Physical factors that affect the number and size of Golgi cisternae

Despite continual membrane reorganization in the Golgi complex, the number of cisternae in a Golgi stack is a stable parameter. The cisternal number is conserved within any given cell line and also after Golgi reassembly, e.g. following brefeldin-A-induced disruption. However, the factors that determine the cisternal number in a single Golgi stack remain to be fully determined. We propose a simple mechanical model of the Golgi stack and present a theoretical analysis of different physical factors that may affect the number of cisternae in a Golgi stack. The model takes into account the Golgi membrane bending elasticity, which is related to the membrane curvature, and the adhesion, which holds the cisternae together. The analysis shows that the equilibrium configuration of the Golgi stack can be regarded as a balance between these two effects - the adhesion, which tends to increase the number of cisternae, is opposed by the membrane resistance to bending, which does not favor highly curved cisternal rims. The adhesion strength that is needed to hold together a typical stack is calculated. In addition, the model is used to analyze changes in the cisternal numbers as a controlled traffic wave enters a Golgi stack and increases the amount of the membrane in that stack.     

The role of ARF1 and rab GTPases in polarization of the Golgi stack

The organization and sorting of proteins within the Golgi stack to establish and maintain its cis to trans polarization remains an enigma. The function of Golgi compartments involves coat assemblages that facilitate vesicle traffic, Rab-tether-SNAP receptor (SNARE) machineries that dictate membrane identity, as well as matrix components that maintain structure. We have investigated how the Golgi complex achieves compartmentalization in response to a key component of the coat complex I (COPI) coat assembly pathway, the ARF1 GTPase, in relationship to GTPases-regulating endoplasmic reticulum (ER) exit (Sar1) and targeting fusion (Rab1). Following collapse of the Golgi into the ER in response to inhibition of activation of ARF1 by Brefeldin A, we found that Sar1- and Rab1-dependent Golgi reformation took place at multiple peripheral and perinuclear ER exit sites. These rapidly converged into immature Golgi that appeared as onion-like structures composed of multiple concentrically arrayed cisternae of mixed enzyme composition. During clustering to the perinuclear region, Golgi enzymes were sorted to achieve the degree of polarization within the stack found in mature Golgi. Surprisingly, we found that sorting of Golgi enzymes into their subcompartments was insensitive to the dominant negative GTP-restricted ARF1 mutant, a potent inhibitor of COPI coat disassembly and vesicular traffic. We suggest that a COPI-independent, Rab-dependent mechanism is involved in the rapid reorganization of resident enzymes within the Golgi stack following synchronized release from the ER, suggesting an important role for Rab hubs in directing Golgi polarization.     

Dissection of the Golgi complex. II. Density separation of specific Golgi functions in virally infected cells treated with monensin

In the accompanying paper (Griffiths, G., P. Quinn, and G. Warren, 1983, J. Cell Biol., 96:835-850), we suggested that the Golgi stack could be divided into functionally distinct cis, medial, and trans compartments, each comprising one or two adjacent cisternae. These compartments were identified using Baby hamster kidney (BHK) cells infected with Semliki Forest virus (SFV) and treated with monensin. This drug blocked intracellular transport but not synthesis of the viral membrane proteins that were shown to accumulate in the medial cisternae. In consequence, these cisternae bound nucleocapsids. Here we show that this binding markedly increased the density of the medial cisternae and allowed us to separate them from cis and trans Golgi cisternae. A number of criteria were used to show that the intracellular capsid-binding membranes (ICBMs) observed in vivo were the same as those membranes sedimenting to a higher density in sucrose gradients in vitro, and this separation of cisternae was then used to investigate the distribution, within the Golgi stack, of some specific Golgi functions. After labeling for 2.5 min with [3H]palmitate, most of the fatty acid attached to viral membrane proteins was found in the ICBM fraction. Because the viral membrane proteins appear to move from cis to trans, this suggests that fatty acylation occurs in the cis or medial Golgi cisternae. In contrast, the distribution of alpha 1-2- mannosidase, an enzyme involved in trimming high-mannose oligosaccharides, and of galactosyl transferase, which is involved in the construction of complex oligosaccharides, was not affected by monensin treatment. Together with data in the accompanying paper, this would restrict these two Golgi functions to the trans cisternae. Our data strongly support the view that Golgi functions have specific and discrete locations within the Golgi stack.     

