Molecular determinants of non-specific recognition of delta, mu, and kappa opioid receptors

Identification of the molecular determinants of recognition common to all three opioid receptors embedded in a single three-dimensional (3D) non-specific recognition pharmacophore has been carried out. The working hypothesis that underlies the computational study reported here is that ligands that bind with significant affinity to all three cloned opioid receptors, delta, mu, and kappa, but with different combinations of activation and inhibition properties at these receptors, could be promising behaviorally selective analgesics with diminished side effects. The study presented here represents the first step towards the rational design of such therapeutic agents. The common 3D pharmacophore developed for recognition of delta, mu, and kappa opioid receptors was based on the receptor affinities determined for 23 different opioid ligands that display no specificity for any of the receptor subtypes. The pharmacophore centers identified are a protonated amine, two hydrophobic groups, and the centroid of an aromatic group in a geometric arrangement common to all 23, non-specific, opioid ligands studied. Using this three-dimensional pharmacophore as a query for searching 3D structural databases, novel compounds potentially involved in non-specific recognition of delta, mu, and kappa opioid receptors were retrieved. These compounds can be valuable candidates for novel behaviorally selective analgesics with diminished or no side effects, and thus with potential therapeutic usefulness.     

Design and synthesis of trivalent ligands targeting opioid,cholecystokinin, and melanocortin receptors for the treatment of pain

It has been known that co-administration of morphine with either cholecystokinin (CCK) receptor or melanocortin (MC) receptor antagonists enhance morphine’s analgesic efficacy by reducing serious side effects such as tolerance and addiction.1, 2, 3, 4 Considering these synergistic effects, we have designed trivalent ligands in which all three different pharmacophores for opioid, CCK, and MC receptors are combined in such a way as to conserve their own topographical pharmacophore structures. These ligands, excluding the cyclic compound, were synthesized by solid phase synthesis using Rink-amide resin under microwave assistance in very high yields. These trivalent ligands bind to their respective receptors well demonstrating that the topographical pharmacophore structures for the three receptors were retained for receptor binding. Ligand 10 was a lead compound to show the best biological activities at all three receptors.     

Development of a 3D pharmacophore for nonspecific ligand recognition of alpha1, alpha2, alpha3, alpha5, and alpha6 containing GABA(A)/benzodiazepine receptors

Transfected cells containing GABA(A) benzodiazepine receptors (BDZRs) have been utilized to systematically determine the affinity of ligands at alpha1, alpha2, alpha3, alpha5 and alpha6 subtypes in combination with beta2 and gamma2. All but a few of the ligands thus far studied have relatively high affinities for each of these alpha subtype receptors. Thus, these ligands must contain common stereochemical properties favorable for recognition by each of the subtype combinations. In the present work, such a common three-dimensional (3D) pharmacophore for recognition of alpha1, alpha2, alpha3, alpha5 and alpha6 containing GABA(A)/BDZRs types of receptors has been developed and assessed, using as a database receptor affinities measured in transfected cells for 27 diverse compounds. The 3D-recognition pharmacophore developed consists of three proton accepting groups, a hydrophobic group, and the centroid of an aromatic ring found in a common geometric arrangement in the 19 nonselective ligands used. Three tests were made to assess this pharmacophore: (i) Four low affinity compounds were used as negative controls, (ii) Four high affinity compounds, excluded from the pharmacophore development, were used as compounds for pharmacophore validation, (iii) The 3D pharmacophore was used to search 3D databases. The results of each of these types of assessments provided robust validation of the 3D pharmacophore. This 3D pharmacophore can now be used to discover novel nonselective ligands that could be activation selective at different behavioral end points. Additionally, it may serve as a guide in the design of more selective ligands, by determining if candidate ligands proposed for synthesis conform to this pharmacophore and selecting those that do not for further experimental assessment.     

Use of hydrophilic diamines for bridging of two opioid peptide pharmacophores. Synthesis and receptor binding of two new analogues.

