changes in stomatal conductance, more physiological and biochemical parameters should be examined.     

Responses of selected birch (Betula pendula Roth) clones to ozone change over time

A long-term free air ozone fumigation experiment was conducted to study changes in physiological ozone responses during tree ontogeny and exposure time in ozone sensitive and tolerant clones of European white birch (Betula pendula Roth), originated from south and central Finland. The trees were grown in soil in natural microclimatic conditions under ambient ozone (control) and 1.4-1.7 x ambient (elevated) ozone from May 1996 to October 2001, and were measured for stem and foliage growth, net photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, stomatal density, visible injuries, foliar starch content and bud formation. After 6 years of exposure, the magnitude of ozone-induced growth reductions in the sensitive clone was 12-48% (significant difference), levels similar or greater than those reported earlier for 2- and 3-year-old saplings undergoing shorter exposures. In the tolerant clone, growth of these larger trees was reduced by 1-38% (significant difference in stem volume), although the saplings had previously been unaffected. In both clones, ozone stress led to significantly reduced leaf-level net photosynthesis but significantly increased stomatal conductance rates during the late summer, resulting in a lower carbon gain for bud formation and the onset of visible foliar injuries. Increasing ozone sensitivity with duration of exposure was explained by a change in growth form (relatively reduced foliage mass), a lower photosynthesis to stomatal conductance ratio during the late summer, and deleterious carry-over effects arising from the reduced number of over-wintering buds.     

Disruption of a gene encoding C4-dicarboxylate transporter-like protein increases ozone sensitivity through deregulation of the stomatal response in Arabidopsis thaliana

To understand better the plant response to ozone, we isolated and characterized an ozone-sensitive (ozs1) mutant strain from a set of T-DNA-tagged Arabidopsis thaliana ecotype Columbia. The mutant plants show enhanced sensitivity to ozone, desiccation and sulfur dioxide, but have normal sensitivity to hydrogen peroxide, low temperature and high light levels. The T-DNA was inserted at a single locus which is linked to ozone sensitivity. Identification of the genomic sequences flanking the T-DNA insertion revealed disruption of a gene encoding a transporter-like protein of the tellurite resistance/C(4)-dicarboxylate transporter family. Plants with either of two different T-DNA insertions in this gene were also sensitive to ozone, and these plants failed to complement ozs1. Transpiration levels, stomatal conductance levels and the size of stomatal apertures were greater in ozs1 mutant plants than in the wild type. The stomatal apertures of ozs1 mutant plants responded to light fluctuations but were always larger than those of the wild-type plants under the same conditions. The stomata of the mutant and wild-type plants responded similarly to stimuli such as light, abscisic acid, high concentrations of carbon dioxide and ozone. These results suggest that OZS1 helps to close stomata, being not involved in the responses to these signals.     

Whole-tree water use efficiency is decreased by ambient ozone and not affected by O3-induced stomatal sluggishness

Steady-state and dynamic gas exchange responses to ozone visible injury were investigated in an ozone-sensitive poplar clone under field conditions. The results were translated into whole tree water loss and carbon assimilation by comparing trees exposed to ambient ozone and trees treated with the ozone-protectant ethylenediurea (EDU). Steady-state stomatal conductance and photosynthesis linearly decreased with increasing ozone visible injury. Dynamic responses simulated by severing of a leaf revealed that stomatal sluggishness increased until a threshold of 5% injury and was then fairly constant. Sluggishness resulted from longer time to respond to the closing signal and slower rate of closing. Changes in photosynthesis were driven by the dynamics of stomata. Whole-tree carbon assimilation and water loss were lower in trees exposed to ambient O(3) than in trees protected by EDU, both under steady-state and dynamic conditions. Although stomatal sluggishness is expected to increase water loss, lower stomatal conductance and premature leaf shedding of injured leaves aggravated O(3) effects on whole tree carbon gain, while compensating for water loss. On average, WUE of trees exposed to ambient ozone was 2-4% lower than that of EDU-protected control trees in September and 6-8% lower in October.     

