Cytogenetic and survival adaptive responses in G1 phase human lymphocytes.

Human lymphocytes from six donors were treated with 5 cGy of X-rays followed by 200 or 400 cGy in the first G1 phase after PHA stimulation, and assayed for cytogenetic aberrations and cell survival. Four donors showed cytogenetic adaptive responses with 400 cGy, and one with both 200 cGy and 400 cGy. Both exchanges and deletions were reduced, indicating that the cytogenetic adaptive response acts by restitution of chromosome breaks. Good correlations were found between nonaberrant cells and survival, although the former were often higher than the later, especially with the 400 cGy dose. In four of six donors, 5 cGy alone had significant effects on cell survival; however, this was independent of the 5 cGy effect on high-dose-induced responses. Two donors had survival adaptive responses with 5 + 200 cGy, while none were found with the 5 + 400 cGy treatment. The comparisons between the cytogenetic and survival responses suggests that a survival adaptive response will only be seen with a sufficient increase in nonaberrant cells. To date, adaptive responses to ionizing radiation have been reported to occur in G0, G1 and late S/early G2 human lymphocytes.     

Adaptive response to 2 low doses of X-rays in human blood lymphocytes

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes exposed to a single adaptive dose of 1 cGy X-rays or 2 adaptive doses, each of 1 cGy, were found to be equally resistant to the induction of chromosome damage by subsequent challenge with a high dose of 1 Gy X-rays, as compared to cells that were not pre-exposed. They responded with a significantly reduced incidence of chromatid and isochromatid breaks. These results indicate the presence of an inducible chromosomal repair mechanism in human blood lymphocytes and confirm the observations made by earlier investigators. The incidence of chromosome damage was found to be similar in the lymphocytes pre-exposed to a single or 2 adaptive doses, suggesting that, under the conditions tested, the second adaptive dose did not offer any additional protection against the chromosome damage induced by the challenge dose.     

Cytogenetic effects of low dose radiation with different LET in human peripheral blood lymphocytes and possible mechanisms of their realization

The induction of chromosome damage by the exposure to low doses of gamma-(60)Co and accelerated carbon ions 12C in peripheral blood lymphocytes of different donors was investigated. The complex nonlinear dose-effect dependence at the range from 1 to 50-70 cGy was observed. At the doses of 1-5 cGy the cells show the highest radiosensitivity (hypersensitivity), mainly due to the chromatid-type aberration, which is typical to those spontaneously generated in the cell and believed not to be induced by the irradiation of unstimulated lymphocytes according to the classical theory of aberration formation. With the increasing dose the frequency of the aberrations decreases significantly, in some cases up to the control level. At the doses over 50-70 cGy the dose-effect curve becomes linear. The possible role of the oxidative stress, caused by radiation-induced increase in mitochondrial reactive oxigen species (ROS) release in the phenomenon of hypersensitivity (HS) at low doses is discussed as well as cytoprotective mechanisms causing the increased radioresistance at higher doses.     

Mechanism of adaptive response: Estimation of human lymphocyte adaptive response to radiation using various criteria

Blood lymphocytes of 15 healthy donors have been investigated for their ability to reduce radiosensitivity after low-dose irradiation-radio-induced adaptive response (AR). The frequency of unstable chromosome aberrations was used to evaluate cell radiosensitivity after the irradiation of cells in low adaptive (5 cGy) and high challenge (1 Gy) doses in comparison with the effect of challenge irradiation only. Three indexes have been used, i.e., (A) the frequency of cells with aberrations per total analyzed cell, (B) the number of chromosome aberrations per one cell, (C) and the number of chromosome aberrations per one aberrant cell. It was found that the donors can be divided in the four following groups: 1. AR was not estimated any of the indexes used; 2. AR was estimated with indexes A and B, but not C; 3. AR was shown by indexes B and C; 4. AR was evident with all three indexes. The generally accepted AR repair model only explains the appearance of group-3 and-4 donors, but not group-2. For the purpose of understanding the AR mechanisms and the difference in AR estimations with various criteria, the metaphase distribution by the number of chromosome aberrations has been analyzed for each donor. It was shown that, in group-2 donors, the number of cells without aberrations after adaptive and challenge irradiations was significantly higher than after irradiation with a challenge dose only. Thus, in this group, AR is formed as a result of the changed frequency of cells in the 0 class (population shift). A similar shift is observed in the metaphase distribution in the donors of group 4, but not in group 3. The data obtained show that AR is probably a result of several processes, including the activation of the reparation of premutational genome damages, population shifts evident in the frequency of undamaged cells, and, possibly, the activation of apoptotic cell death. The complex character of AR is reflected to different degrees in each criterion of radiosensitivity.     

The mechanisms of adaptive response. Estimation of capacity of human blood lymphocytes to radiation adaptive response using different criteria

Blood lymphocytes of 15 healthy donors have been investigated for the ability to decrease their radiosensitivity after treatment with low dose irradiation named radioinduced adaptive response (AR). The unstable chromosome aberrations were used to evaluate the radiosensitivity change after irradiation of cells with low adaptive dose (5 cGy) and subsequent high challenge dose (1.0 Gy) in comparison with the effect of challenge irradiation only. Three indexes were used: the frequency of cells with aberrations in all analyzed cells (A), the number of chromosome aberrations per cell (B) and the number of chromosome aberrations per one aberrant cell (C). It has been discovered that all donors examined can be divided into four groups: 1--individuals which cells did not show AR by all indexes used; 2--individuals which cells showed AR by indexes A and B, but not C; 3--AR was demonstrated by indexes B and C; 4--AR was confirmed by all three indexes. Generally accepted repair model for AR formation explains only the case of donor groups 3 and 4, but can not explain the mechanism leading to the case of group 2. For understanding this mechanism, the distribution of metaphases by the number of chromosome aberrations per cell was analyzes for each donor. It was shown that the part of cells without aberrations in group 2 donors increased significantly after treatment with the adaptive and challenge irradiation in comparison with that after irradiation with challenge dose only. The conclusion is that in this case AR is formed as a result of change in the frequency 0 cell class--population shift. The analogous shift was observed in the distributions of metaphases for all donors of the group 4, but was absent in the group 3 donors. The data obtained suggest that AR of blood lymphocytes might be a result of several processes: activation of submutational genome damage repair; population shifts manifested by the change in the part of undamaged cells; and, possibly, activation of apoptotic cell death. The complex nature of AR affects each of radiosensitivity evaluation criteria to a different extent.     

On the response of a cell population to low-dose irradiation

The cell composition of a population of human blood lymphocytes was studied after irradiation at doses of 5 cGy, 1.0 Gy and 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy and the use of a cytokinesis block. The frequencies of uni-, bi- and multinucleate lymphocytes with and without micronuclei (MN) were taken into account. By the standard criterion the frequency of binucleate lymphocytes with MN among binucleate lymphocytes--the donors were characterized as follows: in with reduction of radiosensitivity after irradiation with 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy as compared to the values of radiosensitivity after irradiation with 1.0 Gy only (an adaptive response, AR); in with no change of radiosensitivity after exposure to these doses (no AR); and with an increased ofradiosensitivity after exposure to these doses (syndrome of increased radiosensitivity, IRS). It was found that upon exposure to 1.0 Gy and 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy in some donors with AR, without AR and with IRS the total numbers of damaged cells in the population and the number of binucleate cells with MN were equal. This result calls in question the involvement of the repair mechanism in the alteration of radiosensitivity of lymphocytes in these donors. It was also observed that in the same donors a simultaneous increase (or a decrease in the case of IRS) of the portion of undamaged binucleate cells in the population took place. Our results demonstrate the existence of a new, populational, mechanism involved in the alteration of radiosensitivity after exposure to the adaptive and challenge doses.     

Relationship between radiation induced adaptive response in human fibroblasts and changes in chromatin conformation

Chromatin conformation changes in the normal human fibroblasts VH-10 were studied by the method of anomalous viscosity time dependence (AVTD). Gamma-irradiation of cells in a dose range of 0.1–3 Gy caused an increase in maximal viscosity of cell lysates. Conversely, irradiation of cells with low doses of 0.5 or 2 cGy resulted in a decrease in the AVTD peaks with a maximum effect approximately 40 min after irradiation. The same exposure conditions were used to study a possible adaptive effect of low doses, measured by changes in cell survival. A primary dose of 2 cGy caused significant modification of cell response to a challenge dose. Approximately 20% protection to challenge doses of 0.5 Gy (p < 0.003), 2 Gy (p < 0.02) and 2.5 Gy (p < 0.002) was observed. However, the direction of this effect (adaptation or synergism) was found to be dependent on a challenge dose. The combined effect of 2 cGy and 1 Gy was significantly synergistic, while no modification was observed for 1.5 Gy and 3 Gy. A partial correlation was found between the AVTD changes and cell survival when the combined effect of a primary dose of 2 cGy and challenge dose was examined. The dose of 2 cGy alone increased survival by 16% (p < 0.0003). These results suggest that the low-dose induced effects on survival may be related to chromatin reorganization.     

Melanin decreases clastogenic effects of ionizing radiation in human and mouse somatic cells and modifies the radioadaptive response

Melanin’s influence on the chromosome aberration frequency induced by radiation in human lymphocytes and mouse bone marrow cells has been studied. We revealed earlier that melanin significantly decreases the frequencies of different radiation-induced mutations in animal germ cells. Melanin protection in somatic cells has been found to be less effective. The melanin effect in somatic cells depends on radiation dose: the lower the damage level, the better the melanin protection. In order to determine the influence of melanin at low radiation doses, the adaptive response was investigated in mouse bone marrow cells in vivo. The level of chromosome aberrations in these cells after fractionated irradiation of 0.2 Gy+1.5 Gy with a 4-h interval was about half that after a single dose of 1.7 Gy. If melanin was injected prior to irradiation, the aberration level decreased by a factor of about two in both cases. This observed result may be due to the potential radioprotective effect of melanin and to the absence of any adaptive response, whereas in the case of melanin application between the priming and challenge doses, the combined effect of the adaptive response as well as melanin protection resulted in a 4-fold decrease of chromosome aberrations. These results allow us to draw the following conclusions: adaptive response can be prevented by a radioprotector such as melanin, and melanin is capable of completely removing low-dose radiation effects. Received: 2 December 1998 / Accepted in revised form: 15 September 1999     

Aspects of the adaptive response to very low doses of radiation and other agents

When human lymphocytes and other cells are pre-exposed to very low doses of ionizing radiation and subsequently exposed to a high dose, less genetic damage, i.e., fewer chromosome aberrations, is found than is observed in cells that had not been pre-exposed. This has been termed the adaptive response and has been attributed to the induction of a repair mechanism by the low dose exposure. Several experiments have now been carried out on this adaptive response to better characterize the phenomenon. (A) Experiments with differential display of mRNAs indicate that human lymphocytes exposed to 2 cGy of X-rays have somewhat different mRNAs expressed than do unexposed cells. This is providing access to DNA that might be involved in adaptation. (B) Other experiments with embryonic cells from transgenic mice that are deficient in superoxide dismutase (SOD) have shown that the adaptive response is unrelated to the amount of SOD in the cells, and thus is independent of superoxide radicals. (C) Experiments in which very low doses of various restriction enzymes were electroporated into human lymphocytes have shown that low levels of double-strand DNA breaks alone are able to induce the adaptive response. (D) Experiments in which human male lymphocytes (XY chromosome constitution) and human female lymphocytes (XX chromosome constitution) were cocultivated have shown that adaptation is not caused by a change in the rate of cell progression to mitosis after a challenge dose, and is a further indication that cell stage sensitivity is not a factor in the adaptive response.     

Cytogenetic effects of low-dose radiation with different LET in human peripheral blood lymphocytes

Chromosome damage and the spectrum of aberrations induced by low doses of γ-irradiation, X-rays and accelerated carbon ions (195 MeV/u, LET 16.6 keV/μm) in peripheral blood lymphocytes of four donors were studied. G₀-lymphocytes were exposed to 1–100 cGy, stimulated by PHA, and analyzed for chromosome aberrations at 48 h post-irradiation by the metaphase method. A complex nonlinear dose–effect dependence was observed over the range of 1 to 50 cGy. At 1–7 cGy, the cells showed the highest radiosensitivity per unit dose (hypersensitivity, HRS), which was mainly due to chromatid-type aberration. According to the classical theory of aberration formation, chromatid-type aberrations should not be induced by irradiation of unstimulated lymphocytes. With increasing dose, the frequency of aberrations decreased significantly, and in some cases it even reached the control level. At above 50 cGy the dose–effect curves became linear. In this dose range, the frequency of chromatid aberrations remained at a low constant level, while the chromosome-type aberrations increased linearly with dose. The high yield of chromatid-type aberrations observed in our experiments at low doses confirms the idea that the molecular mechanisms which underlie the HRS phenotype may differ from the classical mechanisms of radiation-induced aberration formation. The data presented, as well as recent literature data on bystander effects and genetic instability expressed as chromatid-type aberrations on a chromosomal level, are discussed with respect to possible common mechanisms underlying all low-dose phenomena.     

