Intraspecific variability in host plant quality and ovipositionaI preferences in Eucheira socialis (Lepidoptera: Pieridae)

Abstract.

• 1 This study investigates interactions between Eucheira socialis (Pieridae: Lepidoptera), a strict monophagous herbivore, on Arbutus xalapensis (Ericaceae), a host plant with few herbivores. This tight association of insect on plant has many attributes conducive to reciprocal rather than diffuse evolution.
• 2 An indirect way of testing plant–insect coevolutionary theories is to test for the necessary conditions for reciprocal evolution in ecological time. Two conditions for coevolution were studied: (1) host plants vary in their suitability for larval growth and development, and (2) ovipositing insects discriminate among these plants based on their relative suitability.
• 3 Large differences in host plant suitability were found and relative differences were consistent from year to year.
• 4 There was no evidence that female insects based their ovipositional decisions on relative tree quality, which implies that factors other than host plant quality are involved in the maintenance and evolution of oviposition behaviour in Eucheira.
• 5 Of seven factors known to influence ovipositional preferences of insects among plants independent of potential larval success, the most likely causal factor in this system is the ability of females to balance a time/energy budget for finding potential oviposition sites, discriminating among them, and actually ovipositing.