Cellular energy levels and their effect on male cell abortion in cytoplasmically male sterile lines of Petunia hybrida

Summary Using an HPLC method it has proved possible to follow the levels of adenine and pyridine nucleotides in the anthers of normal and cytoplasmically male sterile (CMS) lines of Petunia hybrida. Well before the appearance of any structural differences, anthers of CMS plants begin to show lower ATP/ADP ratios. In anthers, as in other non-photosynthetic plant tissues, there is a strong correlation between the ATP/ADP ratio and levels of NADPH and, when NADPH was assayed in fertile and CMS anthers, very dramatic differences were discovered. In male fertile plants, the NADPH/NADP ratio differs strikingly between somatic and reproductive tissues and reaches a peak in anthers at the early prophase of meiosis. The ratio in male sterile anthers remains largely unchanged from that normally seen in somatic tissues over this period. A cytochemical localisation technique revealed that, at the stage of development in question, the major reserves of anther NADPH are held within the tapetal cells and that levels within CMS tapeta are strikingly lower than those of normal plants. These findings are discussed in the perspective of theories proposed to explain the operation of CMS, and also in terms of the now conclusive evidence that the genetical basis of CMS lies in changes in the organisation of the mitochondrial genome.     

Differential Mitochondrial Electron Transport through the Cyanide-Sensitive and Cyanide-Insensitive Pathways in Isonuclear Lines of Cytoplasmic Male Sterile, Male Fertile, and Restored Petunia

Three pairs of isonuclear lines of cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) and fertile Petunia cells (Petunia hybrida [Hook] Vilm. and Petunia parodii L.S.M.) grown in suspension culture were examined for sensitivity to inhibitors of respiratory electron transport at time-points after transfer into fresh media. Cells from CMS lines differed from cells of fertile lines in their utilization of the cyanide-insensitive oxidase pathway. Under our culture regime, after approximately 3 days of culture cells from the CMS lines exhibited much lower cyanide-insensitive, salicylhydroxamic acid-sensitive respiration than cells from the fertile lines. This respiratory difference was shown to be specific to the mitochondrial alternative oxidase pathway by using other characteristic inhibitors of mitochondrial electron transport in experiments with isolated mitochondria. Immature anthers from CMS plants also showed lower alternative oxidase activity relative to anthers from male fertile plants, but no such difference was detected in leaf tissue, ovary or perianth tissue, or anthers collected just prior to anthesis. A cell line from a fertile plant carrying a nuclear fertility restorer gene and the CMS cytoplasm exhibited increased activity of the alternative pathway compared with the CMS lines.     

On the mechanism of cytoplasmic male sterility in the 447 line of Vicia faba

The trait of cytoplasmic male sterility, expressed in plants bearing the 447 cytoplasm of Vicia faba, is uniquely and positively correlated with the presence of a linear double-stranded RNA molecule (dsRNA) 16.7 kb in size. Restriction enzyme digestion profiles of mitochondrial DNA isolated from fertile and cytoplasmic malesterile (CMS) lines do show a limited number of specific differences in fragment intensities and mobilities. However, mitochondria isolated from the progeny of the cross CMS × Restorer line contain DNA with an identical restriction profile as the male-sterile parent: moreover, subsequent generations are completely and permanently fertile, even upon segregation of the nuclear restoration gene. Southern hybridizations, using cDNA clones as probes, reveal homology between the CMS-associated dsRNA and the nuclear genome of both sterile and fertile lines. The regions cloned, representing approximately 22% of the total dsRNA sequence, show no homology to organelle DNA. We have not been able to stably transmit the dsRNA to fertile lines of V. faba or any other plant species, using a variety of standard virological techniques.     

植物细胞质雄性不育系育种的反向核置换技术分析

通过不育细胞质为选择背景,在田间事先鉴定出杂种后代的优异完全不育株,用花药培养或诱导孤雌生殖使其纯合,测定其配合力,可以筛选到优良的目标不育系。以下3种方法则可能通过目标不育系而获得其同型保持系：一是通过体细胞变异(花药培养)产生;二是在不育系孕穗期高温或低温处理使其转换成可育,选择仍具有不育保持能力的作为保持系,或作为轮回亲本,将其细胞核换到可育细胞质中;三是用原生质体融合的方式向不育系导入已杀死细胞核的可育细胞质而获得配套保持系。它可以使杂种优势利用变得有预见性,可能提高现有杂种优势水平。在创造雄性不育新质源,排除微效可育基因,进行不育系的定向改造,选育高配合力不育系,以及加速育种进程等方面具有重要价值。     

Differences on the microsporogenesis and tapetal development of male fertile and cytoplasmic male sterile pepper (Capsicum annuum L.)