Evidence that N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine induces adaptive response in Bacillus thuringiensis

Bacillus thuringiensis is shown to have an inducible error-free repair system for alkylation damage as found in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. Growth of cells in the presence of low concentrations of N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) induces an adaptive response which is characterized by an increase in resistance to killing and mutagenesis by challenge with higher concentrations of MNNG. In addition, we have noted with interest that adaptive low doses seem to produce lesions at a rate sufficient to induce an increase of mutation frequency, and inhibition of cell division. The possibility of an interaction between SOS and adaptive responses with these low doses of MNNG is discussed.     

The saturated repair kinetics of Chinese hamster V79 cells suggests a damage accumulation--interaction model of cell killing

The aim of this study is to determine whether the repair process in log-phase Chinese hamster V79 cells exposed to X rays is unsaturated, saturable, or saturated. The kinetics of recovery from damage induced by 2 to 14 Gy of 250 kVp X rays was studied by treating cells with 0.5 M hypertonic saline for 20 min at different postirradiation repair intervals. From the kinetic data, the repair half-time (t1/2), the repair time (time needed to attain maximal survival), and the recovery ratio were calculated. The results show that the t1/2 (1.42 min/Gy) and the repair time (6.04 min/Gy) increase linearly with dose, the logarithm of the recovery ratio increases linear-quadratically with dose, and the D0 increases linearly with repair interval at a rate of 2.4 cGy/min. From these results we suggest a model: the repair of damage (undefined lesions) necessary for cell survival is effected by a repair process (t 1/2 of 1.42 min/Gy) which is saturated at doses as low as 2.4 cGy; repair saturation leads to a dose-dependent accumulation of repairable lesions; and interaction among accumulated repairable lesions results in the induction of irreparable (lethal) lesions. We call this the accumulation-interaction model of cell killing by low-LET radiation.     

Critical level of radiation damage of root apical meristem and mechanisms for its recovery in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pisum sativum</Emphasis> L.

Dose dependencies of growth and cytogenetic values have been built to determine that the critical level of root apical meristem damage induced by cute irradiation within the range from 2 to 20 Gy. Causal relationships between frequency of chromosome aberrations and death of tissue, organ, and organism have been analyzed. The critical level of damage in the stem apical meristem and root of seedlings was defined as 44–48% of aberrant anaphase. The exceeding of this level results in launch of a suicidal program in the meristem through induction of multiaberrant damages and interphase cell death. It is assumed that cell competition between clones of nonaberrant, aberrant with single damages, and multiaberrant cells plays an important role in mechanisms of recovery. The exceeding of a 50% level of aberrations results in total or partial recovery of root apical meristem by regeneration. Approximately 70% of chromosome aberrations are the critical index of root apical meristem damage which still allow its regeneration. However, these local regeneration processes are insufficient for recovery of morphogenesis and survival of seedlings.     

The relationship between DNA and chromosome damage after bleomycin treatment: dose-response measurements

The molecular basis for chromosome aberration formation has been studied using the sensitive techniques of premature chromosome condensation and DNA alkaline elution. The dose response of Chinese hamster ovary cells to bleomycin treatment at the DNA and chromosome levels was compared. Each DNA elution curve showed a 2-component profile, with a more sensitive component apparent at low doses. The chromosome aberration curves also exhibited a 2-component profile when determined in G2-PCC; however, this phenomenon was less apparent when chromosome damage was enumerated in mitotic figures. These results suggest that differential sensitivity to bleomycin exists within the cellular chromatin. The effect of dose rate on aberration formation was examined by administering bleomycin at 2 concentrations that, with different treatment times, yielded equivalent amounts of DNA damage. The chromatid exchange rate was independent of dose rate, suggesting that rapidly repaired DNA lesions are not involved in the formation of exchanges.     

