On Cognitive and Moral Enhancement: A Reply to Savulescu and Persson

In a series of recent works, Julian Savulescu and Ingmar Persson insist that, given the ease by which irreversible destruction is achievable by a morally wicked minority, (i) strictly cognitive bio‐enhancement is currently too risky, while (ii) moral bio‐enhancement is plausibly morally mandatory (and urgently so). This article aims to show that the proposal Savulescu and Persson advance relies on several problematic assumptions about the separability of cognitive and moral enhancement as distinct aims. Specifically, we propose that the underpinnings of Savulescu's and Persson's normative argument unravel once it is suitably clear how aiming to cognitively enhance an individual will in part require that one aim to bring about certain moral goods we show to be essential to cognitive flourishing; conversely, aiming to bring about moral enhancement in an individual must involve aiming to improve certain cognitive capacities we show to be essential to moral flourishing. After developing these points in some detail, and their implication for Savulescu's & Persson's proposal, we conclude by outlining some positive suggestions.     

Moral Enhancement and Those Left Behind

Opponents to genetic or biomedical human enhancement often claim that the availability of these technologies would have negative consequences for those who either choose not to utilize these resources or lack access to them. However, Thomas Douglas has argued that this objection has no force against the use of technologies that aim to bring about morally desirable character traits, as the unenhanced would benefit from being surrounded by such people. I will argue that things are not as straightforward as Douglas makes out. The widespread use of moral enhancement would raise the standards for praise and blame worthiness, making it much harder for the unenhanced to perform praiseworthy actions or avoid performing blameworthy actions. This shows that supporters of moral enhancement cannot avoid this challenge in the way that Douglas suggests.     

Should we use Commitment Contracts to Regulate Student use of Cognitive Enhancing Drugs?

Are universities justified in trying to regulate student use of cognitive enhancing drugs? In this article I argue that they can be, but that the most appropriate kind of regulatory intervention is likely to be voluntary in nature. To be precise, I argue that universities could justifiably adopt a commitment contract system of regulation wherein students are encouraged to voluntarily commit to not using cognitive enhancing drugs (or to using them in a specific way). If they are found to breach that commitment, they should be penalized by, for example, forfeiting a number of marks on their assessments. To defend this model of regulation, I adopt a recently‐proposed evaluative framework for determining the appropriateness of enhancement in specific domains of activity, and I focus on particular existing types of cognitive enhancement drugs, not hypothetical or potential forms. In this way, my argument is tailored to the specific features of university education, and common patterns of usage among students. It is not concerned with the general ethical propriety of using cognitive enhancing drugs.     

Conceptual and Practical Problems of Moral Enhancement

Recently, the debate on human enhancement has shifted from familiar topics like cognitive enhancement and mood enhancement to a new and – to no one's surprise – controversial subject, namely moral enhancement. Some proponents from the transhumanist camp allude to the ‘urgent need’ of improving the moral conduct of humankind in the face of ever growing technological progress and the substantial dangers entailed in this enterprise. Other thinkers express more sceptical views about this proposal. As the debate has revealed so far, there is no shared opinion among philosophers (or scientists) about the meaning, prospects, and ethical evaluation of moral enhancement. In this article I will address several conceptual and practical problems of this issue, in order to encourage discussion about the prospects of (thinking about) moral enhancement in the future. My assumption is that (i) for the short term, there is little chance of arriving at an agreement on the proper understanding of morality and the appropriateness of one single (meta‐)ethical theory; (ii) apart from this, there are further philosophical puzzles loosely referred to in the debate which add to theoretical confusion; and (iii) even if these conceptual problems could be solved, there are still practical problems to be smoothed out if moral enhancement is ever to gain relevance apart from merely theoretical interest. My tentative conclusion, therefore, will be that moral enhancement is not very likely to be made sense of – let alone realized – in the medium‐term future.     

ENHANCEMENT OF IMMUNOGOLD-LABELLED FOCAL ADHESION SITES IN FIBROBLASTS CULTURED ON METAL SUBSTRATES: PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS

Visualisation of cell adhesion patterns by scanning electron microscopy requires special preparation and labelling. The membranes and cytoplasm must be removed, without damaging the antigen, to facilitate antibody access to vinculin in the focal adhesions. Low beam energy imaging is used to visualise the cell undersurface (embedded in resin after staining with osmium tetroxide) and immunogold-labelled adhesion sites. The gold probe, must be large enough (>40 nm) for detection, while viewing the whole cell, but large gold markers increase steric hindrance and decrease labelling efficiency. This problem can be overcome by using small gold probes (1-5 nm) followed by enlargement with silver enhancement, but osmium tetroxide stain etches the silver. We demonstrated that metal substrates increased this etching. Reducing the concentration of osmium tetroxide and incubation time reduced the amount of etching. We have demonstrated that gold enhancement was not etched by osmium tetroxide, irrespective of the substrate. Therefore, comparative studies of cell adhesion to different biomaterial substrates can be performed using immunogold-labelling with gold enhancement.     