A new type of coated vesicular carrier that appears not to contain clathrin: its possible role in protein transport within the Golgi stack

Isolated Golgi membranes incubated in the presence of ATP and a cytosolic protein fraction form a population of coated buds or vesicles from the Golgi cisternae. The coats do not have the characteristic hexagonal-pentagonal basketwork of clathrin, and do not react with anti-clathrin polyclonal antibody. The conditions that produce these apparently nonclathrin-coated buds also reconstitute protein transport between compartments of the Golgi stack. The membrane of the buds contains the glycoprotein in transit through these Golgi stacks (VSV-encoded G protein). This suggests that protein transport through the Golgi stack is mediated by a new type of coated vesicle that does not contain clathrin. The concentration of G protein in the coated buds reflects the local concentration of G protein in the cisternae, raising the possibility that the Golgi coated vesicles may be "bulk" membrane carriers.     

Tomographic evidence for continuous turnover of Golgi cisternae in Pichia pastoris

The budding yeast Pichia pastoris contains ordered Golgi stacks next to discrete transitional endoplasmic reticulum (tER) sites, making this organism ideal for structure-function studies of the secretory pathway. Here, we have used P. pastoris to test various models for Golgi trafficking. The experimental approach was to analyze P. pastoris tER-Golgi units by using cryofixed and freeze-substituted cells for electron microscope tomography, immunoelectron microscopy, and serial thin section analysis of entire cells. We find that tER sites and the adjacent Golgi stacks are enclosed in a ribosome-excluding "matrix." Each stack contains three to four cisternae, which can be classified as cis, medial, trans, or trans-Golgi network (TGN). No membrane continuities between compartments were detected. This work provides three major new insights. First, two types of transport vesicles accumulate at the tER-Golgi interface. Morphological analysis indicates that the center of the tER-Golgi interface contains COPII vesicles, whereas the periphery contains COPI vesicles. Second, fenestrae are absent from cis cisternae, but are present in medial through TGN cisternae. The number and distribution of the fenestrae suggest that they form at the edges of the medial cisternae and then migrate inward. Third, intact TGN cisternae apparently peel off from the Golgi stacks and persist for some time in the cytosol, and these "free-floating" TGN cisternae produce clathrin-coated vesicles. These observations are most readily explained by assuming that Golgi cisternae form at the cis face of the stack, progressively mature, and ultimately dissociate from the trans face of the stack.     

The dynamic nature of the Golgi complex

The intracellular transport of newly synthesized G protein of vesicular stomatitis virus is blocked at 20 degrees C and this spanning membrane glycoprotein accumulates in the last Golgi compartment, the trans Golgi-network (TGN). Previous morphological evidence suggested that the TGN enlarged significantly under this condition. In the present study we have used stereological procedures to estimate the volume and surface area of the Golgi stack and the TGN of baby hamster kidney cells under different conditions. The results indicate that the increase in the size of the TGN at 20 degrees C is accompanied by a significant decrease in the surface area and volume of the preceding Golgi compartments. A similar effect is also seen in uninfected cells at 20 degrees C, as well as during normal (37 degrees C) infection with Semliki Forest virus. In the latter case, however, the decrease in the size of the Golgi stack and the increase in that of the TGN is not accompanied by inhibition of transport from the Golgi complex to the cell surface. The results indicate that the Golgi stack and the TGN are dynamic and interrelated structures that are capable of rapid alteration in total surface area in response to changes in the rates of membrane transport.     

