Egg rejection behavior in a population exposed to parasitism: Village Weavers on Hispaniola

In contrast to African Village Weavers (Ploceus cucullatus)that are parasitized by Diederik Cuckoos (Chrysococcyx caprius),introduced weavers on Hispaniola existed without parasitismfor at least 2 centuries until the arrival of the Shiny Cowbird(Molothrus bonariensis) in the 1970s. Cruz and Wiley (1989)found that Hispaniolan weavers had a lower rejection rate offoreign eggs than African populations. Subsequently, Robertand Sorci (1999) and Lahti (2005, 2006) found that acceptanceof dissimilar eggs is not characteristic of the species throughoutits Hispaniolan range. In 1999–2002, we studied egg rejectionin Hispaniolan weavers on a broad regional scale. Rejectionincreased as experimental eggs became increasingly differentfrom the host eggs. Rejection rates for mimetic eggs, differentcolor eggs, different-spotting eggs, and cowbird eggs was 23.2%,33.3%, 61.5%, and 85.3%, respectively, with higher rejectionof cowbird eggs in areas where cowbirds were observed. Althoughrejection is likely to have a genetic component, the differencescould be due to phenotypic plasticity. Plasticity in egg rejectionmay be expected, given the potential cost of rejection and thespatiotemporal distribution of cowbirds. Thus, egg rejectionhas not necessarily decreased in Hispaniolan weavers, but itmay act in a plastic manner, increasing where cowbirds are present.