GETTING MORAL ENHANCEMENT RIGHT: THE DESIRABILITY OF MORAL BIOENHANCEMENT

We respond to a number of objections raised by John Harris in this journal to our argument that we should pursue genetic and other biological means of morally enhancing human beings (moral bioenhancement). We claim that human beings now have at their disposal means of wiping out life on Earth and that traditional methods of moral education are probably insufficient to achieve the moral enhancement required to ensure that this will not happen. Hence, we argue, moral bioenhancement should be sought and applied. We argue that cognitive enhancement and technological progress raise acute problems because it is easier to harm than to benefit. We address objections to this argument. We also respond to objections that moral bioenhancement: (1) interferes with freedom; (2) cannot be made to target immoral dispositions precisely; (3) is redundant, since cognitive enhancement by itself suffices.     

Enhancing Beyond What Ought to be the Case ‐ A Conceptual Clarification

In order to do justice to the intuition that medical treatments as such do not form proper instances of bio‐enhancement, as the notion is employed in the ethical debate, we should construe bio‐enhancements as interventions, which do not aim at states that, other things being equal, ought to obtain. In the light of this clarification, we come to see that cases of moral enhancement are not covered by the notion of bio‐enhancement, properly construed.     

A Kantian ethics approach to moral bioenhancement

It seems, at first glance, that a Kantian ethics approach to moral enhancement would tend towards the position that there could be no place for emotional modulation in any understanding of the endeavour, owing to the typically understood view that Kantian ethics does not allow any role for emotion in morality as a whole. It seems then that any account of moral bioenhancement which places emotion at its centre would therefore be rejected. This article argues, however, that this assumption is incorrect. Given later writings by Kant on the role of sympathy, and taking into account other concerns in Kantian ethics (such as bodily integrity), it may in fact be the case that Kantian ethics would allow for an account of moral bioenhancement through emotional modulation, and that in some (rare) cases such an intervention might even be considered to be a duty.     

New developments in umami (enhancing) molecules

As health has become one of the main drivers in nutrition, the scientific interest in taste receptors and taste molecules has increased considerably. Academia as well as flavor and food companies are searching for molecules that make food more healthy but not less appetizing. In the savory area, salt and umami taste are being investigated. This review deals with the progress made in umami tasting molecules. Umami taste has been known as a separate taste for a long time in Asian countries and has been generally accepted as the fifth basic taste in the last decade of the previous century. In this review, first the current level of understanding of the umami receptors will be described. The main part of the paper will deal with the umami-tasting molecules that have been published recently, including the work that has been performed within Givaudan itself. Lactoyl amides of GMP (guanosine monophosphate) appeared to have remarkably strong umami-tasting properties.     

Rapidly dissolving repaglinide powders produced by the ultra-rapid freezing process

The objective of the study was to produce rapidly dissolving formulations of the poorly water-soluble drug repaglinide using an innovative new technology, ultra-rapid freezing (URF), and to investigate the influence of excipient type on repaglinide stability. Repaglinide compositions containing different types and levels of excipients and different drug potencies (50%–86%) were produced by the URF technology. Repaglinide/excipient solutions were frozen on a cryogenic substrate, collected, and lyophilized to form a dry powder. Surfactants, including sodium dodecyl sulfate, and alkalizing agents such as diethanolamine (DEA) and tromethamine (TRIS) were incorporated into the compositions. Forced degradation of repaglinide was conducted under stressed conditions (eg, elevated temperature, exposure to peroxide) to determine the stability of the drug in such environments. The solubility of repaglinide increased as a function of increasing pH; therefore, incorporation of an alkalizing agent into the URF formulations increased the drug's solubility. Drug instability resulted when the drug was exposed to pH values above 9.0. URF formulations containing alkalizing agents showed no degradation or spontaneous recrystallization in the formulation, indicating that increased stability was afforded by processing. URF processing created nanostructured drug/excipient particles with higher dissolution rates than were achieved for unprocessed drug. Alkalizing agents such as TRIS and DEA, present at levels of 25% to 33% wt/wt in the formulations, did not cause degradation of the drug when processed using URF. URF processing, therefore, yielded fast-dissolving formulations that were physically and chemically stable, resistant to alkali degradation or spontaneous recrystallization in the formulation. Published: July 20, 2007     

Neuroethics

Neuroimaging, psychosurgery, deep-brain stimulation, and psychopharmacology hold considerable promise for more accurate prediction and diagnosis and more effective treatment of neurological and psychiatric disorders. Some forms of psychopharmacology may even be able to enhance normal cognitive and affective capacities. But the brain remains the most complex and least understood of all the organs in the human body. Mapping the neural correlates of the mind through brain scans, and altering these correlates through surgery, stimulation, or pharmacological interventions can affect us in both positive and negative ways. We need to carefully weigh the potential benefit against the potential harm of such techniques. This paper examines some of these techniques and explores the emerging ethical issues in clinical neuroscience.     