The bivalent ligand approach, which assumes that two pharmacophores are connected by a spacer, was used to design receptor type-selective ligands for opioid receptors. The first two opioid peptide bivalent ligands with different spacer lengths containing different numbers of hydroxyl groups, (Tyr-D-Ala-Gly-Phe-NH-CH2-CHOH-)2 (Tyr-D-Ala-Gly-Phe-NH-CH2-CHOH-CHOH-)2, were synthesized and their binding to mu, delta, and kappa opioid receptors was characterized. Both analogues were found to possess high opioid in vitro activities. The length of the hydrophilic spacer does not affect the affinity for delta receptors, whereas shorter spacer length increases affinity for mu and even more so for kappa receptors. Thus receptor type-selective peptides for opioid receptors can be designed using the bivalent approach.     

Complementarity of delta opioid ligand pharmacophore and receptor models

The elaboration of a pharmacophore model for the delta opioid receptor selective ligand JOM-13 (Tyr-c[D-Cys-Phe-D-Pen]OH) and the parallel, independent development of a structural model of the delta receptor are summarized. Although the backbone conformation of JOM-13's tripeptide cycle is well defined, considerable conformational lability is evident in the Tyr(1) residue and in the Phe(3) side chain, key pharmacophore elements of the ligand. Replacement of these flexible features of the ligand by more conformationally restricted analogues and subsequent correlation of receptor binding and conformational properties allowed the number of possible binding conformations of JOM-13 to be reduced to two. Of these, one was chosen as more likely, based on its better superposition with other conformationally constrained delta receptor ligands. Our model of the delta opioid receptor, constructed using a general approach that we have developed for all rhodopsin-like G protein-coupled receptors, contains a large cavity within the transmembrane domain that displays excellent complementarity in both shape and polarity to JOM-13 and other delta ligands. This binding pocket, however, cannot accommodate the conformer of JOM-13 preferred from analysis of ligands, alone. Rather, only the "alternate" allowed conformer, identified from analysis of the ligands but "disfavored" because it does not permit simultaneous superposition of all pharmacophore elements of JOM-13 with other delta ligands, fits the binding site. These results argue against a simple view of a single, common fit to a receptor binding site and suggest, instead, that at least some binding site interactions of different ligands may differ.     

Bi- or multifunctional opioid peptide drugs

Strategies for the design of bi- or multifunctional drugs are reviewed. A distinction is made between bifunctional drugs interacting in a monovalent fashion with two targets and ligands containing two distinct pharmacophores binding in a bivalent mode to the two binding sites in a receptor heterodimer. Arguments are presented to indicate that some of the so-called “bivalent” ligands reported in the literature are unlikely to simultaneously interact with two binding sites. Aspects related to the development of bi- or multifunctional drugs are illustrated with examples from the field of opioid analgesics. The drug-like properties of the tetrapeptide Dmt¹[DALDA] with triple action as a µ opioid agonist, norepinephrine uptake inhibitor and releaser of endogenous opioid peptides to produce potent spinal analgesia are reviewed. Rationales for the development of opioid peptides with mixed agonist/antagonist profiles as analgesics with reduced side effects are presented. Progress in the development of mixed µ opioid agonist/δ opioid antagonists with low propensity to produce tolerance and physical dependence is reviewed. Efforts to develop bifunctional peptides containing a µ opioid agonist and a cholecystokinin antagonist or an NK1 receptor antagonist as analgesics expected to produce less tolerance and dependence are also reviewed. A strategy to improve the drug-like properties of bifunctional opioid peptide analgesics is presented.     

Synthesis and investigations of double-pharmacophore ligands for treatment of chronic and neuropathic pain

Acids 9a–f as possible bivalent ligands designed as a structural combination of opioid μ-agonist (Fentanyl) and NSAID (Indomethacin) activities and produced compounds which were tested as analgesics. The obtained series of compounds exhibits low affinity and activity both at opioid receptors and as cyclooxygenase (COX) inhibitors. One explanation of the weak opioid activity could be stereochemical peculiarities of these bivalent compounds which differ significantly from the fentanyl skeleton. The absence of significant COX inhibitory properties could be explained by the required substitution of an acyl fragment in the indomethacin structure for 4-piperidyl.     

