Grazer control and nutrient limitation of phytoplankton biomass in two Australian reservoirs

1. Grazer and nutrient controls of phytoplankton biomass were tested on two reservoirs of different productivity to assess the potential for zooplankton grazing to affect chlorophyll/phosphorus regression models under Australian conditions. Experiments with zooplankton and nutrients manipulated in enclosures, laboratory feeding trials, and the analysis of in-lake plankton time series were performed. 2. Enclosures with water from the more productive Lake Hume (chlorophyll a = 3–17.5 μg l^–1), revealed significant zooplankton effects on chlorophyll a in 3/6, phosphorus limitation in 4/6 and nitrogen limitation in 1/6 of experiments conducted throughout the year. Enclosures with water from the less productive Lake Dartmouth (chlorophyll a = 0.8–3.5 μg l^–1), revealed significant zooplankton effects in 5/6, phosphorus limitation in 5/6 and nitrogen limitation in 2/6 of experiments. 3. While Lake Hume enclosure manipulations of the biomass of cladocerans (Daphnia and Diaphanosoma) and large copepods (Boeckella) had negative effects, small copepods (Mesocyclops and Calamoecia) could have positive effects on chlorophyll a. 4. In Lake Hume, total phytoplankton biovolume was negatively correlated with cladoceran biomass, positively with copepod biomass and was uncorrelated with total crustacean biomass. In Lake Dartmouth, total phytoplankton biovolume was negatively correlated with cladoceran biomass, copepod biomass and total crustacean biomass. 5. In both reservoirs, temporal variation in the biomass of Daphnia carinata alone could explain more than 50% of the observed variance in total phytoplankton biovolume. 6. During a period of low phytoplankton biovolume in Lake Hume in spring–summer 1993–94, a conservative estimate of cladoceran community grazing reached a maximum of 0.80 day^–1, suggesting that Cladocera made an important contribution to the development of the observed clear-water phase. 7. Enclosure experiments predicted significant grazing when the Cladocera/Phytoplankton biomass ratio was greater than 0.1; this threshold was consistently exceeded during clear water phase in Lake Hume. 8. Crustacean length had a significant effect on individual grazing rates in bottle experiments, with large Daphnia having highest rates. In both reservoirs, mean crustacean length was negatively correlated with phytoplankton biovolume. The observed upper limit of its variation was nearly twice as high compared to other world lakes.     

Phytoplankton nutrient limitation in Colorado mountain lakes

SUMMARY. 1. Limiting nutrients for phytoplankton were studied experimentally in eight mountain lakes of central Colorado between May and November of 1984.
2. Five categories of phytoplankton limitation were identified: no limitation, N limitation, P limitation, concurrent limitation (stimulation only by simultaneous additions of N and P), and reciprocal limitation (stimulation by addition of either N or P). The phytoplankton communities of three lakes were primarily N-limited, one was primarily phosphorus-limited, and four showed primarily combined limitation (concurrent or reciprocal). Switching between categories of limitation was also observed within lakes. Nitrogen was the most frequently limiting nutrient; N, either alone or in combination with P, accounted for 79% of all observed instances of limitation.
3. Nine indices were tested for effectiveness in predicting phytoplankton limitation by N and P. The best indices for discriminating all limitations were ratios of dissolved inorganic N: total P (84% accuracy) and dissolved inorganic N:total dissolved P (80% accuracy). The effectiveness of these indices may be explained by the degree to which they represent N and P fractions actually available to the phytoplankton.     

