Polyphasic characterization of rhizobia microsymbionts of common bean [<Emphasis Type="Italic">Phaseolus vulgaris</Emphasis> (L.)] isolated in Mato Grosso do Sul,a hotspot of Brazilian biodiversity

Common bean [Phaseolus vulgaris (Linnaeus)] is the key source of protein, carbohydrates and micronutrients for over 300 million people in the tropics. Like many legumes, P. vulgaris can fix atmospheric nitrogen in symbiosis with rhizobia, alleviating the need for the expensive and polluting N-fertilizers. The crop is known to nodulate with a wide range of rhizobia and, although Brazil is not a center of genetic origin/domestication of P. vulgaris, a variety of rhizobial species have been found as symbionts of the legume. Mato Grosso do Sul (MS) is one of the largest common bean producer states in Brazil, with reports of high yields and abundant natural nodulation. The objective of this study was to evaluate the diversity of 73 indigenous rhizobia isolated from common bean grown in 22 municipalities of MS. Great morphophysiological and genetic diversity was found, as indicated by the six and 35 clusters formed, considering the similarity level of 75 and 70%, respectively, for the phenotypic and rep-PCR dendrograms. Eleven representative isolates were selected for detailed genetic characterization using 16S rRNA and three protein-coding housekeeping genes, glnII, gyrB and recA. We identified species originated from the centers of origin/domestication of the legume, R. etli and R. phaseoli, species probably indigenous of Brazil, R. leucaenae and others of the Rhizobium/Agrobacterium clade, in addition to putative new species. The results highlight the great rhizobial diversity of the region.     

Agrobacterium strains isolated from root nodules of common bean specifically reduce nodulation by Rhizobium gallicum

In a previous work, we showed that non-nodulating agrobacteria strains were able to colonize root nodules of common bean. Both rhizobia and agrobacteria co-existed in the infected nodules. No impact on symbiosis was found in laboratory conditions when using sterile gravel as a support for growth. In this study, soil samples originating from different geographic and agronomic regions in Tunisia were inoculated with a mixture of agrobacteria strains isolated previously from root nodules of common bean. A significant effect on nodulation and vegetal growth of common bean was observed. Characterization of nodulating rhizobia and comparison with non-inoculated controls showed a biased genetic structure. It seemed that Rhizobium gallicum was highly inhibited, whereas nodulation by Sinorhizobium medicae was favored. Co-inoculation of non-sterile soils with R. gallicum and agrobacteria confirmed these findings. In vitro antibiosis assays indicated that agrobacteria exercised a significant antagonism against R. gallicum.     

Genetic diversity in cultivated carioca common beans based on molecular marker analysis

A wide array of molecular markers has been used to investigate the genetic diversity among common bean species. However, the best combination of markers for studying such diversity among common bean cultivars has yet to be determined. Few reports have examined the genetic diversity of the carioca bean, commercially one of the most important common beans in Brazil. In this study, we examined the usefulness of two molecular marker systems (simple sequence repeats - SSRs and amplified fragment length polymorphisms - AFLPs) for assessing the genetic diversity of carioca beans. The amount of information provided by Roger's modified genetic distance was used to analyze SSR data and Jaccards similarity coefficient was used for AFLP data. Seventy SSRs were polymorphic and 20 AFLP primer combinations produced 635 polymorphic bands. Molecular analysis showed that carioca genotypes were quite diverse. AFLPs revealed greater genetic differentiation and variation within the carioca genotypes (Gst = 98% and Fst = 0.83, respectively) than SSRs and provided better resolution for clustering the carioca genotypes. SSRs and AFLPs were both suitable for assessing the genetic diversity of Brazilian carioca genotypes since the number of markers used in each system provided a low coefficient of variation. However, fingerprint profiles were generated faster with AFLPs, making them a better choice for assessing genetic diversity in the carioca germplasm.     

