Combining protein complementation assays with resonance energy transfer to detect multipartner protein complexes in living cells

A variety of fluorescent proteins with different spectral properties have been created by mutating green fluorescent protein. When these proteins are split in two, neither fragment is fluorescent per se, nor can a fluorescent protein be reconstituted by co-expressing the complementary N- and C-terminal fragments. However, when these fragments are genetically fused to proteins that associate with each other in cellulo, the N- and C-terminal fragments of the fluorescent protein are brought together and can reconstitute a fluorescent protein. A similar protein complementation assay (PCA) can be performed with two complementary fragments of various luciferase isoforms. This makes these assays useful tools for detecting the association of two proteins in living cells. Bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) or fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) occurs when energy from, respectively, a luminescent or fluorescent donor protein is non-radiatively transferred to a fluorescent acceptor protein. This transfer of energy can only occur if the proteins are within 100 Å of each other. Thus, BRET and FRET are also useful tools for detecting the association of two proteins in living cells. By combining different protein fragment complementation assays (PCA) with BRET or FRET it is possible to demonstrate that three or more proteins are simultaneous parts of the same protein complex in living cells. As an example of the utility of this approach, we show that as many as four different proteins are simultaneously associated as part of a G protein-coupled receptor signalling complex.     

Monitoring the interference of protein-protein interactions in vivo by bimolecular fluorescence complementation: the DnaK case

Many cellular processes depend on protein-protein interactions. The identification of molecules able to modulate protein contacts is of significant interest for drug discovery and chemical biology. Nevertheless, finding antagonists of protein interactions that work efficiently within the cell is a challenging task. Here, we describe the novel use of bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BIFC) to detect compounds that block the interaction of target proteins in vivo. In the BIFC method, each interaction partner is fused to a complementary fragment of a fluorescent protein and interactions are detected by fluorescence restoration after reporter reassembly. Here, we demonstrate that the inhibition of specific intracellular protein interactions results in a concomitant decrease in fluorescence emission. We also show that integration of BIFC with flow cytometry might provide an effective means to detect interaction modulators by directly reading out changes in the reporter signal. The in vivo application of this approach is illustrated through monitoring the inhibition of the interaction between the Escherichia coli Hsp70 chaperone and a short peptidic substrate by pyrrhocoricin-derived antibacterial peptides.     

Using the beta-lactamase protein-fragment complementation assay to probe dynamic protein-protein interactions

We have developed a general experimental strategy that enables the quantitative detection of dynamic protein-protein interactions in intact living cells, based on protein-fragment complementation assays (PCAs). In this method, protein interactions are coupled to refolding of enzymes from cognate fragments where reconstitution of enzyme activity acts as the detector of a protein interaction. We have described a number of assays with different reporter readouts, but of particular value to studies of protein interaction dynamics are assays based on enzyme reporters that catalyze the creation of products, thus taking advantage of the amplification of signal afforded. Here we describe protocols for one such PCA based on the enzyme TEM beta-lactamase as a reporter in mammalian cells. The beta-lactamase PCA consists of fusing complementary fragments of beta-lactamase to two proteins of interest. If the proteins interact, the fragments are brought together and fold into active beta-lactamase. Here we describe a protocol for this PCA that can be completed in a few hours, using two different substrates that are converted to fluorescent or colored products by beta-lactamase.     

Chemical genetic strategies to delineate MAP kinase signaling pathways using protein-fragment complementation assays (PCA)

Signal transduction pathways mediated by MAP kinases are among the most studied. Direct analysis of MAP kinase pathways has been difficult because some details of MAP kinase signaling cannot be studied in vitro. Here, we describe a strategy for directly analyzing MAP kinase signaling pathways in living cells using protein-fragment complementation assays (PCA) based on intensely fluorescent proteins. The assays allow for spatial and temporal analysis of protein complexes including those that form upstream and downstream from MAPKs as well as complexes of MAPKs with regulator and effector proteins. We describe high-content assays, high-throughput quantitative microscopic methods to follow temporal changes in complex subcellular location and quantity. Spatial and temporal changes in response to perturbations (chemical, siRNA, and hormones) allow for delineation of MAPK signaling networks and a general and high-throughput approach to identify small molecules that act directly or indirectly on MAPK pathways.     

Application of protein-fragment complementation assays in cell biology

We have developed a general experimental strategy that enables the quantitative detection of dynamic protein-protein interactions in intact living cells, based on protein-fragment complementation assays (PCAs). In this method, protein-protein interactions are coupled to refolding of enzymes from cognate fragments where reconstitution of enzyme activity acts as the detector of a protein interaction. Here we discuss the application of PCA to different aspects of cell biology.     

Protein fragment complementation strategies for biochemical network mapping

The organization of biochemical networks that make up the living cell can be defined by studying the dynamics of protein-protein interactions. To this end, experimental strategies based on protein fragment complementation assays (PCAs) have been used to map biochemical networks and to identify novel components of these networks. Pharmacological perturbations of the interactions can be observed, and the resulting pharmacological profiles and subcellular locations of interactions allow each gene product to be 'placed' at its relevant point in a network. Network mapping by PCA could be used with, or instead of, traditional target-based drug discovery strategies to increase the quantity and quality of information about the actions of small molecules on living cells and the intricate networks that make up their chemical machinery.     

