The ability of Proteus mirabilis to sense surfaces and regulate virulence gene expression involves FliL, a flagellar basal body protein

Proteus mirabilis is a urinary tract pathogen that differentiates from a short swimmer cell to an elongated, highly flagellated swarmer cell. Swarmer cell differentiation parallels an increased expression of several virulence factors, suggesting that both processes are controlled by the same signal. The molecular nature of this signal is not known but is hypothesized to involve the inhibition of flagellar rotation. In this study, data are presented supporting the idea that conditions inhibiting flagellar rotation induce swarmer cell differentiation and implicating a rotating flagellar filament as critical to the sensing mechanism. Mutations in three genes, fliL, fliF, and fliG, encoding components of the flagellar basal body, result in the inappropriate development of swarmer cells in noninducing liquid media or hyperelongated swarmer cells on agar media. The fliL mutation was studied in detail. FliL- mutants are nonmotile and fail to synthesize flagellin, while complementation of fliL restores wild-type cell elongation but not motility. Overexpression of fliL+ in wild-type cells prevents swarmer cell differentiation and motility, a result also observed when P. mirabilis fliL+ was expressed in Escherichia coli. These results suggest that FliL plays a role in swarmer cell differentiation and implicate FliL as critical to transduction of the signal inducing swarmer cell differentiation and virulence gene expression. In concert with this idea, defects in fliL up-regulate the expression of two virulence genes, zapA and hpmB. These results support the hypothesis that P. mirabilis ascertains its location in the environment or host by assessing the status of its flagellar motors, which in turn control swarmer cell gene expression.     

ZapA, the IgA-degrading metalloprotease of Proteus mirabilis, is a virulence factor expressed specifically in swarmer cells

The IgA-degrading metalloprotease, ZapA, of the urinary tract pathogen Proteus mirabilis is co-ordinately expressed along with other proteins and virulence factors during swarmer cell differentiation. In this communication, we have used zapA to monitor IgA protease expression during the differentiation of vegetative swimmer cells to fully differentiated swarmer cells. Northern blot analysis of wild-type cells and beta-galactosidase measurements using a zapA:lacZ fusion strain indicate that zapA is fully expressed only in differentiated swarmer cells. Moreover, the expression of zapA on nutrient agar medium is co-ordinately regulated in concert with the cycles of cellular differentiation, swarm migration and consolidation that produce the bull's-eye colonies typically associated with P. mirabilis. ZapA activity is not required for swarmer cell differentiation or swarming behaviour, as ZapA- strains produce wild-type colony patterns. ZapA- strains fail to degrade IgA and show decreased survival compared with the wild-type cells during infection in a mouse model of ascending urinary tract infection (UTI). These data underscore the importance of the P. mirabilis IgA-degrading metalloprotease in UTI. Analysis of the nucleotide sequences adjacent to zapA reveals four additional genes, zapE, zapB, zapC and zapD, which appear to possess functions required for ZapA activity and IgA proteolysis. Based on homology to other known proteins, these genes encode a second metalloprotease, ZapE, as well as a ZapA-specific ABC transporter system (ZapB, ZapC and ZapD). A model describing the function and interaction of each of these five proteins in the degradation of host IgA during UTI is presented.     

Swarmer cell differentiation of Proteus mirabilis in fluid media

After 3-4 h in a rich fluid medium such as brain--heart infusion broth, motile nonseptate filaments developed from normal short rods and formed about 80% of the cell mass of Proteus mirabilis PM23. This developmental pattern was not observed in any of the other nine representatives of the species. These filaments were considered to be equivalent to swarmer cells formed on agar media because these cells ceased tumbling (i.e., chemotaxis was repressed), they developed large numbers of flagella (i.e., flagella synthesis and insertion was derepressed), and the distribution of nuclei in the filaments indicated that there was normal segregation. The population of cells grown in a minimal medium supplemented with amino acids and nicotinic acid consisted only of short cells with tumbling motility, despite the production of long cells and swarming on the same medium solidified with ordinary agar (refined agar was not effective). These short cells differentiated in 1-1.5 h in brain--heart infusion broth at 37 degrees C after an initial division. The requirements for initiation of differentiation were good basal nutrition, suitable cations (probably Ca2+ and Na+, or K+), and unknown heat-stable organic factors (molecular weight less than 10 000) present in crude agar and yeast extract. Other components of media promoted swarmer differentiation if it was initiated and these included organic acids (lactate), amino acids (proline or serine), phosphate, and an appropriate ionic environment. Comparison of the observed sequence of length classes in brain--heart infusion broth culture with computer generated growth models suggested that, at the outset of growth, 50% of the products of each short cell division ceased septation but grew in length for about five doubling periods and then divided cells from each end at a faster rate (3-5 times per hour) for return to the short cell pool.     

