C4 photosynthesis in C3 rice: a theoretical analysis of biochemical and anatomical factors

Engineering C₄ photosynthesis into rice has been considered a promising strategy to increase photosynthesis and yield. A question that remains to be answered is whether expressing a C₄ metabolic cycle into a C₃ leaf structure and without removing the C₃ background metabolism improves photosynthetic efficiency. To explore this question, we developed a 3D reaction diffusion model of bundle‐sheath and connected mesophyll cells in a C₃ rice leaf. Our results show that integrating a C₄ metabolic pathway into rice leaves with a C₃ metabolism and mesophyll structure may lead to an improved photosynthesis under current ambient CO₂ concentration. We analysed a number of physiological factors that influence the CO₂ uptake rate, which include the chloroplast surface area exposed to intercellular air space, bundle‐sheath cell wall thickness, bundle‐sheath chloroplast envelope permeability, Rubisco concentration and the energy partitioning between C₃ and C₄ cycles. Among these, partitioning of energy between C₃ and C₄ photosynthesis and the partitioning of Rubisco between mesophyll and bundle‐sheath cells are decisive factors controlling photosynthetic efficiency in an engineered C₃–C₄ leaf. The implications of the results for the sequence of C₄ evolution are also discussed.     

Mechanism of c(4) photosynthesis: a model describing the inorganic carbon pool in bundle sheath cells

A theoretical model of the composition of the inorganic carbon pool generated in C₄ leaves during steady-state photosynthesis was derived. This model gives the concentrations of CO₂ and O₂ in the bundle sheath cells for any given net photosynthesis rate and inorganic carbon pool size. The model predicts a bundle sheath CO₂ concentration of 70 micromolar during steady state photosynthesis in a typical C₄ plant, and that about 13% of the inorganic carbon generated in bundle sheath cells would leak back to the mesophyll cells, predominantly as CO₂. Under these circumstances the flux of carbon through the C₄ acid cycle would have to exceed the net rate of CO₂ assimilation by 15.5%. With the calculated O₂ concentration of 0.44 millimolar, the potential photorespiratory CO₂ loss in bundle sheath cells would be about 3% of CO₂ assimilation. Among the factors having a critical influence on the above values are the permeability of bundle sheath chloroplasts to HCO₃⁻, the activity of carbonic anhydrase within these chloroplasts, the assumed stromal volume, and the permeability coefficients for CO₂ and O₂ diffusion across the interface between bundle sheath and mesophyll cells. The model suggests that as the net photosynthesis rate changes in C₄ plants, the level and distribution of the components of the inorganic carbon pool change in such a way that C₄ acid overcycling is maintained in an approximately constant ratio with respect to the net photosynthesis rate.     

Distribution of Photosynthetic Enzymes between Mesophyll, Specialized Parenchyma and Bundle Sheath Cells of Arundinella hirta

Arundinella hirta L. is a C₄ plant having an unusual C₄ leaf anatomy. Besides mesophyll and bundle sheath cells, A. hirta leaves have specialized parenchyma cells which look morphologically like bundle sheath cells but which lack vascular connections and are located between veins, running parallel to them. Activities of phosphoenolpyruvate and ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylases and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase, NADP-and NAD-malic enzymes were determined for whole leaf extracts and isolated mesophyll protoplasts, specialized parenchyma cells, and bundle sheath cells. The data indicate that A. hirta is a NADP-malic enzyme type C₄ species. In addition, specialized parenchyma cells and bundle sheath cells are enzymatically alike. Compartmentation of enzymes followed the C₄ pattern with phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase being restricted to mesophyll cells while ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase and decarboxylating enzymes were restricted to bundle sheath and specialized parenchyma cells.     

Metabolism of epidermal tissues, mesophyll cells, and bundle sheath strands resolved from mature nutsedge leaves