Physiological and ultrastructural responses of sour orange (Citrus aurantium L.) clones to water stress

Water stress is a major abiotic constraint leading to serious crop losses. Recently, in the Mediterranean region, water stress has become markedly sensed, especially in Citrus orchards. This study investigated the physiological responses of local sour orange (Citrus aurantium L.) clones to severe water stress. Water stress was applied by withholding irrigation during weeks, followed by a rewatering phase during three months. Under water stress, sour orange clones decreased their stomatal conductance, net photosynthetic rate, and transpiration rate. On the contrary, biomass was stable, especially in the Kliaa clone. In addition, reduced leaf water potentials (-3 MPa) and water contents were measured in most of the clones, except Kliaa which kept the highest water potential (-2.5 MPa). After rewatering, all clones recovered except of the Ghars Mrad (GM) clone. Ultrastructural observations of leaf sections by transmission electron microscopy did not reveal marked alterations in the mesophyll cells and chloroplast structure of Kliaa in comparison to the sensitive clone GM, in which palisade parenchyma cells and chloroplasts were disorganized. This contrasting behavior was mainly attributed to genetic differences as attested by molecular analysis. This study highlighted GM as the drought-sensitive clone and Kliaa as the tolerant clone able to develop an avoidance strategy based on an efficient stomatal regulation. Although a high percentage of polyembryony characterizes C. aurantium and justifies its multiplication by seeds, heterogeneous water-stress responses could be observed within sour orange plants in young orchards.     

Contrasting effects of simazine on the photosynthetic physiology and leaf morphology of two Populus clones

Differential effects of simazine (2-chloro-4,6-bis(ethylamino)- s -triazine) on the physiology of two Populus clones were investigated in a greenhouse study. Additions of 5 mg/pot simazine to young plants had no deleterious morphological or physiological effects on clone NC 5328 ( P. x euramericana cv. I 45/51; Section Aigeiros), but reduced the rate of CO₂ fixation, increased CO₂ compensation concentrations and lowered the specific leaf weight of clone NE 388 ( P. maximowiczü x P. trichocarpa cv. Kingston; section Tacamahaca). Abaxial leaf conductance to water vapor was not affected in NE 388. Deleterious effects of simazine on NE 388 were detected ca 48 h after exposure of plants to simazine and generally became more pronounced thereafter. Visual symptoms of injury were evident at ca 2 weeks after simazine application.
Toxic responses to simazine in clone NE 388 varied in different portions of the crown. Inhibition of photosynthesis and increased CO₂ compensation concentrations were more pronounced in the region of recently matured leaves, but were somewhat less in the region of expanding leaves. Older mature leaves in the lower crown region showed no visual symptoms of injury and the rate of photosynthesis and CO₂ compensation concentrations were largely unaffected.     

Stomatal factors and vulnerability of stem xylem to cavitation in poplars

The relationships between the vulnerability of stem xylem to cavitation, stomatal conductance, stomatal density, and leaf and stem water potential were examined in six hybrid poplar (P38P38, Walker, Okanese, Northwest, Assiniboine and Berlin) and balsam poplar (Populus balsamifera) clones. Stem xylem cavitation resistance was examined with the Cavitron technique in well-watered plants grown in the greenhouse. To investigate stomatal responses to drought, plants were subjected to drought stress by withholding watering for 5 (mild drought) and 7 (severe drought) days and to stress recovery by rewatering severely stressed plants for 30 min and 2 days. The clones varied in stomatal sensitivity to drought and vulnerability to stem xylem cavitation. P38P38 reduced stomatal conductance in response to mild stress while the balsam poplar clone maintained high leaf stomatal conductance under more severe drought stress conditions. Differences between the severely stressed clones were also observed in leaf water potentials with no or relatively small decreases in Assiniboine, P38P38, Okanese and Walker. Vulnerability to drought-induced stem xylem embolism revealed that balsam poplar and Northwest clones reached loss of conductivity at lower stem water potentials compared with the remaining clones. There was a strong link between stem xylem resistance to cavitation and stomatal responsiveness to drought stress in balsam poplar and P38P38. However, the differences in stomatal responsiveness to mild drought suggest that other drought-resistant strategies may also play a key role in some clones of poplars exposed to drought stress.     