Responses of epilimnetic phytoplankton to experimental nutrient enrichment in three small seepage lakes

This paper describes the responses of three epilimnetic phytoplanktoncommunities to experimental nitrogen and phosphorus enrichmentas compared to the phytoplankton community in a fourth, unmanipulated,lake. Increased nutrient inputs increased total phytoplanktonbiomass, primary productivity, chlorophytes, cryptomonads andspecies turnover rates in all three enriched lakes; cyanobacteriaincreased in two of the three enriched lakes. However, nutrientaddition also led to declines in previously dominant dinoflagellatesand chrysophytes, and in species diversity. At the species level,there were large changes in community composition from yearto year in both enriched and reference lakes, suggesting thatphytoplankton community composition is highly dynamic even inthe absence of enrichment. Overall, changes in total biomass,productivity and species diversity were consistent among theenriched lakes, while changes in species composition differeddue to variation in the physical, chemical and biotic environmentof each lake. This suggests that aggregated variates are moreuseful for quantitative prediction of nutrient effects, whilespecies responses can be used to signal qualitative differencesin environmental conditions among lakes. ³Present address: Department of Biological Sciences, DartmouthCollege, 6044 Gilman Laboratory, Hanover, NH 03755-3576, USA     

Disturbance-diversity relationships in two lakes of similar nutrient chemistry but contrasting disturbance regimes

Phytoplankton diversity was studied in two North German lakes of comparable nutrient chemistry but different exposure to winds. In both lakes, phytoplankton was primarily N-limited but diatoms were Si-limited. Plußsee had a very constant mixing depth during summer, while week-to-week changes of several meters were quite common in the more exposed Behler See. In Plußsee, phytoplankton biomass during summer came closer to the carrying capacity as defined by the available total N. In Plußsee there was a marked decline of diversity during the summer maximum of biomass, while this decline was less pronounced in Behler See. It is concluded that disturbances which prevented phytoplankton from reaching the carrying capacity also maintained a high level of diversity. A negative response of diversity to undisturbed conditions became apparent, after phytoplankton biomass had exceeded about 5% of the carrying capacity.     

Driving forces shaping phytoplankton assemblages in two subtropical plateau lakes with contrasting trophic status

1. We studied driving forces shaping phytoplankton assemblages in two subtropical plateau lakes with contrasting trophic status, the oligotrophic deep Lake Fuxian and the eutrophic shallow Lake Xingyun. 2. Phytoplankton samples were taken monthly for a year and phytoplankton species were sorted into the main taxonomic groups and associations proposed by Reynolds. A canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) was used to test the occurrence of these classification schemes and to determine their discriminatory power. 3. The results suggest that the major driving forces in Lake Fuxian were physical variables, and particularly the underwater light climate, whereas, nutrients were the important driving force in Lake Xingyun. 4. Top–down control through zooplankton grazing in Lake Fuxian was hardly ever a significant determinant itself, because of the scarcity of zooplankton and their low grazing efficiency of predation while a dominance of inedible cyanobacteria throughout the year rendered top–down controls ineffective failing in Lake Xingyun. Hence phytoplankton communities in both lakes appear to be regulated primarily by bottom–up controls.     

Nutrient limitation of periphyton growth in arctic lakes in south-west Greenland

Many arctic lakes are oligotrophic systems where phototrophic growth is controlled by nutrient supply. Recent anthropogenic nutrient loading is associated with biological and/or physico-chemical change in several lakes across the arctic. Shifts in nutrient limitation (nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), or N + P) and associated effects on the growth and composition of algal communities are commonly reported. The Kangerlussuaq region of south-west Greenland forms a major lake district which is considered to receive little direct anthropogenic disturbance. However, long-range transport of pollutant N is now reaching Greenland, and it was hypothesised that a precipitation gradient from the inland ice sheet margin to the coast might also deliver increased N deposition. In situ nutrient bioassays were deployed in three lakes across the region: ice sheet margin, inland (close to Kangerlussuaq) and the coast (near Sisimiut), to determine nutrient limitation of lakes and investigate any effects of nutrients on periphyton growth and community composition. Nutrient limitation differed amongst lakes: N limitation (ice sheet margin), N and P limitation (inland) and N + P co-limitation (coast). Factors including variation in N supply, ice phenology, seasonal algal succession, community structure and physical limnology are explored as mechanisms to explain differences amongst lakes. Nutrient limitation of arctic lakes and associated ecological impacts are highly variable, even across small geographic areas. In this highly sensitive region, future environmental change scenarios carry a strong risk of significantly altering nutrient limitation; in turn, potentially severely impacting lake structure and function.     