An interdisciplinary research strategy to improve symbiotic nitrogen fixation and yield of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) in salinised areas of the Mediterranean basin

The main findings of a cooperative research group of agronomists, plant breeders, microbiologists, physiologists and molecularists to improve the symbiotic nitrogen fixation (SNF) and N2-dependent yield of common bean under moderate salinity in the Mediterranean basin are summarised. Agronomic surveys in reference production areas show large spatial and temporal variations in plant nodulation and growth, and in efficiency of utilisation of the rhizobial symbiosis. The latter was associated with a large rhizobial diversity, including new bean nodulating species. Macrosymbiont diversity in SNF and adaptation to NaCl was found. However, contrasts between plant genotypes could be altered by specific interactions with some native rhizobia. Therefore, variations in soil rhizobial population, in addition to agronomic practices and environmental constraints, may have contributed to erratic results observed in field inoculations. At the mechanistic level, nodule C and N metabolisms, and abcissic acid content, were related to SNF potential and tolerance to NaCl. Their relation with nodule conductance to O2 diffusion was addressed by in situ hybridisation of candidate carbonic anhydrase and aquaporin genes in nodule cortex. The limits and prospects of the cooperative strategy are discussed.     

Genetic resources of nodule bacteria

Nodule bacteria (rhizobia) form highly specific symbiosis with leguminous plants. The efficiency of accumulation of biological nitrogen depends on molecular-genetic interaction between the host plant and rhizobia. Genetic characteristics of microsymbiotic strains are crucial in developing highly productive and stress-resistant symbiotic pairs: rhizobium strain-host plant cultivar (species). The present review considers the issue of studying genetic resources of nodule bacteria to identify genes and their blocks, responsible for the ability of rhizobia to form highly effective symbiosis in various agroecological conditions. The main approaches to investigate of intraspecific and interspecific genetic and genomic diversity of nodule bacteria are considered, from MLEE analysis to the recent methods of genomic DNA analysis using biochips. The data are presented showing that gene centers of host plants are centers of genetic diversification of nodule bacteria, because the intraspecific polymorphism of genetic markers of the core and the accessory rhizobial genomes is extremely high in them. Genotypic features of trapped and nodule subpopulations of alfalfa nodule bacteria are discussed. A survey of literature showed that the genomes of natural strains in alfalfa gene centers exhibit significant differences in genes involved in control of metabolism, replication, recombination, and the formation of defense response (hsd genes). Natural populations of rhizobia are regarded as a huge gene pool serving as a source of evolutionary innovations.     

Diversity and specificity of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viciae on wild and cultivated legumes

The symbiotic partnerships between legumes and their root-nodule bacteria (rhizobia) vary widely in their degree of specificity, but the underlying reasons are not understood. To assess the potential for host-range evolution, we have investigated microheterogeneity among the shared symbionts of a group of related legume species. Host specificity and genetic diversity were characterized for a soil population of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viciae (Rlv) sampled using six wild Vicia and Lathyrus species and the crop plants pea (Pisum sativum) and broad bean (Vicia faba). Genetic variation among 625 isolates was assessed by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of loci on the chromosome (ribosomal gene spacer) and symbiosis plasmid (nodD region). Broad bean strongly favoured a particular symbiotic genotype that formed a distinct phylogenetic subgroup of Rlv nodulation genotypes but was associated with a range of chromosomal backgrounds. Host range tests of 80 isolates demonstrated that only 34% of isolates were able to nodulate V. faba. By contrast, 89% were able to nodulate all the local wild hosts tested, so high genetic diversity of the rhizobial population cannot be ascribed directly to the diversity of host species at the site. Overall the picture is of a population of symbionts that is diversified by plasmid transfer and shared fairly indiscriminately by local wild legume hosts. The crop species are less promiscuous in their interaction with symbionts than the wild legumes.     