Sec7p directs the transitions required for yeast Golgi biogenesis

Endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-to-Golgi traffic in yeast proceeds by the maturation of membrane compartments from post-ER vesicles to intermediate small vesicle tubular clusters (VTCs) to Golgi nodular membrane networks (Morin-Ganet et al., Traffic 2000; 1: 56–68). The balance between ER and Golgi compartments is maintained by COPII- and COPI-mediated anterograde and retrograde traffic, which are dependent on Sec7p and ARF function. The sec7-4 temperature-sensitive allele is a mutation in the highly conserved Sec7 domain (Sec7d) found in all ARF-guanine nucleotide exchange factor proteins. Post-ER trafficking is rapidly inactivated in sec7-4 mutant yeast at the restrictive temperature. This conditional defect prevented the normal production of VTCs and instead generated Golgi-like tubes emanating from the ER exit sites. These tubes progressively developed into stacked cisternae defining the landmark sec7 mutant phenotype. Consistent with the in vivo results, a Sec7d peptide inhibited ER-to-Golgi transport and displaced Sec7p from its membrane anchor in vitro . The similarities in the consequences of inactivating Sec7p or ARFs in vivo was revealed by genetic disruption of yeast ARFs or by addition of brefeldin A (BFA) to whole cells. These treatments, as in sec7-4 yeast, affected the morphology of membrane compartments in the ER-Golgi transition. Further evidence for Sec7p involvement in the transition for Golgi biogenesis was revealed by in vitro binding between distinct domains of Sec7p with ARFs, COPI and COPII coat proteins. These results suggest that Sec7p coordinates membrane transitions in Golgi biogenesis by directing and scaffolding the binding and disassembly of coat protein complexes to membranes, both at the VTC transition from ER exit sites to form Golgi elements and for later events in Golgi maturation.     

Transport into and out of the Golgi complex studied by transfecting cells with cDNAs encoding horseradish peroxidase

We have developed a novel technique with which to investigate the morphological basis of exocytotic traffic. We have used expression of HRP from cDNA in a variety of cells in combination with peroxidase cytochemistry to outline traffic into and out of the Golgi apparatus at the electron microscopic level with very high sensitivity. A secretory form of the peroxidase (ssHRP) is active from the beginning of the secretory pathway and the activity is efficiently cleared from cells. Investigation of the morphological elements involved in the itinerary of soluble ER proteins using ssHRP tagged with the ER retention motif (ssHRPKDEL) shows that it progresses through the Golgi stack no further than the cis-most element. Traffic between the RER and the Golgi stack as outlined by ssHRPKDEL occurs via vesicular carriers as well as by tubular elements. ssHRP has also been used to investigate the trans side of the Golgi complex, where incubation at reduced temperatures outlines the trans-Golgi network with HRP reaction product. Tracing the endosomal compartment with transferrin receptor in double-labeling experiments with ssHRP fails to show any overlap between these two compartments.     

Arachidonyltrifluoromethy ketone, a phospholipase A(2) antagonist, induces dispersal of both Golgi stack- and trans Golgi network-resident proteins throughout the cytoplasm

Arachidonyltrifluoromethy ketone (AACOCF(3)), a phospholipase A(2) antagonist, reversibly induced dispersal of Golgi stack- and trans Golgi network (TGN)-resident proteins throughout the cytoplasm in NRK cells as followed by immunocytochemical staining of ManII and TGN38, respectively. The action of AACOCF(3) was partly blocked by other PLA(2) antagonists, suggesting it be not caused by a general inhibition of phospholipase A(2). AACOCF(3) neither dissociated beta-COP from membranes nor prevented brefeldin A-induced beta-COP release. Action of AACOCF(3) on the Golgi stack and TGN is different from that of brefeldin A and nordihydroguaiaretic acid. The most prominent difference is that the Golgi stack and TGN showed a similar sensitivity to AACOCF(3), while the TGN was dispersed more slowly than the Golgi stack in brefeldin A- or nordihydroguaiaretic acid-treated NRK cells. This novel action of AACOCF(3) may be used as pharmacological tool and give new insights into vesicle-mediated traffic and Golgi membrane dynamics.     

Tension in tubulovesicular networks of Golgi and endoplasmic reticulum membranes

The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi have robust bidirectional traffic between them and yet form distinct membrane compartments. Membrane tubules are pulled from large aggregates of ER or Golgi by microtubule motors to form ER tubulovesicular networks or Golgi tubules both in vivo and in vitro. The physical properties of membranes are critical for membrane traffic and organelle morphology. For example, tension applied to membranes can create tethers, drive membrane flow, and set the diameter of the tubules. Here, we formed ER and Golgi membrane networks in vitro and used optical tweezers to measure directly, for the first time, the membrane tensions of these organelles to clarify the possible role of tension in membrane flow. We report that higher forces are needed to form tethers from ER (18.6 +/- 2.8 pN) than from Golgi (11.4 +/- 1.4 pN) membrane tubules in vitro. Since ER tubules are smaller in diameter than Golgi tubules, it follows that Golgi networks have a lower tension than ER. The lower tension of the ER could be an explanation of how Golgi tubules can be rapidly drawn into the ER by tension-driven flow after fusion, as is observed in vivo.     