Mesophyll cells and bundle sheath strands were isolated from Cyperus rotundus L. leaf sections infiltrated with a mixture of cellulase and pectinase followed by a gentle mortar and pestle grind. The leaf suspension was filtered through a filter assembly and mesophyll cells and bundle sheath strands were collected on 20-μm and 80-μm nylon nets, respectively. For the isolation of leaf epidermal strips longer leaf cross sections were incubated with the enzymes and gently ground as above. Loosely attached epidermal strips were peeled off with forceps. The upper epidermis, which lacks stomata, could be clearly distinguished from the lower epidermis which contains stomata. Microscopic evidence for identification and assessment of purity is provided for each isolated tissue.Enzymes related to the C₄-dicarboxylic acid cycle such as phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, malate dehydrogenase (NADP⁺), pyruvate, P_i dikinase were found to be localized, ≥98%, in mesophyll cells. Enzymes related to operating the reductive pentose phosphate cycle such as RuDP carboxylase, phosphoribulose kinase, and malic enzyme are distributed, ≥99%, in bundle sheath strands. Other photosynthetic enzymes such as aspartate aminotransferase, pyrophosphatase, adenylate kinase, and glyceraldehyde 3-P dehydrogenase (NADP⁺) are quite active in both mesophyll and bundle sheath tissues.Enzymes involved in photorespiration such as RuDP oxygenase, catalase, glycolate oxidase, hydroxypyruvate reductase (NAD⁺), and phosphoglycolate phosphatase are preferentially localized, ≥84%, in bundle sheath strands.Nitrate and nitrite reductase can be found only in mesophyll cells, while glutamate dehydrogenase is present, ≥96%, in bundle sheath strands.Starch- and sucrose-synthesizing enzymes are about equally distributed between the mesophyll and bundle sheath tissues, except that the less active phosphorylase was found mainly in bundle sheath strands. Fructose-1,6-diP aldolase, which is a key enzyme in photosynthesis and glycolysis leading to sucrose and starch synthesis, is localized, ≥90%, in bundle sheath strands. The glycolytic enzymes, phosphoglyceromutase and enolase, have the highest activity in mesophyll cells, while the mitochondrial enzyme, cytochrome c oxidase, is more active in bundle sheath strands.The distribution of total nutsedge leaf chlorophyll, protein, and PEP carboxylase activity, using the resolved leaf components, is presented. ¹⁴CO₂ Fixation experiments with the intact nutsedge leaves and isolated mesophyll and bundle sheath tissues show that complete C₄ photosynthesis is compartmentalized into mesophyll CO₂ fixation via PEP carboxylase and bundle sheath CO₂ fixation via RuDP carboxylase. These results were used to support the proposed pathway of carbon assimilation in C₄-dicarboxylic acid photosynthesis and to discuss the individual metabolic characteristics of intact mesophyll cells, bundle sheath cells, and epidermal tissues.     

Sulfate assimilation and glutathione synthesis in C<Subscript>4</Subscript> plants

Sulfate assimilation and glutathione synthesis were traditionally believed to be differentially compartmentalised in C₄ plants with the synthesis of cysteine and glutathione restricted to bundle sheath and mesophyll cells, respectively. Recent studies, however, showed that although ATP sulfurylase and adenosine 5′ phosphosulfate reductase, the key enzymes of sulfate assimilation, are localised exclusively in bundle sheath in maize and other C₄ monocot species, this is not true for the dicot C₄ species of Flaveria. On the other hand, enzymes of glutathione biosynthesis were demonstrated to be active in both types of maize cells. Therefore, in this review the recent findings on compartmentation of sulfate assimilation and glutathione metabolism in C₄ plants will be summarised and the consequences for our understanding of sulfate metabolism and C₄ photosynthesis will be discussed.     

Activity, location, and role of asparate aminotransferase and alanine aminotransferase isoenzymes in leaves with C4 pathway photosynthesis

Further evidence has been provided that C₄-pathway species characterized by having low malic enzyme activity contain exceptionally high activities of aspartate and alanine aminotransferases. The total activity of both enzymes is distributed about equally between mesophyll and bundle sheath cells. However, the activity in the two cell types is due to different isoenzymes. In addition to the one quantitatively major isoenzyme associated with each cell type there were at least two additional isozymes of each aminotransferase detectable in the different species examined. Increases in activity of both aminotransferases of ten-fold or more were observed during greening of leaves of dark-grown plants. This increased activity was due specifically to the two quantitatively major isoenzymes associated, respectively, with the mesophyll and bundle sheath cells of green leaves, providing further evidence for their specific role in photosynthesis. Apparently, neither the aspartate nor alanine aminotransferases of mesophyll cells was associated with chloroplasts or other subcellular organelles. However, the major aspartate aminotransferase isoenzyme of bundle sheath cells was associated with mitochondria. These findings are discussed in relation to the probable role of aspartate and alanine aminotransferases in C₄-pathway photosynthesis.     

Two major metabolic factors for an efficient NADP-malic enzyme type C4 photosynthesis

Compared to the large number of studies focused on the factors controlling C₃ photosynthesis efficiency, there are relatively fewer studies of the factors controlling photosynthetic efficiency in C₄ leaves. Here, we used a dynamic systems model of C₄ photosynthesis based on maize (Zea mays) to identify features associated with high photosynthetic efficiency in NADP-malic enzyme (NADP-ME) type C₄ photosynthesis. We found that two additional factors related to coordination between C₄ shuttle metabolism and C₃ metabolism are required for efficient C₄ photosynthesis: (1) accumulating a high concentration of phosphoenolpyruvate through maintaining a large PGA concentration in the mesophyll cell chloroplast and (2) maintaining a suitable oxidized status in bundle sheath cell chloroplasts. These identified mechanisms are in line with the current cellular location of enzymes/proteins involved in the starch synthesis, the Calvin–Benson cycle and photosystem II of NADP-ME type C₄ photosynthesis. These findings suggested potential strategies for improving C₄ photosynthesis and engineering C₄ rice.

