Potential and peril of field experimentation: the use of copper to manipulate molluscan herbivores

Barriers of copper-based anti-fouling paints have become a popular method for the experimental manipulation of certain molluscan grazers, presumably by acting as a chemical barrier to movement. Although probably similar in action, copper metal can be more versatile in its application and maintenance. Its efficacy was confirmed in field experiments which examined the colonization of artificial surfaces by the intertidal red alga Halosaccion glandiforme (Rupr.). However, even though copper has the desired indirect effect on algae (i.e., the exclusion of grazers), it can still have undesirable direct effects as well, and these “costs of manipulation” must be recognized. These results demonstrate the necessity of proper controls in field experimentation, a consideration absent in many past studies. The general use of partial manipulations as control treatments appears useless for estimating artifacts associated with the use of copper barriers in particular and for other experimental manipulations in general. More meaningful controls may rely on finding multiple ways of manipulating the variable of interest.