Comparison of dose-response relationships for ethyl methanesulfonate and 1-ethyl-1-nitrosourea in Drosophila melanogaster spermatozoa

The relative importance of different sites of alkylation on DNA was determined by comparing two ethylating agents. 1-Ethyl-1-nitrosourea (ENU) ethylates DNA with a higher proportion of total adducts on ring oxygens than ethyl methanesulfonate, which ethylates with a higher proportion of total adducts on the N-7 of guanine. Research with somatic cells in culture and prokaryotes strongly suggests that O6-guanine (O6-G) is the principal genotoxic site. To determine the importance in germ-line mutagenesis of the O6-G site relative to the N-7 of guanine, dose-response curves were constructed for both ENU and EMS, where dose was measured as total adducts per deoxynucleotide (APdN) and response as sex-linked recessive lethals (SLRL) induced in Drosophila melanogaster spermatozoa. For both mutagens the dose response curve was linear and extrapolated to the origin. The dose-response curve for ENU was fit to an equation m = 6.2D, and the dose response curve for EMS, from this and previous experiments, was m = 3.2D where m = %SLRL and D = APdN X 10(-3). Therefore, ENU is 1.9 times more efficient per adduct in inducing SLRL mutations than EMS. In vitro studies showed that ENU induced 9.5% of its total adducts on O6-G while EMS induced 2.0% of its adducts on O6-G. If O6-G was the sole genotoxic site, then ENU should be 4.8 times more efficient per adduct than EMS. In contrast, if N-7 G was the sole genotoxic site, ENU would be only 0.19 as effective as EMS. It was concluded that while O6-G was the principal genotoxic site, N-7 G made a significant contribution to germ-line mutagenesis.