Dissection of the Golgi complex. I. Monensin inhibits the transport of viral membrane proteins from medial to trans Golgi cisternae in baby hamster kidney cells infected with Semliki Forest virus

Baby hamster kidney (BHK) cells were infected with Semliki Forest virus (SFV) and, 2 h later, were treated for 4 h with 10 microM monensin. Each of the four to six flattened cisternae in the Golgi stack became swollen and separated from the others. Intracellular transport of the viral membrane proteins was almost completely inhibited, but their synthesis continued and they accumulated in the swollen Golgi cisternae before the monensin block. In consequence, these cisternae bound large numbers of viral nucleocapsids and were easily distinguished from other swollen cisternae such as those after the block. These intracellular capsid-binding membranes (ICBMs) were not stained by cytochemical markers for endoplasmic reticulum (ER) (glucose-6-phosphatase) or trans Golgi cisternae (thiamine pyrophosphatase, acid phosphatase) but were labeled by Ricinus communis agglutinin I (RCA) in thin, frozen sections. Since this lectin labels only Golgi cisternae in the middle and on the trans side of the stack (Griffiths, G., R. Brands, B. Burke, D. Louvard, and G. Warren, 1982, J. Cell Biol., 95:781-792), we conclude that ICBMs are derived from Golgi cisternae in the middle of the stack, which we term medial cisternae. The overall movement of viral membrane proteins appears to be from cis to trans Golgi cisternae (see reference above), so monensin would block movement from medial to the trans cisternae. It also blocked the trimming of the high-mannose oligosaccharides bound to the viral membrane proteins and their conversion to complex oligosaccharides. These functions presumably reside in trans Golgi cisternae. This is supported by data in the accompanying paper, in which we also show that fatty acids are covalently attached to the viral membrane proteins in the cis or medial cisternae. We suggest that the Golgi stack can be divided into three functionally distinct compartments, each comprising one or two cisternae. The viral membrane proteins, after leaving the ER, would all pass in sequence from the cis to the medial to the trans compartment.     

The Pathway of Golgi Cluster Formation in Okadaic Acid-Treated Cells

Using stereology and immunoelectron microscopy we examined the pathway of Golgi duster formation during treatment with the phosphatase inhibitor okadaic acid. During the first hour the Golgi stack of suspension HeLa cells lost 90% of its membrane without appreciable reduction in the number of cisternae. During this time clusters of tubules and vesicles (Golgi clusters) appeared and these contained only a fraction of the Golgi membrane present in untreated cells. Despite the overall reduction in membrane the total amount of immunolabeling for galactosyltransferase over the Golgi clusters of a typical cell was maintained, indicating that galactosyltransferase had been retained in Golgi membranes. The observation that, after 40 min okadaic acid treatment, labeling density for galactosyltransferase within trans Golgi cisternae increased 1.6-fold (n = 3, CE 10%) suggests that membrane loss from trans cisternae was selective. Careful evaluation of immunolabeled clusters showed that most of the galactosyltransferase labeling was located over complex tubular profiles and not vesicular profiles. Tubular structures were also observed during disassembly and these were found both connected to disassembling cisternae and within forming Golgi clusters, indicating that they were intermediates in cluster formation. We also investigated the role of vesicular transport in cluster formation. During disassembly we found no accumulation of COP-coated buds and vesicles over Golgi membrane. However, aluminium fluoride, previously found to arrest transport in the Golgi stack, completely inhibited membrane depletion and stack disassembly. Taken together, our results indicate that during Golgi cluster formation, membrane leaves the Golgi but galactosyltransferase is retained within a tubular reticulum which is a direct descendant of trans-Golgi cisternae. Membrane depletion may require ongoing vesicular transport and we postulate that it arises because of an imbalance in membrane traffic into and out of the Golgi apparatus.     

