Expanding the versatility of phage display I: efficient display of peptide-tags on protein VII of the filamentous phage

Background

Phage display is a platform for selection of specific binding molecules and this is a clear-cut motivation for increasing its performance. Polypeptides are normally displayed as fusions to the major coat protein VIII (pVIII), or the minor coat protein III (pIII). Display on other coat proteins such as pVII allows for display of heterologous peptide sequences on the virions in addition to those displayed on pIII and pVIII. In addition, pVII display is an alternative to pIII or pVIII display.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Here we demonstrate how standard pIII or pVIII display phagemids are complemented with a helper phage which supports production of virions that are tagged with octa FLAG, HIS₆ or AviTag on pVII. The periplasmic signal sequence required for pIII and pVIII display, and which has been added to pVII in earlier studies, is omitted altogether.

Conclusions/Significance

Tagging on pVII is an important and very useful add-on feature to standard pIII and pVII display. Any phagemid bearing a protein of interest on either pIII or pVIII can be tagged with any of the tags depending simply on choice of helper phage. We show in this paper how such tags may be utilized for immobilization and separation as well as purification and detection of monoclonal and polyclonal phage populations.     

Expanding the versatility of phage display II: improved affinity selection of folded domains on protein VII and IX of the filamentous phage

Background

Phage display is a leading technology for selection of binders with affinity for specific target molecules. Polypeptides are normally displayed as fusions to the major coat protein VIII (pVIII) or the minor coat protein III (pIII). Whereas pVIII display suffers from drawbacks such as heterogeneity in display levels and polypeptide fusion size limitations, toxicity and infection interference effects have been described for pIII display. Thus, display on other coat proteins such as pVII or pIX might be more attractive. Neither pVII nor pIX display have gained widespread use or been characterized in detail like pIII and pVIII display.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Here we present a side-by-side comparison of display on pIII with display on pVII and pIX. Polypeptides of interest (POIs) are fused to pVII or pIX. The N-terminal periplasmic signal sequence, which is required for phage integration of pIII and pVIII and that has been added to pVII and pIX in earlier studies, is omitted altogether. Although the POI display level on pIII is higher than on pVII and pIX, affinity selection with pVII and pIX display libraries is shown to be particularly efficient.

Conclusions/Significance

Display through pVII and/or pIX represent platforms with characteristics that differ from those of the pIII platform. We have explored this to increase the performance and expand the use of phage display. In the paper, we describe effective affinity selection of folded domains displayed on pVII or pIX. This makes both platforms more attractive alternatives to conventional pIII and pVIII display than they were before.     

Homodimeric peptides displayed by the major coat protein of filamentous phage

Peptide libraries displayed by filamentous bacteriophage have proven a powerful tool for the discovery of novel peptide agonists, antagonists and epitope mimics. Most phage-displayed peptides are fused to the N terminus of either the minor coat protein, pIII, or the major coat protein, pVIII. We report here that peptides containing cysteine residues, displayed as N-terminal fusions to pVIII, can form disulfide-bridged homodimers on the phage coat. Phage clones were randomly selected from libraries containing one or two fixed Cys residues, and surveyed for the presence of peptide-pVIII homodimers by SDS-PAGE analysis that involved pretreatment of the phage with reducing or thiol-modifying agents. For all phage whose recombinant peptide contained a single Cys residue, a significant fraction of the peptide-pVIII molecules were displayed as dimers on the phage coat. The dimeric form was in greater abundance than the monomer in almost all cases in which both forms could be reliably observed. Occasionally, peptides containing two Cys residues also formed dimers. These results indicate that, for a given pVIII-displayed peptide bearing a single Cys residue, a significant fraction of the peptide (>40 %) will dimerize regardless of its sequence; however, sequence constraints probably determine whether all of the peptide will dimerize. Similarly, only occasionally do peptides bearing two Cys residues form intermolecular disulfide bridges instead of intramolecular ones; this indicates that sequence constraints may also determine dimerization versus cyclization. Sucrose-gradient analysis of membranes from cells expressing pVIII fused to a peptide containing a single Cys residue showed that dimeric pVIII is present in the cell prior to its assembly onto phage. A model of the peptide-pVIII homodimer is discussed in light of existing models of the structure and assembly of the phage coat. The unique secondary structures created by the covalent association of peptides on the phage surface suggest a role for homo- and heterodimeric peptide libraries as novel sources of bioactive peptides.     

