Oxidative and reductive pathways of estrogens in hormone responsive and non-responsive human breast cancer cells in vitro

In order to measure the formation and degradation rates of estradiol by human breast cancer cells, after assessing the biochemical basis of hormone responsiveness and growth response to estrogens, we considered both responsive, estrogen receptor (ER) positive, and non-responsive, ER-negative, breast cancer cell lines, i.e. MCF7, ZR75-1 and MDA-MB231. To this end, we employed a novel “intact cell” approach which allows us, after 24 h incubation, to analyze several enzyme activities in sequence, concurrently with the monitoring of labeled precursor degradation. Our investigations led to the following evidence: (a) the reductive activity of the 17β-hydroxysteroid oxoreductase (17β-HSOR) appears to be higher than the oxidative only in responsive, ER-rich MCF7 and ZR75-1 cells, as also previously observed by others; (b) this activity is, on the contrary, much lower in MDA-MB231 cells and other unresponsive, ER-poor breast cancer cell lines; (c) conversely, the oxidative activity shows an opposite pattern, being limited in MCF7 and ZR75-1 cells and much higher in MDA-MB231 cells. Overall, a 17β-HSOR reductive pathway prevails in both MCF7 and ZR75-1 cells, whilst the oxidative pathway is prevalent in MDA-MB231 cells, leading to a large formation of estrone that is no further metabolized, at least in the experimental conditions used. Our results may provide a likely explanation of previous data on the different estrogen content of breast tumor tissues.