Diversity of a soybean rhizobial population adapted to a Cerrados soil

One hundred isolates were trapped by soybean (Glycine max) plants inoculated with a soil from the Cerrados, the main producing area in Brazil. The soil was originally void of rhizobia able to nodulate soybean, and 15 years before received inoculant containing Bradyrhizobium elkanii strains SEMIA 587 and SEMIA 5019; the area has been annually cropped with soybean since then, but with no further inoculation for the past 7 years. Enormous diversity was observed among the isolates, with thirteen serologically distinct groups, twelve protein and seven lipopolysaccharide profiles; no more than five isolates shared similar characteristics. An unexpected feature was that 48% of the isolates showed multiple reactions with the antisera to the serogroups established in the soils. Also 40% of the isolates reacted with the antiserum to B. japonicum strain SEMIA 566, that has never been introduced into the soil, probably due to dispersion from other cropping areas, associated with its high saprophytic competence; 13% of the isolates did not react with any of the antisera. Nodulation and N₂ fixation capacity also varied considerably among the isolates. Although one third of the isolates were fast growers with an acid reaction in vitro, and many formed pseudo-nodules on common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris), they shared several properties with the Bradyrhizobium inoculant strains. A high level of genetic diversity was confirmed when the DNAs were amplified with BOX and RPO1 primers, and several isolates were positioned in far different clusters in the analysis of interspersed repetitive or nif-directed sequences. Moreover, serological properties showed higher correlation with BOX than with RPO1 products. The high diversity could be attributed both to lateral transfer of genetic material between inoculant and indigenous strains and to genomic rearrangements during the adaptation to the Cerrados, and may play an important role as a biological buffer, avoiding the dominance of a particular strain.     

Nod factors stimulate seed germination and promote growth and nodulation of pea and vetch under competitive conditions

Nod factors are lipochitooligosaccharide (LCO) produced by soil bacteria commonly known as rhizobia acting as signals for the legume plants to initiate symbiosis. Nod factors trigger early symbiotic responses in plant roots and initiate the development of specialized plant organs called nodules, where biological nitrogen fixation takes place. Here, the effect of specific LCO originating from flavonoid induced Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae GR09 culture was studied on germination, plant growth and nodulation of pea and vetch. A crude preparation of GR09 LCO significantly enhanced symbiotic performance of pea and vetch grown under laboratory conditions and in the soil. Moreover, the effect of GR09 LCOs seed treatments on the genetic diversity of rhizobia recovered from vetch and pea nodules was presented.     

Nodulation ability in different genotypes of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Phaseolus lunatus</Emphasis> by rhizobia from California agricultural soils

Phaseolus lunatus is the second economically most important species of the genus Phaseolus. It carries out N fixation through symbiosis with rhizobia. However, it is unclear whether P. lunatus can nodulate with native rhizobia from soils where this legume is not native or was not cultivated previously. Thus, this study assessed the ability of 14 geographically distant lima bean genotypes to nodulate with rhizobia from three California agricultural soils: without a history of legumes or P. lunatus cultivation, with a history of legumes as a cover crop, and with a history of P. lunatus cultivation. Nodulation only occurred on genotypes grown in the soil with a history of P. lunatus planting. The analysis of variance of nodulation traits showed that the genotype effect was highly significant in all the traits measured. Shoot biomass had a higher correlation with nodule size and nodule weight than with nodule number. In addition, shoot biomass and leaf N content were positively correlated with nodule coloration and with nodule position close to the main root of the plant. This study suggests that agricultural soils from California do not appear to have native rhizobia able to nodulate P. lunatus, which suggests the need to inoculate, at least initially, the seeds at planting in order to establish the population of rhizobia. Also, geographically distant lima bean genotypes have different responses to nodulating bacteria and it suggests that future studies to test these genotypes across different environments should be pursued.     

Assess suitability of hydroaeroponic culture to establish tripartite symbiosis between different AMF species, beans, and rhizobia

Background  

Like other species of the Phaseoleae tribe, common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) has the potential to establish symbiosis with rhizobia and to fix the atmospheric dinitrogen (N₂) for its N nutrition. Common bean has also the potential to establish symbiosis with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) that improves the uptake of low mobile nutrients such as phosphorus, from the soil. Both rhizobial and mycorrhizal symbioses can act synergistically in benefits on plant.     

