Intrinsic and extrinsic drivers of recruitment across the distribution range of a seed-dimorphic herb

Recruitment of new individuals, through germination and seedling survival, is a key process for short-lived plants. Here, we analyzed intraspecific variation in recruitment across the latitudinal range of Plantago coronopus, a widespread herb that produces both large basal seeds with a mucilaginous coat and small apical seeds without coat. We experimentally tested the effects of seed traits and water availability on recruitment, by using seeds from a wide environmental stress gradient from N Africa to N Europe. Our experiments were carried out in controlled environmental conditions and in dunes where the species naturally occurs. Water shortage decreased seed germination and seedling survival for all populations, showing the importance of water supply for P. coronopus. Basal seeds showed higher and faster germination rates than apical seeds. Since among-population variation in seed mass was not related to potential germination rate, it is the mucilaginous coat rather than size difference that likely drives the differential success between seed morphs. Seed mass positively affected seedling survival instead, but only in controlled conditions with regular water supply. An experiment in a dune showed indeed that the highest survival corresponded to the local population and not the one with the largest seeds. Our results demonstrate that both intrinsic and extrinsic factors drive inter-population variation in the early life stages of this short-lived plant, allowing it to adapt across the environmentally heterogeneous distribution range. Gathering information on intraspecific variation in recruitment-related traits will help us to understand and predict plant responses in a context of climatic change.