To clarify the time and cause of pollen abortion, differences on the microsporogenesis and tapetum development in the anthers of male fertile maintainer line and cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) line pepper were studied using transmission electron microscopy. The results showed that CMS line anthers appeared to have much greater variability in developmental pattern than male fertile maintainer line ones. The earliest deviation from normal anther development occurred in CMS line anthers at prophase I was cytomixis in some microspore mother cells (MMCs), and vacuolisation in tapetal cells. Then, MMCs in CMS line anthers developed asynchronously and a small part of ones at the different stage degenerated in advance appearing to have typical morphological features of programmed cell death (PCD). Most MMCs could complete the meiosis, but formed non-tetrahedral tetrad microspores with irregular shape and different size and uncertain number of nuclei, and some degenerated ahead of time as well. Tapetal cells in CMS line anther degenerated during meiosis, and were crushed at the tetrad stage, which paralleled the collapse of pollens. Pollen abortion in CMS line anthers happened by PCD themselves, and the premature PCD of tapetal cells were closely associated with male sterility.     

白菜细胞核雄性不育花药的细胞化学观察

对一种由一对隐性基因控制的白菜细胞核雄性不育和可育株的花药进行了细胞学和组织化学研究。种子播种后,有1／4植株为不育株,其余的为可育株。通过对不育株和可育株花药发育的细胞学观察,确认不育花粉的败育发生在小孢子发育时期。用组织化学的方法研究了可育株和不育株花药发育过程中的多糖和脂类的分布动态,发现在减数分裂前,可育花药和不育花药的药隔细胞中都储藏了大量的淀粉粒。二者的差异仅是不育花药的绒毡层细胞液泡化明显。在减数分裂后的小孢子发育时期,可育花药的绒毡层细胞具有将药隔细胞中的淀粉粒多糖吸收并转化成脂类的功能,小孢子及以后的二胞花粉中也积累了大量的脂类储藏物质。在不育花药中,虽然减数分裂后药隔细胞中的淀粉粒也都消失,但绒毡层细胞中的脂类物质相比很少,同时绒毡层细胞显示了明显的多糖反应,表明不育花药的绒毡层细胞将糖类转化为脂类的功能受阻。在小孢子的表面有些脂类物质,但在细胞质中却没有脂类积累。这一结果暗示在该种白菜细胞核雄性不育株中,由于花药绒毡层细胞转换多糖为脂类的功能失常,导致了小孢子的败育。     

Effects of Petunia cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) cytoplasm on the development of sterile and fertility-restored P. parodii anthers

The developmental defects causing cytoplasmic male sterility in Petunia parodii are described in isonuclear fertile, sterile, and fertility-restored plants using both light- and scanning electron microscopy. The aberrant development of the sporogenous tissue and tapetal layer caused by the cytoplasmic male sterile cytoplasm in both Petunia hybrida and P. parodii nuclear backgrounds is similar in onset and progression. The degeneration of the sporogenous tissue and tapetal layer of sterile anthers is first apparent late in meiosis and results in highly abnormal sterile sporogenous tissue by tetrad stage of fertile anthers. The stomium and endothecium do not show major developmental differences between fertile and sterile anthers, but the inner connective tissue of sterile anthers contained calcium crystals not found at high abundance in fertile anthers. Ovoid bodies containing magnesium and phosphorus were seen only in the vascular bundles of fertile anthers. Material prepared for the scanning electron microscope by freeze drying showed better retention of fragile morphological features, while critical-point drying permitted examination of nonvolatile structures, such as cell walls.     

萝卜CMS不育系与保持系小孢子发生的细胞学研究

研究了萝卜胞质雄性不育系A2、A4及其相应保持系B2、B4的小孢子发生与花药壁发育的细胞学特征.结果表明,不育系A2的绒毡层细胞在四分体时期出现异常,小液泡增多,至单核期汇合形成大液泡,绒毡层细胞异常膨大;小孢子外壁染色浅,细胞壁受到破坏,最后与绒毡层一同降解.不育系A4在减数分裂期即表现出异常,绒毡层异常肥大;花药发育后期,小孢子外壁亦染色较浅;绒毡层细胞融合形成细胞团块侵入药室挤压小孢子,两者一同降解.     