Alterations in the cell envelope composition of Proteus mirabilis during the development of swarmer cells.

Long, swarming cells of Proteus mirabilis had different proportions of some lipopolysaccharide components when compared to short cells, either agar grown or broth grown. Fluorescence spectrophotometry of antibody binding, and sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis indicated that the change was in the proportion of lipopolysaccharide with long O-antigenic sidechains, swarmer lipopolysaccharide relative to short sidechain lipopolysaccharide than the non-swarming cells. The proteins and phospholipids of the envelop remained the same during swarmer development. The results are discussed in relation to the increase in flagella synthesis and permeability to some antibacterial agents during swarmer development.     

Motility of three strains of Proteus mirabilis (G9, P11 and PM5C) in liquid suspension under different environmental conditions

The effect of compounds on the motility of Proteus mirabilis swarmer cells varies from one strain to another. The effect of compounds on the motility of swarmer cells is mainly at higher concentrations than the concentration used to inhibit swarming. Boric acid only affects the motility of strain G9 swarmer cells, whereas sodium deoxycholate prevented the motility of swarmer cells for three strains. Some antibiotics show their effect on the motility of swarmer cells in anaerobic areas, by slowing the movement of swarmer cells, followed by stopping the movement after a period of time or disappearance of the cells. The differentiation between the strains of Proteus species seems to be better in liquid suspension than on the solid medium.     

Synchronous cell differentiation in Caulobacter crescentus.

The growth of a stalked bacterium, Caulobacter crescentus, has been synchronized easily and reproducibly by a new method. When this bacterium is grown to a late log phase in nutrient broth at 30 C with aeration, swarmer cells are accumulated in the culture to 80% of the whole cell population. When this culture is inoculated into fresh pre-warmed broth at twentyfold dilution, it immediately initiates synchronous cell growth. Simultaneously, synchronous cell differentiation is monitored by the susceptibility of the cells to RNA phage infection. The swarmer cells accumulated in the late log phase of growth possess nearly the same susceptibility to RNA phage infection as those in the early log phase of growth while RNA phage-adsorbing capacity is lower in such swarmer cells. It is suggested that the swarmer cells accumulated in the late log phase of growth have lost some pili.     

Synchronous Cell Differentiation in Caulobacter crescentus

The growth of a stalked bacterium, Caulobacter crescentus, has been synchronized easily and reproducibly by a new method. When this bacterium is grown to a late log phase in nutrient broth at 30 C with aeration, swarmer cells are accumulated in the culture to 80% of the whole cell population. When this culture is inoculated into fresh pre-warmed broth at twentyfold dilution, it immediately initiates synchronous cell growth. Simultaneously, synchronous cell differentiation is monitored by the susceptibility of the cells to RNA phage infection. The swarmer cells accumulated in the late log phase of growth possess nearly the same susceptibility to RNA phage infection as those in the early log phase of growth while RNA phage-adsorbing capacity is lower in such swarmer cells. It is suggested that the swarmer cells accumulated in the late log phase of growth have lost some pili.     

Swarmer cell differentiation in Proteus mirabilis

Under the appropriate environmental conditions, the gram-negative bacterium Proteus mirabilis undergoes a remarkable differentiation to form a distinct cell type called a swarmer cell. The swarmer cell is characterized by a 20- to 40-fold increase in both cell length and the number of flagella per cell. Environmental conditions required for swarmer cell differentiation include: surface contact, inhibition of flagellar rotation, a sufficient cell density and cell-to-cell signalling. The differentiated swarmer cell is then able to carry out a highly ordered population migration termed swarming. Genetic analysis of the swarming process has revealed that a large variety of distinct loci are required for this differentiation including: genes involved in regulation, lipopolysaccharide and peptidoglycan synthesis, cell division, ATP production, putrescine biosynthesis, proteolysis and cell shape determination. The process of swarming is important medically because the expression of virulence genes and the ability to invade cells are coupled to the differentiated swarmer cell. In this review, the genetic and environmental requirements for swarmer cell differentiation will be outlined. In addition, the role of the differentiated swarmer cell in virulence and its possible role in biofilm formation will be discussed.     