Distinct functions for Arf guanine nucleotide exchange factors at the Golgi complex: GBF1 and BIGs are required for assembly and maintenance of the Golgi stack and trans-Golgi network, respectively

We examined the relative function of the two classes of guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) for ADP-ribosylation factors that regulate recruitment of coat proteins on the Golgi complex. Complementary overexpression and RNA-based knockdown approaches established that GBF1 regulates COPI recruitment on cis-Golgi compartments, whereas BIGs appear specialized for adaptor proteins on the trans-Golgi. Knockdown of GBF1 and/or COPI did not prevent export of VSVGtsO45 from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), but caused its accumulation into peripheral vesiculotubular clusters. In contrast, knockdown of BIG1 and BIG2 caused loss of clathrin adaptor proteins and redistribution of several TGN markers, but had no impact on COPI and several Golgi markers. Surprisingly, brefeldin A-inhibited guanine nucleotide exchange factors (BIGs) knockdown prevented neither traffic of VSVGtsO45 to the plasma membrane nor assembly of a polarized Golgi stack. Our observations indicate that COPII is the only coat required for sorting and export from the ER exit sites, whereas GBF1 but not BIGs, is required for COPI recruitment, Golgi subcompartmentalization, and cargo progression to the cell surface.     

Deciphering the Golgi apparatus: from imaging to genes

The Golgi apparatus is a vital organelle in eukaryotic cells. It grabs and processes secretory materials synthesized by the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) before sorting them to their destination. The Golgi also receives materials from vacuoles/lysosomes and the plasma membrane for further recycling to other compartments within the cell (1) (Figure 1). Given the vital role of the Golgi in a cell, it is important to understand how this organelle attains and maintains its structural and functional integrity during the intense processes of membrane traffic. Despite an equally central role of the Golgi in membrane traffic in eukaryotes, the organization of this organelle has some unique features in each cell system. Therefore, the wealth of information available on the structure and activity of the Golgi in one system is not always directly transferable to others. However, certain morphological and functional aspects are common among cell systems. Therefore, studying the factors that regulate organelle biogenesis and organization of the Golgi apparatus is important in basic cell biology of eukaryotes and may also contribute to a better understanding of how different cell systems have evolved. In this study, we report on the identification of Golgi mutants in plant cells. We have developed a screen that is a promising strategy not only for the identification of genes responsible for the morphological and functional integrity of the plant Golgi but could also provide fundamental information on other multicellular systems for which the power of forward genetics cannot be exploited as easily as in Arabidopsis.     

Yif1B Is Involved in the Anterograde Traffic Pathway and the Golgi Architecture

Yif1B is an intracellular membrane‐bound protein belonging to the Yip family, shown previously to control serotonin 5‐HT_1A receptor targeting to dendrites. Because some Yip proteins are involved in the intracellular traffic between the ER and the Golgi, here we investigated the precise localization of Yif1B in HeLa cells. We found that Yif1B is not resident into the Golgi, but rather belongs to the IC compartment. After analyzing the role of Yif1B in protein transport, we showed that the traffic of the VSVG protein marker was accelerated in Yif1B depleted HeLa cells, as well as in hippocampal neurons from Yif1B KO mice. Conversely, Yif1B depletion in HeLa cells did not change the retrograde traffic of ShTx. Interestingly, in long term depletion of Yif1B as in Yif1B KO mice, we observed a disorganized Golgi architecture in CA1 pyramidal hippocampal neurons, which was confirmed by electron microscopy. However, because short term depletion of Yif1B did not change Golgi structure, it is likely that the implication of Yif1B in anterograde traffic does not rely on its role in structural organization of the Golgi apparatus, but rather on its shuttling between the ER, the IC and the Golgi compartments.      

Death receptor ligation triggers membrane scrambling between Golgi and mitochondria

Subcellular organelles such as mitochondria, endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and the Golgi complex are involved in the progression of the cell death programme. We report here that soon after ligation of Fas (CD95/Apo1) in type II cells, elements of the Golgi complex intermix with mitochondria. This mixing follows centrifugal dispersal of secretory membranes and reflects a global alteration of membrane traffic. Activation of apical caspases is instrumental for promoting the dispersal of secretory organelles, since caspase inhibition blocks the outward movement of Golgi-related endomembranes and reduces their mixing with mitochondria. Caspase inhibition also blocks the FasL-induced secretion of intracellular proteases from lysosomal compartments, outlining a novel aspect of death receptor signalling via apical caspases. Thus, our work unveils that Fas ligand-mediated apoptosis induces scrambling of mitochondrial and secretory organelles via a global alteration of membrane traffic that is modulated by apical caspases.     

