Pore formation: an ancient yet complex form of attack

Bacteria, as well as higher organisms such as sea anemones or earthworms, have developed sophisticated virulence factors such as the pore-forming toxins (PFTs) to mount their attack against the host. One of the most fascinating aspects of PFTs is that they can adopt a water-soluble form at the beginning of their lifetime and become an integral transmembrane protein in the membrane of the target cells. There is a growing understanding of the sequence of events and the various conformational changes undergone by these toxins in order to bind to the host cell surface, to penetrate the cell membranes and to achieve pore formation. These points will be addressed in this review.     

Real-Time Visualization of Assembling of a Sphingomyelin-Specific Toxin on Planar Lipid Membranes

Pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are soluble proteins that can oligomerize on the cell membrane and induce cell death by membrane insertion. PFT oligomers sometimes form hexagonal close-packed (hcp) structures on the membrane. Here, we show the assembling of the sphingomyelin (SM)-binding PFT, lysenin, into an hcp structure after oligomerization on SM/cholesterol membrane. This process was monitored by high-speed atomic force microscopy. Hcp assembly was driven by reorganization of lysenin oligomers such as association/dissociation and rapid diffusion along the membrane. Besides rapid association/dissociation of oligomers, the height change for some oligomers, possibly resulting from conformational changes in lysenin, could also be visualized. After the entire membrane surface was covered with a well-ordered oligomer lattice, the lysenin molecules were firmly bound on the membrane and the oligomers neither dissociated nor diffused. Our results reveal the dynamic nature of the oligomers of a lipid-binding toxin during the formation of an hcp structure. Visualization of this dynamic process is essential for the elucidation of the assembling mechanism of some PFTs that can form ordered structures on the membrane.     

Real-Time Visualization of Assembling of a Sphingomyelin-Specific Toxin on Planar Lipid Membranes

Pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are soluble proteins that can oligomerize on the cell membrane and induce cell death by membrane insertion. PFT oligomers sometimes form hexagonal close-packed (hcp) structures on the membrane. Here, we show the assembling of the sphingomyelin (SM)-binding PFT, lysenin, into an hcp structure after oligomerization on SM/cholesterol membrane. This process was monitored by high-speed atomic force microscopy. Hcp assembly was driven by reorganization of lysenin oligomers such as association/dissociation and rapid diffusion along the membrane. Besides rapid association/dissociation of oligomers, the height change for some oligomers, possibly resulting from conformational changes in lysenin, could also be visualized. After the entire membrane surface was covered with a well-ordered oligomer lattice, the lysenin molecules were firmly bound on the membrane and the oligomers neither dissociated nor diffused. Our results reveal the dynamic nature of the oligomers of a lipid-binding toxin during the formation of an hcp structure. Visualization of this dynamic process is essential for the elucidation of the assembling mechanism of some PFTs that can form ordered structures on the membrane.     

Dual chaperone role of the C-terminal propeptide in folding and oligomerization of the pore-forming toxin aerolysin

Throughout evolution, one of the most ancient forms of aggression between cells or organisms has been the production of proteins or peptides affecting the permeability of the target cell membrane. This class of virulence factors includes the largest family of bacterial toxins, the pore-forming toxins (PFTs). PFTs are bistable structures that can exist in a soluble and a transmembrane state. It is unclear what drives biosynthetic folding towards the soluble state, a requirement that is essential to protect the PFT-producing cell. Here we have investigated the folding of aerolysin, produced by the human pathogen Aeromonas hydrophila, and more specifically the role of the C-terminal propeptide (CTP). By combining the predictive power of computational techniques with experimental validation using both structural and functional approaches, we show that the CTP prevents aggregation during biosynthetic folding. We identified specific residues that mediate binding of the CTP to the toxin. We show that the CTP is crucial for the control of the aerolysin activity, since it protects individual subunits from aggregation within the bacterium and later controls assembly of the quaternary pore-forming complex at the surface of the target host cell. The CTP is the first example of a C-terminal chain-linked chaperone with dual function.     