Transposon mutagenesis in Proteus mirabilis.

A technique of transposon mutagenesis involving the use of Tn5 on a suicide plasmid was developed for Proteus mirabilis. Analysis of the resulting exconjugants indicated that Tn5 transposed in P. mirabilis at a frequency of ca. 4.5 x 10(-6) per recipient cell. The resulting mutants were stable and retained the transposon-encoded antibiotic resistance when incubated for several generations under nonselective conditions. The frequency of auxotrophic mutants in the population, as well as DNA-DNA hybridizaiton to transposon sequences, confirmed that the insertion of the transposon was random and the Proteus chromosome did not contain significant insertional hot spots of transposition. Approximately 35% of the mutants analyzed possessed plasmid-acquired ampicillin resistance, although no extrachromosomal plasmid DNA was found. In these mutants, insertion of the Tn5 element and a part or all of the plasmid had occurred. Application of this technique to the study of swarmer cell differentiation in P. mirabilis is discussed.     

Further studies of swarmer cell differentiation of Proteus mirabilis PM23: a requirement for iron and zinc

Proteus mirabilis PM23, unlike other motile strains of the species, differentiates in rich fluid media to form nonseptate filaments resembling the swarmer cells formed on solid media. The swarming activity of PM23 is greater than that of the other strains on solid media and it grows faster than another strain, IM47, in differentiation-supporting broth. This faster growth is not exhibited in broth that does not support differentiation. The differentiation of PM23 in brain-heart infusion broth occurs over a wide range of pH and temperature. Inhibitors of swarming on agar plates (p-nitrophenylglycerol and boric acid) and three chelating agents (EDTA, sodium cyanide, and sodium diethyldithiocarbamate) stop differentiation both on plates and in brain-heart infusion broth; however, EGTA is not effective even at 10 mM (10 times the minimum inhibitory concentration of EDTA). The inhibitory mechanisms of p-nitrophenylglycerol and boric acid are different from that of the chelating agents. The timing of EDTA inhibition suggests generation of a "signal" to differentiate after about 2 h growth. Prevention of differentiation by addition of Fe2+ and Zn2+ up to near the time that differentiation should appear suggests that these cations have a crucial involvement in the process of initiation. However, they are not effective as additives in allowing differentiation to occur in defined media or even nutrient broth; the further addition of nucleotides or cAMP was equally ineffective.     

Proteus mirabilis mutants defective in swarmer cell differentiation and multicellular behavior

Proteus mirabilis is a dimorphic bacterium which exists in liquid cultures as a 1.5- to 2.0-microns motile swimmer cell possessing 6 to 10 peritrichous flagella. When swimmer cells are placed on a surface, they differentiate by a combination of events that ultimately produce a swarmer cell. Unlike the swimmer cell, the polyploid swarmer cell is 60 to 80 microns long and possesses hundreds to thousands of surface-induced flagella. These features, combined with multicellular behavior, allow the swarmer cells to move over a surface in a process called swarming. Transposon Tn5 was used to produce P. mirabilis mutants defective in wild-type swarming motility. Two general classes of mutants were found to be defective in swarming. The first class was composed of null mutants that were completely devoid of swarming motility. The majority of nonswarming mutations were the result of defects in the synthesis of flagella or in the ability to rotate the flagella. The remaining nonswarming mutants produced flagella but were defective in surface-induced elongation. Strains in the second general class of mutants, which made up more than 65% of all defects in swarming were motile but were defective in the control and coordination of multicellular swarming. Analysis of consolidation zones produced by such crippled mutants suggested that this pleiotropic phenotype was caused by a defect in the regulation of multicellular behavior. A possible mechanism controlling the cyclic process of differentiation and dediferentiation involved in the swarming behavior of P. mirabilis is discussed.     