Secretory traffic triggers the formation of tubular continuities across Golgi sub-compartments

The organization of secretory traffic remains unclear, mainly because of the complex structure and dynamics of the secretory pathway. We have thus studied a simplified system, a single synchronized traffic wave crossing an individual Golgi stack, using electron tomography. Endoplasmic-reticulum-to-Golgi carriers join the stack by fusing with cis cisternae and induce the formation of intercisternal tubules, through which they redistribute their contents throughout the stack. These tubules seem to be pervious to Golgi enzymes, whereas Golgi vesicles are depleted of both enzymes and cargo. Cargo then traverses the stack without leaving the cisternal lumen. When cargo exits the stack, intercisternal connections disappear. These findings provide a new view of secretory traffic that includes dynamic intercompartment continuities as key players.     

Vps52p, Vps53p, and Vps54p form a novel multisubunit complex required for protein sorting at the yeast late Golgi

The late Golgi of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae receives membrane traffic from the secretory pathway as well as retrograde traffic from post-Golgi compartments, but the machinery that regulates these vesicle-docking and fusion events has not been characterized. We have identified three components of a novel protein complex that is required for protein sorting at the yeast late Golgi compartment. Mutation of VPS52, VPS53, or VPS54 results in the missorting of 70% of the vacuolar hydrolase carboxypeptidase Y as well as the mislocalization of late Golgi membrane proteins to the vacuole, whereas protein traffic through the early part of the Golgi complex is unaffected. A vps52/53/54 triple mutant strain is phenotypically indistinguishable from each of the single mutants, consistent with the model that all three are required for a common step in membrane transport. Native coimmunoprecipitation experiments indicate that Vps52p, Vps53p, and Vps54p are associated in a 1:1:1 complex that sediments as a single peak on sucrose velocity gradients. This complex, which exists both in a soluble pool and as a peripheral component of a membrane fraction, colocalizes with markers of the yeast late Golgi by immunofluorescence microscopy. Together, the phenotypic and biochemical data suggest that VPS52, VPS53, and VPS54 are required for the retrograde transport of Golgi membrane proteins from an endosomal/prevacuolar compartment. The Vps52/53/54 complex joins a growing list of distinct multisubunit complexes that regulate membrane-trafficking events.     

TRAPP stably associates with the Golgi and is required for vesicle docking

Bet3p, a component of a large novel complex called TRAPP, acts upstream of endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-Golgi SNAREs. Unlike the SNAREs, which reside on multiple compartments, Bet3p is localized exclusively to Golgi membranes. While other proteins recycle from the Golgi to the ER, Bet3p and other TRAPP subunits remain associated with this membrane under conditions that block anterograde traffic. We propose that the persistent localization of TRAPP to the Golgi may be important for its role in docking vesicles to this membrane. Consistent with this proposal, we find that transport vesicles fail to bind to Golgi membranes in vitro in the absence of Bet3p. Binding is restored by the addition of cytosol containing Bet3p. These findings indicate that TRAPP stably associates with the Golgi and is required for vesicle docking.     

Models for Golgi traffic: a critical assessment

A variety of secretory cargoes move through the Golgi, but the pathways and mechanisms of this traffic are still being debated. Here, we evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of five current models for Golgi traffic: (1) anterograde vesicular transport between stable compartments, (2) cisternal progression/maturation, (3) cisternal progression/maturation with heterotypic tubular transport, (4) rapid partitioning in a mixed Golgi, and (5) stable compartments as cisternal progenitors. Each model is assessed for its ability to explain a set of key observations encompassing multiple cell types. No single model can easily explain all of the observations from diverse organisms. However, we propose that cisternal progression/maturation is the best candidate for a conserved core mechanism of Golgi traffic, and that some cells elaborate this core mechanism by means of heterotypic tubular transport between cisternae.