Autonomy,Natality and Freedom: A Liberal Re‐examination of Habermas in the Enhancement Debate

Jurgen Habermas has argued that carrying out pre‐natal germline enhancements would be inimical to the future child's autonomy. In this article, I suggest that many of the objections that have been made against Habermas' arguments by liberals in the enhancement debate misconstrue his claims. To explain why, I begin by explaining how Habermas' view of personal autonomy confers particular importance to the agent's embodiment and social environment. In view of this, I explain that it is possible to draw two arguments against germline enhancements from Habermas' thought. I call these arguments ‘the argument from negative freedom’ and ‘the argument from natality’. Although I argue that many of the common liberal objections to Habermas are not applicable when his arguments are properly understood, I go on to suggest ways in which supporters of enhancement might appropriately respond to Habermas' arguments.     

Internal bulge and tetraloop of the catalytic domain 5 of a group II intron ribozyme are flexible: implications for catalysis

RNA molecules have an inherent flexibility that enables recognition of other interacting partners through potential disorder-order transitions, yet studies to quantify such motional dynamics remain few. With an increasing database of three-dimensional structures of biologically important RNA molecules, quantifying such motions becomes important to link structural deformations with function. One such system studied intensely is domain 5 (D5) from the self-splicing group II introns, which is at the heart of its catalytic machinery. We report the dynamics of a 36 nucleotide D5 from the Pylaiella littoralis group II intron in the presence and absence of magnesium ions, and at a range of temperatures (298K-318 K). Using high-resolution NMR experiments of heteronuclear nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOE), spin-lattice (R(1)), and spin-spin (R(2)) (13)C relaxation rates, we determined the rotational diffusion tensor of D5 using the ROTDIF program modified for RNA dynamic analysis (ROTDIF_RNA). The D5 rotational diffusion tensor has an axial symmetric ratio (D(||)/D(perpendicular)) of 1.7+/-0.3, consistent with an estimated overall rotational correlation time of tau(m)=(2D(||)+4D(perpendicular))(-1) of 6.1(+/-0.3) ns at 298 K and 4.1(+/-0.2) ns at 318 K. The measured relaxation data were analyzed with the reduced spectral density mapping formalism using assumed values of the chemical shift anisotropy of the (13)C spins. Both the relaxation data and the values of the spectral density function reveal that the functional groups in D5 implicated in magnesium ion binding and catalysis (catalytic triad, internal bulge, and tetraloop regions) exhibit thermally induced motion on a wide variety of timescales. Because these motions parallel those observed in the intramolecular stem-loop of the U6 element within the spliceosome, we hypothesize that such extensive dynamic disorder likely facilitates D5 engaging both binding and catalytic regions of the ribozyme, and these may be a conserved feature of the catalytic machinery essential for catalysis.     

The oxygen effect in haploid and diploid yeast strains of different sensitivities

The extent of the oxygen effect for cell survival was studied in diploid and haploid wild-type yeast and in mutants beloning to the rad2, rad6 and rad50 epistatic group. In haploids, reduced oxygen enhancement ratios were found in rad52, rad6 and rad18. The latter two also showed some influence of the mating type. In diploids the oxygen effect was decreased in rad2, rad52 and rad18.     

Hydrological improvement of a former floodplain in an urban area: Potential and limits

The Lobau near Vienna used to be a dynamic floodplain which was cut off from the Danube River in the course of regulation measures in the 19th century. In order to compensate for deficits in the water budget, a water enhancement scheme for the upstream part of the floodplain, the Obere Lobau, was initiated in 2001. The aims of this scheme were to increase water levels in the floodplain and to discharge nutrients from the area's highly eutrophic water bodies by imposing a controlled surface water exchange through the main side arm. Our study evaluates the effects of this artificial water supply on the hydrological and trophic state of the backwaters.The effects of the water enhancement scheme were partly overlaid by the impoundment of the Danube after the construction of a power plant. Both the artificial water enhancement and the Danube impoundment improved the hydrological and trophic condition of the backwaters through an increased surface or sub-surface water supply. In addition, the water enhancement scheme provided a surface water exchange through the chain of backwaters, creating uniformity among the connected water bodies and leading to a significant decrease in temporal variability. However, spatial and temporal restrictions in the scheme ensured that the individual backwaters could maintain their specific biogeochemical character. Our long-term observations of mitigation effects in degraded urban wetlands demonstrate the need for a steady and well controlled water supply in order to achieve successful long-term maintenance of such systems.     

