ATP synthases: insights into their motor functions from sequence and structural analyses

ATP synthases are motor complexes comprised of F₀ and F₁ parts that couple the proton gradient across the membrane to the synthesis of ATP by rotary catalysis. Although a great deal of information has been accumulated regarding the structure and function of ATP synthases, their motor functions are not fully understood. For this reason, we performed the alignments and analyses of the protein sequences comprising the core of the ATP synthase motor complex, and examined carefully the locations of the conserved residues in the subunit structures of ATP synthases. A summary of the findings from this bioinformatic study is as follows. First, we found that four conserved regions in the sequence of subunit are clustered into three patches in its structure. The interactions of these conserved patches with the and subunits are likely to be critical for energy coupling and catalytic activity of the ATP synthase. Second, we located a four-residue cluster at the N-terminal domain of mitochondrial OSCP or bacterial (or chloroplast) subunit which may be critical for the binding of these subunits to F₁. Third, from the localizations of conserved residues in the subunits comprising the rotors of ATP synthases, we suggest that the conserved interaction site at the interface of subunit c and (mitochondria) or (bacteria and chloroplasts) may be important for connecting the rotor of F₁ to the rotor of F₀. Finally, we found the sequence of mitochondrial subunit b to be highly conserved, significantly longer than bacterial subunit b, and to contain a shorter dimerization domain than that of the bacterial protein. It is suggested that the different properties of mitochondrial subunit b may be necessary for interaction with other proteins, e.g., the supernumerary subunits.     

Introduction: A Close Look at the Vacuolar ATPase

The vacuolar ATPases (V-type ATPases) are a family of ATP-dependent ion pumps and found in two principal locations, in endomembranes and in plasma membranes. This family of ATPases is responsible for acidification of intracellulare compartments and, in certain cases, ion transport across the plasma membrane of eucaryotic cells. V-ATPases are composed of two distinct domains: a catalytic V₁ sector, in which ATP hydrolysis takes place, and the membrane-embedded sector, V₀, which functions in ion conduction. In the past decade impressive progress has been made in elucidating the properties structure, function and moleculare biology. These knowledge sheds light also on the evolution of V-ATPases and their related families of A-(A₁A₀-ATPase) and F-type (F₁F₀-ATPases)ATPases.     

ATP synthases: bioinformatic based insights into how their electrochemically driven motor comprised of subunits a and c might serve as a drug target

ATP synthases, widely distributed in bacteria, eukaryotic mitochondria and chloroplasts, are highly conserved multi-subunit complexes. Although the conserved acidic residue in the transmembrane helix of the c subunit functions in H⁺ transport, the surrounding residues differ among species. Such divergence could lead to different regulatory modes since pH-dependent H⁺ transport has been demonstrated in E. coli with a c subunit carrying an additional acidic residue in the helix. There is further divergence in the number of c subunits that form the ring structure which is determined by the higher ordered structure. Recently, it was suggested that certain chemicals recognize the a and c subunits of pathogenic bacterial F₀. Since there may be structural divergence even in well-conserved ATP synthases, the c subunit-ring as well as the a subunit in F₀ could be targets for drugs for specific bacterial species.     

Coupling Proton Movement to ATP Synthesis in the Chloroplast ATP Synthase

The chloroplast F₀F₁-ATP synthase-ATPase is a tiny rotary motor responsible for coupling ATP synthesis and hydrolysis to the light-driven electrochemical proton gradient. Reversible oxidation/reduction of a dithiol, located within a special regulatory domain of the γ subunit of the chloroplast F₁ enzyme, switches the enzyme between an inactive and an active state. This regulatory mechanism is unique to the ATP synthases of higher plants and its physiological significance lies in preventing nonproductive depletion of essential ATP pools in the dark. The three-dimensional structure of the chloroplast F₁ gamma subunit has not yet been solved. To examine the mechanism of dithiol regulation, a model of the chloroplast gamma subunit was obtained through segmental homology modeling based on the known structures of the mitochondrial and bacterial γ subunits, together with de novo construction of the unknown regulatory domain. The model has provided considerable insight into how the dithiol might modulate catalytic function. This has, in turn, suggested a mechanism by which rotation of subunits in F₀, the transmembrane proton channel portion of the enzyme, can be coupled, via the ε subunit, to rotation of the γ subunit of F₁ to achieve the 120° (or 90°+30°) stepping action that is characteristic of F₁ γ subunit rotation.     

Subunit Organization of the Stator Part of the F 0 Complex from Escherichia coli ATP Synthase

Membrane-bound ATP synthases (F₁F₀) catalyze the synthesis of ATP via a rotary catalyticmechanism utilizing the energy of an electrochemical ion gradient. The transmembrane potentialis supposed to propel rotation of a subunit c ring of F₀ together with subunits and of F₁,hereby forming the rotor part of the enzyme, whereas the remainder of the F₁F₀ complexfunctions as a stator for compensation of the torque generated during rotation. This reviewfocuses on our recent work on the stator part of the F₀ complex, e.g., subunits a and b. Usingepitope insertion and antibody binding, subunit a was shown to comprise six transmembranehelixes with both the N- and C-terminus oriented toward the cytoplasm. By use of circulardichroism (CD) spectroscopy, the secondary structure of subunit b incorporated intoproteoliposomes was determined to be 80% -helical together with 14% turn conformation, providingflexibility to the second stalk. Reconstituted subunit b together with isolated ac subcomplexwas shown to be active in proton translocation and functional F₁ binding revealing the nativeconformation of the polypeptide chain. Chemical crosslinking in everted membrane vesiclesled to the formation of subunit b homodimers around residues bQ37 to bL65, whereas bA32Ccould be crosslinked to subunit a, indicating a close proximity of subunits a and b near themembrane. Further evidence for the proposed direct interaction between subunits a and b wasobtained by purification of a stable ab ₂ subcomplex via affinity chromatography using Histags fused to subunit a or b. This ab ₂ subcomplex was shown to be active in proton translocationand F₁ binding, when coreconstituted with subunit c. Consequences of crosslink formationand subunit interaction within the F₁F₀ complex are discussed.     

Manipulating the Length of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">b</Emphasis> Subunit F<Subscript>1</Subscript> Binding Domain in F<Subscript>1</Subscript>F<Subscript>0</Subscript> ATP Synthase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis>

The peripheral stalk of F₁F₀ ATP synthase is composed of a parallel homodimer of b subunits that extends across the cytoplasmic membrane in F₀ to the top of the F₁ sector. The stalk serves as the stator necessary for holding F₁ against movement of the rotor. A series of insertions and deletions have been engineered into the hydrophilic domain that interacts with F₁. Only the hydrophobic segment from {val-121} to {ala-132} and the extreme carboxyl terminus proved to be highly sensitive to mutation. Deletions in either site apparently abolished enzyme function as a result of defects is assembly of the F₁F₀ complex. Other mutations manipulating the length of the sequence between these two areas had only limited effects on enzyme function. Expression of a b subunit with insertions with as few as two amino acids into the hydrophobic segment also resulted in loss of F₁F₀ ATP synthase. However, a fully defective b subunit with seven additional amino acids could be stabilized in a heterodimeric peripheral stalk within a functional F₁F₀ complex by a normal b subunit.     

Mutagenesis Studies of the F1F0 ATP Synthase b Subunit Membrane Domain

A homodimer of b subunits constitutes the peripheral stalk linking the F₁ and F₀ sectors of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase. Each b subunit has a single-membrane domain. The constraints on the membrane domain have been studied by systematic mutagenesis. Replacement of a segment proximal to the cytoplasmic side of the membrane had minimal impact on F₁F₀ ATP synthase. However, multiple substitutions on the periplasmic side resulted in defects in assembly of the enzyme complex. These mutants had insufficient oxidative phosphorylation to support growth, and biochemical studies showed little F₁F₀ ATPase and no detectable ATP-driven proton pumping activity. Expression of the b _N2A,T6A,Q10A subunit was also oxidative phosphorylation deficient, but the b _N2A,T6A,Q10A protein was incorporated into an F₁F₀ complex. Single amino acid substitutions had minimal reductions in F₁F₀ ATP synthase function. The evidence suggests that the b subunit membrane domain has several sites of interaction contributing to assembly of F₀, and that these interactions are strongest on the periplasmic side of the bilayer.     