Display and release of the Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite protein using the autotransporter MisL of Salmonella enterica

The Salmonella enterica MisL (protein of membrane insertion and secretion) is an autotransporter with high homology to AIDA-I (adhesin involved in diffuse adherence) of enteropathogenic Escherichia coli. Considering that it has been reported that the MisL beta translocator domain is able to display heterologous passenger peptides to the bacterial surface, we developed a system to display proteins and release them to the external environment by means of proteolytic cleavage. Plasmids were constructed encoding 8 or 53 repeats of the NANP (Asp-Ala-Asp-Pro) tetrapeptide, which is the main B cell epitope of the Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoitic protein (CSP), fused to the the MisL beta-domain and including the recognition cleavage sequence from the E. coli OmpT surface protease. E. coli XL-10Gold and BL21(DE3) (OmpT positive and negative, respectively) and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium SL3261 (Aro A(-)) were transformed with the plasmids and, both expression and localization of the fusion proteins were assessed by Western blot, indirect immunofluorescence, and flow cytometry, using a monoclonal antibody against (NANP)(3). Higher expression of the (NANP)(8) and (NANP)(53) fusion proteins was demonstrated on the bacterial surface of the OmpT negative E. coli strains and the (NANP)(53) in the culture supernatant of E. coli XL-10Gold indicating a protease mediated cleavage. The flow cytometry analysis suggested 71 and 98% cleavage efficiency for the (NANP)(8) and (NANP)(53), respectively, in E. coli XL-10Gold. Similar results were obtained in S. enterica serovar Typhimurium SL3261, suggesting the involvement of other proteases related to OmpT. These results demonstrate that MisL may be used for the autodisplay and release of passenger proteins in attenuated Salmonella or E. coli strains, which may have several applications in vaccine design.     

Developing strategies to enhance and focus humoral immune responses using filamentous phage as a model antigen

Filamentous bacteriophage are commonly used as immunogenic carriers for peptides and proteins displayed on the phage surface. Previously, we showed that immunization with phage to which peptides had been chemically conjugated can elicit a focused anti-peptide antibody response compared with traditional carrier molecules bearing the same peptide, perhaps due to the low surface complexity of the phage. The regularity of its surface also gives the phage other advantages as a carrier, including immunological simplicity and thousands of well-defined sites for chemical conjugation. More recently, we showed that focusing of antibody responses against 'target' peptides was enhanced when the phage's molecular surface was simplified by removal of immunodominant B-cell epitopes present on the minor coat protein, pIII. The pIII-truncated variant elicits an antibody response that is largely restricted to the exposed N-terminus of the major coat protein, pVIII, and to phage-associated bacterial lipopolysaccharide, and a significant fraction of this response cross-reacts with a 12-residue peptide covering the surface-exposed region of pVIII. This allows one to track antibody responses against the phage (and any associated haptens) as they develop over time, and characterize them using a combination of serological, flow cytometric, cellular and immunogenetic assays. The filamentous phage thus provides an excellent model system for studying various aspects of the antibody response, all with the goal of targeting antibody production against weakly immunogenic peptides, proteins and carbohydrates.     

Use of bioinformatics to predict a function for the GS element in Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis

Filamentous bacteriophages are nonlytic, male-specific bacteriophages which infect Escherichia coli carrying an F-episome. The molecular mechanism of infection remains elusive, including the role of the major coat protein pVIII. In order to evaluate the contributions of major coat protein pVIII in the process of infection, two phage display libraries were generated. One library consisted of random amino acids at positions 2, 4, 5, 8, 11 and 12 of the N-terminus of major coat protein pVIII. The second library was generated by randomizing these positions as well as position 1. All these residues were previously shown to be exposed at the surface of the virions by being accessible to ligands. The infectivity of randomly selected mutant phages was analyzed. The present results demonstrate that phages modified at these positions can be correctly assembled and secreted into the exoplasm, although the efficiency was slightly lower than that of wild-type phage. Their infectivity varied greatly, and a general structural pattern underlying infectivity did not emerge. However, residual differences were observed between infectious and defective phage; in general, uncharged polar amino acids present at positions 5 and 11 of the N-terminus of pVIII reduced phage infectivity, whereas polar residues at position 8 facilitated infection. The first position of pVIII is remarkably critical for infection; when this alanine was substituted with other residues, most of the phages lost their infectivity. These results shed new light on the true complexity of random peptide pVIII phage display libraries.     

The synthesis, cloning and expression of a repeating segment of the circumsporozoite surface protein of Plasmodium falciparum

Repeats of the tetrapeptide (NANP) of the circumsporozoite protein of P. falciparum have been found to be immunogenic and possibly may act as vaccines against malaria infection. The DNA duplex encoding for eight of the (NANP) repeating unit and two of the (NVDP) unit have been synthesized, cloned and expressed in E. coli as a fused protein. The recombinant protein was shown to be immunogenic and to have the antigenic activity of the circumsporozoite.     

Construction and exploitation in model experiments of functional selection of a landscape library expressed from a phagemid

Phage display has evolved during the past 15 years as a powerful technique to select, from libraries of peptides or proteins, binders for various targets or to evolve new functions in proteins. In recent years, the knowledge acquired in phage display technology was exploited to engineer phages as vehicles for receptor-mediated gene delivery. The first vectors generated provided the proof of the concept that development of gene delivery vehicles based on phages was feasible. Results obtained showed that the level of receptor ligand display was an essential factor that determines the efficiency of transduction and suggested that phagemids might be more appropriate than phages for gene delivery. However, due to the limitations of the existing display systems, vectors constructed up to now allowed only relatively low levels of ligand display. The transduction efficiency of these vectors was relatively poor. Here, we describe the construction and optimization of a new phagemid display system that was designed to allow the functional selection of peptides that promote gene delivery from phagemids in a high display format. Peptides are displayed on every copy of the major coat protein pVIII and are expressed from the phagemid itself. The phagemid is rescued as particles by a modified R408 helper phage, deficient in pVIII production. Besides an expression cassette for pVIII, the phagemid also contains the SV40 origin of replication, the GFP gene and the neomycin resistance marker. As a model we constructed a library of octapeptides and showed that the library is amenable to selection on cos-7 cells. Several selection approaches were investigated and a preliminary analysis of the peptides selected was carried out.     

Effects of temperature and Y21M mutation on conformational heterogeneity of the major coat protein (pVIII) of filamentous bacteriophage fd

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy was used to analyze the conformational heterogeneity of the major coat protein (pVIII) of filamentous bacteriophage fd. Both one and two-dimensional solid-state NMR spectra of magnetically aligned samples of fd bacteriophage reveal that an increase in temperature and a single site substitution (Tyr21 to Met, Y21M) reduce the conformational heterogeneity observed throughout wild-type pVIII. The NMR results are consistent with previous studies indicating that conformational flexibility in the hinge-bend segment that links the amphipathic and hydrophobic helices in the membrane-bound form of the protein plays an essential role during phage assembly, which involves a major change in the tertiary, but not secondary, structure of the coat protein.     

Wavelet transforms for the characterization and detection of repeating motifs

The role of repeating motifs in protein structures is thought to be as modular building blocks which allow an economic way of constructing complex proteins. In this work novel wavelet transform analysis techniques are used to detect and characterize repeating motifs in protein sequence and structure data, where the Kyte-Doolittle hydrophobicity scale (Eta Phi) and relative accessible surface area (rASA) data provide residue information about the protein sequence and structure, respectively. We analyze a variety of repeating protein motifs, TIM barrels, propellor blades, coiled coils and leucine-rich repeat structures. Detection and characterization of these motifs is performed using techniques based on the continuous wavelet transform (CWT). Results indicate that the wavelet transform techniques developed herein are a promising approach for the detection and characterization of repeating motifs for both structural and in some instances sequence data.     