A rapid in vivo test for chromosomal damage

An in vivo method for screening drugs, food additives, and other chemicals that might cause chromosomal aberrations has been tested. It is reliable, easy, and very much more rapid than the traditional method.     

Application of nonlinear sampling schemes to COSY-type spectra

Summary Nonlinear sampling along the t₁ dimension is applied to COSY-type spectra. The sine dependence of the time domain signals for the cross peaks is matched by a nonlinear sampling scheme that samples most densely around the maximum of the sine function. Data are processed by maximum entropy reconstruction, using a modified implementation of the Cambridge algorithm of Skilling and Bryan. The procedure is demonstrated for P.E.COSY spectra recorded on a cyclic hexapeptide and on a 126-residue domain of the protein villin. The number of t₁ values in the nonlinearly sampled experiments was reduced by a factor of four compared to linear sampling. The sensitivity and resolution of the resulting spectra are comparable to those achieved by conventional methods. The method described can thus significantly reduce the measuring time for COSY-type spectra.Abbreviations COSY two-dimensional correlation spectroscopy - E.COSY exclusive COSY - P.E.COSY primitive E.COSY - TPPI time proportional phase incrementation - FID free induction decay To whom correspondence should be addressed.     

The dependence of radiation enhancement effect on the concentration of gold nanoparticles exposed to low- and high-LET radiations

We examined the dependence of hydroxyl radical production on the concentration of 15 nm citrate-capped AuNPs and dose using coumarin-3-carboxylic acid in phosphate buffered saline (PBS), and investigated the radiosensitisation of different concentration AuNPs on human cervix carcinoma HeLa cells through clonogenic survival assay for X-rays and carbon ions. The enhancement factor of AuNPs for hydroxyl radical production reached a maximum 3.66 for X-rays at the concentration of 0.1 μg/mL while the maximum was 5.52 for carbon ions in presence of 1.0 μg/mL AuNPs in PBS. At 50% survival level, the sensitizer enhancement ratios of X-rays and carbon ions varied from 1.14 to 2.88 and from 1.27 to 1.44, respectively, when cells were co-cultured with 1.5–15.0 μg/mL AuNPs. Our data indicate AuNPs showed radiosensitisation in terms of hydroxyl radical production and cell killing for low- and high-LET radiations. The concentration of AuNPs in PBS and cells played an important role in radiosensitizing effect. Based on the fact-the AuNPs in PBS could improve the production of hydroxyl radical and no accumulation of cells in the G₂/M phase was observed, we deduce that the increment of hydroxyl radical production with AuNPs provided a mechanism for radiosensitisation.     

Influence of various structural domains of fibrinogen and fibrin on the potentiation of plasminogen activation by recombinant tissue plasminogen activator

Fibrinogen, fibrin, and related fragments have varying stimulatory effects on the initial rate of the activation of human plasminogen ([Glu¹]Pg) by recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA). A detailed analysis of this enhancement was undertaken using various purified and complexed forms of the known domains of fibrin(ogen) with a view to gaining additional knowledge regarding the substructures of fibrinogen and fibrin that are important for their stimulatory capacities. Both arvin-mediated fibrin, as well as fibrinogen fragments generated as a result of its cleavage with CNBr, stimulate the activation in a biphasic manner, most likely as a result of changes in the promoter molecule accompanying the denaturation processes that are normally employed to either solubilize or generate these particular promoters. Using purified fibrinogen and fibrin fragments, it was found that fragment E, which binds to [Glu¹]Pg, does not enhance the activation reaction, while fragment D₁ has a potentiating effect. This suggests that the binding of [Glu¹]Pg to fibrin(ogen) alone is not, in itself, sufficient for stimulation of activation to occur, but that the rt-PA-fibrin(ogen) interaction is fundamental to this same process. All purified and mixtures of fragments containing the fragment D domain (e.g., D₂E, X-oligomer, fragment X) stimulate the reaction to a greater degree than fibrinogen and fragment D₁. It is concluded that the fibrinogen D domain is asine qua non for the enhancement reaction, while structures containing the E domain had a symbiotic effect on enhancement.On study leave from the National Institute for Biological Standards and Control, South Mimms, HERTS EN6 3QG, England.