Nutrient limitation of phytoplankton production in Alaskan Arctic foothill lakes

We used 54 enrichment bioassays to assess nutrient limitation (N, P) of ¹⁴C uptake by natural phytoplankton assemblages in 39 lakes and ponds in the Arctic Foothills region of Alaska. Our purpose was to categorize phytoplankton nutrient status in this under-represented region of North America and to improve our ability to predict the response of primary production to anticipated anthropogenically mediated increases in nutrient loading. Experiments were performed across several watersheds and included assays on terminal lakes and lakes occupying various positions in chains (lakes in series within a watershed and connected by streams). In total, 89% (48 of 54) of the bioassays showed significant stimulation of ¹⁴C primary production by some form of nutrient addition relative to unamended controls. A significant response was observed following enrichment with N and P, N alone and P alone in 83, 35 and 22% of the bioassays, respectively. In experiments where N and P proved stimulatory, the influence of N alone was significantly greater than the influence of P alone. Overall, the data point to a greater importance for N than P in regulating phytoplankton production in this region. The degree of response to N and P enrichment declined as the summer progressed and showed no relationship to irradiance or water temperature, suggesting secondary limitation by some micronutrient such as iron as the summer advanced. Phytoplankton nutrient status was often consistent across lakes within a watershed, suggesting that watershed characteristics influence nutrient availability. Lakes in this region will clearly show increased phytoplankton production in response to anthropogenic activities and anticipated changes in climate that will increase nutrient loading.     

Size fractionated phytoplankton production in two humic shallow lakes with contrasting coverage of free floating plants

We conducted a 1-year survey in two humic shallow lakes from the floodplain of the Lower Paraná River, Laguna Grande Lake (LGL) and a relictual oxbow lake (ROL). We aimed to test two hypotheses: (1) the efficiency in light use of picoplankton (0.2–3 μm) is greater as light restriction increases and (2) the contribution of picoplankton to the total productivity is higher when the total photosynthetic biomass is lower. We performed P–E curves for picoplankton and nano- and microplankton (>3 μm) using the ¹⁴C assimilation technique. The light environments of the water bodies differed mainly owing to the development of free floating plants on the surface of the ROL and the dominance of phytoplankton in LGL. Primary productivity patterns in LGL were seasonality driven whilst in the ROL they were related to the coverage of floating macrophytes, which promoted light limitation and a lower productivity. In LGL, nano- and microplankton were in general more productive and the relative contribution of picoplankton to the total phytoplankton production decreased with the increase in total photosynthetic biomass. Hence, our study extends previously observed patterns to subtropical shallow lakes, where seasonality and free floating plants may influence the dynamics of phytoplankton production.     

Nutrient limitation of bacterioplankton and phytoplankton in humic lakes in northern Sweden

1. Two small humic lakes in northern Sweden with concentrations of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) between 15 and 20 mg L^–1 were fertilized with inorganic phosphorus (P) and inorganic nitrogen (N), respectively. A third lake was unfertilized and served as a control. In addition to this lake fertilization experiment, data from different regional surveys were used to assess the role of different limiting factors.
2. The P fertilization had no effects on bacterioplankton or phytoplankton, while phytoplankton were significantly stimulated by N fertilization. Inorganic nutrient limitation of bacterioplankton was a function of DOC concentration in water of the investigated region and nutrient-limited bacteria were found only in lakes with DOC concentrations less than around 15 mg L^–1
3. The fertilization experiments demonstrated that the DOC-rich experimental lakes contained a bioavailable pool of P that was not utilized to its full potential under natural conditions. The overall mobilization of energy (bacterioplankton plus phytoplankton) in the experimental lakes was restricted by lack of inorganic N.     

Physiological indicators of nutrient deficiency in phytoplankton in southern Chilean lakes

We assessed the nutrient status of phytoplankton in 28 lakes in southern Chile using two types of physiological indicators: specific alkaline phosphatase activity, and the elemental composition (carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus) of seston. Alkaline phosphatase activity ranged from 0.001 to 0.11 mol P g chl^–1 h^–1, with P-deficiency indicated in about one-half the study lakes. C:N ranged from 3.9 to 24, C:P ranged from 86 to 919, and N:P ranged from 8.7 to 99. C:P and N:P ratios greater than the Redfield ratio were common, suggesting P deficiency in many of the lakes. C:N ratios were not generally indicative of N deficiency. Previous studies have suggested N may be the primary limiting nutrient in southern Chilean lakes, but our results indicate that P should not be discounted as a limiting nutrient.     