Ozone‐induced stomatal sluggishness changes stomatal parameters of Jarvis‐type model in white birch and deciduous oak

• Stomatal ozone flux is closely related to ozone injury to plants. Jarvis‐type multiplicative model has been recommended for estimating stomatal ozone flux in forest trees. Ozone can change stomatal conductance by both stomatal closure and less efficient stomatal control (stomatal sluggishness). However, current Jarvis‐type models do not account for these ozone effects on stomatal conductance in forest trees.
• We examined seasonal course of stomatal conductance in two common deciduous tree species native to northern Japan (white birch: Betula platyphylla var. japonica ; deciduous oak: Quercus mongolica var. crispula ) grown under free‐air ozone exposure. We innovatively considered stomatal sluggishness in the Jarvis‐type model using a simple parameter, s , relating to cumulative ozone uptake (defined as POD : phytotoxic ozone dose).
• We found that ozone decreased stomatal conductance of white birch leaves after full expansion (?28%). However, such a reduction of stomatal conductance by ozone fell in late summer (?10%). At the same time, ozone reduced stomatal sensitivity of white birch to VPD and increased stomatal conductance under low light conditions. In contrast, in deciduous oak, ozone did not clearly change the model parameters.
• The consideration of both ozone‐induced stomatal closure and stomatal sluggishness improved the model performance to estimate stomatal conductance and to explain the dose–response relationship on ozone‐induced decline of photosynthesis of white birch. Our results indicate that ozone effects on stomatal conductance (i.e . stomatal closure and stomatal sluggishness) are crucial for modelling studies to determine stomatal response in deciduous trees, especially in species sensitive to ozone.

     

Stomatal Closure During Tobacco Leaf Desiccation as Affected by Ozone

The effect of acute ozone exposure on the stomatal conductance and leaf water content during rapid desiccation was examined in leaves of two tobacco cultivars, ozone sensitive cv. BelW3 and ozone tolerant cv. Samsun. The relative rate of stomatal closure was constant during leaf desiccation in cv. Samsun but decreased in cv. BelW3 in both ozonated and control plants. Ozone exposure increased the relative rate of stomatal closure and transpiration rate (measured on the following day) in cv. Samsun, but reduced the respective parameters in cv. BelW3. As a result, the plants of ozone-sensitive cultivar, treated with ozone, lost more water during desiccation than control plants. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Ozone exposure results in various carry-over effects and prolonged reduction in biomass in birch (Betula pendula Roth)

In the first experiment, saplings of ozone-sensitive and a more tolerant clone of Betula pendula Roth were exposed to ambient ozone (control treatment, accumulated exposure over a threshold 40 nmol mol ^{? 1} (AOT40) exposure of 1·0 μmol mol ^{? 1} h) and 1·5 × ambient ozone (elevated-ozone treatment, AOT40 of 17·3 μmol mol ^{? 1} h) over one growing season, 1996. After over-wintering, the dormant elevated-ozone saplings were transferred to the control blocks and assessed for short-term carry-over effects during the following growing season. In the second experiment, three sensitive, four intermediate and three tolerant clones were grown under ambient ozone (control treatment, AOT40 of 0·5–0·8 μmol mol ^{? 1} h per growing season) and 1·6–1·7 × ambient ozone (elevated-ozone treatment, AOT40 of 18·3–18·6 μmol mol ^{? 1} h per growing season) from May 1994 until May 1996, and were assessed for long-term carry-over effects during growing season 1997, after a 12–16 months recovery period. Deleterious short-term carry-over effects of ozone exposure included reduced contents of Rubisco, chlorophyll, carotenoids, starch and nutrients in leaves, lower stomatal conductance, and decreased new shoot growth and net assimilation rate, followed by a 7·5% (shoot dry weight (DW)), 15·2% (root DW) and 23·2% (foliage area) decreased biomass accumulation and yield over the long term, including a reduced root : shoot ratio. However, a slow recovery of relative growth rates during the following two seasons without elevated ozone was apparent. Several long-lasting structural, biochemical and stomatal acclimation, stress-defence and compensation reactions were observed in the ozone-tolerant clone, whereas in the sensitive clone allocation shifted from growth towards defensive phenolics such as chlorogenic acid. The results provide evidence of persistent deleterious effects of ozone which remain long after the ozone episode.     

Stomatal Conductance and Sulfur Uptake of Five Clones of Populus tremuloides Exposed to Sulfur Dioxide

Plants of five clones of Populus tremuloides Michx. were exposed to 0, 0.2 or 0.5 microliter per liter SO₂ for 8 hours in controlled environment chambers. In the absence of the pollutant, two pollution-resistant clones maintained consistently lower daytime diffusive conductance (LDC) than did a highly susceptible clone or two moderately resistant clones. Differences in LDC among the latter three clones were not significant. At 0.2 microliter per liter SO₂, LDC decreased in the susceptible clone after 8 hours fumigation while the LDC of the other clones was not affected. Fumigation with 0.5 microliter per liter SO₂ decreased LDC of all five clones during the fumigation. Rates of recovery following fumigation varied with the clone, but the LDC of all clones had returned to control values by the beginning of the night following fumigation. Night LDC was higher in the susceptible clone than in the other clones. Fumigation for 16 hours (14 hours day + 2 hours night) with 0.4 microliter per liter SO₂ decreased night LDC by half. Sulfur uptake studies generally confirmed the results of the conductance measurements. The results show that stomatal conductance is important in determining relative susceptibility of the clones to pollution stress.     

