Quantitative analyses of shade-shoot architecture of conifers native to New Zealand

Shoot architecture was quantified by measuring the "maximum silhouette area ratio" (R_max). R_max was calculated from the maximum silhouette area (or projected area) of the intact shoot, divided by the silhouette area of the leaves or phylloclades (leaf-like flattened stems) when they are removed from the shoot and laid out flat. Like conifers of the Northern Hemisphere (NH) with non-appressed foliage, the R_max of shade-adapted shoots ranged from 0.5 to 1.0 in New Zealand (NZ) conifers with non-appressed foliage. Defining a "leaf" to mean either a true leaf or a phylloclade, the following was found: leaf area/leaf dry weight, leaf area/shoot dry weight, and leaf dry weight/shoot dry weight, were all similar in the shade-shoots of NZ and NH conifers. None of these variables were significantly correlated with R_max in the NZ conifers, unless species with leaves averaging less than 4 mm² in size were excluded from the analyses. Foliage dry weight/shoot projected area was strongly correlated with R_max. NZ conifers had both smaller and larger mean leaf sizes in comparison to NH conifers. The mean projected area per shade-adapted leaf of NZ conifers varied from 2.7 to 436 mm². In NH conifers, the mean projected area per shade leaf varied from 12 to 83 mm². Except for the strikingly larger range in leaf size in NZ conifers, the data support a hypothesis of strong convergent evolution of shade-shoot architecture in NZ and NH conifers. The results are discussed in relation to photosynthesis, stand production, and the ecological distribution of conifers.