Variation in larval chaetotaxy in Orthosia gothica (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae): effects of mother,sex and side,and implications for systematics

Insect larval characteristics, including chaetotaxy, are used widely in systematics, including for classification and phylogenetic reconstruction. Despite their common use, basic aspects of larval morphology, including intraspecific variation, effects of relatedness between individuals, sex and asymmetry, are little investigated. In the larvae of the noctuid moth Orthosia gothica, properties of shape and size were separated to examine their effects separately. Siblings were found not to cover the entire variation of a population, and therefore specimens originating from a single female do not represent independent samples. This methodological bias may potentially lead to wrong conclusions regarding species characteristics. We observed slight differences between the left and right sides of the specimens studied, implying that one side should be examined consistently in studying larval chaetotaxy. We found no differences between sexes, but this may apply only to the species examined here; in general, sex should be determined and accounted for. We discovered considerable variation in seta numbers, which further emphasizes the importance of sufficient material, particularly in cladistic analyses in which setal counts are often used as characters.