Structure-function relationships of a membrane pore forming toxin revealed by reversion mutagenesis

Cyt2Aa1 is a haemolytic membrane pore forming toxin produced by Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kyushuensis. To investigate membrane pore formation by this toxin, second-site revertants of an inactive mutant toxin Cyt2Aa1-I150A were generated by random mutagenesis using error-prone PCR. The decrease in side chain length caused by the replacement of isoleucine by alanine at position 150 in the alphaD-beta4 loop results in the loss of important van der Waals contacts that exist in the native protein between I150 and K199 and L203 on alphaE. 28 independent revertants of I150A were obtained and their relative toxicity can be explained by the position of the residue in the structure and the effect of the mutation on side-chain interactions. Analysis of these revertants revealed that residues on alphaA, alphaB, alphaC, alphaD and the loops between alphaA and alphaB, alphaD and beta5, beta6 and beta7 are important in pore formation. These residues are on the surface of the molecule suggesting that they may participate in membrane binding and toxin oligomerization. Changing the properties of the amino acid side-chains of these residues could affect the conformational changes required to transform the water-soluble toxin into the membrane insertion competent state.     

Arresting and releasing Staphylococcal alpha-hemolysin at intermediate stages of pore formation by engineered disulfide bonds

alpha-Hemolysin (alphaHL) is secreted by Staphylococcus aureus as a water-soluble monomer that assembles into a heptamer to form a transmembrane pore on a target membrane. The crystal structures of the LukF water-soluble monomer and the membrane-bound alpha-hemolysin heptamer show that large conformational changes occur during assembly. However, the mechanism of assembly and pore formation is still unclear, primarily because of the difficulty in obtaining structural information on assembly intermediates. Our goal is to use disulfide bonds to selectively arrest and release alphaHL from intermediate stages of the assembly process and to use these mutants to test mechanistic hypotheses. To accomplish this, we created four double cysteine mutants, D108C/K154C (alphaHL-A), M113C/K147C (alphaHL-B), H48C/ N121C (alphaHL-C), I5C/G130C (alphaHL-D), in which disulfide bonds may form between the pre-stem domain and the beta-sandwich domain to prevent pre-stem rearrangement and membrane insertion. Among the four mutants, alphaHL-A is remarkably stable, is produced at a level at least 10-fold greater than that of the wild-type protein, is monomeric in aqueous solution, and has hemolytic activity that can be regulated by the presence or absence of reducing agents. Cross-linking analysis showed that alphaHL-A assembles on a membrane into an oligomer, which is likely to be a heptamer, in the absence of a reducing agent, suggesting that oxidized alphaHL-A is halted at a heptameric prepore state. Therefore, conformational rearrangements at positions 108 and 154 are critical for the completion of alphaHL assembly but are not essential for membrane binding or for formation of an oligomeric prepore intermediate.     

Conformational states of the water-soluble fragment of cytochrome b5. I. pH-induced denaturation

Cytochrome b5 is a membrane protein that comprises two fragments: one is water-soluble and heme-containing, and the other is hydrophobic and membrane-embedded. The function of electron transfer is performed by the former whose crystal structure is known; however, its conformational states when in the membrane field and interacting with other proteins are still to be studied. Previously, we proposed water-alcohol mixtures for modeling the effect of membrane surface on proteins, and used this approach to study the conformational behavior of positively charged cytochrome c as well as relatively neutral retinol-binding protein also functioning in the field of negatively charged membrane. The current study describes the conformational behavior of the negatively charged water-soluble fragment of cytochrome b5 as dependent on pH. Decreasing pH was shown to transform the fragment state from native to intermediate, similar to the molten globule reported earlier for other proteins in aqueous solutions: at pH 3.0, the fragment preserved a pronounced secondary structure and compactness but lost its rigid tertiary structure. A possible role of this intermediate state in cytochrome b5 functioning is discussed.     

Beta-barrel membrane protein folding and structure viewed through the lens of alpha-hemolysin

The beta-barrel is a transmembrane structural motif commonly encountered in bacterial outer membrane proteins and pore-forming toxins (PFTs). Alpha-hemolysin (alphaHL) is a cytotoxin secreted by Staphylococcus aureus that assembles from a water-soluble monomer to form a membrane-bound heptameric beta-barrel on the surface of susceptible cells, perforating the cell membranes, leading to cell death and lysis. The mechanism of heptamer assembly, which has been studied extensively, occurs in a stepwise manner, and the structures of the initial, monomeric form and final, membrane-embedded pore are known. The toxin's ability to assemble from an aqueous, hydrophilic species to a membrane-inserted oligomer is of interest in understanding the assembly of PFTs in particular and the folding and structure of beta-barrel membrane proteins in general. Here we review the structures of the monomeric and heptamer states of LukF and alphaHL, respectively, the mechanism of toxin assembly, and the relationships between alphaHL and nontoxin beta-barrel membrane proteins.     

