Historical and Ecological Factors in the Biogeography of Aposematic Neotropical Butterflies

SYNOPSIS. Quantitative analysis of low-level (mostly subspecific)geographic differentiation of aposematic color patterns in threegroups of forest butterflies (Heliconiini, Ithomiinae, and Troidini),in 1,550 half-degree quadrants throughout the Neotropics, indicatesfour principal species-endemicity regions, 44 principal subspecies-endemicitycenters, and 300 quadrants of subspecies hybridization. Theendemism centers are different in outline but nearly identicalin position for each of the three ecologically different groups.Basic data on present and past physical environments (climate,soils, geomorphology, and vegetation structures), when integratedinto maps, show 1) regions of favorable ecological conditionsfor forest organisms in the present, 2) regions of environmentalconformities and rapid transitions in the present, and 3) regionsof high probability for humid forest persistence during themajor landscape changes at the end of the last glacial period,13,000–20,000 yr ago. Species diversity (a local phenomenon)is readily related to favorable modern ecological conditionsand environmental microheterogeneity, promoted by unpredictablemild disturbance. Biogeographical patterns of evolution at thelevel of regional subspecies correlate very well with presumedpaleoecological conditions. The biogeographical data also supportan hypothesis of differentiation resulting from areas of rapidenvironmental change; most of the hybridization quadrants fallwithin transition zones. There is lower correlation betweencenters of endemism and zones of en vironmental conformity,but some individual cases of differentiation in the butterfliesmay be adequately explained by modern ecological factors. Speciespresently undergoing differentiation in isolated habitat islands(Amazonian savannas and high-altitude Andean forests and paramos)may offer the best opportunities for observation of evolutionaryprocesses in the present.