Kinetic studies of ATP synthase: The case for the positional change mechanism

The mitochondrial ATP synthases shares many structural and kinetic properties with bacterial and chloroplast ATP synthases. These enzymes transduce the energy contained in the membrane's electrochemical proton gradients into the energy required for synthesis of high-energy phosphate bonds. The unusual three-fold symmetry of the hydrophilic domain, F₁, of all these synthases is striking. Each F₁ has three identical subunits and three identical subunits as well as three additional subunits present as single copies. The catalytic site for synthesis is undoubtedly contained in the subunit or an , interface, and thus each enzyme appears to contain three identical catalytic sites. This review summarizes recent isotopic and kinetic evidence in favour of the concept, originally proposed by Boyer and coworkers, that energy from the proton gradient is exerted not directly for the reaction at the catalytic site, but rather to release product from a single catalytic site. A modification of this binding change hypotheses is favored by recent data which suggest that the binding change is due to a positional change in all three subunits relative to the remaining subunits of F₁ and F₀ and that the vector of rotation is influenced by energy. The positional change, or rotation, appears to be the slow step in the process of catalysis and it is accelerated in all F₁F₀ ATPases studied by substrate binding and by the proton gradient. However, in the mammalian mitochondrial enzyme, other types of allosteric rate regulation not yet fully elucidated seem important as well.     

Nucleotide Binding States of Subunit A of the A-ATP Synthase and the Implication of P-Loop Switch in Evolution

The crystal structures of the nucleotide-empty (A_E), 5′-adenylyl-β,γ-imidodiphosphate (A_PNP)-bound, and ADP (A_DP)-bound forms of the catalytic A subunit of the energy producer A₁A_O ATP synthase from Pyrococcus horikoshii OT3 have been solved at 2.47 Å and 2.4 Å resolutions. The structures provide novel features of nucleotide binding and depict the residues involved in the catalysis of the A subunit. In the A_E form, the phosphate analog SO₄²⁻ binds, via a water molecule, to the phosphate binding loop (P-loop) residue Ser238, which is also involved in the phosphate binding of ADP and 5′-adenylyl-β,γ-imidodiphosphate. Together with amino acids Gly234 and Phe236, the serine residue stabilizes the arched P-loop conformation of subunit A, as shown by the 2.4-Å structure of the mutant protein S238A in which the P-loop flips into a relaxed state, comparable to the one in catalytic β subunits of F₁F_O ATP synthases. Superposition of the existing P-loop structures of ATPases emphasizes the unique P-loop in subunit A, which is also discussed in the light of an evolutionary P-loop switch in related A₁A_O ATP synthases, F₁F_O ATP synthases, and vacuolar ATPases and implicates diverse catalytic mechanisms inside these biological motors.     

Osmomechanics of the Propionigenium modestum Fo Motor

In Propionigenium modestum, ATP is manufactured from ADP and phosphate by the enzyme ATP synthase using the free energy of an electrochemical gradient of Na⁺ ions. The P. modestum ATP synthase is a clear member of the family of F-type ATP synthases and the only major distinction is an extension of the coupling ion specificity to H⁺, Li⁺, or Na⁺, depending on the conditions. The use of Na⁺ as a coupling ion offers unique experimental options to decipher the ion-translocation mechanism and the osmotic and mechanical behavior of the enzyme. The single a subunit and the oligomer of c subunits are part of the stator and rotor, respectively, and operate together in the ion-translocation mechanism. During ATP synthesis, Na⁺ diffuses from the periplasm through the a subunit channel onto the Na⁺ binding site on a c subunit. From there it dissociates into the cytoplasm after the site has rotated out of the interface with subunit a. In the absence of a membrane potential, the rotor performs Brownian motions into either direction and Na⁺ ions are exchanged between the two compartments separated by the membrane. Upon applying voltage, however, the direction of Na⁺ flux and of rotation is biased by the potential. The motor generates torque to drive the rotation of the subunit, thereby releasing tightly bound ATP from catalytic sites in F₁. Hence, the membrane potential plays a pivotal role in the torque-generating mechanism. This is corroborated by the fact that for ATP synthesis, at physiological rates, the membrane potential is indispensable. We propose a catalytic mechanism for torque generation by the F_o motor that is in accord with all experimental data and is in quantitative agreement with the requirement for ATP synthesis.     

Evolutionary relationship between Enterobacteriaceae: comparison of the ATP synthases (F1F0) of Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae

The ATP synthase complex of Klebsiella pneumoniae (KF₁F₀) has been purified and characterized. SDS-gel electrophoresis of the purified F₁F₀ complexes revealed an identical subunit pattern for E. coli (EF₁F₀) and K. pneumoniae. Antibodies raised against EF₁ complex and purified EF₀ subunits recognized the corresponding polypeptides of EF₁F₀ and KF₁F₀ in immunoblot analysis. Protease digestion of the individual subunits generated an identical cleavage pattern for subunits , , , , a, and c of both enzymes. Only for subunit different cleavage products were obtained. The isolated subunit c of both organisms showed only a slight deviation in the amino acid composition. These data suggest that extensive homologies exist in primary and secondary structure of both ATP synthase complexes reflecting a close phylogenetic relationship between the two enterobacteric tribes.Abbreviations ACMA 9-amino-6-chloro-2-methoxyacridine - DCCD N,N-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide - FITC fluorescein isothiocyanate - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - TTFB 4,5,6,7-tetrachloro-2-trifluoromethylbenzimidazole     

H+ transport and coupling by the F0 sector of the ATP synthase: Insights into the molecular mechanism of function

The F₀ sector of the ATP synthase complex facilitates proton translocation through the membrane, and via interaction with the F₁ sector, couples proton transport to ATP synthesis. The molecular mechanism of function is being probed by a combination of mutant analysis and structural biochemistry, and recent progress on theEscherichia coli F₀ sector is reviewed here. TheE. coli F₀ is composed of three types of subunits (a, b, andc) and current information on their folding and organization in F₀ is reviewed. The structure of purified subunitc in chloroform-methanol-H₂O resembles that in native F₀, and progress in determining the structure by NMR methods is reviewed. Genetic experiments suggest that the two helices of subunitc must interact as a functional unit around an essential carboxyl group as protons are transported. In addition, a unique class of suppressor mutations identify a transmembrane helix of subunita that is proposed to interact with the bihelical unit of subunitc during proton transport. The role of multiple units of subunitc in coupling proton translocation to ATP synthesis is considered. The special roles of Asp61 of subunitc and Arg210 of subunita in proton translocation are also discussed.     

The Oligomeric Subunit c Rotor in the Fo Sector of ATP Synthase: Unresolved Questions in Our Understanding of Function

We have proposed a model for the oligomeric c-rotor of the F_o sector of ATP synthase and its interaction with subunit a during H⁺-transport driven rotation. The model is based upon the solution structure of monomeric subunit c, determined by NMR, and an extensive series of cross-linking distance constraints between c subunits and between subunits c and a. To explain the complete set of cross-linking data, we have suggested that the second transmembrane helix rotates during its interaction with subunit a in the course of the H⁺-translocation cycle. The H⁺-transport coupled rotation of this helix is proposed to drive the stepwise movement of the c-oligomeric rotor. The model is testable and provides a useful framework for addressing questions raised by other experiments.     

The <Emphasis Type="Italic">b</Emphasis><Subscript>arg36</Subscript> contributes to efficient coupling in F<Subscript>1</Subscript>F<Subscript>O</Subscript> ATP synthase in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis>

In Escherichia coli, the F₁F_O ATP synthase b subunits house a conserved arginine in the tether domain at position 36 where the subunit emerges from the membrane. Previous experiments showed that substitution of isoleucine or glutamate result in a loss of enzyme activity. Double mutants have been constructed in an attempt to achieve an intragenic suppressor of the b _arg36→ile and the b _arg36→glu mutations. The b _arg36→ile mutation could not be suppressed. In contrast, the phenotypic defect resulting from the b _arg36→glu mutation was largely suppressed in the b _{arg36→glu,glu39→arg} double mutant. E. coli expressing the b _{arg36→glu,glu39→arg} subunit grew well on succinate-based medium. F₁F_O ATP synthase complexes were more efficiently assembled and ATP driven proton pumping activity was improved. The evidence suggests that efficient coupling in F₁F_O ATP synthase is dependent upon a basic amino acid located at the base of the peripheral stalk.     

Mutagenic Analysis of the F 0 Stator Subunits

The a and b subunits constitute the stator elements in the F₀ sector of F₁F₀-ATP synthase.Both subunits have been difficult to study by physical means, so most of the information onstructure and function relationships in the a and b subunits has been obtained using mutagenesisin combination with biochemical methods. These approaches were used to demonstrate thatthe a subunit in association with the ring of c subunits houses the proton channel throughF₁F₀-ATP synthase. The map of the amino acids contributing to the proton channel is probablycomplete. The two b subunits dimerize, forming an extended flexible unit in the peripheralstalk linking the F₁ and F₀ sectors. The unique characteristics of specific amino acid substitutionsaffecting the a and b subunits suggested differential effects on rotation during F₁F₀-ATPaseactivity.     