Single-particle cryo-EM reveals conformational variability of the oligomeric VCC β-barrel pore in a lipid bilayer

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a water-soluble, membrane-damaging, pore-forming toxin (PFT) secreted by pathogenic V. cholerae, which causes eukaryotic cell death by altering the plasma membrane permeability. VCC self-assembles on the cell surface and undergoes a dramatic conformational change from prepore to heptameric pore structure. Over the past few years, several high-resolution structures of detergent-solubilized PFTs have been characterized. However, high-resolution structural characterization of small β-PFTs in a lipid environment is still rare. Therefore, we used single-particle cryo-EM to characterize the structure of the VCC oligomer in large unilamellar vesicles, which is the first atomic-resolution cryo-EM structure of VCC. From our study, we were able to provide the first documented visualization of the rim domain amino acid residues of VCC interacting with lipid membrane. Furthermore, cryo-EM characterization of lipid bilayer–embedded VCC suggests interesting conformational variabilities, especially in the transmembrane channel, which could have a potential impact on the pore architecture and assist us in understanding the pore formation mechanism.     

β-Barrel membrane protein folding and structure viewed through the lens of α-hemolysin

The β-barrel is a transmembrane structural motif commonly encountered in bacterial outer membrane proteins and pore-forming toxins (PFTs). α-Hemolysin (αHL) is a cytotoxin secreted by Staphylococcus aureus that assembles from a water-soluble monomer to form a membrane-bound heptameric β-barrel on the surface of susceptible cells, perforating the cell membranes, leading to cell death and lysis. The mechanism of heptamer assembly, which has been studied extensively, occurs in a stepwise manner, and the structures of the initial, monomeric form and final, membrane-embedded pore are known. The toxin's ability to assemble from an aqueous, hydrophilic species to a membrane-inserted oligomer is of interest in understanding the assembly of PFTs in particular and the folding and structure of β-barrel membrane proteins in general. Here we review the structures of the monomeric and heptamer states of LukF and αHL, respectively, the mechanism of toxin assembly, and the relationships between αHL and nontoxin β-barrel membrane proteins.     

Modulation of free energy landscapes as a strategy for the design of antimicrobial peptides

Computational design of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) is a promising area of research for developing novel agents against drug-resistant bacteria. AMPs are present naturally in many organisms, from bacteria to humans, a time-tested mechanism that makes them attractive as effective antibiotics. Depending on the environment, AMPs can exhibit α-helical or β-sheet conformations, a mix of both, or lack secondary structure; they can be linear or cyclic. Prediction of their structures is challenging but critical for rational design. Promising AMP leads can be developed using essentially two approaches: traditional modeling of the physicochemical mechanisms that determine peptide behavior in aqueous and membrane environments and knowledge-based, e.g., machine learning (ML) techniques, that exploit ever-growing AMP databases. Here, we explore the conformational landscapes of two recently ML-designed AMPs, characterize the dependence of these landscapes on the medium conditions, and identify features in peptide and membrane landscapes that mediate protein-membrane association. For both peptides, we observe greater conformational diversity in an aqueous solvent than in a less polar solvent, and one peptide is seen to alter its conformation more dramatically than the other upon the change of solvent. Our results support the view that structural rearrangement in response to environmental changes is central to the mechanism of membrane-structure disruption by linear peptides. We expect that the design of AMPs by ML will benefit from the incorporation of peptide conformational substates as quantified here with molecular simulations.

     

Pore-forming toxins induce multiple cellular responses promoting survival

Pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are secreted proteins that contribute to the virulence of a great variety of bacterial pathogens. They inflict one of the more disastrous damages a target cell can be exposed to: disruption of plasma membrane integrity. Since this is an ancient form of attack, which bears similarities to mechanical membrane damage, cells have evolved response pathways to these perturbations. Here, it is reported that PFTs trigger very diverse yet specific response pathways. Many are triggered by the decrease in cytoplasmic potassium, which thus emerges as a central regulator. Upon plasma membrane damage, cells activate signalling pathways aimed at restoring plasma membrane integrity and ion homeostasis. Interestingly these pathways do not require protein synthesis. Cells also trigger signalling cascades that allow them to enter a quiescent-like state, where minimal energy is consumed while waiting for plasma membrane damage to be repaired. More specifically, protein synthesis is arrested, cytosolic constituents are recycled by autophagy and energy is stored in lipid droplets.     