Evidence for extensive but variable nutrient limitation in New Zealand lakes

Nutrient limitation causes reduced growth of organisms, which can translate into far-reaching consequences for populations, communities, and ecosystems. Phosphorus (P) limitation, in particular, is associated with reductions in organismal growth because ribosomes, upon which growth depends, require abundant phosphorus to be produced. Chromosomes are also relatively rich in P, meaning that organisms with relatively high chromosome complements (e.g. polyploids) might be especially dependent on abundant environmental P. Here we address the likelihood of nutrient limitation in multiple populations of Potamopyrgus antipodarum, a New Zealand freshwater snail featuring wide ploidy variation. We found that some form of P limitation is very likely in many, but not all, populations of this snail that we surveyed. We also detected extensive across-population variation in P and nitrogen (N) content and N and P limitation and co-limitation in the algae that P. antipodarum eat. Accordingly, we then experimentally evaluated how P and N alone and together influenced growth rate in P. antipodarum. We found that response to nutrients differed by lineage and that dietary P content was more important than dietary N content as a determinant of growth rate, a trait closely tied to fitness in P. antipodarum. The widespread likelihood of (1) P limitation and (2) variation in dietary P availability across New Zealand lakes, along with (3), evidence for lineage-level variation in sensitivity to P limitation, sets the stage for the possibility that variation in nutrient availability contributes to the distribution and maintenance of ploidy variation in P. antipodarum.     

Primary productivity,phytoplankton and limiting nutrient factors in labrador lakes

The primary productivity of some lakes and reservoirs in western Labrador was measured by the ¹⁴C method in order to determine the range of productivities and the effects of impoundment. No primary productivity data previously existed for this part of Canada. Both the primary productivity and standing crops of phytoplankton were found to be low in a newly impounded lake but later rose to levels greater than in surrounding natural lakes. In nutrient enrichment experiments, carbon was never found to be limiting but phosphorus stimulated primary productivity when added alone or in combination with nitrogen.     

Priming and microbial nutrient limitation in lowland tropical forest soils of contrasting fertility

Priming is an increase in soil organic carbon decomposition following input of labile organic carbon. In temperate soils where biological activity is limited commonly by nitrogen availability, priming is expected to occur through microbial acquisition of nitrogen from organic matter or stimulated activity of recalcitrant-carbon degrading microorganisms. However, these priming mechanisms have not yet been assessed in strongly weathered tropical forest soils where biological activity is often limited by the availability of phosphorus. We examined whether microbial nutrient limitation or community dynamics drive priming in three lowland tropical forest soils of contrasting fertility (‘low’, ‘mid’ and ‘high’) by applying C₄-sucrose (alone or in combination with nutrients; nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium) and measuring (1) the δ¹³C-signatures in respired CO₂ and in phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA) biomarkers, and (2) the activities of enzymes involved in nitrogen (N-acetyl β-glucosaminidase), phosphorus (phosphomonoesterase) and carbon (β-glucosidase, cellobiohydrolase, xylanase, phenol oxidase) acquisition from organic compounds. Priming was constrained in part by nutrient availability, because priming was greater when sucrose was added alone compared to when added with nutrients. However, the greatest priming with sucrose addition alone was detected in the medium fertility soil. Priming occurred in parallel with stimulated activity of phosphomonoesterase and phenol oxidase (but not N-acetyl β-glucosaminidase); when sucrose was added with nutrients there were lower activities of phosphomonoesterase and phenol oxidase. There was no evidence according to PLFA δ¹³C-incorporation that priming was caused by specific groups of recalcitrant-carbon degrading microorganisms. We conclude that priming occurred in the intermediate fertility soil following microbial mineralization of organic nutrients (phosphorus in particular) and suggest that priming was constrained in the high fertility soil by high nutrient availability and in the low fertility soil by the low concentration of soil organic matter amenable to priming. This first study of priming mechanisms in tropical forest soils indicates that input of labile carbon can result in priming by microbial mineralization of organic nutrients, which has important implications for understanding the fate of organic carbon in tropical forest soils.     