Microsatellite diversity and genetic structure among common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) landraces in Brazil, a secondary center of diversity

Brazil is the largest producer and consumer of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.), which is the most important source of human dietary protein in that country. This study assessed the genetic diversity and the structure of a sample of 279 geo-referenced common bean landraces from Brazil, using molecular markers. Sixty-seven microsatellite markers spread over the 11 linkage groups of the common bean genome, as well as Phaseolin, PvTFL1y, APA and four SCAR markers were used. As expected, the sample showed lower genetic diversity compared to the diversity in the primary center of diversification. Andean and Mesoamerican gene pools were both present but the latter gene pool was four times more frequent than the former. The two gene pools could be clearly distinguished; limited admixture was observed between these groups. The Mesoamerican group consisted of two sub-populations, with a high level of admixture between them leading to a large proportion of stabilized hybrids not observed in the centers of domestication. Thus, Brazil can be considered a secondary center of diversification of common bean. A high degree of genome-wide multilocus associations even among unlinked loci was observed, confirming the high level of structure in the sample and suggesting that association mapping should be conducted in separate Andean and Mesoamerican Brazilian samples.     

Phosphorus uptake by bean nodules

As part of a breeding program to improve the nitrogen-fixing symbiosis between common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) and Rhizobium etli, we developed a rapid screen for common bean accessions that preferentially nodulate with KIM5s, a high nitrogen fixing strain of R. etli. We constructed a mutant of KIM5s that did not fix nitrogen (Fix^-) but was otherwise indistinguishable from KIM5s. We screened plants for symptoms of nitrogen deficiency when grown in a Honduran soil containing indigenous common bean-nodulating rhizobia (10⁴ per gram) and KM6001, the Fix^- mutant of KIM5s (10⁴/seedling added 7 days after planting). Leaf color was scored on a scale of 1 to 5, in which 1 was dark green and 5 was bright yellow. Of 820 genetically diverse accessions of P. vulgaris screened, 51 were scored 1, 626 were scored 2 or 3, and 143 were scored 4 or 5. Selfed seed was produced from common bean plants of the accessions scored 1, 4 or 5. Twenty-four accessions that scored 1, and 58 that scored 4 or 5 were screened in soil containing indigenous rhizobia and the wild type KIM5s (Fix₊), and nodule occupancy was determined by antibiotic resistance. On the 24 common bean accessions that were scored 1, KIM5s occupied 0-6% of the nodules, on 26 of the accessions that were scored 4 or 5, KIM5s occupied 90%-100% of the nodules, and on the remaining 34 that scored 4 or 5, there was a distribution of nodule occupancy. Foliar color was highly correlated with nodule occupancy (r = 0.786,p = 0.01). The results indicate that the rapid visual screen using the Fix- mutant accurately identified common bean accessions that preferentially nodulate with the wild-type KIM5s (Fix⁺) strain in soil containing indigenous rhizobia. This screen will facilitate introduction of the preferential nodulation trait into superior cultivars and provides the foundation for studies of the genetic basis of preferential nodulation.     

A ribosomal RNA gene intergenic spacer based PCR and DGGE fingerprinting method for the analysis of specific rhizobial communities in soil

A direct molecular method for assessing the diversity of specific populations of rhizobia in soil, based on nested PCR amplification of 16S-23S ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA) intergenic spacer (IGS) sequences, was developed. Initial generic amplification of bacterial rDNA IGS sequences from soil DNA was followed by specific amplification of (1) sequences affiliated with Rhizobium leguminosarum "sensu lato" and (2) R. tropici. Using analysis of the amplified sequences in clone libraries obtained on the basis of soil DNA, this two-sided method was shown to be very specific for rhizobial subpopulations in soil. It was then further validated as a direct fingerprinting tool of the target rhizobia based on denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). The PCR-DGGE approach was applied to soils from fields in Brazil cultivated with common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) under conventional or no-tillage practices. The community fingerprints obtained allowed the direct analysis of the respective rhizobial community structures in soil samples from the two contrasting agricultural practices. Data obtained with both primer sets revealed clustering of the community structures of the target rhizobial types along treatment. Moreover, the DGGE profiles obtained with the R. tropici primer set indicated that the abundance and diversity of these organisms were favoured under NT practices. These results suggest that the R. leguminosarum-as well as R. tropici-targeted IGS-based nested PCR and DGGE are useful tools for monitoring the effect of agricultural practices on these and related rhizobial subpopulations in soils.     