M13 bacteriophage display framework that allows sortase-mediated modification of surface-accessible phage proteins

We exploit bacterial sortases to attach a variety of moieties to the capsid proteins of M13 bacteriophage. We show that pIII, pIX, and pVIII can be functionalized with entities ranging from small molecules (e.g., fluorophores, biotin) to correctly folded proteins (e.g., GFP, antibodies, streptavidin) in a site-specific manner, and with yields that surpass those of any reported using phage display technology. A case in point is modification of pVIII. While a phage vector limits the size of the insert into pVIII to a few amino acids, a phagemid system limits the number of copies actually displayed at the surface of M13. Using sortase-based reactions, a 100-fold increase in the efficiency of display of GFP onto pVIII is achieved. Taking advantage of orthogonal sortases, we can simultaneously target two distinct capsid proteins in the same phage particle and maintain excellent specificity of labeling. As demonstrated in this work, this is a simple and effective method for creating a variety of structures, thus expanding the use of M13 for materials science applications and as a biological tool.     

Targeted gene transduction of mammalian cells expressing the HER2/neu receptor by filamentous phage.

Screening a random peptide library displayed on phage as fusion to the major capsid protein pVIII identified a ligand binding the human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) specifically. By mutating the sequence of this ligand, a "secondary" library was generated, whose panning on HER2-positive cells isolated a phage-borne peptide with increased specific binding to HER2 (phage NL1.1). The same peptide recognised HER2 specifically when expressed as an N-terminal fusion to the minor coat protein pIII. Phage NL1.1 was engineered to include a mammalian expression cassette for a reporter gene within its genome. This modified phage transduced HER2-expressing cells with very high specificity (more than 1000-fold that of parental HER2-negative cells) and with an efficiency comparable to that of chemical transfection protocols. The gene delivery process was remarkably fast, requiring less than 15 minutes incubation of phage with target cells to generate detectable levels of gene expression.     

Bottom-up assembly of hydrogels from bacteriophage and Au nanoparticles: the effect of cis- and trans-acting factors

Hydrogels have become a promising research focus because of their potential for biomedical application. Here we explore the long-range, electrostatic interactions by following the effect of trans-acting (pH) and cis-acting factors (peptide mutation) on the formation of Au-phage hydrogels. These bioinorganic hydrogels can be generated from the bottom-up assembly of Au nanoparticles (Au NP) with either native or mutant bacteriophage (phage) through electrostatic interaction of the phage pVIII major capsid proteins (pVIII). The cis-acting factor consists of a peptide extension displayed on the pVIII that mutates the phage. Our results show that pH can dictate the direct-assembly and stability of Au-phage hydrogels in spite of the differences between the native and the mutant pVIII. The first step in characterizing the interactions of Au NP with phage was to generate a molecular model that identified the charge distribution and structure of the native and mutant pVIII. This model indicated that the mutant peptide extension carried a higher positive charge relative to the native pVIII at all pHs. Next, by monitoring the Au-phage interaction by means of optical microscopy, elastic light scattering, fractal dimension analysis as well as Uv-vis and surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy, we show that the positive charge of the mutant peptide extension favors the opposite charge affinity between the phage and Au NP as the pH is decreased. These results show the versatility of this assembly method, where the stability of these hydrogels can be achieved by either adjusting the pH or by changing the composition of the phage pVIII without the need of phage display libraries.     

Expression of an exogenous peptide epitope genetically engineered in the variable domain of an immunoglobulin: implications for antibody and peptide folding.