A modification of the split-tobacco etch virus method for monitoring interactions between membrane proteins in mammalian cells

Despite progress in the development of methods to monitor protein interactions, studies of interactions between membrane proteins in mammalian cells remain challenging. Protein complementation assays (PCAs) are commonly used to study interactions between proteins due to their simplicity. They are based on interaction-mediated reconstitution of a reporter protein, which can be easily monitored. Recently, a protein complementation method named split-TEV (tobacco etch virus) has been developed and is based on the functional reconstitution of TEV protease and subsequent proteolytic-mediated activation of reporters. In this work, we have developed a modification of the split-TEV method to study the interactions between membrane proteins with increased specificity. This assay was validated by addressing the interactions between different membrane proteins, including G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and ion channels. By comparing it with another PCA, we found that this new method showed a higher sensitivity.     

Genome-wide Protein-protein Interaction Screening by Protein-fragment Complementation Assay (PCA) in Living Cells

Proteins are the building blocks, effectors and signal mediators of cellular processes. A protein’s function, regulation and localization often depend on its interactions with other proteins. Here, we describe a protocol for the yeast protein-fragment complementation assay (PCA), a powerful method to detect direct and proximal associations between proteins in living cells. The interaction between two proteins, each fused to a dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) protein fragment, translates into growth of yeast strains in presence of the drug methotrexate (MTX). Differential fitness, resulting from different amounts of reconstituted DHFR enzyme, can be quantified on high-density colony arrays, allowing to differentiate interacting from non-interacting bait-prey pairs. The high-throughput protocol presented here is performed using a robotic platform that parallelizes mating of bait and prey strains carrying complementary DHFR-fragment fusion proteins and the survival assay on MTX. This protocol allows to systematically test for thousands of protein-protein interactions (PPIs) involving bait proteins of interest and offers several advantages over other PPI detection assays, including the study of proteins expressed from their endogenous promoters without the need for modifying protein localization and for the assembly of complex reporter constructs.     

An improved bimolecular fluorescence complementation assay with a high signal-to-noise ratio

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) play crucial roles in various biological processes. Among biochemical, genetic, and imaging approaches that have been used for the study of PPIs, visualization of PPIs in living cells is the key to understanding their cellular functions. The bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assay represents one of these imaging tools for direct visualization of PPIs in living cells. The BiFC assay is based on the structural complementation of two nonfluorescent N- and C-terminal fragments of a fluorescent protein when they are fused to a pair of interacting proteins. Although over 10 different fluorescent proteins have been used for BiFC assays, the two nonfluorescent fragments from all of these fluorescent proteins can spontaneously self-assemble, which contributes to background fluorescence and decreases the signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio in the BiFC assay. Here we report the identification of a mutation, I152L, that can specifically reduce self-assembly and decrease background fluorescence in a Venus-based BiFC system. This mutation allows a 4-fold increase in the S/N ratio of the BiFC assay in living cells. This improved Venus-based BiFC system will facilitate PPI studies in various biological research fields.     

Exploring protein interactions by interaction-induced folding of proteins from complementary peptide fragments

The study of protein--protein interactions is central to understanding the chemical machinery that makes up the living cell. Until recently, facile methods to study these processes in intact, living cells have not existed. Furthermore, the assignment of function to novel proteins relies on demonstrating interactions of these proteins with proteins of known function. This review describes an experimental strategy, devised to study protein--protein interactions in any intact living cells based on protein-fragment complementation assays. Applications to quantitative analysis of interactions, allosteric processes and cDNA library screening are discussed. Recently, the feasibility of employing this strategy in genome-wide biochemical pathway mapping efforts has been demonstrated.     

Protein-protein interaction through beta-strand addition

Protein-protein interactions have essential roles at almost every level of organization and communication in living cells. During complex formation, proteins can interact via covalent, surface-surface or peptide-surface contacts. Many protein complexes are now known to involve the binding of linear motifs in one of the binding partners. An emerging mechanism of such non-covalent peptide-surface interaction involves the donation or addition of a beta strand in the ligand to a beta sheet or a beta strand in the receptor. Such 'beta-strand addition' contacts can dictate or modulate binding specificity and affinity, or can be used in more promiscuous protein-protein contacts. Three main classes of beta-strand addition can be distinguished: beta-sheet augmentation; beta-strand insertion and fold complementation; and beta-strand zippering. A survey of protein-protein complexes in the protein data bank identifies beta-strand additions in many important metabolic pathways. Targeting these interactions might, thus, provide novel routes for rational drug design.     