Molecular mechanisms of Nod factor diversity

The rhizobia–legume symbiosis is highly specific. Major host specificity determinants are the bacterial Nod factor signals that trigger the nodulation programme in a compatible host. Nod factors are lipo-chitooligosaccharides (LCOs) varying in the oligosaccharide chain length, the nature of the fatty acids and substitutions on the oligosaccharide. The nod genotype of rhizobia, which forms the genetic basis for this structural variety, includes a set of nodulation genes encoding the enzymes that synthesize LCOs. Allelic and non-allelic variation in these genes ensures the synthesis of different LCO structures by the different rhizobia. The nod genotypes co-evolved with host plant divergence in contrast to the rhizobia, which followed a different evolution. Horizontal gene transfer probably played an important role during evolution of symbiosis. The nod genotypes are particularly well equipped for horizontal gene transfer because of their location on transmissible plasmids and/or on 'symbiosis islands', which are symbiotic regions associated with movable elements.     

Combined inoculation with Glomus intraradices and Rhizobium tropici CIAT899 increases phosphorus use efficiency for symbiotic nitrogen fixation in common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)

This study compared the response of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) to arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) and rhizobia strain inoculation. Two common bean genotypes i.e. CocoT and Flamingo varying in their effectiveness for nitrogen fixation were inoculated with Glomus intraradices and Rhizobium tropici CIAT899, and grown for 50 days in soil–sand substrate in glasshouse conditions. Inoculation of common bean plants with the AM fungi resulted in a significant increase in nodulation compared to plants without inoculation. The combined inoculation of AM fungi and rhizobia significantly increased various plant growth parameters compared to simple inoculated plants. In addition, the combined inoculation of AM fungi and rhizobia resulted in significantly higher nitrogen and phosphorus accumulation in the shoots of common bean plants and improved phosphorus use efficiency compared with their controls, which were not dually inoculated. It is concluded that inoculation with rhizobia and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi could improve the efficiency in phosphorus use for symbiotic nitrogen fixation especially under phosphorus deficiency.     

The diversity of rhizobia nodulating beans in Northwest Argentina as a source of more efficient inoculant strains

The common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) is cultivated widely in Central and South America and particularly in the Northwest of Argentina. In order to describe the diversity of the common bean nodulating rhizobial population from the bean producing area in Northwest Argentina (NWA), a collection of about 400 isolates of common beans recovered from nodules and soil samples from NWA were characterized by using nifH-PCR, analysis of genes coding for 16S rRNA and nodC, and REP-fingerprinting, respectively. It was found that species Rhizobium etli is predominant in common bean nodules although a high degree of diversity was found within the species. Other bean nodulating genotypes recovered from soils by using Leucaena sp. as the trapping host was found to have the 16S rDNA alleles of species such as Sinorhizobium fredii, Sinorhizobium saheli, Sinorhizobium teranga, Mesorhizobium loti, and Rhizobium tropici. Some of the bean genotypes that were found to be more efficient in green house experiments were selected and assayed in two successive bean-cropping seasons in the field environment in NWA, and an increase in yields with inoculation was found. The performance of strains isolated from the region indicates potential for exploiting the diversity.     

Inactivation of the nodH gene in Sinorhizobium sp. BR816 enhances symbiosis with Phaseolus vulgaris L

Sulfate modification on Rhizobium Nod factor signaling molecules is not a prerequisite for successful symbiosis with the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). However, many bean-nodulating rhizobia, including the broad host strain Sinorhizobium sp. BR816, produce sulfated Nod factors. Here, we show that the nodH gene, encoding a sulfotransferase, is responsible for the transfer of sulfate to the Nod factor backbone in Sinorhizobium sp. BR816, as was shown for other rhizobia. Interestingly, inactivation of nodH enables inoculated bean plants to fix significantly more nitrogen under different experimental setups. Our studies show that nodH in the wild-type strain is still expressed during the later stages of symbiosis. This is the first report on enhanced nitrogen fixation by blocking Nod factor sulfation.     