Structure of Proteus mirabilis biofilms grown in artificial urine and standard laboratory media

Proteus mirabilis is a urinary pathogen that can differentiate from a swimmer cell into a swarmer cell morphotype and can form biofilms on the surfaces of urinary catheters. These biofilms block these catheters due to crystals trapped within these structures. The effect of encrustation on biofilm formation and structure has not been studied using confocal scanning laser microscopy (CSLM). Therefore, a comparison of biofilm structure in artificial urine (AU) and laboratory media was undertaken. We compared the structure of P. mirabilis biofilms in AU and Luria-Bertani broth using CSLM and 3D imaging. Biofilms grown in Luria-Bertani broth formed mushroom structures at 24 h and contained nutrient channels. AU biofilms were observed to form a different structure at 24 h. AU biofilm structure was observed to be a flat layer, almost devoid of nutrient channels. Swarmer cells were observed protruding out of the biofilm into the bulk fluid. This could be due to nutrient depravation within the biofilm or a means of further colonizing the surface. This study has demonstrated that two markedly different biofilm structures are formed, depending on the growth media utilized.     

Evidence that putrescine acts as an extracellular signal required for swarming in Proteus mirabilis

In a search for Proteus mirabilis genes that were regulated by cell-to-cell signalling, a lacZ fusion (cmr437::mini-Tn5lacZ) was identified that was repressed 10-fold by a self-produced extracellular signal from wild-type cells. However, the cmr437::mini-Tn5lacZ insertion itself led to a marked reduction in this extracellular repressing signal. The cmr437::mini-Tn5lacZ insertion was mapped to a speA homologue in P. mirabilis. Sequence analysis indicated that a speB homologue was encoded downstream of speA. Products of the SpeA and SpeB enzymes (agmatine and putrescine) were tested for repression of cmr437::lacZ. Agmatine did not have repressing activity. However, putrescine was an effective repressing molecule at concentrations down to 30 microM. A second prominent phenotype of the cmr437 (speA)::mini-Tn5lacZ insertion was a severe defect in swarming motility. This swarming defect was also observed in a strain containing a disruption of the downstream speB gene. Differentiation of the speB mutant to swarmer cells was delayed by two hours relative to wild-type cells. Furthermore, the speB mutant was unable to migrate effectively across agar surfaces and formed very closely spaced swarming rings. Exogenous putrescine restored both the normal timing of swarmer cell differentiation and the ability to migrate to speB mutants.     

Genomic rearrangements in the flagellin genes of Proteus mirabilis

Molecular analyses have revealed that Proteus mirabilis possesses two genes, flaA and flaB, that are homologous to each other and to flagellin genes of many other species. Both swimmer and swarmer cells transcribe flaA, but not flaB. FlaA- mutants are non-motile and do not differentiate showing the essential role of flaA in swarmer cell differentiation and behaviour. At a low frequency, motile, differentiation-proficient revertants have been found in FlaA-populations. These revertants produce an antigenically and biochemically distinct flagellin protein. The revertant flagellin is the result of a genetic fusion between highly homologous regions of flaA and flaB that places the active flaA promoter and the 5' coding region of flaA adjacent to previously silent regions of flaB generating a hybrid flagellin protein. Analysis of the flaA-flaB region of two such revertants reveals that a portion of this locus has undergone a rearrangement and deletion event that is unique to each revertant. Using a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to amplify the falA-flaB locus from wild-type swimmer cells, swarmer cells and cells obtained after urinary tract infection, we uncover at least six general classes of rearrangements between flaA and flaB. Each class of rearrangement occurs within one of nine domains of homology between flaA and flaB. Rearrangement of flaA and flaB results in a hybrid flagellin protein of nearly identical size and biochemical properties, suggesting a concerted mechanism may be involved in this process. The data also reveal that the frequency and distribution of flaAB rearrangements is predicted on environmental conditions. Thus, rearrangement between flaA and flaB may be a significant virulence component of P. mirabilis in urinary tract infections.     