A cDNA library functional screening strategy based on fluorescent protein complementation assays to identify novel components of signaling pathways

Progress towards a deeper understanding of cellular biochemical networks demands the development of methods to both identify and validate component proteins of these networks. Here, we describe a cDNA library screening strategy that achieves these aims, based on a protein-fragment complementation assay (PCA) using green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a reporter. The strategy combines a simple cell-based cDNA-screening approach (interactions of a "bait" protein of interest with "prey" cDNA products) with specific functional assays that use the same system and provide initial validation of the cDNA products as being biologically relevant. We applied this strategy to identify novel interacting partners of the protein kinase PKB/Akt. This method provides very general means of identifying and validating genes involved in any cellular process and is particularly designed for identifying enzyme substrates or regulatory proteins for which the enzyme specificity can only be defined by their interactions with other proteins in cells in which the proteins are normally expressed.     

Visualization of ternary complexes in living cells by using a BiFC-based FRET assay

Studies of protein interactions have increased our understanding and knowledge of biological processes. Assays that utilize fluorescent proteins, such as fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC), have enabled direct visualization of protein interactions in living cells. However, these assays are primarily suitable for a pair of interacting proteins, and methods to visualize and identify multiple protein complexes in vivo are very limited. This protocol describes the recently developed BiFC-FRET assay, which allows visualization of ternary complexes in living cells. We discuss how to design the BiFC-FRET assay on the basis of the validation of BiFC and FRET assays and how to perform transfection experiments for acquisition of fluorescent images for net FRET calculation. We also provide three methods for normalization of the FRET efficiency. The assay employs a two-chromophore and three-filter FRET setup and is applicable to epifluorescence microscopes. The entire protocol takes about 2-3 weeks to complete.     

In silico protein fragmentation reveals the importance of critical nuclei on domain reassembly

Protein complementation assays (PCAs) based on split protein fragments have become powerful tools that facilitate the study and engineering of intracellular protein-protein interactions. These assays are based on the observation that a given protein can be split into two inactive fragments and these fragments can reassemble into the original properly folded and functional structure. However, one experimentally observed limitation of PCA systems is that the folding of a protein from its fragments is dramatically slower relative to that of the unsplit parent protein. This is due in part to a poor understanding of how PCA design parameters such as split site position in the primary sequence and size of the resulting fragments contribute to the efficiency of protein reassembly. We used a minimalist on-lattice model to analyze how the dynamics of the reassembly process for two model proteins was affected by the location of the split site. Our results demonstrate that the balanced distribution of the “folding nucleus,” a subset of residues that are critical to the formation of the transition state leading to productive folding, between protein fragments is key to their reassembly.     

Split‐Cre recombinase effectively monitors protein–protein interactions in living bacteria

The ability of Cre recombinase to excise genetic material has been used extensively for genome engineering in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. Recently, split‐Cre fragments have been described that advance control of recombinase activity in mammalian cells. However, whether these fragments can be utilized for monitoring protein‐protein interactions has not been reported. In this work, we developed a protein‐fragment complementation assay (PCA) based on split‐Cre for monitoring and engineering pairwise protein interactions in living Escherichia coli cells. This required creation of a dual‐fluorescent reporter plasmid that permits visualization of reconstituted Cre recombinase activity by switching from red to green in the presence of an interacting protein pair. The resulting split‐Cre PCA faithfully links cell fluorescence with differences in binding affinity, thereby allowing the facile isolation of high‐affinity binders based on phenotype. Given the resolution of its activity and sensitivity to interactions, our system may prove a viable option for poorly expressed or weakly interacting protein pairs that evade detection in other PCA formats. Based on these findings, we anticipate that our split‐Cre PCA will become a highly complementary and useful new addition to the protein‐protein interaction toolbox.     

Protein complementation assays: Approaches for the in vivo analysis of protein interactions

The in vivo identification and characterization of protein-protein interactions (PPIs) are essential to understand cellular events in living organisms. In this review, we focus on protein complementation assays (PCAs) that have been developed to detect in vivo protein interactions as well as their modulation or spatial and temporal changes. The uses of PCAs are increasing, spanning different areas such as the study of biochemical networks, screening for protein inhibitors and determination of drug effects. Emphasis is given to approaches that rely on signals of spectroscopic nature (i.e. fluorescence or luminescence), the ones that are more directly related to bioimaging.     

Identification of new fluorescent protein fragments for bimolecular fluorescence complementation analysis under physiological conditions

Protein-protein interactions play a pivotal role in coordinating many cellular processes. Determination of subcellular localization of interacting proteins and visualization of dynamic interactions in living cells are crucial to elucidate cellular functions of proteins. Using fluorescent proteins, we previously developed a bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assay and a multicolor BiFC assay to visualize protein-protein interactions in living cells. However, the sensitivity of chromophore maturation of enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) to higher temperatures requires preincubation at lower temperatures prior to visualizing the BiFC signal. This could potentially limit their applications for the study of many signaling molecules. Here we report the identification of new fluorescent protein fragments derived from Venus and Cerulean for BiFC and multicolor BiFC assays under physiological culture conditions. More importantly, the newly identified combinations exhibit a 13-fold higher BiFC efficiency than originally identified fragments derived from YFP. Furthermore, the use of new combinations reduces the amount of plasmid required for transfection and shortens the incubation time, leading to a 2-fold increase in specific BiFC signals. These newly identified fluorescent protein fragments will facilitate the study of protein-protein interactions in living cells and whole animals under physiological conditions.