Modification of opioid ligand binding in the central and the peripheral nervous system by different buffers

The modification of binding parameters (equilibrium dissociation constant and binding capacity) of three opioid ligands (DADLE, Etorphine and EKC) on bovine adrenal medulla and rat brain membranes have been examined in three buffer systems: Tris-HCl 50 mM, Hepes-NaOH 10 mM and Tes-KOH 10 mM. Major differences of these parameters have been found: Hepes-NaOH provoked a diminution of the apparent number of binding sites, while a concomitant diminution of the KD and Bmax was observed in Tes-KOH buffer. Substitution of counterions in these two buffers produced further changes of binding characteristics: in Hepes buffer we have observed an abolition of 3H DADLE binding, an enhancement of 3H EKC binding and no modification of 3H etorphine binding characteristics. On the contrary an abolition of the specific binding of all three ligands in Tes buffer was found in the bovine adrenal medulla while minor changes were observed in rat brain. It is concluded that, inspite same disadvantages (substitution for bivalent cations and temperature dependence), Tris-HCl is the buffer of choice for the analysis of opioid binding site interactions.     

Conformation-activity relationships of opioid peptides with selective activities at opioid receptors

The discovery of endogenous opioid peptides 25 years ago opened up a new chapter in efforts to understand the origins and control of pain, its relationships to other biological functions, including inflammatory and other immune responses, and the relationships of opioid peptides and their receptors to a variety of undesirable or toxic side effects often associated with the nonpeptide opiates such as morphine including addiction, constipation, a variety of neural toxicities, tolerance, and respiratory depression. For these investigations the need for potent and highly receptor selective agonists and antagonists has been crucial since they in principle allow one to distinguish unequivocally the roles of the different opioid receptors (mu, delta, and kappa) in the various biological and pathological roles of the opioid peptides and their receptors. Conformational and topographical constraint of the linear natural endogenous opioid peptides has played a major role in developing peptide ligands with high selectivity for mu, delta, and kappa receptors, and in understanding the conformational, topographical, and stereoelectronic structural requirements of the opioid peptides for their interactions with opioid receptors. In turn, this had led to insights into the three-dimensional pharmacophore for opioid receptors. In this article we review and discuss some of the developments that have led to potent, selective, and stable peptide and peptidomimetic ligands that are highly potent and selective, and that have delta agonist, mu antagonist, and kappa agonist biological activities (other authors in this issue will discuss the development of other types of activities and selectivities). These have led to ligands that provide unique insight into opioid pharmacophores and the critical roles opioid ligands and receptor scan play in pain, addiction, and other human maladies.     

Benzodiazepine-induced hyperphagia: development and assessment of a 3D pharmacophore by computational methods

Benzodiazepine receptor (BDZR) ligands are structurally diverse compounds that bind to specific binding sites on GABA(A) receptors and allosterically modulate the effect of GABA on chloride ion flux. The binding of BDZR ligands to this receptor system results in activity at multiple behavioral endpoints, including anxiolytic, sedative, anticonvulsant, and hyperphagic effects. In the work presented here, a computational procedure developed in our laboratory has been used to obtain a 3D pharmacophore for ligand recognition of the GABA(A)/BDZRs initiating the hyperphagic response. To accomplish this goal, 17 structurally diverse compounds, previously assessed in our laboratory for activity at the hyperphagic endpoint, were used. The result is a four-component 3D pharmacophore. It consists of two proton acceptor atoms, the centroid of an aromatic ring and the centroid of a hydrophobic moiety in a common geometric arrangement in all compounds with activity at this endpoint. This 3D pharmacophore was then assessed and successfully validated using three different tests. First, two BDZR ligands, which were included as negative controls in the set of seventeen compounds used for the pharmacophore development, did not fit the pharmacophore. Second, some benzodiazepine ligands known to have activity at the hyperphagia endpoint, but not included in the pharmacophore development, were used as positive controls and were found to fit the pharmacophore. Finally, using the 3D pharmacophore developed in the present work to search 3D databases, over 50 classical benzodiazepines were found. Among them, were benzodiazepine ligands known to have an effect at the hyperphagic endpoint. In addition, the novel compounds also found in this search are promising therapeutic agents that could beneficially affect feeding behavior.     