Conformational changes studied by cryo-electron microscopy

Biological processes involving movement, such as muscle contraction or the opening of an ion channel through a membrane, are mediated through conformational changes. These changes often occur in large and flexible macromolecular complexes. Cryo-electron microscopy provides a means of capturing different conformational states of such assemblies. Even if the resulting density maps are at low resolution, they can be combined with atomic structures of subcomplexes or isolated components determined by X-ray crystallography or NMR. This review presents a brief summary of the principles and recent advances in macromolecular structure determination by cryo-electron microscopy.     

Relative solvent accessible surface area predicts protein conformational changes upon binding

Protein interactions are often accompanied by significant changes in conformation. We have analyzed the relationships between protein structures and the conformational changes they undergo upon binding. Based upon this, we introduce a simple measure, the relative solvent accessible surface area, which can be used to predict the magnitude of binding-induced conformational changes from the structures of either monomeric proteins or bound subunits. Applying this to a large set of protein complexes suggests that large conformational changes upon binding are common. In addition, we observe considerable enrichment of intrinsically disordered sequences in proteins predicted to undergo large conformational changes. Finally, we demonstrate that the relative solvent accessible surface area of monomeric proteins can be used as a simple proxy for protein flexibility. This reveals a powerful connection between the flexibility of unbound proteins and their binding-induced conformational changes, consistent with the conformational selection model of molecular recognition.     

On the physico-chemical basis of voltage-dependent molecular gating mechanisms in biological membranes

Summary The possible nature and theoretical treatment of electric field-induced molecular processes in a membrane are examined. Special attention is given to fairly fast switching phenomena as reflected by asymmetry currents as well as ionic gating in squid axon and similar systems. The apparent charge displacement associated with the underlying mechanisms is argued to be brought about by conformational transitions of integral macromolecular structures. Under these circumstances, voltage changes can actually control the functional state of membranes by direct interference with conformational equilibria. A basic model is quantitatively discussed and shown to account for certain observed asymmetry currents. Effects due to temperature, pressure, or chemical interactions can be readily described. It is indicated how more complicated voltage-dependent membrane processes may be approached along these lines.     

Topography of helices 5-7 in membrane-inserted diphtheria toxin T domain: identification and insertion boundaries of two hydrophobic sequences that do not form a stable transmembrane hairpin

The T domain of diphtheria toxin undergoes a low pH-induced conformational change that allows it to penetrate cell membranes. T domain hydrophobic helices 8 and 9 can adopt two conformations, one close to the membrane surface (P state) and a second in which they apparently form a transmembrane hairpin (TM state). We have now studied T domain helices 5-7, a second cluster of hydrophobic helices, using Cys-scanning mutagenesis. After fluorescently labeling a series of Cys residues, penetration into a non-polar environment, accessibility to externally added antibodies, and relative depth in the bilayer were monitored. It was found that helices 5-7 insert shallowly in the P state and deeply in the TM state. Thus, the conformational changes in helices 5-7 are both similar and somehow linked to those in helices 8 and 9. The boundaries of deeply inserting sequences were also identified. One deeply inserted segment was found to span residues 270 to 290, which overlaps helix 5, and a second spanned residues 300 to 320, which includes most of helix 6 and all of helix 7. This indicates that helices 6 and 7 form a continuous hydrophobic segment despite their separation by a Pro-containing kink. Additionally, it is found that in the TM state some residues in the hydrophilic loop between helices 5 and 6 become more highly exposed than they are in the P state. Their exposure to external solution in the TM state indicates that helices 5-7 do not form a stable transmembrane hairpin. However, helix 5 and/or helices 6 plus 7 could form transmembrane structures that are in equilibrium with non-transmembrane states, or be kinetically prevented from forming a transmembrane structure. How helices 5-7 might influence the mechanism by which the T domain aids translocation of the diphtheria toxin A chain across membranes is discussed.     