Diversity in the rhizobia associated with Phaseolus vulgaris L. in Ecuador, and comparisons with Mexican bean rhizobia

Common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) have centers of origin in both Mesoamerica and Andean South America, and have been domesticated in each region for perhaps 5000 years. A third major gene pool may exist in Ecuador and Northern Peru. The diversity of the rhizobia associated with beans has also been studied, but to date with an emphasis on the Mesoamerican center of origin. In this study we compared bean rhizobia from Mexico and Andean South America using both phenotypic and phylogenetic approaches. When differences between the rhizobia of these two regions were shown, we then examined the influence of bean cultivar on the most probable number (MPN) count and biodiversity of rhizobia recovered from different soils. Three clusters of bean rhizobia were distinguished using phenotypic analysis and principal-component analysis of Box AIR-PCR banding patterns. They corresponded principally to isolates from Mexico, and the northern and southern Andean regions, with isolates from southern Ecuador exhibiting significant genetic diversity. Rhizobia from Dalea spp., which are infective and effective on beans, may have contributed to the apparent diversity of rhizobia recovered from the Mesoamerican region, while the rhizobia of wild Phaseolus aborigineus from Argentina showed only limited similarity to the other bean rhizobia tested. Use of P. vulgaris cultivars from the Mesoamerican and Andean Phaseolus gene pools as trap hosts did not significantly affect MPN counts of bean rhizobia from the soils of each region, but did influence the diversity of the rhizobia recovered. Such differences in compatibility of host and Rhizobium could be a factor in the poor reputation for nodulation and N2 fixation in this crop.     

Salt-tolerant rhizobia isolated from a Tunisian oasis that are highly effective for symbiotic N2-fixation with Phaseolus vulgaris constitute a novel biovar (bv. mediterranense) of Sinorhizobium meliloti

Nodulation of common bean was explored in six oases in the south of Tunisia. Nineteen isolates were characterized by PCR–RFLP of 16S rDNA. Three species of rhizobia were identified, Rhizobium etli, Rhizobium gallicum and Sinorhizobium meliloti. The diversity of the symbiotic genes was then assessed by PCR–RFLP of nodC and nifH genes. The majority of the symbiotic genotypes were conserved between oases and other soils of the north of the country. Sinorhizobia isolated from bean were then compared with isolates from Medicago truncatula plants grown in the oases soils. All the nodC types except for nodC type p that was specific to common bean isolates were shared by both hosts. The four isolates with nodC type p induced N₂-fixing effective nodules on common bean but did not nodulate M. truncatula and Medicago sativa. The phylogenetic analysis of nifH and nodC genes showed that these isolates carry symbiotic genes different from those previously characterized among Medicago and bean symbionts, but closely related to those of S. fredii Spanish and Tunisian isolates effective in symbiosis with common bean but unable to nodulate soybean. The creation of a novel biovar shared by S. meliloti and S. fredii, bv. mediterranense, was proposed.     

High genotypic diversity and strong spatial structure in populations of Trifolium alpestre with low seed production

Studies on clonal plants indicate that the proportion between clonal and sexual reproduction can be variable, depending on local habitat conditions and the biological characteristics of the species. In the present study, we assessed this question in Trifolium alpestre by assaying genetic diversity and spatial genotypic structure of natural populations with the use of allozyme markers. Populations revealed high genetic diversity as well as strong spatial structure of multilocus genotypes. The values of genetic diversity were moderately high. Spatially aggregated, identical genotypes spread up to 15 m along linear transects and across 4‐m² plots indicate extensive clonal propagation within populations. However, the existence of numerous unique and small‐sized clones reflects significant contribution from sexual reproduction. Spatially and temporarily stochastic soil disturbances have evidently opened new opportunities for the successful sexual recruitment from the permanent soil seed bank and thus counteracted losses of genetic and genotypic diversity. Seed production in all populations during the three study years was low, in average up to 1.5–2.4 seeds per shoot. The almost total lack of seed set for 57 bagged flower heads on genotypes grown in a common garden indicates that T. alpestre needs pollinators for seed production.