Immunoglobulins bind antigens and express individual antigenic specificities mainly through residues located in hypervariable loops of their N-terminal domains. Hypervariable loops are kept in place by a molecular scaffold organized in a sandwich-like structure with two beta-sheets stabilized by a disulfide bridge (the immunoglobulin fold). This structural feature, together with the possibility of obtaining high level expression, extracellular secretion, easy purification and stability of the protein product, render immunoglobulin an ideal 'molecular vehicle' for the expression of exogenous peptides. Here we report on the engineering of an immunoglobulin expressing an exogenous epitope, the repetitive tetrapeptide Asn-Ala-Asn-Pro (NANP)3. By recombinant DNA techniques, we inserted three copies of the tetrapeptide (NANP)3 in the third hypervariable loop (D region) of an immunoglobulin heavy chain variable domain. We show that the engineered antibody was properly assembled and secreted. A panel of polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies, including anti-synthetic peptides and anti-(NANP)n antibodies, were used to study the molecular configuration of the engineered domain's surface. The results indicate that (i) the exogenous sequence did not appreciably alter the overall fold of the variable domain; and (ii) the inserted epitope folded with a configuration immunologically similar to the one assumed in the native protein, suggesting that short- and medium- rather than long-range interactions stabilized the structure of the (NANP)3 peptide in the folded protein. We propose this system for the expression of peptidic sequences, and their structural and functional analysis.     

Reconstitution of the M13 major coat protein and its transmembrane peptide segment on a DNA template

The major coat protein (pVIII) of M13 phage is of particular interest to structure biologists since it functions in two different environments: during assembly and infection, it interacts with the bacterial lipid bilayer, but in the phage particle, it exists as a protein capsid to protect a closed circular, single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) genome. We synthesized pVIII and a 32mer peptide consisting of the transmembrane and DNA binding domains of pVIII. The 32mer peptide displays typically an alpha-helical structure in trifluroethanol or 0.2 M octylglucoside solutions similar to pVIII. Attachment of polyethylene glycol (PEG) onto the N-terminal of 32mer increased the alpha-helical content and the peptide thermal stability. The peptides were reconstituted with DNA from a detergent solution into a discrete (<200 nm diameter) nanoparticle on both linear double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and linear ssDNA, where the linear dsDNA is used to mimic the closed circular, ssDNA in M13 phage, upon removal of the detergent. The peptide/DNA particle was an irregular and not a rod-shaped aggregate when imaged by atomic force microscopy. All three peptides underwent a structural transition from alpha-helix to beta-sheet within approximately 1 h of DNA addition to the detergent solution. There was a further decrease in alpha-helical content when the detergent was removed. The presence of anionic (such as octanoic acid) or cationic (such as 1,5-diaminopentane) molecules in the detergent mixture resulted in the retention of the peptide alpha-helical structure. Thus the interaction between the peptide and DNA in octylglucoside is driven by electrostatic forces, and peptide-peptide interactions are responsible for the transition from alpha-helix to beta-sheet conformation in pVIII and its analogues. These results suggest that the assembly process to form a rod-shaped phage is a delicate balance to maintain pVIII in an alpha-helical conformation that requires either an oriented bilayer to solubilize pVIII prior to interaction with the DNA or other phage proteins to nucleate pVIII in the alpha-helical conformation on the DNA.     

Synthetic peptide immunogens eliciting antibodies to Plasmodium falciparum sporozoite and merozoite surface antigens in H-2b and H-2k mice

Peptides representing conserved (MSA2/1A and MSA2/1B) and variant (MSA2/2, MSA2/6 and MSA2/7) regions of the merozoite surface Ag 2 (MSA2) of Plasmodium falciparum (FCQ-27/PNG isolate) were coupled to either peptide NP(NANP)5NA or peptide C(NANP)6 both of which contained the core sequence (NANP)n. The coupling was done via the N-terminus of one peptide and a cysteine residue on either terminus of the other. BL/10 (H-2b) and B10.BR (H-2k) mice were immunized with these MSA2-(NANP)n conjugates. The mice were also immunized with the unconjugated MSA2 peptides and with NP(NANP)5NA and C(NANP)6. Antibody responses were evaluated by 1) ELISA, in which the MSA2 peptides and C(NANP)6 were used as Ag; 2) immunofluorescence assays (IFAT) against intact sporozoites and merozoites; and 3) immunoblotting experiments against solubilized P. falciparum blood stage proteins. High titer antibodies to (NANP)n were elicited in both BL/10 and B10.BR mice after immunization with all the conjugates except MSA2/7-(NANP)n which gave only a very limited response in B10.BR mice. These antibodies recognized unfixed sporozoites. The conjugates also elicited antibodies to MSA2 as shown by ELISA, IFAT, and immunoblotting except for mice immunized with MSA2/1B-(NANP)n where an anti-MSA2 response was only detectable by immunoblotting. Immunization with unconjugated MSA2 peptides showed that MSA2/2 was immunogenic in both BL/10 and BR.10 mice, with MSA2/6 and MSA2/7 being immunogenic only in BL/10 mice. The antibodies elicited recognized both merozoites and the MSA2 protein. However, the antibody titers were lower overall than those seen when these peptides were used in the conjugated form. No anti-MSA2 antibodies were detected after immunization with MSA2/1A and MSA2/1B. Immunization of mice with the peptide NP(NANP)5NA produced antibodies in BL/10 (H-2b) mice only, and the immunogenicity of this preparation was poor. In contrast, C(NANP)6 produced a strong antibody response in both mouse strains. The antibodies elicited by NP(NANP)5NA and C(NANP)6 recognised sporozoites in IFAT. The MSA2 peptides studied (or their derivatives) were previously shown to be recognized by human T cells. Their immunogenic potential shows promise in that complex anti-P. falciparum responses can be elicited with simple synthetic immunogens based on these peptides.     

External surface display of proteins linked to DNA-binding domains.

A novel system (DBDX) was developed which allows the external surface display on filamentous bacteriophage of proteins fused to either the N- or the C-terminus of a DNA-binding protein. In conjunction with helper phage infection, expression of proteins fused to the estrogen receptor DNA-binding domain (DBD) in a phagemid vector containing the DNA sequence recognized by the DBD resulted in the production of phage particles which display the fusion protein through the phage pVIII coat on the external surface of the particle. The viability of the technique was established with several model systems: particles displaying the C-terminal domain of N-cadherin or the biotinylation domain of propionyl coenzyme A carboxylase fused to the C-terminus of the DBD were found to be bound specifically by antibody or streptavidin, respectively. Human kappa constant region cDNA was selected from a N-terminal DBD fusion lymphocyte cDNA library after two rounds of selection with anti-kappa antibody. This display system may complement currently available bacterial selection techniques.     

1H-NMR studies of synthetic polypeptide models of Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite protein tandemly repeated sequence

The major immunodominant region of the coating protein of Plasmodium falciparum sporozoites contains multiple tandem copies of the sequence Asn-Ala-Asn-Pro (NANP). Current efforts for the development of an antisporozoite vaccine are focused on the synthesis of polypeptides reproducing part of the circumsporozoite protein repeat sequence and, in an attempt to relate conformational properties and biological response, 1H-nmr one- and two-dimensional studies of the synthetic models (NANP)2NA and (NANP)6 were carried out in water and water/methanol mixtures, at 400 and 500 MHz. In water, (NANP)6 undergoes fast conformational averaging. At variance, in water/methanol, the molecule appears to adopt an extensive structure, but detailed analysis is impaired by high spectral degeneracy. Based on the results obtained with (NANP)2NA and from preliminary experiments in water/trifluoroethanol, an interpretation is suggested for the (NANP)6 data in water/methanol in terms of a mixed sequence of beta I-turns and half-turns (or/and gamma I-turns) around the positions Ni-1-Pi-Ni + 1.     

Construction of immunogens for synthetic malaria vaccines

The immunogenicity of a peptide consisting of eight repeats of the tetrapeptide sequence NANP (Asn-Ala-Asn-Pro) contained in the circumsporozoite protein of Plasmodium falciparum was investigated in mice under different modes of presentation. This peptide was able to produce biologically active antibodies when administered with adjuvant and linked to a protein carrier. However, a (NANP) peptide polymerized by carbodiimide was found to be immunogenic in the absence of protein carrier in H-2b mice. In contrast, the (NANP)8 peptide polymerized by glutaraldehyde was not immunogenic in the same strain. Furthermore, the efficacy of murabutide in saline, as an immunological adjuvant, was compared to the efficacy of Freund's complete adjuvant.