High levels of PGA and PEP in mesophyll cell chloroplasts and a suitable oxidation state in bundle sheath cell chloroplasts are the requirements for efficient C₄ photosynthesis.     

Photosynthetic and Carbohydrate Metabolism in Isolated Leaf Cells of Digitaria pentzii

Mesophyll cells and bundle sheath strands were isolated rapidly from leaves of the C₄ species Digitaria pentzii Stent. (slenderstem digitgrass) by a chopping and differential filtration technique. Rates of CO₂ fixation in the light by mesophyll and bundle sheath cells without added exogenous substrates were 6.3 and 54.2 micromoles of CO₂ per milligram of chlorophyll per hour, respectively. The addition of pyruvate or phosphoenolpyruvate to the mesophyll cells increased the rates to 15.2 and 824.6 micromoles of CO₂ per milligram of chlorophyll per hour, respectively. The addition of ribose 5-phosphate increased the rate for bundle sheath cells to 106.8 micromoles of CO₂ per milligram of chlorophyll per hour. These rates are comparable to those reported for cells isolated by other methods. The K_m(HCO₃⁻) for mesophyll cells was 0.9 mm; for bundle sheath cells it was 1.3 mm at low, and 40 mm at higher HCO₃⁻ concentrations. After 2 hours of photosynthesis by mesophyll cells in ¹⁴CO₂ and phosphoenolpyruvate, 88% of the incorporated ¹⁴C was found in organic acids and 0.8% in carbohydrates; for bundle sheath cells incubated in ribose 5-phosphate and ATP, more than 58% of incorporated ¹⁴C was found in carbohydrates, mainly starch, and 32% in organic acids. These findings, together with the stimulation of CO₂ fixation by phosphoenolpyruvate for mesophyll cells and by ribose 5-phosphate plus ATP for bundle sheath cells, and the location of phosphoenolpyruvate and ribulose bisphosphate carboxylases in mesophyll and bundle sheath cells, respectively, are in accord with the scheme of C₄ photosynthesis which places the Calvin cycle in the bundle sheath and C₄ acid formation in mesophyll cells.     

Two-Dimensional Electrophoretic Mapping of Proteins of Bundle Sheath and Mesophyll Cells of the C(4) Grass Digitaria sanguinalis (L.) Scop. (Crabgrass)

Two-dimensional electrophoresis was performed on proteins of bundle sheath and mesophyll cells isolated from the C₄ grass Digitaria sanguinalis (L.) Scop. Two-dimensional maps of these proteins were constructed and ribulose-1,5-biphosphate carboxylase and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase were identified. Of the total number of proteins found in both cell types, 36% were found only in bundle sheath cells, 17% only in mesophyll cells, and 47% in both cell types. By comparison, the distributions of 48 enzymes assayed in these cell types were 35%, 21%, and 44%, respectively.

Protein patterns were also compared with C₄ plants exhibiting different decarboxylation pathways and, in both bundle sheath and mesophyll cells, proteins were found which were unique to each species. Bundle sheath proteins of one C₄ species were found to be more like bundle sheath proteins of another C₄ species than like mesophyll proteins of the same species.

     

Pyruvate, pi dikinase in bundle sheath strands as well as in mesophyll cells in maize leaves

Mesophyll protoplasts and bundle sheath strands were isolated from maize leaves. Light microscopic observation showed the preparations were pure and without cross contamination. Protein blot analysis of mesophyll and bundle sheath cell soluble protein showed that the concentration of pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase (EC 2.7.9.1) is about one-tenth as much in the bundle sheath cells as in mesophyll cells, but about eight times greater than that found in wheat leaves, on the basis of soluble protein. Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.31) was barely detectable in the bundle sheath cells, while ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.39) and NADP-dependent malic enzyme (EC 1.3.1.37) were exclusively present in the bundle sheath cells and were absent in the mesophyll cells. Whereas pyruvate, Pi dikinase was previously considered localized only in mesophyll cells of C₄ plants, these results clearly demonstrate the presence of appreciable quantities of the enzyme in the bundle sheath cells of the C₄ species maize.     