A comparative light and electron microscopic analysis of microspore and tapetum development in fertile and cytoplasmic male sterile radish

To gain further insight into the abortive stages and ultrastructural changes leading to pollen degeneration of a novel cytoplasmic male sterile radish 805A, we compared differences of cellular and subcellular structure of sterile anther with fertile anther by light and electron microscopy analysis. Two types of locule degeneration in sterile anther were detected, of which the time of degeneration occurred and completed was different. In type I, abnormality of pollen mother cells (PMCs) and tapetal cells, including condensation of cytoplasm and large vacuoles within tapetal cells, was shown at PMC stage. In type II, meiosis and early tetrad stage progressed normally except for large vacuoles that appeared in tapetal cells. Ultrastructural alterations of the cellular organization were observed in the type II locules, such as chromatin condensation at the periphery of the nucleus and degeneration of the karyotheca, compared with normal pollen development. The results suggested that the cytoplasmic male sterility anther degeneration was probably caused by dysfunctions of tapetum and vacuolation of tapetum, PMCs, and microspores. Thus, the identical factors, which induced CMS in the same cytoplasmic and nuclear genetic background, might affect development of tapetum and microspore at different stages during the cytoplasmic male sterile 805A anther development.     

Isolation,sorting, and characterization of uni- and binucleate tapetal protoplasts from anthers of normal and Texas cytoplasmic male-sterileZea mays L.

Summary A cytological study of Texas cytoplasmic male sterile (Tcms) and normal (N) anther tapetal protoplasts ofZea mays was undertaken to determine whether there were any differences prior to Tcms male cell abortion not noted in previous published studies. Squash preparations, tapetal protoplast separation via flow cytometry, image analysis, and electron microscopy were utilized. Chemically preserved tapetal protoplasts from both lines were prominently angular in shape and typically smaller than any other cell type in the anthers. The tapetum from both lines consisted of a mixture of uninucleate and binucleate protoplasts. The Tcms tapetum consistently had a higher proportion of binucleate protoplasts during all stages of microsporogenesis prior to abortion. The size of Tcms uniand binucleate tapetal protoplasts was more variable than the N tapetal protoplasts and was largest during the microspore stage when male cells abort. Tapetal nuclear size in both lines was less variable. Uni- and binucleate tapetal protoplasts from each line could be separated from the other anther cells and from each other by filtration and then by flow cytometry, based on intensity of nuclear fluorescence. These results suggest that Tcms uninucleate tapetal protoplasts have a higher level of DNA than N uninucleate tapetal protoplasts. Both fluorescence microscopy and electron microscopy confirmed pure populations of intact uni- and binucleate tapetal protoplasts using flow cytometry. The results from this study indicate that the methodology presented here could be used for a variety of further studies to better understand the cellular and molecular basis of male sterility in maize, and in other taxa, where the tapetum is the primary target that leads to male sterility.Abbreviations AO acridine orange - Bi binucleate protoplast - D dyad - DAPI 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole - FC flow cytometry - M meiocyte - MI microspore - MMC mithramycin - N normal anther tapetal protoplast - PI propidium iodide - PS protoplast sorting - RT room temperature - SM sporogenous mass - Tems Texas cytoplasmic male sterile anther tapetal protoplast - Uni uninucleate protoplast     

Cytochemical investigation of genic male-sterility in Chinese cabbage

A genic male sterile Chinese cabbage, Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis Makino, was examined using cytological and cytochemical methods to characterize the process of pollen abortion in this plant. Thick sections of both fertile and sterile anthers at different developmental stages were stained using Toluidine Blue O, Periodic Acid-Schiff’s (PAS) reaction and Sudan Black B to detect cytochemical changes that may occur in the distribution of insoluble polysaccharide and lipid storage bodies. Pollen abortion in sterile anthers occurs at an early stage of microspore development. During early microspore development, reductions in the number of starch grains in the connective tissue of fertile anthers coincide with the accumulation of starch grains in cells of the anther wall. In the late microspore stage, a large vacuole forms in the microspore, and tapetal cells synthesize and accumulate lipid droplets. The cellular organization of tapetal cells in sterile anthers appears similar to that in fertile anthers, except for the absence of lipid droplets in cells of sterile anthers and diffusely labeled tapetal polysaccharides, suggesting defects in nutrient storage. Supported by National Natural Science Foundation of CHINA (30170060)     

ORGANELLE SIZE AND NUMBER IN FERTILE AND T-CYTOPLASMIC MALE-STERILE CORN

Anthers of inbred F₄₄ fertile (N) and cytoplasmic male-sterile (T) corn plants (Zea mays L.) were compared cytologically. No differences between fertile and sterile anthers were observed in size and number of mitochondria or plastids until after the start of anther degeneration. A rapid division of mitochondria was observed, however, in the tapetum and sporogenous cells of both fertile and sterile anthers during early growth stages. This rapid increase in mitochondrial numbers per cell (some 20-to 40-fold) preceded tapetal breakdown in sterile anthers and did not occur in other anther cells or in plastids. Limited observations on the megagametophyte and nucellus revealed that mitochondria in ovules remain relatively constant in size and number during gametogenesis and do not undergo degeneration.     