Linking nutrient limitation and water chemistry in upland lakes to catchment characteristics

Overbank sedimentation on river floodplains can result in significant reduction of the suspended sediment load transported by a river and can thus represent an important component of the catchment sediment budget. Such conveyance losses will also exert an important influence on sediment-associated contaminant fluxes and budgets. This contribution reports the results of a study of sediment-associated contaminants (i.e. total-P, Cr, Cu, Pb and Zn) fluxes in the River Swale (1346 km²) and River Aire (1002 km²) in Yorkshire, U.K., aimed at quantifying the role of overbank floodplain sedimentation in the sediment-associated contaminant budgets. The catchment of the River Aire is dominated by urban and industrial land use in its middle and lower reaches, whereas the River Swale drains a largely rural catchment, although there is a legacy of metal mining in its headwaters which impacts on heavy metal transport by the river. The results for the River Swale indicate that the conveyance losses associated with the deposition of sediment-associated contaminants on the floodplains bordering the main river can be as high as 47% of the total flux through the main channel system. Equivalent values for the River Aire range up to 26%. Contrasts between the two rivers reflect both the location of the contaminant sources within the catchments and the relative magnitude of the fine sediment deposition fluxes associated with their floodplains.     

Effects of nutrient and light limitation on the biochemical composition of phytoplankton

Three marine phytoplankters (Isochrysis galbana, Chaetoceros calcitrans andThalassiosira pseudonana), commonly used in the culture of bivalve larvae, were grown in batch or semi-continuous cultures. Changes in protein, carbohydrate, lipid and some fatty acids were measured as growth became limited by nitrogen, silicon, phosphorus or light. Under N starvation (2 d) the % lipid remained relatively constant, while% carbohydrate increased and% protein decreased in all 3 species compared to cells growing under no nutrient limitation. Under Si starvation (6 h) there was no change in lipid, protein or carbohydrates. The amount of two fatty acids, 20 : 53 and 22 : 63 remained relatively constant under N, P and Si starvation, exept for a sharp drop in the cells of P-starvedT. pseudonana. However, there were pronounced species differences withI. galbana containing significantly less 20 : 5 3 thanC. calcitrans orT. pseudonana. Under light limitation the amount of lipid per cell showed no consistent trend over a range of irradiances for all 3 species. The amount of N per cell (an index of protein content) as a function of irradiance, was relatively constant forI. galbana andT. pseudonana, while the amount of N per cell was lower under low irradiances forC. calcitrans. These examples of changes in protein, carbohydrate, lipid and certain fatty acids under nutrient (N, Si or P) or light limitation, emphasize the importance of knowing the phase (e.g. logarithmic vs stationary) of the growth curve in batch cultures, since the nutritional value of the phytoplankters could change as cultures become dense and growth is terminated due to nutrient or light limitation.Presented at the XIIIth International Seaweed Symposium, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada, August 1989.     

Primary production studies in two linked but contrasting Welsh lakes

SUMMARY. Llyn Padarn and Llyn Peris have distinct phytoplankton populations. During 1975–76, the standing crop measured as chlorophyll- a was 5.5 times greater in Padarn than in Peris and the production rate, determined by the ¹⁴CO₂ method, was faster by 3.4 times. These differences were attributed to the higher concentrations of phosphorus in the lower lake caused by treated sewage effluent. Incident light intensity, which was slightly lower in Peris due to mountain shading, and temperature, which was 1–4°C higher in Padarn, made little significant contribution to these differences during the summer. The reduced transparency of Padarn water, compared with that of Peris, resulted from denser phytopiankton crops in Padarn. During the summer, Padarn exhibited carbon dioxide depletion which correlated with the chlorophyll concentration. Light inhibition at the surfaces of both lakes correlated with solar radiation intensity. However, the relationship between pigment content and maximum photosynthetic rate was poor. Extracellular products accounted for about 16% of the total production in the lakes. Uptake of ¹⁴C-labelled acetate was low compared with that of ¹⁴CO₂ uptake.     