Synthesis and evaluation of bivalent ligands for binding to the human melanocortin-4 receptor

Membrane proteins, especially G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs), are interesting and important theragnostic targets since many of them serve in intracellular signaling critical for all aspects of health and disease. The potential utility of designed bivalent ligands as targeting agents for cancer diagnosis and/or therapy can be evaluated by determining their binding to the corresponding receptors. As proof of concept, GPCR cell surface proteins are shown to be targeted specifically using multivalent ligands. We designed, synthesized, and tested a series of bivalent ligands targeting the over-expressed human melanocortin 4 receptor (hMC4R) in human embryonic kidney (HEK) 293 cells. Based on our data suggesting an optimal linker length of 25 ± 10 Å inferred from the bivalent melanocyte stimulating hormone (MSH) agonist, the truncated heptapeptide, referred to as MSH(7): Ac-Ser-Nle-Glu-His-D-Phe-Arg-Trp-NH₂ was used to construct a set of bivalent ligands incorporating a hMC4R antagonist, SHU9119: Ac-Nle-_c[Asp-His-2′-D-Nal-Arg-Trp-Lys]-NH₂ and another set of bivalent ligands containing the SHU9119 antagonist pharmacophore on both side of the optimized linkers. These two binding motifs within the bivalent constructs were conjoined by semi-rigid (Pro-Gly)₃ units with or without the flexible poly(ethylene glycol) (PEGO) moieties. Lanthanide-based competitive binding assays showed bivalent ligands binds to the hMC4R with up to 240-fold higher affinity than the corresponding linked monovalent ligands.     

Opioid and melanocortin receptors: do they have overlapping pharmacophores?

We have identified compound 1 as a novel ligand for opioid and melanocortin (MC) receptors, which is derived from the overlapping of a well known structure for the delta opioid receptor, 2,6-dimethyltyrosine (Dmt)-1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline-3-carboxylic acid (Tic), and a small molecule for the MC receptor, Tic-DPhe(p-Cl)-piperidin-4-yl-N-phenyl-propionamide. Ligand 1 showed that there is an overlapping pharmacophore between opioid and MC receptors through the Tic residue. The ligand displayed high biological activities at the delta opioid receptor (Ki = 0.38 nM in binding assay, EC(50) = 0.48 nM in GTP-gamma-S binding assay, IC(50) = 74 nM in MVD) as an agonist instead of an antagonist and showed selective binding affinity (IC(50) = 2.3 muM) at the MC-3 receptor rather than at the MC-5 receptor. A study of the structure-activity relationships demonstrated that the residues in positions 2, 3, and the C-terminus act as a pharmacophore for the MC receptors, and the residues in positions 1 and 2 act as a pharmacophore for the opioid receptors. Thus, this structural construct can be used to prepare chimeric structures with adjacent or overlapping pharmacophores for opioid and MC receptors.     

Benzodiazepine-Induced Hyperphagia: Development and Assessment of a 3D Pharmacophore By Computational Methods

Abstract

Benzodiazepine receptor (BDZR) ligands are structurally diverse compounds that bind to specific binding sites on GABAA receptors and allosterically modulate the effect of GABA on chloride ion flux. The binding of BDZR ligands to this receptor system results in activity at multiple behavioral endpoints, including anxiolytic, sedative, anticonvulsant, and hyperphagic effects. In the work presented here, a computational procedure developed in our laboratory has been used to obtain a 3D pharmacophore for ligand recognition of the GABAA/BDZRS initiating the hyperphagic response. To accomplish this goal, 17 structurally diverse compounds, previously assessed in our laboratory for activity at the hyperphagic endpoint, were used. The result is a four-component 3D pharmacophore. It consists of two proton acceptor atoms, the centroid of an aromatic ring and the centroid of a hydrophobic moiety in a common geometric arrangement in all compounds with activity at this endpoint. This 3D pharmacophore was then assessed and successfully validated using three different tests. First, two BDZR ligands, which were included as negative controls in the set of seventeen compounds used for the pharmacophore development, did not fit the pharmacophore. Second, some benzodiazepine ligands known to have activity at the hyperphagia endpoint, but not included in the pharmacophore development, were used as positive controls and were found to fit the pharmacophore. Finally, using the 3D pharmacophore developed in the present work to search 3D databases, over 50 classical benzodiazepines were found. Among them, were benzodiazepine ligands known to have an effect at the hyperphagic endpoint. In addition, the novel compounds also found in this search are promising therapeutic agents that could beneficially affect feeding behavior.     