The MACPF/CDC family of pore-forming toxins

Pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are commonly associated with bacterial pathogenesis. In eukaryotes, however, PFTs operate in the immune system or are deployed for attacking prey (e.g. venoms). This review focuses upon two families of globular protein PFTs: the cholesterol-dependent cytolysins (CDCs) and the membrane attack complex/perforin superfamily (MACPF). CDCs are produced by Gram-positive bacteria and lyse or permeabilize host cells or intracellular organelles during infection. In eukaryotes, MACPF proteins have both lytic and non-lytic roles and function in immunity, invasion and development. The structure and molecular mechanism of several CDCs are relatively well characterized. Pore formation involves oligomerization and assembly of soluble monomers into a ring-shaped pre-pore which undergoes conformational change to insert into membranes, forming a large amphipathic transmembrane β-barrel. In contrast, the structure and mechanism of MACPF proteins has remained obscure. Recent crystallographic studies now reveal that although MACPF and CDCs are extremely divergent at the sequence level, they share a common fold. Together with biochemical studies, these structural data suggest that lytic MACPF proteins use a CDC-like mechanism of membrane disruption, and will help understand the roles these proteins play in immunity and development.     

Conformational States of the Water-Soluble Fragment of Cytochrome b5. I. pH-Induced Denaturation

Cytochrome b ₅ is a membrane protein that comprises two fragments: one is water-soluble and heme-containing, and the other is hydrophobic and membrane-embedded. The function of electron transfer is performed by the former whose crystal structure is known; however, its conformational states when in the membrane field and interacting with other proteins are still to be studied. Previously, we proposed water–alcohol mixtures for modeling the effect of membrane surface on proteins, and used this approach to study the conformational behavior of positively charged cytochrome c as well as relatively neutral retinol-binding protein also functioning in the field of a negatively charged membrane. The current study describes the conformational behavior of the negatively charged water-soluble fragment of cytochrome b ₅ as dependent on pH. Decreasing pH was shown to transform the fragment state from native to intermediate, similar to the molten globule reported earlier for other proteins in aqueous solutions: at pH 3.0, the fragment preserved a pronounced secondary structure and compactness but lost its rigid tertiary structure. A possible role of this intermediate state in cytochrome b ₅ functioning is discussed.     

Crystal structures and electron micrographs of fungal volvatoxin A2

Membrane adhesion and insertion of protein are essential to all organisms, but the underlying mechanisms remain largely unknown. Membrane pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are potential model systems for studying these mechanisms. We have determined the crystal structures of volvatoxin A2 (VVA2), a fungal PFT from Volvariella volvacea, using Br-multiple-wavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD). The VVA2 structures obtained at pH 4.6, pH 5.5 and pH 6.5 were refined to resolutions of 1.42 A, 2.6 A and 3.2 A, respectively. The structures reveal that the VVA2 monomer contains a single alpha/beta domain. Most of the VVA2 surface is occupied by its oligomerization motif and two putative heparin-binding motifs. Residues Ala91 to Ala101 display several conformations at different pH values, which might be under the control of His87. We also found that the shape of one putative heparin-binding motif in VVA2 appears similar to those found in fibroblast growth factors, and the other one displays a linear polypeptide. Our results suggest several possible intermediates of protein assembly in solution and protein adhering to cell membranes before conformational changes. The electron micrographs of VVA2 molecules in solution, at a protein concentration of 1 microg ml(-1), show that they can assemble into filament-like or braid-like oligomers in a pH-dependent way. In addition, the arc-shaped VVA2 structure obtained at pH 6.5 suggests that VVA2 could form a two-layered helical oligomer with 18 subunits per turn. The structures presented here could be used to elucidate the pore-formation mechanisms of VVA2 and its structural neighbors, Cyt toxins from Bacillus thuringiensis.     

Rabies virus-induced membrane fusion.

Rabies virus is a member of the rhabdovirus family. It enters cells by a process of receptor mediated endocytosis. Following this step, the viral envelope fuses with the endosomal membrane to allow release of the viral nucleocapsid into the cytoplasm. Fusion is induced by the low pH of the endosomal compartment and is mediated by the single viral glycoprotein G, a homotrimeric integral membrane protein. Rabies virus fusion properties are related to different conformational states of G. By different biochemical and biophysical approaches, it has been demonstrated that G can assume at least three different states: the native (N) state detected at the viral surface above pH 7, the activated (A) hydrophobic state which interacts with the target membrane as a first step of the fusion process, and the fusion inactive (I) conformation. Differently from other fusogenic viruses for which low pH-induced conformational changes are irreversible, there is a pH dependent equilibrium between these states, the equilibrium being shifted toward the I-state at low pH. The objective of this review is to detail recent findings on rhabdovirus-induced membrane fusion and to underline the differences that exist between this viral family and influenza virus which is the best known fusogenic virus. These differences have to be taken into consideration if one wants to have a global understanding of virus-induced membrane fusion.