The Holocene development of some low and high arctic Greenland lakes

During the Holocene most West Greenland lakes passed from an early eutrophic stage, rich in both flora and fauna, through a mesotrophic to an oligotrophic stage with very low productivity. Temperature conditions were limiting factors only in the very beginning, whereas chemical factors alone were decisive later on.     

Bacterial chitin hydrolysis in two lakes with contrasting trophic statuses

Chitin, which is a biopolymer of the amino sugar glucosamine (GlcN), is highly abundant in aquatic ecosystems, and its degradation is assigned a key role in the recycling of carbon and nitrogen. In order to study the significance of chitin decomposition in two temperate freshwater lakes with contrasting trophic and redox conditions, we measured the turnover rate of the chitin analog methylumbelliferyl-N,N'-diacetylchitobioside (MUF-DC) and the presence of chitinase (chiA) genes in zooplankton, water, and sediment samples. In contrast to the eutrophic and partially anoxic lake, chiA gene fragments were detectable throughout the oligotrophic water column and chiA copy numbers per ml of water were up to 15 times higher than in the eutrophic waters. For both lakes, the highest chiA abundance was found in the euphotic zone--the main habitat of zooplankton, but also the site of production of easily degradable algal chitin. The bulk of chitinase activity was measured in zooplankton samples and the sediments, where recalcitrant chitin is deposited. Both, chiA abundance and chitinase activity correlated well with organic carbon, nitrogen, and concentrations of particulate GlcN. Our findings show that chitin, although its overall contribution to the total organic carbon is small (~0.01 to 0.1%), constitutes an important microbial growth substrate in these temperate freshwater lakes, particularly where other easily degradable carbon sources are scarce.     

Recovery of three arctic stream reaches from experimental nutrient enrichment

1. Nutrient enrichment and resulting eutrophication is a widespread anthropogenic influence on freshwater ecosystems, but recovery from nutrient enrichment is poorly understood, especially in stream environments. We examined multi‐year patterns in community recovery from experimental low‐concentration nutrient enrichment (N + P or P only) in three reaches of two Arctic tundra streams (Kuparuk River and Oksrukuyik Creek) on the North Slope of Alaska (U.S.A.). 2. Rates of recovery varied among community components and depended on duration of enrichment (2–13 consecutive growing seasons). Biomass of epilithic algae returned to reference levels rapidly (within 2 years), regardless of nutrients added or enrichment duration. Aquatic bryophyte cover, which increased greatly in the Kuparuk River only after long‐term enrichment (8 years), took 8 years of recovery to approach reference levels, after storms had scoured most remnant moss in the recovering reach. 3. Multi‐year persistence of bryophytes in the Kuparuk River appeared to prevent recovery of insect populations that had either been positively (e.g. the mayfly Ephemerella, most chironomid midge taxa) or negatively (e.g. the tube‐building chironomid Orthocladius rivulorum) affected by this shift in dominant primary producer. These lags in recovery (of >3 years) were probably driven by the persistent effect of bryophytes on physical benthic habitat. 4. Summer growth rates of Arctic grayling (both adults and young‐of‐year) in Oksrukuyik Creek (fertilised for 6 years with no bryophyte colonisation), which were consistently increased by nutrient addition, returned to reference rates within 1–2 years. 5. Rates of recovery of these virtually pristine Arctic stream ecosystems from low‐level nutrient enrichment appeared to be controlled largely by duration of enrichment, mediated through physical habitat shifts caused by eventual bryophyte colonisation, and subsequent physical disturbance that removed bryophytes. Nutrient enrichment of oligotrophic Arctic stream ecosystems caused by climate change or local anthropogenic activity may have dramatic and persistent consequences if it results in the colonisation of long‐lived primary producers that alter physical habitat.