THE RELATIONSHIP AND ORIGIN OF TSUGA HETEROPHYLLA AND TSUGA MERTENSIANA BASED ON PHYTOCHEMICAL AND MORPHOLOGICAL INTERPRETATIONS

Morphological intermediacy between Tsuga heterophylla and Tsuga mertensiana has stimulated controversy concerning the relationship between these two hemlock species and has led to wide acceptance of hybridization as a causative factor of intermediate forms in areas of distributional overlap. In this study, comparative’ chemical analyses were used to test the theory of hybrid derivation of intermediates. Chromatographic analyses were further applied to the phylogenetic ranking of several North American and Asian species of Tsuga and to the examination of the hypothesis that Tsuga mertensiana is a derivative of intergeneric hybridization involving Tsuga heterophylla and Picea sitchensis. Chromatographic data derived from extensive sampling in the western Cascades of Washington led me to conclude that hybridization of Tsuga heterophylla and T. mertensiana is a possible but rare phenomenon and is not necessarily indicated by morphological intermediacy. Phylogenetically both of these species are typical representatives of Tsuga and are distinct from species of Picea. There is, however, some support for the derivation of Tsuga mertensiana by intergeneric hybridization.