植物细胞质雄性不育系育种的反向核置换技术分析

通过不育细胞质为选择背景,在田间事先鉴定出杂种后代的优异完全不育株,用花药培养或诱导孤雌生殖使其纯合,测定其配合力,可以筛选到优良的目标不育系.以下3种方法则可能通过目标不育系而获得其同型保持系:一是通过体细胞变异(花药培养)产生;二是在不育系孕穗期高温或低温处理使其转换成可育,选择仍具有不育保持能力的作为保持系,或作为轮回亲本,将其细胞核换到可育细胞质中;三是用原生质体融合的方式向不育系导入已杀死细胞核的可育细胞质而获得配套保持系.它可以使杂种优势利用变得有预见性,可能提高现有杂种优势水平.在创造雄性不育新质源,排除微效可育基因,进行不育系的定向改造,选育高配合力不育系,以及加速育种进程等方面具有重要价值.     

Cytological and molecular characterization of a novel monogenic dominant GMS in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica napus</Emphasis> L.

A novel genic male sterile (GMS) line in Brassica napus L., which was identified in 1999, was found to be controlled by a monogenic dominant gene, which we have designated as MDGMS. The microspores of the MDGMS abort before the degradation of the tapetal cell layer. The F1 fertility from any fertile lines crossed with MDGMS segregated and the ratio was close to 1:1. Bulked segregation analysis (BSA) was employed to identify random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers linked to the Ms gene in MDGMS. Among 880 random 10-mer oligonucleotide primers screened against the bulk DNA of sterile and fertile, one primer S243 (5′-CTATGCCGAC-3′) gave a repeatable 1500-bp DNA polymorphic segment S243₁₅₀₀ between the two bulks. Analysis of individual plants of each bulks and other types of GMS and cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) lines suggest that the RAPD marker S243₁₅₀₀ is closely linked to the MDGMS locus in rapeseed. This RAPD marker has been converted into sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR) marker to aid identification of male-fertility genotypes in segregating progenies of MDGMS in marker-assisted selection (MAS) breeding programs.     

DNA,RNA, AND PROTEIN COMPARISONS BETWEEN NODULATED AND NON-NODULATED MALE-STERILE AND MALE-FERTILE GENOTYPES OF SOYBEAN (GLYCINE MAX L.)

Four soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) lines isogenic except for loci controlling male sterility (ms₁) and nodulation (rj₁) were developed to study the effects of reproductive development and nitrogen source on the nucleic acid and protein levels within the leaves. Changes in DNA, RNA, protein, and cellular viability were measured from flowering (77 days after emergence) until maturity (147 days after emergence) in leaves of nodulated and non-nodulated male-sterile and fertile soybean genotypes. Leaf nuclei from the sterile genotypes yielded DNA amounts that were significantly higher than those from the fertile lines. The average DNA values for the nodulated sterile and nodulated fertile lines at 147 days after emergence were 7.01 and 2.45 picograms, respectively. The average 2C DNA amount as determined from dividing root-tip nuclei was 2.83 picograms, which indicated occurrence of endopolyploid mechanisms in the sterile lines and age-related loss of DNA in fertile lines. Similar to DNA findings, the RNA and protein values in the sterile lines were significantly higher than those values observed in the fertile lines, suggesting an increased capacity to synthesize protein. The soybean leaf nuclear DNA declined, especially in the fertile lines in terms of the percent endopolyploid nuclei as well as the average DNA content during maturation. The DNA decline in leaves of fertile genotypes suggests that the leaves may be exporting nucleosides and phosphates to the seeds during embryo formation. In the sterile lines, due to the reduced pod-set, these ready reserves of nucleosides and phosphates tended to accumulate in the chromatin of the leaf nucleus as manifested by the DNA specific Feulgen stain. By the end of the study (147 days after emergence), the nodulated fertile genotypes had experienced a dramatic loss in DNA, RNA, and protein. The nodulated sterile genotypes, however, indicated 65% more DNA, 59% more RNA, and 53% more protein as compared to the nodulated fertile genotypes at 147 days after emergence. The sterile lines also indicated the slowest increase in the death of cells, while the fertile lines indicated the fastest increase in nonviable cells, as shown by trypan blue staining. The fertile lines displayed normal monocarpic senescence throughout the study. The reproductive structures of fertile plants utilized the molecules in seed production, whereas in the sterile lines, these accumulated in leaf cells.     