A constraint scaffold enhances affinity of a bivalent N-acetylglucosamine ligand against wheat germ agglutinin

Bivalent glycoconjugates have a minimal valence with avidity potential on protein-carbohydrate interactions as well as simplicity of chemical structures enabling simple synthesis with low cost. Understanding the way to maximize the affinities of bivalent glycoconjugates is important for the development of cost-effective tools for therapeutic and diagnostic research. However, there has been little discussion about the effects of constraints imposed from ligand scaffolds on the binding abilities. We synthesized three kinds of biantennary N-acetylglucosamine glycosides with different scaffolds using isobutenyl bis(propargyl)ether as a common scaffold precursor. Decoration of the scaffold branches with GlcNAc moieties through copper-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition and grafting of the alkenyl focal point to another bivalent biotin dendron through thiol-ene and nucleophilic substitution reactions were successfully carried out in an orthogonal manner. The association constants of the ligands against wheat germ agglutinin were determined by a fluorometric titration assay. A bivalent biotin counterpart provided higher affinity than an isobutyl scaffold, whereas an isobutenyl scaffold yielded more enhancement than a bivalent biotin counterpart. The present work suggested that the constraint and steric bulk of ligand scaffolds are possible factors for improving binding properties of glycoconjugates against lectins or proteins.     

Redefining the structure-activity relationships of 2,6-methano-3-benzazocines. Part 6: Opioid receptor binding properties of cyclic variants of 8-carboxamidocyclazocine

A series of 7,8- and 8,9-fused pyrimidinone, aminopyrimidine and pyridone derivatives of 8-carboxamidocyclazocine (8-CAC) have been prepared and evaluated in opioid receptor binding assays. Targets were designed to corroborate a pharmacophore hypothesis regarding the bioactive conformation of the carboxamide of 8-CAC. In addition to the results from this study strongly supporting this pharmacophore hypothesis, a number of novel compounds with high affinity to opioid receptors have been identified.     

In Vivo Characterization of (−)(−)MCL-144 and (+)(−)MCL-193: Isomeric,Bivalent Ligands with Mu/Kappa Agonist Properties

Once opioid receptor dimers were postulated, a goal has been to synthesize and screen novel opioids, with the hope of furthering our knowledge of the structure-activity relationship of opioid ligands with the opioid receptors. The aim of the current study was to address whether two isomeric bivalent ligands would have pharmacological differences after central administration, in vivo. The two compounds, (−) bis(N-cyclobutylmethyl-morphinan-3-yl) sebacoylate dihydrochloride (MCL-144) and 1−((+)N-cyclobutylmethylmorphinan-3-yl)-10-((−) N-cyclobutylmethylmorphinan-3-yl)sebacolyate (MCL-193) are each linked by a 10-carbon chain ester. The active (−) enantiomer for both ligands is 3-hydroxy-N-cyclobutylmethyl morphinan ((−)MCL-101), a N-cyclobutylmethyl analogue of cyclorphan (J Med Chem 43:114–122, 2000). MCL-144 contains two active levo rotatory (−)(−) pharmacophores, while MCL-193 contains one active (−) and one inactive (+) pharmacophore of MCL-101. In vitro analysis demonstrated that all three compounds, (−)(−)MCL-144, (+)(−)MCL-193 and (−)MCL-101 were κ agonists and μ partial agonists. (−)(−)MCL-144 and (−)MCL-101 had much higher affinity for both the μ and κ opioid receptors compared to (+)(−)MCL-193. In vivo, (−)(−)MCL-144 and (+)(−)MCL-193 produced full dose–response curves, in the 55°C tail-flick test, with each compound having an ED₅₀ value of 3.0 nmol after intracerebroventricular (i.c.v.) administration. The analgesic properties of both compounds were antagonized by the μ-selective antagonist, β-funaltrexamine and the κ-selective antagonist nor-binaltorphimine. Concomitant, i.c.v., administration of either (−)(−)MCL-144 or (+)(−)MCL-193 with morphine, did not significantly antagonize morphine-induced antinociception at any dose tested. In antinociceptive tests, (−)(−)MCL-144 and (+)(−)MCL-193 had the same pharmacological properties, demonstrating that having two active pharmacophores separated by a 10-carbon spacer group did not increase the antinociceptive efficacy of the compound. Additionally, it was also of interest to compare (−)(−)MCL-145 and (−)(−)MCL-144, as the only difference between these bivalent ligands is the spacer region connecting the two pharmacophores, yet (−)(−)MCL-145 produced an ED₅₀ value 10-fold lower than (−)(−)MCL-144 (ED₅₀ values = 0.3 nmol and 3.0 nmol, respectively). Special issue article in honor of Dr. Ji-Sheng Han.     

Preferred conformation of endomorphin-1 in aqueous and membrane-mimetic environments.

The newly discovered endomorphin-1 (Tyr-Pro-Trp-Phe-NH2) and endomorphin-2 (Tyr-Pro-Phe-Phe-NH2) are potent opioid peptides with the highest affinity and selectivity for the mu receptor among all known endogenous ligands. To investigate a possible correlation between these biological properties and the conformational preferences of the small peptides, a comparative structural analysis was performed of endomorphin-1 in aqueous buffer and in membrane-mimicking SDS and AOT normal and reverse micelles by the use of CD, FT-IR, fluorescence and(1)H-NMR spectroscopy. It is well established for opioid peptides that, independently of the receptor selectivity, the Tyr1 residue plays the role of the primary pharmacophore and that the orientation of the second aromatic pharmacophore relative to the tyrosine side-chain dictates the mu or delta-receptor selectivity. By varying the environment of endomorphin-1 from water to the amphipathic SDS micelles and even more efficiently to the AOT reverse micelles, the display of the aromatic side-chains changes from an interaction of the Tyr1 and Phe4 residues to a switch of the Trp3 indole group into close contact with the phenolic moiety to prevent this type of interaction and to force an orientation of the Phe4 side-chain into the opposite direction. This conformational switch is accompanied by a stabilization of the cis -Pro2 isomer and the resulting spatial array of the pharmacophoric groups correlate well with the structural model of mu receptor-bound opioid peptides. The results indicate that AOT reverse micelles with a woof 10, where almost exclusively ordered water is secluded in the cavity, constitute with their electrostatic and hydrophobic potential an excellent mimetic of amphipathic surfaces as present on lipid bilayers and on ligand-recognition and ligand-binding sites of proteins.     

A bivalent ligand (KMN-21) antagonist for μ/κ heterodimeric opioid receptors

In an effort to develop antagonists for κ–μ opioid receptor heterodimers, a series of bivalent ligands 3–6 containing κ- and μ-antagonist pharmacophores were designed and synthesized. Evaluation of the series in HEK-293 cells revealed 4 (KMN-21) to selectively antagonize the activation of κ–μ heterodimers, suggesting possible bridging of receptors when the bivalent ligand spacer contains 21 atoms.     

Development and assessment of a 3D pharmacophore for ligand recognition of BDZR/GABAA receptors initiating the anxiolytic response

Benzodiazepine receptor (BDZR) ligands are structurally diverse compounds that bind to specific binding sites on GABAA receptors and allosterically modulate the effect of GABA on chloride flux. The binding of BDZR ligands to this receptor system results in activity at multiple behavioral end points including anxiolytic, sedative, hyperphagic, anticonvulsant and hyperthermic effects. In the work presented here, 17 structurally diverse BDZR ligands of the receptors initiating the anxiolytic response have been studied using a systematic computational procedure developed in our laboratory. Using this procedure, a five component 3D recognition pharmacophore was obtained consisting of two proton acceptors, a hydrophobic group, an aromatic electron accepting ring and a ring containing polar moieties, all found in a common geometric arrangement in the 15 compounds with an effect at the anxiolytic end point and absent in two control compounds. The 3D pharmacophore developed was validated by searching 3D databases and finding known BDZR ligands active at the anxiolytic end point, including 1,4-BDZ derivatives, imidazo BDZ and beta-carboline ligands.