The promoters of two carboxylases in a C4 plant (maize) direct cell-specific, light-regulated expression in a C3 plant (rice)

C₄ plants have two carboxylases which function in photosynthesis. One, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) is localized in mesophyll cells, and the other, ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase (RuBPC) is found in bundle sheath cells. In contrast, C₃ plants have only one photosynthetic carboxylase, RuBPC, which is localized in mesophyll cells. The expression of PEPC in C₃ mesophyll cells is quite low relative to PEPC expression in C₄ mesophyll cells. Two chimeric genes have been constructed consisting of the structural gene encoding β-glucuronidase (GUS) controlled by two promoters from C₄ (maize) photosynthetic genes: (i) the PEPC gene (pepc) and (ii) the small subunit of RuBPC (rbcS). These constructs were introduced into a C₃ cereal, rice. Both chimeric genes were expressed almost exclusively in mesophyll cells in the leaf blades and leaf sheaths at high levels, and no or very little activity was observed in other cells. The expression of both genes was also regulated by light. These observations indicate that the regulation systems which direct cell-specific and light-inducible expression of pepc and rbcS in C₄ plants are also present in C₃ plants. Nevertheless, expression of endogenous pepc in C₃ plants is very low in C₃ mesophyll cells, and the cell specificity of rbcS expression in C₃ plants differs from that in C₄ plants. Rice nuclear extracts were assayed for DNA-binding protein(s) which interact with a cis-regulatory element in the pepc promoter. Gel-retardation assays indicate that a nuclear protein with similar DNA-binding specificity to a maize nuclear protein is present in rice. The possibility that differences in pepc expression in a C₃ plant (rice) and C₄ plant (maize) may be the result of changes in cis-acting elements between pepc in rice and maize is discussed. It also appears that differences in the cellular localization of rbcS expression are probably due to changes in a trans-acting factor(s) required for rbcS expression.     

Intercellular Localization of Assimilatory Sulfate Reduction in Leaves of Zea mays and Triticum aestivum

The intercellular distribution of assimilatory sulfate reduction enzymes between mesophyll and bundle sheath cells was analyzed in maize (Zea mays L.) and wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) leaves. In maize, a C₄ plant, 96 to 100% of adenosine 5′-phosphosulfate sulfotransferase and 92 to 100% of ATP sulfurylase activity (EC 2.7.7.4) was detected in the bundle sheath cells. Sulfite reductase (EC 1.8.7.1) and O-acetyl-l-serine sulfhydrylase (EC 4.2.99.8) were found in both bundle sheath and mesophyll cell types. In wheat, a C₃ species, ATP sulfurylase and adenosine 5′-phosphosulfate sulfotransferase were found at equivalent activities in both mesophyll and bundle sheath cells. Leaves of etiolated maize plants contained appreciable ATP sulfurylase activity but only trace adenosine 5′-phosphosulfate sulfotransferase activity. Both enzyme activities increased in the bundle sheath cells during greening but remained at negligible levels in mesophyll cells. In leaves of maize grown without addition of a sulfur source for 12 d, the specific activity of adenosine 5′-phosphosulfate sulfotransferase and ATP sulfurylase in the bundle sheath cells was higher than in the controls. In the mesophyll cells, however, both enzyme activities remained undetectable. The intercellular distribution of enzymes would indicate that the first two steps of sulfur assimilation are restricted to the bundle sheath cells of C₄ plants, and this restriction is independent of ontogeny and the sulfur nutritional status of the plants.     

Distribution of carboxylation and decarboxylation enzymes in isolated mesophyll cells and bundle sheath strands of C 4 plants

Mature leaves of Cyperus rotundus, Cyperus polystachyos, Digitaria decumbens, and Digitaria sanguinalis were separated, using pectinase and cellulase, into pure preparations of mesophyll cells and bundle sheath strands. Assays on these distinct leaf cell types show a clear compartmentation of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, >98%, into mesophyll cells and of ribulose-1, 5-diphosphate carboxylase and malic enzyme, >98%, into the bundle sheath strands. The results clearly establish that the major CO₂ uptake in mesophyll cells is via a β-carboxylation and that both a decarboxylation and a carboxylation reaction occurs in the bundle sheath strands of plants using C₄-dicarboxylic acid photosynthesis.     

Metabolic Activities in Extracts of Mesophyll and Bundle Sheath Cells of Panicum miliaceum (L.) in Relation to the C(4) Dicarboxylic Acid Pathway of Photosynthesis

The activities of certain enzymes related to the carbon assimilation pathway in whole leaves, mesophyll cell extracts, and bundle sheath extracts of the C₄ plant Panicum miliaceum have been measured and compared on a chlorophyll basis. Enzymes of the C₄ dicarboxylic acid pathway—phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and NADP-malic dehydrogenase—were localized in mesophyll cells. Carbonic anhydrase was also localized in mesophyll cell extracts. Ribose 5-phosphate isomerase, ribulose 5-phosphate kinase, and ribulose diphosphate carboxylase—enzymes of the reductive pentose phosphate pathway—were predominantly localized in bundle sheath extracts. High activities of aspartate and alanine transaminases and glyceraldehyde-3-P dehydrogenase were found about equally distributed between the photosynthetic cell types. P. miliaceum had low malic enzyme activity in both mesophyll and bundle sheath extracts.