Responses to ozone on Populus “Oxford” clone in an open top chamber experiment assessed before sunrise and in full sunlight

The effects of ambient levels of ozone and summer drought were assessed on a poplar clone (Populus maximowiczii Henry X P. × berolinensis Dippel — Oxford clone) in an open top chamber experiment carried out at the Curno facilities (Northern Italy). Chlorophyll (Chl) a fluorescence parameters (from both modulated and direct fluorescence) were assessed at different hours of the day (predawn, morning, midday, afternoon, and evening), from June to August 2008. This paper compares the results from predawn (PD, before sunrise) and afternoon (AN, in full sunlight) measurements, in order to evaluate the role of high sunlight as a factor influencing responses to ozone stress. Sunlight affected the maximum quantum yield of primary photochemistry (decrease of F_v/F_m) thus indicating photoinhibition. The effective quantum yield (Φ_PSII) and the photochemical quenching (q_P) were enhanced in the afternoon with respect to the predawn, whereas the nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) was reduced. The effect of ozone was detected with fluorescence on well watered plants in the first week of July, before the onset of visible symptoms. As far as F_v/F_m are concerned, the differences between ozone-treated and control plants were statistically significant in the predawn, but not in the afternoon. Ozone exerted only minor effects on drought exposed plants because of the reduced stomatal ozone uptake, but effects on the IP phase of the fluorescence transient were observed also in drought-stressed plants.     

Biochemical plant responses to ozone : I. Differential induction of polyamine and ethylene biosynthesis in tobacco

Polyamine metabolism was examined in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) exposed to a single ozone treatment (5 or 7 hours) and then postcultivated in pollutant-free air. The levels of free and conjugated putrescine were rapidly increased in the ozone-tolerant cultivar Bel B and remained high for 3 days. This accumulation was preceded by a transient rise of l-arginine decar-boxylase (ADC, EC 4.1.1.19) activity. The ozone-sensitive cultivar Bel W3 showed a rapid production of ethylene and high levels of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid after 1 to 2 hours of exposure. Induction of putrescine levels and ADC activity was weak in this cultivar and was observed when necrotic lesions developed. Leaf injury occurred in both lines when the molar ratio of putrescine to 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid or ethylene fell short of a certain threshold value. Monocaffeoyl-putrescine, an effective scavenger for oxyradicals, was detected in the apo-plastic fluid of the leaves of cv Bel B and increased upon exposure to ozone. This extracellular localization could allow scavenging of ozone-derived oxyradicals at the first site of their generation. Induction of either polyamine or ethylene pathways may represent a control mechanism for inhibition or promotion of lesion formation and thereby contribute to the disposition of plants for ozone tolerance.     

Photosynthesis of two poplar clones contrasting in O3 sensitivity

 Two clones of poplar known for their phenomenological difference in response to ozone were fumigated with 150 nl l^–1 of ozone for 5 h. In both clones the treatment significantly reduced the light-saturated rate of CO₂ uptake of recently mature leaves and this was accompanied by a decrease in stomatal conductance. Intercellular CO₂ concentration of the resistant clone increased following the fumigation. After 20 h of recovery, photosynthesis recovered completely only in the resistant clone. Electrolyte leakage of leaf disks increased in both clones to indicate damage to membranes; after the recovery time this parameter only reached values of the control in the resistant clone. The photochemical efficiency of PSII slightly decreased in the resistant clone. In the other clone, the treatment caused a decline of all chlorophyll fluorescence parameters and only some of them returned to normal values after the recovery time. The physiological response appears to be different in the two clones. In the resistant one, the most probable mechanism involved in the photosynthetic reduction was a regulatory reduction in CO₂ fixation. Also data obtained by the solute leakage indicate that in the resistant clone repair mechanisms play a role. The reduction of photosynthesis observed in the sensitive clone is related both to strong stomatal closure and to an impairment in fluorescence parameters. These alterations can indicate a general disruption at the membrane level as confirmed by the solute leakage data. Received: 30 June 1997 / Accepted: 3 September 1997