Cytogenetic effects of low doses of radiation in mammalian cells: analysis of the hypersensitivity phenomenon and induced resistance

The induction of cytogenetic damage after irradiation of chinese hamster cells and human melanoma cells within a dose range 1-200 cGy was studied. The anaphase and metaphase analysis of chromosome damage and micronuclei test were applied. The hypersensitivity (HRS) at doses below 20 cGy and the increased radio-resistence at higher doses (IR) were shown with all cytogenetic critheria for both cell lines. The phenomenon of HRS/IR was reproduced in synchronic as well as in a synchronic population of chinese hamster cells. This fact shows that HRS was caused by high radiosensitivity of all cells and can not be explained by any differential sensitivity of cells in different phase of the cell cycle. So it was supposed that the increasing radio-resistence is determined by the inclusion of the inducible repair processes in all cells. This conclusion consents with the facts, that there was no evidence of HRS on dose-effect curves and that some parts of pre-existent damage was repaired after preliminary irradiation with low doses (1-20 cGy) which induce repair processes. It can be concluded that same inducible repair processes an analogous in mechanisms underlying in the base of HRS/IR phenomenon and adaptive response.     

Human lymphocytes exposed to low doses of X-rays are less susceptible to radiation-induced mutagenesis

Human lymphocytes exposed to low doses of X-rays become refractory to the subsequent induction of chromosomal damage by high doses of radiation (Shadley and Wolff, 1987). The current study was designed to test the effect of pretreatment of human T-lymphocytes with a low dose of X-rays on the induction of mutations at the hprt locus by a subsequent challenge dose. When cells were exposed to 1 cGy X-rays 24 h after phytohemagglutinin stimulation, the yield of mutations induced by a 300 cGy X-ray dose given 16 h later was reduced by approximately 70% from the control level of X-ray-induced mutations. This indicates that this previously described adaptive response to low dose X-rays also results in lymphocytes becoming refractory to the induction of gene mutations.     

Chromosome aberrations and reproductive death of mammalian cells. Quantitative relations between these effects

The data reported in the literature concerning the relationship between the yield of chromosome aberrations and the number of cells without aberrations, on the one hand, and the survival rate of mammalian cells, on the other, with a reference to different types of radiation are reviewed in this article. It is shown that the number of chromosome aberrations per one lethal damage, as to the results obtained by different authors, ranges from 0.5 to 1.5, this discrepancy is mainly due to different methods applied by different authors, and at least one chromosome aberration corresponds to a lethal damage caused by irradiation in the G1 phase.     

Comparison of Three Inbred Mouse Strains with Respect to General and Genetic Radiosensitivity

The radiosensitivities of three mouse strains (BALB/cLacY, C3H/SnY, and 101/HY) have been compared using the following parameters: survival after irradiation at a dose of 6–7 Gy, chromosome aberration frequency in bone marrow cells after irradiation at a dose of 1.5 Gy, and the change in testis weight and frequency of abnormal sperm heads (ASHs) after irradiation at doses from 0.5 to 4 Gy. Strain BALB/c is the most radiosensitive with respect to the survival and chromosome aberration frequency in the bone marrow but the most resistant with respect to the change in testis weight and the frequency of abnormal sperm heads. Strain 101/HY was the most resistant with respect to survival and chromosome aberration frequency in bone marrow after irradiation but the most radiosensitive with respect to testis damage.     

Evidence that N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine induces adaptive response in Bacillus thuringiensis

Bacillus thuringiensis is shown to have an inducible error-free repair system for alkylation damage as found in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. Growth of cells in the presence of low concentrations of N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) induces an adaptive response which is characterized by an increase in resistance to killing and mutagenesis by challenge with higher concentrations of MNNG. In addition, we have noted with interest that adaptive low doses seem to produce lesions at a rate sufficient to induce an increase of mutation frequency, and inhibition of cell division. The possibility of an interaction between SOS and adaptive responses with these low doses of MNNG is discussed.     

Comparison of three inbred lines of mice by overall and genetic radiosensitivity

The radiosensitivities of three mouse strains (BALB/cLacY, C3H/SnY, and 101/HY) have been compared using the following parameters: survival after irradiation at a dose of 6-7 Gy, chromosome aberration frequency in bone marrow cells after irradiation at a dose of 1.5 Gy, and the change in testis weight and frequency of abnormal sperm heads (ASHs) after irradiation at doses from 0.5 to 4 Gy. Strain BALB/c is the most radiosensitive with respect to the survival and chromosome aberration frequency in the bone marrow but the most resistant with respect to the change in testis weight and the frequency of abnormal sperm heads. Strain 101/HY was the most resistant with respect to survival and chromosome aberration frequency in bone marrow after irradiation but the most radiosensitive with respect to testis damage.