甜椒胞质雄性不育雄配子发育的解剖学和超微结构研究

运用石蜡切片和电子显微镜超薄切片方法观察了甜椒(Capsicum annuum L．)细胞质雄性不育系8A和保持系8B雄配子发育过程。结果表明：不育系和保持系都能正常进行减数分裂,绒毡层细胞无明显差异,形成了正常的四分孢子。在四分体单核居中期后,不育系的绒毡层细胞异常膨大并伸进药室,挤压花粉粒,同时绒毡层细胞提前降解,不育系单核晚期花粉粒开始崩出内含物。致使不育系的雄配子在双核花粉粒形成之前就完全裂解,不能发育成正常的花粉粒。此外,超薄切片还观察到不育系花粉粒在单核早期绒毡层细胞线粒体空泡化,这种变化表明雄性不育的遗传缺陷包括在花药发育早期发生的线粒体结构变化。     

白菜细胞核雄性不育花药的细胞化学观察

对一种由一对隐性基因控制的白菜细胞核雄性不育和可育株的花药进行了细胞学和组织化学研究。种子播种后,有1/4植株为不育株,其余的为可育株。通过对不育株和可育株花药发育的细胞学观察,确认不育花粉的败育发生在小孢子发育时期。用组织化学的方法研究了可育株和不育株花药发育过程中的多糖和脂类的分布动态,发现在减数分裂前,可育花药和不育花药的药隔细胞中都储藏了大量的淀粉粒。二者的差异仅是不育花药的绒毡层细胞液泡化明显。在减数分裂后的小孢子发育时期,可育花药的绒毡层细胞具有将药隔细胞中的淀粉粒多糖吸收并转化成脂类的功能,小孢子及以后的二胞花粉中也积累了大量的脂类储藏物质在不育花药中,虽然减数分裂后药隔细胞中的淀粉粒也都消失,但绒毡层细胞中的脂类物质相比很少,同时绒毡层细胞显示了明显的多糖反应,表明不育花药的绒毡层细胞将糖类转化为脂类的功能受阻。在小孢子的表面有些脂类物质,但在细胞质中却没有脂类积累。这一结果暗示在该种白菜细胞核雄性不育株中,由于花药绒毡层细胞转换多糖为脂类的功能失常,导致了小孢子的败育。     

A fertile revertant from petaloid cytoplasmic male-sterile carrot has a rearranged mitochondrial genome

 A spontaneously derived fertile plant was recovered from a petaloid cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) carrot inbred line. Genetic analysis indicated a single nuclear gene was responsible for the restoration to fertility. Within a family segregating for the nuclear restorer in combination with the sterility-inducing cytoplasm, fertile plants were recovered that could not restore fertility when crossed to sterile genotypes. Genetic analysis indicated cytoplasmic reversion for fertility, and Southern analysis, comparing mtDNA organization of the fertile revertant and its CMS progenitor, identified mitochondrial genome rearrangements. Hybridization of cosmids representing a 108-kb subgenomic circle of the sterile line to DNA of a fertile maintainer and fertile revertant lines indicated a similar mtDNA organization for these genotypes that was distinct from that of the sterile line. Six restriction fragments totalling 43.2 kb were common to the fertile maintainer and revertant and absent in the sterile; other restriction fragments totalling 38.2 kb were present only for the sterile line. Unique fragments of low stoichiometry, two for the fertile maintainer and three for the revertant, distinguished these lines. The reversion to fertility in the sterile line could have resulted from the amplification of a mitochondrial submolar genome highly homologous to that found in the fertile maintainer line. Received: 4 October 1997/Accepted: 12 December 1997     

Small mitochondrial DNA molecules of wild abortive cytoplasm in rice are not necessarily associated with CMS

Summary Mitochondrial DNA was isolated from leaf tissue of both the cytoplasmic male sterile line of Indica rice variety V41, which carries wild abortive (WA) cytoplasm, and from the corresponding maintainer line. In addition to the main mitochondrial DNA, four small plasmid-like DNA molecules were detected in both the male sterile and fertile lines. Restriction analysis of total mitochondrial DNA from the male sterile and fertile lines showed DNA fragments unique to each. Our findings suggest that the four small mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) molecules are conserved when WA cytoplasm is transferred into different nuclear backgrounds. However, there is no simple correlation between the presence/ absence of small mitochondrial DNA molecules and the expression of WA cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS).