The limitations of heart rate as a predictor of metabolic rate in fish

Although telemetered heart rate (f_H) has been used as a physiological correlate to predict the metabolic rate (as oxygen consumption, V?O₂) of fish in the field, it is our contention that the method has not been validated adequately for fish. If f_H in fish is to be used to estimate V?O₂, a single linear (or log-linear) relationship must be established for each species between the two variables which allows V?O₂ to be predicted accurately under all environmentally relevant conditions. Our analyses of existing data indicate that while a good linear (or log-linear) relationship can be established between f_H and V?O₂, the conditions under which the relationship applies may be quite restricted. Physiological states and environmental factors affect the relationship between f_H and V?O₂ significantly such that several curves can exist for a single species. In addition, there are situations in which f_H and V?O₂ do not covary in a significant manner. In some situations f_H can vary over much of its physiological range while V?O₂ remains constant; in others V?O₂ may vary while f_H is invariate. The theoretical basis for this variability is examined to explain why the use of telemetered f_H in predicting V?O₂ of fish may be limited to certain specified applications.