Coordinated regulation of two independent cell-cell signaling systems and swarmer differentiation in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium

Almost all members of the genus Salmonella differentiate and migrate on semisolid surfaces in a coordinated population behavior known as swarming. Important virulence determinants are coupled to swarmer differentiation in several other pathogenic organisms, collectively suggesting that conditions that trigger swarming in the laboratory may fortuitously promote the cells to enter a robust physiological state relevant to the host environment. Here, we present evidence that expression of two independent cell-cell signaling systems are also coupled to swarmer differentiation in S. enterica serovar Typhimurium. Expression of both pfs and sdiA genes was up-regulated in the actively migrating swarmers compared to their vegetative counterparts propagated in broth or spread plated on the surface of swim, swarm, and solid media. Accordingly, swarmers produced elevated levels of a universally recognized signaling molecule, autoinducer-2, and exhibited increased sensitivity to N-acyl homoserine lactones (AHLs), signaling molecules that Salmonella does not produce. Expression of the rck operon was concomitantly up-regulated in the swarmers in an SdiA-dependent manner only in the presence of exogenous AHLs. In addition to the previously reported adaptive antibiotic resistance phenotype and global shift in metabolism, this work presents another component of the physiological changes that are specifically associated with swarmer differentiation in serovar Typhimurium and not simply due to growth on a surface.     

Growth inhibition of Proteus mirabilis by cyclic adenosine 3''-5''-monophosphate.

Growth of Proteus mirabilis on a synthetic agar medium containing either glycerol, galactose, or trehalose as the sole source is inhibited by 5 mM cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP). Inhibition on an agar medium is evident as loss of viability, but in broth cAMP only slightly inhibits growth rate. Inhibition is associated with the accumulation of methylglyoxal in the medium. A nonswarming mutant of P. mirabilis is not inhibited by cAMP on either of the three carbon sources, but it is sensitive to exogenous methylglyoxal.     

Urease activity related to the growth and differentiation of swarmer cells of Proteus mirabilis

Urease activity was measured using whole cells of both long (swarming) and short (nonswarming) populations of Proteus mirabilis from casein hydrolysate agar (CHA) and broth (CHB) cultures, and from brain heart infusion broth (BHIB) cultures. Urease is a constitutive enzyme for both long and short cells, but its activity was tremendously increased when urea was incorporated into the media. Urease production was also affected by culture age and media used. Before exponential phase, urease activity was very low, and it increased to its highest point after about 4 h in BHIB and 8 h in both CHA and CHB cultures at 37 degrees C. Long cells had higher urease activity than did short cells when grown on CHA, and was also expressed by two different strains cultured in BHIB. Strain PM23, in BHIB, was able to form long cells (swarming cells) to a maximum proportion after about 4 h, but strain IM47 could not differentiate in any of the liquid media. The former had more urease when swarming differentiation was initiated. PM23 grew relatively faster than IM47 when the former began to differentiate, but this fast growth could not be observed when nutrient broth or minimal medium was used. These observations suggest that long or swarming cells are "faster growing" rather than "nongrowing bacteria".     

Acidic conditions enhance bactericidal effects of sodium bisulfite on Helicobacter pylori

BACKGROUND: The Brucella broth medium, which is often used for the cultivation of microaerobic bacteria including Helicobacter pylori. It contains sodium bisulfite to decrease oxygen content in the medium. The growth of H. pylori, however, is inhibited by sodium bisulfite. In this study, the effect of sodium bisulfite was compared with several antioxidants and quantified under acidic conditions, mimicking the gastric environment. METHODS: Growth of H. pylori in the presence of several antioxidants was evaluated at OD655 nm. Effect of sodium bisulfite on H. pylori under acidic conditions was evaluated by measuring colony forming units (cfu). RESULTS: Under neutral conditions, sodium bisulfite was a more potent suppressor of H. pylori. Resveratrol, a polyphenol found in wine, exhibited the most potent inhibitory activity. To quantify the effect of sodium bisulfite on H. pylori under acidic conditions, the bacteria were grown at 37 degrees C for 30 minutes in 0.15 mol/l HCl/KCl (pH 2.0) with or without urea and sodium bisulfite. Sodium bisulfite (0.5 mmol/l) did not affect the viability at neutral pH 7.0, however, it killed H. pylori under acidic conditions, even if urea, the key substance enabling H. pylori to survive under acidic conditions, was present. The bacteria, which had been incubated under acidic conditions in the presence of urea, could survive a subsequent 30 minute-incubation at pH 2.0 without urea. Presence of sodium bisulfite, however, in the subsequent 30 minute-incubation, killed the bacteria. CONCLUSIONS: The bactericidal effect of sodium bisulfite on H. pylori was greater under acidic conditions and independent of urease activity.