Functional and stoichiometric analysis of subunit e in bovine heart mitochondrial F<Subscript>0</Subscript>F<Subscript>1</Subscript>ATP synthase

The role of the integral inner membrane subunit e in self-association of F₀F₁ATP synthase from bovine heart mitochondria was analyzed by in situ limited proteolysis, blue native PAGE/iterative SDS-PAGE, and LC-MS/MS. Selective degradation of subunit e, without disrupting membrane integrity or ATPase capacity, altered the oligomeric distribution of F₀F₁ATP synthase, by eliminating oligomers and reducing dimers in favor of monomers. The stoichiometry of subunit e was determined by a quantitative MS-based proteomics approach, using synthetic isotope-labelled reference peptides IAQL*EEVK, VYGVGSL*ALYEK, and ELAEAQEDTIL*K to quantify the b, γ and e subunits, respectively. Accuracy of the method was demonstrated by confirming the 1:1 stoichiometry of subunits γ and b. Altogether, the results indicate that the integrity of a unique copy of subunit e is essential for self-association of mammalian F₀F₁ATP synthase. Elena Bisetto and Paola Picotti contributed equally to this work.     

ADP and ATP binding to noncatalytic sites of thiol-modulated chloroplast ATP synthase

A modified ‘cold chase’ technique was used to study tight [¹⁴C]ADP and [¹⁴C]ATP binding to noncatalytic sites of chloroplast ATP synthase (CF₀F₁). The binding was very low in the dark and sharply increased with light intensity. Dissociation of labeled nucleotides incorporated into noncatalytic sites of CF₀F₁ or CF₁ reconstituted with EDTA-treated thylakoid membranes was also found to be light-dependent. Time dependence of nucleotide dissociation is described by the first order equation with a k _d of about 5 min⁻¹. The exposure of thylakoid membranes to 0.7–24.8 μM nucleotides leads to filling of up to two noncatalytic sites of CF₀F₁. The sites differ in their specificity: one preferentially binds ADP, whereas the other – ATP. A much higher ATP/ADP ratio of nucleotides bound at noncatalytic sites of isolated CF₁ dramatically decreases upon its reconstitution with EDTA-treated thylakoid membranes. It is suggested that the decrease is caused by conformational changes in one of the α subunits induced by its interaction with the δ subunit and/or subunit I–II when CF₁ becomes bound to a thylakoid membrane.     

Expression of subunits a and c of the sodium-dependent ATPase of Propionigenium modestum in Escherichia coli

The aim of the present study was to construct functional hybrid ATPases consisting of all Escherichia coli ATPase subunits excepts the F₀ subunits a or c which were replaced by the respective subunits of the Propionigenium modestum ATPase. This would give valuable information on the subunit(s) conferring the coupling ion specificity. Plasmids were constructed that carried the gene for subunit c (uncE) or subunit a (uncB) behind a tac promoter. These plasmids were transformed into E. coli strains which differed with respect to the unc operon and the expression of the P. modestum genes was verified biochemically. Enhanced expression of the P. modestum genes led to strong growth inhibition of all E. coli strains tested. However, the expressed P. modestum proteins could not functionally complement E. coli strains that lacked the homologous subunit.Abbreviations PCR Polymerase chain reaction - ACMA 9-amino-6-chloro-2-methoxyacridine - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - DCCD N,N-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide - PMSF pnenylmethyl sulfornyl fluoride - DFP dirsopropylfluorphosphat - TCA trichloroacetic acid     

The coupling of the relative movement of thea andc subunits of the F0 to the conformational changes in the F1-ATPase

F₀F₁-ATPase structural information gained from X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy has activated interest in a rotational mechanism for the F₀F₁-ATPase. Because of the subunit stoichiometry and the involvement of both thea- andc-subunits in the mechanism of proton movement, it is argued that relative movement must occur between the subunits. Various options for the arrangement and structure of the subunits involved are discussed and a mechanism proposed.     

Organization and nucleotide sequence of the atp genes encoding the ATP synthase from alkaliphilic Bacillus firmus OF4

Summary The atp operon from the extreme alkaliphile Bacillus firmus OF4 was cloned and sequenced, and shown to contain genes for the eight structural subunits of the ATP synthase, preceded by a ninth gene predicted to encode a 14 kDa hydrophobic protein. The arrangement of genes is identical to that of the atp operons from Escherichia coli, Bacillus megaterium, and thermophilic Bacillus PS3. The deduced amino acid sequences of the subunits of the enzyme are also similar to their homologs in other ATP synthases, except for several unusual substitutions, particularly in the a and c subunits. These substitutions are in domains that have been implicated in the mechanism of proton translocation through F₀-ATPase, and therefore could contribute to the gating properties of the alkaliphile ATP synthase or its capacity for proton capture.