Cladoceran Densities,Day-to-Day Variability in Food Selection by Smelt,and the Birth-Rate-Compensation Hypothesis

Late-evening gut inspection of a dominant planktivore (smelt) and evaluation of densities, fecundities, and body-size distributions in dominant zooplankton prey (cladocerans) were made in day-to-day sequences in June–July (24 days in 1999 and 24 days in 2000). This was conducted as a field test of the hypothesis that species-specific population densities in cladocerans result from size-selective predation by a dominant fish assumed to be a general predator, switching from one prey to another as relative abundance changes. Little of the expected coincidence has been revealed between population density declines and increased numbers of a given prey in smelt diet. However, the data were consistent with the notion that fish would switch from one prey to another depending on the prey relative abundance (the number of prey a fish would see in its reaction field volume). Each cladoceran population fluctuated around its species-specific density level, lower or higher, depending on individual susceptibility to smelt predation, from 0.2 ind. l^–1 in large-bodied Daphnia hyalina and Leptodora kindtii, to 30.0 ind. l^–1 in small-bodied Daphnia cucullata andBosmina thersites. In spite of high fish-to-fish and day-to-day variability in both smelt diet and smelt selectivity for different prey, all cladocerans (also copepods and midge larvae) were equally persistent in smelt diet, and smelt selectivity was similar for small- and large-bodied prey categories, but lower for elongated-(Daphnia, Diaphanosoma) than for compact-body (Bosmina, Chydorus) species, when integrated for the entire sampling time. Closer examination of D. cucullata and B. thersites revealed strong smelt selection for later instars and females with greater clutches, showing that size distribution in a cladoceran population might be structured by fish predation in a similar way to that a cladoceran community (species relative abundance) is structured in a lake habitat. The birth-rate-compensation hypothesis is offered to explain why the value of food selectivity index in a planktivorous fish would remain the same for alternate prey categories with similar life-history traits, unless they differ in susceptibility to predation before the time of first reproduction.