Rates of readmission and death associated with leaving hospital against medical advice: a population-based study

Background:

Leaving hospital against medical advice may have adverse consequences. Previous studies have been limited by evaluating specific types of patients, small sample sizes and incomplete determination of outcomes. We hypothesized that leaving hospital against medical advice would be associated with increases in subsequent readmission and death.

Methods:

In a population-based analysis involving all adults admitted to hospital and discharged alive in Manitoba from Apr. 1, 1990, to Feb. 28, 2009, we evaluated all-cause 90-day mortality and 30-day hospital readmission. We used multivariable regression, adjusted for age, sex, socioeconomic status, year of hospital admission, patient comorbidities, hospital diagnosis, past frequency of admission to hospital, having previously left hospital against medical advice and data clustering (patients with multiple admissions). For readmission, we assessed both between-person and within-person effects of leaving hospital against medical advice.

Results:

Leaving against medical advice occurred in 21 417 of 1 916 104 index hospital admissions (1.1%), and was associated with higher adjusted rates of 90-day mortality (odds ratio OR] 2.51, 95% confidence interval CI] 2.18–2.89), and 30-day hospital readmission (within-person OR 2.10, CI 1.99–2.21; between-person OR 3.04, CI 2.79–3.30). In our additional analyses, elevated rates of readmission and death associated with leaving against medical advice were manifest within 1 week and persisted for at least 180 days after discharge.

Interpretation:

Adults who left the hospital against medical advice had higher rates of hospital readmission and death. The persistence of these effects suggests that they are not solely a result of incomplete treatment of acute illness. Interventions aimed at reducing these effects may need to include longitudinal interventions extending beyond admission to hospital.Patients leaving hospital against medical advice have been discussed in the medical literature for more than 50 years.¹ Reported to occur in 1%–2% of patients in general hospitals,^2,3 the numbers are large; in the United States, 368 000 patients left against medical advice in 2007,³ and rates higher than 10% have been documented in certain subgroups, including Canadian patients with HIV and predominantly poor residents of inner city areas.^4,5 The main concern over leaving hospital against medical advice is that it may increase morbidity or mortality. Previous studies attempting to assess this effect^2,4–13 have all been restricted to specific types of patients, and most studies were limited by small sample sizes and incomplete determination of outcomes. In this study, we used data that avoided these limitations to test the hypothesis that patients who leave hospital against medical advice have higher rates of hospital readmission and death.